Saturday, November 21, 2015

Crusade: “War Zone” (Babylonian TV, Turner Network Television, Warner Bros., 1999)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Though just about everyone thought Crusade — itself a title fraught with unintended significances these days, given that to the West the term “Crusade” just connotes a major struggle that mobilized a large number of people for an idealistic end, to the Muslim world it’s a reminder of a genuine holy war once waged by Christian Europe against Islam and a word used by Muslim terrorists eager to portray themselves as heroes in a millennial “clash of civilizations” with Christian nations — was inferior to Babylon 5 (the people at the screening thought so, as did the critics at the time, the imdb.com reviewers and the TV audience, since its ratings were poor and it was canceled after just one season), I found it much more profound and moving. At least part of that was due to its plot similarities to the entire “war on terror” in general and its most recent battlefront — the November 13 attacks in Paris by groups either part of or associated with or allegiance to (the lines between those relationships do get blurred) Islamic State, sometimes known as ISIS (Islamic State in Iraq and Syria) or ISIL (Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant) or DAESH (which is apparently a transliteration of their initials in the Arabic alphabet and can also be “bent” in its pronunciation to sound like an Arabic slur). The plot of Crusade, which was apparently outlined in a special two-hour episode of Babylon 5 called “A Call to Arms” which was presented as a TV-movie, is that an alien race called the Drakh mounted an all-out assault on Earth, intending to conquer it. Their spaceships were vanquished and they retreated, but they left behind a genetically engineered plague virus that, once it learns how to infect earth organisms — a process Earth’s scientists have figured will take about five years — will destroy all life on Earth.

As a result, Earth itself has been placed under quarantine, and with Earth seemingly under a microbiological death sentence anyway, a number of apocalyptic religious cults have sprung up. They have their disagreements with each other but all subscribe to the deep-ecological notion that humans had become a pestilence on Earth even before the attack and the virus is actually a judgment from God that people have screwed up so badly everyone and everything on the planet needs to die. The two episodes of this very interesting show that were presented last night were the series opener, “War Zone,” and the eighth one, “Ruling from the Tomb.” The gimmick is that while the colony of Earth scientists on Mars are desperately researching the Drakh plague and seeking to find a cure within the five-year (literal) deadline, Earth authorities have also sent out a spaceship called the Excalibur and recruited hotshot space-fleet officer Captain Matthew Gideon (Gary Cole) to captain her. I’ve had a hot crush on Gary Cole since I saw him not long ago in a Lifetime TV-movie called Lies He Told, made in 1997 (two years before Crusade), in which he played an ex-Air Force servicemember who was using his special operations training to support himself by robbing banks, and he’d married (bigamously) to a woman so naïve she kept believing his more and more preposterous explanations about where his money was coming from and what he was doing when he set off and disappeared for days or weeks on end. (That’s a major part of the Lifetime iconography: just about any genuinely hot male on one of their shows turns out to be a villain!) The opening fistfight insisted on by the “suits” at TNT takes place between Gideon and a group of young crew members who attempt to mutiny on his previous ship, and whom he of course subdues easily through what appears to be a combination of upper-body strength and the sheer force of his star personality. Since the ringleader of the mutiny, and the participant Gideon personally slugged, was the son of a prominent Senator in the Interplanetary Federation (or whatever it’s called in this fictional universe), when Gideon is summoned to Mars he thinks it’s to get a dressing-down.

Instead it’s to get a promotion to command the Excalibur, a ship that’s 1.3 miles long (though that’s nothing compared to the one in Babylon 5, which was five miles long), whose mission it will be to hunt down the Drakh and see if they can either capture one alive or find out enough information that they will be able to help the scientists on Mars cure the plague and save all life on Earth. Gideon asks if he’ll be able to select his own crew and he’s told he’ll be able to pick some of them but not all — “We’ve had to make a lot of compromises to get this thing off the ground,” he’s told, in what one imdb.com “Trivia” poster said might be an allusion to what J. Michael Straczynski went through trying to get the series on the air — and in particular he insists on carrying over his first mate from his previous command, Lt. John Matheson (Daniel Dae Kim — why this obviously Asian actor is playing a character with an Anglo last name is a mystery), and also he insists on hiring Dureena Nafeel (Carrie Dobro), a member of the “Thieves’ Guild” who persuades Gideon she’ll be a useful addition to his crew since she can hack any security system and break into anything. In the opening episode the crew — including Dr. Sarah Chambers (Marjean Holden), one of the crew members forced on Gideon by his superiors (and an odd-looking woman who resembles Mick Jagger in drag) — encounter an archaeological team on a planet on which a Drakh spaceship was forced to land after an Earth attack. Gideon finds a couple of befuddled archaeologists, Max Eilerson (David Allen Brooks), who has somehow managed to learn the Drakh language and talks his way onto the Excalibur crew with that skill; and the much younger (and hunkier) Trace Miller (Alex Mendoza, who in his later career apparently used the name “Zeus Mendoza”). They also capture the captain of the Drakh vessel that landed there, but he invokes the laws of war and refuses to talk — and Gideon is too nice and too ethical to torture or “enhance” him. Overall, “War Zone” was a good and provocative beginning for a series whose central premise seemed to me to be a lot more compelling than Babylon 5, and which promised great things.

Crusade: “Ruling from the Tomb” (Babylonian Productions, Turner Network Television, Warner Bros., 1999)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The other Crusade episode shown last night, “Ruling from the Tomb,” delivered on the promise of “War Zone” and proved unexpectedly intense as drama — though its strong resemblance to the recent ISIS attacks on Paris (both led by nihilistic religious groups with a bizarre, twisted faith in their idea of God and a willingness to kill indiscriminately to fulfill their “spiritual” beliefs) probably made it more moving than it would have been if I’d seen it another time and seemed to carry parallels the writers (J. Michael Straczynski and Peter David) didn’t imagine when they were creating it. The setting is Mars, in and around a huge conference center in which a group of scientists and other experts are going to convene for a big meeting on how to deal with the Drakh plague. Just why they have to do a face-to-face meeting, with all the intendant security risks, when one would presume the technology of 2267 (when this show takes place) would enable them to do the meeting electronically with the participants appearing to each other as holograms (c’mon, guys, Skype exists already!), is a mystery, but much of the episode is a battle of wills between Matthew Gideon (Gary Cole), the series’ star and captain of the Excalibur, and Captain Elizabeth Lockley (Tracy Scoggins), who’s in charge of security for the conference. The plot kicks into high gear when one of the conference attendees is stabbed to death, and the killer turns out to be Dr. Alain Lebecque (John Novak), one of the classmates of Trace Miller (Alex Mendoza) when he was in seminary studying for the priesthood before Trace bailed out and went into archaeology instead. Lebecque has bought into the deep-ecological beliefs of the nastiest of the doomsday cults that have sprung up in the wake of the Drakh plague, the quarantine of Earth and the whole sense of impending doom that has gripped the human race — even those members who are safe, at least for the time being, on other planets or in space. The whole episode is chilling as a parable of the degree to which religious fanaticism can lead people to great actions for good or ill; it turns out Lebecque has become obsessed with the idea that he’s being addressed from the great beyond by no less than Joan of Arc, and when they find his journal in which he’s recorded everything she’s supposedly told him, all the entries are direct quotes from the real Joan of Arc as they’ve survived in historical records from her era. I don’t know what the entire Crusade series was like, but if it’s anything like these two shows the whole run would be very much worth watching!

Friday, November 20, 2015

Inspector George Gently: “Gently Going Under" (Company Pictures/BBC/PBS, 2013, released 2014)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night’s “feature” was a 2014 episode of the 1960’s-set BBC-TV mystery series Inspector George Gently, “Gently Going Under” (the copyright date was 2013 but the episode first aired in the U.K. on February 27, 2014), which seemed to be aiming for a plot that would almost literally have it all: Arthur Hawkes (Ralph Ineson, whose character is dead at the start but seen in enough flashbacks later on he actually has a fair amount of screen time) is a shop steward at the Burnsend coal mine until he’s found dead under mysterious circumstances in the mine. Apparently whoever killed him was trying to fake it to look like he died in a mining accident — his body was even placed next to a seam within the mine that had already been closed down as unsafe — only he lived long enough to crawl out of range so the pilings didn’t just fall on top of him the way whoever killed him was hoping for. Britain’s National Coal Board (which ran the mines from the time Clement Attlee’s Labour government had them nationalized in 1945 until Margaret Thatcher’s government had them denationalized again) is planning to close the Burnsend mine because it’s old, not especially productive and soon to be played out altogether, but the coal board’s representative is meeting with the miners and assuring them that the mine is likely to remain open. Arthur is an old-line labor leader who participated in a strike in the 1930’s (there’s a photo of him doing so on the miners’ union headquarters’ wall) and is trusted by the men, so they listen to him when he talks them out of striking. Then it turns out that he’s well aware the mine is closing and has asked the Coal Board to give him a new job at a mine in Leeds, and naturally when this comes out it ups the ante for Inspector George Gently in that it suddenly gives a lot more people the motive to kill him.

Arthur Hawkes has a penchant for spending his weekends at Newcastle with his best friends from the mines, Billy Shearer (Jack Deam) and Panda Wheelan (Dale Meeks), getting drunk and betting on dog races — in fact the three actually owned three dogs and were working a scam whereby one of their dogs would be doped to slow it down in preliminary races to drive up the odds, so the dog would win the big race when they doped him to run faster (which led to Arthur having 300 pounds in his locker at the mine when he was killed and led Gently to suspect briefly that bookies who’d lost big on this race might have had him done in). It turns out, though, that the real move for Arthur’s murder has to do with his family; his wife died of cancer some years before the story begins, but he has two children, a 20-something son named Sam (Lewis Reeves) and a 17-year-old daughter named Hannah (Poppy Lee Friar). Hannah is having an affair with Joe Turner (Michael Socha), son of a long-time friend of Arthur’s named Peter Turner (Simon Greenall); Joe is startled when his mom Margaret (Lucy Cohu) tries to break him and Hannah up, but he assumes she’s just worried about the age difference. It turns out, though, that the real reason Margaret is so het up about Joe dating Hannah is that they’re actually half-siblings; Joe was conceived when Peter was off fighting in World War II and Arthur Hawkes is his real father. This comes out after Hannah disappears, leaving a big puddle of blood in her home that turns out to be from an illegal D.I.Y. abortion Margaret helped her with, which went so badly Hannah had to be taken to the hospital, and one can readily imagine the writers, Mike Cullen and the uncredited Steve Lightfoot, high-fiving each other and saying, “Look what we got into this episode — coal miners, crooked labor leaders, class struggle, adultery, abortion, incest!” In case you were wondering, the killer is Peter Turner, who even though it's been over two decades since it happens still goes into a jealous hissy-fit when he learns his wife tricked out on him all those many years ago, and gets into an argument with the man she tricked with (and whom he suspect she’s still in love with) lo those many years ago.

The sleuths are George Gently (Martin Shaw) himself — who injures himself in the leg tramping around the mine to investigate the scene of the crime — and his assistant John Bacchus (Lee Ingelby), who looks like he ended up on the Inspector George Gently set by mistake while en route to another BBC studio where they were casting a biopic of the Beatles (he could be passed off as the young John Lennon or George Harrison relatively easily) and whose dialogue is so full of Right-wing attacks on the coal miners and their unions as “Commies” and the like one gets the impression that once Thatcher takes power he’ll feel right at home in the New Britain. I hadn’t cared for the previous Inspector George Gently episode I’d seen — it dealt with anti-nuclear protests and didn’t really rise to the potential of their subject — but I liked this one even though it couldn’t help bur remind me of the Law and Order: Special Victims Unit fifth-season episode “Families,” which also centered around the character of a young man having an intense affair with a woman he doesn’t know (until the end) is his half-sister.

Wednesday, November 18, 2015

The Fidel Castro Tapes (PBS, 2014)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

One of the PBS documentaries last night was called The Fidel Castro Tapes and was actually a rerun from September 2014, a unique and engaging program in that it told the story of Fidel Castro from his early days as a college radical to his retirement from power in 2008 (replaced by his only slightly younger brother Raúl) largely in Castro’s own words, from interviews and clips of his speeches. What was fascinating is that before Castro became the black-hearted enemy, the face of Communism’s one beachhead in the Western Hemisphere, according to the incessant U.S. propaganda against him, before he took power he was seen in the U.S. either as a sympathetic figure or at least an ambiguous one, a nationalist revolutionary who fought against the government of his predecessor, Fulgencio Batista (who had taken power in a military coup staged in 1952 on the eve of a national election in which Cubans would have voted for president and a legislature, and Castro was actually planning to run for a seat in the Cuban Congress) and who said all the right things about not seeking power for himself but only in the name of the Cuban people, to whom he promised democracy, free elections and freedom of thought. During his time in the Sierra Maestre mountains in 1958, as his guerrillas gained strength and defeated Batista’s supposedly professional army in one battle after another, he was quite frequently interviewed and even visited by U.S. news reporters, to whom he spoke in delightfully fractured English and explained that he was a nationalist and a democrat, not a Communist.

Just how Fidel Castro changed in U.S. propaganda from sympathetic democrat to loathsome Communist (recently Charles and I watched a 1959 movie from TCM called Pier 5, Havana, in which the Castro government were depicted as good guys and the hero foiled a counterrevolutionary plot by Batistanos to overthrow him) is unclear; relations between Castro and the U.S. in the first year and a half or so were a weird mess of misunderstandings. Castro actually went to Washington, D.C. in 1959 and sought a meeting with President Eisenhower, who begged off and instead sent his vice-president, Richard Nixon. Castro told reporters he thought the meeting had gone well, but Nixon told Eisenhower Castro was “a man to be watched” (though, as Charles joked, Nixon seems to have felt that virtually everybody ought to be “watched” in that pejorative sense) and the U.S. Congress first froze Cuba’s sugar quotas and then cut them off completely. That seems to have driven Castro into the arms of the Soviet Union, who sent their vice-chair to Cuba and negotiated an agreement to buy 1 million tons of Cuban sugar per year, and with that foot in the door the Soviets then negotiated a series of mutual aid treaties and, ultimately, a military alliance that led to Cuba definitively taking the socialist road, nationalizing the U.S. companies (there’s an interesting clip here of the names “United Artists” and “Warner Brothers” being chiseled off the façades of Cuban movie theatres) that had dominated Cuba’s economy before the Revolution, and ultimately leading to the U.S. trade embargo against Cuba which (despite the wishful thinking of the writing staff on the compelling CBS series Madam Secretary) continues to this day, with no end in sight. (Indeed, given that Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz, both sons of anti-Castro Cuban émigrés, are currently top contenders for the Republican Presidential nomination, it seems likely that even the small “opening” to Cuba President Obama had made in resuming diplomatic relations may well be reversed by the next President.)

The second half of the documentary is more familiar, covering the Cuban missile crisis of 1962 (and in particular the fact that Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev withdrew the missiles from Cuba without consulting Castro, who was predictably livid that he’d been sold out), the brief “opening” to Cuba during the Carter thaw (during which I got to go to Cuba myself on a trip my mother arranged, and my greatest memory is the spectacular beaches, the pre-Revolutionary Meyer Lansky-build Habana Riviera Hotel where we stayed, the nightclub where at least part of the Cuban musical and cultural tradition was preserved, but best of all the ability to spend one week in an environment without public advertising: the only billboards to be seen had revolutionary slogans and pictures of people like Lenin and Ché), the Mariel boatlift of 1980 (which was largely an opportunity seized on by Castro to get rid of criminals and Queers; indeed Oliver Stone seized on this when writing the script for the 1983 remake of Scarface by changing the central character from an Italian-American to a Cuban immigrant with a criminal record in his own country who came over during the boatlift), the “special period” in which Cuba had to respond to the collapse of the Soviet Union and the overnight drying-up of the spigots of aid Castro had been relying on to keep his country afloat (earlier writer-director Tom Jennings had made the point that when the Batista government had fled into exile they had done such a good job taking the Cuban treasury with them that Castro and his crew literally didn’t have enough money on hand to run the country and they desperately needed emergency aid from somebody, and when the United States didn’t come through and the Soviet Union did, they got the influence they had sought and an unforeseen but welcome “beachhead” in the Western Hemisphere), the hysterical (in both senses) controversy over Elian Gonzalez, and ultimately the modus vivendi, including a partial (but often rescinded and then re-established) reopening of the possibility of private enterprise in Cuba and enough deals with non-American companies (despite a Congressional law passed in the early 1990’s that actually tightened the trade embargo by enforcing it against not only U.S. but other countries’ companies doing business in Cuba — the idea was to get the world’s capitalist enterprises to abandon Cuba en masse by forcing them to choose between selling to the U.S. and selling to Cuba, but most companies worked around it by routing their Cuba trade through subsidiaries and cut-out that had no U.S. presence) to maintain an economy.

There’s enough residual hatred against Cuba from the long-ago émigré Cubans in the Miami diaspora to keep the U.S. and Cuba at loggerheads for years or even decades to come, even though younger Cuban-Americans with no direct memory of life on the island would like to see the embargo lifted so they can see their relatives who stayed behind, and there are plenty of farmers and businesspeople in the U.S. who would like to see it fall because they’d like to sell to Cuba — but as with gun legislation (on which the National Rifle Association has the power to kill any reform, no matter how mild or how sensible or how broadly supported by the American people, because they can mobilize voters on their side and the gun-safety groups can’t), it’s the anti-Castro minority, still fighting the battles of the Cold War, that hold sway on the issue.

American Comandante: The William Morgan Story (PBS “American Experience,” 2015)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

After The Fidel Castro Tapes PBS showed a documentary on their American Experience series called American Comandante: The William Morgan Story — a Cuba-related tale that told the story of the revolution in a very different manner from the one we got in The Fidel Castro Tapes, and told it through the eyes of William Morgan, a ne’er-do-well from Toledo, Ohio who ran away from home at 14 to join the circus. His dad ran him down in Chicago and brought him back, but Morgan kept getting into trouble until he joined the Army immediately after World War II and participated in the occupation of Japan — until he got dishonorably discharged for stealing and selling guns from the armory. With a dishonorable discharge on his record he was virtually unable to find any other decent employment — not that he particularly seemed to want to; he joined the circus again and this time, since he was an adult, his parents couldn’t do anything about it. He married and had two kids, but got restive again and saw his main chance when he heard there was a revolution going on in Cuba and it needed fighters.

One point The William Morgan Story made was that Fidel Castro was not the only revolutionary who was making war against the corrupt dictatorship of Fulgencio Batista in the late 1950’s. Havana was in the northwest corner of Cuba; the Sierra Maestre mountains where Castro had his redoubt were in the southeast; and in the middle of the island there was another mountain range called the Escambray, where the dominant revolutionaries were a group called the Second National Front of the Escambray and their leader was Eloy Gutierrez Menoyo. Morgan’s original intent was to join Castro’s group, the 26th of July Movement (named after the date Castro and a small band of fighters had tried to raid the Cuban army base at Moncada in what was the equivalent in Castro’s career to the Beer Hall Putsch in Hitler’s; it failed and he was sentenced to 15 years in prison, but after a lot of worldwide pressure on Batista to relax his treatment of political dissidents, he was part of a general pardon and was freed after just two years), but he couldn’t get all the way across the island from Havana without being apprehended by Batista’s troops, so he settled in the Escambray and joined Menoyo’s movement instead. Like Castro’s guerrillas, Menoyo’s won a key series of engagements against the better equipped but less motivated Batista regulars, and towards the end of 1958 as Batista’s fall looked imminent, Castro sent Ché Guevara to the Escambray with orders to negotiate with Menoyo and bring his force into the broader Cuban resistance as led by Castro. Menoyo’s response was to capture Ché and hold him at gunpoint, and though Menoyo more or less joined forces with Castro eventually, when the new Cuban government was organized Castro gave all the principal positions to his loyalists and relegated Menoyo’s to the second tier.

Later in 1959 William Morgan got a call from the Mafiosi who had occasionally employed him before he left for Cuba offering him a million dollars. “Who do I have to kill for it?” Menoyo said. The answer was Fidel Castro, whom the Mafia had marked for death because they had lost a lot of money in the elaborate casinos they had built in Cuba which the Cuban government had now closed. (The government later reopened the hotels as venues for international tourists — many of whom were Russians, since the Soviet government often used trips to Cuba as prizes for particularly hard workers or others they wanted to reward in some way — but kept the casinos closed.) It turned out there was an elaborate plot that had been worked out between the Mafia, FBI director J. Edgar Hoover, and Dominican Republic dictator Rafael Trujillo (a nasty Right-wing creep who had taken Batista in after the Cubans had driven him out) that was to include the murder of Castro, an attack on the capital from the Batista supporters who had remained there, an anti-Castro uprising in the Escambray, and a massive invasion launched from the Dominican Republic to overthrow the Castro regime and ostensibly establish democracy in Cuba (but more likely just revert to the status quo ante and install a pliable dictator who would let the United Fruit Company and the Mafia alone to exploit the island). Morgan met with Castro and the two worked out a counter-plot that involved bugging Morgan’s entire house so every word uttered in it would be recorded somewhere and Castro would find out who the remaining Batistanos on the island were and be able to arrest and execute them en masse. The plotters were uncovered, but both J. Edgar Hoover and the State Department were so furious with Morgan they rescinded his American citizenship.

Then in 1960, as Cuba’s “tilt” to the Soviet Union increased and Castro announced his intention to make Cuba a socialist, and then a communist, country, Menoyo himself had had enough and he decided to launch a revolution of his own to overthrow Castro and start a new government loyal to the first principles of the revolution, including democracy and freedom of thought. Castro infiltrated two people into Menoyo’s security detail and was able to stop the plot before it really had a chance to start, and while Menoyo fled to Miami and eventually was allowed to return to Cuba (where he died in 2012), Morgan was captured and eventually executed under Castro’s orders after a sham “trial” before a military commission, two of whose five members slept through most of the proceedings. Morgan’s story is a fiction film waiting to be made, especially his progress from ne’er-do-well deserter to the world of circuses, carnivals and the Mafia and then to Cuba, where he married a Cuban woman and found a calling working for a revolution he helped to triumph and then opposed after he’d felt it had betrayed its original ideals. I couldn’t help but think this would be a great film for Tim Burton to direct and Johnny Depp to star! As things turned out for Morgan, not only did Castro have him executed, he worked overtime to erase him from Cuban history (as George Orwell would have put it, “He did not exist — he never existed”), and this film (and the book written by this film’s author and director, Aran Shetterly) only came about because he was in Cuba in 2001 and someone told him about Morgan’s story. A series of titles at the end mentions that Morgan’s wife (who was allowed by the Cuban government to leave, where she settled in the U.S. and apparently married another American, since she’s listed in the credits as “Olga Rodriguez Goodwin”) petitioned the U.S. government and got Morgan’s American citizenship restored posthumously in 2007, but his actual remains are still in Cuba.

Frontline: “ISIS in Afghanistan" (WGBH/PBS, 2015)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

After that PBS ran a Frontline documentary that probably proved timelier than it had seemed when they commissioned it: a story about the campaign of Islamic State against both the government and the Taliban in Afghanistan. They were doing this as part of a split show that also covered the Taliban’s presence in Pakistan (which is pretty much old news by now) but I turned it off after the segment on ISIS in Afghanistan because I’d had enough coverage of terror and destruction for a while. I couldn’t help but think throughout this program of Margaret Mead’s famous quote, “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.” Most people who cite that think of it in terms of a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens trying to do good in the world, but the problem is it applies equally well to small groups of thoughtful, committed citizens who wish to do evil. The Ku Klux Klan, the Bolsheviks, the Nazis, Operation Rescue, the Tea Party (the modern one) and ISIS all began as small groups of thoughtful, committed citizens (if one removes the positive value judgment usually attached to the word “thoughtful” and just thinks of it as meaning people who have thought deeply about what they are doing, whether the thoughts are positive or negative) seeking to change the world, and they all accomplished that. For me, the scariest moments of the show were the final words, from Abu Rashid, a former Taliban who defected to al-Qaeda, in which he said, “The garden of the caliphate wants a river of blood from us. Faith and belief demand blood. You must sacrifice to gain eternal life. God will expand this beautiful caliphate everywhere.” Once again we’re in the presence of people like the Nazis and the Communists who want to remake the world no matter how many millions of people’s blood they have to spill in the process — and while ISIS may not seem like a threat at the level of the Nazis or the Communists now, they very well could be, especially if they achieve state power in a country (as they are arguably close to doing in the parts of Iraq and Syria they control) and especially if they achieve state power in a country (like Pakistan, maybe?) that has nuclear weapons.

The Frontline segment on “ISIS in Afghanistan” was the work of expat Afghan journalist Najibullah Quraishi, who’s previously done other Frontline segments on the Taliban and who this time was reporting on a group of people so sinister, so evil, so vicious they actually make the Taliban look good by comparison. In one interview early in the show Abu Rashid explained that he had a moral duty to switch allegiances from the Taliban to ISIS: “Yes, we were fighting holy war as Taliban. Our holy war was just because there was no caliphate then. But God says when there is a caliphate, you must join the caliphate. There is a caliphate now, so we’ve left the Taliban. We’re fighting holy war under [the] caliph’s leadership.” Of course, some other ex-Taliban who’ve joined ISIS have had more mercenary reasons for the change in allegiance — like ISIS pays better: as Quraishi explained, “The commander told me ISIS offering them $700 per month. Once they join ISIS, they get a normal salary and they can feed their families. Afghanistan is a poor country, and you have to do something, you have to work something, and $700 is a lot in Afghanistan.” He shows an ISIS school where children are trained not only in the justice of jihad but in the use of weapons; they’re given a chance to play with Kalashnikovs, automatic pistols and hand grenades. “What is jihad?” says the teacher in the clip from a class shown in Quraishi’s documentary. “We must implement God’s religion over all people. God says do jihad until intrigue, idolatry and infidelity are gone from the world.” Elsewhere Abu Rashid says, “We want the Islamic system all over the world, and we will fight for it.” ISIS’s recent attacks against Lebanon, Russia (where they blew up an airliner in mid-flight from Cairo to Moscow) and now France have been at once a dramatic change in strategy for them — previously they’d been more like a guerrilla army than a terrorist group, concentrating on holding territory and governing it in Syria and Iraq rather than mounting major attacks against the West (indeed, ISIS broke off from al-Qaeda in Iraq precisely over their belief at the time that 9/11-style attacks on Western targets were ineffective in bringing about the Muslim Caliphate and re-establishing Muslim rule over all the territory between Spain and India, which was ISIS’s stated goal when it was formed) — and a wake-up call for the world that these people are not going to go away.

And what’s more, they’re not a force that can be vanquished by conventional military means — ironically the Paris attack happened on November 13, the very day the U.S. had announced the killing of the ISIS official nicknamed “Jihadi John,” and President Obama had gone on TV to announce that ISIS had been “contained” (which in the history of bad calls ranks right up there with “Dewey Defeats Truman”) — which only underscored that a group like ISIS has a huge “bench.” It’s not dependent on one person, or a handful of people, because it’s recruited enough people that for every one ISIS official or fighter we kill, there will be 10 or more to take his place. And what’s more, every time we send in a drone strike or drop a bomb on a presumed ISIS headquarters, innocent civilians will die, their families will hate us forever and ISIS will have more recruits and more propaganda points with which to recruit them. It’s not clear how ISIS will ever be defeated but it is clear that the kind of retaliation both French and U.S. officials are talking about won’t do it — the clash between ISIS and the Western world is less a “clash of civilizations” (as both ISIS and many of their so-called “Christian” opponents would like to frame it) than a clash of ideals, and if the horrible last century or so of human existence has proved anything, it’s that you only defeat a bad idea with a better idea. It’s not clear at the moment what should be done about ISIS, but it’s clear that the U.S. strategy of trying to keep a three-way war going in Syria — between ISIS, the government of Bashir al-Assad, and the so-called “moderate rebels” (who are in fact an insignificant force; the U.S. recently spent half a billion dollars trying to “train” them and got no more than 128 active battle participants in return) — is utterly insane and the Russians are right when they say the only way to defeat ISIS in Syria is to support, arm and protect the Assad government and its professional, well organized military. Likewise the mutual threat of ISIS is one reason the U.S. should be pursuing more and better relations with the Islamic Republic of Iran, who are predominantly Shi’a Muslims and therefore are considered apostates and heretics by the Sunni crazies that make up groups like al-Qaeda and ISIS. ISIS has succeeded in the number one task of a terrorist organization — to spread terror — and the more we respond to them by staging bombing raids that kill uninvolved civilians, the more they will gain.

What’s more, they’ve been experts at using the Internet in general and social media in particular — a book on terrorism I read not long ago, by an author who had formerly worked in U.S. counterterrorism and therefore had to keep his name out of the book, said that the Internet is having the same disastrous effect on world peace as the invention of the printing press and its export to Western Europe in the 15th century. His argument is that new technologies for spreading information and ideology often have the opposite effect than the “bringing people together” optimists often think they will: he said that the ability of printers to disseminate information quickly in the 15th century led to hundreds of years of wars between different religious sects and their secular representatives in national leadership that virtually paralyzed Europe, and likewise the rise of the Internet will bring about more world war instead of world peace, as terror organizations like ISIS (which didn’t yet exist when he wrote, but he saw the signs) have a new tool of unprecedented effectiveness in bringing together disaffected young people, mostly but not always from Muslim backgrounds (there’s a provocative article in a recent Los Angeles Times that argues that it’s precisely Britain’s willingness to allow its Muslim immigrants to form their own insular communities and even run their own courts that has immunized the U.K. from the kind of sweeping attack we saw against France, where a tradition of separation of church and state originally designed to keep the Roman Catholic Church from dominating the government has been applied to Muslims and thereby made them feel like they have to choose between Islam and France). It occurred to me while watching the William Morgan documentary that he went to Cuba because that was the game in town for a wanna-be revolutionary in the 1950’s; had he had those feelings of isolation and alienation in the 1930’s, he might well have joined the Abraham Lincoln Brigade to fight on the Republican side in the Spanish Civil War — and today a person like Morgan might well be high-tailing it to Syria, Iraq or Afghanistan to join ISIS.

Monday, November 16, 2015

A Mother Betrayed (Feifer Worldwide, Lifetime, 2015)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Our “feature” last night was another “world premiere” on Lifetime, Michael Feifer’s (he’s one of four producers listed as well as director and writer, and the studio is called “Feifer Worldwide” — other studios that make bad movies may call themselves “International,” but his is “Worldwide”!) A Mother Betrayed. The mother who gets betrayed is Monica Hooper (Lynn Collins), who as the film begins is at the beach with her husband Jonathan (David Paetkau, who looks barely old enough to have graduated from high school but is supposed to be his wife’s partner in an up-and-coming architectural firm) when she tells him she’s pregnant and they take a rather grotesque-looking “selfie” of themselves on the beach as he responds to the good news. Alas, on their way back from the beach their car is run off the road by a mysterious driver and Jonathan is killed (and the shot of his corpse on the road is a singularly unconvincing one that looks like Feifer did it with a doll he bought at Toys ’r Us). Monica is taken to a hospital and it’s unclear what happens to her for the next nine months or so, since the next time we see her she’s in a hospital bed having just given birth to a daughter. We’re told by Monica’s mother Barbara (a first-rate performance by veteran actress Joanna Cassidy) that the doctors had to give her an emergency C-section to get the baby out, and since her daughter was hors de combat Barbara chose to name the girl Maddy. Then comes one of Lifetime’s usual titles to announce the passage of time, “Four Years Later,” and four years later Monica is the head of a multi-million dollar architectural firm bidding for projects in Australia, Tokyo and Dubai as well as Seattle (where she takes a two-day trip and we see a stock shot of the Space Needle to establish “Seattlicity”). Somehow she has managed to work herself as well as her principal associates into virtual exhaustion and build this fantastic business even while also suffering from crippling migraines and nightmares that frequently flash her back to That Night. Her principal assistant Lisa (Bree Williamson) suggests that it’s time for her to start dating again, and at a party Monica is throwing at her home for her firm and its (local) clients the seemingly right man turns up: Kevin Richardson (Adam Kaufman), who seems reasonably attractive without the level of drop-dead gorgeousness that generally signals villainy in the Lifetime iconography.

It turns out that Kevin is a villain, though; he’s part of a plot cooked up by Lisa to drive Monica crazy and take over her firm. We began to suspect this as soon as we saw the sinister glint in Lisa’s eyes as she watched Monica run things at the office, but it takes over an hour of running time before Feifer finally lets us in not only on what the plot is but also how Lisa and Kevin are connected. Monica is madly in love with Kevin, whom she not only marries but allows to legally adopt Maddy (who, in a common casting dodge, is played by identical twins Ariella and Isabella Nurkovic — it’s standard practice to cast an important child role with twins to get around the limitations on how long a child performer can work; one twin plays some scenes and the other twin plays others, so the director gets enough screen time for the character without breaking the law on how long each child can work). Then, about an hour and 10 minutes into this two-hour (less commercials) movie, Monica stumbles on an old photo showing Kevin and Lisa with her late husband Jonathan (ya remember her late husband Jonathan?) and she catches on to the whole scheme. Well, most of it, anyway; what she doesn’t realize is that Kevin is spiking her food with a drug of his own invention that is causing her to black out, have memory lapses and hallucinate (including one scene in which she imagines Jonathan in the car with her, telling her to “join him,” and for a brief moment I wondered if he was a real person, an actor Kevin and Lisa had hired to impersonate Jonathan and get Monica to commit suicide). Monica has complained about this to Lisa, and Lisa has recommended she see a psychiatrist, Dr. Sommers (Cain Coley) — who, aside from coming off like Nurse Ratched in her later career, is also part of the plot, as is Kevin’s attorney Jerry (John Griffin, whom we get some nice topless views of while he’s hanging out with Kevin and Maddy at Monica’s home — he is the sexiest guy in this film!), though they’re getting restive about when Kevin and Lisa are going to pay them off and whether their participation is really worth risking their licenses to practice.

Meanwhile, Barbara and Monica’s dad Harry (Richard Cox) are starting to figure things out — at one point they try to take Maddy away from Lisa and Kevin intervenes and comes close to strangling Barbara — and eventually it ends with Monica stealing Dr. Sommers’ cell phone and using it to record Kevin confessing all, including the revelation that Lisa is his wife (but then how could Kevin inherit Monica’s firm if his “marriage” to Monica is bigamous? If she’s declared mentally incompetent, control would pass to her parents! Or were we supposed to believe Kevin and Lisa had done a divorce of convenience before he married Monica?), and an exciting action scene in which Monica escapes from the hospital in Kevin’s SUV, Kevin carjacks a white Jeep and gives chase, and the police chase both of them until Kevin loses control of his vehicle and drives it off a cliff, while Lisa is arrested. A Mother Betrayed had the makings of a good Lifetime movie, but whereas another Lifetime writer like Christine Conradt would have made it both more suspenseful and more dramatically credible — she would have had Monica pick up little hints that led her gradually to realize all was not as it seemed with her and her “dreamboat” husband, and given Lynn Collins more of a chance to act internal conflict over whether she should keep trusting him or not — Feifer gave her one “Rosebud” moment that turns her instantly from trusting patsy to aware victim. Still, it’s a nicely done thriller, well acted (especially by Collins and Bree Williamson as Lisa — along with old-pro Joanna Cassidy, who it seems would give a great performance no matter what she was getting from the director’s chair) and reasonably entertaining even if severely weakened by the far-fetched plot devices Feifer relied on to power his script — and, as I’m fond of saying about not-so-good movies made by writer-directors, since the director was also the writer he has no one to blame but himself!