by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2014 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night’s Lifetime movie was a lumbering production
called Deliverance Creek, heavily hyped
because it was not only based on a story written by blockbuster romance
novelist Nicholas Sparks but made by his production company (though it’s hard
to tell whether Sparks had anything to do with actually constructing the story
for this because Melissa Carter is listed as the only credited writer on
imdb.com, with Jon Amiel as director). My only previous experience with the work
of Nicholas Sparks is the film version of his novel Nights in
Rodanthe, which has actually been shown on
Lifetime several times but which I actually bought on DVD, mainly because my
hero Christopher Meloni was in it as the second lead (as the cheating husband
the heroine, played by Diane Lane, leaves, thereby making herself available for
a rebound affair with disgraced doctor Richard Gere — it doesn’t sound like
much in synopsis but it was actually pretty good within the limits of the
romance genre, and having Meloni
and Viola Davis in the supporting cast didn’t hurt either!), but on the basis
of Deliverance Creek I suspect
Sparks is a decent writer dealing with contemporary reality but is totally at
sea trying to create historical fiction. Deliverance Creek takes place in 1863, at about the midpoint of the
U.S. Civil War, and it’s centered around the efforts of Deliverance Creek,
Missouri landowner (her place is described throughout the dialogue as a “ranch”
but it looked like an ordinary farm to me) Belle Gatlin Barlowe (Lauren
Ambrose, who deserves kudos for bringing some semblance of credibility to a part whose writers
wrote her all over the moral, emotional and psychological map) to maintain her
land and keep her three kids fed, clothed, sheltered and alive in the face of
relentless pressures from both sides.
The film actually opens in Kansas, where
a band of Confederate irregulars (today they’d be called “unlawful combatants”
and they’re described later as part of the band organized by William Quantrill,
which launched the outlaw careers of Jesse and Frank James) disguised in Union
uniforms ambushes a genuine Union unit and massacres them all — except for a
man who spares his own life by telling them that a shipment of gold is about to
arrive at a bank in Deliverance Creek, Missouri to be used to pay the Union
soldiers, and if the Confederates can steal that gold they can not only fatten
their own war coffers but destabilize the Union army because the soldiers that
were expecting to get paid won’t be. The Confederates are led by Belle’s
brother Jasper Gatlin (Christopher Backus) but also include a psycho who cuts
off their informant’s ears on the spot because he didn’t hear the most
important part of the information: when the gold payroll will arrive. The bank it’s arriving at is owned by
matriarch Cordelia Crawford (Katherine Willis) and her sons Ben (Joel
Johnstone) and Jeb (Barry Tubb); Jeb is a Union commander looking for Jasper
and convinced that Belle is shielding him — which she is; he arrived wounded by
a Union bullet and she hid him out, removed the bullet herself and is letting
him and his band stay there while he recuperates — though when she receives
word a Union raiding party is about to come to her farm to search for them, she
tells the healthy ones to leave and hides Jasper in her cellar. The cellar is a
quite popular place because it’s also being used by Belle’s sister Hattie
(Caitlin Custer) to hide the members of a slave family she’s helping to escape.
One of the slaves, Moses Washington (Tishuan Scott), is an ordinary field hand
who’s later captured by the Confederates, who whip and torture him just for the
hell of it, but his wife (they weren’t officially married but they “jumped the
broomstick”) Kessie (Yaani King) is a house servant who knows how to read and
write, and also figured out how to steal the key to her master’s safe so she
could steal money and his seal, along with paper and ink she used to forge a
set of papers declaring herself free. I’ll say one thing for Sparks and Carter;
they’ve created a set of characters with believably mixed motives that don’t
neatly fall into “hero” or “villain” categories — Kessie is virtually the only
person in the story, white or Black, who’s totally sympathetic — but they’ve
also enmeshed these people in so many different story lines and plot threads
it’s difficult to figure out moment-by-moment just what this movie is supposed to be about.
Eventually the
Union raiding party shoot and kill Belle’s oldest child, her son Caleb (Judah
Lewis, who looks in his mid-teens instead of the character’s stated age of 12)
after messing up her place in what seems to be gratuitous throwing their weight
around (do they really think
they’re going to find a Confederate fugitive literally hiding in a bread box?), since they see him coming
down the stairs wearing Jasper’s spurs (a gift from Jasper earlier) and assume
he’s Jasper. This propels Belle into seeking her revenge against the Crawfords
by joining the Confederates’ plan to rob their bank — which she insists will happen
her way, by having the local
pro-Southern whores steal the Crawfords’ keys long enough for Kessie to make
impressions and then having the robbers tunnel through the nearby
saloon/whorehouse (where on the night of the robbery there’s a colossal
distraction as both Union and Confederate forces seek to use the bar — and
presumably the whores as well — and they confront each other, with the
Confederates holding forth with “Dixie” until the Union commander holds a gun
to the bar pianist’s head and forces him to play “The Battle Hymn of the
Republic” — obviously Sparks and
Carter modeled this preposterous scene on the famous “Marseillaise” sequence in
Casablanca and fell far, far
short of their model) so they can break into the bank, open the vault, steal
the money and sneak out again in the cover of darkness with no one the wiser
and no one getting killed or needing to fire a gun. Only Cordelia Crawford
catches on because at the last minute she has the vault changed from a key lock
to a combination, and just in case the robbers get in anyway (and guess who
figures it out? It’s Kassie, a.k.a. Superblack, who teaches herself
safe-cracking in the nick of time; in case you’re wondering why she’s helping
the Confederates it’s because she’s hoping that her share of the bank loot will
be enough to buy her whole family’s legal freedom) she stations Ben Crawford
with a gun behind the vault to shoot anyone who breaks in. But it’s the robbers
who get the first shot and Ben falls dead — which leaves Belle in a stew of mixed
loyalties since he’s the brother of the man who killed her son, but he’s also
the boyfriend of her sister and
he’s risked his life to help fugitive slaves escape. (I’ll say one thing for Deliverance
Creek: it’s one U.S. Civil War movie that
says unambiguously that slavery was bad.)
Deliverance Creek seems less like a self-contained movie and more like
the opening chapter of a serial — it ends pretty inconclusively, with the
Confederates getting the bank loot out of town by hiding it in wooden coffins
ostensibly containing the bodies of smallpox victims and Belle left alone on
the farm with her two remaining kids, the ex-boyfriend who was actually Caleb’s
father even though her own dad forced her to marry someone else (and who, of
course, still wants her) and a bunch of Union soldiers sniffing around her
place because she was wearing a chain with a ring through it around her neck,
and director Amiel cuts ominously from a Union soldier finding it at the scene
of the robbery (ah, a Clue!) to
Belle feeling around her neck and discovering it missing. Deliverance
Creek might actually work as a series — at
least the hour-long format of conventional episodic television would force
Sparks and whatever writers are assisting (or ghosting for) him on this project
to confine themselves to one or, at most, two storylines per episode — but as a
stand-alone TV-movie it’s a woeful failure, giving us not only way too many
plot lines to follow but nobody (aside from Kessie) to root for. It’s nice to
be reminded that the Civil War was a morally ambiguous struggle when it was
occurring and people took up arms for one side or the other for reasons that
had little to do with the legitimacy or illegitimacy of the South’s “peculiar
institution” and the “states’ rights” dogma the Southerners came up with to
justify it — and even the people who were doing the “right” thing by our
modern-day standards were often doing it for personal or financial reasons that
blow the whole image of the Civil War as a brutal struggle fought over High Moral
Principles. But one would think that artists as different as Bruce Catton and
Ken Burns (from whose Civil War
documentary the makers of Deliverance Creek copied the gimmick of having a scratchy solo violin
be their main musical instrument) had made that point already!
Sunday, September 14, 2014
Friday, September 12, 2014
The Dolly Sisters (20th Century-Fox, 1945)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2014 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The film was The Dolly Sisters, a 1945 musical extravaganza from 20th Century-Fox that ostensibly tells the story of Jenny Dolly (Betty Grable) and her sister Rosie (June Haver), Hungarian-born singer-dancers who became major international stars in the 1910’s and 1920’s. They were originally born in Hungary as Jancsika and Rozsika Deutsch and were brought to the U.S. in 1905 by their parents, Julius and Margaet Deutsch. They first started entertaining as children and, like Buster Keaton and many talented child performers in the early part of the 20th century, ran afoul of the Gerry Society, a bunch of do-gooders in New York City who campaigned against exploitation of children in entertainment. (They went so far as to file suit to declare Buster Keaton’s parents unfit to raise him and to have him taken away from them — Buster saved himself from an orphanage and his parents from jail by performing his dangerous-looking act in court and proving to the judge that as hair-raising as it looked on stage, he was a professionally trained acrobat and he was not in any real danger when he performed.) When the Dollys were adults they appeared in a stage musical called The Echo and were signed by Florenz Ziegfeld. After the end of World War I they moved to France, where they became huge stars, bought a chateau and courted so many rich men they became known as the “Million Dollar Dollies.” They also spent a lot of time gambling, usually “staked” by their wealthy admirers. By 1927 their popularity as entertainers began to fade and in 1933, torn between two wealthy admirers and out for a drive with one before deciding whether or not to marry the other, Jenny Dolly crashed her car and needed to sell a lot of her jewels to finance the plastic surgery that preserved her looks. By 1936 Jenny had had to sell the rest of her jewels to live on, and in 1941 she hanged herself in her Hollywood apartment. Rosie survived her sister by 30 years, kept out of the public eye, did volunteer work for children’s charities in Hungary in the 1960’s and died in 1971. That’s from the Wikipedia page on the Dolly Sisters and, as you might expect, it bears little relationship to the plot of the film The Dolly Sisters: the sisters themselves and Jenny’s first husband, dancer, singer and songwriter Harry Fox, make it into the movie, and so does Jenny’s gambling habit and her car accident, but screenwriters John Larkin and Marion Spitzer remodeled most of their life story to fit the Hollywood cliché mold.
In their version the Dollys (who aren’t depicted as identical twins, which they were in real life, and this being a 20th Century-Fox musical they’re blonde instead of dark-haired, though at least Betty Grable and June Haver look enough alike they’re credible as sisters on screen) are good little girls and Harry Fox (John Payne) is the love of Jenny’s life: they married, are separated by World War I (in which Harry enlists and gets stuck in Germany with the occupation force well after the war is over) and have a tearful farewell in a Paris train station in which Jenny picks her sister and her career over her husband (John Payne’s mostly workmanlike performance picks up considerable power when he gets to act this scene — after Fox decided he was over-the-hill and dropped him he decided to duplicate Dick Powell’s transition from musical star to noir actor, and while he wasn’t as successful as Powell had been in either genre he was considerably more interesting and moving as an actor in his later noirs), though of course they’re reconciled at the end when they appear together at a New York benefit that’s the first appearance of the Dolly Sisters since Jenny’s accident. In the film they’re raised not by their parents but by Uncle Latzie (S. Z. Sakall, charming and cuddly as ever), and there’s an interesting argument between him and an unbilled Sig Ruman as Ignatz Tsimmis, manager of the Little Hungary Café, where they make their debut as entertainers (and I couldn’t help recall that Sakall and Ruman both were involved in Hollywood’s version of World War II, on opposite sides — Sakall as the bartender at Rick’s in Casablanca and Ruman as the Nazi, “Concentration Camp Ehrhardt,” in To Be or Not to Be). The first half of The Dolly Sisters is a sprightly musical, with one nice production number after another — including “The Vamp,” a bizarre song from the early 1920’s (an era that had more than their fair share of them!), which they perform at a movie theatre in Elmira, New Jersey at their first professional gig — and such new songs as “I Can’t Begin to Tell You” (which Grable secretly recorded for Columbia with her then-husband Harry James — Fox production chief Darryl F. Zanuck didn’t want his stars to make records for fear audiences would buy the records instead of paying to see the movies, so she was billed on the label as “Ruth Haag,” a pseudonym formed from her and James’s middle names) and a bizarre production number called “Old-Fashioned Girl” that segues into a preposterous ode to a woman’s makeup kit, complete with chorines impersonating lipstick, powder (and the puff it’s applied with), rouge and mascara. (The “mascara” lady sings a languorous ballad that reminded me of the “Marihuana” song from Murder at the Vanities.) There’s an even odder number later on that supposedly represents the Dollys’ big show in Paris, a staging of Shelton Brooks’ song “The Darktown Strutters’ Ball” with the Dollys performing in front of a bizarre chorus line of white girls made up to look vaguely Black — it only looks like they’ve all had a particularly intense course at a tanning salon and three-strip Technicolor, which was generally kindly to real Black people, goes haywire trying to reproduce this makeup.
In the second half the film does a hard right turn towards war melodrama — no combat is shown but the scene at the train station is emotionally intense and vivid and shot in a subdued color scheme more reminiscent of a film of today than what we usually think of as “Technicolor” (though Charles noted at least three people wearing bright-red handkerchiefs and scarves and argued that Natalie Kalmus, the “consultant” who rode herd on every Technicolor movie and always wanted the colors neon-bright, was this film’s real auteur) — and then to tearjerking as Jenny Dolly laboriously recovers from her accident, before it once again becomes a light, fun musical in the closing scene. Along the way there’s an appealing mix of 1920’s and new songs — though the only old song credited is “I’m Always Chasing Rainbows,” which had been done to perfection by Judy Garland four years previously in Ziegfeld Girl. Neither Payne nor Grable come close to the riveting emotional power of Judy’s version, but then we really didn’t expect them to either, and Payne shows off a decent, unexceptional voice that’s believable from a character whose principal talents are supposed to be songwriting and dancing. The Dolly Sisters was a troublesome experience for Grable because she wasn’t used to being paired up with someone with an equally important role (she hadn’t been since she and Alice Faye made Tin Pan Alley together in 1940), but she and Haver got along — oddly, the real Dollys had frequently broken up the act and then reunited to build publicity, which would have given Larkin and Spitzer a real (and Production Code-licit) dramatic issue to build their movie around — and the movie was a huge box-office hit at a time when Grable’s Fox contract was about to expire, enabling her to renew it at a $300,000 per year salary that made her the highest-paid woman entertainer in the world (a title she took over from Bette Davis, by the way). Competently directed by Irving Cummings, and highlighted by those two huge production numbers by Seymour Felix (in which he seemed to be trying to prove he could do just as demented a spectacle as the great Berkeley), and also benefiting from all that overripe Fox Technicolor (it’s a lot of fun to watch 1940’s color movies and be brought back to a time when color movies were actually colorful!), The Dolly Sisters is silly but great fun, ably showcasing Grable and Haver.
The film was The Dolly Sisters, a 1945 musical extravaganza from 20th Century-Fox that ostensibly tells the story of Jenny Dolly (Betty Grable) and her sister Rosie (June Haver), Hungarian-born singer-dancers who became major international stars in the 1910’s and 1920’s. They were originally born in Hungary as Jancsika and Rozsika Deutsch and were brought to the U.S. in 1905 by their parents, Julius and Margaet Deutsch. They first started entertaining as children and, like Buster Keaton and many talented child performers in the early part of the 20th century, ran afoul of the Gerry Society, a bunch of do-gooders in New York City who campaigned against exploitation of children in entertainment. (They went so far as to file suit to declare Buster Keaton’s parents unfit to raise him and to have him taken away from them — Buster saved himself from an orphanage and his parents from jail by performing his dangerous-looking act in court and proving to the judge that as hair-raising as it looked on stage, he was a professionally trained acrobat and he was not in any real danger when he performed.) When the Dollys were adults they appeared in a stage musical called The Echo and were signed by Florenz Ziegfeld. After the end of World War I they moved to France, where they became huge stars, bought a chateau and courted so many rich men they became known as the “Million Dollar Dollies.” They also spent a lot of time gambling, usually “staked” by their wealthy admirers. By 1927 their popularity as entertainers began to fade and in 1933, torn between two wealthy admirers and out for a drive with one before deciding whether or not to marry the other, Jenny Dolly crashed her car and needed to sell a lot of her jewels to finance the plastic surgery that preserved her looks. By 1936 Jenny had had to sell the rest of her jewels to live on, and in 1941 she hanged herself in her Hollywood apartment. Rosie survived her sister by 30 years, kept out of the public eye, did volunteer work for children’s charities in Hungary in the 1960’s and died in 1971. That’s from the Wikipedia page on the Dolly Sisters and, as you might expect, it bears little relationship to the plot of the film The Dolly Sisters: the sisters themselves and Jenny’s first husband, dancer, singer and songwriter Harry Fox, make it into the movie, and so does Jenny’s gambling habit and her car accident, but screenwriters John Larkin and Marion Spitzer remodeled most of their life story to fit the Hollywood cliché mold.
In their version the Dollys (who aren’t depicted as identical twins, which they were in real life, and this being a 20th Century-Fox musical they’re blonde instead of dark-haired, though at least Betty Grable and June Haver look enough alike they’re credible as sisters on screen) are good little girls and Harry Fox (John Payne) is the love of Jenny’s life: they married, are separated by World War I (in which Harry enlists and gets stuck in Germany with the occupation force well after the war is over) and have a tearful farewell in a Paris train station in which Jenny picks her sister and her career over her husband (John Payne’s mostly workmanlike performance picks up considerable power when he gets to act this scene — after Fox decided he was over-the-hill and dropped him he decided to duplicate Dick Powell’s transition from musical star to noir actor, and while he wasn’t as successful as Powell had been in either genre he was considerably more interesting and moving as an actor in his later noirs), though of course they’re reconciled at the end when they appear together at a New York benefit that’s the first appearance of the Dolly Sisters since Jenny’s accident. In the film they’re raised not by their parents but by Uncle Latzie (S. Z. Sakall, charming and cuddly as ever), and there’s an interesting argument between him and an unbilled Sig Ruman as Ignatz Tsimmis, manager of the Little Hungary Café, where they make their debut as entertainers (and I couldn’t help recall that Sakall and Ruman both were involved in Hollywood’s version of World War II, on opposite sides — Sakall as the bartender at Rick’s in Casablanca and Ruman as the Nazi, “Concentration Camp Ehrhardt,” in To Be or Not to Be). The first half of The Dolly Sisters is a sprightly musical, with one nice production number after another — including “The Vamp,” a bizarre song from the early 1920’s (an era that had more than their fair share of them!), which they perform at a movie theatre in Elmira, New Jersey at their first professional gig — and such new songs as “I Can’t Begin to Tell You” (which Grable secretly recorded for Columbia with her then-husband Harry James — Fox production chief Darryl F. Zanuck didn’t want his stars to make records for fear audiences would buy the records instead of paying to see the movies, so she was billed on the label as “Ruth Haag,” a pseudonym formed from her and James’s middle names) and a bizarre production number called “Old-Fashioned Girl” that segues into a preposterous ode to a woman’s makeup kit, complete with chorines impersonating lipstick, powder (and the puff it’s applied with), rouge and mascara. (The “mascara” lady sings a languorous ballad that reminded me of the “Marihuana” song from Murder at the Vanities.) There’s an even odder number later on that supposedly represents the Dollys’ big show in Paris, a staging of Shelton Brooks’ song “The Darktown Strutters’ Ball” with the Dollys performing in front of a bizarre chorus line of white girls made up to look vaguely Black — it only looks like they’ve all had a particularly intense course at a tanning salon and three-strip Technicolor, which was generally kindly to real Black people, goes haywire trying to reproduce this makeup.
In the second half the film does a hard right turn towards war melodrama — no combat is shown but the scene at the train station is emotionally intense and vivid and shot in a subdued color scheme more reminiscent of a film of today than what we usually think of as “Technicolor” (though Charles noted at least three people wearing bright-red handkerchiefs and scarves and argued that Natalie Kalmus, the “consultant” who rode herd on every Technicolor movie and always wanted the colors neon-bright, was this film’s real auteur) — and then to tearjerking as Jenny Dolly laboriously recovers from her accident, before it once again becomes a light, fun musical in the closing scene. Along the way there’s an appealing mix of 1920’s and new songs — though the only old song credited is “I’m Always Chasing Rainbows,” which had been done to perfection by Judy Garland four years previously in Ziegfeld Girl. Neither Payne nor Grable come close to the riveting emotional power of Judy’s version, but then we really didn’t expect them to either, and Payne shows off a decent, unexceptional voice that’s believable from a character whose principal talents are supposed to be songwriting and dancing. The Dolly Sisters was a troublesome experience for Grable because she wasn’t used to being paired up with someone with an equally important role (she hadn’t been since she and Alice Faye made Tin Pan Alley together in 1940), but she and Haver got along — oddly, the real Dollys had frequently broken up the act and then reunited to build publicity, which would have given Larkin and Spitzer a real (and Production Code-licit) dramatic issue to build their movie around — and the movie was a huge box-office hit at a time when Grable’s Fox contract was about to expire, enabling her to renew it at a $300,000 per year salary that made her the highest-paid woman entertainer in the world (a title she took over from Bette Davis, by the way). Competently directed by Irving Cummings, and highlighted by those two huge production numbers by Seymour Felix (in which he seemed to be trying to prove he could do just as demented a spectacle as the great Berkeley), and also benefiting from all that overripe Fox Technicolor (it’s a lot of fun to watch 1940’s color movies and be brought back to a time when color movies were actually colorful!), The Dolly Sisters is silly but great fun, ably showcasing Grable and Haver.
Wednesday, September 10, 2014
Greenwich Village (20th Century-Fox, 1944)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2014 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
I was curious about Greenwich Village, a 1944 20th Century-Fox color musical which I had recorded off American Movie Classics back when it was still commercial-free, because Clive Hirschhorn’s book The Hollywood Musical listed Nacio Herb Brown and Leo Robin as having written a complete original score for the film (one of only two films — the other being Sam Goldwyn’s 1930 operetta film One Exciting Night — Brown worked on at any studio other than MGM) and credited them with the following songs: “I’m Down to My Last Dream,” “It Goes to Your Toes,” “Give Me a Band and a Bandana,” “Oh Brother,” “It’s Art for Art’s Sake,” “I Have to See You Privately,” “This Is Our Lucky Day,” “You Make Me So Mad,” “Never Before,” “I’ve Been Smiling in My Sleep,” “Tell Me It’s You” and “That Thing They Talk About.” As things turned out, though, “It Goes to Your Toes,” “It’s Art for Art’s Sake” and “Give Me a Band and a Bandana” were the only Brown/Robin songs used in the final cut; the rest of the score was made up of standards from the 1920’s (the film was set in 1922, though Fox’s version of the 1920’s didn’t look all that different from their version of the 1890’s in previous period musicals from the studio) like “Whispering,” “Swinging Down the Lane,” “When You Wore a Tulip” (which was actually from the “teens” rather than the ’20’s) and “Ain’t We Got Fun.”
Those weren’t the only things left on the cutting-room floor; according to Gary Carey’s biography of Judy Holliday, the Revuers — the legendary nightclub act from the real Greenwich Village, which included Holliday as well as Betty Comden and Adolph Green (as both performers and writers) — were signed for the film “to bring a note of much-needed authenticity to the film’s background.” The Revuers shot two sequences from their nightclub act and hung around “on the periphery of several other scenes,” Carey said, but they did all their work on the film for a second-unit director instead of the director of record, Walter Lang, and all of it ended up on the cutting-room floor “except for a brief scene in which Comden, as a hat-check girl, handed [Don] Ameche his fedora.” No doubt of far more concern to Fox was their difficulty in finding a female star: Alice Faye, their first choice; and Betty Grable, their second, both got pregnant; June Haver, their third, sprained an ankle during rehearsals and had to drop out; and finally they gave the part to Vivian Blaine, billed her fourth and gave her a special credit announcing that the film was “introducing Vivian Blaine in her first featured role.” (Actually her first featured role in a 20th Century-Fox film had been one year earlier, in Malcolm St. Clair’s Jitterbugs with Laurel and Hardy — just about the only Laurel and Hardy Fox film of any real quality.) As things turned out, Carmen Miranda ended up top-billed in the film even though her part, “Querida,” was clearly a second lead. Don Ameche was billed second and William Bendix third. Set in 1922, the plot cast Ameche as Kenneth Harvey, an aspiring classical composer from Kansas who comes to New York City to get his concerto published and performed by the great conductor Kavosky (Emil Rameau). Since he’s already left Kansas when the film opens, it can start in shrieking Technicolor and doesn’t have to open in black-and-white like The Wizard of Oz; the credited cinematographers are Leon Shamroy and Harry Jackson, with Natalie Kalmus and Richard Mueller as the Technicolor consultants, and the neon-bright overripeness of the colors is all too typical of what Shamroy, Fox and Technicolor all seemed to want.
I was curious about Greenwich Village, a 1944 20th Century-Fox color musical which I had recorded off American Movie Classics back when it was still commercial-free, because Clive Hirschhorn’s book The Hollywood Musical listed Nacio Herb Brown and Leo Robin as having written a complete original score for the film (one of only two films — the other being Sam Goldwyn’s 1930 operetta film One Exciting Night — Brown worked on at any studio other than MGM) and credited them with the following songs: “I’m Down to My Last Dream,” “It Goes to Your Toes,” “Give Me a Band and a Bandana,” “Oh Brother,” “It’s Art for Art’s Sake,” “I Have to See You Privately,” “This Is Our Lucky Day,” “You Make Me So Mad,” “Never Before,” “I’ve Been Smiling in My Sleep,” “Tell Me It’s You” and “That Thing They Talk About.” As things turned out, though, “It Goes to Your Toes,” “It’s Art for Art’s Sake” and “Give Me a Band and a Bandana” were the only Brown/Robin songs used in the final cut; the rest of the score was made up of standards from the 1920’s (the film was set in 1922, though Fox’s version of the 1920’s didn’t look all that different from their version of the 1890’s in previous period musicals from the studio) like “Whispering,” “Swinging Down the Lane,” “When You Wore a Tulip” (which was actually from the “teens” rather than the ’20’s) and “Ain’t We Got Fun.”
Those weren’t the only things left on the cutting-room floor; according to Gary Carey’s biography of Judy Holliday, the Revuers — the legendary nightclub act from the real Greenwich Village, which included Holliday as well as Betty Comden and Adolph Green (as both performers and writers) — were signed for the film “to bring a note of much-needed authenticity to the film’s background.” The Revuers shot two sequences from their nightclub act and hung around “on the periphery of several other scenes,” Carey said, but they did all their work on the film for a second-unit director instead of the director of record, Walter Lang, and all of it ended up on the cutting-room floor “except for a brief scene in which Comden, as a hat-check girl, handed [Don] Ameche his fedora.” No doubt of far more concern to Fox was their difficulty in finding a female star: Alice Faye, their first choice; and Betty Grable, their second, both got pregnant; June Haver, their third, sprained an ankle during rehearsals and had to drop out; and finally they gave the part to Vivian Blaine, billed her fourth and gave her a special credit announcing that the film was “introducing Vivian Blaine in her first featured role.” (Actually her first featured role in a 20th Century-Fox film had been one year earlier, in Malcolm St. Clair’s Jitterbugs with Laurel and Hardy — just about the only Laurel and Hardy Fox film of any real quality.) As things turned out, Carmen Miranda ended up top-billed in the film even though her part, “Querida,” was clearly a second lead. Don Ameche was billed second and William Bendix third. Set in 1922, the plot cast Ameche as Kenneth Harvey, an aspiring classical composer from Kansas who comes to New York City to get his concerto published and performed by the great conductor Kavosky (Emil Rameau). Since he’s already left Kansas when the film opens, it can start in shrieking Technicolor and doesn’t have to open in black-and-white like The Wizard of Oz; the credited cinematographers are Leon Shamroy and Harry Jackson, with Natalie Kalmus and Richard Mueller as the Technicolor consultants, and the neon-bright overripeness of the colors is all too typical of what Shamroy, Fox and Technicolor all seemed to want.
Anyway, Our Hero ends
up in a speakeasy called “Danny’s Den” owned by would-be theatrical producer
Danny (William Bendix), whose great star attraction (Blaine) is being scouted
by Ziegfeld but whom he’s determined to keep away from established producers
until he can raise the money to launch her in a show of his own. It’s another
one of those stories where we’re expected to believe that a hero so naïve he
can hardly find his shoes in the morning has nonetheless written a great piece
of music adaptable both for concert performance and as the basis for a show score (with lyrics written
by Blaine’s character, who dropped her poetic aspirations and went to work for
Danny as a singer to make a living). A romantic triangle naturally develops
between Ameche, Blaine and Bendix — who loves her but gallantly gives her up at
the end — and there’s a bizarre subplot in which a once-talented but now
burned-out violinist (Felix Bressart) embezzles $3,500 from Ameche, ostensibly for
a bond to ensure the musicians who perform the concerto will get paid, only to
be confronted by Bendix’s gangster-like bodyguards and forced to give the money
back. Miranda, though hardly on screen long enough to qualify for top billing,
nonetheless dominates the scenes she is in and proves the most entertaining performer in the film (especially
when she gets to sing a lot of “Give Me a Band and a Bandana,” as well as a bit
of “I’m Just Wild About Harry,” in her native Portuguese — Brazilian music and
the samba band Miranda insisted appear in all of her films seem particularly
incongruous in a movie set in 1922, but they’re well worth seeing anyway); also
of note is a great costume-ball sequence at Webster Hall in which a Black dance
group called the Four Step Brothers do a great routine that momentarily brings
the film to life. Aside from that, Greenwich Village is reasonably entertaining but no more, evidence
that the Fox formula of building elaborate musicals around parts of New York City (previous entries had included Tin
Pan Alley, Wabash Avenue and Coney
Island) was running out of steam — and
aside from a few nice gags about artistic pretension (the best is one in which
Bendix, confused by a painting he’s ordered that from some angles looks like
Picasso and from others like Duchamp, keeps rotating it on his wall until he
finally hangs it in a direction that pleases him — whereas two pretentious
customers at his speakeasy pass it and declare it a masterpiece, leaving a
befuddled Bendix to wonder about what makes it so special) the story could have
been set just about anywhere and one misses the real empathy and realistic
sense of an artists’ colony Vincente Minnelli, Alan Jay Lerner and Gene Kelly
brought to An American in Paris
seven years later! — 12/14/02
•••••
For our movie last night Charles and I watched Greenwich
Village, an item from the five-DVD box of
Carmen Miranda I’d just got at Costco — and it’s startling to look her up on
imdb.com and realize her film career was so short (six movies in Brazil before
she came to the U.S., 10 during her years under contract to 20th
Century-Fox between 1940 and 1946, and just four more between her release from
Fox and her death in 1955). The box focused on the second half of her Fox
career, starting with her fifth film for them — the dazzling Busby Berkeley
masterpiece The Gang’s All Here —
and cycling through the rest of her output for the studio (omitting Four
Jills in a Jeep, a semi-documentary about
the USO shows during World War II in which Miranda played herself). Greenwich
Village was a troubled production,
originally planned as a vehicle for The Gang’s All Here star Alice Faye — who got pregnant with her second
child just before it was scheduled to go before the cameras — and after an
attempt to get Betty Grable to do it also fell through, Darryl Zanuck and the
film’s line producer, William LeBaron, decided to make Miranda’s second-lead
role the top-billed one and cast then little-known Vivian Blaine as the
ingénue. What came out of this, directed by 20th Century-Fox
reliable Walter Lang from a script by the usual committee (Frederick Hazlitt
Brennan, “original” story; Michael Fessier and Ernest Pagano, “adaptation”;
Earl Baldwin and Walter Bullock, script), was a follow-up to the sequence of
Fox musicals built around parts of New York City that were, or could be,
associated with music — Tin Pan Alley, Coney Island, Wabash Avenue — and also a rehash of a set of clichés most
blatantly used before in Naughty but Nice (1939, starring Dick Powell in his last film as a Warner Bros.
contractee) and Swing Fever
(1943, with Kay Kyser in one of his unlikeliest roles): Midwestern hayseed
comes to New York City with the manuscript of a potentially great classical
work under his arm, tries unsuccessfully to get it published come
scritto, but ultimately ends up involved
with a group of Broadway producers who take the themes of his
concerto/rhapsody/sinfonietta/whatever, turn them into show tunes and use them
as the basis of a hit stage musical.
This time the hayseed composer is called
“Kenneth Harvey” and is played by Don Ameche, also on the downgrade at the
time, and in the year 1922 he comes to New York and ends up getting off the
tour bus at Greenwich Village (incidentally the driver announces a list of
legendary talents who got their start in the Village — including George
Gershwin, whose own career was just beginning in 1922) and arriving in Danny’s
Den, a speakeasy owned by Danny O’Mara (William Bendix — having just seen him
in his marvelous performance as the crazy war veteran in The Blue
Dahlia I couldn’t help but reflect, “Carmen
Miranda and Raymond Chandler — one degree of separation!”), who’s trying to
produce a Broadway show starring his girlfriend Bonnie Watson (Vivian Blaine,
fresh from her appearance opposite Laurel and Hardy in Jitterbugs, their only truly good film for 20th
Century-Fox, and being given a big push and a special “Introducing” credit)
while at the same time keeping Florenz Ziegfeld’s talent scout away from his
club for fear Ziegfeld might sign her for the Follies. Kenneth instantly falls in love with Bonnie
himself, and in a marvelous piece of Chaplin-esque pantomime surprising from an
actor as usually stiff as Ameche, he passes out in her bedroom after a drunken
“surprise” party in her apartment (she lives in a room upstairs from Danny’s
speakeasy) and ends up falling into bed with her — completely decorously, this
being a Production Code full-enforcement era movie — and then falls out of bed
again, coming to on the floor. Kenneth is intent on placing his concerto —
whose main theme, oddly, is the well-known 1920 song “Whispering” by John and
Malvin Schonberger which was Paul Whiteman’s star-making recording hit — with
the legendary conductor Kavosky (Emil Rameau), who lives in a huge house with a
stone block with his name on it in front (which led Charles to joke that by
putting up his tombstone that early he’d taken “pre-need buying” to an
extreme). Kavosky, not surprisingly, is based on Leopold Stokowski — like the
real Stokowski, the fictitious Kavosky conducts without a baton and shows off
the beauty of his arms to impress his audience — and, like the real Stokowski in Deanna Durbin’s great vehicle One
Hundred Men and a Girl, Kavosky is
imperious and virtually impossible for an aspiring musician to see. So Hofer
(Felix Bressart), a former violinist in Kavosky’s orchestra who’s reduced to
being a hanger-on at Danny’s Den, offers to help Kenneth get to see Kavosky and
get his music orchestrated — only he’s really after scamming Kenneth out of the $3,500 in savings
Kenneth brought to New York to live on while he got his concerto placed. (Kudos
to the writers for breaking with cliché enough that they did not make Kenneth direly poor from the beginning — and
also for having it be the “classical” entrepreneur, not the apparently sleazy
Bendix from the Greenwich Village night world, who scams him out of his
bankroll.)
Of course, Kenneth thinks that everyone in O’Mara’s organization — O’Mara himself, Bonnie
and Querida (Carmen Miranda, essentially a comic-relief role more or less blown
up to justify her top billing) — was in on Hofer’s fraud, and it isn’t until
O’Mara’s review, the Greenwich Village Gaieties (a title clearly ripped off from the 1925 show The
Garrick Gaieties, which began the superstar
careers of song composer Richard Rodgers and lyricist Lorenz Hart), opens and
features Kavosky himself on stage conducting a portion of Kenneth’s concerto —
which includes three piano
soloists instead of just one (no wonder he had such trouble interesting a music
publisher in it!) — following which Bonnie comes on and interprets the main
melody as “Whispering,” the pop song it was originally written as in real life
(and as which it works considerably better). Greenwich Village is one of those frustrating movies that’s good as it
stands but could have been a lot greater; for someone who’s supposed to be the
star — at least if the billing order is to be believed — Carmen Miranda isn’t
given much to do, just a few malapropistic comedy scenes, a running gag in
which both her last name and her (claimed) country of origin change according
to her agenda at the moment, and some songs. One of them is a rendition of “I’m
Just Wild about Harry” with some nonsense patter-scat breaks that sound like
what Gilbert and Sullivan would have if they’d been Brazilian. One is “I Like
to Be Loved by You,” a Harry Warren song that, according to imdb.com, is
actually an outtake left over from the 1942 film Springtime in the
Rockies and spliced in here. Miranda’s big
number at the end is “Give Me a Band and a Bandana,” a lavish production that
features a nice chorus in Portuguese (Miranda had it in her contract that she’d
get to sing in Portuguese in at least one song per film) and a lot of
choristers milling about pretty aimlessly while she and her hotshot samba band
(another star perk of Miranda’s; she’d brought them from Brazil with her and
insisted they be used in every one of her films — and they occasionally made
appearances in films that didn’t
include Carmen Miranda, like Sam Goldwyn’s quirky 1948 musical A Song
Is Born) hold forth. This was obviously
meant to be the follow-up to the big “Lady in the Tutti-Frutti Hat” number from
The Gang’s All Here but fell well short of its model, mainly because this time the
choreography was by nice, reliable Seymour Felix instead of the demented genius
Busby Berkeley.
It also doesn’t help that there’s surprisingly little of the
raunchy Greenwich Village atmosphere; it’s true the writers and director Lang
were hamstrung by the Production Code, which prevented them from showing a lot of the things the real-life Village is famous for
(like its Queer community), but they tried to cram in whatever they could into
a big number called “It’s All for Art’s Sake” that mildly spoofs the
pretensions of artists’ colonies in general and anticipates the “Black and
White Ball” scene that precedes the big ballet in An American in
Paris seven years later; it’s a good number
but, like the film itself, nowhere near as much fun as it could have been. One major missed opportunity was the Revuers, the legendary
comedy troupe — Judy Holliday, Betty Comden, Adolph Green and Alvin Hammer —
who were hired for the film, shot at least two of their major comedy routines
for it (including a spoof of the Shubert Brothers’ operetta productions and
something called “The Baroness Bazooka”) and are actually listed in the credits
— but none of their routines were used and the troupe ended up almost
exclusively on the cutting-room floor. “[I]n the release print of the film …
the Revuers had vanished except for a brief scene in which Comden, as a
hat-check girl, hands [Don] Ameche his fedora,” Holliday biographer Gary Carey
wrote (though I thought I saw the same woman who handed Ameche his hat briefly
dancing down the “Village” street of the Fox back lot in a sequence shortly
after that). Nor are we ever told why the interior of Danny’s Den is made to
look like a pirate ship, yet another aspect of this movie of which all too
little is made. Miranda and Bendix dominate the cast; Ameche is dull as usual
except for that spectacular pantomime scene; and Vivian Blaine is charming,
personable and sings with a nice voice, though just as Patricia Morison was
wasted in Hollywood as a villainess in the 1940’s and found her true métier as co-star of the 1948 classic Broadway musical Kiss
Me, Kate, so Vivian Blaine found hers when
she left Hollywood and played a superb comic role in the 1950 Broadway musical
classic Guys and Dolls, including
a raucous vocal style far different and more distinctive than her nice but
rather bland singing here. — 9/10/14
Tuesday, September 9, 2014
Alan Young Show (CBS-TV, April 18, 1950)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2014 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The show was a half-hour April 18, 1950 episode of The Alan Young Show, an odd little offering from CBS that lasted two years (1950-1951) and seemed to follow the same format every time: an opening monologue (Charles has noted that the format of TV variety shows seems to have hardened into orthodoxy in the earliest years — including a comedian/host who delivered an opening monologue), a dance number, a featured singer (at least in all the surviving episodes the featured singer always seems to have been a woman) and a couple of comedy sketches. Young was a British-born comedian (“Young” was the last name on his birth certificate but the original first name was “Angus”!) but he comes off here as a cross between Danny Kaye and Jerry Lewis, and it’s not too surprising that the writers, David R. Schwartz and Leo Solomon, were Jewish. The monologue made fun of TV stars using various cheats to avoid having to memorize lines — Young has his speech written on various parts of his shirt and nearly has to undress on camera to read them all (and the punch line, when he finally finds it on his shirttail, hardly seems worth it) — and the sketches were about a reading of a will that’s sabotaged by a leaking cylinder of nitrous oxide, better known as “laughing gas,” which causes the would-be heirs to crack up hysterically over being disinherited; and another in which Young is a nebbish seeking to date the young daughter of a middle-aged married couple. What made this interesting is that her father was played by William Frawley a year before he debuted on I Love Lucy, and as jarring as it is to see him with someone other than Vivian Vance playing his wife, it’s a lot of fun and he’s as lovably acerbic as ever.
Charles and I had downloaded this after another archive.org download, a May 22, 1955 episode of a show called Masquerade Party, had piqued our curiosity about singer Monica Lewis, who was one of the contestants on that — the show featured celebrities in really thick disguises (including one segment in which Black boxer Archie Moore was made to look white) and a panel that had to guess who they really were. We’d already seen Monica Lewis in the 1952 film The Strip (starring Mickey Rooney as a wanna-be jazz drummer who gets to sit in with Louis Armstrong’s All-Stars, featuring Barney Bigard, Jack Teagarden and Earl “Fatha” Hines — almost certainly the greatest band Armstrong ever had and the real reason I wanted to see that film) doing a faux-Latin number, and here Lewis performed a version of “Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea” which was quite nicely sung (though there were plenty of other singers around in 1950 who could have done it better) but undone by a bad, overly gimmicky arrangement by music director Lud Gluskin or whoever was doing his vocal charts: it starts out as a rhumba, slows down and then speeds up again. Still, Lewis was attractive, personable and had a nice voice, and one could see why she became at least something of a star — and probably would have had more of a career if she’d been about a decade older before the rock ’n’ roll revolution would severely weaken, though not completely destroy, the popular appeal of her kind of music. Young himself was best known from the Mister Ed TV series of the early 1960’s, in which he was the human interlocutor of the talking horse (originally called “Francis” in the film series from the 1950’s and voiced on both film and TV by Chill Wills) but had a rather interesting career even though he wasn’t a distinctive enough performer to make it as a major star.
The show was a half-hour April 18, 1950 episode of The Alan Young Show, an odd little offering from CBS that lasted two years (1950-1951) and seemed to follow the same format every time: an opening monologue (Charles has noted that the format of TV variety shows seems to have hardened into orthodoxy in the earliest years — including a comedian/host who delivered an opening monologue), a dance number, a featured singer (at least in all the surviving episodes the featured singer always seems to have been a woman) and a couple of comedy sketches. Young was a British-born comedian (“Young” was the last name on his birth certificate but the original first name was “Angus”!) but he comes off here as a cross between Danny Kaye and Jerry Lewis, and it’s not too surprising that the writers, David R. Schwartz and Leo Solomon, were Jewish. The monologue made fun of TV stars using various cheats to avoid having to memorize lines — Young has his speech written on various parts of his shirt and nearly has to undress on camera to read them all (and the punch line, when he finally finds it on his shirttail, hardly seems worth it) — and the sketches were about a reading of a will that’s sabotaged by a leaking cylinder of nitrous oxide, better known as “laughing gas,” which causes the would-be heirs to crack up hysterically over being disinherited; and another in which Young is a nebbish seeking to date the young daughter of a middle-aged married couple. What made this interesting is that her father was played by William Frawley a year before he debuted on I Love Lucy, and as jarring as it is to see him with someone other than Vivian Vance playing his wife, it’s a lot of fun and he’s as lovably acerbic as ever.
Charles and I had downloaded this after another archive.org download, a May 22, 1955 episode of a show called Masquerade Party, had piqued our curiosity about singer Monica Lewis, who was one of the contestants on that — the show featured celebrities in really thick disguises (including one segment in which Black boxer Archie Moore was made to look white) and a panel that had to guess who they really were. We’d already seen Monica Lewis in the 1952 film The Strip (starring Mickey Rooney as a wanna-be jazz drummer who gets to sit in with Louis Armstrong’s All-Stars, featuring Barney Bigard, Jack Teagarden and Earl “Fatha” Hines — almost certainly the greatest band Armstrong ever had and the real reason I wanted to see that film) doing a faux-Latin number, and here Lewis performed a version of “Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea” which was quite nicely sung (though there were plenty of other singers around in 1950 who could have done it better) but undone by a bad, overly gimmicky arrangement by music director Lud Gluskin or whoever was doing his vocal charts: it starts out as a rhumba, slows down and then speeds up again. Still, Lewis was attractive, personable and had a nice voice, and one could see why she became at least something of a star — and probably would have had more of a career if she’d been about a decade older before the rock ’n’ roll revolution would severely weaken, though not completely destroy, the popular appeal of her kind of music. Young himself was best known from the Mister Ed TV series of the early 1960’s, in which he was the human interlocutor of the talking horse (originally called “Francis” in the film series from the 1950’s and voiced on both film and TV by Chill Wills) but had a rather interesting career even though he wasn’t a distinctive enough performer to make it as a major star.
Sunday, September 7, 2014
The Brittany Murphy Story (LeGrand Productions, Marvista Entertainment, Lifetime, 2014)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2014 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Yesterday night I watched the “world premiere” of a Lifetime TV movie called The Brittany Murphy Story, more or less based on the life of actress Brittany Murphy (1977-2009) — predictably, its accuracy has been challenged on various online fora — who got her start at age 13 doing commercials while she (Amanda Fuller) and her mom Sharon (Sherilyn Fenn) were living in Edison, New Jersey. She pressured mom to relocate to Los Angeles so she could crack Hollywood and worked up the 1990’s version of the ladder to stardom, starting with guest roles in TV sitcoms (her non-commercial debut was in an episode of Murphy Brown and, predictably, she regarded the title of the show as a good omen) up to semi-regular parts on long-forgotten shows like Drexell’s Class, Almost Home and Sister, Sister. Then she cracked the big screen in a supporting role in the film Clueless, followed by Girl, Interrupted and 8 Mile — but none of these were vehicles for her, and instead they propelled their featured performers (Alicia Silverstone, Angelina Jolie and Eminem, respectively) to stardom. Unwilling to relegate herself to playing the heroine’s perky brunette sidekick, she dyed her hair blonde, lost weight and cultivated a “sexy” image — only to spark rumors that she was doing drugs (as Murphy’s stand-in, interviewed in the Behind the Headlines “documentary” Lifetime showed right after the movie, noted, every time a young woman in Hollywood suddenly loses weight everyone in the business assumes she’s either doing drugs or is anorexic) — which snowballed when a so-called “blind item” on a Hollywood Web site (a “blind item” actually dates back to Walter Winchell and his rivals in the 1930’s — it’s the sort of thing that asks, “What Hollywood star just … ” and, by not naming a specific person, not only avoids the risk of a libel suit but keeps the industry’s people guessing as to who it is) called her the “Jordache Junkie,” saying that some woman had not only been doing drugs at a party honoring the Jordache jeans label (a blessedly forgotten 1980’s and early 1990’s phenomenon that provoked the unforgettable retort from comedienne Elayne Boozler: “Why would you pay all that money just to have some French guy’s name on your ass?”) but had had a quickie sexual encounter with a “cater waiter” inside the stairwell of the building. The item was actually about a newly hired Jordache model, but since Murphy had just been hired to do a series of ads for Jordache much of Hollywood thought it was about her — and though the original site on which it was published eventually retracted it and said it wasn’t about Murphy, the damage was done. The film touches on the highlights and lowlights of Brittany Murphy’s career, including her brief romance with actor Ashton Kutcher (ironically, the producers got an actor to play Kutcher, Adam Hagenbuch, whom I thought was even hotter than the real one!) — it was really a rebound from the failure of Kutcher’s controversial marriage to Demi Moore (who was a generation older than he — when Kutcher’s first feature film, The Butterfly Effect, was released, it failed at the box office, partly due to an ill-advised tacked-on ending that turned it silly but also because critics seemed more interested in reviewing Kutcher’s marriage than his movie!) and a result of the fact that the film they’d made together, Just Married, cast them as newlyweds.
Yesterday night I watched the “world premiere” of a Lifetime TV movie called The Brittany Murphy Story, more or less based on the life of actress Brittany Murphy (1977-2009) — predictably, its accuracy has been challenged on various online fora — who got her start at age 13 doing commercials while she (Amanda Fuller) and her mom Sharon (Sherilyn Fenn) were living in Edison, New Jersey. She pressured mom to relocate to Los Angeles so she could crack Hollywood and worked up the 1990’s version of the ladder to stardom, starting with guest roles in TV sitcoms (her non-commercial debut was in an episode of Murphy Brown and, predictably, she regarded the title of the show as a good omen) up to semi-regular parts on long-forgotten shows like Drexell’s Class, Almost Home and Sister, Sister. Then she cracked the big screen in a supporting role in the film Clueless, followed by Girl, Interrupted and 8 Mile — but none of these were vehicles for her, and instead they propelled their featured performers (Alicia Silverstone, Angelina Jolie and Eminem, respectively) to stardom. Unwilling to relegate herself to playing the heroine’s perky brunette sidekick, she dyed her hair blonde, lost weight and cultivated a “sexy” image — only to spark rumors that she was doing drugs (as Murphy’s stand-in, interviewed in the Behind the Headlines “documentary” Lifetime showed right after the movie, noted, every time a young woman in Hollywood suddenly loses weight everyone in the business assumes she’s either doing drugs or is anorexic) — which snowballed when a so-called “blind item” on a Hollywood Web site (a “blind item” actually dates back to Walter Winchell and his rivals in the 1930’s — it’s the sort of thing that asks, “What Hollywood star just … ” and, by not naming a specific person, not only avoids the risk of a libel suit but keeps the industry’s people guessing as to who it is) called her the “Jordache Junkie,” saying that some woman had not only been doing drugs at a party honoring the Jordache jeans label (a blessedly forgotten 1980’s and early 1990’s phenomenon that provoked the unforgettable retort from comedienne Elayne Boozler: “Why would you pay all that money just to have some French guy’s name on your ass?”) but had had a quickie sexual encounter with a “cater waiter” inside the stairwell of the building. The item was actually about a newly hired Jordache model, but since Murphy had just been hired to do a series of ads for Jordache much of Hollywood thought it was about her — and though the original site on which it was published eventually retracted it and said it wasn’t about Murphy, the damage was done. The film touches on the highlights and lowlights of Brittany Murphy’s career, including her brief romance with actor Ashton Kutcher (ironically, the producers got an actor to play Kutcher, Adam Hagenbuch, whom I thought was even hotter than the real one!) — it was really a rebound from the failure of Kutcher’s controversial marriage to Demi Moore (who was a generation older than he — when Kutcher’s first feature film, The Butterfly Effect, was released, it failed at the box office, partly due to an ill-advised tacked-on ending that turned it silly but also because critics seemed more interested in reviewing Kutcher’s marriage than his movie!) and a result of the fact that the film they’d made together, Just Married, cast them as newlyweds.
According to this
film, though, Murphy and Kutcher broke up because he wanted to be a Hollywood
party boy and she was more studious and wanted to stay home more and develop
her craft — though the next scenes in the script by Peter Hunziker and Cynthia
Riddle show Murphy becoming more irresponsible and diva-ish by the day, as she
gets fired by her agents over the “Jordache Junkie” rumor, spirals down into
lesser parts in more forgettable genre movies, and ultimately hooks up with a British photographer turned
screenwriter turned wanna-be “producer” named Simon Monjack (Eric Petersen, who
not surprisingly has a bearish charm — the real Simon Monjack was a fat schlub and an odd companion for a still strikingly
beautiful woman) who promises to help her rebuild her career. Only she gets
warned against him by a woman who comes up to her while she and her mom are
dining in a restaurant and tells Brittany her fiancé owes $500,000 in unpaid
legal settlements, is being investigated by Immigration and Customs Enforcement
(ICE) for being in the U.S. illegally on an expired visa, and has bilked so
many people out of so much money he really should be called “Simon Conjack.” But Brittany Murphy remembers Simon
Monjack as a photographer who was kind to her in the early days, when she did
her first red-carpet walk at the premiere of Clueless — back when the paparazzi and the gossip-mongers from the tabloids were still
on her side instead of smelling blood in the water as her career unravels (for
reasons Hunziker, Riddle and director Joe Menendez don’t really make that
clear) and she’s reduced to making a cheap movie in Puerto Rico from which
she’s almost immediately fired after she shows up for work in a drug-soaked
haze, can’t remember her lines and insists on “mandatory breaks.” At least
that’s the version in the TV-movie; the one in the documentary is considerably
more ambiguous and comments on the lack of sanitation on the location (as in no running water or flush toilets) and the overall
horrible conditions that led Murphy either to walk or get let go after the
first day. (Both the movie and the documentary carefully leave this production
unnamed, but the Wikipedia page on Brittany Murphy said it was called The
Caller and was completed with Rachelle
Lefevre in the role originally intended for Murphy, though the film wasn’t
released until February 22, 2011 — over a year after Murphy’s death — and
judging from the imdb.com synopsis it sounds like it could be a pretty good, if
derivative, movie: “Troubled divorcee Mary Kee is tormented by a series of
sinister phone calls from a mysterious woman. When the stranger reveals she's
calling from the past, Mary tries to break off contact … .”)
The film leaps
around — it’s actually told in strict chronology but there are a lot of jumps
forward in the continuity — to Brittany Murphy’s still-mysterious death on
December 20, 2009, when she collapsed in the bathroom of the Hollywood mansion
(originally built by Madonna, sold by her to Justin Timberlake and Britney
Spears, then sold by them to
Brittany Murphy and her entourage) she shared with her husband and her mom and
was ultimately pronounced dead. An autopsy by the L.A. County Coroner’s office
determined that the causes of death were pneumonia, anemia and multiple drug
intoxication — Murphy had always denied that she used cocaine or any other
“drugs,” but she seems to have had the same rationalization as Elvis and a lot
of Hollywood’s other prescription drug abusers, that as long as it came in an
amber bottle with a doctor’s name on it it wasn’t a “drug” and therefore it
didn’t “count.” Murphy had a heart murmur she’d been diagnosed with as a
teenager, she was quite possibly bipolar (at least she’s depicted as such in
the movie — the “B”-word isn’t used but shortly before her death there’s a
scene in which she’s shown giddy with excitement and shame-facedly admits to
Simon that she’s gone off her meds), and in the scenes showing them together
she and Simon are enthusiastically trading each other their prescription drugs
heedless of the possible bad effects of taking someone else’s meds. The documentary claims that at the time of
her death Murphy and her husband were both under investigation for
“doctor-shopping” — i.e., visiting more than one physician in order to get
larger amounts of abusable prescription drugs than one could legally get from
just one doctor. What made Murphy’s death even more bizarre — and probably
plucked this story out from the huge pile of tales of people who couldn’t
handle stardom and its discontents (particularly the constant pressure to stay at the top and avoid that one wrong decision that
could kill your career stone-dead — as Hollywood insiders have told wanna-bes
and established stars alike for decades, “You’re only as good as your last
picture”) — was that just five months after Murphy died, Simon Monjack died in
the same house from similar causes (his autopsy also listed pneumonia and
anemia as causes of death), sending the conspiracy-mongers into overdrive.
Brittany Murphy’s father, Angelo Joseph Bertolotti — who had broken up with her
mom when she was 2 and had had so little interaction with her during her life
he isn’t even a character in the TV-movie — came slamming back onto the scene,
somehow obtained hair samples and had them analyzed, and claimed on the basis
of that analysis that she had been poisoned. More recently he’s claimed that
Brittany’s mom did it — an article on the In Touch Weekly Web site purported to be an interview of him by Diana
Cooper in which he made that claim, but at the moment the story is literally lined out on the In Touch Weekly site, though the comments section survives. That’s
one of those head-scratchers because, aside from the fact that no one who knew
Brittany and her mom saw the relationship as anything other than mutually
supportive (indeed, having your mom continue to live with you even after you
get married sounds, if anything, hopelessly co-dependent to me!), what on earth
would Sharon Murphy’s motive have
been for knocking off her daughter and son-in-law? Brittany, even with her
career in tatters, was clearly worth a lot more to her alive than dead! She wasn’t Elvis, Marilyn Monroe or Michael Jackson (all stars
who also died from pharmaceutical drug abuse); she hadn’t created the kind of
body of work that was going to generate a lucrative posthumous career, and as
one of the interviewees on the Behind the Headlines show noted, Brittany Murphy is going to be
remembered, if at all, only for
her untimely demise and not for her actual work. I did a search for her on my
movie blog and noted I had only two entries for films she was in — Spun, a quite good anti-drug movie from 2002 but which
cast her only as the girlfriend of “The Cook” (Mickey Rourke), who makes crystal
meth for virtually the entire rest of the cast; and Abandoned (2010), her next-to-last film, in which like a lot
of other movies these days (including the posthumous releases of Philip Seymour
Hoffman and Robin Williams) the deceased star had finished his or her part
while still alive but the ever-lengthening period of post-production
(especially given the extensive use of computer-generated imagery these days,
which creates splendid effects but also takes a very long time) meant the films could not be released
until after the stars died. I quite liked Abandoned and it’s evidence that, however extensive Brittany
Murphy’s talents were, they had held up to the end — it’s a damsel-in-distress
thriller in which her character is caught up in an elaborate plot to embezzle
money from the bank where she works as an executive; I wrote, “[W]hile it’s
grimly ironic, to say the least, that the central character who evades a
life-threatening situation is being played by an actress who didn’t live long
enough to see the film completed and in release … Brittany Murphy turns in an
excellent performance and she’s well matched by Dean Cain (who’s considerably
hotter than most of the guys Lifetime itself casts in these roles) and
especially by Jay Pickett (as the cop who unravels the plot and catches the
baddies) … and Tim Thomerson (as the mastermind of the plot).”
All in all, The
Brittany Murphy Story is a typical piece of
Hollywood exploitation which presses her story — whatever it was — into the
usual mold (in more ways than one since one of the more bizarre explanations
for her and her husband’s deaths was that their house was supposedly infested
with toxic mold — I’m not making this up, you know!): young girl with talent
and ambition to burn comes to the big, bad movie capital, gets caught up in the
superstar lifestyle and ultimately drinks, drugs, parties, screws or all of the
above herself to death. Of course, with all the theories being thrown around as
to why both Brittany Murphy and Simon Monjack died in the same house within
five months of each other, I couldn’t help but come up with one myself based on
a hint from the Behind the Headlines
documentary from someone who knew them and noted that the health of both these
chronically ill people (she’d been diagnosed with a heart murmur and he’d
already had two minor heart attacks when they got together) took a major
nosedive once they returned from that abortive Puerto Rican trip to make The
Caller; what if both of them caught a
parasitic infection there that went either undiagnosed (one part of the story
that rings true was Brittany’s intense fear of seeking medical attention for anything, lest the paparazzi and tabloid columnists get hold of it, start
printing deathly-looking photos of her and accompanying text suggesting she was
going to croak any moment, and deal the final blow to what was left of her
career) or misdiagnosed until they both died, and maybe even afterwards?
Saturday, September 6, 2014
Pavarotti: A Voice for the Ages (PBS, 2014)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2014 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
I kept the TV on KPBS to watch Pavarotti: A Voice for the Ages, thinking it would be the quite interesting documentary on the late superstar tenor Luciano Pavarotti recently reviewed in Fanfare magazine, a “warts and all” portrait that featured his former manager Hubert Breslin — who had helped build Pavarotti as an attraction and raised him out of the ghetto of opera stardom into full-fledged mass-market celebrity-hood, only to have a bitter falling-out with him. Alas, what this show turned out to be was a hagiographical presentation of clips from Pavarotti’s previous PBS appearances, complete with a few archival interview clips from Pavarotti himself — including a surprisingly revealing comment that he loved appearing on TV because it’s a close-up medium and therefore he didn’t have to act with his body (which, given his sheer bulk, was always a challenge and became increasingly difficult for him as, like Orson Welles, he became even more bloated in his later years than he’d started out) but could communicate character with his face. The show gave an interesting if rather incomplete portrait of Pavarotti the artist, including several depictions of a real-life singer-conductor couple who helped him and frequently appeared with him in the early years — soprano Mirella Freni and her husband, conductor Leone Magiera (an early Italian TV clip of Puccini’s La Bohème with them nearly a decade before they recorded it together with Herbert von Karajan and the Vienna Philharmonic is fascinating — especially for Pavarotti’s attractiveness; he was certainly big but not as huge as he got later, and though hefty he wasn’t so large he wasn’t believable as a starving poet in a Parisian garret) — but it surprisingly doesn’t mention a far more prominent soprano-conductor couple who helped him even more, including getting him his recording contract with British Decca (then known as London Records in the U.S.): Joan Sutherland and Richard Bonynge.
But then the producers of this show seemed to be going out of their way to minimize Pavarotti the bel-cantist; though his repertory reached at least as far back in operatic history as Mozart’s Idomeneo (revived by the Met in the 1990’s especially for him) and much of his early prominence came from recording scores like Donizetti’s Lucia di Lammermoor and La Fille du Regiment and Bellini’s La Sonnambula and I Puritani with Sutherland and Bonynge (indeed, it was his performance of the notoriously difficult aria “Pour mon âme” from Fille du Regiment, with nine, count ’em, nine high C’s, that earned Pavarotti his early nickname “King of the High C’s”), all the opera excerpts in this show were familiar “chestnuts” by Verdi or Puccini. There was a well-sung “Celeste Aïda” from a Met gala tribute to conductor James Levine (alas, shorn of the opening recitative); Pavarotti rather tastelessly boomed out the final high note fortissimo instead of singing it softly as Verdi asked for, but as with such other uncalled-for “Verdi” high notes as the high C at the end of “Di quella pira” in Il Trovatore and the E-flat in alt at the end of “Sempre libera” in La Traviata, just about everybody sings it this way now. (Caruso sang the high note softly in his first recording of “Celeste Aïda” in 1902, left the entire phrase out of his second recording — the 78 rpm master ran out of room — but thereafter sang it loud.) The show was divided into three parts — each separated by the interminable, pleading “pledge breaks” inflicted on PBS viewers by an increasingly financially desperate network (one Republican Congressmember in the 1980’s said he found the “pledge breaks” more offensive than out-and-out commercials, and though he was using this as an excuse to vote to end all federal funding for PBS I could still see his point) — the first showing Pavarotti the opera singer, the second his collaborations with pop stars — including U2, Eric Clapton and Sting — and the third dealing with the whole “Three Tenors” phenomenon, in which the people considered the most important living tenors in the world, Pavarotti, Plácido Domingo and José Carreras, grouped together for mega-concerts. The original Three Tenors concert took place in Rome in 1990 and was planned in connection with the final match of the World Cup soccer (or, as the rest of the world outside the U.S. and U.K. terms it, “football”) tournament, and the second one took place in L.A. in 1994, also just before that year’s World Cup final.
It’s indicative of what a phenomenon this became and how it leapfrogged out of the classical-music ghetto that the album of the 1990 concert came out on British Decca/U.S. London and had a respectable classical-style cover (it didn’t use the “Three Tenors” sobriquet and was simply billed as “Carreras-Domingo-Pavarotti in Concert”), while the album and video of the 1994 concert came out on Atlantic and featured a swooping animated logo in which the numeral “3” came dancing out of the sky before it settled down in front of the screen along with the words “The” and “Tenors.” The Three Tenors concerts featured both classical and popular music, and alas the pop selections were pretty ghastly, including a version of the Neapolitan song “O sole mio” used as an excuse for the tenors (especially Pavarotti) to ham it up, and the awful song “My Way,” which began as a French song about a long-term married couple now bored by each other, got changed into the bizarre peroration we know by Paul Anka (who was hired by the song’s publisher to supply an English lyric — an original, not a translation of the original French) and recorded by Frank Sinatra, a horrifyingly bad record because it hooked the egomania that was by far the least attractive part of Sinatra’s public persona. In the Three Tenors’ performances “My Way” has you asking, “What are three guys with nice voices like yours doing with a song like this?” I’m not saying it’s a bad move for opera singers to record pop material, but not when the pop material is so far removed from opera that they haven’t a clue what to do with it; Caruso was able to do material like George M. Cohan’s “Over There” and make it work, but the influence of African-American music on popular music worldwide — manifested in the successive eras of ragtime, jazz, swing, rock and rap — has carried pop music ever farther from opera and made it more difficult for opera singers to find lighter material that can work for them. This is probably why so many opera singers, tenors in particular, fall back on the so-called “Neapolitan Song” genre, of which “O sole mio” (the only song recorded by both of RCA Victor’s two most legendary artists, Enrico Caruso and Elvis Presley) is the most famous example — these songs can be beautiful if they’re treated with respect, as Pavarotti did in what is probably his best singing on this program, Tosti’s “A vucchella,” with Leone Magiera accompanying him on piano. There’s no hamming, no milking, no blatant playing to the audience — just three minutes of finely honed, sweetly voiced romantic singing that remind us what a great voice Pavarotti had even if he didn’t always use it in the best of taste.
The pop songs include “Miss Sarajevo” by U2 — a typical piece of Bonoesque irony inspired by a news item that women in war-torn Sarajevo were hosting a beauty contest, for which Pavarotti’s contribution was a section melodically different from the rest and sung in Italian (which, like everything else in this frustrating program, was not subtitled — opera mavens will know the texts of the well-known arias like Verdi’s “La donna è mobile” and “Celeste Aïda” and Puccini’s “Che gelida manina” and “Nessun dorma” — a piece Pavarotti so extensively publicized that Puccini’s opera Turandot, which it’s from, emerged from the shadows of the established repertory to a level of popularity comparable to Puccini’s “Big Three,” Bohème, Tosca and Madama Butterfly — but it would have been nice to know what Pavarotti was singing about on the less familiar pieces) — and a “Hail Mary” duet with Clapton in which, as Charles pointed out later, it was a good thing Clapton sang the song before Pavarotti did because we wouldn’t have been able to understand the English words from the hash Pavarotti made of them. (This, as Charles pointed out, was probably the reason Pavarotti never sang an opera role in English; though in the reviews of the world premiere production of Samuel Barber’s Vanessa in 1958 the singer praised for the best English diction was, ironically, tenor Nicolai Gedda — the only one whose native language was not English — Pavarotti was no Gedda in terms of the precision of his diction in any language.) The third clip featuring Pavarotti with a pop singer was his duet on César Franck’s “Panis Angelicus” with Sting — and Sting proved as clueless how to “speak” Pavarotti’s musical language as Pavarotti had been to “speak” Clapton’s. Pavarotti’s 1970’s Christmas special from Montréal gave us a precious clip of him singing this solo (he also recorded it and it was on the compilation Pavarotti’s Greatest Hits) and that’s the version that should have been presented here. The statement that most rankled me was made, not by anyone in the program itself, but by the KPBS announcer promoting it, who called Pavarotti “the greatest tenor of the 20th century” — huh? What about Caruso, Melchior, Björling or his contemporary (and fellow “Three Tenors” tenor) Domingo? In a review of a bootleg CD of an early (1973) Pavarotti recital in New York, Bill White wrote in the March-April 2014 Fanfare, “Plàcido Domingo is by all odds probably the best operatic tenor of the last 50 years, but the best tenor voice in that same span in all probability belongs to Luciano Pavarotti” — which probably sums up the difference between them: Pavarotti’s voice was more charismatic, instantly recognizable and overwhelming, but Domingo used his with more intelligence and also dared a considerably wider range of repertoire (including Wagner).
There were odd lacunae on this show, like so many domestic scenes of Naples you’d have thought Pavarotti was born there (he wasn’t — he was born in Modena, in the Po Valley in southern Italy, a smallish town whose other main claim to fame was that Enzo Ferrari established his car factory there) — but on the other hand Pavarotti: A Voice for the Ages is a good hour-long program featuring some of Pavarotti’s loveliest singing, but it still whets my curiosity for the mysterious biographical documentary Hubert Breslin worked on that probably explores the darker side of Pavarotti’s life, including his weird superstitions (he thought that in order to have good luck before a performance he had to find a bent nail backstage, so Pavarotti’s organization — unbeknownst, of course, to him — included a staff member whose job it was to leave bent nails around backstage wherever he was to perform so he’d find one and be reassured that his appearance would go well), his heavy-duty womanizing (an aspect of his character actually worked into the script for Yes, Giorgio, the flop movie he made for MGM in 1982 in which he plays a world-class tenor who loses his voice, is nursed back to both physical and vocal health by a woman doctor, and starts an ongoing relationship with her even though he has a wife and kids back in Italy — and we were supposed to think of this as a happy ending!) and his huge intake of food. Most opera singers try to avoid a big meal in the last hours before a performance because they don’t want to be distracted by indigestion; Pavarotti would often be snacking practically until the moment the curtain went up, and one friend remembers receiving a phone call from him at 3 a.m. while the great tenor was on tour. Thinking it was some sort of dire emergency, the friend rushed to Pavarotti’s room — whereupon Pavarotti told him that the reason he’d summoned him at that hour was he’d just got a new sausage that was so good he wanted his friend to have the opportunity to share it!
I kept the TV on KPBS to watch Pavarotti: A Voice for the Ages, thinking it would be the quite interesting documentary on the late superstar tenor Luciano Pavarotti recently reviewed in Fanfare magazine, a “warts and all” portrait that featured his former manager Hubert Breslin — who had helped build Pavarotti as an attraction and raised him out of the ghetto of opera stardom into full-fledged mass-market celebrity-hood, only to have a bitter falling-out with him. Alas, what this show turned out to be was a hagiographical presentation of clips from Pavarotti’s previous PBS appearances, complete with a few archival interview clips from Pavarotti himself — including a surprisingly revealing comment that he loved appearing on TV because it’s a close-up medium and therefore he didn’t have to act with his body (which, given his sheer bulk, was always a challenge and became increasingly difficult for him as, like Orson Welles, he became even more bloated in his later years than he’d started out) but could communicate character with his face. The show gave an interesting if rather incomplete portrait of Pavarotti the artist, including several depictions of a real-life singer-conductor couple who helped him and frequently appeared with him in the early years — soprano Mirella Freni and her husband, conductor Leone Magiera (an early Italian TV clip of Puccini’s La Bohème with them nearly a decade before they recorded it together with Herbert von Karajan and the Vienna Philharmonic is fascinating — especially for Pavarotti’s attractiveness; he was certainly big but not as huge as he got later, and though hefty he wasn’t so large he wasn’t believable as a starving poet in a Parisian garret) — but it surprisingly doesn’t mention a far more prominent soprano-conductor couple who helped him even more, including getting him his recording contract with British Decca (then known as London Records in the U.S.): Joan Sutherland and Richard Bonynge.
But then the producers of this show seemed to be going out of their way to minimize Pavarotti the bel-cantist; though his repertory reached at least as far back in operatic history as Mozart’s Idomeneo (revived by the Met in the 1990’s especially for him) and much of his early prominence came from recording scores like Donizetti’s Lucia di Lammermoor and La Fille du Regiment and Bellini’s La Sonnambula and I Puritani with Sutherland and Bonynge (indeed, it was his performance of the notoriously difficult aria “Pour mon âme” from Fille du Regiment, with nine, count ’em, nine high C’s, that earned Pavarotti his early nickname “King of the High C’s”), all the opera excerpts in this show were familiar “chestnuts” by Verdi or Puccini. There was a well-sung “Celeste Aïda” from a Met gala tribute to conductor James Levine (alas, shorn of the opening recitative); Pavarotti rather tastelessly boomed out the final high note fortissimo instead of singing it softly as Verdi asked for, but as with such other uncalled-for “Verdi” high notes as the high C at the end of “Di quella pira” in Il Trovatore and the E-flat in alt at the end of “Sempre libera” in La Traviata, just about everybody sings it this way now. (Caruso sang the high note softly in his first recording of “Celeste Aïda” in 1902, left the entire phrase out of his second recording — the 78 rpm master ran out of room — but thereafter sang it loud.) The show was divided into three parts — each separated by the interminable, pleading “pledge breaks” inflicted on PBS viewers by an increasingly financially desperate network (one Republican Congressmember in the 1980’s said he found the “pledge breaks” more offensive than out-and-out commercials, and though he was using this as an excuse to vote to end all federal funding for PBS I could still see his point) — the first showing Pavarotti the opera singer, the second his collaborations with pop stars — including U2, Eric Clapton and Sting — and the third dealing with the whole “Three Tenors” phenomenon, in which the people considered the most important living tenors in the world, Pavarotti, Plácido Domingo and José Carreras, grouped together for mega-concerts. The original Three Tenors concert took place in Rome in 1990 and was planned in connection with the final match of the World Cup soccer (or, as the rest of the world outside the U.S. and U.K. terms it, “football”) tournament, and the second one took place in L.A. in 1994, also just before that year’s World Cup final.
It’s indicative of what a phenomenon this became and how it leapfrogged out of the classical-music ghetto that the album of the 1990 concert came out on British Decca/U.S. London and had a respectable classical-style cover (it didn’t use the “Three Tenors” sobriquet and was simply billed as “Carreras-Domingo-Pavarotti in Concert”), while the album and video of the 1994 concert came out on Atlantic and featured a swooping animated logo in which the numeral “3” came dancing out of the sky before it settled down in front of the screen along with the words “The” and “Tenors.” The Three Tenors concerts featured both classical and popular music, and alas the pop selections were pretty ghastly, including a version of the Neapolitan song “O sole mio” used as an excuse for the tenors (especially Pavarotti) to ham it up, and the awful song “My Way,” which began as a French song about a long-term married couple now bored by each other, got changed into the bizarre peroration we know by Paul Anka (who was hired by the song’s publisher to supply an English lyric — an original, not a translation of the original French) and recorded by Frank Sinatra, a horrifyingly bad record because it hooked the egomania that was by far the least attractive part of Sinatra’s public persona. In the Three Tenors’ performances “My Way” has you asking, “What are three guys with nice voices like yours doing with a song like this?” I’m not saying it’s a bad move for opera singers to record pop material, but not when the pop material is so far removed from opera that they haven’t a clue what to do with it; Caruso was able to do material like George M. Cohan’s “Over There” and make it work, but the influence of African-American music on popular music worldwide — manifested in the successive eras of ragtime, jazz, swing, rock and rap — has carried pop music ever farther from opera and made it more difficult for opera singers to find lighter material that can work for them. This is probably why so many opera singers, tenors in particular, fall back on the so-called “Neapolitan Song” genre, of which “O sole mio” (the only song recorded by both of RCA Victor’s two most legendary artists, Enrico Caruso and Elvis Presley) is the most famous example — these songs can be beautiful if they’re treated with respect, as Pavarotti did in what is probably his best singing on this program, Tosti’s “A vucchella,” with Leone Magiera accompanying him on piano. There’s no hamming, no milking, no blatant playing to the audience — just three minutes of finely honed, sweetly voiced romantic singing that remind us what a great voice Pavarotti had even if he didn’t always use it in the best of taste.
The pop songs include “Miss Sarajevo” by U2 — a typical piece of Bonoesque irony inspired by a news item that women in war-torn Sarajevo were hosting a beauty contest, for which Pavarotti’s contribution was a section melodically different from the rest and sung in Italian (which, like everything else in this frustrating program, was not subtitled — opera mavens will know the texts of the well-known arias like Verdi’s “La donna è mobile” and “Celeste Aïda” and Puccini’s “Che gelida manina” and “Nessun dorma” — a piece Pavarotti so extensively publicized that Puccini’s opera Turandot, which it’s from, emerged from the shadows of the established repertory to a level of popularity comparable to Puccini’s “Big Three,” Bohème, Tosca and Madama Butterfly — but it would have been nice to know what Pavarotti was singing about on the less familiar pieces) — and a “Hail Mary” duet with Clapton in which, as Charles pointed out later, it was a good thing Clapton sang the song before Pavarotti did because we wouldn’t have been able to understand the English words from the hash Pavarotti made of them. (This, as Charles pointed out, was probably the reason Pavarotti never sang an opera role in English; though in the reviews of the world premiere production of Samuel Barber’s Vanessa in 1958 the singer praised for the best English diction was, ironically, tenor Nicolai Gedda — the only one whose native language was not English — Pavarotti was no Gedda in terms of the precision of his diction in any language.) The third clip featuring Pavarotti with a pop singer was his duet on César Franck’s “Panis Angelicus” with Sting — and Sting proved as clueless how to “speak” Pavarotti’s musical language as Pavarotti had been to “speak” Clapton’s. Pavarotti’s 1970’s Christmas special from Montréal gave us a precious clip of him singing this solo (he also recorded it and it was on the compilation Pavarotti’s Greatest Hits) and that’s the version that should have been presented here. The statement that most rankled me was made, not by anyone in the program itself, but by the KPBS announcer promoting it, who called Pavarotti “the greatest tenor of the 20th century” — huh? What about Caruso, Melchior, Björling or his contemporary (and fellow “Three Tenors” tenor) Domingo? In a review of a bootleg CD of an early (1973) Pavarotti recital in New York, Bill White wrote in the March-April 2014 Fanfare, “Plàcido Domingo is by all odds probably the best operatic tenor of the last 50 years, but the best tenor voice in that same span in all probability belongs to Luciano Pavarotti” — which probably sums up the difference between them: Pavarotti’s voice was more charismatic, instantly recognizable and overwhelming, but Domingo used his with more intelligence and also dared a considerably wider range of repertoire (including Wagner).
There were odd lacunae on this show, like so many domestic scenes of Naples you’d have thought Pavarotti was born there (he wasn’t — he was born in Modena, in the Po Valley in southern Italy, a smallish town whose other main claim to fame was that Enzo Ferrari established his car factory there) — but on the other hand Pavarotti: A Voice for the Ages is a good hour-long program featuring some of Pavarotti’s loveliest singing, but it still whets my curiosity for the mysterious biographical documentary Hubert Breslin worked on that probably explores the darker side of Pavarotti’s life, including his weird superstitions (he thought that in order to have good luck before a performance he had to find a bent nail backstage, so Pavarotti’s organization — unbeknownst, of course, to him — included a staff member whose job it was to leave bent nails around backstage wherever he was to perform so he’d find one and be reassured that his appearance would go well), his heavy-duty womanizing (an aspect of his character actually worked into the script for Yes, Giorgio, the flop movie he made for MGM in 1982 in which he plays a world-class tenor who loses his voice, is nursed back to both physical and vocal health by a woman doctor, and starts an ongoing relationship with her even though he has a wife and kids back in Italy — and we were supposed to think of this as a happy ending!) and his huge intake of food. Most opera singers try to avoid a big meal in the last hours before a performance because they don’t want to be distracted by indigestion; Pavarotti would often be snacking practically until the moment the curtain went up, and one friend remembers receiving a phone call from him at 3 a.m. while the great tenor was on tour. Thinking it was some sort of dire emergency, the friend rushed to Pavarotti’s room — whereupon Pavarotti told him that the reason he’d summoned him at that hour was he’d just got a new sausage that was so good he wanted his friend to have the opportunity to share it!
Sweetheart of the Campus (Columbia, 1941)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2014 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The film was Sweetheart of the Campus, a 1941 musical from Columbia that was Ruby Keeler’s last film, and which Turner Classic Movies had shown as part of a tribute to its director, Edward Dmytryk. It turned out to be a quite engaging modest musical, with serviceable if not truly great songs and a pleasant if clichéd plot. Besides Keeler, the stars were bandleader Ozzie Nelson and his wife (since 1935 — for some reason, probably due to a misreading of a Films of the Golden Age article, I’d thought they hadn’t married until much later) and band singer Harriet Hilliard, who in this film played characters creatively named “Ozzie Norton” and “Harriet Hale.” In the script by Robert Hardy Andrews (for some reason billed with the wrong middle initial, “D.”) and Edmund L. Hartmann, “Ozzie Norton”’s featured attraction is dancer Betty Blake (Ruby Keeler), who’s in love with him. They’re about to open at a club near the campus of Lambeth Technological Institute — too near, as it turns out, since Minnie Lambeth Sparr (Kathleen Howard, a Margaret Dumont type), who’s the heir of the college’s founder, is determined to drive it out of business by closing down the athletic program, arts and music, and anything else that might draw students by making their Lambeth experience fun. She takes advantage of a local law that says a nightclub can’t be located within five miles of a college to have the place padlocked by the local sheriff (Don Beddoe).
Harriet Hale (Harriet Hilliard), apparently the one decent human being on the college staff, works out a plan to save the livelihoods of Betty, Ozzie and their bandmates by enrolling them at Lambeth as students and having them stage their show inside the college gym. She gets them past the entrance exam by teaching them the answers by rote — the college’s education director, Dr. Bailey (Byron Foulger), gives the same test again and again — and “Ozzie Norton” stages a weekly experimental television broadcast over the college’s station, WOO. (It’s interesting that the television equipment — both the cameras and the receiving sets — look like what’s familiar to us now, though by the time this movie was made TV stations and sets already existed — NBC had started TV broadcasting in New York City in 1939 but the program was put on hiatus due to the U.S. involvement in World War II. So the filmmakers could show actually existing TV equipment instead of the preposterous-looking sci-fi gadgetry in mid-1930’s films like Murder by Television and Columbia’s own Trapped by Television.) Sparr, who’s determined to close Lambeth so she can turn it into a girls’ seminary, is incensed that as the only female student among 300 males, Betty Blake is making Lambeth popular and helping the school reach their quota of 300 students, which it needs to stay in business under the terms of John Lambeth’s will. She has Dr. Bailey give a really tough set of final exams to flunk out as many of the new Lambeth enrollees as possible — including a group of football players who’ve been working the college circuit for up to 12 years (yet another film that jokes about the practice of colleges then of hiring professional “ringers” to beef up their football teams — a scandal depicted in several serious dramatic films in the 1930’s and hilariously spoofed in the Marx Brothers’ Horse Feathers) — but Ozzie and Betty are able to keep their broadcasts going even as Betty gets an offer from a Broadway producer and opens on the Main Stem as a huge overnight star. Alas, Betty loses Ozzie to Harriet Hale — she even laments how often she hears the words “Ozzie and Harriet” (“you say it like they go together, like ham and eggs!”) three years before the couple started their Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet radio sitcom that eventually transferred to TV in 1952 and made them TV stars for real 11 years after this movie. I joked about the former Mrs. Al Jolson taking the present and future Mrs. Ozzie Nelson aside and telling her, “Being married to someone more famous than you are isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.”
Sweetheart of the Campus is one of those films from the studio era that isn’t a world-beater but does achieve a nice level of entertainment — it’s certainly better than Keeler’s last film for Warner Bros., Ready, Willing and Able in 1937 (in the intervening four years she made just one other movie, the RKO non-musical Mother Carey’s Chickens in 1938, which I’ve heard so many ghastly things about I haven’t been able to bring myself to sit through it) — and one of the nicest things about it is it gives us a chance to see what a good dancer Ruby Keeler really was. In her most famous films at Warners she’d been surrounded by Busby Berkeley’s platoons of choristers, who had got in her way; also, according to one report I’ve read in 42nd Street she’d been doing something closer to clog-dancing than tap-dancing, wearing wooden (or at least wooden-heeled) shoes which required her to stomp on the floor hard to make an audible tap sound — which may explain why she looked jerky in the solo bits. Here she’s doing normal tap dancing and doing it spectacularly well, especially in the boogie-woogie number that was obviously put into the film to show the audience that Ruby Keeler (and Ozzie Nelson) could swing, and she’s at least a serviceable actress and sometimes better than that, especially when she has to play her disappointment that Ozzie is going to end up with Harriet instead of her.
The film was Sweetheart of the Campus, a 1941 musical from Columbia that was Ruby Keeler’s last film, and which Turner Classic Movies had shown as part of a tribute to its director, Edward Dmytryk. It turned out to be a quite engaging modest musical, with serviceable if not truly great songs and a pleasant if clichéd plot. Besides Keeler, the stars were bandleader Ozzie Nelson and his wife (since 1935 — for some reason, probably due to a misreading of a Films of the Golden Age article, I’d thought they hadn’t married until much later) and band singer Harriet Hilliard, who in this film played characters creatively named “Ozzie Norton” and “Harriet Hale.” In the script by Robert Hardy Andrews (for some reason billed with the wrong middle initial, “D.”) and Edmund L. Hartmann, “Ozzie Norton”’s featured attraction is dancer Betty Blake (Ruby Keeler), who’s in love with him. They’re about to open at a club near the campus of Lambeth Technological Institute — too near, as it turns out, since Minnie Lambeth Sparr (Kathleen Howard, a Margaret Dumont type), who’s the heir of the college’s founder, is determined to drive it out of business by closing down the athletic program, arts and music, and anything else that might draw students by making their Lambeth experience fun. She takes advantage of a local law that says a nightclub can’t be located within five miles of a college to have the place padlocked by the local sheriff (Don Beddoe).
Harriet Hale (Harriet Hilliard), apparently the one decent human being on the college staff, works out a plan to save the livelihoods of Betty, Ozzie and their bandmates by enrolling them at Lambeth as students and having them stage their show inside the college gym. She gets them past the entrance exam by teaching them the answers by rote — the college’s education director, Dr. Bailey (Byron Foulger), gives the same test again and again — and “Ozzie Norton” stages a weekly experimental television broadcast over the college’s station, WOO. (It’s interesting that the television equipment — both the cameras and the receiving sets — look like what’s familiar to us now, though by the time this movie was made TV stations and sets already existed — NBC had started TV broadcasting in New York City in 1939 but the program was put on hiatus due to the U.S. involvement in World War II. So the filmmakers could show actually existing TV equipment instead of the preposterous-looking sci-fi gadgetry in mid-1930’s films like Murder by Television and Columbia’s own Trapped by Television.) Sparr, who’s determined to close Lambeth so she can turn it into a girls’ seminary, is incensed that as the only female student among 300 males, Betty Blake is making Lambeth popular and helping the school reach their quota of 300 students, which it needs to stay in business under the terms of John Lambeth’s will. She has Dr. Bailey give a really tough set of final exams to flunk out as many of the new Lambeth enrollees as possible — including a group of football players who’ve been working the college circuit for up to 12 years (yet another film that jokes about the practice of colleges then of hiring professional “ringers” to beef up their football teams — a scandal depicted in several serious dramatic films in the 1930’s and hilariously spoofed in the Marx Brothers’ Horse Feathers) — but Ozzie and Betty are able to keep their broadcasts going even as Betty gets an offer from a Broadway producer and opens on the Main Stem as a huge overnight star. Alas, Betty loses Ozzie to Harriet Hale — she even laments how often she hears the words “Ozzie and Harriet” (“you say it like they go together, like ham and eggs!”) three years before the couple started their Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet radio sitcom that eventually transferred to TV in 1952 and made them TV stars for real 11 years after this movie. I joked about the former Mrs. Al Jolson taking the present and future Mrs. Ozzie Nelson aside and telling her, “Being married to someone more famous than you are isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.”
Sweetheart of the Campus is one of those films from the studio era that isn’t a world-beater but does achieve a nice level of entertainment — it’s certainly better than Keeler’s last film for Warner Bros., Ready, Willing and Able in 1937 (in the intervening four years she made just one other movie, the RKO non-musical Mother Carey’s Chickens in 1938, which I’ve heard so many ghastly things about I haven’t been able to bring myself to sit through it) — and one of the nicest things about it is it gives us a chance to see what a good dancer Ruby Keeler really was. In her most famous films at Warners she’d been surrounded by Busby Berkeley’s platoons of choristers, who had got in her way; also, according to one report I’ve read in 42nd Street she’d been doing something closer to clog-dancing than tap-dancing, wearing wooden (or at least wooden-heeled) shoes which required her to stomp on the floor hard to make an audible tap sound — which may explain why she looked jerky in the solo bits. Here she’s doing normal tap dancing and doing it spectacularly well, especially in the boogie-woogie number that was obviously put into the film to show the audience that Ruby Keeler (and Ozzie Nelson) could swing, and she’s at least a serviceable actress and sometimes better than that, especially when she has to play her disappointment that Ozzie is going to end up with Harriet instead of her.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)