Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Slander (MGM, 1956, released 1957)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last Saturday, November 14 my husband Charles and I watched a quite interesting if ultimately frustrating film on Eddie Muller’s “Noir Alley” program on Turner Classic Movies. It was called Slander and was filmed in 1956 but released in 1957. Directed by Roy Rowland from a script by Jerome Weidman based on a CBS-TV show called A Public Figure by Harry W. Junkin, Slander is a thinly veiled portrait of the real Hollywood scandal magazine Confidential. The Wikipedia page on the real Confidential suggests that there’s a much better potential movie in its actual story than the one we got here (though given that Confidential was still alive and very much near the peak of its power when Slander was made, it’s quite obvious why the filmmakers had to tread gingerly around it). Confidential was launched in 1952 by publisher Robert Harrison, who’d got his start working for Bernarr MacFadden on the New York Evening Graphic, a pioneering tabloid that blazed the trail a lot of its successors took, selling papers with sleazy stories about major celebrities. When the Depression killed the Graphic, Harrison moved on to Hollywood both literally and figuratively, taking a job with the Motion Picture Herald, run by Martin Quigley, a hard-core Roman Catholic and one of the authors of the Motion Picture Production Code. During his tenure with the Herald, Harrison collected a number of sexually suggestive but not outright pornographic photos of women in or aspiring to be in the movies. He started a series of magazines to showcase such photos, including Beauty Parade and five others, but drew the line at outright nudity. Realizing that his business model was being threatened by the advent of Hugh Hefner’s Playboy, which famously did feature nudes (Playboy’s first “Playmate of the Month” was Marilyn Monroe; Hefner had acquired the rights to the nude calendar shot Monroe had modeled for in 1949), Harrison decided to launch a new magazine that would do the same sort of star scandal-mongering MacFadden had done at the Evening Graphic. He called it Confidential and it was an instant hit.

To run Confidential Harrison hired an editor with an even weirder background than his: Howard Rushmore. Rushmore had been an active Communist and a film critic for the Daily Worker until 1939, when he was abruptly fired for giving a positive review to Gone With the Wind. Like a lot of other people who were mistreated by the Communists, Rushmore’s politics did a 180° and he hired on as a professional anti-Communist writer for William Randolph Hearst’s New York Journal-American. Rushmore was also briefly on the staff of Red-baiting Senator Joseph McCarthy (R-Wisconsin) until he clashed with McCarthy’s chief of staff, attorney (and later mentor to Donald Trump) Roy Cohn. As editor of Confidential, Rushmore used similar tactics to the ones he’d previously used as a Congressional investigator: targeting lower-level people (some of them active Communists, some of them “fellow travelers” or sympathizers, and some of them non-Communist liberals) and offering to spare them if they gave them information on higher-ups. Harrison and Rushmore cultivated a wide network of informers in Hollywood, including actress Barbara Payton; actor Bruce Cabot’s ex-wife, Francesca De Scaffa; and screenwriter Joseph Quillen’s ex Ronnie, and got stories out of them. Often Confidential would publish a story whose central allegation was true but would embellish it with other accusations that were entirely fictional. As Harrison himself explained, “Once we establish the star in the hay and that's documented, we can say anything we want and I think we make them a hell of a lot more interesting than they really are. What’s a guy gonna do, sue us and admit he was in the hay with the dame, but claim he didn’t do all the other things we dress the story with?” Confidential met its downfall in 1957, when California Attorney General Edmund G. “Pat” Brown (who’d later become governor and sire another California governor) prosecuted the magazine for conspiracy to commit criminal libel. His main witnesses were actresses Maureen O’Hara and Dorothy Dandridge (Confidential had published a totally false story about O’Hara allegedly having sex with a man she’d just met in the balcony of a movie theatre) as well as Howard Rushmore, whom Harrison had fired and would turn against him for revenge. In 1958 Rushmore met with his estranged wife under the guise of attempting a reconciliation; instead he took her in a cab and shot her and then himself.

In the film Slander, the Confidential analogue is called Real Truth and its publisher is H. R. Manley (Steve Cochran, older and more heavy-set than he was at his career peak in the late 1940’s but still great at oily villainy). He’s anxious to get out of a printing deal with Harry Walsh (Robert Burton) who helped give the magazine its seed capital, but he still owes the man $100,000. To get it he insists that the next issue of the magazine must have a really spectacular exposé that will jack up its sales enough to pay off the printer and he’s fastened on movie mega-star Mary Sawyer as the person he'll expose. To the world Mary Sawyer is an ultra-clean celebrity with a husband and family, but Manley is convinced that there’s a dark secret in her past that he can reveal to the world. He fastens on an aspiring puppeteer named Scott Ethan Martin (Van Johnson), who’s married to Connie (Ann Blyth, who actually does pretty well in a thankless role) and has a 10-year-old son, Joey (Richard Eyer, whose freckles help make him convincing as Van Johnson’s offspring). After years of struggle during which he did free shows at settlement houses, Martin, with the help of his friend and agent Seth Jackson (Harold J. Stone), has finally landed a job hosting a TV show and doing his puppet act there. Only he ends up in the cross-hairs of H. R. Manley, who wants to use him to destroy Mary Sawyer because they grew up in the same poor neighborhood of New York City. Martin’s own dark secret is that at age 19 he was convicted of armed robbery and spent four years in prison for it; his wife knew but no one else did (he was planning to tell his son when the kid turned 15 and the Martins assumed he’d be mature enough to handle the revelation). Manley discovers this and prepares an article for Real Truth exposing the new kids’ show host as an ex-convict, then tells Connie Martin he won’t publish it if Scott will give him dirt on Mary Sawyer. It turns out the dirt Scott Martin has on Mary Sawyer is that as a teenage girl she got “in trouble” and Scott’s mother helped her out of it. (It had to be veiled in the script to get it past the Production Code, but it’s obvious to us that Sawyer had got pregnant and Scott’s mother had arranged for an illegal abortion.)

Scott virtuously refuses to “rat” Mary Sawyer out to Manley and in exchange Manley publishes the article about him. The sponsor of his TV show immediately fires him, saying that since their product (a breakfast cereal) appeals mainly to children they can’t have a “jailbird” associated with it publicly. When the issue of Real Truth exposing Scott’s criminal past comes out, Joey’s schoolmates start bullying him about having an ex-con father, and in a scene whose flagrant melodramatics alienated me from the story, Joey flees the classmates, gets run over by a delivery van, and is killed. I don’t know who to blame for this ridiculous turn into outright melodrama ¬– original writer Junkin or screenwriter Weidman – but it hearkened back to the early tear-jerker musicals Al Jolson made at Warner Bros., The Singing Fool (1928) and Say It With Songs (1929) and gave the rest of the movie a false cast. Needless to say, the writers had to figure out a way for Manley to get his comeuppance, and they did it by having his mother (Marjorie Rambeau) shoot him at the end. At least they’d established an antagonism between them over how Manley was making his money, which she found distasteful even though he pointed out that the earnings from his scandal rag were at least enabling her to wear nice clothes, dine at fancy restaurants (though he'd often try to make reservations for her and they’d refuse because the proprietors of New York’s fanciest restaurants were appalled at the way her son made his living), and indulge her alcoholism with far better booze than the rotgut she’d previously had to consume. The film ends with Scott Martin going on a talk show called What Do You Read? with a host who’d already targeted Manley and his magazine and telling his story.

Slander was a personal film for Van Johnson since he’d been libeled by Confidential himself with a story that claimed he was Gay. (They’d leveled that accusation against other celebrities as well, including ones like Liberace and Tab Hunter who really were Gay.) Eddie Muller said at the end that he found the scene in which Manley’s mother shoots him disappointing in that Rowland cut away from her just before she fired the fatal shot, and he wished that Sam Fuller had directed the film. Actually Fuller made a number of films about the sordid side of publishing, including Park Row (1952) and an even earlier one, Scandal Sheet (1951), which Fuller didn’t direct (Phil Karlson did) but was based on a Fuller novel called The Dark Page (1944) and, like John Farrow’s The Big Clock (1948), was about a psychopathic publisher who commits a murder and uses his papers to cover it up. Muller compared the film to Ace in the Hole (1951), Billy Wilder’s masterpiece about corrupt journalism (though in Wilder’s film the villain is a corrupt reporter instead of a corrupt publisher), and I can think of films even further back which made more of this theme, including Mervyn LeRoy’s little-known masterpiece Five Star Final (1931), in which Edward G. Robinson plays a guilt-ridden tabloid editor and Boris Karloff is his star reporter, a former divinity student (until he was expelled) who uses his knowledge of the Bible to pose as a minister and get stories. Eddie Muller said that the title of Slander is inaccurate because slander means a false or defamatory statement about someone made orally, and the written version is called libel. The Wikipedia page on Slander points out that the title is doubly inaccurate because both slander and libel mean making false statements, while the allegation against Van Johnson’s character in the movie is actually true (and he admits it during the story). Slander is actually a pretty good movie that could have been great, and even so it raises questions about just how we know what we think we know about the broader world and what obligations, if any, do reporters have to those they cover and the justifications behind revealing really sleazy tales about celebrities just to titillate readers.

Don't Talk (MGM, 1942)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

After Slander on Saturday, November 14 Turner Classic Movies showed a film in MGM’s Crime Does Not Pay series called Don’t Talk (1942). Eddie Muller’s immediately previous “Noir Alley” showing of the film Breakdown (1952) had been succeeded by another Crime Does Not Pay short, The Public Pays, which had been relatively dull (it was about an extortion racket targeting dairies in a fictional Midwestern city). The genesis of Crime Does Not Pay, which ran from 1935 to 1947, is interesting; it began as The Inquiring Reporter, a series of fake newsreels commissioned by MGM production chief Irving Thalberg to sandbag the Democratic gubernatorial candidacy of socialist writer Upton Sinclair in 1934. The “newsreels” were supposed “person on the street” interviews with respectable people ostensibly supporting Sinclair’s Republican opponent, Frank Merriam, and homeless bums who were allegedly about to flood into California once Sinclair was elected to take advantage of the largesse he was promising. (It’s fascinating that Right-wing propaganda has changed so little over the years; remember that Donald Trump has more than once claimed that the U.S. is threatened by so-called “caravans” of immigrants crashing into the country to take jobs and benefits away from “real Americans.”) After The Inquiring Reporter had served its purpose – Merriam beat Sinclair in the 1934 election – Thalberg green-lit a series of shorts with a similar approach and called it Crime Does Not Pay, which ran until 1947. It served the purpose of giving new talent just signed by MGM important experience in front of the cameras – Robert Taylor, star of the first Crime Does Not Pay short, Buried Loot (1935), later became a huge star and a mainstay of MGM – and on at least one occasion a Crime Does Not Pay short, They’re Always Caught (1938), was remade at “B”-feature length as Kid Glove Killer (1942).

Don’t Talk was a timely warning about how even the most seemingly innocuous quasi-public conversations in restaurants and beauty shops could give away wartime secrets that the enemy could take advantage of. Directed by Joseph M. Newman (who’d later become a contract director at Universal and make, among other films, the 1955 science-fiction classic This Island Earth) from a script by Alan Friedman, Don’t Talk is especially interesting not only for the central premise but also for the very interesting actress who plays the principal spy. She’s Gloria Holden, whose terrific performance in the title role of Universal’s horror classic Dracula’s Daughter (1936) should have made her a major star. Unfortunately, Dracula’s Daughter was made at the tail end of the original Universal horror cycle, when Carl Laemmle and his son Carl, Jr. were about to lose control of the studio to a hedge fund run by a man named J. Cheever Cowdin, and Cowdin and his newly installed production chief, Charles Rogers, decided horror films were “out” and Deanna Durbin musicals were “in.” Holden mostly played character roles thereafter, though she’s easily the most interesting cast member in Don’t Talk. She works as a waitress at the Elite Café, across the street from a major factory producing gear assemblies for military vehicles. Most of the workers at the factory eat lunch at the Elite Café, and Holden’s character, a Turkish refugee named Beulah Binvicko who uses the Americanized name “Beulah Anderson,” seems to have ears like antennae. She’s tuned in on any bit of gossip, no matter how seemingly innocuous, that she can use to relay her Axis spymasters so they can target the factory’s products for sabotage.

The Axis spy ring, which among other things has foreknowledge of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor two weeks before it famously happened on December 7, 1941, is run out of a local beauty parlor run by a man named Anatole (Harry Worth). Among Beulah’s assignments at the Elite Café is posting the menu in the café’s front window, and doing so in code so the spies can glean her information from where the letters are arranged in the signboard. The good guys in this one are FBI agents Jack Sampson (Donald Douglas) and Freed (Barry Nelson, later the first actor to play James Bond in the 1954 Climax! TV episode “Casino Royale”), though in a well-done final chase scene the villains run their car off the road and hold them at gunpoint until they’re able to turn the tables on them (absurdly easily) and preserve the precious shipment of gear parts (which we’re told had to be hand-machined, so their destruction by saboteurs would delay war production of a particularly important item by about a month or two). One quirk in the plotting is that, realizing the bad guys have learned the gears are to be shipped out by train, the good guys have the shipment re-routed to go by truck instead. Only one of the truck drivers sprains his hand loading them onto the truck and shows up at the Elite Café with his hand bandaged. He calls his wife at their home to let her know what happened to him – and Beulah overhears his phone call and thus learns that the gears are going to be shipped by trucks instead. So the bad guys plant bombs on a bridge along the route intending to set them off and blow up the trucks as they’re crossing the bridge, and the driver who inadvertently let out the secret panics when he learns what’s going on. “My son is driving one of those trucks!” he bursts out at the FBI agents as he lets them know what route the trucks are going to take and pleads with them to stop the saboteurs before they can blow up the trucks and kill his son. Don’t Talk was an obvious propaganda movie, but it was also surprisingly well made and genuinely suspenseful.

Monday, November 16, 2026

Spellbound (Selznick International Pictures, Vanguard Films, United Artists, 1945)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Sunday, November 15) my husband Charles and I watched a mini-marathon of three films on Turner Classic Movies: Alfred Hitchcock’s Spellbound (1945) and The Paradine Case (1947) and a really oddball item, an unfinished 1913 film called Lime Kiln Club Field Day that was a vehicle for African-American comedy star Bert Williams. TCM was doing a double bill of Spellbound and The Paradine Case not only because they were both directed by Alfred Hitchcock and starred Gregory Peck (the only two films Hitchcock and Peck made together) but because they were both given major restorations by the Walt Disney Company in association with the Film Foundation. The TCM showings were co-hosted by Ben Mankiewicz and British filmmaker Edgar Wright, whom I hadn’t recalled but I’ve seen at least one of his previous movies, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World, which I raved about in 2010 on my moviemagg.com blog at https://moviemagg.blogspot.com/2010/12/by-mark-gabrish-conlan-copyright-2010_30.html. I called Scott Pilgrim “refreshingly irreverent towards life, love, teen angst movies, video games, rock bands, vegans and everything else that fits within its compass.” Wright was expressing his admiration for Alfred Hitchcock (just about everyone who’s made a movie since Hitchcock’s time admires him) and also talking about how uncertainties as to who held the rights to these movies had jeopardized their continued existence and made it harder to ensure that they were properly restored and preserved. Spellbound began life in 1927, when two British authors, Hillary St. George Saunders (of whom Hitchcock said, “I think [he] became librarian in the House of Commons or something”) and John Palmer, who published a novel called The House of Dr. Edwardes under the joint pseudonym “Francis Beeding.” (Other major mystery writers, including “Ellery Queen” and “Whit Masterson,” were joint pseudonyms for two people.)

I’ve read The House of Dr. Edwardes in an edition that used the title of the movie, Spellbound, and made it seem like it was the same story as the film – which it isn’t. The House of Dr. Edwardes is about an escaped mental patient who murders the head of an asylum, impersonates him, and takes the place over, turning it into a Satanic religious cult with him as its unquestioned leader. Spellbound is an original by Hitchcock and his favorite writer, Ben Hecht, whose credits state it was merely “suggested” by the novel – which is true. All it took from the book was the basic situation of an impostor taking over a mental institution (with the delightfully inane name “Green Manors”) and ultimately revealing his own mental illness. Constance Petersen (Ingrid Bergman, top-billed, in the first of her three films for Hitchcock) is a psychiatrist at Green Manors who’s totally devoted to her work and uninterested in pursuing a romantic relationship of any kind. One of her colleagues, Dr. Fleurot (John Emery, husband of Tallulah Bankhead, who’d starred in Hitchcock’s immediately previous film Lifeboat), rather patronizingly warns her that until she’s got in touch with her own romantic emotions she won’t be a good psychiatrist no matter how much of the tradecraft she knows. The head of Green Manors, Dr. Murchison (Leo G. Carroll, who made more movies with Hitchcock – six: Rebecca, Suspicion, Spellbound, The Paradine Case, Strangers on a Train, and North by Northwest – than any other actor), has just had a nervous breakdown and the board of Green Manors has forced him into retirement. The man they’ve hired to replace him is Anthony Edwardes (seen in a flashback and played by Edward Fielding), an internationally renowned expert on guilt complexes. Only the person who shows up and claims to be Edwardes (Gregory Peck) is really an impostor with a severe case of amnesia that has cost him all memory of who he really is. Dr. Peterson first catches on when she notices that his signature on a note doesn’t match that of the real Dr. Edwardes on an autographed copy of his major work on guilt complexes found in the Green Manors library. But she asks him a question about medicine and realizes when he answers correctly that whoever he is, he’s had medical training. The impostor is convinced that he murdered the real Dr. Edwardes and took his place.

He also has a phobia triggered by seeing black lines on a white surface, which Dr. Petersen notices when she traces such lines with his fork on a napkin as the Green Manors staff members are having dinner together. The mystery man writes a note to Dr. Petersen saying that he’s leaving Green Manors (which is in Vermont) and going to the Empire State Hotel in New York City. Two police officers show up looking for him, and there’s a marvelous scene in which they, Dr. Murchison and other Green Manors staffers hotly debate where “Dr. Edwardes” might be when they’re stepping all over the note which we know (because we saw “Edwardes” write it) contains his whereabouts but the characters don’t. After everyone else leaves and she finally reads the note, Dr. Petersen determines to head for New York and rendezvous with him there, not only out of concern but because he’s so drop-dead gorgeous he’s hooked her love instincts at long last. Realizing that the police and the house detective at the Empire State have recognized them (his looks are unknown but her face has made it to front pages throughout New York even though the film was shot and set in the middle of World War II and one would think there’d be some more important stories on the front pages). When they realize they’ve been recognized and have to flee New York, Petersen takes “Edwardes” to a train station and tells him to ask the man at the counter for a ticket to whatever destination he went to last – and after a lot of hemming and hawing (which predictably irritates the train station ticket clerk), he says, “Rome.” When they get on the train the conductor is momentarily startled that they’re both taking the train, which floored me for a second until I realized that this was in the middle of World War II and the conductor was probably used to seeing women saying goodbye to their menfolk as the men were going off either to a military camp or an actual combat zone. From the reference to “Rome” and the crude skin grafts on the back of one of his hands, Petersen has deduced that “Edwardes” is a military doctor who was injured in combat in the Italian theatre, and from the initials “J.B.” on his cigarette case she’s at least deduced part of his real name. Calling him “John Brown” for cover, Petersen takes her to her own mentor in Rochester, New York, Dr. Alexander Brulov (Michael Chekhov), where there’s a stunning scene in which a sleepwalking “Brown” stalks Drs. Petersen and Brulov and looks ready to kill either or both of them until Brulov gives him a glass of milk laced with a sedative and he goes under.

Eventually “Brown” a.k.a. “Edwardes” realizes that his guilt complex about black lines in white snow came from an incident in his childhood in which he accidentally killed his younger brother while sliding down a bannister in the snow (depicted by Hitchcock and cinematographer George Barnes in what the hosts called a “counter-zoom” effect, tracking in one direction and simultaneously zooming in the other, which Hitchcock is usually given credit for inventing 13 years later in the scenes of Vertigo that show James Stewart’s character actually experiencing vertigo). For the rest of it the revelation comes in a dream sequence designed by Salvador Dali and ghost-directed by William Cameron Menzies, a longtime Selznick collaborator who had no other role on this film. “I brought in Salvador Dali to do the dream sequences, not for publicity purposes – as Selznick thought – but because I wanted to have dreams photographed vividly,” Hitchcock told Charles HIgham and Joel Greenberg for their 1969 book The Celluloid Muse. “Until then, movie dreams were always blurred, always double exposures, and misty; and dreams are not like that, they’re very, very vivid.” Sorry, Sir Alfred, but that’s just another case of “first-itis” (my term for the tendency of people to claim they or their biographical subjects were the first to do something when other people had beaten them to it). In 1924, over two decades before Spellbound, Buster Keaton had made the film Sherlock, Jr., in which he played a movie projectionist who dreams his way into the film he’s showing – and Keaton (who directed as well as starring), cinematographers Elgin Lessley and Byron Houck, and special-effects genius Fred Gabourie had made his dream sequences bright and vivid, too. (Keaton has finally been recognized as one of the two great geniuses of silent comedy, alongside Charlie Chaplin, but he’s still underrated as a filmmaking innovator.) Predictably, Dali, who’d made two experimental silent films in France in 1929 (Un Chien Andalou) and 1930 (L’Age d’Or) with Luis Buñuel, was not happy with the way his sequences were used in Spellbound. Dali had intended the dream to last 20 minutes; in the finished film it’s only two minutes, and it has a voice-over narration by Gregory Peck in character overly literal in its explanation of what we’re seeing. (Hitchcock recalled that one of Dali’s ideas was to have Ingrid Bergman, who doesn’t appear at all in the film’s dream sequence as it stands, covered in ants, an effect he’d already used in Un Chien Andalou.)

From the dream and Peck’s explanation of it, Petersen deduces that the mystery man was at a ski resort with the real Dr. Edwardes and he witnessed him die in a skiing accident. Using the information Petersen has got out of him, the police go to the resort and find Edwardes – only his body has a bullet in his back, indicating he was murdered. The cops arrest Peck’s character (who in the meantime has recalled his real name, “John Ballantyne”) and Petersen is trying to prove him innocent. She confronts Dr. Murchison, who in Edwardes’s absence has regained his old job running Green Manors, only [spoiler alert!] Murchison makes a slip: he says, “I knew Edwardes only slightly,” revealing himself to be Edwardes’s killer because if he’d known Edwardes at all he’d have instantly recognized Peck’s character as an impostor. Murchison and Petersen meet in his office and Murchison pulls the gun out of his desk drawer, holds it on Petersen, and threatens to kill her. She points out that he might be able to plead insanity on Edwardes’s death but if he shoots her it’ll be in cold blood and he’ll surely be executed. Then she leaves the office and we see an extreme close-up of the gun as Murchison turns it on himself and uses it to commit suicide. (Joseph Breen, head of the Production Code Administration, usually frowned on having a criminal commit suicide because that meant he evaded being held legally accountable, but apparently Selznick talked him into O.K.’ing the scene because Murchison had already been depicted as mentally ill.) The gunshot is shown in a few frames of color film inserted into this otherwise black-and-white movie, though for years prints of Spellbound didn’t contain that flash of color. Ultimately Dr. Brulov and Dr. Fleurot see Ballantyne and Petersen off on their honeymoon.

I regard Spellbound as a good but not a great movie; its sexism annoyed me when I first saw it in the 1970’s and it still does. It was the first film for which Hitchcock got a possessory credit – “Alfred Hitchcock’s Spellbound” – indicating that, like D. W. Griffith, Cecil B. DeMille, and Frank Capra at their peaks, Hitchcock had become a marketable name to movie audiences and people would pay to see a Hitchcock movie no matter who was in it. Spellbound was nominated for seven Academy Awards but won only one, for Miklós Rósza’s musical score (which originally included long stretches of entrance and exit music which were dropped from prints until this reissue), which illustrated the mental discombobulation of Peck’s character by using the theremin, the all-electronic instrument Dr. Leon Theremin, a Russian refugee who moved to the U.S., had invented in 1920 and patented in 1928. David Selznick was hoping to be able to advertise Spellbound as the first film to use the theremin in its score, but in the meantime Rósza got a job working on Billy Wilder’s The Lost Weekend, using the theremin to express the anguish of Ray Milland’s alcoholic character. Due to difficulties Selznick was having with his distributor, United Artists, The Lost Weekend, though made after Spellbound, reached theatres ahead of it. Ironically, after Rósza pioneered the theremin as an expression of mental instability, it became most familiar to movie audiences in innumerable science-fiction cheapies from the 1950’s heralding the arrival of a flying saucer from outer space! Spellbound also has problems with its cast; Ingrid Bergman nails her part but Gregory Peck, in only his third film (after Days of Glory and The Keys of the Kingdom), seems rather gawky and one wonders how Joseph Cotten, whom Hitchcock had wanted for an earlier version of the project that stuck more closely to the novel, might have played it. Then again Peck’s inexperienced gawkiness works, after a fashion, for a man who literally does not know who he is. David O. Selznick green-lit Spellbound because he wanted to make a movie that would celebrate and glorify psychoanalysis. He was under analysis himself with a therapist named Dr. May Romm, whom he appointed to the film as a technical advisor and who apparently frequently clashed with Hitchcock.

The Paradine Case (The Selznick Stodio, Vanguard Films, Selznick Releasing Organizaiton, 1947)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The Turner Classic Movies mini-marathon of Alfred Hitchcock/Gregory Peck movies on Sunday, November 15 continued with The Paradine Case, made in 1947 and once again produced by Selznick, who this time also wrote the script. (The initial adaptation was done by Alma Reville, Mrs. Alfred Hitchcock, and James Bridie, and Ben Hecht also made some uncredited contributions.) The Paradine Case began in 1933 as a novel by Robert Hichens, and Selznick, who’d just started an unhappy two years as a producer at his father-in-law’s studio, MGM, immediately grabbed the movie rights as a vehicle for Greta Garbo. Unfortunately [spoiler alert!] Garbo flatly refused to make the film because it would have cast her as a murderess. Selznick nursed the idea of making The Paradine Case for the next 14 years until, flush with the success of his 1946 cornball Western Duel in the Sun (a vehicle for his second wife, actress Jennifer Jones), he finally put it together and assigned the direction to Hitchcock. After once again trying for Garbo and also offering it to Ingrid Bergman, who was disgusted with Selznick and his contractual stranglehold on her career, Selznick imported Italian actress Alida Valli (whom he billed as “Valli,” her last name alone, and in cursive script) to play the story’s central character: Mrs. Maddalena Anna Paradine, wife of a British colonel who’d been blinded in the war. (The last name is pronounced “Para-deen,” by the way.) When the film opens Col. Paradine has just died by poison and Mrs. Paradine is being arrested for the crime in a scene that seems like it was adapted from Cole Porter’s song “Miss Otis Regrets” (which was written around the same time as Hichens’s novel). Being accused of murder seems to bother Mrs. Paradine less than being pulled away from the dinner her cook has just prepared and her butler has just served, and she’s more concerned with making sure all her fine clothes are brought to her in jail and she’s allowed to wear them than with the facts of her case. Mrs. Paradine turns to an old family friend, Sir Simon Flaquer (Charles Coburn), for legal help, but because Flaquer is only a solicitor (a business lawyer) he can’t take her case. (British law makes a distinction between a solicitor and a barrister, a courtroom lawyer; Mexican law makes a similar distinction between a licenciado, a business lawyer, and an abogado, a courtroom lawyer.)

Simon arranges for his friend Anthony Keane (Gregory Peck), a brilliant trial lawyer who’s never lost a case, to take on Mrs. Paradine. The moment Keane and Mrs. Paradine meet, he’s immediately infatuated with her even though he’s already married and has been for 11 years. Flaquer and Keane also frequently socialize with the judge assigned to the case, Lord Thomas Horfield (Charles Laughton), who immediately has the hots for Keane’s wife Gay (Ann Todd). In the U.S. today the idea of the judge socializing and having dinner parties with an attorney in a case before him would be considered an outrageous conflict of interest. At one point Keane offers to withdraw from Mrs. Paradine’s case if that will save his marriage, but Gay insists that he remain on the job and work his ass off to acquit her because if someone else represents her and she’s found guilty, the memory of her will come between them forever. Though the alleged crime took place in London, Keane insists on traveling to the Paradines’ country estate, where he meets André Latour (Louis Jourdan), whom Keane comes to suspect of the crime. Keane intuits that Latour and Mrs. Paradine were having an affair and that Latour gave Col. Paradine the poisoned burgundy wine that killed him. Maybe it was an assisted suicide with Latour merely serving as the instrument of Col. Paradine’s death; maybe Latour killed his boss in cold blood out of lust for his wife. When the trial begins in London’s Old Bailey courthouse, represented by a quite impressive set as well as an establishing exterior in which a portion of the front of the building has been blown off by a World War II bomb, facing Leo G. Carroll as the prosecutor, Keane insists on a vicious and aggressive cross-examination of Latour despite Mrs. Paradine’s insistence that Latour should be left alone. When Keane’s brilliant cross-examination finally has broken Latour’s credibility to shreds, Mrs. Paradine makes a stunning confession that she really did kill her husband because she loved Latour and wanted to be with him. Keane is devastated; he makes a half-hearted attempt at a closing argument, flees the courtroom, and holes up at the home of Flaquer and his grown daughter (the only two voices of reason we see in this film) until he and his wife are finally able to reconcile.

The Paradine Case is much more a David Selznick movie than an Alfred Hitchcock one, and though Edgar Wright acknowledged introducing it on Turner Classic Movies that he’d never seen it until the recent restoration and was quite impressed with it, I had seen it before and hadn’t liked it then or now. Much of it reminded me of the note F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote during his brief stint as a screenwriter on Selznick’s Gone With the Wind, and in particular his comment, “I still think it’s dull and false for one character to describe another.” Selznick didn’t take Fitzgerald’s advice on Gone With the Wind and he didn’t on The Paradine Case, either; The Paradine Case is full of dull and false scenes in which the characters describe each other. Hitchcock was not happy with the cast Selznick saddled him with; he wanted a British actor like Ronald Colman or Laurence Olivier to play Keane. (My husband Charles had the same complaint; he joked that Peck was playing “the only American barrister in London,” though I found Peck’s quirky accent believable as a Brit. I also couldn’t help but recall that Peck’s most famous and highly regarded film, To Kill a Mockingbird, also cast him as a trial lawyer.) But the actor who most ticked Hitchcock off was Louis Jourdan. He had wanted Robert Newton, a considerably uglier character actor, for the role because, as he explained to Charles Higham and Joel Greenberg in the 1969 interview book The Celluloid Muse, “[T]he whole point about the lawyer falling in love with the murderess was to realize the degradation of falling for a woman who had as one of her lovers a manure-smelling groom. He should have had to sit face to face with a coarse, horny-handed slob, and look and say, ‘I’ve sunk low enough to become infatuated with a woman who will even sleep with this. And of course it was all lost because Selznick had signed this pretty-pretty boy.” (Hitchcock was obviously intending for an attraction between the two along the lines of D. H. Lawrence’s 1928 novel Lady Chatterley’s Lover.) In the movie one can see Hitchcock and cinematographer Lee Garmes trying to give Jourdan as unflattering a lighting as possible, but they still weren’t able to turn this French pretty-boy into the manure-smelling lout of Hitchcock’s dreams.

One of the film’s Academy Award nominations was for Ethel Barrymore as Judge Horfield’s wife, though most of her part was lost on the cutting-room floor and she’s only in the film as it stands for three minutes. Apparently the Academy voters screened a longer three-hour version which, according to a “Trivia” item on the film’s imdb.com page, contained “a brilliant museum scene where Lady Horfield requests Anthony Keane to save Mrs. Paradine, and another scene where Lady Horfield tries to hide her coughing from her husband.” (Frankly, watching The Paradine Case I’d found myself wishing that Laughton’s real-life wife, Elsa Lanchester, had been playing his wife in the movie.) The Paradine Case is a David O. Selznick movie masquerading as an Alfred Hitchcock movie, and it’s hard not to look at it without wondering what it might have been had Selznick got to make it at MGM in 1933 with Garbo and Colman in the leads and a more complaisant, less personal director.

Lime Kiln Club Field Day (Klaw and Erlanger, Biograph, New York Museum of Modern Art, filmed 1913, released 2014)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Sunday, November 15), after Turner Classic Movies’s mini-marathon of Alfred Hitchcock, Gregory Peck, and Leo G. Carroll in Spellbound and The Paradine Case, Jacqueline Stewart’s “Silent Sunday Nights” feature was a fascinating film that was shot in 1913 but wasn’t edited and released until 101 years later. It was called Lime Kiln Club Field Day and was a vehicle for the great African-American comedian Bert Williams. Lime Kiln Club Field Day was based on a novel called Brother Gardner’s Lime-Kiln Club by Charles Bertrand Lewis and it was produced as a co-venture between the Klaw and Erlanger stage production company and American Biograph, the pioneering studio that was part of Thomas A. Edison’s Motion Picture Patents Trust and launched the career of D. W. Griffith. It was preserved by one of the great unsung heroines of film preservation history: Iris Barry, who as curator of the New York Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in the 1930’s managed to sell her bosses on the idea that film was a modern American art form and therefore as worthy of preservation as any other. (Remember that this was the era in which movies were still legally considered “a business.” In 1912 the U.S. Supreme Court had ruled that films were not a form of “speech” under the protection of the First Amendment, and the court didn’t reverse this until 40 years later. So studios during the entire “classic Hollywood” era of the 1920’s, 1930’s, and 1940’s lived in fear that government censors would come down on them and dictate the contents of their films, and they formed the Motion Picture Producers and Distributors Association of America to forestall government censorship by censoring themselves.) When Barry got word that the then-current owners of Biograph in 1938 were about to junk all the surviving negatives and prints of their films, she got in touch with them and arranged for them to donate the reels to MoMA instead. Alas, it literally took decades for MoMA to inventory the Biograph collection, and while particularly important titles (like most of Griffith’s one-reelers for the company) were in circulation by the 1950’s, much of the Biograph output lay fallow in the MoMA vaults.

In 2014 MoMA’s current curators found this stash of footage from a movie that had been abandoned in post-production after all or most of it had been shot, and film preservationist Karl Malkames transferred the fragile 35 mm. nitrate camera negatives to fine-grained positive stock. The surviving footage of Lime Kiln Club Field Day was assembled under certain rules, including the idea that the preservationists would keep the individual shots together and let them run as long as they did instead of trying to edit them, which would have meant second-guessing the original filmmakers. Jacqueline Stewart presented Lime Kiln Field Day with a co-host, white (or at least white-presenting) author Allyson Nadia Field, author of a number of books on silent film, including Acts of Love: Black Performance and the Kiss That Changed Film History. The “kiss that changed film history” was between a Black man, Saint Suttle, and a Black woman, Gertie Brown, who regularly performed together as part of a group called The Ragtime Four. Along with the other members, John and Maud Brewster, they were responsible for popularizing the cakewalk; Suttle even wrote a song for it, “Old Jasper’s Cake Walk.” Ironically, Suttle and Brown were among the famous Black performers who played in blackface and advertised themselves as “The Two Real Coons” – as did Bert Williams and his vaudeville partner, George Walker. Stewart and Field prefaced Lime Kiln Club Field Day with the 1898 Thomas A. Edison short Something Good – Negro Kiss, which showed Suttle and Brown kissing each other several times. Like Edison’s other movies at the time, it was just one minute long and was meant to be viewed in a peep-show device rather than projected on a screen.

Lime Kiln Club Field Day has a simple plot: the Black workforce at the titular lime kiln (which I’d encountered in movies before only as a particularly efficacious place for dumping the body of a murder victim and having the lime eat it without a trace) has a major picnic and county fair. Bert Williams plays a con artist who fleeces the crowd by selling gin allegedly drawn from a “gin spring” on the grounds of the picnic, but in fact from a jug he accidentally dropped down an otherwise dry well, causing its contents to break and spill. Bert is also one of three rivals for the affections of a quite statuesque young woman (Odessa Warren Grey), all of whom want to take her to the fair despite her overprotective mother (Abbie Mitchell, one of only two cast members besides Williams I’d actually heard of before; she was the wife of Will Marion Cook, member of James Reese Europe’s Clef Club, leader of the Southern Syncopated Orchestra that brought authentic jazz to Europe for the first time in 1919, and Duke Ellington’s composition teacher; Mitchell herself was in the original cast of George Gershwin’s Black opera Porgy and Bess in 1935 and introduced the song “Summertime”), who dumps buckets of water on them. One of the club members is played by Charles Gilpin, the elusive Black actor for whom Eugene O’Neill wrote The Emperor Jones and All God’s Chillun Got Wings (only they had a falling-out because Gilpin demanded O’Neill delete the “N-word” from the script of The Emperor Jones and O’Neill refused), while one of Bert’s rivals for Odessa’s affections is played by Sam Corker, Jr., apparently a major figure in Black theatre in New York until he died just a year after Lime Kiln Club Field Day was shot. The film was accompanied by a rather overly raucous score by Donald Sosin, though for one quite moving scene (the one, seen in three takes, where Bert drops the gin jug down the well) Sosin wisely used an instrumental version of Williams’ own song “Nobody.”

What I knew about Bert Williams before seeing this film came mainly from white performers from his time or the generation afterwards. W. C. Fields said, “Bert Williams was the funniest man I ever saw on stage, and the saddest man I ever saw off it.” Mae West told her late-in-life biographer Charlotte Chandler that her uncle, show business attorney Thomas West, had arranged for her to meet Williams, and Mae West was stunned when she met Williams and found that, while still visibly Black, he was considerably lighter-skinned than he was on stage. Williams regularly performed in blackface, and in Lime Kiln Club Field Day he was reportedly the only character who wore blackface (though I thought I spotted about two or three others). I was already familiar with Williams’s records, including “Nobody,” and from them I was expecting a performance that would blend comedy and pathos in the way Charlie Chaplin became a star from years later. Indeed, throughout Lime Kiln Club Field Day I was thinking “Black Chaplin,” and I had to keep reminding myself that this was shot one year before Chaplin ever faced a camera and two years before he evolved the celebrated “Tramp” character that brought pathos to screen comedy. After the movie Stewart and Field made the same point: Bert Williams was playing the same balance Chaplin became famous for and he was doing it before Chaplin did. It’s both idle and infuriating to think what sort of a film career Bert Williams might have had if Lime Kiln Club Field Day had been completed and released in a timely fashion (though Williams did make a film for Biograph three years later, A Natural-Born Gambler, that’s available on archive.org); maybe he’d have had a star career in film the way he had in the Ziegfeld Follies on stage (which is where he and W. C. Fields crossed paths), or maybe he would have left a few scraps of film behind that would have us asking, “What could he have accomplished if he hadn’t handicapped by racism?,” the way Florence Cole Talbert’s stunning recording of the Bell Song from Leo Delibes’s opera Lakmé from 1922 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=56kd69bBmlw&list=RD56kd69bBmlw&start_radio=1) showed what a great potential talent the opera world denied itself by its anti-Black racism.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Law and Order: Special Victims Unit: "Obedience" (Dick Wolf Entertainment, Universal Television, NBC-TV, aired November 12, 2026)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Thursday, November 12) my husband Charles and I watched episodes of Law and Order: Special Victims Unit and the flagship Law and Order. Law and Order: Special Victims Unit has become the longest-running (it’s into its 28th season) scripted series in prime time, and last night’s episode, “Obedience,” was its 600th. Executive producer Dick Wolf and line producer Michele Fazekas decided to commemorate the anniversary by bringing back Elliott Stabler (Christopher Meloni, my greatest celebrity crush of all time; he’s now considerably older and more grizzled but that fabled basket is still intact, and since he was wearing blue jeans throughout the episode I got to see a lot more of it than when he was an SVU “regular” and that great bod was frustratingly encased in Armani suits) and having him and Captain Olivia Benson (Mariska Hargitay) rework and old case. It dealt with the rape and murder of a nun named Sister Benedicta (her pre-ordination first name was Clare but I don’t recall her last name) in 1998 (a year before the show actually went on the air). A young Black man named Charles Greene (Chukwudi Iwuji) with a history of crack addiction and petty crime to support it was convicted of the murder and has served 28 years in Attica for it. But Gwen Sharpe (J. Smith-Cameron) of an Innocence Project-like organization approaches Benson and asks her to reopen the case. Greene claims he merely found Clare’s body after she’d already been stabbed, and he tried to pull the knife from her chest only to have her blood splatter all over him. He was convicted after a test of the bite marks on her shoulder matched his and after Stabler’s interrogation, which was not videotaped. Stabler is at first super-reluctant to reopen the case because he’s convinced he got it right the first time, but after certain details don’t add up and Benson points out that bite-mark evidence is no longer considered scientifically credible, he turns around. As part of the re-investigation Stabler and Benson interview Sandra Garza (Laura Innes), who left the order of nuns at the center of the case and has led a secular life ever since. Garza tells the cops that there was a corrupt priest at the convent named Father Anthony Lazzaro (William Sadler) who took advantage of the nuns’ sexual naïveté to molest them, including both performing oral sex on them and making them suck him. He was able to get away with it because many of the women in the convent had never had sex even before they took the vow of chastity and therefore were easy prey for his assertion that having sex with him would bring them closer to God.

The cops try to trace Father Lazzaro but have to maneuver through the church hierarchy to do so. First Stabler and Benson interview an African-American priest, Father Dave (Darrell Morris, Jr.), who’s running Father Lazzaro’s old parish, but he can’t (or won’t) tell them Father Lazzaro’s current location. Then they’re told by church attorney Peter O’Sullivan (a marvelously smarmy performance by Jim Gaffigan, usually known as a stand-up comedian) that he’s not allowed to tell them where Father Lazzaro is. The cops demand the information and get swamped with irrelevant and useless documentation which they have to go through for the few nuggets of important information – a classic strategy used by big bureaucracies both sacred and secular to evade responsibility for their actions. Stabler and Benson also interview the Mother Superior of the convent, Mother Eusebia (Kathleen Chalfant), who acknowledges that she knows where Father Lazzaro is. He’s at a so-called “therapy” camp in upstate New York which the church maintains for priests accused of sexual sins so they aren’t actually punished for their crimes. Instead he and his fellow residents are being kept in that relatively nice environment, and when the cops show up to arrest him not only for Clare’s murder but that of another nun named Christine (whose corpse they exhumed from the basement of Father Lazzaro’s old church and discovered not only she but her unborn baby had been killed, and they were able to extract enough DNA from the surviving skeleton to prove that Lazzaro was the father), he’s alone in a canoe rowing for relaxation at the facility’s private lake. The director of the “treatment center” (Brian Sgambati) calls Lazzaro to come in from his rowboat outing and talk to the cops, and he’s initially combative until they mention Christine. The assistant district attorney assigned to SVU, Dominick Carisi, Jr. (Peter Scanavino), takes charge of securing Greene’s formal exoneration and release despite Greene’s fully understandable bitterness that he was robbed of 28 years of a normal life he could have had if he hadn’t been busted and convicted of a murder he didn’t commit. Writer Michele Fazekas did a nice job of conveying both the antagonism and affection between Stabler and Benson as they reunite to solve a case they initially got wrong, and there’s an especially poignant moment when Stabler acknowledges that one of his initial errors in the investigation was not interviewing Father Lazzaro at all. When Benson asks him what would have happened if he had, Stabler says, “He’d have denied it all, and I would have believed him because I’m a Catholic myself and we believe the priests are close to God.”

Law and Order: "Do No Harm" (Dick Wolf Entertainment, Universal Television, NBC-TV, aired November 12, 2026)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Just about any story after Law and Order: Special Victims Unit: “Obedience” would have been a tough follow-up, but Dick Wolf and his writers (Art Alamo and Thomas Wong) came up with a lulu for the Law and Order episode that followed “Obedience” on November 12. It was called “Do No Harm,” after the Hippocratic Oath, and was about a 24-year-old medical student named Grace Zhou (Emily Song) who’s found dead in her apartment by her roommate, Ryleigh McAdams (Lisa Naso). The ultimate cause of death is suffocation with a pillow, but the medical examiner finds three puncture marks, one on one arm and the other two on the others, indicating that she received injections just before she died. The drugs in her system from the injections included a saline solution, rocuronium bromide to induce paralysis, and potassium chloride to stop the heart and kill – the same sequence as is common practice in lethal-injection executions. The investigation by police detectives Theo Walker (David Ajala) and Rob Calvino (James Badge Dale) turns up a number of actual or seeming red herrings, including Grace’s ex-boyfriend Curtis Foster (Jake Goodhart) and two doctors she worked with as a medical student, Aekansh Reddy (Sorab Wadia) and Anton Visser (Travis Laughlin). The cops initially think that Grace was having affairs with either or both these men, especially when they discover a silent surveillance video of Grace in a major argument with Dr. Visser over something. It turns out that Grace had been working with Dr. Visser on a clinical trial of a supposed new anti-depressant that worked differently from existing ones, but the trial had found that the new drug was ineffective. The argument came over Dr. Visser’s determination to write a research paper saying that the study was “inconclusive” rather than the drug didn’t work at all, and later we learn that Grace had a personal reason for hoping the drug would work. In the opening scene we’d actually seen Grace seem upbeat and happy, but later we learn that she’d suffered from long-term depression since age 13 and had decided to kill herself. She’d already made two suicide attempts, one five years before and one two years before, and in both cases her parents Henry (Michael Tow) and Eleanor (Deborah S. Craig) had signed her into the hospital and therefore knew about it. Her killer was her ex-boyfriend Curtis Foster, who agreed to help her die in her own apartment, though in the end the lethal injection drugs didn’t work (the recent case of Christa Pike, sentenced to death by lethal injection in Tennessee for a murder committed 30 years ago but who survived the experience, albeit in intense pain, is actually mentioned in the script) and Curtis had to kill her by smothering her with a pillow.

One of the interesting twists in the Alamo-Wong script is that the attitude of Henry and Eleanor Zhou does a 180° during the trial, from the desire for vengeance to seeing Curtis as a good friend of their daughter who only wanted to help her relieve her suffering. The case also arouses an emotional conflict between the two prosecutors, Nolan Price (Hugh Dancy) and Samantha Maroun (Odelya Halevi). Samantha is five months’ pregnant (though this is something of a surprise since the Law and Order screenwriters have not previously mentioned a husband, partner, significant other or even a one-night stand that might have knocked her up), and in one scene in a corridor of the courthouse Eleanor Zhou confides in her that motherhood is a burden as well as a satisfaction. It’s an odd bit of connection between a woman who’s just lost her only child and a woman who’s about to become a mother for (presumably) the first time. Samantha’s impending motherhood is making her feel sorrier for the Zhous and more sympathetic to Curtis Foster, to the point where she actually pleads with Price to arrange a deal and allow Curtis to plead to manslaughter. Price in turn is fearful that if Curtis is allowed to plead down, or even worse is acquitted by the jury, it will open the floodgates. He notes that the New York legislature passed a right-to-die law but specifically limited its effect to terminal physical illnesses, and in fact put a provision in that the person seeking legal permission for an assisted suicide must be of “sound mind.” If Curtis Foster gets away with killing Grace Zhou, Price warns, just about everyone suffering from long-term depression will grab the opportunity to enlist doctors or health professionals (or, in Curtis’s case, wanna-be health professionals) in helping them off themselves. Curtis’s defense counsel, Rebecca Fuller (Hettienne Park), calls Grace’s psychiatrist to the stand, and she testifies not only that untreatable depression should be considered a terminal condition within the right-to-die law but that Grace’s seemingly good spirits in the last week of her life should be interpreted as gratitude that her ordeal would finally end soon. This is not an easy show to write about or to watch; it’s Law and Order at its best, where we’re not sure either how we want to see it end or whether justice would be best served by Curtis’s acquittal or conviction – though in the end [spoiler alert!] Curtis is found guilty of murdering Grace, largely because in the end when the lethal injection drugs didn’t work he killed her with the pillow instead of calling 911 to have her rescued.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Godzilla Minus Zero (Toho Studios, Robot Communications, GKIDS, 2026)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Tuesday, November 10) my husband Charles and I joined about eight other members of Bears San Diego for a showing at the AMC Mission Valley theatres of the 2026 film Godzilla Minus Zero. This turned out to be a direct sequel to the 2023 film Godzilla Minus One, made by the Japanese Toho company (which developed the character of Godzilla in the first place for a 1954 movie called Gojira which I’ve previously hailed as one of only two truly great giant-monster movies, the original 1933 King Kong being the other) once they recovered the rights to him from Legendary Entertainment, the U.S. company affiliated with Warner Bros. that had made a four-film sequence in the so-called “Monsterverse” that paired Godzilla with King Kong and various other giant-monster characters. I went into the theatre not knowing that this was a Japanese production or that the film was (except for a couple of brief scenes featuring American military characters speaking English) in Japanese with English subtitles. I give a lot of credit to the largely youthful audience for being willing to sit through a film with subtitles, though one critic noted that young people growing up in today’s Internet- and social-media-saturated world are used to reading text on their screens. What surprised me most about the film was that it may well be the grimmest Godzilla movie ever made since the 1954 original. It takes place in 1949, just four years after Japan’s defeat in World War II and the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. At the time the U.S. was still ruling Japan directly as an occupying power, under the direction of General Douglas MacArthur, which continued until the U.S. and Japan signed the Treaty of San Francisco on April 28, 1952.

As in the 1954 Gojira (the first Godzilla movie and still the best of the ones I’ve seen, far better than the brutally re-edited and largely re-shot version the U.S. got from American International two years later), Japan in this movie seems to be going through a nationwide post-traumatic stress disorder stemming from the loss of World War II and in particular the obliteration of much of their urban infrastructure first from the fire-bombing raids that had pounded Tokyo and other cities and then from the atomic attacks. The central characters are Kôichi Shikishima (Ryūnosuke Kamiki), a would-be kamikaze pilot whose suicide bombing raid was interrupted during the war by a mechanical problem with his plane; his wife, Noriko Ôishi (Minami Hamabe), who during the events of the 2023 Godzilla Minus One got contaminated with some of Godzilla’s DNA and therefore has a mysterious telepathic ability to communicate with him; their pre-pubescent daughter (the Wikipedia page on the film describes her as adopted but that wasn’t clear in the movie itself) Akiko (Sae Nagatani); and various scientists. Kenji Noda (Hidetaka Yoshioka) heads an agency called the Large-Scale Disaster Response Bureau, which publicly pretends to be in the business of responding to natural disasters but is really in existence to ward off attacks on Japan by giant monsters. The coastal city of Matsumoto is attacked by a giant creature that looks a lot like Godzilla except that it can fly.

An embittered scientist named Kanji Murakami (Min Tanaka), who lost a son at Hiroshima (the poor kid’s burned body becomes a recurring image during the film), and his assistant, Akira Hagiwara (Kô Maehara), work on the response to this new monster, depicted as an arrival from outer space. The scientists name it “Ghidorah” as a mash-up of the words for “chimera” and “hydra” (as the original Japanese name for Godzilla, Gojira, was a mash-up of “gorilla” and “whale,” which was what the creature was supposed to look like originally until director Ishirô Honda decided to make it a dinosaur instead). With the reluctant support of American authorities (there’s one rather bitter scene in which the insignia of a U.S. plane is painted out and replaced with a red sun, the emblem of Japan’s air force, so the U.S. can maintain plausible deniability that their aircraft are being used to hunt down giant monsters), an aerial expedition against Ghidorah is undertaken. The fact that all the planes in this 1949-set film are still being moved by propellers instead of jets adds to the retro atmosphere of this movie. Shikishima’s two colleagues are killed in the attack against Ghidorah, but he successfully launches a new sort of fuel-air bomb intended to kill the monster. Only it has the opposite effect; instead of doing him in it transforms him into something even more lethal, complete with three heads and two tails as well as the ability to lift and destroy buildings with a gravity beam. The authorities eventually decide that the only way they can defeat Ghidorah is to revive Godzilla, who sank in the sea at the end of the 2023 film, and to do that they invent a device called a “resonance wave amplifier.” (The fact that the electronics of it are powered by vacuum tubes instead of transistors, which the U.S. invented but Japan most successfully exploited commercially, also adds a nice retro feel to this film’s tech.)

They test this contraption by turning it on and immediately causing a flock of nearby crows to fly into their building, a sequence that reminded Charles of Alfred Hitchcock’s The Birds. Unfortunately, they need Noriko Ôishi to operate this machine to revive Godzilla and turn it against Ghidorah, and this puts a strain on her already weakened (by its infection with Godzilla’s DNA) body. There’s an odd fantasy sequence in which the embittered Murakami envisions sending the revived Godzilla to the U.S. to destroy the Statue of Liberty and the Brooklyn Bridge, which reminded me of the 1932 film Chandu the Magician and the similar sequence in which that film’s villain, Roxor (Bela Lugosi), fantasizes using his bizarre machines to destroy several world capitals, including Paris and London. Meteorologist Makoto Aoyama (Masami Nagasawa) has figured out where Ghidorah is likely to turn up next by examining the weather patterns around Japan. The scientists running the response effort select the Ginza neighborhood of Tokyo as the location where they want Godzilla and Ghidorah to have their big fight scene, since Godzilla already obliterated most of it in the 2023 film. The plan is to let the two monsters weaken each other and then kill the one that survived. They first attack Ghidorah with liquid nitrogen to make its body brittle and frozen, and then they drop a heat bomb on it, only instead of going on to kill Godzilla after they’ve finished off Ghidorah, the crew receives orders (from whom we’re not sure) to keep him alive after all in case he’s ever needed to ward off another giant-monster threat. In the finale Kôichi Shikishima and Noriko Ôishi decide they literally know too much to allow the government to let them remain at liberty. At first they threaten to leave their daughter Akiko behind with their next-door neighbor, orphanage operator Sumiko Ôta (Sakura Andō), but she’s all too aware that the other orphans were all told that by their parents, who were mostly killed in the war. At the end Shikishima and Ôishi let Akiko get on their motorcycle and flee with them.

I liked Godzilla Minus Zero a good deal better than I’d thought I would, mainly because it duplicated the sense of social pain better than any Godzilla movie I’ve seen since the 1954 Gojira. I’ve never seen the 2023 Godzilla Minus One but I’d like to (even though there are a lot of movies on my must-see list ahead of it). Another thing I like about this movie is the writer/director, Takashi Yamazaki, wisely kept Godzilla and Ghidorah off screen through much of the movie; though that made much of the plot exposition more ponderous than it might have been, it also had the Val Lewton-style effect of making the monsters more menacing precisely because they weren’t being pounded into our faces every minute. I was also impressed by the musical score by Naoki Satô, even though it was mixed awfully loudly in the manner of most modern movies aimed at the teen audience. I even liked the surround-sound effects (this was apparently the first Japanese film made in the IMAX format), even though some of those low-frequency rumbles seemed to go back to the late 1970’s and Universal’s “Sensurround” process. Still, I had a better time watching Godzilla Minus Zero than I was expecting!

Monday, November 9, 2026

Battlestar Galactica: "Saga of a Star World" (Glen A. Larson Productions, Universal Television, ABC-TV, aired September 17, 1978)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Sunday, November 8) my husband Charles and I watched “Saga of a Star World,” the first episode (of 24) in the short-lived ABC-TV series Battlestar Galactica, a really obvious knockoff of Star Wars produced by Universal Television. I got interested in this when Fanfare magazine sent me a boxed set of eight CD’s in a five-volume package containing Stu Phillips’s original scores for the Battlestar Galactica show. I’ll also never forget the hype that surrounded Battlestar Galactica when it was first aired, or the bad luck that beset ABC the night the show was scheduled to premiere. It was September 17, 1978, also the night then-U.S. President Jimmy Carter announced from Camp David near Washington, D.C. that he had successfully brokered a peace deal between Israel and Egypt. The opening of Battlestar Galactica was pre-empted so we could see the ceremony and hear a lot of promising talk from the principals – Carter, Israeli prime minister Menachem Begin, and Egyptian president Anwar Sadat – about what a great deal they’d made with each other and how peace would finally come to the Middle East at last. That was a really strange lead-in to a TV show whose whole plot is based around a peace treaty that goes horribly wrong and allows an attack that wipes out virtually all of the human race. Set many centuries in the future, Battlestar Galactica posited that Earth had colonized a string of nearby planets in other solar systems, only this had happened so long ago that the people living in these colonies had only dim and distant memories and legends about their true origins. The bad guys in Battlestar Galactica are the Cylons, who have been fighting a war with the colonists for 1,000 years and seek the utter annihilation of the human race (sort of like Hitler with the Jews).

The Cylons are actually robots; they were originally invented by a race of sentient reptiles but, like the robots in Karel Čapek’s R.U.R. (the pioneering 1920 science-fiction play that not only invented the concept of artificial humans but actually coined the term “robots” for them; Čapek took it from the Czech word Robotnik, meaning “worker”), they rebelled against their makers, killed them en masse, and took over. It’s as if George Lucas had decided to make everybody in the Star Wars Evil Empire look like Darth Vader, though I wondered if Battlestar Galactica creator Glen A. Larson had taken the concept from the Daleks of Doctor Who, also killer robots who wanted to annihilate the human race. (Charles cited another possible source for this plot element: Fred Saberhagen’s Berserker series, about a universe whose killer robots, which like the Cylons obliterated the race that created them, seek to eliminate not only human beings but all biological life forms, Saberhagen first introduced this universe in a 1963 magazine story, published his first book using it in 1967, and continued until 2005, two years before his death, so it was still running when Battlestar Galactica was made.) When the “Saga of a Star World” episode begins, the Cylons have sued for peace after 1,000 years of war against humanity, and President Adar (Lew Ayres), leader of the Council of Twelve that rules the various human colonies, has gladly accepted the peace offer. Only it’s a Cylon trap and, as the humans are resting and taking it easy thinking there will be peace at last, they will launch their genocidal attack and eliminate humanity once and for all. There seems to be something uncomfortably ironic about the casting of Ayres, real-life conscientious objector during World War II, as the President whose appeasement policy leads to humanity’s near-extermination, as if series creator Glen A. Larson and casting director Mark Malis were telling Ayres, “You were wrong then and you’re wrong now.”

The one member of the Council of Twelve who sees through the Cylons’ scheme is Adama (Lorne Greene, once again playing a single father with a number of adult kids as he did on his star-making role on the Western TV series Bonanza), who’s also the commander of Galactica, one of 12 “battlestar” spaceships that are the main defense force of the colonists. He sends his most trusted pilots, his son Captain Apollo (Richard Hatch, the only actor who appeared in both the original Battlestar Galactica and its 2004-2008 reboot) and Lieutenant Starbuck (Dirk Benedict), who’s dating Adama’s daughter Lt. Athena (Maren Jensen) but also has, you might say, a girl on every planet. Unfortunately, Starbuck bails at the last minute to give Apollo’s brother Zac (Rick Springfield, whom Charles immediately recognized even though at the time he’d only appeared as an actor on General Hospital; his brief but spectacular career as a singer would come later) a chance to fly his first patrol. The Cylons attack them and Apollo escapes but Zac is killed. The Cylons also destroy all the other 11 battlestars, including the Atlantia, which kills President Adar, as well as virtually all the colonized planets and their inhabitants. The federation organizes a Dunkirk-style evacuation of as many survivors as they can find and fit in on a ragtag batch of leftover freighters that made it through the Cylon attack. The rest of the show is a pretty dreary succession of battles and near-misses as the evacuees are understandably upset that they’re on spaceships without food or water. They call the fleet command and get only evasive answers that what’s left of the federation’s leadership is aware of the situation. The Galactica and the freighters make it past the Nova of Madagon, their only route to safety, by sending advance fighters out to detonate all the mines the Cylons have planted there.

Ultimately they land on a planet called Carillon, where there’s plenty of food and drink. There’s also a major casino whose players seemingly never lose, and a deposit of tylium, the fuel needed for the federation’s spaceships. Previously the federation had set up a tylium mining operation, but Count Baltar (John Colicos, an actor who’d worked with Igor Stravinsky; in 1962 in Canada he and Stravinsky had recorded the five-minute mini-cantata “Babel,” which Stravinsky had written for the multi-composer piece Genesis Suite in 1945), a traitor in league with the Cylons, had falsely reported that the mine didn’t contain enough tylium to be economically viable. Starbuck gets distracted by one of the evacuees, Cassiopeia (Laurette Spang), a “socialator” (a legal but not socially accepted prostitute), only their attempt at a tryst is caught by his girlfriend Athena, who fills the cabin they’re in with steam so he's badly burned when he makes the all-important trip to disarm the Cylon mines. There’s also a single woman and her son, an obnoxiously cute kid named Boxey (Noah Hathaway), whose dog was killed in the Cylon attack on their planet, though the federation scientists make him a robot replica (essentially Battlestar Galactica’s equivalent to R2-D2 on Star Wars) with which he falls in love. Eventually, and not surprisingly, the planet Carillon turns out to be yet another trap; its inhabitants, the Ovions, are in league with the Cylons and have set up that casino where nobody ever loses to lure the surviving humans to the planet so they can be either destroyed or turned into slave laborers to mine tylium for the Cylon war fleet. There’s also a three-being vocal group called the Tucanas, who look like normal Black women with sky-high Afros except that their facial organs are doubled: four eyes, two noses, and two mouths. Starbuck sees them perform in the film’s equivalent of the Star Wars cantina and immediately wants to sign them up and make money off them (though how he can do this in an era in which almost the entire human race has been destroyed, along with almost all of its infrastructure, is beyond me).

There’s also another traitor, Council of Twelve member Sire Uri (Ray Milland), who cuts a deal with the Cylons by which they will voluntarily disarm and prove to the Cylons that the human race (or what’s left of it) means them no harm by destroying the Galactica and all its weapons. The treaty is supposed to be announced at a ceremony in which Apollo and Starbuck are going to be given the highest human award. Once again most of the humans fall for it but Adama sees it as a trap; he realizes that the Cylons mean to get all the human warriors together so they can destroy them in one fell swoop. So he and his second-in-command, Col. Tigh (Terry Carter) concoct a plan to dress as many of the battlestar’s support staff as possible in battle uniforms to fool the Cylons into eliminating the wrong people. Starbuck catches on when he sees people he recognizes in uniforms they don’t normally wear. Ultimately the good guys win when they target a Cylon base star and send it crashing into Carillon, where it sets off a tylium explosion that literally blows up the planet. Then the fleet sets off on its long-delayed search for the legendary planet Earth, the only place in the universe where they can hope to be safe. Battlestar Galactica, seen at this remove, is alternately frustrating and campy. 20th Century-Fox, the production company that made Star Wars, sued Universal for plagiarism, noting 34 points of similarity between Star Wars and Battlestar Galactica, though when Charles read that on the Battlestar Galactica Wikipedia page he thought it was rich of anyone connected with Star Wars to sue anyone else for plagiarism when Star Wars creator George Lucas himself ripped off so much of Star Wars from previous stories. Universal countersued and claimed that Lucas had ripped off the Buck Rogers serials from the 1940’s and their 1972 film Silent Running, directed by Douglas Trumbull, who’d worked on the famous psychedelic ending of 2001: A Space Odyssey and the light show at the end of Steven Spielberg’s Close Encounters of the Third Kind.

Lucas also sued John Dykstra, who’d built the spaceship models for both 2001: A Space Odyssey and Star Wars, for having left his company, Industrial Light and Magic, to work on Battlestar Galactica. (Dykstra was acknowledged with a producer credit on the show, and when the National Lampoon parodied Battlestar Galactica they called it Battlestar Dykstra.) Charles and I were watching “Saga of a Star World” on a DVD (not Blu-Ray) from Universal, part of a multi-disc box containing the full initial run of the show (24 episodes from September 17, 1978 to April 29, 1979). It presented the show in the original 4:3 TV aspect ratio (not the cropped 16:9 widescreen version that was briefly released as a theatrical movie), and it was a lousy transfer. Some scenes looked relatively clear but others were intensely grainy, and it also didn’t help that the soundtrack was mono (Battlestar Galactica was made at the dawn of the stereo TV era) and that Stu Phillips’s score was muddy and mixed far too softly. Phillips’s score, the main reason I was watching this (I had received a five-volume, eight-CD boxed set of the music from Intrada Records via Fanfare for review purposes), was about what you’d expect. In a project that from the get-go was intended as a knock-off of Star Wars, Phillips knew that he’d have to go after John Williams’s sound as much as possible. He responded with lots of loud brass fanfares accompanied by strings and plenty of pounding percussion, though occasionally the scripts offered him opportunities to write more quietly and lyrically. Battlestar Galactica was a flop on its initial TV run and ABC canceled it after just seven months on the air, largely because it cost so much to produce (Universal spent $8 million on the pilot alone), but it developed a cult following and Universal revived it for a new series that ran from 2004 to 2009 and produced 74 episodes, considerably more than the 24 of the original show.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Breakdown (Pegasus Productions, Realart Pictures, 1952)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Saturday, November 7) my husband Charles and I watched an unusual film on Turner Classic Movies: Breakdown, a 1952 boxing melodrama directed by Edmond Angelo (whose only film this was) and written by Robert Abel based on a play of his called The Samson Slasher. (That title had me dreading that there’d be a plot complication along the lines of the 1940 James Cagney vehicle City for Conquest, in which he played a prizefighter billed as “Young Samson.” His enemies are gangsters who spike his eye medicine with poison, thereby blinding him like the Biblical Samson. Fortunately, Abel didn’t go there.) This came at the end of an odd run of movies including two co-hosted by Ben Mankiewicz and Diane Warren, who probably did more than any other single person to rehabilitate professional songwriting as a career path. The irony is that one of the films she was co-hosting was A Hard Day’s Night, whose stars, The Beatles (John Lennon and Paul McCartney in particular), had been instrumental (pardon the pun) in destroying non-performing songwriting as a musical career because not only did they rely on their own material, their manager, Brian Epstein, promoted that about them. (The other film Mankiewicz and Warren co-hosted was Born Free, an O.K. movie with a quite memorable theme song by John Barry and Don Black that won the Academy Award and became a huge hit.) Between A Hard Day’s Night and Breakdown TCM showed a 20-minute short in the MGM series Crime Does Not Pay: The Public Pays (1942), about an attempt by gangsters to set up an extortion racket targeting dairies in the fictional “Claiborne City.” Directed by Errol Taggart and written by John C. Higgins, The Public Pays was a pretty straightforward little film (some of the Crime Does Not Pay shorts had intimations of film noir about them, but this one didn’t) whose main distinction was casting Cy Kendall, usually an oily villain, as the hero: John Carney, the Claiborne City police chief who partners with Paige Creamery CEO Charles Paige (Ivan Miller) to bust the extortionists by infiltrating his officers into Paige’s workforce and having them pose as milkmen. (In an earlier Crime Does Not Pay short, 1941’s Coffins on Wheels, he’d played a cynical used-car dealer who sells unsafe cars to teenagers.)

The 1952 Breakdown is a truly unusual movie, at once boxing drama, gangster movie, romantic melodrama, and film noir. Terry Williams (William Bishop) is a promising young boxer who runs afoul of the big-city political machine when he intervenes to stop them from roughing up a public speaker who’s trying to oppose them. In the course of the melee one of the machine’s enforcers gets killed accidentally, and Williams is convicted of manslaughter and sent to prison for 10 years. The judge in the case, Sam Hannum (John Vosper), has been bribed by the political machine to ensure Williams’s conviction by the promise of a major political career, including the state governorship. Meanwhile, machine gangster Nick Sampson (Sheldon Leonard) and his brother Pete (Wally Cassell) are looking for a potential championship contender, and they find him in Williams when they watch Williams and a sparring partner fight in a ring set up in the prison’s exercise yard. (Fortunately we get a lot of yummy shots of William Bishop in his boxing togs, with plenty of chest hair. For years Hollywood had forbidden men to have chest hair; if they had to go topless and they weren’t chest-hairless au naturel, they had to shave it.) Love, or at least sex, enters the story in the person of June Hannum (Ann Richards, who’d got a big star buildup at MGM but abruptly quit the business to marry director Angelo; she hadn’t made a film in four years and this would be her last). She’s not only the niece of Judge Hannum, she’s also Nick Sampson’s girlfriend, though she’s only reluctantly with him and she quickly gets the hots for Williams. Terry Williams works his way up as a boxer through a series of fights, in each of which he wins by a knockout in the first round. Unlike the heavyweight contender in Mark Robson’s The Harder They Fall (1956), an inept boxer who’s carefully built up through a series of fixed fights, Williams is genuinely talented in the ring. Though writer Abel doesn’t come right out and say Williams’s opponents are being paid to take dives – he has one of the characters say that his adversaries have been carefully selected – the monotonous similarity of the outcomes certainly leaves that impression.

At least two characters in the film, Harry “Punchy” Adams (Richard Benedict) and “Longshot” Maginnis (Joe McTurk), serve as warnings of the long-term consequences of a prizefighting career. They both work as ill-defined assistants in Pete Sampson’s gym, and “Punchy”’s ex-girlfriend Candy Allen (Anne Gwynne) is so angry at the sport she pleads with Terry to give it up while both his looks and his brains remain intact. (He’s so far gone he literally has no idea who she is when they see each other at the gym.) In fact, before one bout Terry is told to look carefully at the face of his opponent to determine how much experience that man has had by the number of scars he’s carrying from previous bouts. If nothing else, Breakdown is a particularly vivid film in terms of dramatizing the toll boxing takes as a career on its practitioners; in some ways it anticipates The Raging Bull (1980) in this regard. Even previous films like The Set-Up and Champion (both 1949) didn’t go as far as this one. The movie reaches its climax when June Hannum puts pressure on Terry to agree to a championship fight against reigning titleholder Joe Thompson (Hal Baylor) to benefit the Milk Fund charity (“Milk Fund” was an all-purpose nonprofit for which to raise money in classic-era movies). Pete Sampson insists that Terry isn’t ready for a championship fight and won’t be for another year or so, but the other characters pull rank on him and convince him to do it. Once the bout actually begins, Pete Sampson turns out to be right; Terry is totally outclassed and is beaten so badly by the champ one wonders why the referees don’t stop the fight. I’m guessing the reason is that for his anti-boxing message Robert Abel needed Terry not only to lose but to be beaten so badly he needs hospitalization by the time it’s all over, and he’s literally carried out of the arena on a stretcher. Director Angelo gives us plenty of close-ups of Terry’s previously pristine face as it’s been hammered into near-oblivion by Thompson’s blows, though at least June (ya remember June?) stays with him at the end and is presumably going to remain a part of his life, no matter what he does with the rest of it.

Breakdown is a quite accomplished movie even though it had a rock-bottom production budget and an 11-day shooting schedule. It was filmed at Republic studios even though it wasn’t a Republic release (it was produced by a collapsible outfit called Pegasus Productions and released through Realart, which was usually a reissue label for Universal but also released a few originals like this), though the special-effects credit to “Consolidated Film Laboratories, Inc.” is a giveaway. Consolidated Film Laboratories was Republic’s parent company; Republic was founded in 1935 by Consolidated’s owner, Herbert J. Yates, who offered to forgive the debts Mascot and Monogram had run up to him for processing their film if he could take control of their companies. Yates paid off both Nat Levine of Mascot and W. Ray Johnston of Monogram. Johnston banked his money and, after a falling-out with Yates, re-started Monogram in 1937; Levine blew his on bad horse-racing bets and had a catch-as-catch-can existence until his death in 1989 at age 90. As for Edmond Angelo, after Breakdown (and after a lawsuit against Realart because he claimed they had sold the film to TV too soon after its theatrical run), he left the movie business (as well as the theatre, where he’d produced plays before his brief foray into filmmaking) to become, of all things, a rocket scientist for a California aerospace firm. Richards pursued a career as a writer and poet but mostly just stayed out of the public eye and stayed married to Angelo until his death in 1983 (she died in 2006).

Saturday, November 7, 2026

The Enchanted Cottage (RKO, 1945)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Friday, November 6) my husband Charles and I watched an alternately intriguing and frustrating film from RKO in 1945 called The Enchanted Cottage, based on a play by British dramatist Sir Arthur Wing Pinero, who premiered it in 1920 and called it “a fable in three acts.” It was first filmed in 1924 by First National with Richard Barthelmess as star and John S. Robertson (best known today for the 1920 John Barrymore silent version of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde) as director. Not surprisingly, the original play took place in Sussex, England in 1919 in the aftermath of World War I (or “The Great War,” as it was usually called before there was a World War II). In 1945 RKO remade it with John Cromwell as director and Robert Young and Dorothy McGuire as stars. They were coming off the success of a 1943 film called Claudia, about the trials and tribulations of a young newlywed couple adjusting to married life, which McGuire (though not Young) had previously done on stage as a play. RKO’s producer, Harriet Parsons (who nearly lost the assignment to Dudley Nichols and had to fight the studio brass to stay on the film), and her writers, DeWitt Bodeen and Herman J. Mankiewicz (who came on for a last-minute rewrite just before the shooting started), moved the story to the U.S., to New England, and set it in an otherwise destroyed or ruined mansion of which only a cottage survived. The property’s former owner had made it a practice to rent the cottage to newlywed couples on their honeymoons, allowing them to stay as long as they liked, but the current owner, Abigail Minnett (Mildred Natwick in quite a good performance), has ended the practice. Previous couples have etched their names and dates when they lived there onto the cottage’s windows. The latest tenants are Oliver Bradford (Robert Young) and his fiancée Beatrice Alexander (Hillary Brooke, who frankly is too strong a personality for the nothing role she’s playing here; I liked her a lot better as the black-hearted villainess and partner of Professor Moriarty in the Sherlock Holmes film The Woman in Green, made the same year with Basil Rathbone as Holmes, Nigel Bruce as Watson, and Henry Daniell as Moriarty). When Oliver borrows the engagement ring he’s given Beatrice and tries to use it to etch their names on the window, the stone falls out and Mrs. Minnett tells them they’re not supposed to do that yet since they haven’t actually married.

The date is December 7, 1941, and when the Pearl Harbor attack happens that very day Oliver becomes a pilot with the U.S. Army Air Corps (it wasn’t until 1955 that the U.S. Air Force became a separate service branch of its own). Mrs. Minnett is herself a war widow; her husband was killed in the Great War and she’s kept her desk calendar set to April 6, 1917, the date the U.S. formally entered World War I. The whole story is framed as a flashback narrated by Major John Hillgrove (Herbert Marshall), who was blinded while serving in the Great War and took up piano playing and musical composition as part of his recovery process. I couldn’t help but note that Marshall is playing a man who became disabled as a result of World War I when the war had disabled him in real life as well, though instead of going blind he’d lost his left leg in the Second Battle of Arras, France. (To add to the irony, Marshall’s war injury occurred on April 9, 1917, just three days after the date on Mrs. Minnett’s calendar.) Oliver returns to the cottage a year later with his face badly scarred by an accident from when his plane was shot down in combat in the Pacific theatre. There he takes up with Laura Pennington (Dorothy McGuire), a homely woman whom Mrs. Minnett had hired years before as a maid. The two not-quite-attractive people are gradually drawn together and ultimately fall in love and get married, despite each of them having anxieties that the other has married them only out of pity. Hillgrove regularly visits the cottage with his nephew, Danny “Taxi” Stanton (Alec Englander), leading him. As he would the next year in the ponderous Tyrone Power vehicle The Razor’s Edge, Marshall as Hillgrove is the voice of sanity in this rather mixed set of emotions and frequently prattles on about spirituality and the life beyond this one. Laura and Oliver announce that they’ve gone through a physical transformation that’s made them both beautiful, or at least conventionally attractive – only the sudden appearance of Oliver’s mother, Violet Price (Spring Byington), and stepfather Frederick Price (Richard Gaines), breaks the illusion and their images in the movie revert to the ones we’ve been seeing all movie.

Hillgrove narrates all this in flashback during a party which he’s giving in Oliver’s and Laura’s honor and at which he’s going to play a piano reduction of the new tone poem, “The Enchanted Cottage,” which he’s written in their honor. Unfortunately they’re late coming to their own party and Hillgrove has to fill in for them by narrating their story and playing the piece (with Max Rabinowitz as his piano double). Ultimately Oliver and Laura etch their names on the window of the cottage and then show up at Hillgrove’s party declaring their undying love for each other. I looked up the Wikipedia page on Pinero’s play and learned not only that the original was set in England (as I had guessed from the fact that no one drinks coffee in the film; all the characters’ hot drink of choice is tea) but it had a much greater supernatural element. In the original play we never get to see Oliver (whose last name is the clunkier “Bashforth”) before he’s disabled, and his injuries are quite a bit more severe. According to Wikipedia, “In the stage directions, Oliver is described as an emaciated wreck of a man, broken by the war. The dialogue reveals that he was wounded in the neck and that it is painful to straighten his left leg, but he says his ‘head,’ meaning his mind, is the worst. In the 1924 film, his body is contorted, he walks with a cane, and he cannot put his right foot to the ground. In the 1945 film, most of Oliver’s face is scarred, and he has completely lost the use of his right arm and hand. He can walk without aids and there is no visible impairment of his lower body.” (I must say I didn’t notice that his right arm was disabled.) Also in the play Mrs. Minnett is actually a witch, albeit a beneficent one (one would think that just six years after MGM filmed The Wizard of Oz a “good witch” wouldn’t have been an unfamiliar concept to an American movie audience), and there’s a long dream sequence for Laura in the second act in which she dreams that both she and Oliver are good-looking people.

In the dream they’re attended by Mrs. Minnett and at least one other witch, along with three other married couples, three bridesmaids, and assorted cherubs, imps, and children. (In 1920 audiences for the original play had had a problem reconciling the supernatural plot elements with Pinero’s previous reputation as a rom-com writer, just as James M. Barrie is thought of today mainly as the author of Peter Pan even though most of his works were rom-coms, too.) Alas, in this film writers Bodeen (who’d done a much better job balancing realistic and supernatural elements in his script for the Val Lewton/Jacques Tourneur Cat People three years earlier) and Mankiewicz can’t get the supernatural plot elements to work at all. When we first see Robert Young and Dorothy McGuire in full Hollywood makeup and Herbert Marshall’s character proclaims it a “miracle,” all we can think is, “God must be a really good plastic surgeon.” The Enchanted Cottage is one film from Hollywood’s classic era I’d never seen before, and I’m not sure what to make of it now. Charles said he thought he might like it better on later reflection than he did when we were actually watching it. Curiously, there was an attempt to remake The Enchanted Cottage in 1973 and the would-be producers wanted Robert Young and Dorothy McGuire to be in it, Young in Marshall’s role and McGuire in Natwick’s. Young, who was on record as saying this was the best film he ever made, was eager to do it, but McGuire watched the earlier film and said, essentially, “You can’t go home again.” The Enchanted Cottage wasn’t remade until 2016, with Richard Hatch (not the same one who won the first season of Survivor; this Hatch said, “We forget there are other people with our name, and somehow we feel an ownership with our name. Honestly, this is one of the strangest experiences that's ever happened in my life, and I'm having to deal with it”) and Sarah Navratil in the leads and three credited directors (Joshua Arcadi, Ryan Del Nero, and Andrew Fisher), not a good sign.

Friday, November 6, 2026

Law and Order: Special Victims Unit: "Forsaken" (Dick Wolf Entertainment, Universal Television, NBC-TV, aired November 5, 2026)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Thursday, November 5) I put on NBC for the latest two episodes of Law and Order and Law and Order: Special Victims Unit. They’re showing them in reverse order these days, with SVU first, to make room for that abominable “reality” show The Traitors they’ve scheduled for 8 p.m. The SVU episode was called “Forsaken” and opened at a much-publicized wedding of a major male comedian who’d been living with the same woman for years but had finally got around to tying the knot legally. At first I assumed that the comedian would be the principal perpetrator and it would be a story about how he raped a woman to get his rocks off one last time before he got hitched, but writer Justine Ferrara took her plot in a quite different direction. The victim is Chloe Davis (Lauren Cole, turning in an impressive performance), who’s found lying unconscious in a pool of her own blood at the wedding party. The investigating police detectives, including Captain Olivia Benson (Mariska Hargitay) and Detective Amanda Rollins (Kelli Giddish), have to deal with Chloe’s overbearing mother Monica (Jessalyn Gilsig) and even more overbearing stepfather Rick (Bill Heck). Chloe gives a description of her assailant as a young man in his 20’s, tall, white, and with red hair. As things turn out, a man matching that description, Scott Germon (Harrison Ball), was actually at the event and is arrested for the crime, but he turns out to be innocent. We don’t feel too badly for him, mainly because he was at the wedding party to sell cocaine to one of the other guests and there was already a bench warrant outstanding on him for violating his probation on a previous offense.

It turns out that the Davises are a monumentally dysfunctional family even by SVU standards: they consist of Rick, Monica, Chloe, her stepbrother Tyler (Sam Cusson), and her seven-year-old half-brother Evan (Emmett Moss). Evan is the only direct offspring of both Rick and Monica; Chloe is Monica’s daughter by her previous partner (who’s in prison for a long stretch of his own) and Tyler is Rick’s son by his earlier wife. So Tyler and Chloe have one of those weird sort of relationships that is psychologically incestuous even though it isn’t literally (sort of like Victor Frankenstein and Elizabeth Lavenza in Mary Shelley’s original Frankenstein, who grew up together as virtual brother and sister even though they were not biologically related). What’s more, Tyler is literally a psychopath and Rick has been actively covering for him, intimidating the rest of the family into endorsing his evil. It turns out that Tyler was Chloe’s assailant, and he attacked her for revenge after another woman whom he was cruising at the wedding party turned him down. Prosecutor Dominic Carisi, Jr. (Peter Scanavino) has the problem of convincing the trial jury of this, particularly since Rick Davis was a quite persuasive witness for Tyler’s defense. Monica offers to break spousal privilege and testify for the prosecution about what’s really been going on in their household, but Carisi decides that she’s changed her story so often that she won’t be credible to the jury.

Instead he calls seven-year-old Evan, and after the usual rigmarole involving a child witness as to whether or not they will be “swearable” – whether they understand the difference between the truth and a lie well enough to comprehend the oath – Evan testifies. While his son is on the witness stand Rick stalks out of the courtroom, and that’s where Dick Wolf and Justine Ferrara end it. We don’t see the jury return a verdict either way, and we are left with a sense of dread as to just what’s going to happen to the other Davises after Evan broke Rick’s omertà about Tyler’s psychopathology. I’m guessing they’re setting us up for a sequel. The most remarkable aspect about this episode is Sam Cusson’s chilling performance as Tyler. He’s of medium height and has an angelic face reminiscent of the young David Cassidy (he’s close enough he’d be good casting for a biopic, especially if he could sing), and he projects just the right sort of affect (or lack thereof) I’ve seen in TV documentaries about real psychos. Incidentally this was the 599th episode of SVU, and afterwards they announced that Christopher Meloni is going to return for the 600th episode next week. That will be a treat, even though he’s become too old and grizzled to do much for me the way he did when he was on SVU for its first 12 seasons and I literally lusted after him (as, I suspect, did much of Gay male America; when he was on the show I used to joke that SVU had two different fan bases: Gay men who thought Christopher Meloni was hot and straight men who thought Mariska Hargitay was hot).