by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The April 29, 2017 “premiere” showing on Lifetime was of a
movie called Manny Dearest — a horrible
pun on the title of Christina Crawford’s infamous memoir of life with her
superstar (adoptive) mom, Mommie Dearest. It turns out “manny” has become a term of art for a man who’s hired
to take care of a single woman’s (or a single man’s, or a married couple’s)
children while the parent(s) aren’t home — it’s supposed to be a contraction of
“male nanny.” It shouldn’t be surprising that after all the movies Lifetime has
churned out about crazy women who take jobs as nannies and want to take over
from them both with the children and in their husband’s (or boyfriend’s) bed —
including The Perfect Nanny, the
2000 movie (has it really been that long?) that was Christine Conradt’s first
sale to the network — they decided this time around to switch the genders and
have a male nanny (I hate the term “manny” even more than I hate the word
“intersectionality” and the plethora of initials the Queer community identifies
itself with nowadays!) doing a psycho number and ultimately terrorizing a woman
out of a demented and decidedly unrequited crush on her. This time the male
nanny is the reasonably attractive (though not as drop-dead gorgeous as the
usual Lifetime male villain) Alex Stanley (Mitch Ryan), who registers with a
nanny agency and gets a job with Karen Clark (Ashley Scott), who’s tall,
willowy, blonde and wears her hair in a page-boy cut (the latter two points
turn out to be important and you’ll be tested on them). She has two kids, Max
(Dylan Kingwell) and Rex (Jett Klyne) — if she’d had a third son would she have
called him Dix? — but their father has been dead for three years. She’s
currently “serious” about a youngish man named Greg Hitchens (Woody Jeffreys),
whom we get to meet when he’s coming out of Karen’s bed blessedly naked except
for a pair of black undies — and though he’s supposed to be the good guy and
most good-looking guys on Lifetime are villains, he’s nice-looking enough it’s
a delight to see him that way. He also turns out to be a recovering alcoholic
who’s been clean and sober for the last three years, though we don’t learn that
about him until much later. Alex
immediately bonds with Max and Rex, does such beyond-the-call stuff as
thoroughly cleaning Karen’s house, and makes such a fuss fondling Karen’s
clothes that at first we think he might be Gay — until we see a fantasy
sequence of him and Karen making love.
Though the script for this movie doesn’t
mention Whittendale University, it’s the product of the writers who created the
“Whittendale universe” — Ken Sanders co-wrote the original story with Daniel
West, and Bryan Dick (an unfortunate last name given the sorts of scripts he
writes) did the screenplay — and it’s got some of their trademarks, including
some bizarre and often confusing cut-ins of fantasy sequences representing the
sexual things one of the characters wants to do with another, even though the fantasy object wants nothing to do
with him or her that way. Alex
instantly falls in love with Karen, while Karen’s best friend Gillian Hagen
(Fiona Vroom), a single mother of two girls who frequently play with Karen’s
two boys, instantly falls in lust with Alex and is willing to do just about
anything to get him to have sex with her. Alex does everything he can to win
Karen’s affections, including helping Max out with Brett, a bully (Cory
Gruter-Andrew), who’s intimidating him at school and stealing his possessions;
first he gives Max a quickie self-defense lesson and then, when Max takes on
Brett and gets beaten up (and rescued by Rex, who turns in a false fire alarm),
Alex kidnaps Brett’s dog and threatens to kill the dog unless Brett lays off
Rex from then on and gives back all the stuff he stole from him. Alex also
secretly films Karen in her bedroom, courtesy of a toy drone he’s bought,
ostensibly as a present for the kids but really so he can spy on Karen either
alone in her bedroom or having sex with Greg. Only Alex’s jealousy really goes
into overdrive when he’s asked to look after the kids at night so Karen and
Greg can have a “special date” at the restaurant where they had their first
date — and Alex realizes that Greg means to propose marriage to Karen. Alex
drugs the kids so he can leave them alone, stalks Karen and Greg at the
restaurant, turns in a false fire alarm and races back to Karen’s home — which
he has to do on foot because he inadvertently parked his car in a no-parking
zone and he arrives back at it just to see a tow truck pulling it away — to
make it look like he’s been there all along. Later he spikes Greg’s iced tea
and drugs him, then pours whiskey
all over him and leaves the half-empty bottle, as well as some beers, to make
Karen think that Greg has relapsed big-time on a night she had entrusted him with her kids (apparently Alex has seen the 1939
James Cagney film Each Dawn I Die
— either that or the writers of Manny Dearest have) — and for several acts Karen refuses to listen
to Greg try to explain what happened.
Karen abruptly and angrily breaks up with
Greg, who responds by researching Alex on the Internet and finding out that
when he was eight his parents killed themselves and he ended up in foster care
(the only clue we’re going to get as to What Made Alex Run), and that he
previously worked for a woman named Gwen Brown, who also (apparently) committed
suicide (though an ambiguous prologue, set some time before the main action,
made it look as if Alex had killed her). Gwen is played by Lindsay Maxwell, who
looks as much like Ashley Scott as Lifetime’s makeup and casting people could
manage — complete with the blonde page-boy haircut, which seems to be the only type of woman that attracts Alex. (At one point we
see Alex actually attempting sex with Gillian — she’s hacked into his phone and
downloaded his naughty pics of Karen, and will delete them only if he fucks her
— but he’s only able to get it up with her if he fantasizes her as the page-boy
blonde that’s his only “type.”) It ends about the way you’d expect it to, with
Alex taking Karen’s kids to the Wonder World amusement park (though it’s
currently closed for the off-season) since that’s the last place where Alex saw
his parents before they died, and insisting they’re going to be a real family
from now on — only Greg not only figures it out and makes it there himself but
leads the police there. Karen and the kids are rescued and Greg ends up in her
good graces at the end, but the film has one of those annoying tag sequences
Lifetime has been doing a lot of lately, in which Alex gets away and, under
another name, is shown interviewing for another “manny” job with another woman
who presumably is going to go through the same traumas at his hands. Manny
Dearest — filmed under the title A
Stranger with My Kids, which wouldn’t have
been much better — is just too formulaic to be all that interesting, the sort of
movie that you know what’s going to happen an act or two before it does and the
writers and director (Chad Krowchuk) don’t throw you any curveballs: they just
keep pitching their plot points straight down the middle, and any even slightly
experienced Lifetime viewer won’t have any problem hitting these soft pitches
out of the park.
Sunday, April 30, 2017
Woman on the Run (Annuit Coeptis Entertainment, Johnson Production Group, Lifetime, 2017)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Lifetime’s April 29 follow-up to Manny Dearest was Woman on the Run, which despite its generic “thriller” title had a good deal more potential than its schedule-mate but was one of those Lifetime productions in which a good director (Jason Bourque) with a real flair for suspense ran afoul of a script that piled so many improbabilities on top of each other it was more oppressive than entertaining. It’s essentially a blend of Hitchcock’s The Lady Vanishes, Kafka’s The Trial and Kesey’s One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest: mystery writer Nomi Gardner (Sarah Butler) is married to Seattle-based hedge-fund investor Mark Gardner (Jim Thorburn, O.K.-looking but not as drop-dead gorgeous as Lifetime’s usual villains). They have two kids, six-year-old daughter Jane (Bailey Skodje) and infant son Aiden, and they’ve hired a nanny named Greta March (Lindsay Maxwell, who also played the small role of murder victim Gwen Brown on Manny Dearest). The plot kicks off when Mark has to go out of town on a trip to meet potential new investors for his hedge fund, and he brings Nomi and the kids along — only Nomi realizes that she didn’t bring diapers or formula for Aiden, so she goes out of their hotel to the nearest drugstore to get those items. While she’s out she’s mysteriously attacked, and she fends off the attacker — only when she returns to the hotel room, she’s told that she’s really Greta and Greta is really Nomi. She finds that her ID has been mysteriously switched so it has her face but Greta’s name, and she has no documentary way of proving her true identity. We get what’s happening right away — at some point Greta and Mark started an affair and hatched this plot to get rid of Nomi and keep her from getting her hands on $5 million in income Mark had just received from a mysterious source and which he’d shielded from his wife by telling her his businesses were doing poorly.
Nomi’s peril soon turns Kafka-esque — or at least as Kafka-esque as this film’s considerably less talented writer, Paul A. Birkett, could make it — as she tries to go to the police, who buy Mark’s and Greta’s explanation that this is just a crazy ex-nanny whom they had to fire and who is still stalking them. She tries calling Ted Curtis (Jerry Wasserman), her old writing teacher, whom she was seen talking to on Skype in an opening scene and who therefore knows what she looks like (earlier Birkett has tried to get us to believe she’s so reclusive she doesn’t know anybody else in her own neighborhood and she’s never allowed her photo to appear on the dust jackets of her books), and he agrees to fly cross-country to identify her — only when she and that officious woman detective meet Ted at the police station he identifies Nomi as Greta. She starts screaming at him that Mark and Greta have obviously got to him, too — and of course the policewoman decides she’s being paranoid and warns her once again to stop stalking the Gardners or they’ll arrest her and put her in a psych ward. In fact Mark and Greta did bribe Ted, offering him $100,000 — only when he realizes they stand to gain $5 million from their scam, whatever it is, he demands $1 million and Mark responds by sending Lyle (Josh Byer), his handyman and hit man, to strangle him in his car and then crash it off the road so it will look like Ted, an alcoholic, got drunk and ran his car off a mountain road in an accident. Lyle also attempts to kill Nomi — the real one — but botches the job at least twice. The only person Nomi actually has in her corner is Oscar (Matthew MacCaull), who was working as a bellboy at the hotel where Mark, Nomi and Greta were staying and who ran into her in the lobby, found out who she was (how?) and told her he was a fan of her books. (Given how many Murder, She Wrote reruns I’ve been watching lately, I joked that he’d tell her, “You’re the first mystery writer I’ve met here since Jessica Fletcher!”)
When the cops actually put her in a psych ward and she tries to escape, only they catch her and are about to give her electroshock therapy (an error since in Washington state, where this is set, no one can be given electroshock therapy against their will without first obtaining a court order), faithful Oscar manages to pull a fake “emergency” that causes the building to be evacuated and escapes with Nomi. At the end, though, the big weak link in Mark’s and Greta’s plot turns out to be Mark’s and Nomi’s daughter Jane: in the final confrontation, when a different woman detective also seems to be going along with Mark’s and Greta’s plot, Jane hugs the real Nomi and makes it clear to the cop that it’s the dark-haired woman, not the blonde, who’s her real mother — whereupon Mark and Greta get arrested and Nomi ends up in a relationship with Oscar (hey, the kids need a dad from somewhere, and it’s already been established that he was attracted to her!). Woman on the Run, despite its blah title, had the potential to be a really good exercise in suspense, and Jason Bourque has done some pretty good Lifetime movies before this one, including Are You My Daughter? and I Didn’t Kill My Sister (also about a woman who discovers not only that her husband is having an affair but the girlfriend is trying to displace her completely), but once again he’s hamstrung by a script that’s so silly, so poorly motivated and requires so many suspensions of disbelief you could hang the Golden Gate Bridge off of them. The actors do the best they can with Birkett’s absurdities and Bourque, as in his previous Lifetime movies, proves himself a quite capable director of suspense and action that just needs better scripts than the major-domos at Lifetime have been giving him!
Lifetime’s April 29 follow-up to Manny Dearest was Woman on the Run, which despite its generic “thriller” title had a good deal more potential than its schedule-mate but was one of those Lifetime productions in which a good director (Jason Bourque) with a real flair for suspense ran afoul of a script that piled so many improbabilities on top of each other it was more oppressive than entertaining. It’s essentially a blend of Hitchcock’s The Lady Vanishes, Kafka’s The Trial and Kesey’s One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest: mystery writer Nomi Gardner (Sarah Butler) is married to Seattle-based hedge-fund investor Mark Gardner (Jim Thorburn, O.K.-looking but not as drop-dead gorgeous as Lifetime’s usual villains). They have two kids, six-year-old daughter Jane (Bailey Skodje) and infant son Aiden, and they’ve hired a nanny named Greta March (Lindsay Maxwell, who also played the small role of murder victim Gwen Brown on Manny Dearest). The plot kicks off when Mark has to go out of town on a trip to meet potential new investors for his hedge fund, and he brings Nomi and the kids along — only Nomi realizes that she didn’t bring diapers or formula for Aiden, so she goes out of their hotel to the nearest drugstore to get those items. While she’s out she’s mysteriously attacked, and she fends off the attacker — only when she returns to the hotel room, she’s told that she’s really Greta and Greta is really Nomi. She finds that her ID has been mysteriously switched so it has her face but Greta’s name, and she has no documentary way of proving her true identity. We get what’s happening right away — at some point Greta and Mark started an affair and hatched this plot to get rid of Nomi and keep her from getting her hands on $5 million in income Mark had just received from a mysterious source and which he’d shielded from his wife by telling her his businesses were doing poorly.
Nomi’s peril soon turns Kafka-esque — or at least as Kafka-esque as this film’s considerably less talented writer, Paul A. Birkett, could make it — as she tries to go to the police, who buy Mark’s and Greta’s explanation that this is just a crazy ex-nanny whom they had to fire and who is still stalking them. She tries calling Ted Curtis (Jerry Wasserman), her old writing teacher, whom she was seen talking to on Skype in an opening scene and who therefore knows what she looks like (earlier Birkett has tried to get us to believe she’s so reclusive she doesn’t know anybody else in her own neighborhood and she’s never allowed her photo to appear on the dust jackets of her books), and he agrees to fly cross-country to identify her — only when she and that officious woman detective meet Ted at the police station he identifies Nomi as Greta. She starts screaming at him that Mark and Greta have obviously got to him, too — and of course the policewoman decides she’s being paranoid and warns her once again to stop stalking the Gardners or they’ll arrest her and put her in a psych ward. In fact Mark and Greta did bribe Ted, offering him $100,000 — only when he realizes they stand to gain $5 million from their scam, whatever it is, he demands $1 million and Mark responds by sending Lyle (Josh Byer), his handyman and hit man, to strangle him in his car and then crash it off the road so it will look like Ted, an alcoholic, got drunk and ran his car off a mountain road in an accident. Lyle also attempts to kill Nomi — the real one — but botches the job at least twice. The only person Nomi actually has in her corner is Oscar (Matthew MacCaull), who was working as a bellboy at the hotel where Mark, Nomi and Greta were staying and who ran into her in the lobby, found out who she was (how?) and told her he was a fan of her books. (Given how many Murder, She Wrote reruns I’ve been watching lately, I joked that he’d tell her, “You’re the first mystery writer I’ve met here since Jessica Fletcher!”)
When the cops actually put her in a psych ward and she tries to escape, only they catch her and are about to give her electroshock therapy (an error since in Washington state, where this is set, no one can be given electroshock therapy against their will without first obtaining a court order), faithful Oscar manages to pull a fake “emergency” that causes the building to be evacuated and escapes with Nomi. At the end, though, the big weak link in Mark’s and Greta’s plot turns out to be Mark’s and Nomi’s daughter Jane: in the final confrontation, when a different woman detective also seems to be going along with Mark’s and Greta’s plot, Jane hugs the real Nomi and makes it clear to the cop that it’s the dark-haired woman, not the blonde, who’s her real mother — whereupon Mark and Greta get arrested and Nomi ends up in a relationship with Oscar (hey, the kids need a dad from somewhere, and it’s already been established that he was attracted to her!). Woman on the Run, despite its blah title, had the potential to be a really good exercise in suspense, and Jason Bourque has done some pretty good Lifetime movies before this one, including Are You My Daughter? and I Didn’t Kill My Sister (also about a woman who discovers not only that her husband is having an affair but the girlfriend is trying to displace her completely), but once again he’s hamstrung by a script that’s so silly, so poorly motivated and requires so many suspensions of disbelief you could hang the Golden Gate Bridge off of them. The actors do the best they can with Birkett’s absurdities and Bourque, as in his previous Lifetime movies, proves himself a quite capable director of suspense and action that just needs better scripts than the major-domos at Lifetime have been giving him!
Saturday, April 29, 2017
Heaven Before I Die (Brothers in Arms, PM Entertainment Group, 1997)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night Charles and I watched Heaven Before I Die, which had been sitting in my backlog for quite a while (I must have bought it online but I can’t remember from what source or what quirky algorithm guided me to it), which turned out to be a 1997 independent production from Canada, written and directed by Izidore K. Musallam. It’s about a young man named Jacob who’s born in occupied Palestine, in Jerusalem (there’s a grimly funny sequence in which he goes to a call center to pay for a long-distance phone call to his family back home, and he grandly announces to the operator that he wants to place a call to “Jerusalem, The Holy Land,” and is rather officioualy informed, “The only Jerusalem we have listed is in Israel”) with such a severe case of pronation — the condition in which your feet are at an angle and your toes point outward instead of staying parallel with the rest of your body — that he looks and walks like Charlie Chaplin. Needless to say, he’s continually being teased about this, both as a child (he’s played by three actors — Hannin Eisa Abu-Alhumos as a baby, Mohammed Eisa Abu-Alhumos as a boy, and the devastatingly handsome Andy Velasquez as an adult through most of the film) and when he grows up, falls diffidently in love with a local girl named Nora (Ruti Moinster), only to be heartbroken when, before he’s had the chance to have sex or do much of anything physical with her, she decides to emigrate. Several years later Jacob decides to emigrate, too, after he sees a gang of smugglers give a street presentation promoting Canada as “the real land of milk and honey” and a good place for a young Palestinian to go to flee the Israeli occupation and the ultra-limited job prospects at home. There’s a nicely amusing scene in which the Asian-born man who’s supposed to help him says that a “sip” is waiting to take him to Boston, from where he can hitch a ride to Toronto, and it takes quite a while before he realizes the word is “ship.”
Once he makes it to Toronto he falls in with two small-time crooks, likewise undocumented immigrants to Canada, named Sharif (played by Giancarlo Giannini, who in the early 1970’s briefly became an international star through his roles in Lina Wertmuller’s movies The Seduction of Mimi, Swept Away and Seven Beauties) and Stavros (Geoffrey Lower — his character is listed in the credits as “Sterrea,” presumably his last name, but “Stavros” is how he’s addressed throughout the film). They agree to put Jacob up, only his first night at their place he walks into their living room in the middle of the night on his way to the kitchen to get some food — and he sees Sharif, Stavros and their poker buddies (watching this movie I couldn’t help but recall the similar scenes of proletarian men playing poker in Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire — indeed, Williams’ working title for that play was The Poker Night) hunching over a piece of graph paper on which is drawn the floor plan for some building. From the drawing and from their conversation, with its references to an “in-and-out” job, it’s obvious they’re planning something illegal, but it’s not clear exactly what (Charles thought they were plotting to rob a convenience store, I thought they were going after a bank) until later in the film. It seems they’ve devised a gadget they can stick into the card slot of an ATM to hack it and get it to dispense all its cash on hand — which comes out as a series of red-and-white bills that probably don’t look at all like real Canadian money (throughout Hollywood’s classic era the U.S. Treasury Department forbade the use of real American currency in Hollywood films, and in 1949 the producers of the film T-Men made a big deal out of the fact that theirs was the first film to show genuine American money: since the film was about counterfeiters and much of the plot turned around the ability — or lack thereof — of the counterfeiters to make their money look like the real deal, actually showing the real deal was important to the filmmakers, so they cut a deal with the Treasury Department to let them show it) — and though they tell Jacob to wait in the car while they do this, he gets out and his Chaplinesque stumbles attract the attention of the security guard and thereby inadvertently help his crook roommates get away with it.
The next time they try it, though, he gets chased by a cab driver who’s long dreamed of making a citizen’s arrest and he ends up spending the night in jail, only to be bailed out by Selma (Joanna Pacula), a waitress at a club the crooks frequent, whom Sharif wanted as a girlfriend but who only has eyes for Jacob. Selma and Jacob drift into a rather odd relationship, hampered by the fact that back home he pledged fidelity to Nora even though he now has no idea where she is, and he rather guiltily turns down Selma’s advances. One night Selma shows him a video of a film by Charlie Chaplin (The Cure, produced by Mutual Studios in 1917 — though Selma tells him in the dialogue it’s from 1928), and at first Jacob is outraged that so liberal a country as Canada would make a film ridiculing his disability. Selma explains to him that not only is it an old movie, but the person who made it is considered a comic genius. She persuades Jacob to join her as a busker, doing an act called “Jacob and the Pig” in which he dresses in Chaplin’s “Tramp” costume, and they become so sensationally popular that the advertising agency behind Le Savoir perfume hires Jacob to shoot an ad layout for them in Chaplin drag. (The assistant to the agency’s casting director is obviously Gay, and the subtle way he holds Jacob’s hand, hoping that will be the start of a seduction while the terminally naïve Jacob is totally unaware of his intentions, is especially nice.) This makes him at least a minor local star in Toronto and starts making him money, though his success is dimmed when one day, while he’s out performing, his roommates receive a call from his “brother number six” (his parents had 13 kids in all) telling him that their father has just died.
The film ends with a big scene in which he crashes the special Sunday-night gatherings at Selma’s workplace, the Club Paradise — on Sunday nights the club closes to the regular public but is open to an invited crowd, and part of the attraction is that various patrons impersonate famous people, some living and some dead. Jacob is particularly taken by Khalil Gibran (Omar Sharif — Charles joked that his fee probably ate up most of the filmmakers’ budget), who spouts some of the pseudo-prophetic lines from the real Gibran’s writings — and the club bills Leonard Cohen (still very much alive in 1997) as their featured attraction, though what both we and the patrons actually see is an actor (Danny Marks) impersonating Cohen and lip-synching to the real Cohen’s record “Dance Me to the End of Love.” Then there’s a scene in which, in order to mourn his father, Jacob goes to a cemetery and lights on the tombstone of a man named McBride inscribed with some fly-on-my-sweet-angel sentiments, and a relative of the real McBride shows up to leave a flower on the grave and play a piece on the violin — which for some reason inspires Jacob to jettison the Chaplin drag and face his future as himself. Heaven Before I Die (it’s not altogether clear why it’s called that) is clever and a real charmer, though early on I thought it was working too hard to be clever and charming; stories of an innocent naïf emigrating and experiencing culture shock aren’t exactly the freshest plot lines in cinema, but the basic premise is well done here. It’s also one low-budget film whose director is able to make its budget limitations work for him; he shot in 1.33-1 aspect ratio instead of any of the wide-screen formats (and it was jolting to see the “film” credit to “Kodak of Canada” and realize this was in the day when even low-budget films were actually shot on film instead of with digital equipment), and the compact format and naturalistic colors give the movie an intimate quality that works for the story. I don’t know what possessed me to be interested enough in Heaven Before I Die to buy the DVD, but it turned out to be well worth the money and time (the running time is a nice 95 minutes, just long enough to do justice to its story without feeling bloated the way some longer big-budget movies have) Charles and I invested in seeing it.
Last night Charles and I watched Heaven Before I Die, which had been sitting in my backlog for quite a while (I must have bought it online but I can’t remember from what source or what quirky algorithm guided me to it), which turned out to be a 1997 independent production from Canada, written and directed by Izidore K. Musallam. It’s about a young man named Jacob who’s born in occupied Palestine, in Jerusalem (there’s a grimly funny sequence in which he goes to a call center to pay for a long-distance phone call to his family back home, and he grandly announces to the operator that he wants to place a call to “Jerusalem, The Holy Land,” and is rather officioualy informed, “The only Jerusalem we have listed is in Israel”) with such a severe case of pronation — the condition in which your feet are at an angle and your toes point outward instead of staying parallel with the rest of your body — that he looks and walks like Charlie Chaplin. Needless to say, he’s continually being teased about this, both as a child (he’s played by three actors — Hannin Eisa Abu-Alhumos as a baby, Mohammed Eisa Abu-Alhumos as a boy, and the devastatingly handsome Andy Velasquez as an adult through most of the film) and when he grows up, falls diffidently in love with a local girl named Nora (Ruti Moinster), only to be heartbroken when, before he’s had the chance to have sex or do much of anything physical with her, she decides to emigrate. Several years later Jacob decides to emigrate, too, after he sees a gang of smugglers give a street presentation promoting Canada as “the real land of milk and honey” and a good place for a young Palestinian to go to flee the Israeli occupation and the ultra-limited job prospects at home. There’s a nicely amusing scene in which the Asian-born man who’s supposed to help him says that a “sip” is waiting to take him to Boston, from where he can hitch a ride to Toronto, and it takes quite a while before he realizes the word is “ship.”
Once he makes it to Toronto he falls in with two small-time crooks, likewise undocumented immigrants to Canada, named Sharif (played by Giancarlo Giannini, who in the early 1970’s briefly became an international star through his roles in Lina Wertmuller’s movies The Seduction of Mimi, Swept Away and Seven Beauties) and Stavros (Geoffrey Lower — his character is listed in the credits as “Sterrea,” presumably his last name, but “Stavros” is how he’s addressed throughout the film). They agree to put Jacob up, only his first night at their place he walks into their living room in the middle of the night on his way to the kitchen to get some food — and he sees Sharif, Stavros and their poker buddies (watching this movie I couldn’t help but recall the similar scenes of proletarian men playing poker in Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire — indeed, Williams’ working title for that play was The Poker Night) hunching over a piece of graph paper on which is drawn the floor plan for some building. From the drawing and from their conversation, with its references to an “in-and-out” job, it’s obvious they’re planning something illegal, but it’s not clear exactly what (Charles thought they were plotting to rob a convenience store, I thought they were going after a bank) until later in the film. It seems they’ve devised a gadget they can stick into the card slot of an ATM to hack it and get it to dispense all its cash on hand — which comes out as a series of red-and-white bills that probably don’t look at all like real Canadian money (throughout Hollywood’s classic era the U.S. Treasury Department forbade the use of real American currency in Hollywood films, and in 1949 the producers of the film T-Men made a big deal out of the fact that theirs was the first film to show genuine American money: since the film was about counterfeiters and much of the plot turned around the ability — or lack thereof — of the counterfeiters to make their money look like the real deal, actually showing the real deal was important to the filmmakers, so they cut a deal with the Treasury Department to let them show it) — and though they tell Jacob to wait in the car while they do this, he gets out and his Chaplinesque stumbles attract the attention of the security guard and thereby inadvertently help his crook roommates get away with it.
The next time they try it, though, he gets chased by a cab driver who’s long dreamed of making a citizen’s arrest and he ends up spending the night in jail, only to be bailed out by Selma (Joanna Pacula), a waitress at a club the crooks frequent, whom Sharif wanted as a girlfriend but who only has eyes for Jacob. Selma and Jacob drift into a rather odd relationship, hampered by the fact that back home he pledged fidelity to Nora even though he now has no idea where she is, and he rather guiltily turns down Selma’s advances. One night Selma shows him a video of a film by Charlie Chaplin (The Cure, produced by Mutual Studios in 1917 — though Selma tells him in the dialogue it’s from 1928), and at first Jacob is outraged that so liberal a country as Canada would make a film ridiculing his disability. Selma explains to him that not only is it an old movie, but the person who made it is considered a comic genius. She persuades Jacob to join her as a busker, doing an act called “Jacob and the Pig” in which he dresses in Chaplin’s “Tramp” costume, and they become so sensationally popular that the advertising agency behind Le Savoir perfume hires Jacob to shoot an ad layout for them in Chaplin drag. (The assistant to the agency’s casting director is obviously Gay, and the subtle way he holds Jacob’s hand, hoping that will be the start of a seduction while the terminally naïve Jacob is totally unaware of his intentions, is especially nice.) This makes him at least a minor local star in Toronto and starts making him money, though his success is dimmed when one day, while he’s out performing, his roommates receive a call from his “brother number six” (his parents had 13 kids in all) telling him that their father has just died.
The film ends with a big scene in which he crashes the special Sunday-night gatherings at Selma’s workplace, the Club Paradise — on Sunday nights the club closes to the regular public but is open to an invited crowd, and part of the attraction is that various patrons impersonate famous people, some living and some dead. Jacob is particularly taken by Khalil Gibran (Omar Sharif — Charles joked that his fee probably ate up most of the filmmakers’ budget), who spouts some of the pseudo-prophetic lines from the real Gibran’s writings — and the club bills Leonard Cohen (still very much alive in 1997) as their featured attraction, though what both we and the patrons actually see is an actor (Danny Marks) impersonating Cohen and lip-synching to the real Cohen’s record “Dance Me to the End of Love.” Then there’s a scene in which, in order to mourn his father, Jacob goes to a cemetery and lights on the tombstone of a man named McBride inscribed with some fly-on-my-sweet-angel sentiments, and a relative of the real McBride shows up to leave a flower on the grave and play a piece on the violin — which for some reason inspires Jacob to jettison the Chaplin drag and face his future as himself. Heaven Before I Die (it’s not altogether clear why it’s called that) is clever and a real charmer, though early on I thought it was working too hard to be clever and charming; stories of an innocent naïf emigrating and experiencing culture shock aren’t exactly the freshest plot lines in cinema, but the basic premise is well done here. It’s also one low-budget film whose director is able to make its budget limitations work for him; he shot in 1.33-1 aspect ratio instead of any of the wide-screen formats (and it was jolting to see the “film” credit to “Kodak of Canada” and realize this was in the day when even low-budget films were actually shot on film instead of with digital equipment), and the compact format and naturalistic colors give the movie an intimate quality that works for the story. I don’t know what possessed me to be interested enough in Heaven Before I Die to buy the DVD, but it turned out to be well worth the money and time (the running time is a nice 95 minutes, just long enough to do justice to its story without feeling bloated the way some longer big-budget movies have) Charles and I invested in seeing it.
Friday, April 28, 2017
Midsomer Murders: “Hidden Depths” (Bentley Productions/ITV Channel Four, 2005)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
I put on KPBS for what turned out to be a 12-year-old rerun from the British TV series Midsomer Murders (the odd spelling of the first word is actually the name of the rural British county where the show takes place — and the series has been running since 1997 and is still on the air, a record that would make Dick Wolf green with envy). Usually this is a show I avoid because the ITV commercial TV channel in Britain that produced it split every episode into two parts so they could air each story in two one-hour time slots, and the PBS stations that rerun it in the U.S. have the annoying habit of breaking the two parts so they air the second half of one story and then the first half of another. Fortunately, last night KPBS had an attack of good sense and showed both parts of a Midsomer Murders episode, “Hidden Depths,” back-to-back so I could see the entire show in one go. It turned out to be surprisingly dark for a British rural mystery, with the usual pairing of two white male cops — the older official Tom Barnaby (John Nettles) and the younger (and quite hunky!) Sgt. Dan Scott (John Hopkins) — attempting to solve the mystery of the death of solicitor (that’s Brit-speak for corporate or business attorney, as opposed to “barrister,” which is what they call a courtroom attorney) Nick Turner (James Weber Brown). When the episode opens he’s just taken a plunge off the roof of his home, and the question the cops have to ponder is whether he killed himself or was murdered. Of course they immediately suspect Nick’s wife Felicity (played by the striking red-haired actress Lucy Russell) and guess that Nick might have been killed either by Felicity herself or by his friend Jack Wilmot (Matthew Flynn), with whom Felicity was supposedly having an affair. But this theory is complicated when Wilmot disappears, and as Barnaby and Scott dig deeper into the case they run into a locally unpopular old man named Otto Benham (Oliver Ford Davis), who has a wife who uses a wheelchair (thanks to injuries she sustained in a car crash) and wants to be rid of him because he abuses her; Peter Blagdon (Charles Millham), ne’er-do-well brother of local landowner Anthony Blagdon (whom we never see) who’s just returned to the area after years outside the country — or has he? Maybe he’s just impersonating the real one … which turns out to be the case, since he’s part of an elaborate scheme along with local con artist Mike Spicer (Robert Daws — and yes, under current U.S. political circumstances it was nice to be watching a show in which one of the bad guys was named “Spicer”!).
They stumbled on a long-lost secret cellar on the Blagdon property that had once been used for wine, and while the cellar was empty when they found it they hit on a scheme to defraud Nick Turner of 150,000 pounds by claiming it was full of 1960’s era wine of especially high quality and selling it to him on the black market. They put one bottle of genuinely rare, collectible wine in the cellar so Nick would check it with a vintner and be told it was valuable — the rest they just bought at local supermarkets and soaked off the original labels (one gets the impression it was the British equivalent of Two-Buck Chuck), then put on counterfeits of the high-priced vintage labels and sprayed the cellar with white gunk to make it look like the cellar and the wines inside it had been gathering dust for over 40 years. Then, after taking Nick’s and another “investor”’s money, they ran the van containing the false wines off the road and claimed the whole lot had been destroyed in a regrettable accident — and Nick, realizing he’d been conned, worked out an elaborate revenge plot. First he would fake his own death — with his wife’s assistance: she flirted publicly with his friend Jack to create the illusion that they were having an affair, then Nick pushed Jack off the roof of his house and passed Jack off as Nick, going to the point of dressing him in a suit identical to one worn regularly by Nick (though how they kept Jack’s own wife Antonia, played by Nancy Carroll, from recognizing her husband was something writer David Hoskins didn’t do a good job explaining), then knocked off the other participants in unusual and kinky ways. Nick nailed Otto to his own croquet field and used a reproduction of an old Roman catapult that was part of Otto’s collection to fire wine bottles at him — and in the show’s most chilling moment Otto’s wife, watching the scene from her balcony window, said to the masked killer, “I would suggest you aim a little bit more to the right” — and he literally drowned Mike Spicer (a former actor who was once up for a BAFTA — the British equivalent of the Academy Awards — “or at least I should have been,” he adds) inside a television while videotaping the killing (and later watching the tape with his wife; the cops arrest them just as they’re gleefully watching the tape of Spicer die). This was one of those British mysteries that almost sinks from the sheer confusion of its multiple plot lines, plethora of suspects and overall level of chaos, but the kinkiness of the murder plot and the outrageousness of the situations makes up for that.
I put on KPBS for what turned out to be a 12-year-old rerun from the British TV series Midsomer Murders (the odd spelling of the first word is actually the name of the rural British county where the show takes place — and the series has been running since 1997 and is still on the air, a record that would make Dick Wolf green with envy). Usually this is a show I avoid because the ITV commercial TV channel in Britain that produced it split every episode into two parts so they could air each story in two one-hour time slots, and the PBS stations that rerun it in the U.S. have the annoying habit of breaking the two parts so they air the second half of one story and then the first half of another. Fortunately, last night KPBS had an attack of good sense and showed both parts of a Midsomer Murders episode, “Hidden Depths,” back-to-back so I could see the entire show in one go. It turned out to be surprisingly dark for a British rural mystery, with the usual pairing of two white male cops — the older official Tom Barnaby (John Nettles) and the younger (and quite hunky!) Sgt. Dan Scott (John Hopkins) — attempting to solve the mystery of the death of solicitor (that’s Brit-speak for corporate or business attorney, as opposed to “barrister,” which is what they call a courtroom attorney) Nick Turner (James Weber Brown). When the episode opens he’s just taken a plunge off the roof of his home, and the question the cops have to ponder is whether he killed himself or was murdered. Of course they immediately suspect Nick’s wife Felicity (played by the striking red-haired actress Lucy Russell) and guess that Nick might have been killed either by Felicity herself or by his friend Jack Wilmot (Matthew Flynn), with whom Felicity was supposedly having an affair. But this theory is complicated when Wilmot disappears, and as Barnaby and Scott dig deeper into the case they run into a locally unpopular old man named Otto Benham (Oliver Ford Davis), who has a wife who uses a wheelchair (thanks to injuries she sustained in a car crash) and wants to be rid of him because he abuses her; Peter Blagdon (Charles Millham), ne’er-do-well brother of local landowner Anthony Blagdon (whom we never see) who’s just returned to the area after years outside the country — or has he? Maybe he’s just impersonating the real one … which turns out to be the case, since he’s part of an elaborate scheme along with local con artist Mike Spicer (Robert Daws — and yes, under current U.S. political circumstances it was nice to be watching a show in which one of the bad guys was named “Spicer”!).
They stumbled on a long-lost secret cellar on the Blagdon property that had once been used for wine, and while the cellar was empty when they found it they hit on a scheme to defraud Nick Turner of 150,000 pounds by claiming it was full of 1960’s era wine of especially high quality and selling it to him on the black market. They put one bottle of genuinely rare, collectible wine in the cellar so Nick would check it with a vintner and be told it was valuable — the rest they just bought at local supermarkets and soaked off the original labels (one gets the impression it was the British equivalent of Two-Buck Chuck), then put on counterfeits of the high-priced vintage labels and sprayed the cellar with white gunk to make it look like the cellar and the wines inside it had been gathering dust for over 40 years. Then, after taking Nick’s and another “investor”’s money, they ran the van containing the false wines off the road and claimed the whole lot had been destroyed in a regrettable accident — and Nick, realizing he’d been conned, worked out an elaborate revenge plot. First he would fake his own death — with his wife’s assistance: she flirted publicly with his friend Jack to create the illusion that they were having an affair, then Nick pushed Jack off the roof of his house and passed Jack off as Nick, going to the point of dressing him in a suit identical to one worn regularly by Nick (though how they kept Jack’s own wife Antonia, played by Nancy Carroll, from recognizing her husband was something writer David Hoskins didn’t do a good job explaining), then knocked off the other participants in unusual and kinky ways. Nick nailed Otto to his own croquet field and used a reproduction of an old Roman catapult that was part of Otto’s collection to fire wine bottles at him — and in the show’s most chilling moment Otto’s wife, watching the scene from her balcony window, said to the masked killer, “I would suggest you aim a little bit more to the right” — and he literally drowned Mike Spicer (a former actor who was once up for a BAFTA — the British equivalent of the Academy Awards — “or at least I should have been,” he adds) inside a television while videotaping the killing (and later watching the tape with his wife; the cops arrest them just as they’re gleefully watching the tape of Spicer die). This was one of those British mysteries that almost sinks from the sheer confusion of its multiple plot lines, plethora of suspects and overall level of chaos, but the kinkiness of the murder plot and the outrageousness of the situations makes up for that.
Wednesday, April 26, 2017
Doctor Who: “The Moonbase” (BBC Wales TV, 1967)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Charles and I had a chance to watch a movie together last night and I picked out the DVD of a Doctor Who sequence from 1967, “The Moonbase,” featuring Patrick Troughton, the second Doctor. One of the conceits of the show is that the Doctor, a Time Lord from the planet Gallifrey, can periodically rearrange his atoms at will and change his appearance — thereby giving the producers of the show the chance to replace the actor playing the Doctor and “explain” his different looks by saying he’s just rearranged his atoms. (Charles was a bit put out when the BBC recently announced their latest casting change so there’s now a 13th actor playing the Doctor, when the original series posited that he could only have 12 alternate appearances, like the proverbial nine-lived cat.) We’d seen one previous run in this series of reissue DVD’s, a French Revolution story with the original Doctor, William Hartnell; this time it was a science-fiction tale instead of a history lesson (apparently the original intent of the series was that it would teach kids about real-life historical events by creating versions that wrote the Doctor and his sidekicks into them) and ran only four half-hour episodes instead of six. Once again we were at the mercy of the BBC’s policy in the 1960’s of “wiping” — that is, erasing and reusing the videotapes — their lighter fare (as I’ve noted in these pages before, six of the original 45 Monty Python shows were lost to this policy and the only reason the other 39 survive is some anonymous bureaucrat at the BBC put a note on them saying, “Save these. We may be able to do something with them in the States”); the original second and fourth episodes of the run survived but the first and third existed only as soundtracks (I guess they were broadcasting these as radio shows as well as on TV) and had to be reconstructed via animation synched to the original soundtracks.
I was also amused that the villains, the Cybermen (a returning Doctor Who menace who’d already been introduced earlier and apparently killed off when the Earthlings destroyed their home planet — which meant that the cast were startled when they turned up again this soon after the apocalypse that supposedly wiped them out), were supposed to be robots made of metal, but the folds of their cloth costumes were clearly visible as they walked, especially when they were shown with their backs to the camera. It got even more amusing when the show switched from live-action episode 2 to animated episode 3 and the animators had faithfully reproduced the revealing mistake of the cloth folds being visible! “The Moonbase” was actually quite a good science-fiction tale that, according to the surviving actors being interviewed for the making-of feature on the DVD, got added weight and heft from the fact that it was being shot during the early stages of the Apollo program and everyone involved with the program — including producer Innes Lloyd, director Morris Barry and writer Kit Pedler — were well aware that in just a few years humans would be on the moon for real. The show is set in the year 2070, by which time humans have not only colonized the moon but have set up a base there containing a “gravitron,” a sort of giant device that looks like a cross between a telescope and a cannon and which can alter the earth’s gravitational field so it affects the tides and thereby changes earth’s weather. The idea is to keep things as temperate as possible and make sure that any hurricanes or other big storms exhaust themselves harmlessly over oceans instead of striking dry land and causing loss of life and property.
Only just as the Doctor and his sidekicks Jamie (Frazer Hines), Polly (Anneke Wills) and Ben (Michael Craze, who must have endured a formidable amount of teasing over his last name when he was a kid!) arrive at the moonbase — true to form, the Doctor was aiming for Mars but missed — the weather machine starts going haywire due to the graviton going out of control. Hurricanes start hitting places like Florida after decades during which the Floridians haven’t had to worry about them, and the moonbase commander, Jack Hobson (Patrick Barr, who’d previously played Patrick Troughton’s father on stage in a play called Honor Bright), is trying to figure out what’s going wrong. At first this exasperated in-over-his-head bureaucrat blames the Doctor and his crew for sabotaging the gravitron, but eventually he learns that the real cause is an invading force of Cybermen from flying saucers who have broken into the moonbase through its storage room and sickened a lot of the staff with a “neurotropic virus” that first makes their nervous system visible through their skin and then immobilizes and finally kills them. (There’s a howler of a scientific mistake in Pedler’s script: the Doctor discovers the virus by looking at it on a slide under an ordinary visible-light microscope; viruses, unlike bacteria, are too small to be seen through a visible-light microscope, which is one reason it took so long to discover them.) Only the Cybermen usually don’t wait for the virus to kill the human victims; instead they want to take them over and put them under control of the Cybermen’s hive-mind so they’ll become accomplices in the Cybermen’s plan to turn the gravitron against Earth and destroy it.
For this series the producers made some impressive changes in the Cybermen’s costuming — instead of wearing stocking masks over their faces to denote “cybericity” they got full metal masks which I suspect costume designers Daphne Dare, Alexandra Tyson and Mary Woods copied from the Iron Man comic books, and when we didn’t see those giveaway cloth folds the lamé suits they wore looked suitably metallic for robot-people. Also, though 11 actors played the Cybermen visually on screen, they were all voiced by the same person, which left the actors playing humans sometimes confused about which Cyberman was speaking to them and therefore whom they should turn to when they gave their response line. “The Moonbase” has some good suspense moments and nice bits of dry wit in Pedler’s script — my favorite line was when the Commander back Earth (Alan Rowe) gives Hobson some utterly impractical bit of instruction and Hobson mutters under his breath, “He’ll probably get knighted for this” — as well as a surprisingly butch performance by Patrick Troughton as the Doctor. During the show I had assumed Troughton was deliberately modeling his acting on Richard Burton’s and had decided to make the Doctor more butch, without the screaming-queen nelliness that had afflicted the otherwise charming acting of his predecessor, William Hartnell — but in the making-of featurette Anneke Wills recalled that Troughton loved the camp aspects of the show and, among other things, was begging its writers for scripts in which he could do drag. Apparently it was director Barry who pushed Troughton’s performance in these episodes away from camp and towards a more serious, action-oriented reading of the character.
“The Moonbase” drags in spots, and the junctures between the surviving live action and the animation jar (and given all the time, money and trouble that went into the production — including building an elaborate set of the moon’s surface that apparently took up virtually all of Ealing Studios, one of three facilities used to make this show — it seems bizarre to say the least that the BBC should have had such a cavalier attitude towards it that they erased two of the four episodes just to recycle the videotape!), but overall it’s a quite good science-fiction tale and the special effects are considerably more credible than they were in the first Cybermen story (which Charles and I watched together on videotape ages ago and in which I invidiously compared the effects to those in the original Star Trek, which was made about the same time but had the benefit of larger production budgets and color) even though some of the costumes and props are endearingly tacky — including the white plastic household bottles we’re supposed to believe supply the astronauts with oxygen when they’re in spacesuits on the surface of the moon. According to the surviving actors interviewed on the making-of featurette, the real problem with the spacesuits is that their helmets were clear plastic bubbles (not the metal helmets with plastic visors that real astronauts wore) and that they fogged up quite quickly so you couldn’t see. Frazer Hines recalled that no sooner were you encased in the spacesuit that you’d develop a virtually uncontrollable urge to do some normal bodily function you couldn’t do in that costume, like scratch your nose or use the restroom — the latter just had to wait until they finished shooting and could give the go-ahead for the laborious process of dismantling the costume and getting you out of it again. Ah, the practical problems of making a science-fiction movie!
Charles and I had a chance to watch a movie together last night and I picked out the DVD of a Doctor Who sequence from 1967, “The Moonbase,” featuring Patrick Troughton, the second Doctor. One of the conceits of the show is that the Doctor, a Time Lord from the planet Gallifrey, can periodically rearrange his atoms at will and change his appearance — thereby giving the producers of the show the chance to replace the actor playing the Doctor and “explain” his different looks by saying he’s just rearranged his atoms. (Charles was a bit put out when the BBC recently announced their latest casting change so there’s now a 13th actor playing the Doctor, when the original series posited that he could only have 12 alternate appearances, like the proverbial nine-lived cat.) We’d seen one previous run in this series of reissue DVD’s, a French Revolution story with the original Doctor, William Hartnell; this time it was a science-fiction tale instead of a history lesson (apparently the original intent of the series was that it would teach kids about real-life historical events by creating versions that wrote the Doctor and his sidekicks into them) and ran only four half-hour episodes instead of six. Once again we were at the mercy of the BBC’s policy in the 1960’s of “wiping” — that is, erasing and reusing the videotapes — their lighter fare (as I’ve noted in these pages before, six of the original 45 Monty Python shows were lost to this policy and the only reason the other 39 survive is some anonymous bureaucrat at the BBC put a note on them saying, “Save these. We may be able to do something with them in the States”); the original second and fourth episodes of the run survived but the first and third existed only as soundtracks (I guess they were broadcasting these as radio shows as well as on TV) and had to be reconstructed via animation synched to the original soundtracks.
I was also amused that the villains, the Cybermen (a returning Doctor Who menace who’d already been introduced earlier and apparently killed off when the Earthlings destroyed their home planet — which meant that the cast were startled when they turned up again this soon after the apocalypse that supposedly wiped them out), were supposed to be robots made of metal, but the folds of their cloth costumes were clearly visible as they walked, especially when they were shown with their backs to the camera. It got even more amusing when the show switched from live-action episode 2 to animated episode 3 and the animators had faithfully reproduced the revealing mistake of the cloth folds being visible! “The Moonbase” was actually quite a good science-fiction tale that, according to the surviving actors being interviewed for the making-of feature on the DVD, got added weight and heft from the fact that it was being shot during the early stages of the Apollo program and everyone involved with the program — including producer Innes Lloyd, director Morris Barry and writer Kit Pedler — were well aware that in just a few years humans would be on the moon for real. The show is set in the year 2070, by which time humans have not only colonized the moon but have set up a base there containing a “gravitron,” a sort of giant device that looks like a cross between a telescope and a cannon and which can alter the earth’s gravitational field so it affects the tides and thereby changes earth’s weather. The idea is to keep things as temperate as possible and make sure that any hurricanes or other big storms exhaust themselves harmlessly over oceans instead of striking dry land and causing loss of life and property.
Only just as the Doctor and his sidekicks Jamie (Frazer Hines), Polly (Anneke Wills) and Ben (Michael Craze, who must have endured a formidable amount of teasing over his last name when he was a kid!) arrive at the moonbase — true to form, the Doctor was aiming for Mars but missed — the weather machine starts going haywire due to the graviton going out of control. Hurricanes start hitting places like Florida after decades during which the Floridians haven’t had to worry about them, and the moonbase commander, Jack Hobson (Patrick Barr, who’d previously played Patrick Troughton’s father on stage in a play called Honor Bright), is trying to figure out what’s going wrong. At first this exasperated in-over-his-head bureaucrat blames the Doctor and his crew for sabotaging the gravitron, but eventually he learns that the real cause is an invading force of Cybermen from flying saucers who have broken into the moonbase through its storage room and sickened a lot of the staff with a “neurotropic virus” that first makes their nervous system visible through their skin and then immobilizes and finally kills them. (There’s a howler of a scientific mistake in Pedler’s script: the Doctor discovers the virus by looking at it on a slide under an ordinary visible-light microscope; viruses, unlike bacteria, are too small to be seen through a visible-light microscope, which is one reason it took so long to discover them.) Only the Cybermen usually don’t wait for the virus to kill the human victims; instead they want to take them over and put them under control of the Cybermen’s hive-mind so they’ll become accomplices in the Cybermen’s plan to turn the gravitron against Earth and destroy it.
For this series the producers made some impressive changes in the Cybermen’s costuming — instead of wearing stocking masks over their faces to denote “cybericity” they got full metal masks which I suspect costume designers Daphne Dare, Alexandra Tyson and Mary Woods copied from the Iron Man comic books, and when we didn’t see those giveaway cloth folds the lamé suits they wore looked suitably metallic for robot-people. Also, though 11 actors played the Cybermen visually on screen, they were all voiced by the same person, which left the actors playing humans sometimes confused about which Cyberman was speaking to them and therefore whom they should turn to when they gave their response line. “The Moonbase” has some good suspense moments and nice bits of dry wit in Pedler’s script — my favorite line was when the Commander back Earth (Alan Rowe) gives Hobson some utterly impractical bit of instruction and Hobson mutters under his breath, “He’ll probably get knighted for this” — as well as a surprisingly butch performance by Patrick Troughton as the Doctor. During the show I had assumed Troughton was deliberately modeling his acting on Richard Burton’s and had decided to make the Doctor more butch, without the screaming-queen nelliness that had afflicted the otherwise charming acting of his predecessor, William Hartnell — but in the making-of featurette Anneke Wills recalled that Troughton loved the camp aspects of the show and, among other things, was begging its writers for scripts in which he could do drag. Apparently it was director Barry who pushed Troughton’s performance in these episodes away from camp and towards a more serious, action-oriented reading of the character.
“The Moonbase” drags in spots, and the junctures between the surviving live action and the animation jar (and given all the time, money and trouble that went into the production — including building an elaborate set of the moon’s surface that apparently took up virtually all of Ealing Studios, one of three facilities used to make this show — it seems bizarre to say the least that the BBC should have had such a cavalier attitude towards it that they erased two of the four episodes just to recycle the videotape!), but overall it’s a quite good science-fiction tale and the special effects are considerably more credible than they were in the first Cybermen story (which Charles and I watched together on videotape ages ago and in which I invidiously compared the effects to those in the original Star Trek, which was made about the same time but had the benefit of larger production budgets and color) even though some of the costumes and props are endearingly tacky — including the white plastic household bottles we’re supposed to believe supply the astronauts with oxygen when they’re in spacesuits on the surface of the moon. According to the surviving actors interviewed on the making-of featurette, the real problem with the spacesuits is that their helmets were clear plastic bubbles (not the metal helmets with plastic visors that real astronauts wore) and that they fogged up quite quickly so you couldn’t see. Frazer Hines recalled that no sooner were you encased in the spacesuit that you’d develop a virtually uncontrollable urge to do some normal bodily function you couldn’t do in that costume, like scratch your nose or use the restroom — the latter just had to wait until they finished shooting and could give the go-ahead for the laborious process of dismantling the costume and getting you out of it again. Ah, the practical problems of making a science-fiction movie!
Monday, April 24, 2017
The Psycho She Met Online (Reel One Entertainment, NB Thrilling Films, Thrill Films, Lifetime, 2017)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night Lifetime ran two “Premiere” movies — unusually given that it was Sunday instead of Saturday, the night they usually reserve for these sorts of shows — including one called The Psycho She Met Online which, despite its formula title, I had hopes for because Christine Conradt was the screenwriter and her frequent collaborator, Curtis James Crawford, was the director. Alas, this time around Conradt put all too little flesh on the bones of her (and Lifetime’s) usual formula. This time the heroine is Karen Hexley (Chelsea Hobbs), an emergency medical technician (EMT) in Philadelphia who makes national headlines when the man whose life she saves after he’s involved in a car accident is her husband Andrew (Matthew Lawrence, who for some reason wears his hair long in a “do” that makes him look like Caitlyn Jenner immediately before her final transition), even though she hadn’t known when she went out on the call that the victim would indeed be he. The titular psycho she’s going to meet online is Miranda Breyers (Charity Shea — inevitably I find myself wondering if she has sisters named Faith and Hope), who answers Karen’s ad to rent out her spare room on “Vacay ’n’ Stay,” a fictitious Web site obviously patterned on Airbnb — yes, it’s Lifetime’s latest attempt to keep up with the times and plug their familiar formulae into the world of smartphones and apps. Having already given us a rapist who meets his victims by being an Uber driver, now they have a psycho locating her victim via Airbnb (or something very much like it). Of course, one key element of the formula is that the heroine has to have a best friend who cottons onto the game the psycho is really playing even as she poses as nice ’n’ perky to win the heroine’s trust — though in this story that role is split between two people. One is Aubrey Hunt (Alexis Maitland), Karen’s sorority “sister” from college — with whom she’s sustained a strong relationship since she was (at least as far as she knows) an only child and never had a real biological sister — and the other is her other “Vacay ’n’ Stay” tenant, a charming old British nature photographer named Evander Swanson (Robert Welch) whom Miranda ambushes and kills because he’s getting too nosy about her and her background and she’s worried he will find her out.
Exactly what there is to find out about her remains a mystery: when we first meet Miranda she’s in Portland, Oregon, living with a creepy layabout boyfriend who bears a striking resemblance to the late Kurt Cobain, only without the scraggly beard, and when he tries to keep her from leaving she kicks him in the balls until he falls down, then kicks him again with the stiletto heel of one of her shoes (which, it’s later established, she stole from a store and did a three-month jail sentence for shoplifting) and walks out. Her departure for Philadelphia, where the main part of the story takes place, is explained by her seeing a story about Karen Hexley saving her husband’s life on the Internet, and at first we (or at least I) think she recognized Andrew as a former boyfriend and wanted revenge on the woman who took him away from her. When Miranda shows up in Philadelphia and “randomly” answers Karen’s Vacay ’n’ Stay ad, she’s as sweet as can be at first but also awesomely possessive about Karen, to the point of bugging her bedroom with a video camera (one wonders if she’s interested in eavesdropping while Karen and Andrew are having sex, but as it turns out that’s about the last of her concerns) and going into a jealous hissy-fit when she sees how closely bonded Karen and her sorority sister Aubrey are. Miranda — who tells Karen she’s working as a personal trainer but is actually a stripper — also sets out to seduce Andrew’s brother Tyler (Yani Gellman, to my mind considerably cuter than Matthew Lawrence!), apparently as a means of bonding ever closer to Karen’s family, since she’s already told Karen that she’s her half-sister — Karen’s mom had an affair with Miranda’s dad while still married to Karen’s dad. We’re half-expecting that Karen will find that Miranda is lying about that, but as things turn out that’s the one thing Miranda says about her background that’s actually true — when Karen’s dad found out that his wife was pregnant by another man he agreed to take her back but only on condition that she put the baby up for adoption, and as a result Miranda was raised by another family and the adoption records were kept secret until a recent change in the law opened them, whereupon Miranda traced her mom to an alternative cancer clinic in Mexico. The story Miranda told Karen was that mom committed suicide when her cancer was so advanced she was going to die anyway — but in fact Miranda killed mom when mom refused to have anything to do with her, then strung her up by a shower rod to make it look like she’d killed herself.
Eventually there’s a typical Christine Conradt confrontation scene in which Miranda sneaks into Karen’s home (by this time Karen has thrown her out) and grabs a kitchen knife, intending to murder both Andrew and Karen with it — she gets as far as stabbing Andrew, though not fatally, and is about to kill Karen when the police arrive in the person of a very butch woman detective who shoots Miranda down before she can kill Karen. Christine Conradt’s usual trademark as a Lifetime writer is moral ambiguity — she likes to make her villains complex characters so we feel for them even as we root for the rather simple-minded heroines (or, more rarely, heroes) they’re attempting to entrap — but on this script she offered us way too little on What Made Miranda Run and mostly ran the Lifetime cliché machine on autopilot. Either that or she was rewritten: this was actually filmed under the title The Guest She Met Online and changed to the more florid and obvious title The Psycho She Met Online, and while no other writer is credited it’s possible someone rewrote Conradt’s script, not enough to qualify for credit but enough to make the film itself, as well as its title, more blatantly black-and-white in its morality. The acting is O.K. — no one really stands out, and Chelsea Hobbs is such a blah screen presence it’s hard to root for her (especially since Conradt makes her a whiz at her job — though one would think that in the final scene, once her own life was no longer in danger she’d make a bee-line to her wounded husband and treat him, and she doesn’t — but a dolt in virtually everything else), while Charity Shea delivers a good but by-the-numbers performance as the titular psycho: she’s engagingly evil but we’ve seen this sort of acting in a million other Lifetime movies. And the men are simply along for the ride, though Yani Gellman has some nice moments when he realizes the woman he’s just taken home and screwed is his sister-in-law and he’s revolted because it feels incestuous even though they’re not biological kin.
Last night Lifetime ran two “Premiere” movies — unusually given that it was Sunday instead of Saturday, the night they usually reserve for these sorts of shows — including one called The Psycho She Met Online which, despite its formula title, I had hopes for because Christine Conradt was the screenwriter and her frequent collaborator, Curtis James Crawford, was the director. Alas, this time around Conradt put all too little flesh on the bones of her (and Lifetime’s) usual formula. This time the heroine is Karen Hexley (Chelsea Hobbs), an emergency medical technician (EMT) in Philadelphia who makes national headlines when the man whose life she saves after he’s involved in a car accident is her husband Andrew (Matthew Lawrence, who for some reason wears his hair long in a “do” that makes him look like Caitlyn Jenner immediately before her final transition), even though she hadn’t known when she went out on the call that the victim would indeed be he. The titular psycho she’s going to meet online is Miranda Breyers (Charity Shea — inevitably I find myself wondering if she has sisters named Faith and Hope), who answers Karen’s ad to rent out her spare room on “Vacay ’n’ Stay,” a fictitious Web site obviously patterned on Airbnb — yes, it’s Lifetime’s latest attempt to keep up with the times and plug their familiar formulae into the world of smartphones and apps. Having already given us a rapist who meets his victims by being an Uber driver, now they have a psycho locating her victim via Airbnb (or something very much like it). Of course, one key element of the formula is that the heroine has to have a best friend who cottons onto the game the psycho is really playing even as she poses as nice ’n’ perky to win the heroine’s trust — though in this story that role is split between two people. One is Aubrey Hunt (Alexis Maitland), Karen’s sorority “sister” from college — with whom she’s sustained a strong relationship since she was (at least as far as she knows) an only child and never had a real biological sister — and the other is her other “Vacay ’n’ Stay” tenant, a charming old British nature photographer named Evander Swanson (Robert Welch) whom Miranda ambushes and kills because he’s getting too nosy about her and her background and she’s worried he will find her out.
Exactly what there is to find out about her remains a mystery: when we first meet Miranda she’s in Portland, Oregon, living with a creepy layabout boyfriend who bears a striking resemblance to the late Kurt Cobain, only without the scraggly beard, and when he tries to keep her from leaving she kicks him in the balls until he falls down, then kicks him again with the stiletto heel of one of her shoes (which, it’s later established, she stole from a store and did a three-month jail sentence for shoplifting) and walks out. Her departure for Philadelphia, where the main part of the story takes place, is explained by her seeing a story about Karen Hexley saving her husband’s life on the Internet, and at first we (or at least I) think she recognized Andrew as a former boyfriend and wanted revenge on the woman who took him away from her. When Miranda shows up in Philadelphia and “randomly” answers Karen’s Vacay ’n’ Stay ad, she’s as sweet as can be at first but also awesomely possessive about Karen, to the point of bugging her bedroom with a video camera (one wonders if she’s interested in eavesdropping while Karen and Andrew are having sex, but as it turns out that’s about the last of her concerns) and going into a jealous hissy-fit when she sees how closely bonded Karen and her sorority sister Aubrey are. Miranda — who tells Karen she’s working as a personal trainer but is actually a stripper — also sets out to seduce Andrew’s brother Tyler (Yani Gellman, to my mind considerably cuter than Matthew Lawrence!), apparently as a means of bonding ever closer to Karen’s family, since she’s already told Karen that she’s her half-sister — Karen’s mom had an affair with Miranda’s dad while still married to Karen’s dad. We’re half-expecting that Karen will find that Miranda is lying about that, but as things turn out that’s the one thing Miranda says about her background that’s actually true — when Karen’s dad found out that his wife was pregnant by another man he agreed to take her back but only on condition that she put the baby up for adoption, and as a result Miranda was raised by another family and the adoption records were kept secret until a recent change in the law opened them, whereupon Miranda traced her mom to an alternative cancer clinic in Mexico. The story Miranda told Karen was that mom committed suicide when her cancer was so advanced she was going to die anyway — but in fact Miranda killed mom when mom refused to have anything to do with her, then strung her up by a shower rod to make it look like she’d killed herself.
Eventually there’s a typical Christine Conradt confrontation scene in which Miranda sneaks into Karen’s home (by this time Karen has thrown her out) and grabs a kitchen knife, intending to murder both Andrew and Karen with it — she gets as far as stabbing Andrew, though not fatally, and is about to kill Karen when the police arrive in the person of a very butch woman detective who shoots Miranda down before she can kill Karen. Christine Conradt’s usual trademark as a Lifetime writer is moral ambiguity — she likes to make her villains complex characters so we feel for them even as we root for the rather simple-minded heroines (or, more rarely, heroes) they’re attempting to entrap — but on this script she offered us way too little on What Made Miranda Run and mostly ran the Lifetime cliché machine on autopilot. Either that or she was rewritten: this was actually filmed under the title The Guest She Met Online and changed to the more florid and obvious title The Psycho She Met Online, and while no other writer is credited it’s possible someone rewrote Conradt’s script, not enough to qualify for credit but enough to make the film itself, as well as its title, more blatantly black-and-white in its morality. The acting is O.K. — no one really stands out, and Chelsea Hobbs is such a blah screen presence it’s hard to root for her (especially since Conradt makes her a whiz at her job — though one would think that in the final scene, once her own life was no longer in danger she’d make a bee-line to her wounded husband and treat him, and she doesn’t — but a dolt in virtually everything else), while Charity Shea delivers a good but by-the-numbers performance as the titular psycho: she’s engagingly evil but we’ve seen this sort of acting in a million other Lifetime movies. And the men are simply along for the ride, though Yani Gellman has some nice moments when he realizes the woman he’s just taken home and screwed is his sister-in-law and he’s revolted because it feels incestuous even though they’re not biological kin.
New York Prison Break: The Seduction of Joyce Mitchell (Mountainair Films/Lifetime, 2017)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
After The Psycho She Met Online Lifetime showed a movie they’d been heavily hyping for weeks now: New York Prison Break: The Seduction of Joyce Mitchell, based on a real-life New York prison escape from the Clinton Correctional Facility in June 2015. The escape, in which two convicts with the unfortunate names David Sweat (Joe Anderson) and Richard Matt (Myk Watford) broke out and had help doing so from two prison employees, Joyce Mitchell (Penelope Ann Miller) and Gene Palmer — and were at large for three weeks before Matt was shot down while threatening police with a shotgun and Sweat was taken alive two days later — made national news. Indeed, I can remember thinking when the story broke, “Someday this will be made into a Lifetime movie” — and now here it is. It’s also quite well done, written and directed by Stephen Tolkin — who’s done reality-based Lifetime movies before, including The Craigslist Killer and Cleveland Abduction, and also has some feature-film credits — and vividly acted by the three principals as well as by Daniel Roebuck as Joyce’s husband Lyle, a hapless guy with a penchant for boring the shit out of her with conversational rambles. He’s still turned on by her but she couldn’t be less interested in him — they both work at the local prison and at one point, when he finally suspects she’s smuggling contraband to the prisoners, chews her out for jeopardizing these great jobs they both have, making $50,000 a year each with full health coverage, including dental (reinforcing how prisons have become one of the few industries where well-paying blue-collar jobs are still available — reason enough for working-class voters to support candidates who are “tough on crime”) — even though, as she tells Sweat one day when they’re alone together in the storeroom of the prison’s tailor shop (they make uniforms for the New York state police), she was carrying on an affair with Lyle while still married to husband number one, and in one particular throe of passion they were caught screwing on the railroad tracks behind where they worked. “Didn’t you get splinters?” Sweat asks — though the message Joyce’s story sends him is that here is a woman with a strong sex drive who’d be a sitting duck for a concentrated seduction campaign and would be willing to do anything for a man who’d give her ashes a good hauling, or even throw hints in that direction. We also know that about Joyce because we see her in bed — her husband is there but she’s ignoring him, and he’s already nodding off while she has earbuds on and is listening to a particularly lubricious soft-core porn passage in an audiobook version of a romance novel.
Actually Joyce never gets it on with Sweat — even when she’s caught after the escape and interrogated, and is admitting to just about everything she did (including smuggling the prisoners hacksaw blades and evading the metal detectors by stuffing them in hamburger meat and freezing it), she insists that she and Sweat were never lovers, though she and the much homelier Matt were. We’re told in the dialogue that he has an especially impressive “manhood,” and we get an unmistakable scene in that storeroom in which Joyce gives him oral sex and then he pulls her up for the full “treatment.” Despite its rather clinical title, New York Prison Break works on just about every level, from the intrinsic kinky interest of the story to the highly atmospheric direction Tolkin gives it, to the Hitchcockian game he plays throughout where he shows so much detail of how Sweat and Matt are literally digging their way out of the prison we end up rooting for them to succeed even though Tolkin tried to forestall that sort of moral reversal by beginning his film with a graphic depiction of the crime Sweat and Matt committed (a robbery of a gun store that included shooting down a police officer and torturing the gun-store owner into revealing the location of a secret cash stash the crooks believed he had even though we suspect that, like the victims of In Cold Blood, the “stash” was just a rumor in the crime world and didn’t actually exist). Most prison-escape movies hedge their bets by making the prisoners sympathetic and the jailers the bad guys — either they’re Nazis running a concentration camp or the authorities on Devil’s Island or some such place lording it over unjustly convicted victims — but in this one the bad guys are bad guys, and yet through Tolkin’s writing and direction and the appropriately edgy acting of Anderson and Watford they come off as just the sort of sexually irresistible studs that might turn on a woman like Joyce Mitchell full of unfulfilled sexual longings and desires. Penelope Ann Miller’s performance as Joyce is also excellent, particularly when she switches from bored housewife and career woman to acting like a giddy teenager in the first throes of romantic passion when she gets lurid notes from Sweat and contemplates a future with him on the outside — a dream of hers he, of course, has no intention of fulfilling! Miller manages to bring her (and the character’s) actual age (the actress herself is 53 and looks it — a well-preserved 53, but still 53) and her teenage-style immaturity in her crush on Sweat (even though it’s Matt, not Sweat, who does the down-’n’-dirty with her — and we see her fantasy of the three of them in Mexico jointly canoodling at a beach resort) into a nerve-wracking and rather repulsive juncture that makes us want to walk into the screen and tell her, “Just act your age already!”
New York Prison Break is obviously an exploitation film aimed at taking advantage of the publicity surrounding the real event, and yet it’s also a finely honed piece of drama — not a great film by any means, but a solidly appealing one that manages to offer quality entertainment and is particularly good at dramatizing the sexual frustration that leads Joyce Mitchell to her fatal infatuation with Sweat and Matt. (One thing Tolkin’s focus on Joyce’s literal and figurative “seduction” led him to do was write Gene Palmer, the other prison employee who helped the two men escape, entirely out of the story — as well as anyone else on the prison staff who might have aided and abetted the escapees: at least some members of New York state law enforcement were convinced that other prison employees besides Mitchell and Palmer helped the escape, even though Mitchell and Palmer were the only two people charged and convicted of doing so.) New York Prison Break is a fun movie, appealingly dark without being so gloomy as to be unwatchable, and where Tolkin scores best is in the clashes between the three main characters — Mitchell the infatuated mature woman (it’s established that she’s already a grandmother) who’s acting like a giddy teenager; Matt the confident seducer who’s able to get what he wants with his gifts as an artist (he paints quite a few pictures, including ones of Mitchell and other prison staffers which he trades for favors, and he has one of Marilyn Monroe in his cell) and a lover; and Sweat the callous but deliciously hunky brute (hell, if he were really as Joe Anderson plays him I’d have probably had the hots for him!) who’s willing to exploit not only Joyce but Matt as well — in one of the film’s most chilling scene, after the two have broken out together (and after Sweat has peremptorily told Matt he won’t be included in the escape unless he loses enough pounds to be able to fit through the prison’s ventilation pipes they’re going to use as part of their way out), Sweat dumps Matt and tells him that now that his plans have changed and they’re fleeing to Canada instead of Mexico, he won’t need Matt because the only reason he included Matt was that Matt spoke Spanish and he doesn’t have to have a Spanish-speaker on board if he’s going to Canada instead. New York Prison Break is the sort of quirky delight that keeps us unlikely Lifetime buffs watching this often exploitative (particularly in their “reality” series, less so in their movies) but also often oddly compelling network.
After The Psycho She Met Online Lifetime showed a movie they’d been heavily hyping for weeks now: New York Prison Break: The Seduction of Joyce Mitchell, based on a real-life New York prison escape from the Clinton Correctional Facility in June 2015. The escape, in which two convicts with the unfortunate names David Sweat (Joe Anderson) and Richard Matt (Myk Watford) broke out and had help doing so from two prison employees, Joyce Mitchell (Penelope Ann Miller) and Gene Palmer — and were at large for three weeks before Matt was shot down while threatening police with a shotgun and Sweat was taken alive two days later — made national news. Indeed, I can remember thinking when the story broke, “Someday this will be made into a Lifetime movie” — and now here it is. It’s also quite well done, written and directed by Stephen Tolkin — who’s done reality-based Lifetime movies before, including The Craigslist Killer and Cleveland Abduction, and also has some feature-film credits — and vividly acted by the three principals as well as by Daniel Roebuck as Joyce’s husband Lyle, a hapless guy with a penchant for boring the shit out of her with conversational rambles. He’s still turned on by her but she couldn’t be less interested in him — they both work at the local prison and at one point, when he finally suspects she’s smuggling contraband to the prisoners, chews her out for jeopardizing these great jobs they both have, making $50,000 a year each with full health coverage, including dental (reinforcing how prisons have become one of the few industries where well-paying blue-collar jobs are still available — reason enough for working-class voters to support candidates who are “tough on crime”) — even though, as she tells Sweat one day when they’re alone together in the storeroom of the prison’s tailor shop (they make uniforms for the New York state police), she was carrying on an affair with Lyle while still married to husband number one, and in one particular throe of passion they were caught screwing on the railroad tracks behind where they worked. “Didn’t you get splinters?” Sweat asks — though the message Joyce’s story sends him is that here is a woman with a strong sex drive who’d be a sitting duck for a concentrated seduction campaign and would be willing to do anything for a man who’d give her ashes a good hauling, or even throw hints in that direction. We also know that about Joyce because we see her in bed — her husband is there but she’s ignoring him, and he’s already nodding off while she has earbuds on and is listening to a particularly lubricious soft-core porn passage in an audiobook version of a romance novel.
Actually Joyce never gets it on with Sweat — even when she’s caught after the escape and interrogated, and is admitting to just about everything she did (including smuggling the prisoners hacksaw blades and evading the metal detectors by stuffing them in hamburger meat and freezing it), she insists that she and Sweat were never lovers, though she and the much homelier Matt were. We’re told in the dialogue that he has an especially impressive “manhood,” and we get an unmistakable scene in that storeroom in which Joyce gives him oral sex and then he pulls her up for the full “treatment.” Despite its rather clinical title, New York Prison Break works on just about every level, from the intrinsic kinky interest of the story to the highly atmospheric direction Tolkin gives it, to the Hitchcockian game he plays throughout where he shows so much detail of how Sweat and Matt are literally digging their way out of the prison we end up rooting for them to succeed even though Tolkin tried to forestall that sort of moral reversal by beginning his film with a graphic depiction of the crime Sweat and Matt committed (a robbery of a gun store that included shooting down a police officer and torturing the gun-store owner into revealing the location of a secret cash stash the crooks believed he had even though we suspect that, like the victims of In Cold Blood, the “stash” was just a rumor in the crime world and didn’t actually exist). Most prison-escape movies hedge their bets by making the prisoners sympathetic and the jailers the bad guys — either they’re Nazis running a concentration camp or the authorities on Devil’s Island or some such place lording it over unjustly convicted victims — but in this one the bad guys are bad guys, and yet through Tolkin’s writing and direction and the appropriately edgy acting of Anderson and Watford they come off as just the sort of sexually irresistible studs that might turn on a woman like Joyce Mitchell full of unfulfilled sexual longings and desires. Penelope Ann Miller’s performance as Joyce is also excellent, particularly when she switches from bored housewife and career woman to acting like a giddy teenager in the first throes of romantic passion when she gets lurid notes from Sweat and contemplates a future with him on the outside — a dream of hers he, of course, has no intention of fulfilling! Miller manages to bring her (and the character’s) actual age (the actress herself is 53 and looks it — a well-preserved 53, but still 53) and her teenage-style immaturity in her crush on Sweat (even though it’s Matt, not Sweat, who does the down-’n’-dirty with her — and we see her fantasy of the three of them in Mexico jointly canoodling at a beach resort) into a nerve-wracking and rather repulsive juncture that makes us want to walk into the screen and tell her, “Just act your age already!”
New York Prison Break is obviously an exploitation film aimed at taking advantage of the publicity surrounding the real event, and yet it’s also a finely honed piece of drama — not a great film by any means, but a solidly appealing one that manages to offer quality entertainment and is particularly good at dramatizing the sexual frustration that leads Joyce Mitchell to her fatal infatuation with Sweat and Matt. (One thing Tolkin’s focus on Joyce’s literal and figurative “seduction” led him to do was write Gene Palmer, the other prison employee who helped the two men escape, entirely out of the story — as well as anyone else on the prison staff who might have aided and abetted the escapees: at least some members of New York state law enforcement were convinced that other prison employees besides Mitchell and Palmer helped the escape, even though Mitchell and Palmer were the only two people charged and convicted of doing so.) New York Prison Break is a fun movie, appealingly dark without being so gloomy as to be unwatchable, and where Tolkin scores best is in the clashes between the three main characters — Mitchell the infatuated mature woman (it’s established that she’s already a grandmother) who’s acting like a giddy teenager; Matt the confident seducer who’s able to get what he wants with his gifts as an artist (he paints quite a few pictures, including ones of Mitchell and other prison staffers which he trades for favors, and he has one of Marilyn Monroe in his cell) and a lover; and Sweat the callous but deliciously hunky brute (hell, if he were really as Joe Anderson plays him I’d have probably had the hots for him!) who’s willing to exploit not only Joyce but Matt as well — in one of the film’s most chilling scene, after the two have broken out together (and after Sweat has peremptorily told Matt he won’t be included in the escape unless he loses enough pounds to be able to fit through the prison’s ventilation pipes they’re going to use as part of their way out), Sweat dumps Matt and tells him that now that his plans have changed and they’re fleeing to Canada instead of Mexico, he won’t need Matt because the only reason he included Matt was that Matt spoke Spanish and he doesn’t have to have a Spanish-speaker on board if he’s going to Canada instead. New York Prison Break is the sort of quirky delight that keeps us unlikely Lifetime buffs watching this often exploitative (particularly in their “reality” series, less so in their movies) but also often oddly compelling network.
Sunday, April 23, 2017
The Night the World Exploded (Clover/Columbia, 1957)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The films at last night’s Vintage Sci-Fi screening were surprising in that, though both were “B”-pictures released by Columbia in 1957, one of the movies had some surprising points of social comment and the other not only had major amounts of social comment but was actually quite a good film. The first one shown was called The Night the World Exploded, and was made by Sam Katzman’s Clover company in association with Columbia. It was directed by Katzman’s go-to director in those days, Fred F. Sears (who also did his rock movies and his production Calypso Heat Wave, which not only featured some odd casting — including Joel Grey, Alan Arkin and Maya Angelou during her brief attempt at a singing career, at which she was quite good — but clearly showed that Sears was more inspired by calypso than he was by rock) from a script by Jack Natteford and Luci Ward. It’s unusual for a 1957 science-fiction film in that a woman is top-billed — Kathryn Grant, who made this film a few months before she became the second wife of Bing Crosby. She plays Laura “Hutch” Hutchinson, collaborator of scientist Dr. David Conway (William Leslie), who’s just invented a device that looks like a giant mimeograph machine (or a small printing press) but actually is a machine to predict earthquakes.
The films at last night’s Vintage Sci-Fi screening were surprising in that, though both were “B”-pictures released by Columbia in 1957, one of the movies had some surprising points of social comment and the other not only had major amounts of social comment but was actually quite a good film. The first one shown was called The Night the World Exploded, and was made by Sam Katzman’s Clover company in association with Columbia. It was directed by Katzman’s go-to director in those days, Fred F. Sears (who also did his rock movies and his production Calypso Heat Wave, which not only featured some odd casting — including Joel Grey, Alan Arkin and Maya Angelou during her brief attempt at a singing career, at which she was quite good — but clearly showed that Sears was more inspired by calypso than he was by rock) from a script by Jack Natteford and Luci Ward. It’s unusual for a 1957 science-fiction film in that a woman is top-billed — Kathryn Grant, who made this film a few months before she became the second wife of Bing Crosby. She plays Laura “Hutch” Hutchinson, collaborator of scientist Dr. David Conway (William Leslie), who’s just invented a device that looks like a giant mimeograph machine (or a small printing press) but actually is a machine to predict earthquakes.
Only Conway
and Hutch keep getting readings that indicate far more impending seismic activity
than they expected, and the earthquakes not only happen on cue (represented by
whatever stock footage Columbia could scarf up of accidents, disasters or wars
— much of the footage representing the aftermath of the quakes seems to have
come from previous films depicting or dramatizing World War II bombing raids)
but keep getting worse. When the film starts Hutch is proclaiming that she will
soon be quitting the lab to get married to some guy named Brad, whom we don’t
see — yet more evidence of how taken for granted it was in the 1950’s that
women had to decide between a career and a marriage, and could not have both. A
third person in the lab, Dr. Ellis Morton (Tristram Coffin, though the credits
shorten his first name to “Tris”), takes Hutch aside and tells her he knows
that her real romantic attraction
is to Dr. Conway, but she laments that he sees her only as a co-worker and not
a woman. With the quakes and the amount of stock-footage damage they’re doing
rising, the three scientists locate the epicenter in Carlsbad Caverns, New
Mexico — represented by an artfully designed set that’s considerably more
elaborate than we expect from a “B” budget — and Hutch freezes with fear as
they lower her down a cave in a portion of the cavern that isn’t open to the public.
“Wouldn’t you know a woman would pull a stunt like this?,” Dr. Conway chews her
out. “You’re all scientists until there’s the slightest bit of danger, then you
fold up! Want your mommy and daddy?” — yet more evidence of the extent to which
sexist prejudices were simply taken for granted in the 1950’s. Kirk (Paul
Savage), one of the park rangers enlisted by the scientists to help them dig
under the caverns for evidence of what’s causing the quakes, finds a small
black object and, being a rock collector, wants to take it home — only it
expands to several times its original size and blows up, taking Kirk and his
home with it.
Eventually Dr. Conway deduces that the black substance is a
hitherto unknown element, whose atomic number is 112 and which blows up almost
instantly when exposed to air. (There really is an Element 112 — it was discovered in 1996, 39 years
after this film was made, and in 2009 it was officially recognized and named
copernicum — only it’s a highly unstable radioactive element and of its two
known isotopes, one has a half-life of four seconds and the other has a
half-life of 30 seconds, nothing at all like the “Element 112” in the film.) In
the film’s intriguing bit of social comment, Dr. Conway informs the authorities
and us that Element 112 once existed so deep in the bowels of the earth that it
never came into contact with air and therefore was not dangerous, but all the
fossil-fuel extraction the human race has been doing — all that drilling for
oil and digging for coal — has opened so many holes in the earth that air is
getting down there and coming into contact with Element 112, thereby setting it
off and causing the quakes. He and Hutch are finally able to seal off the pit
inside the cavern where air and Element 112 were having their explosive unions,
and the final shot is of the world saved and Conway and Hutch hugging and
kissing for a presumably explosive union of their own. The Night the
World Exploded is a pretty good
science-fiction movie of the time with some odd touches — nothing special but
nothing too embarrassing, either — and an interesting and unusual ecological
sub-plot for its time (though the 1948 Columbia serial Superman had also hinted that Superman’s home planet,
Krypton, was disintegrating because its inhabitants had so extensively
plundered its environment for energy and other resources it could no longer
hold together).
The 27th Day (Romson/Columbia, 1957)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The 27th Day, which followed The Night the World Exploded on the Vintage Sci-Fi film program, turned out to be a much better movie! Also released by Columbia, it had different production auspices: the co-production company was named “Romson Productions,” the producer was Lewis J. Rachmil (who would go on to do some important films, including Hawai’i and Footloose) and the director was William Asher, who would go on to create the Columbia TV sitcom Bewitched and marry its star, Elizabeth Montgomery. The screenwriter was John Mantley, adapting his own novel — a good sign — and the story turned out to be an artful reworking of The Day the Earth Stood Still but with bits of Red Planet Mars and some quite unique variations that were clearly part of Mantley’s contribution. Five ordinary people in various parts of the world — Los Angeles reporter Jonathan Clark (Gene Barry, making at least his third appearance in a science-fiction thriller after The Atomic City and The War of the Worlds); British something-or-other Eve Wingate (Valerie French) — she’s first shown on a familiar-looking beach with her painter boyfriend (it’s familiar because it’s the same stretch of Malibu coastline where Burt Lancaster had romanced/roughhoused Deborah Kerr in yet another 1950’s Columbia movie, From Here to Eternity) and she tells us we’re in “Cornwall, England” (Cornwall is actually in Wales, not England) — German scientist Prof. Klaus Bechner (George Voskovec); Russian prison guard Pvt. Ivan Godofsky (Azemat Janti) and Chinese woman Su Tan (Marie Tsen), who disappears midway through the action and it’s not at all clear what happens to her — are all accosted by an alien from another planet (Arnold Moss — we never see him full-face or full-body, but just as a silhouetted image).
The 27th Day, which followed The Night the World Exploded on the Vintage Sci-Fi film program, turned out to be a much better movie! Also released by Columbia, it had different production auspices: the co-production company was named “Romson Productions,” the producer was Lewis J. Rachmil (who would go on to do some important films, including Hawai’i and Footloose) and the director was William Asher, who would go on to create the Columbia TV sitcom Bewitched and marry its star, Elizabeth Montgomery. The screenwriter was John Mantley, adapting his own novel — a good sign — and the story turned out to be an artful reworking of The Day the Earth Stood Still but with bits of Red Planet Mars and some quite unique variations that were clearly part of Mantley’s contribution. Five ordinary people in various parts of the world — Los Angeles reporter Jonathan Clark (Gene Barry, making at least his third appearance in a science-fiction thriller after The Atomic City and The War of the Worlds); British something-or-other Eve Wingate (Valerie French) — she’s first shown on a familiar-looking beach with her painter boyfriend (it’s familiar because it’s the same stretch of Malibu coastline where Burt Lancaster had romanced/roughhoused Deborah Kerr in yet another 1950’s Columbia movie, From Here to Eternity) and she tells us we’re in “Cornwall, England” (Cornwall is actually in Wales, not England) — German scientist Prof. Klaus Bechner (George Voskovec); Russian prison guard Pvt. Ivan Godofsky (Azemat Janti) and Chinese woman Su Tan (Marie Tsen), who disappears midway through the action and it’s not at all clear what happens to her — are all accosted by an alien from another planet (Arnold Moss — we never see him full-face or full-body, but just as a silhouetted image).
They’re beamed aboard his
spaceship (represented by some long shots of a flying saucer that are either
stock clips or outtakes from the 1956 film Earth vs. the Flying
Saucers, which led imdb.com to credit Ray
Harryhausen with special effects on this film even though he had nothing to do
with it) and each are given a clear round item containing three capsules. The
alien explains that in 35 days his race’s home planet is going to
self-destruct, and they’ve identified Earth as a planet they can relocate to —
but it’s against their moral principles to stage a war of conquest and just
take us over. So they’re giving five randomly selected Earthlings clear plastic
containers, each about the size of a ladies’ compact. Each compact contains
three objects that look like large pills, which the alien explains are actually
a super-weapon developed by his planet’s scientists that has several hundred
times the destructive power of the largest H-bomb either the U.S. or the Soviet
Union had then developed. One gimmick is that only the people actually
receiving each packet can open it — but once it is opened anyone can use the
weapon just by speaking aloud the latitude and longitude where they want it to
detonate — and the weapon capsule will go there and blow up itself and whatever
else is there. Another gimmick is that the weapon is effective only against human life — it doesn’t harm either physical
objects or other animals or plants — so effectively John Mantley thought up the
neutron bomb at least a quarter-century before anyone took the idea at all
seriously. The whole point of this is that if humankind starts a war within the
next 27 days (hence the title), the alien super-weapon will destroy the entire
human race and leave Earth depopulated of homo sapiens but with an otherwise intact biosphere and
infrastructure so the aliens can migrate en masse to our planet and take it over. If the humans can
hold off from using the weapons in the 27-day period, the alien race will spare
us but itself die off. It’s an intriguing premise for a science-fiction story
and Mantley and Asher make the most of it.
At first the people who received the
super-weapons have the idea of throwing them away — and Eve actually does that
with hers on the same stretch of beach at “Cornwall, England” [sic] — really
Malibu, California — at which she had her date with her disposable artist
boyfriend in the opening scene. Then the alien, like Michael Rennie’s character
in The Day the Earth Stood Still,
takes over all Earth radio and TV and delivers a 10-minute spiel in which,
among other things, he announces the names and whereabouts of all the
recipients of the super-weapons. That immediately makes them the most wanted
people in the world, and in the meantime the British authorities and population
freak out, thinking that the weapon is an undersea mine and Eve wasn’t throwing
it away but planting it. Another
gimmick, which the alien uses his hack of earth broadcasting to explain, is
that if any of the recipients is killed, this will automatically neutralize the
weapon (which we see in action when the Chinese woman is killed in her
country’s civil war — a bit dated a plot point in 1957 or, for that matter, in
1955, when Mantley first published his book — and the insides of the capsules
crumble into dust). Eve flies to the U.S. and meets up with Clark, who’s
disguised himself by the simple expedient of shaving off the moustache he was
wearing in the early part of the film, and the two hide out at the Santa Anita
racetrack, which is being patrolled by a security guard who drives through
every hour in a Jeep but is otherwise deserted because the racing season isn’t
going on. In an earlier scene, in which Clark and Eve are riding in a cab
discussing the situation but Clark doesn’t want the cab driver to be able to
hear what they’re talking about (yeah, right), Clark plays a portable radio very loud and the
music we hear is a typical 1950’s hybrid, a big-band instrumental with a drum
backbeat to make it sound a bit more rock-ish — but Clark identifies it as
“rock ’n’ roll — music, almost.”
Eventually Clark and Eve realize that they’re
going to have to turn themselves in, and while they ultimately hook up with
Prof. Bechner and the American authorities, the bad ol’ Russians are torturing
poor Private Ivan Godofsky to get him to open the container and release the
weapons, so they can attack the United States and North America in general and
thereby eliminate their only superpower competition. Unfortunately for them but
fortunately for the good guys, they torture him within an inch of his life,
then give him pentothal, which gets him to release the capsules — and the
Russians issue an ultimatum to the U.S.: withdraw all American troops and investments from Europe and Asia
and pull back to the borders of the continental U.S. (when this film was made
Alaska and Hawai’i hadn’t yet been admitted as U.S. states), or else the
Russians will set off their super-weapon (which of course, being 1950’s movie
Commies, they’re going to do anyway). It’s up to Prof. Bechner to figure out a
way to stop them, which he does: first he decides he wants to test the weapon,
for which he needs a human sample since it only affects human life. He gets his test subject when his colleague Dr. Karl Neuhaus
(Frederick Ledebur) announces that he’s deliberately exposed himself to gamma
rays, so it will actually be more humane to send him out in the middle of the
ocean and have him taken out by the alien super-weapon than leave him alone to
die a painful death from radiation sickness. Neuhaus is shown standing up in a
raft — and when the weapon goes off he simply disappears from his clothes like
the titular characters in the contemporaneous Columbia “B” horror film Zombies
of Mora-Tau. Now Bechner knows the weapon
works as advertised, but looking at the two capsules he has left he also sees
markings etched to the side of them, which he figures out is a mathematical
formula and if he can decipher it, he can reprogram the weapons. Only he’s
already used one of his capsules, so he has to get Clark to open his container so he can complete the set.
The ending is
as compelling and thought-provoking as the rest of the movie: Neuhaus takes
down the formula and uses it to reprogram the weapons so they take out everyone
in the world who harbors evil intentions against their fellow humans, while
leaving everyone else alone — and there’s a final sequence in the United
Nations General Assembly in which the U.S. representative extends an invitation
to the 30,000 aliens from the planet that’s about to blow up in eight days to
come to Earth and live in peaceful coexistence with humans. (This would have
set up some intriguing possibilities for a sequel, especially if Mantley or whoever
wrote it posited that some
Earthlings and/or aliens with evil intentions had escaped and the nice Earth
people and the nice aliens found themselves having to come together to defeat
their nasty brethren armed with the aliens’ super-technology.) Though its
derivations from The Day the Earth Stood Still and (less significantly) Red Planet Mars are obvious, The 27th Day is a quite impressive movie, well directed (like
Frank R. Strayer, who went from some quite interesting and quirky horror films
and thrillers in the early 1930’s to making the Blondie series at Columbia in the late 1930’s, Asher gave up
a potentially interesting career as director of films like this to take up a
commercially successful but artistically uninteresting sitcom series like Bewitched) and decently acted (even though Gene Barry’s butch
act gets a bit wearing after a while), and making its points through a
compelling dramatic idea, effectively realized. And Asher wasn’t the only
creative talent involved with this film who went onto a less compelling career
on TV: John Mantley ended up the producer of the Western series Gunsmoke in its later years.
Saturday, April 22, 2017
Race to Mars (Galafilm Productions, Arte France, Discovery Channel Canada, 2006)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The movie at last night’s Mars film screening was a three-hour Canadian TV movie called Race to Mars, made in 2006 and split into four 42-minute episodes — though the imdb.com page on the film makes it appear it was shown in just two parts. It deals with a cooperative mission to Mars in the years 2029-2031 (it takes a year to get there and a year to get back, and the astronauts only have about 11 days to spend on the planet’s surface) undertaken by a consortium of nations including the U.S. (which contributes two members of the crew, flight commander Rick Erwin [Michael Riley] and engineer Lucia Alarcón [Claudia Ferri], while the other nations involved get only one each), Canada, France (representing the European Union — given the way French politics are going and the likely outcomes from their presidential election tomorrow, the prediction that France will still be in the E.U. in 2029 is almost as optimistic as the one that we’ll actually be going to Mars!), Russia and Japan. The other crew members are the ship’s doctor, Antoine Hébert (Lothaire Bluteau) — that’s a man, by the way, despite the gender ambiguity of both the character’s and the actor’s first names — along with Jackie Decelles (Pascale Bussières), the only other woman besides Lucia; Mikhail Cerenkov (Frank Schorpion) and Hiromi Okuda (Kevan Ohtsji). The gender box score is four men and two women, and while we’re told the characters have families they’ve left behind back on Earth, the only relatives we see are Rick’s: his wife Lynn (Macha Grenon), their son Adam (Robert Naylor) and Rick’s father (David Rigby), with whom they communicate via videophone — and writers Garfield and Judith Reeves-Stevens build in the characters’ frustrations over the minutes-long gaps between the signals from Earth and Rick Erwin’s responses from space.
The Reeves-Stevenses and director George Mihalka build the Mars trip into a surprisingly understated suspense drama in which the characters — including Glenn Hartwell (Francis X. McCarthy), who’s running Mission Control back home in Houston (still! Lyndon Johnson’s gift to his home state that just keeps on giving!) and giving them instructions and advice that just seemed nit-picky to me — speak in formal, military jargon (including saying “Copy that?” and replying “Copy that” an awful lot to indicate they’ve understood the message they were given) that rings true because it’s basically the way real astronauts have spoken to each other and to the Mission Controllers back home on actual space flights. The Reeves-Stevenses are able to have a lot of things happen in that highly confined space in which the characters spend two years of their lives without underlining it with the melodrama typical of science-fiction flights about space travel (even such good ones as the pioneering Fritz Lang silent from 1928, Woman on the Moon, as well as Kurt Neumann’s Rocketship X-M, clips from which are actually included here as an in-flight movie the crew members are watching and laughing at the scientific errors). First they find that a number of the circuit boards on which the various systems of their spacecraft, the Terra Nova, depend are faulty and keep going out on them — it turns out that, fearful that the Chinese (who didn’t join the consortium) would beat them to Mars and be the first ones to discover water and then life on the Red Planet (which they do and they don’t: they land a probe that drills for and discovers water, but it’s unmanned and thus Our Heroes get to be the first people to set foot on Mars), the company building the spaceship cut corners and used the boards without testing them first. (At this point I thought of Arthur Miller’s play All My Sons — in which an aircraft manufacturer used defective parts to build military planes during World War II, with the result that several pilots lost their lives unnecessarily — and figured the Reeves-Stevenses were ripping off that plot point and putting it in a science-fiction context.) Because so many of the boards are out of whack, commander Erwin has to order his crew to bypass as many of the automatic control systems as possible and run the ship manually. Then, just as the crew members are watching the meteor-shower sequence of Rocketship X-M and laughing at how much bigger the meteors are than real ones, the ship starts getting hit by a repetitive banging — at first I wondered if the Chinese ship was playing battering-cars with them in outer space, but it turns out to be neither that nor a meteor but one of the ship’s two grappling arms working itself loose, repeatedly hammering away at the ship, and forcing the crew to jettison it. (I joked, “The flying corkscrew has just jettisoned the flying nutcracker.” As in the more recent film Passengers, the spaceship looks like a flying corkscrew because it’s designed to spin on its own axis to generate artificial gravity, so the crew members can do their work without having to worry about how to control themselves and any objects they manipulate — and the producers can save a lot of money by not having to do all the wire work needed to simulate weightlessness.) All this has dented the exterior of the ship, but since the hull hasn’t actually been breached the crew members aren’t worried.
Then, once the crew have finally got to Mars, they get a message from Mission Control that due to all the problems they got into on the way, the Mission Controllers have determined that instead of actually landing on Mars, they should turn around and go back to Earth — only the crew members are predictably upset at having to turn back just when they’re so close and the other three (unmanned) rockets that were supposed to send up their support craft, including the Gagarin in which they’re supposed to land (named after the Russian cosmonaut who became the first human in space in 1961) and the “MarsHab” Atlantis in which they’re supposed to live, as well as the two vehicles in which they are able to travel around Mars’s surface — they quietly but firmly decide to land. Once on Mars they’re confronted with a new problem: one of the landing legs the Atlantis is supposed to rest on didn’t descend fully, and they’re not allowed to enter it until the leg is touching the Martian surface. (I read this as yet another surprisingly quirky literary reference made by the Reeves-Stevenses: Herman Melville’s Billy Budd, so much of whose plot turns on the inflexible rules of the British Navy and how even its captains were forced to abide by them, no matter what.) They finally get the leg down, but in the process Japanese astronaut Hiromi Okuda breaks his arm and Dr. Decelles orders him to remain in quarantine until his arm heals — and he’s naturally upset that he can’t be out on the Martian surface with the others. The crew sets up a drill to look for water on Mars — the Chinese unmanned probe found some, but it was so salty the human crew of the Terra Nova assume it was the remnant of an otherwise long-since evaporated Martian sea — only their drill bits keep breaking and the consortium back on Earth contacts the Chinese to see if their astronauts can cannibalize parts from the Chinese probe. They ultimately find water, which turns to snow in the frigid Martian temperature, but eventually the water well gushers and Okuda is buried in Martian slush and killed.
On the way back (we’re up to episode three of the four by now) the crew members start getting sick, and at first they assume it’s a common infection they brought with them from Earth. Later they conclude it’s actually something from Mars (so in addition to all the other stories the Reeves-Stevenses are “referencing,” as imdb.com wold say, we can add The Andromeda Strain!). Dr. Decelles wants permission to open the samples of the Martian soil and water the expedition collected, but yet another standing order forbids them from doing that on the spaceship — not that that matters, anyway, because just when the crew is trying to decide whether to go ahead and open a sample even though it risks getting them all quarantined indefinitely if and when they make it back to Earth, the ship is hit by a solar flare. At first I was thinking that the energy from the solar flare would kill whatever the Martian organism was that was making them sick — but it turns out there isn’t a Martian organism that’s making them sick. Instead the rapid alternations between hot and cold on the voyage opened that dent in the side of the ship caused by the flailing arm and part of that solar flare fried some critical equipment, with the result that the ship’s systems are stuck on a particular time coordinate and the instruments that monitor the air quality are going haywire. The crew realize this when they find the mice, who were taken along for the same reason canaries are used in coal mines — to see when the atmosphere had become too dangerous to breathe — are dead (they must have been props since the film contains a “No animals were harmed” designation), and they ultimately realize that they have to go outside the vehicle and swap out some more damaged boards so the ship’s environmental controls start giving it breathable air instead of the heavy concentration of carbon monoxide that was actually making them sick. This means having to take down two of the cabin doors because the ship’s nuclear propulsion system (a concept that was actually researched in the 1970’s as a possible propellant for future spacecraft) has made the area dangerously radioactive, and the two crew members chosen for the mission, Erwin and Cerenkov, have a strict hour-and-a-half time limit on how long they can be out there before receiving a dangerously high dose of radiation. Fortunately everything works out in the end and the five surviving astronauts return home.
Race to Mars is stuck with a deceptive title (since the Chinese probe they are supposedly “racing” to beat to Mars is unmanned, it’s not a real “space race” like the infamous one between the U.S. and the Soviet Union in the early 1960’s, in which the Soviets kept beating us until they just gave up, so they won the race to be first in space, we won to be first on the moon, and then we gave up — supposedly when he was President in the early 1970’s Richard Nixon canceled all of NASA’s manned programs past Apollo and also canceled the research into the nuclear thermal propulsion system used in this film, and that’s why after Apollo 17 humans never went to the moon again instead of going on to Mars) and some hilarious uses of stock footage (notably in an unintentionally risible scene in which the various capital cities of the consortium countries are shown supposedly celebrating the astronauts’ safe landing on the Martian surface, and what we’re really seeing are stock shots of New Year’s celebrations in those cities), but for the most part it’s a quite well made film, nicely acted and staged with a quiet dignity that avoids the melodramatic complications of much science fiction and instead goes for a depiction of space travel the way we’ve actually seen it done in the footage from the Apollo missions and the shuttles. Race to Mars is one of the better recent space-travel movies and I was glad to have seen it — and particularly glad to have been able to see it in one “go” without the false suspense created by watching it as four discrete episodes of a TV mini-series.
The movie at last night’s Mars film screening was a three-hour Canadian TV movie called Race to Mars, made in 2006 and split into four 42-minute episodes — though the imdb.com page on the film makes it appear it was shown in just two parts. It deals with a cooperative mission to Mars in the years 2029-2031 (it takes a year to get there and a year to get back, and the astronauts only have about 11 days to spend on the planet’s surface) undertaken by a consortium of nations including the U.S. (which contributes two members of the crew, flight commander Rick Erwin [Michael Riley] and engineer Lucia Alarcón [Claudia Ferri], while the other nations involved get only one each), Canada, France (representing the European Union — given the way French politics are going and the likely outcomes from their presidential election tomorrow, the prediction that France will still be in the E.U. in 2029 is almost as optimistic as the one that we’ll actually be going to Mars!), Russia and Japan. The other crew members are the ship’s doctor, Antoine Hébert (Lothaire Bluteau) — that’s a man, by the way, despite the gender ambiguity of both the character’s and the actor’s first names — along with Jackie Decelles (Pascale Bussières), the only other woman besides Lucia; Mikhail Cerenkov (Frank Schorpion) and Hiromi Okuda (Kevan Ohtsji). The gender box score is four men and two women, and while we’re told the characters have families they’ve left behind back on Earth, the only relatives we see are Rick’s: his wife Lynn (Macha Grenon), their son Adam (Robert Naylor) and Rick’s father (David Rigby), with whom they communicate via videophone — and writers Garfield and Judith Reeves-Stevens build in the characters’ frustrations over the minutes-long gaps between the signals from Earth and Rick Erwin’s responses from space.
The Reeves-Stevenses and director George Mihalka build the Mars trip into a surprisingly understated suspense drama in which the characters — including Glenn Hartwell (Francis X. McCarthy), who’s running Mission Control back home in Houston (still! Lyndon Johnson’s gift to his home state that just keeps on giving!) and giving them instructions and advice that just seemed nit-picky to me — speak in formal, military jargon (including saying “Copy that?” and replying “Copy that” an awful lot to indicate they’ve understood the message they were given) that rings true because it’s basically the way real astronauts have spoken to each other and to the Mission Controllers back home on actual space flights. The Reeves-Stevenses are able to have a lot of things happen in that highly confined space in which the characters spend two years of their lives without underlining it with the melodrama typical of science-fiction flights about space travel (even such good ones as the pioneering Fritz Lang silent from 1928, Woman on the Moon, as well as Kurt Neumann’s Rocketship X-M, clips from which are actually included here as an in-flight movie the crew members are watching and laughing at the scientific errors). First they find that a number of the circuit boards on which the various systems of their spacecraft, the Terra Nova, depend are faulty and keep going out on them — it turns out that, fearful that the Chinese (who didn’t join the consortium) would beat them to Mars and be the first ones to discover water and then life on the Red Planet (which they do and they don’t: they land a probe that drills for and discovers water, but it’s unmanned and thus Our Heroes get to be the first people to set foot on Mars), the company building the spaceship cut corners and used the boards without testing them first. (At this point I thought of Arthur Miller’s play All My Sons — in which an aircraft manufacturer used defective parts to build military planes during World War II, with the result that several pilots lost their lives unnecessarily — and figured the Reeves-Stevenses were ripping off that plot point and putting it in a science-fiction context.) Because so many of the boards are out of whack, commander Erwin has to order his crew to bypass as many of the automatic control systems as possible and run the ship manually. Then, just as the crew members are watching the meteor-shower sequence of Rocketship X-M and laughing at how much bigger the meteors are than real ones, the ship starts getting hit by a repetitive banging — at first I wondered if the Chinese ship was playing battering-cars with them in outer space, but it turns out to be neither that nor a meteor but one of the ship’s two grappling arms working itself loose, repeatedly hammering away at the ship, and forcing the crew to jettison it. (I joked, “The flying corkscrew has just jettisoned the flying nutcracker.” As in the more recent film Passengers, the spaceship looks like a flying corkscrew because it’s designed to spin on its own axis to generate artificial gravity, so the crew members can do their work without having to worry about how to control themselves and any objects they manipulate — and the producers can save a lot of money by not having to do all the wire work needed to simulate weightlessness.) All this has dented the exterior of the ship, but since the hull hasn’t actually been breached the crew members aren’t worried.
Then, once the crew have finally got to Mars, they get a message from Mission Control that due to all the problems they got into on the way, the Mission Controllers have determined that instead of actually landing on Mars, they should turn around and go back to Earth — only the crew members are predictably upset at having to turn back just when they’re so close and the other three (unmanned) rockets that were supposed to send up their support craft, including the Gagarin in which they’re supposed to land (named after the Russian cosmonaut who became the first human in space in 1961) and the “MarsHab” Atlantis in which they’re supposed to live, as well as the two vehicles in which they are able to travel around Mars’s surface — they quietly but firmly decide to land. Once on Mars they’re confronted with a new problem: one of the landing legs the Atlantis is supposed to rest on didn’t descend fully, and they’re not allowed to enter it until the leg is touching the Martian surface. (I read this as yet another surprisingly quirky literary reference made by the Reeves-Stevenses: Herman Melville’s Billy Budd, so much of whose plot turns on the inflexible rules of the British Navy and how even its captains were forced to abide by them, no matter what.) They finally get the leg down, but in the process Japanese astronaut Hiromi Okuda breaks his arm and Dr. Decelles orders him to remain in quarantine until his arm heals — and he’s naturally upset that he can’t be out on the Martian surface with the others. The crew sets up a drill to look for water on Mars — the Chinese unmanned probe found some, but it was so salty the human crew of the Terra Nova assume it was the remnant of an otherwise long-since evaporated Martian sea — only their drill bits keep breaking and the consortium back on Earth contacts the Chinese to see if their astronauts can cannibalize parts from the Chinese probe. They ultimately find water, which turns to snow in the frigid Martian temperature, but eventually the water well gushers and Okuda is buried in Martian slush and killed.
On the way back (we’re up to episode three of the four by now) the crew members start getting sick, and at first they assume it’s a common infection they brought with them from Earth. Later they conclude it’s actually something from Mars (so in addition to all the other stories the Reeves-Stevenses are “referencing,” as imdb.com wold say, we can add The Andromeda Strain!). Dr. Decelles wants permission to open the samples of the Martian soil and water the expedition collected, but yet another standing order forbids them from doing that on the spaceship — not that that matters, anyway, because just when the crew is trying to decide whether to go ahead and open a sample even though it risks getting them all quarantined indefinitely if and when they make it back to Earth, the ship is hit by a solar flare. At first I was thinking that the energy from the solar flare would kill whatever the Martian organism was that was making them sick — but it turns out there isn’t a Martian organism that’s making them sick. Instead the rapid alternations between hot and cold on the voyage opened that dent in the side of the ship caused by the flailing arm and part of that solar flare fried some critical equipment, with the result that the ship’s systems are stuck on a particular time coordinate and the instruments that monitor the air quality are going haywire. The crew realize this when they find the mice, who were taken along for the same reason canaries are used in coal mines — to see when the atmosphere had become too dangerous to breathe — are dead (they must have been props since the film contains a “No animals were harmed” designation), and they ultimately realize that they have to go outside the vehicle and swap out some more damaged boards so the ship’s environmental controls start giving it breathable air instead of the heavy concentration of carbon monoxide that was actually making them sick. This means having to take down two of the cabin doors because the ship’s nuclear propulsion system (a concept that was actually researched in the 1970’s as a possible propellant for future spacecraft) has made the area dangerously radioactive, and the two crew members chosen for the mission, Erwin and Cerenkov, have a strict hour-and-a-half time limit on how long they can be out there before receiving a dangerously high dose of radiation. Fortunately everything works out in the end and the five surviving astronauts return home.
Race to Mars is stuck with a deceptive title (since the Chinese probe they are supposedly “racing” to beat to Mars is unmanned, it’s not a real “space race” like the infamous one between the U.S. and the Soviet Union in the early 1960’s, in which the Soviets kept beating us until they just gave up, so they won the race to be first in space, we won to be first on the moon, and then we gave up — supposedly when he was President in the early 1970’s Richard Nixon canceled all of NASA’s manned programs past Apollo and also canceled the research into the nuclear thermal propulsion system used in this film, and that’s why after Apollo 17 humans never went to the moon again instead of going on to Mars) and some hilarious uses of stock footage (notably in an unintentionally risible scene in which the various capital cities of the consortium countries are shown supposedly celebrating the astronauts’ safe landing on the Martian surface, and what we’re really seeing are stock shots of New Year’s celebrations in those cities), but for the most part it’s a quite well made film, nicely acted and staged with a quiet dignity that avoids the melodramatic complications of much science fiction and instead goes for a depiction of space travel the way we’ve actually seen it done in the footage from the Apollo missions and the shuttles. Race to Mars is one of the better recent space-travel movies and I was glad to have seen it — and particularly glad to have been able to see it in one “go” without the false suspense created by watching it as four discrete episodes of a TV mini-series.
Friday, April 21, 2017
The Bells of Cockaigne (Armstrong Floor Company, NBC-TV, November 17, 1953)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
I brought out the James Dean TV boxed set — a compilation of most (though, frustratingly, not all — it’s missing his episode of the ABC-TV science-fiction series Tales of Tomorrow and Dean’s very last TV appearance, The Unlighted Road, a fugitive tale he did between Rebel Without a Cause and Giant) of Dean’s surviving work on television from 1951 through 1955 — and screened The Bells of Cockaigne, an episode of the Armstrong Circle Theatre (a show sponsored by the Armstrong flooring company which aired from 1950 through 1963, a long run for a series like this). Originally aired November 17, 1953, The Bells of Cockaigne, an original TV script by George Lowther, is an outrageously sentimental soap opera about some sort of unloading operation (though it’s not clear from the tacky painted sets typical of live TV whether it’s at a dock or a train station’s freight yard) in which the star, Gene Lockhart, plays Gus, a janitor (at least we think he’s a janitor because the one piece of actual work we see him do is sweep a floor) who regularly plays a newspaper sweepstakes in which they publish the serial number of 10 $1 bills, and if you have the bill with that serial number you can go to the newspaper’s office and claim a $500 prize. Joey Frazier (James Dean) is one of the workers on the dock or freight yard or whatever, and we get to see him shirtless throughout virtually the whole program (and we get quite a few shots of equally hunky young men equally semi-clad).
He’s got a wife (Donalee Marans) who on payday tries to show up at the dock (or whatever) to collect his money before he can blow it on his co-workers’ poker game — they need money desperately not only for themselves but also their nine-year-old child (who’s referred to as their son in some scenes and their daughter in others — apparently George Lowther wasn’t big on plot consistency), who has such a severe case of chronic asthma the kid’s doctors have urged the Fraziers to get the hell out of New York and relocate to a warmer, drier climate that will be better for their child’s health. The grim business between Mr. and Mrs. Frazier about a drug their doctor has just prescribed for the kid that will make him considerably better, at least in the short term, but which they can’t afford because it costs $9 rings all too true today, in which thanks to America’s wonderful free-market for-profit health-care system all too many people have to choose between putting food on their table, paying their rent, paying their bills and buying the prescription medications they need. Anyway, Joey ends up at the poker game and actually wins, but another worker, Rivnock (John Dennis), threatens to beat him up if Joey doesn’t continue playing until Rivnock gets his money back. You can pretty much write the rest of it yourself: Gus (ya remember Gus?) finds he’s actually got the winning bill for the newspaper sweepstakes, which he’s been playing for years in hopes he could get the $500 to visit his native Ireland one more time before he dies (and Gene Lockhart seems to have got his whole idea of how to play an Irishman by having watched Thomas Mitchell’s performances in John Ford movies), only he gives it to the Fraziers (he’s actually smart enough to give it to Mrs. Frazier) so they’ll have the grubstake they need to get themselves and their kid out of New York. The Bells of Cockaigne is an O.K. mini-drama, indicative of the economy of storytelling that allowed TV producers, directors and writers in the early 1950’s to do half-hour drama shows, and while it’s not exactly fresh storytelling it is moving in most of the ways the creators clearly intended — and Dean, who didn’t usually get to play parts this sympathetic in his TV shows (most of the time he was cast as an ex-convict or a thug), turns in a performance well balanced between toughness and vulnerability and illustrating his own comment about himself: “There’s Montgomery Clift going, ‘Help me! Help me!,’ and there’s Marlon Brando going, ‘Fuck you! Fuck you!,” and somewhere in the middle there is James Dean.”
I brought out the James Dean TV boxed set — a compilation of most (though, frustratingly, not all — it’s missing his episode of the ABC-TV science-fiction series Tales of Tomorrow and Dean’s very last TV appearance, The Unlighted Road, a fugitive tale he did between Rebel Without a Cause and Giant) of Dean’s surviving work on television from 1951 through 1955 — and screened The Bells of Cockaigne, an episode of the Armstrong Circle Theatre (a show sponsored by the Armstrong flooring company which aired from 1950 through 1963, a long run for a series like this). Originally aired November 17, 1953, The Bells of Cockaigne, an original TV script by George Lowther, is an outrageously sentimental soap opera about some sort of unloading operation (though it’s not clear from the tacky painted sets typical of live TV whether it’s at a dock or a train station’s freight yard) in which the star, Gene Lockhart, plays Gus, a janitor (at least we think he’s a janitor because the one piece of actual work we see him do is sweep a floor) who regularly plays a newspaper sweepstakes in which they publish the serial number of 10 $1 bills, and if you have the bill with that serial number you can go to the newspaper’s office and claim a $500 prize. Joey Frazier (James Dean) is one of the workers on the dock or freight yard or whatever, and we get to see him shirtless throughout virtually the whole program (and we get quite a few shots of equally hunky young men equally semi-clad).
He’s got a wife (Donalee Marans) who on payday tries to show up at the dock (or whatever) to collect his money before he can blow it on his co-workers’ poker game — they need money desperately not only for themselves but also their nine-year-old child (who’s referred to as their son in some scenes and their daughter in others — apparently George Lowther wasn’t big on plot consistency), who has such a severe case of chronic asthma the kid’s doctors have urged the Fraziers to get the hell out of New York and relocate to a warmer, drier climate that will be better for their child’s health. The grim business between Mr. and Mrs. Frazier about a drug their doctor has just prescribed for the kid that will make him considerably better, at least in the short term, but which they can’t afford because it costs $9 rings all too true today, in which thanks to America’s wonderful free-market for-profit health-care system all too many people have to choose between putting food on their table, paying their rent, paying their bills and buying the prescription medications they need. Anyway, Joey ends up at the poker game and actually wins, but another worker, Rivnock (John Dennis), threatens to beat him up if Joey doesn’t continue playing until Rivnock gets his money back. You can pretty much write the rest of it yourself: Gus (ya remember Gus?) finds he’s actually got the winning bill for the newspaper sweepstakes, which he’s been playing for years in hopes he could get the $500 to visit his native Ireland one more time before he dies (and Gene Lockhart seems to have got his whole idea of how to play an Irishman by having watched Thomas Mitchell’s performances in John Ford movies), only he gives it to the Fraziers (he’s actually smart enough to give it to Mrs. Frazier) so they’ll have the grubstake they need to get themselves and their kid out of New York. The Bells of Cockaigne is an O.K. mini-drama, indicative of the economy of storytelling that allowed TV producers, directors and writers in the early 1950’s to do half-hour drama shows, and while it’s not exactly fresh storytelling it is moving in most of the ways the creators clearly intended — and Dean, who didn’t usually get to play parts this sympathetic in his TV shows (most of the time he was cast as an ex-convict or a thug), turns in a performance well balanced between toughness and vulnerability and illustrating his own comment about himself: “There’s Montgomery Clift going, ‘Help me! Help me!,’ and there’s Marlon Brando going, ‘Fuck you! Fuck you!,” and somewhere in the middle there is James Dean.”
Wednesday, April 19, 2017
Nazi Mega Weapons: The S.S. and the Siegfried Line (Darlow Smithson Productions, PBS, 2015)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
I watched a couple of episodes of the TV series Nazi Mega Weapons, a British production from 2014, on PBS — imdb.com lists three seasons for it (2013, 2014 and 2015) but even on these shows, the second season, the producers were obviously pumping up the project by covering aspects of the Nazi regime and its military machine that were not really “mega weapons” in the sense of the huge construction projects, many of them so big as to be impractical, covered in the show’s first season. One episode, originally aired January 21, 2015, was called “The S.S.” — which wasn’t a mega-weapon at all but an elite force, essentially the worst of the worst of Nazidom, who began before Hitler took power as his personal bodyguards but soon expanded under its commander, Heinrich Himmler, to run virtually the entire police force of Nazi Germany, to control the concentration camps (which were originally built before World War II as a place to imprison political enemies and turn them into slave laborers before they were expanded into the territories Germany conquered in the early years of the war — the most famous camp, Auschwitz, wasn’t in Germany but in Poland — and converted from forced-labor camps into extermination facilities) and in its later incarnation, the Waffen S.S. (which simply means “armed S.S.”), to fight alongside the regular German military in operations for which the Nazis wanted a particularly brutal and uncompromising force. The show contains at least one fortress the S.S. built (with slave labor) in Poland, where they dug under no fewer than 36 mountains to build an underground facility called “The Giant” which would have enabled the Nazis to maintain a government and continue a resistance movement even if German lost the war above ground (which in fact was never used because the Soviet troops advanced through that part of Poland and recaptured it before “The Giant” was anywhere near completion).
When the show’s narrator (who in some ways is its most risible feature; he sounds and looks all too much like Eric Idle parodying British newscasters on Monty Python’s Flying Circus) descended into “The Giant,” some of the original caves had become so flooded he had to go into them on a raft à la The Phantom of the Opera. The show also mentions the weird cult Himmler tried to create to give the Nazis in general and the S.S. in particular a “spiritual” basis, linking them to old Teutonic myths. The program didn’t describe Himmler’s spiritual cult as a direct attack on Christianity, but Himmler himself certainly did: he said, “We live in an era of the ultimate conflict with Christianity. It is part of the mission of the S.S. to give the German people in the next half century the non-Christian ideological foundations on which to lead and shape their lives. This task does not consist solely in overcoming an ideological opponent but must be accompanied at every step by a positive impetus: in this case that means the reconstruction of the German heritage in the widest and most comprehensive sense.” Himmler seized a castle that had been built on the site of a victory the ancient German tribes had won against the Roman Empire and remodeled it into what amounted to the Vatican of his S.S. cult, and (though this isn’t touched on in the program) he also sent out anthropologists worldwide to dig up “evidence” of his racial theories — an effort even some of the other leading Nazis thought was nuts. The show goes into some detail about how the S.S. were recruited (Himmler wanted people with blond hair, blue eyes, at least 5’ 11” tall and with perfect vision — even though Himmler himself was shorter than that, dark-haired and wore glasses) and how they were trained to wipe any amount of humanity or compassion out of them — though the S.S. training as shown here wasn’t that different from what any army puts its recruits through so they’ll lose their individuality and blend together as a unitary fighting force.
The other Nazi Mega Weapons episode shown last night was at least closer to what the show’s concept was originally: it was first aired January 28, 2015 and called “The Siegfried Line” — after the nickname Hitler’s enemies gave to the Westwall, the extensive fortifications and defenses Hitler ordered built on the border between Germany and France to prevent a repeat of the trench-warfare stalemate that had made World War I last four years and produced so many human casualties. (The French similarly built the Maginot Line but stupidly ignored the fact that in World War I the Germans had invaded France via neutral Belgium; so they stopped the Maginot Line at the French-Belgian border — and the Nazis, like the Kaiser’s army before them, once again crossed through Belgium and got into France without having to bring down the Maginot Line.) The Siegfried Line took advantage of the natural defenses of the Hürtgen Forest on the German-French border — with its closely packed trees and rolling terrain — and among its elements were “dragon’s teeth” (giant concrete outcroppings built to stop enemy tanks), huge pill-boxes and turrets from which German soldiers could aim machine guns at the enemy without being vulnerable themselves, and concrete abutments that reinforced the natural defenses of the Hürtgen Forest. Ironically, the Siegfried Line was at least in part a victim of the Germans’ early successes in the war: Hitler ordered many of its guns removed so they could be used in the Nazi invasion of France, and by the time the fortunes of war reversed and he once again needed to worry about defending the homeland, much of the Line’s fortification was obsolete because improvements in light artillery, tanks and other mobile weapons had made it possible for the Allies to break through the line.
Nonetheless, the Line was effective enough as a defense that the U.S. Army’s first attempt to break through the western border of Germany at the town of Aachen (also known, by the way, as the city where Herbert von Karajan got his first important job as conductor in 1938) turned into a bloodbath and delayed them long enough that Hitler was able to put together an army for the counteroffensive that became known as the Battle of the Bulge. “The Siegfried Line” tells its story largely through two experts, retired British Army Captain Patrick Bury and “battlefield archaeologist” Tony Pollard (one wonders just how you decide you want to be a “battlefield archaeologist” and where you go to train as one), as well as the diaries and letters of Fritz Tillmans, a German soldier who fought in the battle for Aachen — and it’s a compelling one, even though the moral of Nazi Mega Weapons as a whole is that the Germans hobbled themselves with their mania for size; instead of doing what the Allies did — building large quantities of small, maneuverable tanks and guns — the Nazis concentrated on a few big weapons they didn’t have the resources to mass-produce and which in some cases were absurdly vulnerable. One of the previous episodes of Nazi Mega Weapons was about an ultra-huge cannon that was so large they had to build special railway tracks just to move it — and it was so big and so difficult to move it was a sitting duck for enemy aircraft. I know we’re not supposed to make comparisons between Adolf Hitler and Donald Trump — that’s considered very politically incorrect even by Trump’s bitterest enemies — but they have an awful lot in common, including this mania for making everything “yuge” as well as a maddening (to their associates as well as everyone else) tendency to base their decisions on whatever they’re told by the last person who discusses something with them — the surviving diaries of Joseph Goebbels and the memoirs of Albert Speer both describe their machinations to make sure they were the last people to see Hitler on a particular issue they wanted his support on, and their frustrations when someone else in the Nazi hierarchy got to der Führer before they did!
I watched a couple of episodes of the TV series Nazi Mega Weapons, a British production from 2014, on PBS — imdb.com lists three seasons for it (2013, 2014 and 2015) but even on these shows, the second season, the producers were obviously pumping up the project by covering aspects of the Nazi regime and its military machine that were not really “mega weapons” in the sense of the huge construction projects, many of them so big as to be impractical, covered in the show’s first season. One episode, originally aired January 21, 2015, was called “The S.S.” — which wasn’t a mega-weapon at all but an elite force, essentially the worst of the worst of Nazidom, who began before Hitler took power as his personal bodyguards but soon expanded under its commander, Heinrich Himmler, to run virtually the entire police force of Nazi Germany, to control the concentration camps (which were originally built before World War II as a place to imprison political enemies and turn them into slave laborers before they were expanded into the territories Germany conquered in the early years of the war — the most famous camp, Auschwitz, wasn’t in Germany but in Poland — and converted from forced-labor camps into extermination facilities) and in its later incarnation, the Waffen S.S. (which simply means “armed S.S.”), to fight alongside the regular German military in operations for which the Nazis wanted a particularly brutal and uncompromising force. The show contains at least one fortress the S.S. built (with slave labor) in Poland, where they dug under no fewer than 36 mountains to build an underground facility called “The Giant” which would have enabled the Nazis to maintain a government and continue a resistance movement even if German lost the war above ground (which in fact was never used because the Soviet troops advanced through that part of Poland and recaptured it before “The Giant” was anywhere near completion).
When the show’s narrator (who in some ways is its most risible feature; he sounds and looks all too much like Eric Idle parodying British newscasters on Monty Python’s Flying Circus) descended into “The Giant,” some of the original caves had become so flooded he had to go into them on a raft à la The Phantom of the Opera. The show also mentions the weird cult Himmler tried to create to give the Nazis in general and the S.S. in particular a “spiritual” basis, linking them to old Teutonic myths. The program didn’t describe Himmler’s spiritual cult as a direct attack on Christianity, but Himmler himself certainly did: he said, “We live in an era of the ultimate conflict with Christianity. It is part of the mission of the S.S. to give the German people in the next half century the non-Christian ideological foundations on which to lead and shape their lives. This task does not consist solely in overcoming an ideological opponent but must be accompanied at every step by a positive impetus: in this case that means the reconstruction of the German heritage in the widest and most comprehensive sense.” Himmler seized a castle that had been built on the site of a victory the ancient German tribes had won against the Roman Empire and remodeled it into what amounted to the Vatican of his S.S. cult, and (though this isn’t touched on in the program) he also sent out anthropologists worldwide to dig up “evidence” of his racial theories — an effort even some of the other leading Nazis thought was nuts. The show goes into some detail about how the S.S. were recruited (Himmler wanted people with blond hair, blue eyes, at least 5’ 11” tall and with perfect vision — even though Himmler himself was shorter than that, dark-haired and wore glasses) and how they were trained to wipe any amount of humanity or compassion out of them — though the S.S. training as shown here wasn’t that different from what any army puts its recruits through so they’ll lose their individuality and blend together as a unitary fighting force.
The other Nazi Mega Weapons episode shown last night was at least closer to what the show’s concept was originally: it was first aired January 28, 2015 and called “The Siegfried Line” — after the nickname Hitler’s enemies gave to the Westwall, the extensive fortifications and defenses Hitler ordered built on the border between Germany and France to prevent a repeat of the trench-warfare stalemate that had made World War I last four years and produced so many human casualties. (The French similarly built the Maginot Line but stupidly ignored the fact that in World War I the Germans had invaded France via neutral Belgium; so they stopped the Maginot Line at the French-Belgian border — and the Nazis, like the Kaiser’s army before them, once again crossed through Belgium and got into France without having to bring down the Maginot Line.) The Siegfried Line took advantage of the natural defenses of the Hürtgen Forest on the German-French border — with its closely packed trees and rolling terrain — and among its elements were “dragon’s teeth” (giant concrete outcroppings built to stop enemy tanks), huge pill-boxes and turrets from which German soldiers could aim machine guns at the enemy without being vulnerable themselves, and concrete abutments that reinforced the natural defenses of the Hürtgen Forest. Ironically, the Siegfried Line was at least in part a victim of the Germans’ early successes in the war: Hitler ordered many of its guns removed so they could be used in the Nazi invasion of France, and by the time the fortunes of war reversed and he once again needed to worry about defending the homeland, much of the Line’s fortification was obsolete because improvements in light artillery, tanks and other mobile weapons had made it possible for the Allies to break through the line.
Nonetheless, the Line was effective enough as a defense that the U.S. Army’s first attempt to break through the western border of Germany at the town of Aachen (also known, by the way, as the city where Herbert von Karajan got his first important job as conductor in 1938) turned into a bloodbath and delayed them long enough that Hitler was able to put together an army for the counteroffensive that became known as the Battle of the Bulge. “The Siegfried Line” tells its story largely through two experts, retired British Army Captain Patrick Bury and “battlefield archaeologist” Tony Pollard (one wonders just how you decide you want to be a “battlefield archaeologist” and where you go to train as one), as well as the diaries and letters of Fritz Tillmans, a German soldier who fought in the battle for Aachen — and it’s a compelling one, even though the moral of Nazi Mega Weapons as a whole is that the Germans hobbled themselves with their mania for size; instead of doing what the Allies did — building large quantities of small, maneuverable tanks and guns — the Nazis concentrated on a few big weapons they didn’t have the resources to mass-produce and which in some cases were absurdly vulnerable. One of the previous episodes of Nazi Mega Weapons was about an ultra-huge cannon that was so large they had to build special railway tracks just to move it — and it was so big and so difficult to move it was a sitting duck for enemy aircraft. I know we’re not supposed to make comparisons between Adolf Hitler and Donald Trump — that’s considered very politically incorrect even by Trump’s bitterest enemies — but they have an awful lot in common, including this mania for making everything “yuge” as well as a maddening (to their associates as well as everyone else) tendency to base their decisions on whatever they’re told by the last person who discusses something with them — the surviving diaries of Joseph Goebbels and the memoirs of Albert Speer both describe their machinations to make sure they were the last people to see Hitler on a particular issue they wanted his support on, and their frustrations when someone else in the Nazi hierarchy got to der Führer before they did!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)