by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2019 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The “feature” Charles and I watched last night was Convict’s
Code, a title that seems to be an attempt
to rip off the name of Columbia’s dark classic The Criminal Code from 1931, a great prison movie directed by Howard
Hawks from a play by Martin Flavin and featuring Boris Karloff in a magnificent
performance as a convict who murders one of his fellow prisoners for
“squealing.” The Criminal Code as
a title is a marvelous pun referring both to the laws under which the prisoners
have been convicted — at one point Walter Huston, a former prosecutor who quit
to run for governor, lost and got appointed warden as a sort of consolation
prize, thumps a pile of lawbooks and thunders in his best “Lincoln” voice, “I
go by the criminal code!” — and the code of
behavior of the convicts themselves, the criminals’ code by which ratting out
another prisoner is a crime punishable by death. Unfortunately, that’s not the
movie we’re dealing with here: the 1939 Convict’s Code is by Monogram (second iteration) and may or may not
be a remake of a now-lost film from Trem Carr Productions in 1930 called Convict’s
Code (the connection is that by 1939 Carr
was a producer at Monogram and he might have brought the story with him, though
the credits for the 1939 Convict’s Code don’t reference the writers of the 1930 version and credit John W.
Krafft with an “original” story and screenplay — when I saw that credit I
thought, “There probably deserve to be quotation marks around that word
‘original’,” and I was right). Convict’s Code begins with a newspaper headline reminiscing about
the former exploits of college football star “Whizz” Tyler (Robert Kent) and
telling us that he’s just about to be paroled after having served three years
in prison for driving the getaway car at an armed robbery he says he didn’t
commit. He’s released under his real name, Dave Tyler, and given an elaborate
set of restrictions — he’s not supposed to move or change jobs without the
approval of his parole officer, C. W. Bennett (the dog-faced actor Victor
Kilian); he’s not supposed to drink alcohol, be friends with criminals, or own
a gun; and he also can’t marry without Bennett’s approval. He’s also obliged to
let Bennett inspect his residence any time Bennett likes (the signing away of
Fourth Amendment rights is a frequent condition of parole or probation even
today) and to sign a card certifying he’s a parolee, ostensibly to know any law
enforcement official who tries to arrest him as a fugitive from justice that he
was released legitimately and did not escape.
Tyler asserts to everyone in
earshot, including the prison warden, that he didn’t actually commit the crime
even though six witnesses testified at his trial that they saw him drive the
getaway car, and once he’s out he gets a room in a rooming house surprisingly
easily (the landlady is played by the great Maude Eburne — though she lost the
final “e” of her first name in Monogram’s credits — who previously had
experience in a prison movie in 1933’s Ladies They Talk About as an inmate herself, a madam who concealed her
bordello under the guise of a manicure shop and got busted by a cop who
accidentally brought his wife in for a manicure!) and gets a job even more
easily! Dave’s friend Jeff Palmer (Ben Alexander, who was Jack Webb’s regular
partner on the original 1950’s TV series Dragnet — on which Robert Kent also played a cop!), the
reporter who wrote the story about him that appeared in his paper and broke
Tyler’s case open, leading to his parole, helps him get re-established and says
that several employers have offered him jobs. Tyler takes the one working in an
investment company owned by Gregory Warren (Sidney Blackmer), whom we’re soon told (as if we couldn’t have guessed, given
who’s playing him!) was the person who actually framed Tyler for the crime and
got him sent to prison in the first place. Warren starts assigning Tyler to
drive his sister Julie (Anne Nagel, on loan from Universal and turning in by
far the best performance in the film) around on various errands, and proximity
works its magic and the two start falling in love. Naturally she has no idea
either that her current boyfriend is a parolee or her brother is the crook who
framed him, and Dave is worried that she’ll break off with him if she finds out
about his ex-con status.
Dave ends up in a low-class bar (the sort of hangout
he’s not supposed to be at) drinking alcohol with a crook he knew in prison
named Sniffy Johnson (Pat Flaherty) — we never learn his real first name; maybe
it was something like Ethelbert — who claims he knows who framed Dave but won’t
tell him unless Dave joins him in a robbery of a fur warehouse he has planned.
Instead of doing what any even remotely sensible person in this situation would
do — go to the police and offer to go undercover with Sniffy and pretend to be
part of the robbery so Sniffy can be arrested — Dave joins the robbery but then
sabotages it, turning the burglar alarm at the warehouse on himself and holding
a gun on Sniffy to get Sniffy to tell him who framed him. Sniffy does so but is
later shot dead by the building’s watchman (at least I think that’s what happened: we see him flee and then we
see the watchman pull out his own gun and fire two bullets at him), and Warren
orders his henchman Joe Russell (Norman Willis) to kill Dave before he can
spill the secret to the police — only in the meantime parole officer Bennett
has done one of his snap searches of Dave’s room and found a gun under the mattress
(why did he have one when he knew that owning a firearm was one of the bozo
no-nos that would send him back to prison?). When Dave returns to his room
Bennett arrests him and the next time we see him he’s back in prison, in prison
clothes, facing the six more years of his original sentence — only he gets out
because in the meantime Warren and Joe Russell have had a falling-out, they’ve
fatally wounded each other, and just before he died Warren told all and
confessed his involvement in the original crime to protect his sister and
enable her and her boyfriend to be happy together “outside.” Julie shows up at
the prison with a signed statement from her brother and a pardon from the
governor, and she and Dave lip-lock at the fadeout.
There are a couple of at
least unusual, if not truly “original,” elements in this crime drama — Warren’s
offer of a job to the parolee he framed in the first place and his
’tis-a-far-far-better-thing-I-do willingness to exonerate Dave on his deathbed
— but for the most part Convict’s Code is a pretty ordinary crime melodrama for the period. I had hopes for
it mainly because of the director, Lambert Hillyer, an underrated silent-era
veteran who made the last two horror films produced by Universal while the
Laemmle family still owned the studio, The Invisible Ray and Dracula’s Daughter (both 1936) and who made one of the greatest
superhero serials ever, the first Batman (1943), distinguished not only by Hillyer’s atmospheric direction but
by Lewis Wilson, the first actor ever to play Batman and to my mind the best.
Unfortunately, Hillyer’s usual acumen for getting a lot out of a low budget
wasn’t on display here; Convict’s Code is as uncreatively directed as it is written and very little of the
film has any visual atmosphere at all. The main problem with Convict’s
Code is the hero’s sheer naïveté: it’s hard
for us to work up much sympathy for someone who’s stupid enough to think that
the way to exonerate himself out of a false charge for a previous crime is to
get in bed (figuratively and almost
literally, since after a night out on the town with Sniffy he passes out and
wakes up in Sniffy’s bed) with a known criminal and commit a new one. One gets
the impression that the actor this film really needed, James Cagney (way too big a star for this sort of thing in 1939),
would have made Dave Tyler seem streetwise instead of stupid — the real Cagney
made a film in which he was framed and unjustly imprisoned in 1939, with the
marvelous title Each Dawn I Die,
and though not generally considered one of his best it’s a damned sight better
than Convict’s Code.
Saturday, February 9, 2019
Thursday, February 7, 2019
The Dictator’s Playbook: Francisco Franco (Crown Productions, Twin Cities Public Television, PBS, 2019)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2019 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
I watched the next episode of The Dictator’s Playbook, one I was particularly interested because the “dictator of the week” (as Charles inevitably joked) was Francisco Franco, the Generalísimo who ruled Spain with an iron hand from 1939, when his Nationalist forces won the Spanish Civil War, to 1975, when he died. Of the six dictators profiled on The Dictator’s Playbook — Mussolini, Franco, Kim Il Sung, Manuel Noriega, Saddam Hussein and Idi Amin — Franco and Kim Il Sung were the only ones who held power uninterruptedly until their deaths, and Franco lingered so long on his deathbed that the original cast of Saturday Night Live did screamingly funny mock newscasts announcing that “Generalissimo Francisco Franco is carrying on his valiant struggle to remain dead.” The Franco episode of The Dictator’s Playbook was fascinating in two aspects: first, it showcased his unusual background — he served most of his pre-power military stint in Spain’s remaining colonies, mostly Morocco — and second, it was a necessary corrective to the later image (shaped by Cold War Western propaganda that regarded Franco’s Spain as an important bulwark against Communism in Western Europe) of Franco as a “soft” dictator, repressive but not particularly bloodthirsty. The first point first: Franco was the third son of a father who was a sixth-generation officer in the Spanish navy, and Franco’s ambition growing up was to be in the navy, too — until, when Franco was six, Spain got its ass kicked by the U.S. in the Spanish-American War of 1898-1900. The Spanish navy shrank to insignificance and the last vestiges of Spain’s imperial domains outside of North Africa and the Canary Islands — Cuba, Puerto Rico and the Philippines — passed to American dominance. Because Spain virtually had no navy left, Franco joined the army — and got posted to Morocco largely because it would be quicker and easier to be promoted there. When the Moroccans mounted a rebellion in 1912, Franco was key to the repression; leading a force called the “Army of Africa” —who were actually native Moroccans fighting, like the Gurkhas in India, for the imperialist power against their countrymen — he ordered mass murders of any Moroccans who were associated, however tenuously, with the rebellion. His idea was to kill enough potential dissenters as to frighten the rest of the population into silence and acquiescence.
Franco’s rise to power began in 1931, when grass-roots protests against the Spanish monarchy in general and the reigning monarch, Alfonso XIII, in particular, led to the king’s abdication and Spain becoming a republic. Left-wing candidates won Spain’s first free elections in 1931 and Franco was exiled to a command post on the Canary Islands — the new government having concluded that the way to neutralize the potential of a Right-wing coup was to exile the officers as far away from Spain as possible. Spain’s politics continued to be volatile as the Leftists lost power to a Right-wing coalition in the 1933 elections, only to regain it in 1936 after the various Left-wing parties came together to form an alliance called the Popular Front. By this time Franco was back in Morocco and he became part of a coalition of Right-wing officers anxious to get back to Spain, overthrow the republican government and take over — but they still had the problem of moving their forces from Morocco across the Straits of Gibraltar to Spain itself. Franco solved that problem by calling Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini and enlisting their support in his Right-wing coup; Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy provided the planes Franco used to fly his forces over the Straits of Gibraltar and land them in Spain. Once on the ground, Franco used the same wide-open terror tactics he’d pioneered in Morocco, including mass executions not only of regime opponents but also their families and anyone who might someday be a threat. He also protected the Roman Catholic Church against attacks by anarchists who regarded the church (rightly) as a key element in Spain’s repressive Right-wing culture and targeted it, looting the churches and killing priests.
What Franco thought would be an easy victory turned into a three-year civil war when the Soviet Union came to the aid of the republican government (or at least the Communist elements in it — the Popular Front was an unstable coalition of Communists, anarchists and something called the POUM, independent Leftists whom the Communists denounced as Trotskyists), only to withdraw their support in February 1939 and allow Franco and his forces to take the final redoubt of the republican government, Madrid. Most of the show dealt with the civil war and it only touched on Franco’s rule after that, though it did mention how thoroughly he took over all the instruments of communication, including the educational system as well as the media, in an attempt to make sure that not only Leftists themselves but Left-wing ideals were stamped out of Spain forever. In that he failed; unlike a surprising number of dictators, Franco actually arranged an exit strategy aimed at preserving his regime after he died — only his strategy, which was to restore the monarchy in the person of young Prince Juan Carlos, backfired: once in power Juan Carlos decided to restore democracy and turn Spain into a British-style constitutional monarchy governed by a popularly elected legislature. The Dictator’s Playbook episode on Franco was quite good even though they only touched on Spain’s neutrality during World War II — Franco wisely kept Spain out of the conflict so he could continue in power no matter which side won, and Joseph Goebbels’ diaries are full of imprecations against Franco that he wasn’t joining the Axis “after all we did for him!”
I watched the next episode of The Dictator’s Playbook, one I was particularly interested because the “dictator of the week” (as Charles inevitably joked) was Francisco Franco, the Generalísimo who ruled Spain with an iron hand from 1939, when his Nationalist forces won the Spanish Civil War, to 1975, when he died. Of the six dictators profiled on The Dictator’s Playbook — Mussolini, Franco, Kim Il Sung, Manuel Noriega, Saddam Hussein and Idi Amin — Franco and Kim Il Sung were the only ones who held power uninterruptedly until their deaths, and Franco lingered so long on his deathbed that the original cast of Saturday Night Live did screamingly funny mock newscasts announcing that “Generalissimo Francisco Franco is carrying on his valiant struggle to remain dead.” The Franco episode of The Dictator’s Playbook was fascinating in two aspects: first, it showcased his unusual background — he served most of his pre-power military stint in Spain’s remaining colonies, mostly Morocco — and second, it was a necessary corrective to the later image (shaped by Cold War Western propaganda that regarded Franco’s Spain as an important bulwark against Communism in Western Europe) of Franco as a “soft” dictator, repressive but not particularly bloodthirsty. The first point first: Franco was the third son of a father who was a sixth-generation officer in the Spanish navy, and Franco’s ambition growing up was to be in the navy, too — until, when Franco was six, Spain got its ass kicked by the U.S. in the Spanish-American War of 1898-1900. The Spanish navy shrank to insignificance and the last vestiges of Spain’s imperial domains outside of North Africa and the Canary Islands — Cuba, Puerto Rico and the Philippines — passed to American dominance. Because Spain virtually had no navy left, Franco joined the army — and got posted to Morocco largely because it would be quicker and easier to be promoted there. When the Moroccans mounted a rebellion in 1912, Franco was key to the repression; leading a force called the “Army of Africa” —who were actually native Moroccans fighting, like the Gurkhas in India, for the imperialist power against their countrymen — he ordered mass murders of any Moroccans who were associated, however tenuously, with the rebellion. His idea was to kill enough potential dissenters as to frighten the rest of the population into silence and acquiescence.
Franco’s rise to power began in 1931, when grass-roots protests against the Spanish monarchy in general and the reigning monarch, Alfonso XIII, in particular, led to the king’s abdication and Spain becoming a republic. Left-wing candidates won Spain’s first free elections in 1931 and Franco was exiled to a command post on the Canary Islands — the new government having concluded that the way to neutralize the potential of a Right-wing coup was to exile the officers as far away from Spain as possible. Spain’s politics continued to be volatile as the Leftists lost power to a Right-wing coalition in the 1933 elections, only to regain it in 1936 after the various Left-wing parties came together to form an alliance called the Popular Front. By this time Franco was back in Morocco and he became part of a coalition of Right-wing officers anxious to get back to Spain, overthrow the republican government and take over — but they still had the problem of moving their forces from Morocco across the Straits of Gibraltar to Spain itself. Franco solved that problem by calling Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini and enlisting their support in his Right-wing coup; Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy provided the planes Franco used to fly his forces over the Straits of Gibraltar and land them in Spain. Once on the ground, Franco used the same wide-open terror tactics he’d pioneered in Morocco, including mass executions not only of regime opponents but also their families and anyone who might someday be a threat. He also protected the Roman Catholic Church against attacks by anarchists who regarded the church (rightly) as a key element in Spain’s repressive Right-wing culture and targeted it, looting the churches and killing priests.
What Franco thought would be an easy victory turned into a three-year civil war when the Soviet Union came to the aid of the republican government (or at least the Communist elements in it — the Popular Front was an unstable coalition of Communists, anarchists and something called the POUM, independent Leftists whom the Communists denounced as Trotskyists), only to withdraw their support in February 1939 and allow Franco and his forces to take the final redoubt of the republican government, Madrid. Most of the show dealt with the civil war and it only touched on Franco’s rule after that, though it did mention how thoroughly he took over all the instruments of communication, including the educational system as well as the media, in an attempt to make sure that not only Leftists themselves but Left-wing ideals were stamped out of Spain forever. In that he failed; unlike a surprising number of dictators, Franco actually arranged an exit strategy aimed at preserving his regime after he died — only his strategy, which was to restore the monarchy in the person of young Prince Juan Carlos, backfired: once in power Juan Carlos decided to restore democracy and turn Spain into a British-style constitutional monarchy governed by a popularly elected legislature. The Dictator’s Playbook episode on Franco was quite good even though they only touched on Spain’s neutrality during World War II — Franco wisely kept Spain out of the conflict so he could continue in power no matter which side won, and Joseph Goebbels’ diaries are full of imprecations against Franco that he wasn’t joining the Axis “after all we did for him!”
Wednesday, February 6, 2019
Berlioz Concert: Les Siècles, François-Xavier Roth, conductor; January 11, 2019
by MARK GABRISH CONLAN
Copyright © 2019 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights
reserved
Two nights ago
my husband Charles and I watched something special on TV: a tribute concert to
Hector Berlioz broadcast from the Paris Philharmonie last January 11 with the
following program:
Benvenuto Cellini (Ouverture)
Beatrice et Bénédict (Ouverture)
Le Carnaval romain (Ouverture)
Roméo et Juliette: Roméo seul -
Grande fête chez les Capulets
Harold en Italie
Encore: La Damnation de Faust –
Hungarian March
Tabea Zimmermann, Alto
Les Siècles
Dir.: François-Xavier Roth
I had seen this
performance available on a download but found I couldn’t open the video file on
my computer, nor could I burn it to a DVD — but I could copy it onto a flash
drive and play it on the TV from that. Berlioz is one of my favorite composers,
partly due to his sheer Romanticism and also due to his quirkiness. He’s the
one French composer of the 19th century whose music stacks up at the
same level of quality of the Germans who then dominated classical symphonic
music, and when the band Art of Noise did their tribute album to Claude Debussy
in the late 1990’s and their narrator proclaimed Debussy France’s greatest composer,
I thought, “A good case could be made for him, but a good case could also be
made for Berlioz.” I’ve read Berlioz’ autobiography, in which among other
things he laments that he was cursed by being born in such an unmusical nation
as France and suggested that the Prix de Rome — an annual competition for French artists in various fields, started
under Louis XIV and continued until it ended as part of the overall
near-revolutionary ferment of 1968, in which the winner got a three-year trip
to Italy and a stipend to live on while there in return for sending back at
least one work per year (called an Énvoi) to prove that the French government wasn’t wasting its money sending
them there — was a good prize for visual artists who could benefit by seeing
the Renaissance masterpieces in their homeland, but for musicians the French
government would have been better off sending them to Germany. (Berlioz himself
won the Prix de Rome on his
fourth try when he realized he needed to “write down” to the level of the judges
and give them what they wanted.)
The Psychedelic Pioneer
Berlioz made his
reputation in 1830 with the Symphonie Fantastique, which I’ve called the first piece of psychedelic music because it had
two major things in common with the psychedelic rock of the 1960’s: it used
elaborate sonic effects (including now-obsolete instruments like the ophicleide
and the serpent — the latter, pronounced “ser-PENT,” was a big brass instrument
that sounded like a tuba but with a peculiarly buzzing quality that made me wonder,
when I heard Roger Norrington’s early-1990’s recording of the Symphonie
Fantastique, whether my stereo was grounded
correctly) and it was intended as a musical depiction of the act of taking
drugs. Berlioz himself wrote a program for the work indicating that it was a
“program symphony” — i.e., a piece that, though entirely instrumental, was
intended to tell a story — and the story was about a young artist who, under
the influence of opium, takes his girlfriend to a ball, then takes her to the
country, kills her, is hanged for the crime and ends up in hell. (The last
movement, “Dream of a Witches’ Sabbath,” was used in the 1991 film Sleeping
with the Enemy as the theme for the
physically abusive husband of Julia Roberts’ character.)
Shakespeare and Paganini
The program for
the January 11 concert included three Berlioz overtures — the ones to his first
and third (and last) operas, Benvenuto Cellini and Béatrice et Bénédict
(based on Shakespeare’s play Much Ado About Nothing), as well as a separate piece, Roman
Carnival — along with one of the six
movements of Berlioz’ symphony based on Romeo and Juliet (if you get the impression Berlioz was a big-time fan
of Shakespeare, you’re right: he wrote shorter pieces based on scenes from Hamlet and The Tempest and his first wife, Henrietta Smithson, was an actress from Scotland
he’d seen in a production of Hamlet
and fallen in love with on the spot even though he didn’t know a word of
English) and, as the post-intermission feature, Berlioz’ second symphony, Harold
in Italy.
This one came
about as the result of a commission from the best-known violinist of the 19th
century, Niccoló Paganini, whom I’ve described elsewhere as the Jimi Hendrix of
his time: he was a flamboyant showman (one of his tricks was to partially saw
through the strings before a performance so that, under the lash of his
ferocious playing, they’d break one by one until he’d be left fiddling on just
one string), he extended the technique of the violin far beyond anything any
previous player had imagined (much the way Hendrix did with the electric
guitar), he wrote a lot of his own music to showcase his technical and
showmanship skills, and like Hendrix he set the seal on his legend by dying
young.
Paganini had
just acquired a Stradivarius viola and wanted to get Berlioz to write him a
piece for viola and orchestra to showcase him playing it — why Paganini didn’t
write the piece himself is a mystery, since he composed quite a lot of music,
including six violin concerti and 24 caprices for unaccompanied violin, but
maybe he didn’t feel as assured writing for viola as he did for violin.
Berlioz’ first thought was to do a three-movement work on the life of Mary,
Queen of Scots, with the viola playing Mary, but as the work germinated in his
head the three movements became four and the story shifted from Mary, Queen of
Scots to Lord Byron’s star-making epic poem Childe Harold.
When Paganini
finally saw the work in score he rejected it because, instead of the viola
concerto he’d been expecting, it was a symphony that used the viola as an
obbligato instrument and incorporated it into the ensemble. Berlioz had to get
another violist to play it for the premiere, though Paganini liked it well
enough when he finally heard it that he paid Berlioz for it anyway — a large
chunk of money the chronically cash-poor Berlioz desperately needed. (Don’t be
fooled by the above credit to Tabea Zimmermann for “alto” into thinking it’s a
vocal work and she’s a low-voiced woman singer; “alto” is simply the French
word for “viola.”)
The concert on
January 11 was given by an orchestra called “Les Siècles,” which means “The
Centuries,” and that means they’re interested in using the instruments of the
period in which the pieces they play were composed — something that was most apparent
visually in the strangely shaped trumpets, the unvalved “natural” French horns,
the wooden flutes, and the convex bow used by one of the two featured bass
players (though the other bassist we saw — there were six in the orchestra, but
only two were visible in the telecast — was using the concave bow that is the
modern-day standard).
Fortunately, the
antique instruments didn’t alter the sound too much from what we’re used to in
these pieces, and the musicians were adept enough that they could play them
well — which was not always the case in the early days of “historically
informed performances” (I remember a Musical Heritage Society LP of Handel’s Music
for the Royal Fireworks which sounded
excruciatingly out of tune, though as I listened to that record more and more I
actually got to like it; not only were the players doing the best they could
with these oddball and difficult instruments, it probably was closer to what
Handel and his original audience heard than the slick big-orchestra versions
I’d heard before) — and I was able to enjoy the music as such and not think,
“Oh, they’re doing the best they can with these obsolete instruments.”
The two opera
overtures came first in the program, and then followed the Roman Carnival — which particularly impressed Charles because he
said he’d never seen a classical-music telecast in which the performers seemed
to be having that much fun. The
musicians were grinning from ear to ear as they played this joyous music, and
so was the conductor, François-Xavier Roth. (I hadn’t noticed it as much
because I’d been too busy grinning my way through it myself.)
Berlioz and Wagner
After that the
orchestra played one movement of one of Berlioz’ greatest works, his symphony
based on Romeo and Juliet, an oddly
structured piece in that it sandwiches a four-movement symphony in between a
prologue and epilogue with vocal soloists and chorus. The prologue gives a
basic outline of the story and pays homage to Shakespeare by name; then we get
four movements in classical symphonic form — a fast movement with a slow
opening representing “Romeo alone” and then his decision to crash the Capulets’
big ball, where he meets Juliet; a slow movement depicting their love scene; a
scherzo based on the Queen Mab speech in the play; and a long last movement
depicting the deaths of the lovers.
Then there’s an
epilogue which dramatizes in near-operatic style the final scene of the play,
in which Friar Laurence brings the Montagues and Capulets together at long last
following the tragic deaths of their kids. It’s an absolutely glorious work for
what it is, but it’s also frustrating in that one wishes if Berlioz were so
interested in the story of Romeo and Juliet,
why didn’t he just set it as an opera? (There’s one report that he was considering writing an opera on Romeo and
Juliet at the end of his life and he just
ran out of time to do so.)
I vividly
remember the first time I heard the Romeo and Juliet symphony — in the 1970’s, in the first flush of my
enthusiasm for all things Wagnerian — and was astonished when I heard the
opening of the “Romeo Alone” movement, the one Les Siècles and François-Xavier
Roth programmed in the January 11 concert, and noticed its amazing resemblance
to the famous opening of the Act I Prelude to Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde, composed 20 years later. Both Berlioz and Wagner
pulled the same musical trick — stacking dissonances on top of each other
without resolving them to more consonant harmonies — to depict the same
dramatic situation: the beginning of a doomed, tragic love affair. Since the
so-called “Tristan chord” had
been considered one of Wagner’s greatest musical innovations, I was startled to
hear that a French composer had been there 20 years before him.
Later I got the
book Wagner Writes from Paris, edited
and translated by Hubert Jacobs and Geoffrey Skelton from articles Wagner wrote
as a musical correspondent to the Dresdener Abendzeitung (the name simply means “Dresden Evening Paper”)
while he was living in Paris. It includes a remarkable piece called “Berlioz
and Liszt,” published May 4, 1841, in which he calls Berlioz a “man of genius”
and adds, “His great virtue is that he does not write for money … Berlioz is a
sworn enemy of anything vulgar, beggarly or catchpennyish.” (Wagner in other
essays used the term “banker-composers” to indicate his contempt of the French
composers he believed did write
for money, and given Wagner’s anti-Semitism and the fact that his principal
target for that epithet was the German expat Jewish composer Giacomo Meyerbeer
it’s not hard to read “banker-composers” as dog-whistle racism for “Jewish
composers.”)
Wagner also
wrote of Berlioz, “If you want to hear Berlioz’s music you will have to go
where he is, for you will encounter him nowhere else … You will hear Berlioz’s
compositions only at the concerts which he himself gives once or twice a year.
These are his own exclusive territory, and here he has his works performed by
an orchestra of his own making, before a public captured by him in the course
of a ten-year campaign.” The moment I first read those words I thought, “Role
model,” for what Berlioz had successfully (more or less — the poor man was always in financial trouble and at the thin edge of
bankruptcy) accomplished in Paris in the late 1830’s was what Wagner ultimately
did at Bayreuth in 1876: open a theatre devoted exclusively to his own
compositions with an orchestra he had personally trained and an audience he had
attracted by sheer persistence.
There have been
arguments back and forth about what Berlioz and Wagner really thought of each
other — in Berlioz’ autobiography his one mention of Wagner is a sense of envy
that Wagner was able to write his own opera libretti instead of having to go
hat-in-hand for writers willing to work with him — though later Berlioz’ references
to Wagner, both in his public articles (Berlioz subsidized himself as a
composer by writing as a music critic for the French press) and his letters,
became kvetchier and more hostile.
In 1859 Berlioz
reviewed a concert of excerpts from Wagner’s operas, conducted by Wagner
himself, and wrote, “It must be concluded, I believe,
that he possesses that rare intensity of feeling, inner fire, will-power, and
conviction which overwhelm, move and sweep the listener along. But those
qualities would have far greater impact if they were combined with more
inventiveness, less calculation and a juster appreciation of some of the
fundamental elements of the art of music.”
Two years later, reviewing a concert of symphonies by the
French composer Henri Reber, Berlioz made a veiled allusion to Wagner and
saying that Reber’s music avoided a trap German composers of the day were
falling into: “His [Reber’s] harmonic writing is bolder than that of Haydn and
Mozart, though without betraying the slightest taste for the savage dissonances
and the chaotic style (style charivarique)
that has been systematically adopted these last four or five years by some
German musicians of unsound mind, and which is nowadays a source of alarm and
horror to the civilised musical world.”
Of course, being Wagner, his praise of Berlioz in 1841 had
its own left-handed aspects, and many of them got filtered through Wagner’s
nationalism: “[H]is French characteristics prevent him from ever making direct
contact with the genius of Beethoven. The tendency of the French is directed
outwards in a search for common points of contact in extremes. A German prefers
to withdraw from social life in order to seek the sources of his inspiration
inside himself, whereas the Frenchman looks for inspiration in the remotest
reaches of society. …
“What inner conflicts must therefore arise in an artist’s
soul such as Berlioz’s, when on the one hand his lively imagination urges him
to explore the profoundest and most mysterious depths of his inner being, while
on the other hand the demands and peculiarities of the people to whom he
belongs, and whose sympathies he shares, oblige him to express his thoughts
only on the immediate surface — when indeed his own creative impulses compel
him in this direction?” This is what led Wagner to say that Berlioz probably
wished he had been born in Germany — something I discounted until I read
Berlioz himself cursing his French ancestry.
Wagner also wrote about the Romeo and Juliet symphony — which he was reviewing in his article — that “in
this work there are so many examples of tastelessness and so many artistic
blemishes, ranged side by side with passages of pure genius, that I could not
help wishing that Berlioz had shown it before the performance to a man like
Cherubini, who would certainly have known how to remove a large number of its
ugly distortions without in any way harming the original as a whole.”
While the idea of Richard Wagner, of all people, criticizing another composer’s work for
being too long stretches the imagination like a taffy-pull (and Wagner either
didn’t know about the bitter enmity Berlioz felt towards Cherubini or was
insensitively rubbing Berlioz’ nose in it), Berlioz himself shortened the work
considerably between the 1839 version Wagner was reviewing and his first
publication of it in 1847, including eliminating another vocal interlude
between the love scene and the Queen Mab scherzo which added further
information about the plot. And yet Wagner had enough of a long-standing
admiration for Berlioz in general and Romeo and Juliet in particular that when he finished Tristan und Isolde he gave Berlioz a copy of the score of Tristan and inscribed it, “To the dear and great author of Romeo
and Juliet [from] the grateful author of Tristan
und Isolde.”
Indeed, the movement of Romeo and Juliet played by Les Siècles at the January 11, 2019 concert
shows the duality of Berlioz’ character, the deep “German” introspection he was
capable of in writing about the lonely torments of Romeo before he meets Juliet
and the superficial “French” gaiety of the ball he goes to more out of sheer
boredom — and a cheekiness in sneaking into the home of his family’s bitterest
enemies — than anything else, where he meets the love who will exalt his life
and (in just two days!) destroy it. As with the other pieces in the first half
of his concert, Roth conducted brilliantly, capturing the sheer joi de vivre of the Capulets’ ball as well as he had done with the
generic “Roman carnival” of the preceding concert overture, and also reveling
in the Tristanisms of the opening of “Romeo alone.”
Harold: Home
from Italy
The three overtures and the Romeo and Juliet excerpt made up the first half of this quite interesting
Les Siècles Berlioz concert. The second half was taken up by Harold in Italy, which I was looking forward to hearing even though I
think it’s the least interesting of Berlioz’ four major quasi-symphonic scores
(the Fantastique, Romeo and Juliet and The
Damnation of Faust — in the last of those
Berlioz still called the work a “dramatic symphony” but it’s a full-fledged
operatic work in which each of the characters is played by a singer and, though
Berlioz didn’t intend it as one, it’s actually been staged as an opera). I’m
not sure why; perhaps Berlioz felt constrained by the commission (even though
he didn’t deliver Paganini the virtuoso concerto he wanted), or maybe the
material didn’t turn him on as much.
Still, I was grateful for the chance to see Harold in
Italy performed. I’d recently re-heard the
late-1950’s recording made by the Philharmonia Orchestra under the young Colin
Davis (one of his few recordings for EMI before he switched to the Philips
label and recorded virtually all of Berlioz’ major works for them). The soloist
on Davis’s recording was Yehudi Menuhin, who like Paganini was primarily a
violinist who took up viola for this work. Recordings of Harold have sometimes used violinists for the viola part,
sometimes viola soloists (not that there are that many of them, though the
first studio recording of Harold in
1944 featured one, William Primrose), and sometimes conductors have simply
pressed into service the first violist of their orchestras (as Arturo Toscanini
did when he recorded Harold with his
regular lead violist, Carleton Cooley).
One problem just listening to Harold is it’s
not always that easy to tell when the viola soloist is playing, since sometimes
Berlioz brings him or her front and center and sometimes lets the solo part
sink into the overall string texture. (That was probably the main reason
Paganini rejected the piece.) Seeing
the work performed clarified things a lot. The soloist for Les Siècles, Tabea
Zimmermann, seemed quite accomplished; she’s a hard-core violist rather than a
violin “switcher.” She was born in Lahr, Germany in 1966 and started studying
viola at 3 and piano at 5. She plays a viola of modern manufacture, hand-made
by Étienne Vatelot in 1980, which she won at the Maurice Vieux International
Viola Competition in 1983 and has used ever since.
Zimmermann is a
heavy-set but reasonably attractive woman who played Harold about as well as anyone could. I’d like to hear her
in other music sometime — she’s recorded chamber music with violinist Gidon
Kremer and has made an album of solo viola works. She’s also featured in a
recording of Harold that may be
from this very same performance, since it was released just eight days later,
also features Les Siècles with François Xavier-Roth as conductor, and is
coupled with a performance of Berlioz’ song cycle Les Nuits d’Été — which I wish they’d performed in the concert since it’s a glorious composition and
one of the first song cycles with full orchestra instead of piano. It would
have been nice to have a representation of Berlioz as vocal composer, and also
interesting since Roth recorded it in an alternate version Berlioz wrote for
baritone (here Stèphane Dugout) whereas every recording I’ve heard has used the
original for soprano.
Though the notes
for this concert designated Harold as
for viola and orchestra (in that order), according to the Wikipedia page on the
piece the official title Berlioz gave it is “Symphonie en quatre parties avec
un alto principal” — “Symphony in four parts with viola obbligato.”
The four parts,
taken from sections in Lord Byron’s poem Childe Harold, are “Harold in the Mountains,” “March of the
Pilgrims” (in which the pilgrims Harold passes as he’s out and about in Italy
are singing an evening hymn — just as they did in Wagner’s Tannhäuser, composed 11 years later), “Serenade of a
Mountaineer of the Abruzzi to His Sweetheart” (the Abruzzi is a region in
central Italy known for its mountains, the Apennines), and “Orgy of the
Brigands” — though the Wikipedia page on Harold contains a quote from Jacques Barzun’s book Berlioz
and the Romantic Century that says
“brigands” doesn’t mean “bandits,” as we might assume: “The brigand of
Berlioz’s time is the avenger of social injustice, the rebel against the City,
who resorts to nature for healing the wounds of social man.”
Harold in
Italy is an impressive work, though it just
doesn’t seem to me to be at the level of Berlioz’s other big program
symphonies, and Zimmermann, Roth and Les Siècles did it as much justice as they
could. Following that they did an unannounced encore: the “Rakozcy March” from La
Damnation de Faust. Berlioz originally wrote
this 4 ½-minute orchestral piece as a one-off, made to create a show-stopping
impression at a concert he was giving in Hungary — it was based on a Hungarian
military march and he knew his audience would get a bang from hearing their
familiar melody, first played softly and then rising in a mighty crescendo. He
then incorporated it into his Faust symphony even though that meant having to
do a quick rewrite of his text to take Faust to Hungary.
In the
“Hungarian March” (which also exists in a piano version by Franz Liszt, though
I’ve never been able to figure out whether Liszt worked from Berlioz’ score or
based his version on the original tune that was, after all, from his native
land) Roth was back on form, clearly having fun with the work as it got louder
and bringing his concert to a close on a viscerally exciting note.
Europe’s
Rich Heritage of Classical Music on TV
This show was
one of a number of televised concerts I’ve been able to obtain lately from
European online sources. Among the others are one Charles and I screened
earlier — a performance of French composer César Franck’s violin sonata from
Utrecht, The Netherlands, with violinist Noa Wildschut and pianist Elisabeth
Brauss giving a tight-knit, exciting, unified performance of a piece that’s been
known to ramble; and the one we watched last night, a really surprising and
beautiful performance of the violin concerto by Aram Khachaturian.
Though the
Khachaturian concerto was filmed and recorded in the famous Concertgebouw hall
in Amsterdam, The Netherlands, the orchestra involved was the Borusan Istanbul
Philharmonic Orchestra, a Turkish group under the leadership of Sascha Goetzel,
a native of Vienna, Austria who’s been conductor of the Borusan since 2008 (and
seemed to have sneaked in a lot of European musicians, judging from the
decidedly non-Turkish looking personnel with whom the orchestra abounded). The
soloist was Nemanja Radulović, who’s listed on his Web page as part French and
part Serbian.
Like the British
violinist Nigel Kennedy, who emerged on the classical scene in the early 1980’s
looking like a punk rocker, Radulović defies the stereotype of what a classical
concert soloist should look like. His hair looks like someone tried to
cross-breed Jimi Hendrix, Bob Marley and Toshiro Mifune in one of his samurai roles (the pics on his Wikipedia page show him with
Marley-style dreadlocks and he’s added the topknot since), and he’s a quite
active musician physically, bobbing and weaving in time to the music instead of
just standing there, stock still, in front of the orchestra the way Serious Musicians are expected to.
The last time I
heard the Khachaturian violin concerto was in a record from EMI that should
have been unsurpassable — the great Russian virtuoso David Oistrakh as the
soloist and an orchestra conducted by Khachaturian himself — but it was a
frustrating experience. Not only was the recording an LP in poor shape, but the
music seemed to be incredibly banal — it sounded like the score for a bad
Hollywood movie about the Middle East. This time around it seemed considerably
better: Radulović and Goetzel tore into the piece and gave it meat and sinew.
It’s still got those big fat tunes from Khachaturian’s native Armenia, but the
performance came together beautifully and made this concerto seem like a real
piece of music and not just a pleasant travelogue.
These two short
films are examples of the kind of programming classical music fans in Europe
get regularly from their TV networks, which are either publicly owned or
privately owned by people who take seriously their obligation to “serve the
people” — all the people, not just the
lowest-common-denominator audience. By comparison, even the U.S.’s Public
Broadcasting Service (PBS) offers precious little cultural programming (and
sometimes stations like San Diego’s KPBS outlet ghettoize even that little to
absurd time slots like Sundays at noon), and the major commercial networks once
broadcast classical music but now seem all too relieved to have dumped that
responsibility onto PBS.
Monday, February 4, 2019
Dunkirk (Warner Brothers, Syncopy, Dombey Street Productions, 2017)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2019 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Two nights ago Charles and I saw a quite remarkable recent movie, Dunkirk, one of two films released in 2017 dealing with the fabled British retreat and evacuation from the French beach at Dunkirk (or, as the French themselves spell it, Dunkerque) in 1940 between the fall of France to Nazi Germany and the Battle of Britain, in which Adolf Hitler and his air minister Hermann Göring attempted to bomb the people of Britain in general and London in particular into submission with sustained aerial attacks, only the British fighter planes, the Hurricane and the Spitfire, existed in large enough numbers (and had enough pilots to fly them) they were able to shoot down a lot of the German bombers. (They were helped by a new technology, radar, which enabled the British to figure out where the German planes were coming from and in what direction they were flying; the Germans could have reversed the tide of battle by bombing the radar stations, but after they tried twice, they gave up.) The air attacks were supposed to soften up Britain prior to a land invasion across the English Channel, but instead the Nazis never launched the invasion and British prime minister Winston Churchill got the one thing he knew would make the difference between whether or not his country survived intact and independent: American entry into the war on the British side.
The two films about Dunkirk released in 2017 were Dunkirk, dealing with the actual evacuation; and Darkest Hour, dealing with the political machinations in the British government and particularly the rivalry between Winston Churchill, appointed as interim prime minister of a national unity government after Neville Chamberlain stepped down just months before his death of cancer in late 1940; and Lord Halifax, who’d been Chamberlain’s foreign minister and was inclined to accept Italian dictator Benito Mussolini’s offer to mediate a peace deal between Britain and Germany. Churchill’s attitude towards a peace, brokered by Mussolini or anyone else, was no thanks and get the hell out of here: unlike a lot of others on the British Right, he knew Hitler and the Nazis posed a huge danger to the peace and freedom of the world, and though he rallied the British people to a bitter-end resistance with his rhetoric he was well aware that Britain could not beat the Nazis on their own and he carried on a secret correspondence with U.S. President Franklin Roosevelt (both signed their letters “Former Naval Person,” since Churchill had been First Lord of the Admiralty and Roosevelt Assistant Secretary of the Navy in World War I) on ways to get around an isolationist Congress and get the U.S. into the war. That’s the story told in Darkest Hour; the story told in Dunkirk is how the British Expeditionary Force, trapped on the beach as the Nazis swept through France and easily overcame what there was of any French resistance, were moved off it again in what was by any measure a military defeat — a hair’s-breadth avoidance of total disaster — but became a huge political win for the Churchill government and ultimately saved both 300,000 British and 100,000 French troops from either annihilation or capture so they could take part in later battles of the war.
Dunkirk was written and directed by Christopher Nolan, a filmmaker best known for the so-called “Dark Knight” trilogy of Batman movies that starred Christian Bale as Batman, and also for Memento and Inception. Nolan, who’s known for non-linear storytelling and a dark view of the world, had never before either written or directed a film based on a true story, and indeed there are parts of Dunkirk in which one starts to wonder not only “Where are we?” but “When are we?” as he freely intercuts between parts of the action that take place on land (mostly on or about “The Mole,” the pier the British were counting on being able to use to moor their ships and therefore take the men they were rescuing off the beach in an orderly fashion), at sea (mostly in the middle of the English Channel on the ships — ranging in size from Navy vessels to yachts and other pleasure craft that were pressed into service by the British government to get as many men off as possible), and in the air (mostly from German planes — heavy bombers, the notorious Stuka dive bombers — equipped with the so-called “Jericho Trumpets,” sirens attached to the plane that made them even louder than their engines did and were supposed to intimidate anyone on the ground below where the bombs were going to go off). I haven’t been a fan of much of Nolan’s previous work — I found the first two films in his Batman trilogy too somber and negative (though the third one, 2012’s The Dark Knight Rises, was quite good) and thought Inception was a movie weakened severely by its director’s quirks, in particular his unwillingness to construct plots that make sense. (Yes, I know that Inception was supposed to be about dreams, and in particular a new technology that allows people in a control room to put someone else through a dream they have programmed for him or her, but I expect even a dream movie to make some level of sense; to my mind, the best dream movie ever made is Buster Keaton’s Sherlock, Jr. from 1924.)
Well, working within the confines of a true story (though attentive imdb.com “Goofs” posters still noticed some mistakes, notably sorts of car interiors, telephone poles, harbor cranes and apartment blocks that didn’t exist in 1940) proved good discipline for Nolan: though there are still some odd time displacements in this movie — Charles said this was the most “meanwhile” movie we’d seen since the 1916 silent version of Jules Verne’s 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, in which so many titles began with the word “meanwhile” that at one juncture Charles complained, “‘meanwhile’ to what?,” and we do get some typical Nolanesque cutbacks to events that actually occurred before the ones we were just watching — for the most part it’s a taut, disciplined modern-day movie whose basic point was that all wars, even the ones fought for the noblest of causes (and a war designed to stop Hitler’s vile attempt to conquer the world and exterminate large chunks of the human population is about as “noble” or “just” as war ever gets), are ultimately pointless wastes of human life and treasure. When I looked up Dunkirk on imdb.com I found a review that faulted the film for not creating any heroic story arcs, not offering much in the way of individualized characterizations of the evacuees (the most interesting people in the movie are a well-to-do middle-aged man who sails his yacht across the English Channel to pick up evacuees, his son — played by an almost ethereally beautiful blond-haired young man who wears a red sweater that practically becomes a character itself — and their deckhand, who’s fatally wounded by a flyer who ditched his plane in the Channel and was suffering from what was then called “shell shock” and is now named post-traumatic stress disorder; the crazy pilot assaults the deckhand and inadvertently kills him, and after the evacuation the son places a story with the local newspaper proclaiming the deckhand a fallen hero of Dunkirk), and for maintaining an emotionally somber tone throughout. Well, I liked that about this movie!
It did seem odd that we saw only one woman, briefly, during the movie — a middle-aged woman serving the men aboard a minesweeper that was one of the craft being used to evacuate the soldiers (until the Germans dive-bombed it into oblivion) — there weren’t the obligatory flashbacks showing the soldiers with the girls back home they abandoned to fight there would have been in a film like this made either in the U.S. or Britain during the war. But Nolan’s approach worked beautifully in dramatizing the sense of panic that must have swept across the soldiers waiting on the beach, desperately hoping that they would be rescued and seeing craft after craft sunk by the Germans until they inexplicably pulled back from the beach and stopped interfering with the British retreat (a military boner on par with the one Union Army General George B. McClellan pulled after beating the Confederates at the Battle of Antietam Creek, Maryland in September 1862; with the Confederate capital, Richmond, only 15 miles away and left unguarded because Robert E. Lee had pulled its defenders away to fight at Antietam, McClellan stopped his advance and let the Confederates regroup and safeguard their capital) for reasons historians are still arguing about. One imdb.com “Trivia” poster wrote, “The Halt Order was agreed by Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt, commander of Army Group A, and General Günther von Kluge, commander of the Fourth Army, at the request of the tank unit commander General Paul von Kleist, who had lost fifty percent of his armored forces and needed time to regroup. After the war, von Rundstedt tried to blame the Halt Order on Adolf Hitler. Von Rundstedt’s biographer conceded that this ‘does not represent the whole truth,’ because the original impetus for a pause came from Kleist and von Rundstedt.” (Later in the war Hitler would anger his commanders by refusing permission for them to do strategic retreats like the British had done at Dunkirk; “Where the German soldier stands, there he stays!” Hitler would say, thereby turning survivable defeats into total routs and hastening Germany’s loss of the war.)
I was strongly impressed by Dunkirk and particularly by the somber tone Nolan kept through the entire movie. I was also especially impressed by the musical score by Hans Zimmer, whom I call the “room man” because Zimmer is the German word for “room.” I’ve never liked Zimmer much — his scores usually seem to me too pat, too superficial, accompanying the film acceptably but adding little or nothing to its emotional weight — but here he triumphs. He recorded Christopher Nolan’s watch and had a faint, almost subliminal ticking sound from it running through the score — an effect that may have been inspired by the famous ticking clock in the 1952 Western classic High Noon (also about a town threatened with annihilation from a fearsome, amoral enemy) and which works beautifully here to guy up the tension and force us to see the Dunkirk story the way Nolan wants us to: “heroic” only in the sense that any action in war is heroic, in that it forces people to push themselves to limits and overcome obstacles in ways they didn’t know they could before they had to. Otherwise, Nolan is saying, war is a waste, even if it’s being fought for “good” intentions — a country like 1940 Britain may be forced to fight for its survival, but that still doesn’t make the fighting itself a good thing. He also does a marvelous job reproducing the quiet terror of the Dunkirk stand, the emotions the servicemembers must have gone through wondering whether they would be rescued and pondering what would be likely to happen to them if they weren’t. In an age way too cynical about war (or just about everything else) to accept an uncomplicated view of “heroism” in a real-world context (though part of the problem with Nolan’s Batman movies is he tried to bring the same kind of cynicism that works for him in Dunkirk to a comic-book superhero legend, where we do expect to see, and indeed we cry out for, uncomplicated white-white heroes and black-black villains), this is the sort of movie we’re going to get about Dunkirk, and it’s a real testament to Christopher Nolan and his great ensemble cast that they give it to us so powerfully and eloquently.
Two nights ago Charles and I saw a quite remarkable recent movie, Dunkirk, one of two films released in 2017 dealing with the fabled British retreat and evacuation from the French beach at Dunkirk (or, as the French themselves spell it, Dunkerque) in 1940 between the fall of France to Nazi Germany and the Battle of Britain, in which Adolf Hitler and his air minister Hermann Göring attempted to bomb the people of Britain in general and London in particular into submission with sustained aerial attacks, only the British fighter planes, the Hurricane and the Spitfire, existed in large enough numbers (and had enough pilots to fly them) they were able to shoot down a lot of the German bombers. (They were helped by a new technology, radar, which enabled the British to figure out where the German planes were coming from and in what direction they were flying; the Germans could have reversed the tide of battle by bombing the radar stations, but after they tried twice, they gave up.) The air attacks were supposed to soften up Britain prior to a land invasion across the English Channel, but instead the Nazis never launched the invasion and British prime minister Winston Churchill got the one thing he knew would make the difference between whether or not his country survived intact and independent: American entry into the war on the British side.
The two films about Dunkirk released in 2017 were Dunkirk, dealing with the actual evacuation; and Darkest Hour, dealing with the political machinations in the British government and particularly the rivalry between Winston Churchill, appointed as interim prime minister of a national unity government after Neville Chamberlain stepped down just months before his death of cancer in late 1940; and Lord Halifax, who’d been Chamberlain’s foreign minister and was inclined to accept Italian dictator Benito Mussolini’s offer to mediate a peace deal between Britain and Germany. Churchill’s attitude towards a peace, brokered by Mussolini or anyone else, was no thanks and get the hell out of here: unlike a lot of others on the British Right, he knew Hitler and the Nazis posed a huge danger to the peace and freedom of the world, and though he rallied the British people to a bitter-end resistance with his rhetoric he was well aware that Britain could not beat the Nazis on their own and he carried on a secret correspondence with U.S. President Franklin Roosevelt (both signed their letters “Former Naval Person,” since Churchill had been First Lord of the Admiralty and Roosevelt Assistant Secretary of the Navy in World War I) on ways to get around an isolationist Congress and get the U.S. into the war. That’s the story told in Darkest Hour; the story told in Dunkirk is how the British Expeditionary Force, trapped on the beach as the Nazis swept through France and easily overcame what there was of any French resistance, were moved off it again in what was by any measure a military defeat — a hair’s-breadth avoidance of total disaster — but became a huge political win for the Churchill government and ultimately saved both 300,000 British and 100,000 French troops from either annihilation or capture so they could take part in later battles of the war.
Dunkirk was written and directed by Christopher Nolan, a filmmaker best known for the so-called “Dark Knight” trilogy of Batman movies that starred Christian Bale as Batman, and also for Memento and Inception. Nolan, who’s known for non-linear storytelling and a dark view of the world, had never before either written or directed a film based on a true story, and indeed there are parts of Dunkirk in which one starts to wonder not only “Where are we?” but “When are we?” as he freely intercuts between parts of the action that take place on land (mostly on or about “The Mole,” the pier the British were counting on being able to use to moor their ships and therefore take the men they were rescuing off the beach in an orderly fashion), at sea (mostly in the middle of the English Channel on the ships — ranging in size from Navy vessels to yachts and other pleasure craft that were pressed into service by the British government to get as many men off as possible), and in the air (mostly from German planes — heavy bombers, the notorious Stuka dive bombers — equipped with the so-called “Jericho Trumpets,” sirens attached to the plane that made them even louder than their engines did and were supposed to intimidate anyone on the ground below where the bombs were going to go off). I haven’t been a fan of much of Nolan’s previous work — I found the first two films in his Batman trilogy too somber and negative (though the third one, 2012’s The Dark Knight Rises, was quite good) and thought Inception was a movie weakened severely by its director’s quirks, in particular his unwillingness to construct plots that make sense. (Yes, I know that Inception was supposed to be about dreams, and in particular a new technology that allows people in a control room to put someone else through a dream they have programmed for him or her, but I expect even a dream movie to make some level of sense; to my mind, the best dream movie ever made is Buster Keaton’s Sherlock, Jr. from 1924.)
Well, working within the confines of a true story (though attentive imdb.com “Goofs” posters still noticed some mistakes, notably sorts of car interiors, telephone poles, harbor cranes and apartment blocks that didn’t exist in 1940) proved good discipline for Nolan: though there are still some odd time displacements in this movie — Charles said this was the most “meanwhile” movie we’d seen since the 1916 silent version of Jules Verne’s 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, in which so many titles began with the word “meanwhile” that at one juncture Charles complained, “‘meanwhile’ to what?,” and we do get some typical Nolanesque cutbacks to events that actually occurred before the ones we were just watching — for the most part it’s a taut, disciplined modern-day movie whose basic point was that all wars, even the ones fought for the noblest of causes (and a war designed to stop Hitler’s vile attempt to conquer the world and exterminate large chunks of the human population is about as “noble” or “just” as war ever gets), are ultimately pointless wastes of human life and treasure. When I looked up Dunkirk on imdb.com I found a review that faulted the film for not creating any heroic story arcs, not offering much in the way of individualized characterizations of the evacuees (the most interesting people in the movie are a well-to-do middle-aged man who sails his yacht across the English Channel to pick up evacuees, his son — played by an almost ethereally beautiful blond-haired young man who wears a red sweater that practically becomes a character itself — and their deckhand, who’s fatally wounded by a flyer who ditched his plane in the Channel and was suffering from what was then called “shell shock” and is now named post-traumatic stress disorder; the crazy pilot assaults the deckhand and inadvertently kills him, and after the evacuation the son places a story with the local newspaper proclaiming the deckhand a fallen hero of Dunkirk), and for maintaining an emotionally somber tone throughout. Well, I liked that about this movie!
It did seem odd that we saw only one woman, briefly, during the movie — a middle-aged woman serving the men aboard a minesweeper that was one of the craft being used to evacuate the soldiers (until the Germans dive-bombed it into oblivion) — there weren’t the obligatory flashbacks showing the soldiers with the girls back home they abandoned to fight there would have been in a film like this made either in the U.S. or Britain during the war. But Nolan’s approach worked beautifully in dramatizing the sense of panic that must have swept across the soldiers waiting on the beach, desperately hoping that they would be rescued and seeing craft after craft sunk by the Germans until they inexplicably pulled back from the beach and stopped interfering with the British retreat (a military boner on par with the one Union Army General George B. McClellan pulled after beating the Confederates at the Battle of Antietam Creek, Maryland in September 1862; with the Confederate capital, Richmond, only 15 miles away and left unguarded because Robert E. Lee had pulled its defenders away to fight at Antietam, McClellan stopped his advance and let the Confederates regroup and safeguard their capital) for reasons historians are still arguing about. One imdb.com “Trivia” poster wrote, “The Halt Order was agreed by Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt, commander of Army Group A, and General Günther von Kluge, commander of the Fourth Army, at the request of the tank unit commander General Paul von Kleist, who had lost fifty percent of his armored forces and needed time to regroup. After the war, von Rundstedt tried to blame the Halt Order on Adolf Hitler. Von Rundstedt’s biographer conceded that this ‘does not represent the whole truth,’ because the original impetus for a pause came from Kleist and von Rundstedt.” (Later in the war Hitler would anger his commanders by refusing permission for them to do strategic retreats like the British had done at Dunkirk; “Where the German soldier stands, there he stays!” Hitler would say, thereby turning survivable defeats into total routs and hastening Germany’s loss of the war.)
I was strongly impressed by Dunkirk and particularly by the somber tone Nolan kept through the entire movie. I was also especially impressed by the musical score by Hans Zimmer, whom I call the “room man” because Zimmer is the German word for “room.” I’ve never liked Zimmer much — his scores usually seem to me too pat, too superficial, accompanying the film acceptably but adding little or nothing to its emotional weight — but here he triumphs. He recorded Christopher Nolan’s watch and had a faint, almost subliminal ticking sound from it running through the score — an effect that may have been inspired by the famous ticking clock in the 1952 Western classic High Noon (also about a town threatened with annihilation from a fearsome, amoral enemy) and which works beautifully here to guy up the tension and force us to see the Dunkirk story the way Nolan wants us to: “heroic” only in the sense that any action in war is heroic, in that it forces people to push themselves to limits and overcome obstacles in ways they didn’t know they could before they had to. Otherwise, Nolan is saying, war is a waste, even if it’s being fought for “good” intentions — a country like 1940 Britain may be forced to fight for its survival, but that still doesn’t make the fighting itself a good thing. He also does a marvelous job reproducing the quiet terror of the Dunkirk stand, the emotions the servicemembers must have gone through wondering whether they would be rescued and pondering what would be likely to happen to them if they weren’t. In an age way too cynical about war (or just about everything else) to accept an uncomplicated view of “heroism” in a real-world context (though part of the problem with Nolan’s Batman movies is he tried to bring the same kind of cynicism that works for him in Dunkirk to a comic-book superhero legend, where we do expect to see, and indeed we cry out for, uncomplicated white-white heroes and black-black villains), this is the sort of movie we’re going to get about Dunkirk, and it’s a real testament to Christopher Nolan and his great ensemble cast that they give it to us so powerfully and eloquently.
Sunday, February 3, 2019
Death of a Cheerleader (Just Singer Entertainment, Reunion Pacific Entertainment, Lifetime, 2019)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2019 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night Charles and I watched two movies, one on Lifetime and one on DVD. The one on DVD was Dunkirk, which I’ll have to reserve comment on, but the one before it we watched on Lifetime turned out to be surprisingly good. The omens weren’t great — the title was Death of a Cheerleader and according to imdb.com it was based on a real-life case from 1984, in which a high-school girl named Bernadette Protti murdered classmate Kirsten Costas in Orinda, California, and it had already been filmed in 1994 with Tori Spelling and Kellie Martin. The promos for the movie had made it look like a really cheesy piece of exploitation Lifetime had decided to commission mainly because the word “cheerleader” in a movie title, with its promise of lots of nubile young female flesh in scanty costume, is one of the few ways they have of getting straight men to watch their channel. Surprise: Death of a Cheerleader, directed by Paul Shapiro from a well-constructed script by Caitlin D. Fryers, turned out to be very, very good. It took a while for a dramatic design to emerge or for me to figure out which of the high-school girls were going to be the most significant members of the dramatis personae, but eventually I “got” that the central conflict would be over status in the elite Hollybrook High School’s pecking order — including Ivy League-style “clubs” like the Sonata Club (which made me wonder if they got together to listen to extended pieces of classical music for only one or two performers) and the Bobbettes, and a martinet-style principal who keeps telling the students that if they succeed at Hollybrook High they’ll succeed in college and the career world as well, with the unspoken but clear message that the ones that fall behind in high school will stay behind all their adult lives, too. The principal combatants are Bridget Moretti (Aubrey Peeples), who’s being raised by a single mother, is working two jobs (including one as a babysitter) to finance all the extracurricular activities she wants to get involved in so people going over college admissions applications will let her in; and Kelly Locke (a marvelously balanced performance by Sarah Dugdale that avoids making her too much of a bitch), the product of two 1-percenters who has everything Bridget wants.
Kelly lets Bridget join the Bobbettes but beats her out of the position on the cheerleading squad and the job on the school yearbook Bridget also wanted, and she also schedules the Bobbettes to go on a ski weekend she knows Bridget either won’t be able to afford at all or will have to scrounge for — the scene in which Kelly waxes her own skis and snubs Bridget by telling her skis are so hopelessly ugly and out-of-date they’re dangerous is one of the best and most insightful moments of the film. Like Restless Virgins and several other Lifetime movies, Death of a Cheerleader is surprisingly class-conscious, and there’s a third girl in the mix, Nina Miller (Morgan Taylor Campbell), who comes to her first class at Hollybrook with her dark hair long and stringy, looking like she just stepped off the set of a movie about 1960’s hippies, only she soon cuts it short and off-center, dyes part of it platinum and looks like she’s about to audition for a job as lead singer in a punk band. Nina makes it clear from the get-go, to her mom, her classmates and to us in brief voice-overs that give us at least some of the information we need to follow the story, that she has absolutely no use for the upper-class crap Kelly has by birth and family influence, and Bridget is working so hard for even though the game is stacked against her. She even calls it “bullshit” in one confrontation with Bridget — and yes, it was quite shocking to hear so strong a swear word on the soundtrack of a Lifetime movie instead of having the second syllable audibly blipped. The more prizes in this stupid game Kelly collects, the more Bridget feels left out, until one night she lies to Kelly and lures her to her car (actually her dad’s car, which her mom has been teaching her to drive even though she’s not quite old enough to be licensed yet), ostensibly just to have it out with her, though when Kelly realizes that the “party” Bridget had promised her isn’t going to happen, and threatens to expose Bridget and rat her out to the other Bobbettes, Bridget loses it, grabs a kitchen knife from inside the car (what was it doing there if this wasn’t a premeditated assault?) and stabs her multiple times in a scene whose explicit gore was as surprising for a Lifetime movie as the sound of the word “bullshit.”
At first Nina is accused of the murder, partly because she lied to her mom about what she was doing that night — she told mom she was going to see the movie Ghostbusters (writer Fryers kept the 1984 setting of the real-life event instead of trying to move it up — at least partly, I suspect, because Bridget wouldn’t have been able to corner Kelly at her her home and kill her after Kelly tries to flee and a neighbor drives Kelly home in the age of cell phones; today Kelly could have just called 911 on her phone and the police would have apprehended Bridget before she could kill Kelly) and she was really going on a date with a young man from Berkeley. Nina also wrote a death threat to Kelly in her class notebook after Kelly insulted her, but in the end her alibi — her real one — checks out and an FBI agent who claims skills as a “profiler” (a hot topic in the 1980’s before profiling got a bad name when the FBI got the Unabomber and the Atlanta Olympics bomber totally wrong) ultimately manages to talk Bridget into confessing. She’s tried and convicted of second-degree murder (not first-degree because the jury decides it was not premeditated within the meaning of the law), much to the fury of Kelly’s parents, and she’s sentenced to nine years in prison, though an end title reveals that the real person was let out in seven. Death of a Cheerleader, despite its tacky title, is actually an impressive piece of work, one of the better Lifetime movies in its class consciousness and also in the multidimensionality of the characters: we hate what Bridget does but at the same time we understand what drove her to it, and though we don’t want to see Kelly killed (especially since she does have some genuinely nice qualities along with the bitchery) we do want to see her get some sort of comeuppance for the way she treated Bridget in particular and anyone in general who didn’t have money and/or didn’t live up to her “standards.”
Last night Charles and I watched two movies, one on Lifetime and one on DVD. The one on DVD was Dunkirk, which I’ll have to reserve comment on, but the one before it we watched on Lifetime turned out to be surprisingly good. The omens weren’t great — the title was Death of a Cheerleader and according to imdb.com it was based on a real-life case from 1984, in which a high-school girl named Bernadette Protti murdered classmate Kirsten Costas in Orinda, California, and it had already been filmed in 1994 with Tori Spelling and Kellie Martin. The promos for the movie had made it look like a really cheesy piece of exploitation Lifetime had decided to commission mainly because the word “cheerleader” in a movie title, with its promise of lots of nubile young female flesh in scanty costume, is one of the few ways they have of getting straight men to watch their channel. Surprise: Death of a Cheerleader, directed by Paul Shapiro from a well-constructed script by Caitlin D. Fryers, turned out to be very, very good. It took a while for a dramatic design to emerge or for me to figure out which of the high-school girls were going to be the most significant members of the dramatis personae, but eventually I “got” that the central conflict would be over status in the elite Hollybrook High School’s pecking order — including Ivy League-style “clubs” like the Sonata Club (which made me wonder if they got together to listen to extended pieces of classical music for only one or two performers) and the Bobbettes, and a martinet-style principal who keeps telling the students that if they succeed at Hollybrook High they’ll succeed in college and the career world as well, with the unspoken but clear message that the ones that fall behind in high school will stay behind all their adult lives, too. The principal combatants are Bridget Moretti (Aubrey Peeples), who’s being raised by a single mother, is working two jobs (including one as a babysitter) to finance all the extracurricular activities she wants to get involved in so people going over college admissions applications will let her in; and Kelly Locke (a marvelously balanced performance by Sarah Dugdale that avoids making her too much of a bitch), the product of two 1-percenters who has everything Bridget wants.
Kelly lets Bridget join the Bobbettes but beats her out of the position on the cheerleading squad and the job on the school yearbook Bridget also wanted, and she also schedules the Bobbettes to go on a ski weekend she knows Bridget either won’t be able to afford at all or will have to scrounge for — the scene in which Kelly waxes her own skis and snubs Bridget by telling her skis are so hopelessly ugly and out-of-date they’re dangerous is one of the best and most insightful moments of the film. Like Restless Virgins and several other Lifetime movies, Death of a Cheerleader is surprisingly class-conscious, and there’s a third girl in the mix, Nina Miller (Morgan Taylor Campbell), who comes to her first class at Hollybrook with her dark hair long and stringy, looking like she just stepped off the set of a movie about 1960’s hippies, only she soon cuts it short and off-center, dyes part of it platinum and looks like she’s about to audition for a job as lead singer in a punk band. Nina makes it clear from the get-go, to her mom, her classmates and to us in brief voice-overs that give us at least some of the information we need to follow the story, that she has absolutely no use for the upper-class crap Kelly has by birth and family influence, and Bridget is working so hard for even though the game is stacked against her. She even calls it “bullshit” in one confrontation with Bridget — and yes, it was quite shocking to hear so strong a swear word on the soundtrack of a Lifetime movie instead of having the second syllable audibly blipped. The more prizes in this stupid game Kelly collects, the more Bridget feels left out, until one night she lies to Kelly and lures her to her car (actually her dad’s car, which her mom has been teaching her to drive even though she’s not quite old enough to be licensed yet), ostensibly just to have it out with her, though when Kelly realizes that the “party” Bridget had promised her isn’t going to happen, and threatens to expose Bridget and rat her out to the other Bobbettes, Bridget loses it, grabs a kitchen knife from inside the car (what was it doing there if this wasn’t a premeditated assault?) and stabs her multiple times in a scene whose explicit gore was as surprising for a Lifetime movie as the sound of the word “bullshit.”
At first Nina is accused of the murder, partly because she lied to her mom about what she was doing that night — she told mom she was going to see the movie Ghostbusters (writer Fryers kept the 1984 setting of the real-life event instead of trying to move it up — at least partly, I suspect, because Bridget wouldn’t have been able to corner Kelly at her her home and kill her after Kelly tries to flee and a neighbor drives Kelly home in the age of cell phones; today Kelly could have just called 911 on her phone and the police would have apprehended Bridget before she could kill Kelly) and she was really going on a date with a young man from Berkeley. Nina also wrote a death threat to Kelly in her class notebook after Kelly insulted her, but in the end her alibi — her real one — checks out and an FBI agent who claims skills as a “profiler” (a hot topic in the 1980’s before profiling got a bad name when the FBI got the Unabomber and the Atlanta Olympics bomber totally wrong) ultimately manages to talk Bridget into confessing. She’s tried and convicted of second-degree murder (not first-degree because the jury decides it was not premeditated within the meaning of the law), much to the fury of Kelly’s parents, and she’s sentenced to nine years in prison, though an end title reveals that the real person was let out in seven. Death of a Cheerleader, despite its tacky title, is actually an impressive piece of work, one of the better Lifetime movies in its class consciousness and also in the multidimensionality of the characters: we hate what Bridget does but at the same time we understand what drove her to it, and though we don’t want to see Kelly killed (especially since she does have some genuinely nice qualities along with the bitchery) we do want to see her get some sort of comeuppance for the way she treated Bridget in particular and anyone in general who didn’t have money and/or didn’t live up to her “standards.”
Saturday, February 2, 2019
Miss London, Ltd. (Gainsborough/Gaumont-British, 1943)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2019 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Charles and I ran a really quirky 1943 British wartime musical he’d downloaded from an online source called Miss London, Ltd. It was a vehicle for an inexplicably popular British comedian named Arthur Askey, and it was produced under impressive auspices — the Gainsborough company, in partnership with Gaumont-British, with Michael Balcon as studio head, Edward Black as producer and Val Guest as director, co-writer (with Marriott Edgar), and co-songwriter (with Manning Sherwin) — adding Guest to the short list (Charlie Chaplin, Victor Schertzinger and Clint Eastwood) of auteurs who’ve directed, written and scored their films. It’s a sort of portmanteau musical with some genuinely talented performers and an overall insouciance and a refreshing understanding of just how preposterous the musical is as a genre — especially when it’s not about people who sing and dance for a living. It opens with “The 8:50 Choo Choo,” a big number set in a train station in which the station announcer and all the porters are women — it was World War II, you know, and there are signs in the station indicating how train travel (like just about everything else) was being rationed, including “Don’t Travel for Pleasure” and “Is This Trip Really Necessary?” It seems as if Val Guest and Manning Sherwin had seen how popular the “Chattanooga Choo Choo” number had been for Glenn Miller, both as a record (it wasn’t the first to sell a million copies but it was the first to be formally awarded a Gold Record for doing so) and a number in Miller’s film Sun Valley Serenade, and decided to emulate it. The train is bringing in Terry Arden (Evelyn Dall), an American from New York (though we have to take that pretty much on faith — Dall’s only attempt at an American accent is to speak her lines in a very clipped, staccato manner) who has just inherited half of a British escort service — and, this being a movie made under the jurisdiction of the British Board of Film Censors, “escort” means precisely that and isn’t a euphemism for prostitution — called “Miss London, Ltd.” Only when she reaches the offices of Miss London, Ltd. she finds that the premises are dusty, there’s virtually no business, the girls whose photos are on file are buxom creatures from the turn of the previous century, and Miss London herself is really Miss London himself, Arthur Bowman (Arthur Askey), who inherited the business (or his half, anyway) from his mother.
The situation of the American coming over the Atlantic to inherit a business that turns out to be on its last legs had been done many times — including the 1935 Astaire-Rogers classic Roberta (adapted from the stage musical that had made Bob Hope a star) and a number of Laurel and Hardy’s films — but Evelyn Dall, despite her problematic accent, plays the part with authority and works hard to recruit new girls to make the business a success. Alas, Arthur and his sidekick Joe Nelson (Jack Train) have fallen six months’ behind on their rent, so in a ripoff of the famous scene from Henri Murger’s Scénes de la Vie de Bohème that did not make it into Puccini’s opera La Bohème, they set up shop on the sidewalk outside (a situation also used in the big Bojangles Robinson-Fats Waller production number, “Living in a Great Big Way,” that ends the 1935 RKO musical Hooray for Love and is the best thing in it) and try to keep running the business outdoors despite the attempts of an officious cop to move on. One of the few dates they were actually able to arrange was between Gail Martin (Anne Shelton, a major music star in Britain — she did the best record of the song “A Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square” and her career lasted long enough to have at least a tangential connection with the Beatles: when Brian Epstein opened his big record store on Great Charlotte Street in Liverpool, he got Shelton to perform at his opening) and Captain Rory O’Moore (Peter Graves — no, not that Peter Graves!), a servicemember who wanted female companionship for his one day’s leave in London. (That part of the story reminded Charles of On the Town, which didn’t premiere on stage until a year after this film was made.) It turns out that O’Moore is the owner of the Hotel Splendide in London, and he offers Miss London, Ltd. a whole floor in his hotel — but only if they can obtain a second date for him with Gail, who’s unwilling not only because she already has a job as the female station announcer we saw in the opening scene but her first date went poorly. Instead of taking her out O’Moore gave her a “private supper” in his hotel bedroom and clearly had seduction on his mind — and Gail’s virtue was saved only by Arthur, who locked the officious waiter Romero (Max Bacon, playing the part as a Continental — in an American film on this premise it would have been Eric Blore playing a Brit!) in a hotel closet and took over, disrupting O’Moore’s plans to get Gail into his bed.
Miss London, Ltd. is a film a good deal funnier in its parts than as a whole — its best sequence comes in which, not realizing that O’Moore is the hotel proprietor they are trying to get in to see, they hit on the idea of impersonating celebrities. But who? They run through a list of various big names of the time, including Clark Gable, Jack Benny and his Black sidekick Rochester (in the post-Michael Jackson era Jack Train’s attempts to explain why he looks white when he’s “really” Black play a bit differently than they did in 1943!) and then someone suggests to Arthur Bowman that he impersonate Arthur Askey — which leads to some marvelously metafictional dialogue in which Arthur Askey’s character tells us how he can’t stand Arthur Askey. The celebrities they decide to impersonate are the Marx Brothers, with Askey as Harpo, Train as Chico and Dall as Groucho — the idea of a woman (complete with long blonde hair) trying to pass herself off as Groucho just adds to an already funny scene (certainly we’ve seen less impressive Marx Brothers impersonations than this!), and of course the whole gag is a ripoff of the real Marx Brothers’ attempt to get off the ship in Monkey Business by impersonating Maurice Chevalier. The Marxmanship continues at the big party celebrating Miss London, Ltd.’s re-opening in the Hotel Splendide, in which Askey does a piano routine which begins with him playing the opening of Rachmaninoff’s Prelude in C-sharp minor — a piece the real Harpo Marx parodied in A Day at the Races. Then he complains that the rest of the piece is too difficult and goes into Eubie Blake’s “Memories of You.” He’s got placards on his piano giving the title of each piece in case anyone came late and missed his announcements, and after the ones reading “Rachmaninoff’s Prelude” and “Memories” he gets to one labeled “Ladies’ Cloakroom.” There’s suspense over whether Gail will make it to the party on time — certainly her first date with O’Moore was not an experience she wanted to repeat — but she does at the very last minute, and ultimately she and O’Moore pair off for good (or at least until he returns from his latest deployment), as do Dall and Askey — though Askey’s draft notices finally catch up with him at the last minute and he’s clapped into a Navy brig from which Dall says goodbye to him as he ships out.
Askey was a stage performer who in 1938 broke into stardom with a radio show called Band Waggon (note the spelling with two “g”’s) which got filmed in 1940 (I commented on it at https://moviemagg.blogspot.com/2013/10/band-waggon-gaumont-britishgainsborough.html) as a satire of the monopsony power (for those who missed Econ 102, a monopoly is a single seller and a monopsony is a single buyer — and in this case it meant the publicly owned British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) as the only company to which aspiring British radio performers could sell their services, and also a war-themed plot line in which they inadvertently stumble on and foil an attempt by Fifth Columnists to take over the BBC’s experimental TV station and use it to broadcast Nazi propaganda. This made him a film star through the 1940’s and into the 1950’s, and when his movie popularity started to fade he got on TV and hosted a self-named show from 1961 until his retirement (he died in 1982 in London at age 82 from gangrene after having both legs amputated, which suggests he was severely diabetic — this is also how Ella Fitzgerald died). His act in Miss London, Ltd. seems to be a bit wearing — he was short (5’ 2”, two inches shorter than Charlie Chaplin), wore Harold Lloyd-style glasses and could be a Lee Tracy-ish wise guy and an effeminate milquetoast — but he’s funny and Guest and co-writer Edgar fortunately structure their script so we don’t have to look at him for that much of the movie — it’s a vehicle for him but there are enough strongly etched roles for the other characters, especially the two women leads, it counts as an ensemble piece. It’s also a skillfully constructed piece in the way the songs, not particularly memorable in themselves, are smoothly integrated in the action; though it’s nowhere nearly as good a film as Rouben Mamoulian’s Love Me Tonight, which I still regard as the best musical movie ever made, bar none, Miss London, Ltd. shares its understanding of the basic artificiality of the musical genre — the sheer absurdity of the idea that in the middle of ordinary conversations people will suddenly stop talking and start singing, and orchestras will magically appear out of nowhere to accompany them. I like musicals (including the recent La La Land) that simultaneously exploit the musical conventions and make fun of them.
Charles and I ran a really quirky 1943 British wartime musical he’d downloaded from an online source called Miss London, Ltd. It was a vehicle for an inexplicably popular British comedian named Arthur Askey, and it was produced under impressive auspices — the Gainsborough company, in partnership with Gaumont-British, with Michael Balcon as studio head, Edward Black as producer and Val Guest as director, co-writer (with Marriott Edgar), and co-songwriter (with Manning Sherwin) — adding Guest to the short list (Charlie Chaplin, Victor Schertzinger and Clint Eastwood) of auteurs who’ve directed, written and scored their films. It’s a sort of portmanteau musical with some genuinely talented performers and an overall insouciance and a refreshing understanding of just how preposterous the musical is as a genre — especially when it’s not about people who sing and dance for a living. It opens with “The 8:50 Choo Choo,” a big number set in a train station in which the station announcer and all the porters are women — it was World War II, you know, and there are signs in the station indicating how train travel (like just about everything else) was being rationed, including “Don’t Travel for Pleasure” and “Is This Trip Really Necessary?” It seems as if Val Guest and Manning Sherwin had seen how popular the “Chattanooga Choo Choo” number had been for Glenn Miller, both as a record (it wasn’t the first to sell a million copies but it was the first to be formally awarded a Gold Record for doing so) and a number in Miller’s film Sun Valley Serenade, and decided to emulate it. The train is bringing in Terry Arden (Evelyn Dall), an American from New York (though we have to take that pretty much on faith — Dall’s only attempt at an American accent is to speak her lines in a very clipped, staccato manner) who has just inherited half of a British escort service — and, this being a movie made under the jurisdiction of the British Board of Film Censors, “escort” means precisely that and isn’t a euphemism for prostitution — called “Miss London, Ltd.” Only when she reaches the offices of Miss London, Ltd. she finds that the premises are dusty, there’s virtually no business, the girls whose photos are on file are buxom creatures from the turn of the previous century, and Miss London herself is really Miss London himself, Arthur Bowman (Arthur Askey), who inherited the business (or his half, anyway) from his mother.
The situation of the American coming over the Atlantic to inherit a business that turns out to be on its last legs had been done many times — including the 1935 Astaire-Rogers classic Roberta (adapted from the stage musical that had made Bob Hope a star) and a number of Laurel and Hardy’s films — but Evelyn Dall, despite her problematic accent, plays the part with authority and works hard to recruit new girls to make the business a success. Alas, Arthur and his sidekick Joe Nelson (Jack Train) have fallen six months’ behind on their rent, so in a ripoff of the famous scene from Henri Murger’s Scénes de la Vie de Bohème that did not make it into Puccini’s opera La Bohème, they set up shop on the sidewalk outside (a situation also used in the big Bojangles Robinson-Fats Waller production number, “Living in a Great Big Way,” that ends the 1935 RKO musical Hooray for Love and is the best thing in it) and try to keep running the business outdoors despite the attempts of an officious cop to move on. One of the few dates they were actually able to arrange was between Gail Martin (Anne Shelton, a major music star in Britain — she did the best record of the song “A Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square” and her career lasted long enough to have at least a tangential connection with the Beatles: when Brian Epstein opened his big record store on Great Charlotte Street in Liverpool, he got Shelton to perform at his opening) and Captain Rory O’Moore (Peter Graves — no, not that Peter Graves!), a servicemember who wanted female companionship for his one day’s leave in London. (That part of the story reminded Charles of On the Town, which didn’t premiere on stage until a year after this film was made.) It turns out that O’Moore is the owner of the Hotel Splendide in London, and he offers Miss London, Ltd. a whole floor in his hotel — but only if they can obtain a second date for him with Gail, who’s unwilling not only because she already has a job as the female station announcer we saw in the opening scene but her first date went poorly. Instead of taking her out O’Moore gave her a “private supper” in his hotel bedroom and clearly had seduction on his mind — and Gail’s virtue was saved only by Arthur, who locked the officious waiter Romero (Max Bacon, playing the part as a Continental — in an American film on this premise it would have been Eric Blore playing a Brit!) in a hotel closet and took over, disrupting O’Moore’s plans to get Gail into his bed.
Miss London, Ltd. is a film a good deal funnier in its parts than as a whole — its best sequence comes in which, not realizing that O’Moore is the hotel proprietor they are trying to get in to see, they hit on the idea of impersonating celebrities. But who? They run through a list of various big names of the time, including Clark Gable, Jack Benny and his Black sidekick Rochester (in the post-Michael Jackson era Jack Train’s attempts to explain why he looks white when he’s “really” Black play a bit differently than they did in 1943!) and then someone suggests to Arthur Bowman that he impersonate Arthur Askey — which leads to some marvelously metafictional dialogue in which Arthur Askey’s character tells us how he can’t stand Arthur Askey. The celebrities they decide to impersonate are the Marx Brothers, with Askey as Harpo, Train as Chico and Dall as Groucho — the idea of a woman (complete with long blonde hair) trying to pass herself off as Groucho just adds to an already funny scene (certainly we’ve seen less impressive Marx Brothers impersonations than this!), and of course the whole gag is a ripoff of the real Marx Brothers’ attempt to get off the ship in Monkey Business by impersonating Maurice Chevalier. The Marxmanship continues at the big party celebrating Miss London, Ltd.’s re-opening in the Hotel Splendide, in which Askey does a piano routine which begins with him playing the opening of Rachmaninoff’s Prelude in C-sharp minor — a piece the real Harpo Marx parodied in A Day at the Races. Then he complains that the rest of the piece is too difficult and goes into Eubie Blake’s “Memories of You.” He’s got placards on his piano giving the title of each piece in case anyone came late and missed his announcements, and after the ones reading “Rachmaninoff’s Prelude” and “Memories” he gets to one labeled “Ladies’ Cloakroom.” There’s suspense over whether Gail will make it to the party on time — certainly her first date with O’Moore was not an experience she wanted to repeat — but she does at the very last minute, and ultimately she and O’Moore pair off for good (or at least until he returns from his latest deployment), as do Dall and Askey — though Askey’s draft notices finally catch up with him at the last minute and he’s clapped into a Navy brig from which Dall says goodbye to him as he ships out.
Askey was a stage performer who in 1938 broke into stardom with a radio show called Band Waggon (note the spelling with two “g”’s) which got filmed in 1940 (I commented on it at https://moviemagg.blogspot.com/2013/10/band-waggon-gaumont-britishgainsborough.html) as a satire of the monopsony power (for those who missed Econ 102, a monopoly is a single seller and a monopsony is a single buyer — and in this case it meant the publicly owned British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) as the only company to which aspiring British radio performers could sell their services, and also a war-themed plot line in which they inadvertently stumble on and foil an attempt by Fifth Columnists to take over the BBC’s experimental TV station and use it to broadcast Nazi propaganda. This made him a film star through the 1940’s and into the 1950’s, and when his movie popularity started to fade he got on TV and hosted a self-named show from 1961 until his retirement (he died in 1982 in London at age 82 from gangrene after having both legs amputated, which suggests he was severely diabetic — this is also how Ella Fitzgerald died). His act in Miss London, Ltd. seems to be a bit wearing — he was short (5’ 2”, two inches shorter than Charlie Chaplin), wore Harold Lloyd-style glasses and could be a Lee Tracy-ish wise guy and an effeminate milquetoast — but he’s funny and Guest and co-writer Edgar fortunately structure their script so we don’t have to look at him for that much of the movie — it’s a vehicle for him but there are enough strongly etched roles for the other characters, especially the two women leads, it counts as an ensemble piece. It’s also a skillfully constructed piece in the way the songs, not particularly memorable in themselves, are smoothly integrated in the action; though it’s nowhere nearly as good a film as Rouben Mamoulian’s Love Me Tonight, which I still regard as the best musical movie ever made, bar none, Miss London, Ltd. shares its understanding of the basic artificiality of the musical genre — the sheer absurdity of the idea that in the middle of ordinary conversations people will suddenly stop talking and start singing, and orchestras will magically appear out of nowhere to accompany them. I like musicals (including the recent La La Land) that simultaneously exploit the musical conventions and make fun of them.
The Dictator’s Playbook: Benito Mussolini (Crown Productions, Twin Cities Public Television, PBS, 2019)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2019 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Yesterday I got to see a quite remarkable press conference by President Trump (with the unusually bright White House lights penetrating his comb-over and exposing his bald spot more than usual) saying that Nancy Pelosi and the Democrats are hurting the country by not giving him the money for his border wall, the conference-committee negotiations over the Homeland Security funding bill are “a waste of time,” and he’s planning — or at least thinking — about other steps, including the so-called “declaration of emergency” that would, he says, give him the authority to take money from wherever he pleases in the federal budget and devote it to building the wall. Though I’ve downloaded an article from lawfare.com which says that “Presidential emergencies” are actually pretty routine — when the article was published in December 2017 we were actually in 28 of them, mostly dealing with natural disasters — I suspect what Trump has in mind is a full-scale end run around constitutional government itself, one more step in his desire to become a virtual dictator. I’m probably thinking along these lines because of the program I streamed on Thursday night from the PBS Web site, an episode of their six-part series The Dictator’s Playbook, dealing with six 20th-century dictators from what might be called the “B-list”: Benito Mussolini, Francisco Franco, Kim Il Sung, Saddam Hussein, Idi Amin and Manuel Noriega. Mussolini’s example is probably the most relevant to Trump because he was the only one of the six who came to power via exploiting a democratic (or quasi-democratic) system and then destroying it: Franco won a civil war, Kim Il Sung won a resistance movement and Saddam, Amin and Noriega all took power in coups. The program describes Mussolini’s history as a violent kid who got expelled from multiple schools for fighting with his classmates, grew up to be a hothead and then discovered political causes, first socialism (he was the editor of the Italian Socialist paper Avanti!) and then Right-wing nationalism. Mussolini not only invented the ideology of fascism, he coined the name — from the fasces, a bundle of sticks bound together with an ax inside, a symbol of the power of ancient Rome and its standing in the world, to which Mussolini wanted Italy to return.
The makers of the Mussolini episode of The Dictator’s Playbook seemed all too conscious of the Mussolini-Trump parallels: both were fanatical nationalists who appealed to people with a promise to return their countries to a past age of glory (one of the expert historians on the show actually says that the reason there are still Mussolini supporters in Italy who stage fascist parades, fly Mussolini’s flags and root for a restoration of his regime is that they want to “make Italy great again”!); both idealized the military (though at least Mussolini, unlike Trump, actually served in combat); both called their political enemies scathing nicknames; and, most importantly, both fastened on a scapegoat on whom they could blame all their country’s problems. For Mussolini it was the Communists in general and Lenin in particular; for Trump it’s been immigrants and Muslims. Both rhetorically compared their scapegoats to insects and vermin — Trump’s over-the-top rhetoric against immigrants fits right in with this particular version of the would-be dictator’s playbook — and both also savaged their political opponents, though so far (at least) Trump hasn’t gone to the lengths of having them murdered the way Mussolini did with his principal rival, Giacomo Matteotti, in 1924 (and Manuel Noriega did with his, Hugo Spadafora, in 1985 — both dictators circulated gruesome photos of their enemies’ corpses as a public lesson in what would happen to dissenters). Most of the histories have portrayed Mussolini as a sort of junior partner in the Axis, but in fact he took power in Italy in 1922 — 11 years before Hitler seized the rulership of Germany — and the Nazis copied a lot of the tactics of the Italian fascists, including organizing uniformed paramilitaries (Mussolini’s wore black shirts, Hitler’s brown shirts) and engaging in physical assaults against political enemies and their events. They also staged huge public rallies before adoring crowds (an obvious commonality with Trump!) and stoked national anxieties by scapegoating marginal groups — both Hitler and Mussolini went after Communists, and Hitler went after Jews as well. (The Italian fascists were not particularly anti-Semitic until Mussolini allied with Hitler in the 1930’s on the advice of his son-in-law and foreign minister, Count Ciano — like Trump, Mussolini gave quite a lot of power to a son-in-law that wasn’t particularly capable of using it wisely — and as part of the alliance started to incorporate anti-Semitism and anti-Masonry into Fascist ideology.)
The Dictator’s Playbook show tells the history of World War II, in particular the disastrous campaign by Italy to hold their colonies in North Africa (the Germans had to send an army to bail their nominal allies out, with disastrous results for both countries of the Axis — Field Marshal Montgomery’s victory over Rommel at El Alamein is considered, along with the Russian defeat of the Germans at Stalingrad, one of the two key turning points in the European theatre of World War II), and Mussolini’s fall from power in 1943, the dramatic rescue of him from a mountaintop prison by Nazi commandos led by pilot Otto Skorzeny, and Hitler’s installation of him as a puppet ruler of the northern half of Italy as the Republic of Saló. Mussolini was finally captured by Italian partisans in 1945 as he and his mistress, Clara Petacci, were trying to flee into Austria; they gave him a sham trial, killed him and Petacci, and hung them both in public until a U.S. army unit took control of the town and finally cut them down. Mussolini had taken power in a sort of hybrid system, like Britain in the 18th and 19th centuries, in which there was both a legislature and a monarchy, and the monarch still had considerable power — it was he who appointed the prime minister — which meant that after the war Italians largely regarded their king as complicit in the misdeeds of Mussolini’s regime, and in a 1946 referendum they voted to end the monarchy and make Italy a republic (though the vote was surprisingly close). Given President Trump’s hints that he’s going to declare a “state of emergency” if he can’t get the Democrats in Congress to go along with funding his wall — though he’s also saying the wall is already being built — Mussolini’s example seems particularly relevant today even though with Trump we’re likely to be saved from his malevolence by his incompetence.
Mussolini and the other profilees in The Dictator’s Playbook were all very determined individuals who were able to make long-range plans and stick to them: Trump seems madly impulsive and quite frankly lacks the concentration to stick with much of anything for very long — as witness the rapidity with which his administration’s cover stories change. Still, it’s not entirely inconceivable that Trump may not only declare the “state of emergency” but expand it to a general attack on the whole concept of democratic government and seek to do what he’s always wanted: to rule by decree (the real message he was sending in the early days of his administration, where he seemed to be governing exclusively by executive orders, presenting them in handsome leather-bound cases and signing them in huge letters with a Sharpie, which, as I joked at the time, he seems to have selected to tell America that a Sharpie was the only writing instrument big enough for his … hands). Trump also revels in the same kinds of theatricality Mussolini and Hitler did, with the big rallies, the adoring crowds and his obvious love for the trappings of power — and it hasn’t escaped me during the discussion of whether Trump will declare a “state of emergency” so he can build his border wall in spite of Congress, that Hitler similarly got the Reichstag to vote him emergency powers through the so-called “Enabling Acts” after the Reichstag fire, so he was able to circumvent and escape the limits of the Weimar constitution without having to go through the bothersome necessity of having it formally repealed. I’ve suggested not only that Trump could be America’s Mussolini, destroying democratic institutions and norms once and for all, but also that he might be America’s Boris Yeltsin, making such a mockery of “democracy” that the country rejects it and turns to an equally unscrupulous but far more capable character, an American Vladimir Putin, to replace Trump’s incompetent autocracy with a competent (though still corrupt) one the way Putin’s replaced Yeltsin’s.
Yesterday I got to see a quite remarkable press conference by President Trump (with the unusually bright White House lights penetrating his comb-over and exposing his bald spot more than usual) saying that Nancy Pelosi and the Democrats are hurting the country by not giving him the money for his border wall, the conference-committee negotiations over the Homeland Security funding bill are “a waste of time,” and he’s planning — or at least thinking — about other steps, including the so-called “declaration of emergency” that would, he says, give him the authority to take money from wherever he pleases in the federal budget and devote it to building the wall. Though I’ve downloaded an article from lawfare.com which says that “Presidential emergencies” are actually pretty routine — when the article was published in December 2017 we were actually in 28 of them, mostly dealing with natural disasters — I suspect what Trump has in mind is a full-scale end run around constitutional government itself, one more step in his desire to become a virtual dictator. I’m probably thinking along these lines because of the program I streamed on Thursday night from the PBS Web site, an episode of their six-part series The Dictator’s Playbook, dealing with six 20th-century dictators from what might be called the “B-list”: Benito Mussolini, Francisco Franco, Kim Il Sung, Saddam Hussein, Idi Amin and Manuel Noriega. Mussolini’s example is probably the most relevant to Trump because he was the only one of the six who came to power via exploiting a democratic (or quasi-democratic) system and then destroying it: Franco won a civil war, Kim Il Sung won a resistance movement and Saddam, Amin and Noriega all took power in coups. The program describes Mussolini’s history as a violent kid who got expelled from multiple schools for fighting with his classmates, grew up to be a hothead and then discovered political causes, first socialism (he was the editor of the Italian Socialist paper Avanti!) and then Right-wing nationalism. Mussolini not only invented the ideology of fascism, he coined the name — from the fasces, a bundle of sticks bound together with an ax inside, a symbol of the power of ancient Rome and its standing in the world, to which Mussolini wanted Italy to return.
The makers of the Mussolini episode of The Dictator’s Playbook seemed all too conscious of the Mussolini-Trump parallels: both were fanatical nationalists who appealed to people with a promise to return their countries to a past age of glory (one of the expert historians on the show actually says that the reason there are still Mussolini supporters in Italy who stage fascist parades, fly Mussolini’s flags and root for a restoration of his regime is that they want to “make Italy great again”!); both idealized the military (though at least Mussolini, unlike Trump, actually served in combat); both called their political enemies scathing nicknames; and, most importantly, both fastened on a scapegoat on whom they could blame all their country’s problems. For Mussolini it was the Communists in general and Lenin in particular; for Trump it’s been immigrants and Muslims. Both rhetorically compared their scapegoats to insects and vermin — Trump’s over-the-top rhetoric against immigrants fits right in with this particular version of the would-be dictator’s playbook — and both also savaged their political opponents, though so far (at least) Trump hasn’t gone to the lengths of having them murdered the way Mussolini did with his principal rival, Giacomo Matteotti, in 1924 (and Manuel Noriega did with his, Hugo Spadafora, in 1985 — both dictators circulated gruesome photos of their enemies’ corpses as a public lesson in what would happen to dissenters). Most of the histories have portrayed Mussolini as a sort of junior partner in the Axis, but in fact he took power in Italy in 1922 — 11 years before Hitler seized the rulership of Germany — and the Nazis copied a lot of the tactics of the Italian fascists, including organizing uniformed paramilitaries (Mussolini’s wore black shirts, Hitler’s brown shirts) and engaging in physical assaults against political enemies and their events. They also staged huge public rallies before adoring crowds (an obvious commonality with Trump!) and stoked national anxieties by scapegoating marginal groups — both Hitler and Mussolini went after Communists, and Hitler went after Jews as well. (The Italian fascists were not particularly anti-Semitic until Mussolini allied with Hitler in the 1930’s on the advice of his son-in-law and foreign minister, Count Ciano — like Trump, Mussolini gave quite a lot of power to a son-in-law that wasn’t particularly capable of using it wisely — and as part of the alliance started to incorporate anti-Semitism and anti-Masonry into Fascist ideology.)
The Dictator’s Playbook show tells the history of World War II, in particular the disastrous campaign by Italy to hold their colonies in North Africa (the Germans had to send an army to bail their nominal allies out, with disastrous results for both countries of the Axis — Field Marshal Montgomery’s victory over Rommel at El Alamein is considered, along with the Russian defeat of the Germans at Stalingrad, one of the two key turning points in the European theatre of World War II), and Mussolini’s fall from power in 1943, the dramatic rescue of him from a mountaintop prison by Nazi commandos led by pilot Otto Skorzeny, and Hitler’s installation of him as a puppet ruler of the northern half of Italy as the Republic of Saló. Mussolini was finally captured by Italian partisans in 1945 as he and his mistress, Clara Petacci, were trying to flee into Austria; they gave him a sham trial, killed him and Petacci, and hung them both in public until a U.S. army unit took control of the town and finally cut them down. Mussolini had taken power in a sort of hybrid system, like Britain in the 18th and 19th centuries, in which there was both a legislature and a monarchy, and the monarch still had considerable power — it was he who appointed the prime minister — which meant that after the war Italians largely regarded their king as complicit in the misdeeds of Mussolini’s regime, and in a 1946 referendum they voted to end the monarchy and make Italy a republic (though the vote was surprisingly close). Given President Trump’s hints that he’s going to declare a “state of emergency” if he can’t get the Democrats in Congress to go along with funding his wall — though he’s also saying the wall is already being built — Mussolini’s example seems particularly relevant today even though with Trump we’re likely to be saved from his malevolence by his incompetence.
Mussolini and the other profilees in The Dictator’s Playbook were all very determined individuals who were able to make long-range plans and stick to them: Trump seems madly impulsive and quite frankly lacks the concentration to stick with much of anything for very long — as witness the rapidity with which his administration’s cover stories change. Still, it’s not entirely inconceivable that Trump may not only declare the “state of emergency” but expand it to a general attack on the whole concept of democratic government and seek to do what he’s always wanted: to rule by decree (the real message he was sending in the early days of his administration, where he seemed to be governing exclusively by executive orders, presenting them in handsome leather-bound cases and signing them in huge letters with a Sharpie, which, as I joked at the time, he seems to have selected to tell America that a Sharpie was the only writing instrument big enough for his … hands). Trump also revels in the same kinds of theatricality Mussolini and Hitler did, with the big rallies, the adoring crowds and his obvious love for the trappings of power — and it hasn’t escaped me during the discussion of whether Trump will declare a “state of emergency” so he can build his border wall in spite of Congress, that Hitler similarly got the Reichstag to vote him emergency powers through the so-called “Enabling Acts” after the Reichstag fire, so he was able to circumvent and escape the limits of the Weimar constitution without having to go through the bothersome necessity of having it formally repealed. I’ve suggested not only that Trump could be America’s Mussolini, destroying democratic institutions and norms once and for all, but also that he might be America’s Boris Yeltsin, making such a mockery of “democracy” that the country rejects it and turns to an equally unscrupulous but far more capable character, an American Vladimir Putin, to replace Trump’s incompetent autocracy with a competent (though still corrupt) one the way Putin’s replaced Yeltsin’s.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)