Wednesday, December 2, 2015

Marked Money (Pathé, 1928)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The movie was Marked Money, a 1928 production from Pathé starring child actor Junior Coghlan and George Duryea, the true name of the 1930’s Western star Tom Keene, and the ambiguous notes on the movie from the download site made it look like it was a Western about counterfeiters. Wrong on both counts: it starts out on board a sailing ship but it’s clearly set in 1928, and “Boy” (Junior Coghlan, whose real name was Frank Coghlan, Jr.) is on board when two plug-ugly thugs attack one of the officers because he won’t tell them where a small box containing $25,000 in cash is hidden on the boat. The victim survives long enough to be taken off the ship and to the home of the (apparently retired) Captain Fairchild (Bert Woodruff), but then expires, and on his body they find a note saying that he wants Captain Fairchild to raise the boy and the $25,000 is to pay for his education and all other expenses taking care of him until he’s an adult. Boy is shown as a precocious little kid — he cuts off a piece of chewing tobacco and uses it himself, and when he sees Captain Fairchild’s model ship he points out that the rigging is wrong. It’s obvious the people who made this movie — writers George Dromgold, Howard H. Green, Sanford Hewitt and John T. Krafft, and director Spencer Gordon Bennet (who had a long career but in the sound era specialized in serials — he did the second Columbia Batman serial, Batman and Robin, and their two Superman serials, Superman and Atom-Man vs. Superman) — were channeling Charlie Chaplin’s The Kid and Jackie Coogan’s marvelous performance in it, and particularly Coogan’s precociousness; Coogan made being precocious the stock in trade of virtually every child actor in the movies until 1934, when the enormous success of Shirley Temple transformed the default setting for depicting kids in movies from “precocious” to “cute.” Marked Money isn’t a Western and doesn’t have anything to do with counterfeiters — we’re given no evidence that the $25,000 is anything other than the Real Federal Reserve McCoy — and though imdb.com marks it as “melodrama” it’s closer to comedy than anything else. Captain Fairchild has a daughter, Grace (the quite lovely and appealing Virginia Bradford, who for some reason didn’t attempt a transition to sound and made only one more film, One Man Dog, in 1929), who shows up in aviator drag and is warned by the family servant, Bill Clemons (Tom Kennedy, who did go on to a talkie career as a character actor, usually playing dumb cops), to get out of those clothes before she sees her dad, who doesn’t like pilots or anything to do with flying.

As luck would have it, Grace is dating Clyde (George Duryea a.k.a. Tom Keene), who’s a Navy aviator — she solemnly warns him to take the wings off his uniform and as (bad) luck would have it, he drops them into Captain Fairchild’s soup and the good captain digs them out again and realizes not only that his daughter is fooling around with planes, she’s in love with a guy who flies, too. Of course Clyde’s pilot skills come in handy big-time when Grace is kidnapped by the bad guys (ya remember the bad guys?) who have grabbed her in hopes she’ll know where the $25,000 is (ya remember the $25,000?) — they’re pretty hapless bad guys, given to staring into the house through the mail slot and looking for all the world like they’re going to seek admission into a speakeasy by saying “swordfish.” (Like Command Performance, Marked Money is the sort of bad movie that keeps reminding you of great ones.) The climax is an aerial dogfight in which Grace is thrown into the back of a plane but comes to long enough to pilot herself and Boy to safety, while the baddies are brought to book and Clyde shows off his own aerial heroics in bringing them to justice. There’s a tag scene in which Boy ties a “Just Married” sign and some string with tin cans tied to it to the back of the plane in which Clyde and Grace take off on their honeymoon. Marked Money isn’t a great film, but it’s charming and cute, and Coghlan, Duryea/Keene and Bradford are all appealing in their roles (which helps take the edge off a typically obnoxious, hammy performance in the role of Captain Fairchild — though I wouldn’t blame Bert Woodruff for this because in movies this old playing a father, especially one whose kid was already an adult, was practically an engraved invitation to overact), and it was nice to see it with the original RCA Photophone soundtrack attached. Though Marked Money was shot as a silent film, it was equipped with a recorded music score that was sent out as part of the film so theatres who had wired for sound and paid off their in-house musicians because they thought their jobs would no longer be necessary could still show the film. Enough movies equipped with recorded versions of the live scores that had previously been played in-house came out and were advertised as “sound” that in some cities the Better Business Bureau warned moviegoers, “‘Sound’ doesn’t always mean ‘talk.’”

Tuesday, December 1, 2015

Command Performance (James Cruze Productions/Tiffany Pictures, 1931)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night Charles and I watched a rather interesting movie from 1931, billed on imdb.com as being made by “James Cruze Productions” (though, alas, Cruze, one of the most underrated directors of the silent era, didn’t direct this one — the young Walter Lang did) and released through Tiffany Pictures. The original title was Command Performance, and it was based on a short-lived (only 29 performances) Broadway play by Stafford Dickens (no relation, I presume) that shamelessly ripped off The Prisoner of Zenda (which when this movie was made had already been filmed twice as silents — including a 1922 version directed by Rex Ingram and starring Ramon Novarro — but which wouldn’t be made as a talkie until the superb David O. Selznick production from 1937, starring Ronald Colman). The play used the names of real Eastern European countries or provinces — the prince at the center of the action, Alexis (played in the movie by Neil Hamilton), is from Moldavia and his father, the Moldavian prince consort, wants him to marry Katerina (a surprisingly non-comic Una Merkel), princess of Wallachia, to cement an alliance against a well-armed foreign power who will conquer Moldavia if it can’t find an ally. (The real Wallachia is one of the three provinces, along with Moldavia and Transylvania, that make up modern-day Romania; Wallachia was also where the 15th century king and warlord Vlad Tepes Drakulya ruled and reportedly beheaded and impaled over 100,000 victims to keep himself in power; he was the historical character on which Bram Stoker based his vampire Dracula — the name a corruption of the Romanian “Drakulya,” meaning “Little Dragon,” since Vlad’s father had called himself “Drakul,” or “Dragon” — only he misread the historical sources and located Dracula’s origins in Transylvania, and many writers who’ve adapted the Dracula story have compounded the error by locating Transylvania in Hungary!) For the movie, however, screenwriters Maude Fulton and Gordon Rigby changed the names of the countries from the real Moldavia and Wallachia to “Serbland” (at least that’s what Charles and I thought we heard on the soundtrack on a download — from a reissue print that changed the title of the movie to He’s a Prince! — and Charles looked up “Serbland” on his smartphone’s Web connection and found it’s the name of a region in Montenegro, which made both of us chuckle at the thought that a country as small as Montenegro could have “regions”) and “Cordovia,” respectively.

Anyway, the plot is about an actor in Serbland (or whatever it’s called) named Peter Fedor (Neil Hamilton), who’s arrested by Serblandian police in full Ruritanian palace guard gear while rehearsing his latest production. It turns out the cops want him because on his way to the rehearsal he saw a man accosting his co-star and girlfriend Lydia (Thelma Todd, who is fine but regrettably disappears after the opening scene), and hit him. Alas for Peter, the man he hit was Prince Alexis, who’s a notorious skirt-chaser but for some reason finds Katerina, the woman his parents want him to marry, too repulsive to go through with the deal. So Queen Elinor has the Prince imprisoned, and her husband and his justice minister threaten Peter with a likely lethal term of imprisonment at hard labor in the salt mines. Then they notice the striking resemblance between Peter and Prince Alexis, so they decide to make Peter an offer he really can’t refuse: if he doesn’t want to go to the salt mines, he can go to Cordovia, make Katerina fall in love with him, and ready her to marry the prince. (One imdb.com reviewer lampooned this movie and its prototype, The Prisoner of Zenda, for basing their central premises on the idea that two people growing up miles away from each other and with no discernible family ties should be such exact doubles of each other that they can be played by the same actor, but there’s a bit of passing dialogue in Command Performance that suggests Peter is actually the illegitimate son of Queen Elinor and therefore the prince’s half-brother. Zenda too explained the resemblance between the royal and his impersonator through an illegitimate birth, but even though it took place generations earlier than the main action, Selznick’s 1937 version got the Production Code censors riled up in an era of tighter enforcement than prevailed when Command Performance was made in 1931.) When he gets to Cordovia Peter is greeted with open arms by King Nicholas (Albert Gran), a man whose sole hobby is cracking and eating nuts (which suggested to me he’d be more at home ruling Klopstokia, the mythical setting of the 1932 Million Dollar Legs — yes, Command Performance is the sort of mediocre movie that keeps reminding you of great ones), and his queen, Elizabeth (Vera Lewis) — but Katerina herself has his doubts about him and really doesn’t want to marry a man just to cement a political alliance.

As if that weren’t enough jeopardy for Our Hero, he also has to worry about the prime minister, Duke Charles (Mischa Auer in one of the marvelous slimy-villain performances he turned in during the early 1930’s before he got “typed” as a comic actor), who’s killed every previous suitor for Katerina’s hand and is out to kill the prince because he’s an isolationist who doesn’t believe Cordovia needs any entangling alliances that might get the country involved in other people’s wars. Of course, he also wants to marry Katerina himself and become king, or at least prince consort, of Cordovia and the real power behind the throne — and I couldn’t help but quote the lines from Lubitsch’s The Love Parade in which the courtiers complain that no one really wants to be the prince consort because “he has nothing to do” — to which Eugene Pallette, in his unmistakable gravelly voice, said, “Well, he does have something to do” (i.e., fuck the queen to produce an heir to the throne). You see what I told you about Command Performance being a mediocre movie that keeps reminding you of great ones? Indeed, at one point there was a grand scene in which the entire court of Cordovia is assembled to give the (supposed) prince a formal greeting, and all I could think of was Duck Soup; I said, “Where was Groucho Marx when this film needed him?” The story progresses doggedly along the Prisoner of Zenda plot template until the ending, when the formal wedding of Prince Alexis and Princess Katerina is about to take place — even though Peter has already “outed” himself to Katerina and she’s hopelessly in love with the actor and is willing to marry the prince and even have sex with him, but has no feeling for him whatsoever. Then Alexis disappears from the action, leaving his parents a note which says that he realizes the princess doesn’t love him and he doesn’t really want to be a king anyway, so he’s renouncing all rights to the Serblandian throne and leaving the country. There’s only one thing to do: the queen and her consort persuade Peter to take Alexis’s place permanently, marry Katerina and rule the combined kingdoms of Serbland and Cordovia once their currently existing monarchs croak.

This happy ending is hardly as moving as the bittersweet one of The Prisoner of Zenda, but it works for a film that’s surprisingly good for a 1931 indie even though Lang was still directing like it was 1929, allowing his actors to deliver their lines in a stage-bound manner and having them pause between their cue lines and their own lines. (Those maddening pauses were among the reasons a lot of critics in 1929 thought silent films were more naturalistic than talkies.) Though the budgets of James Cruze Productions and Tiffany Pictures didn’t allow for any shots showing both Neil Hamilton characters in the same frame (compare to the dazzling on-screen meetings between the two Ronald Colmans in the 1937 Zenda), remember that this was first done as a play and having Alexis and Peter meet onstage would have been impossible there, too. Producer Cruze and director Lang artfully use stock footage (most likely newsreels of actual weddings from the Austro-Hungarian Empire or some of the countries that derived from it after it was on the losing side in World War I) to make their movie look more impressively budgeted than it was, and they were also quite good at finding standing sets — including the veranda shown in the opening sequences (one of those frame-breakers in which it looks like Peter and Lydia are really Ruritanian royals, and then the camera pulls back and reveals they’re only rehearsing a play), which I’ve recognized from several Paramount films, including the Marx Brothers’ Monkey Business (there, I’m doing it again! I’m citing an acknowledged classic Command Performance reminds me of). Even at just 1 hour and 11 minutes, Command Performance drags a little, and of course it wins no points for originality (one almost wishes they’d gone whole-hog with the resemblance and spoofed The Prisoner of Zenda instead of ripping it off “seriously”), and of course Neil Hamilton can’t hold a candle to either Ramon Novarro or Ronald Colman, but Command Performance is still a charming movie in its own right and the performances of Merkel and (briefly) Todd are especially treasurable in roles quite different from the ones we’re used to seeing them in.

Sunday, November 29, 2015

Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters (20th Century-Fox, 2013)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The film was Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters, a 2013 sequel to the delightful 2010 movie Percy Jackson and the Olympians: The Lightning Thief. These films began as a series of books — I’ve never seen one so I don’t know whether they’re considered children’s or “young adult” literature — by Rick Riordan based on the conceit that the Greek gods actually exist. Not only that, but they’re still continuing their habitual practice, documented in the original myths, of descending to earth, having sex with opposite-sex mortals (I guess the target audience for these stories is too young for them to get into Ganymede territory!) and generating children, who in the first episode were called “demigods” but here are called “half-bloods.” The gods have set up a sort of boot camp for their half-human offspring during which they’re trained to be warriors, and in this episode Percy Jackson (Logan Lerman), who in the first film in the series recovered the lightning bolt with which Zeus rules the world, is training with a new recruit named Clarisse (Levan Rambin, who was deleted from the first book when it was filmed but is brought to the screen now that Katniss Everdeen in The Hunger Games has made women action heroines, especially young teen ones, fashionable; incidentally Rambin’s head shot on imdb.com shows her as blonde but she wore a dark wig for her role here) who keeps beating him to the top of a peculiar contraption that’s the demigods’ version of an obstacle course but looks something like the mills in Frankenstein (the 1931 one) and White Zombie. A prologue explains that early in the demigods’ camp’s existence, four people were going there but only three made it; Zeus’s daughter Thalia (pronounced “Tah-lee-uh”) was killed by a monster just outside the gates.

To save her in at least some sort of life, Zeus turned her into a tree and gave the tree the power to protect the camp by setting up a force field around it (an obvious ripoff of the Daphne myth), only when the movie opens the force field is being attacked by a weird sort of half-bull, half-robot that can crash the force field because it too has a god in its bloodline. Thalia the tree is brought near death by this and in order to revive her, the kids have to get together to recover the Golden Fleece from the cyclops Polyphemus, who you’ll recall lost his eye to Odysseus in The Odyssey but now has regained at least some of his sight through the universal curative powers of the Fleece (which in this version is a blanket instead of a piece of sheep’s fur). Unfortunately, the bad half-blood Luke (whom I still think is far sexier than Logan Lerman!) wants the Fleece for another, more dastardly reason: to revive the Titan Cronus, who was killed by his son Zeus so Zeus could take over as master of the universe. The officials at the school for half-bloods organize an official party to look for the Fleece, but Percy, his girlfriend Annabeth (Alexandria Daddario), their Black satyr friend Grover (Brandon T. Jackson) — they would make the Black guy a satyr! — and Tyson (Douglas Smith), half-brother of Percy because he’s also the son of Poseidon, though his mom was a water-nymph and when you cross a god and a water nymph you get a cyclops — form their own expedition. They run into three female New York cabdrivers who have only one eye between them (“Shouldn’t the one who’s driving have the eye?” Percy rather sensibly asks) who are supposed to be the “Gray Sisters” (Mary Birdsong, Yvette Nicole Brown and Missi Pyle) and who take them as far as Washington, D.C. before the drivers realize the kids don’t have any drachmas and therefore can’t pay them. The kids end up taken to the Bermuda Triangle — the so-called “Sea of Monsters” referred to in the title — and they end up in the belly of Charybdis, a giant sea creature, only by irritating her insides they get her to puke them up again.

They still have to fight Polyphemus to get the Golden Fleece — Tyson was hoping to get Polyphemus to give it to them by talking to him cyclops-to-cyclops — and the climax takes place at an amusement park called “Circeland” (played by Jazzland, a former amusement park in New Orleans taken over by the Six Flags company and then condemned because it was so badly damaged during Hurricane Katrina — the setting of the climax in an abandoned amusement park couldn’t help but remind me of Carnival of Souls!) in which the good guys from the official and unofficial crews get together and sail to the park in an old Confederate warship, the C.S.S. Birmingham (built on the same ironclad principle as the more famous Merrimac, a.k.a. Virginia) to confront Polyphemus, get the Fleece and use it to revive Thalia — only the Fleece works too well and instead of just keeping her alive as a tree, it restores her to half-blood human status (in which she’s played by someone with the marvelously multicultural name of Paloma Kwiatkowski). Other characters include Chiron, the half-human, half-horse character who runs the school (and is played this time around by Anthony Stewart Head instead of Pierce Brosnan, who played him in the earlier film) and Dionysus, who centuries earlier made the mistake of seducing someone Zeus was also interested in and is being punished by having the wine in his glass turn to water as soon as he pours it. “You know, the Christians have a guy who can do this trick in reverse,” Dionysus says. “Now that’s a god.” Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters isn’t anywhere near as good as the earlier film in the series — which had a considerably better constructed plot (this time around Thor Friedenthal instead of Chris Columbus directed and Marc Guggenheim, not Craig Titley, wrote the script) and more genuine suspense and excitement — but it’s still a fun romp through some familiar mythology given a new and delicious “spin.”

Wednesday, November 25, 2015

American Experience: “The Pilgrims” (PBS, 2015)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

I put on PBS for a fascinating American Experience episode called “The Pilgrims,” a Thanksgiving-themed show directed by Ric Burns (Ken Burns’ brother) aimed at telling the story of the Plymouth colonists and also gently exposing the myth-making surrounding them. It became as much a show about historiography than history, noting how the Separatists (their own name for themselves, though they also called themselves “Brownists”; the common term for them comes from a brief passage in William Bradford’s autobiographical manuscript comparing them to “pilgrimes” — that was the spelling he used, just as he called their colony “Plimoth” in his title — in the original meaning of the term as someone who goes on a journey in search of religious or spiritual enlightenment) created a lot of the imagery by which they’re known today via Bradford’s and (less famously) Edward Winslow’s manuscripts. Ric Burns couldn’t follow his brother’s style of having actors read the surviving letters of the people he was biographing because there weren’t any letters — the only people the Separatists would have written to would have been their co-religionists they had left behind in Leiden, The Netherlands, and they would have no way to get letters to them because no ships were regularly crossing the Atlantic at the time. So he had an actor playing Bradford quote extensively from the autobiography as well as appear on screen in silent re-enactments of the Separatists’ activities in England, Holland and America, and there’s one bizarre shot near the end in which we get a black-and-white image of the actor playing Bradford that I think was supposed to look like what an actual photo would have if photos had existed that early.

The show overall was a quite engaging history of the Separatist clique around the village of Scrooby in England and how they were caught up in the religious politics that had been temporarily settled by Queen Elizabeth, albeit with measures that seem absurdly harsh to us today. Not only had Elizabeth steered the Church of England onto a safe middle course between Roman Catholicism and Protestantism, she had made church attendance mandatory, with heavy fines imposed on people who didn’t show up for Sunday services at the established Anglican churches. For the Separatists, who were basically hard-core Protestants who believed that individual church members ought to read the Bible for themselves and not trust a priestly hierarchy (Catholic, Lutheran or Anglican) to explain it to them, the idea of being forced by law to attend a church they didn’t believe in was horrifying — and things got even worse when Elizabeth died in 1603 and was replaced by James I, son of Mary, Queen of Scots, who in order to answer charges that he and his Stuart family were really closet Catholics seeking to re-impose the rule of Rome on the British church, got even tougher about enforcing the laws regarding Anglican church attendance. The Separatists responded by fleeing to the Netherlands in 1608, which as this show recounts itself was a cloak-and-dagger affair because in order to leave England on a ship you needed an official pass, and the government was not forthcoming with passes for religious dissenters seeking to escape the official church. They settled first in Amsterdam and then in the port city of Leiden, but they grew restive there partly because, for people who had been used to supporting themselves as farmers, they were uncomfortable in an early industrial town in which the big jobs available were in weaving and other textiles. They also grew anxious about wanting to remain an English (and English-speaking) community, and got worried when their kids started assimilating and speaking Dutch instead of English.

So they determined to strike out for a totally new land in the U.S., and for this they got financial backing from someone named Thomas Weston, who headed a company called the Merchant Adventurers. Judging from the way they’re portrayed in this show, Weston was essentially the 17th century’s version of a venture capitalist, underwriting the Separatist colony in the New World in hopes of making money from its exports, and the Merchant Adventurers were basically a hedge fund. (According to Wikipedia, major enterprises that were bulwarks of the British Empire of the 17th and 18th centuries, including the Hudson’s Bay Company and the British East India Company, were spinoffs of the Merchant Adventurers.) Indeed, after some testy business issues that reminded me of what modern-day entrepreneurs have gone through with their “V.C.’s,” mainly due to the failure of the colonists to bring Weston and company any marketable goods (the first ship they sent back — a return voyage by the Mayflower — had an empty cargo hold and the second one was plundered before the Adventurers could have it unloaded and its valuable cargo, beaver pelts, was stolen) — the company wrote them off as a bad investment but insisted that they pay back what they had been advanced (which they were able to do thanks to an unforeseen spike in the price of beaver pelts between 1627 and 1628). One thing I the hadn’t known about the Separatists were that they were not only not the first people in the part of Massachusetts where they ended up (they were originally supposed to colonize around the mouth of the Hudson River but, trying to navigate the stormy North Atlantic in the worst possible time of the year — September to November — they drifted off course and landed 200 miles north of their official destination, at what is now Cape Cod), they weren’t even the first white people. A few years earlier a white Englishman who was there either as a fisherman, a trader or both had shown up among the Wampanoag Indians carrying a plague germ that wiped out huge numbers of their population, so when the Separatists arrived and settled in what is now Plymouth, Massachusetts the place was literally a ghost town; it had had Native inhabitants, but the plague already brought by a preceding Englishman had decimated the population and only a handful of people were left.

What’s more, only about half of the 102 people who made it across on the Mayflower, the old trading ship Thomas Weston contributed to the project (it had primarily been used to ferry wines across the English Channel), were Separatists; the others, whom William Bradford and the other Separatists on the journey called “Strangers,” were people Weston had recruited for the voyage intending that they would govern the colony and contribute needed skills in construction and other work. Bradford’s wife Dorothy made it across the Atlantic but fell overboard, in what could have been a suicide, not long after the ship anchored in Cape Cod (though he eventually remarried), and the first winter was bitterly harsh. The group survived largely by having planted corn they had plundered from the graves of dead Natives, and it wasn’t until the spring that the sachem (chief) of the Wampanoag, Massacoit, cut his famous deal with the settlers that he’d teach them how to farm the New England land and how to keep themselves alive if in exchange they’d help him and the other surviving Wampanoag in their wars with the Narragansett, Massachusetts and other local tribes that had historically been the Wampanoag’s enemies. (At least two Native spokespeople were interviewed for this show, including a survivor of the Wampanoag who’s part of their tribe’s history project.) The so-called “First Thanksgiving” really didn’t take place until 1623, after the colony had been settled for three years, and the event that really kick-started Thanksgiving as a concept didn’t happen until decades later, after a far better supplied and officially sanctioned group of Puritan colonists had established the city of “New Boston” and formed the Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1630, and the Natives, led by Massacoit’s son and heir, Metacomet (who became known for some reason as “King Philip” by the whites), led a war to wipe out the English from their territory once and for all. (In this war, ironically, the Narragansett allied with the English against the Wampanoag.)

One particularly cruel story told in Edward Winslow’s memoir, but not in Bradford’s, put a grisly spin on the early years of white-Native conflict; Winslow recalled that the colonists would put people who were nearly dead and prop them up with muskets in their hands, so the Natives would see them and think the white army protecting the settlement was much bigger than it really was. From this reality sprang the myths that the dead settlers were merely being buried at night, not propped up like a phantom army. Indeed, one of the themes that runs through this show is how the “Pilgrim myth” got created in the first place and why Plymouth — not Jamestown, Virginia, which was settled 13 years earlier — is generally considered the “birthplace of America” and the start of Anglo-American culture and life in the New World. (When the narrator mentioned that the so-called “Pilgrims” are considered the foundation of the U.S. and not any of the earlier colonists, Charles joked, “That’s because they were the only ones who weren’t prisoners or slavers!”) The commentary notes that the colonists who wrote their memoirs, William Bradford (who was elected governor after the first one, John Carver, died, and served in that capacity for 32 of the first 38 years of the colony’s independent existence until his own death) in particular, consciously shaped and guided their accounts of events, and after Bradford died later historians — including Increase Mather (father of Cotton Mather of Salem witch trials infamy) — added to and gilded the legend. The Pilgrims is as much a show about how history is written as about what “really” happened — to the extent we can even discern it about things that happened nearly 400 years ago, and how the Separatists’ experience was chopped and channeled by themselves and later historians to provide a suitable “origin story” for what became the United States of America. After the show PBS was showing a Secrets of the Dead episode about Jamestown, which I was rather interested in when it appeared that they were going to be doing an origin story of the real first surviving British colony in the Americas, but I turned off (in both senses: I lost interest and decided to watch something else) the show when it turned out it was going to be about a young woman whose remains were found by modern archaeologists and who appeared to be a victim of cannibalism.

Young Man of Manhattan (Paramount, 1930)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Instead I ran Charles Young Man of Manhattan, a 1930 Paramount production (filmed at their New York studio in Astoria, Queens so they could use actors who were also appearing on Broadway — they could act in films by day and in plays by night) which, based on an ambiguous notation on the site I downloaded it from, I had assumed co-starred Ginger Rogers and Ethel Merman, who when this film was being made were co-starring on Broadway in the Gershwin musical Girl Crazy. (Merman introduced “I Got Rhythm” in this show, with Red Nichols’ orchestra in the pit backing her, and it was her star-making song.) As things turned out, Merman wasn’t in Young Man of Manhattan but Rogers was — it was her first film and she was still wearing her hair in its natural black color (later she would bleach it and go blonde), though you don’t see much of her hair since she’s wearing a helmet-like cap in most of her scenes. The film was actually more soap opera than musical (though Rogers sings two songs in it, “I’ve Got ‘It’ but ‘It’ Don’t Do Me No Good” and “Good ’n’ Plenty”) and it’s really a vehicle for Claudette Colbert and her then-husband, Norman Foster, and the opening is an interesting anticipation of the first Spencer Tracy-Katharine Hepburn film Woman of the Year from 12 years later. They’re both newspaper reporters for rival papers — she does general coverage with a special emphasis on celebrity interviews for a morning paper, and he covers sports for an evening paper — and the film opens with a stunning overhead shot of a boxing match. It turns out that the fight is taking place outdoors in a driving rainstorm and everyone there is getting drenched (and according to imdb.com the fight is represented by stock footage of the real 1927 heavyweight championship bout between Jack Dempsey and Gene Tunney). Toby McLean (Norman Foster) offers to give Ann Vaughn (Claudette Colbert) a ride home, and on the way he bets her that he’ll marry her that night. He does, and they set up housekeeping together and agree that no matter what happens between them, they won’t get jealous or possessive of each other. (The film, written by Robert Presnell and Daniel Reed based on a novel by Katharine Brush — best known at the time as an F. Scott Fitzgerald imitator — and stunningly directed by the usually hacky Monta Bell, has the refreshing and salty honesty about people’s real relationships, including their sex drives, that marks it as a product of the Hollywood glasnost, the so-called “pre-Code” era between 1930 and 1934.)

Of course, the exact opposite happens; Ann gets an offer from magazine publisher Dwight Knowles (Leslie Austin, in the sort of role Neil Hamilton played earlier and Ian Hunter played later) to write a series of six star profiles for $200 each, and while at an out-of-town game Toby’s “friend” and tempter Shorty Ross (Charlie Ruggles in a surprisingly non-comic role for him) introduces him to the so-called “gilded girl,” Puff Randolph (Ginger Rogers), a devil-may-care flapper with a voice like Helen Kane’s (whom Rogers actually replaced in Paul Ash’s dance band) and a cheerful disregard for traditional morality and anything connected with it. She immediately starts cruising Toby and isn’t going to let such minor details as his having a wife get in her way, and she also proudly announces that she’s going to be moving to New York so he’ll have easy access to her. Toby starts losing it not only because of Puff’s seemingly omnipresent temptations but also because he’s feeling “unmanned” because Ann is making more money than he is — which, as Charles pointed out, became a quite common clichés in movies of the later 1930’s but was still relatively novel when this one was made — and he responds by drinking too much, to the point where he’s missing deadlines and Shorty and his other sportswriter friends are covering for him by writing his columns for him. Things come to a head when he has to go to cover a baseball team’s spring training in Florida (actually a pretty chintzy-looking attempt to reproduce “Florida” on an Astoria sound stage) — he makes it onto the train, leaving an opened but undrunk bottle of bootleg booze on his kitchen table, but he’s pretty hopeless as a writer once he gets there — and meanwhile Ann, his wife (ya remember his wife? He’s pretty much forgotten her!), returns from doing celebrity interviews in Hollywood, pours herself a drink from the bottle her husband left opened but undrunk, and promptly goes blind.

This was actually a significant risk from bootleg liquor; to enforce Prohibition the government insisted that companies making alcohol for industrial or medicinal use add adulterants that could have near-lethal side effects if drunk, and the bootleggers’ chemists worked out ways to remove the adulterants so their products wouldn’t blind or kill their customers (which even in the free-wheeling 1920’s would have been bad for business). At least one other film from 1930, Puttin’ On the Ritz — a vehicle for Broadway star Harry Richman — also features a character becoming blind from drinking bootleg liquor whose makers hadn’t got the adulterants out properly, and one contributor to the Bix Beiderbecke online forum has suggested that Bix got at least two doses of adulterated hooch, one in November 1928 (which led to his significant impairment, increasingly erratic behavior and ultimate loss of his job with Paul Whiteman) and one about a month before he died in August 1931, which finally poisoned him. In Puttin’ On the Ritz it’s Richman’s charater, an egomaniac star, who’s blinded by the bad liquor and learns humility even as he has to rely on his wife (Joan Bennett) to support and care for him; in Young Man of Manhattan Toby responds to the news that his wife has gone blind from a bottle he meant to have himself and share with his friends by rushing home, sobering up, writing the novel he’s long wanted to do but never applied himself long enough, getting a $1,000 advance and using it to pay for the series of treatments that at least partially restore her sight. Young Man of Manhattan isn’t the sort of feel-good musical romp I’d have expected from the title and Ginger Rogers’ presence in it, but on its own terms it’s quite good even though Norman Foster is a bit too whiny for us to believe both the Colbert and Rogers characters find him irresistible, and a part of me wishes that Paramount had waited two years to make it until Cary Grant would have been available for the role — but the alcoholism plot thread anticipates The Lost Weekend (also a Paramount production) by 15 years and once again gives the lie to the oft-repeated legend that until The Lost Weekend Hollywood treated alcoholics and their disease only as the stuff of jokes!

Sunday, November 22, 2015

Marooned (Frankovich/Columbia, 1969)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night’s movie at the Vintage Sci-Fi showing in Golden Hill was a big-budget epic from 1969 (the last year the venue organizer considers “vintage”) called Marooned, made by Columbia in 1969 and co-produced with an in-house “independent” company headed by the studio’s then-production chief, Mike Frankovich. Marooned began life as a novel by Martin Caidin, who also wrote Cyborg — the basis for the TV series The Six Million Dollar Man — though his emergence as a writer of science fiction, or indeed any fiction, in the 1960’s was a surprise because until then he’d been known mostly as an author of nonfiction books about World War II (including The Night Hamburg Died and A Torch to the Enemy, about the U.S. bombing raids against Germany and Japan, respectively). The first person to think about turning Marooned into a movie was veteran director Frank Capra, who, coming off the spectacular failure of his 1961 film A Pocketful of Miracles (the bloated and casting-compromised[1] remake of his 1933 classic Lady for a Day), did a 20-minute short about space travel, Reaching for the Stars, for showing at the New York World’s Fair. The experience led him to space as a possible subject for another feature film, and he seized on Caidin’s Marooned, selling it to Columbia (his old stomping grounds from 1926 to 1939) and persuading Frankovich, who ironically had got his start in films on a major Capra project (he had a bit part as an announcer in Meet John Doe), to greenlight it. “Mike went for Marooned in a big way,” Capra recalled in his autobiography. “I moved back into Columbia Studios in May 1964. Walter Newman began writing what was to become a most magnificent script. Three long, frustrating years later, I backed off from Marooned, a beaten, frustrated man. Using his powers of script and budget approval, Frankovich finally forced me into an impossible position: make the film for under $3 million or give up the project. I gave up the project. Whereupon Frankovich took it over as his personal production, engaged John Sturges to direct it, and spent $8 million in filming it.”

It’s hard to imagine Marooned fitting into Capra’s oeuvre — unless the whooping horns that go off at the space center in Houston when at least some of the marooned astronauts are rescued are supposed to represent their guardian angels getting their wings — but it doesn’t really fit into Sturges’ oeuvre either. His best-known films are the taut modern-Western melodrama Bad Day at Black Rock and the action-fests The Magnificent Seven and The Great Escape, two key films in the career of Steve McQueen, and he was available to take over Marooned because McQueen had just fired him from the auto-racing drama Le Mans after they’d been having arguments over McQueen’s insistence on fewer lines. (Most actors read a script and demand the writers give them more dialogue; McQueen, who was convinced he was at his most star-powered when he reacted on screen to what others were saying or doing, asked for less dialogue, and on Le Mans his penchant for silent reaction grew to the point where he said nothing for the first 30 minutes of a two-hour movie. “Steve, you’ve got to say something!” Sturges pleaded. McQueen fired him.) Marooned was problematic for a director whose best films range widely across picturesque countrysides because virtually all of it takes place in confined spaces: first, the spacecraft being ridden by the Apollo “Ironman I” mission and the space station in which they live for five months (it’s supposed to be seven, but the fuddy-duddies at Mission Control cut it short after they notice the astronauts are becoming cognitively impaired by their long period of weightlessness), then the control room at the space center in Houston and finally the interior of the XRV which flies a hazardous rescue mission to save the three astronauts who ended up trapped in their spacecraft when the retro-rockets (the backwards-firing rockets that are supposed to slow their descent into the atmosphere so they land safely and don’t disintegrate into ash in the atmosphere upon re-entry) mysteriously fail.

The plot (as conceived by Caidin and scripted by Mayo Simon — a name that seems to inspire so many bad jokes I won’t go there — after Frankovich junked Newman’s “most magnificent script” — judging from Newman’s work on Billy Wilder’s Ace in the Hole, also a drama about a rescue, a Marooned made from his script would probably be better than the one we have) concerns the three trapped astronauts, Jim Pruett (Richard Crenna), Clayton Stone (James Franciscus) and “Buzz” Lloyd (Gene Hackman) — by coincidence, one of the astronauts on the first Apollo mission actually to land on the moon was also nicknamed “Buzz,” Bob Aldrin — along with Charles Keith (Gregory Peck, top-billed), the fussy Mission Control head who’s in charge of trying to talk them down; hot-shot former astronaut Ted Dougherty (David Janssen, who steals the first half of the film out from under the other principals until he’s locked inside the XRV for the second half and becomes just another anonymous guy in a spacesuit — one lesson you learn from the film is that if you’re wearing a spacesuit your ability to act is severely limited no matter how good you are in normal clothes), who insists on launching a rescue mission even though the only available rocket was designed for something else and the XRV has never actually been tested for manned flight; and the astronauts’ Stepford wives: Celia Pruett (the overqualified Lee Grant), Teresa Stone (Nancy Kovack, whom I’d otherwise heard of only as the female romantic lead in the Three Stooges’ last film, The Outlaws Is Coming, with Adam “Batman” West as the male lead), and Betty Lloyd (Mariette Hartley, who’s almost as overqualified for her role as Lee Grant). When one of the women says that they understand their job is to keep house and hold down the fort while their menfolk do exciting things like explore space, the two women in our audience groaned and the screening’s organizer said, “Now do you believe this is a vintage movie?” (And this film was released in 1969, six years after the Soviet Union had launched the first woman into space; I remember pissing off a woman in a grocery line in 1983 when I was saying people were making way too much of Sally Ride being the first American woman astronaut to fly a space mission, and she thought I was just being a male-chauvinist asshole until I added, “20 years after the Russians did it,” and she understood and got my point.)

The big problem with Marooned is it’s surprisingly boring — the most frustrating sort of bad movie, one with a good movie trapped inside and desperately trying to get out — it’s a plot that had been done before (in overall outline even if not in the details) and would be done far better later (in the masterly Apollo 13 and, from what I hear, in Gravity, a film that’s still sitting in my DVD backlog but which I’m interested in watching because other people at the screening said they felt Gravity succeeded where Marooned failed), but it still should have had potential for a better film than the one that got made. Deprived of the wide-open spaces of his Westerns and chase films, director Sturges muffs one opportunity for suspense after another; the astronauts look almost indistinguishable from each other in their spacesuits (and Gene Hackman, the most talented actor of the three, just makes himself insufferable in an attempt to “spin” his character and establish a difference from the other two); Gregory Peck goes through the entire movie showing almost no emotion at all (I understand taciturnity was part of his stock in trade as an actor, but in his best films, like To Kill a Mockingbird, you at least got the impression there were things he cared about emotionally) and coldly weighing the alternatives of leaving the astronauts up there until the oxygen in their spacecraft runs out and mounting a rescue attempt that just got more difficult because a hurricane is aiming straight for the launch site at Cape Canaveral (though it’s called “Cape Kennedy” here during the short-lived renaming of the site for the 35th President) — a problem Peck’s character solves by waiting to do the launch until the rocket is in the eye of the hurricane; and the sheer sang-froid of the Stepford wives the astronauts are married to is a thing of ugliness and a horror to behold. (Even when Mrs. Pruett is called over and informed that her husband has just sacrificed his own life so the other two will have enough oxygen to hold out until the rescue vehicle arrives, she doesn’t seem to break a sweat over the news: she’s upset but neither angry, grief-stricken nor shocked.)

As if the malfunctioning retro-rockets, the lack of testing of the rescue vehicle, and the hurricane weren’t enough melodramatic elements to keep the plot boiling, a Russian space vessel (which you can tell is Russian not only because its name is in Cyrillic lettering but it looks like a giant samovar — where the Apollo spacecraft looks like a giant vacuum cleaner and the red XRV looks like a giant budgie) comes along and saves Lloyd, while Stone is rescued by the XRV. The audience at our screening watched the film in stunned silence for the first two hours of its swollen 132-minute running time (about 100 minutes would have been the right length for this story) and then, during the final sequences in which various astronauts are floating around, untethered, in deep space either being rescued or missing it, started laughing. If there’s one thing that can be said for Marooned, it’s that it carried over from Stanley Kubrick’s masterpiece 2001: A Space Odyssey from the previous year the taciturn emotionlessness of the astronauts themselves and all the people on the ground helping them — I remember that auteur critic Andrew Sarris hated 2001 when it was first released but said it looked more believable after the Apollo 11 moon landing because the real astronauts had behaved in the same emotionless fashion as the ones in Kubrick’s film — but whereas 2001 was exaltation Marooned is just a bore, and it didn’t even do well at the box office, earning just $4,350,000 in its initial release. And because it takes place in the filmmakers’ present and depicts only technology that actually existed at the time, I’m not even sure Marooned qualifies as science fiction; it’s just a bad quasi-military melodrama about space travel that could have been a nail-biting thriller but fell far short of its potential.


[1] — Capra wanted Helen Hayes for the part of Apple Annie, the young Steve McQueen as gangster Dave the Dude and Shirley Jones as his nightclub-owning girlfriend. He was forced to settle for a miscast Bette Davis as Annie, Glenn Ford as Dave the Dude and Hope Lange, Ford’s then-squeeze, as the girl.

Saturday, November 21, 2015

Babylon 5: “Objects in Motion” (Babylonian Productions, Warner Bros., 1999)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The TV shows shown at last night’s “Mars Movie Night” — an episode of Babylon 5 from its last season (in fact, there were just two more episodes after this one) and two shows from the interesting series spinoff, Crusade — proved surprisingly compelling, and after last week’s events in Paris these shows (especially the latter Crusade episode, “Ruling from the Tomb”) seemed deeper and richer than they might have otherwise, especially given that they were written and produced in 1999, two years before the 9/11 attacks brought the “war on terror” home to the U.S. Babylon 5 was originally based on an idea by Harlan Ellison, a marvelously creative writer but also notoriously tetchy and protective of his ideas. Ellison gave interviews before the show went into production saying that he wanted it to be the ultimate “answer story” to Star Trek, for which he’d written one of the best and most highly regarded episodes (“The City on the Edge of Forever”), but the producer, J. Michael Straczynski, took over, rewrote the whole concept and used so little of what Ellison had provided that he got listed as “creator” of the series while Ellison got only the nebulous credit “conceptual consultant.” Later, when he spun off Crusade for Turner Network Television (TNT), it was Straczynski who had to fight off notes he got from the bosses at TNT, including their insistence that the first episode begin with a fist fight (why?), so it was Straczynski who got to enact the role of the put-upon Artist forced to compromise his vision at the behest of the “suits.” (Karma — ain’t it a bitch.) I hadn’t watched any of either of these shows until I started seeing them at the Mars movie nights, but as nearly as I could tell from what I’ve seen so far of Babylon 5 it seems to center around a spaceship called Bellerophon which gets involved in what amounts to a war between Earth and its former colony Mars, in which the human outpost on Mars helps dethrone a corrupt Earth President and declares its independence.

The main dramatis personae on the episode we watched last night, “Objects in Motion” (which was followed, almost inevitably, by “Objects at Rest,” though the cultural referent that occurred to me was “ … may be closer than they appear”), in addition to the series regulars (led by Bruce Boxleitner as John Sheridan, the captain of the Bellerophon — or was it the Agamemmnon, as I recorded it the last time I posted about this show?), were Tessa Holloran (Marjorie Monaghan), first president of the newly independent Mars (she’s also referred to as “Number One” and I couldn’t help but wonder if this was an oblique reference to the character of “Number One,” the cold, emotionless woman who was going to be the second-in-command on the original Star Trek until the first pilot, “The Cage,” was rejected and her coolly logical demeanor was grafted onto the Vulcan Mr. Spock to give Leonard Nimoy the character all Trekkies know and love); and Lise Hampton-Edgars (Denise Gentile), who’s just inherited ownership of one of the biggest companies exploiting Mars’s resources in its colonial period. She’s also engaged to Michael Garibaldi (Jerry Doyle, second billed to Boxleitner on the series’ regular cast list), who as the episode begins she’s helping detox from a long spell of heavy-duty drinking (so he hardly seems like a prize catch), but whose help she needs to get rid of a corrupt board of directors who tried to have her assassinated because they were worried that she and Garibaldi would uncover their corrupt machinations and get them jailed for ripping off both the company and the Martians.

Another part of the plot concerned the farewell party being given for G’Kar (Andreas Katsulas), one of the indigenous Martians on the show — you can tell the indigenous Martians because they’re wearing ugly and pretty blatantly fake-looking helmets to make their heads look bulging and their skin look mottled — which is where Garibaldi and Lise figure the hit people hired to kill her will strike. This episode had the look and feel of something being drafted to tie up loose ends before the show completed its run (indeed, one imdb.com reviewer, the quite prolific “planktonrules” from Florida, wished the show had ended with this episode because “the final two were amazingly depressing and maudlin”), and it seemed quite beautiful and moving even though one would have to have a lot more knowledge of what happened in the previous 4 ¾ seasons to appreciate it fully. But then I’ve long felt that is one of the annoyances of TV serials: whereas episodes of classic series like Law and Order and its spinoffs were self-contained and you could generally enjoy them without having to have watched them all, too many modern shows tell you basically that in order to enjoy them you have to watch all the episodes in sequence, and when TV producers tell me “all or none,” they’re pretty well guaranteeing I will watch none.