Monday, December 7, 2015

Sinatra: 100th Birthday Concert (Sinatra Family, National Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences, CBS-TV), December 6, 2015

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night’s big TV special on CBS was a tribute to Frank Sinatra on his 100th birthday (though his 100th birthday isn’t until December 12! Ironically, Billie Holiday, one of the two singers — along with Bing Crosby — Sinatra always cited as an influence, was also born in 1915, on April 7.) It was being presented by the National Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences (NARAS) — better known to you as the Grammy organization — in collaboration with the Sinatra family, and like the previous Grammy tributes to the Beatles and Stevie Wonder it featured miscellaneous modern artists performing Sinatra’s songs, mostly from the 1950’s (there was a sporadic attempt to cover his entire career but the great Capitol recordings, sometimes with Billy May and Gordon Jenkins but usually with Nelson Riddle as the arranger, were the principal focus) — and for the most part performing them surprisingly well and suggesting that the Great American Songbook will still have a future as a live item once the last Grand Old Man of singing from Sinatra’s generation, Tony Bennett, finally passes. Bennett was there, of course — introduced by a film clip from Sinatra himself proclaiming him the greatest singer of their sort of music — though the presentation dodged Sinatra’s influences. I’ve written before in these pages that Sinatra formed his style from equal parts Bing Crosby and Billie Holiday — when he was growing up he admired Bing’s musicality and easy phrasing (though in his early years as a solo artist, 1931-1934, Bing was a far more wrenchingly emotional and soulful singer than he became later), and then he heard Billie singing in nightclubs and was jolted into an awareness of how she used phrasing and rubato to turn ordinary (and sometimes worse than ordinary) pop songs into intense emotional dramas.

Sinatra’s style was something like an iron fist concealed in a velvet glove; there are any number of Sinatra records, both on ballads and uptempo songs, where you can listen and feel like nothing particularly interesting is happening — just a nice voice singing a nice song — and then suddenly he’ll twist the knife in and throw in a turn of phrase, an accent, a “dying fall” downward glissando (the “dying fall” was a particular Holiday trademark) that will suddenly plunge you into a different emotional landscape. Almost none of last night’s singers even attempted that level of emotional involvement with Sinatra’s material, but there were few performances that didn’t show some sympathy with the musical style of Sinatra’s songs; about the only performer who just bulled his way through the material and didn’t try to phrase it was Juanés, who was assigned to represent Sinatra’s bossa nova recordings (the two albums he made in the late 1960’s with Antonio Carlos Jobim in support) who tried to make it through one chorus of “One Note Samba” and had utterly no feel for the Brazilian rhythm. Obviously he was picked for the song because he’s South American, but Colombia is not Brazil; its native language is Spanish, not Portuguese; and the light feel of Brazil’s music totally eluded him. The program began with Sinatra himself — bits of his performance of “It Was a Very Good Year” from the Man and His Music TV specials from the 1960’s were interspersed in the show, and the opening clip also included his early hit “Saturday Night (Is the Loneliest Night of the Week)” from what looked like those odd clips from his 1957 ABC-TV series which had him singing in front of a white screen (so additional music and images could be laid in later — among his other innovations Sinatra was the first person to use vocal overdubbing on an entire album; his whole 1950 LP Sing and Dance with Frank Sinatra was recorded with the band playing first and Sinatra, who was going through a vocal crisis at the time, adding his parts later), and which were rediscovered several years ago and used for some sporadic attempts to re-create a “live” Sinatra concert by showing the films and having a live orchestra play Riddle’s (or whoever’s) arrangements behind them.

Then it began with Adam Levine singing “I Get a Kick Out of You,” and while Levine or whoever was in charge of the production dodged the “I get no kick from cocaine” lyric (Cole Porter authorized a version that substituted “perfumes from Spain” and I believe that was the one Sinatra recorded) by simply omitting the second “A” strain from the song (that happened again on at least one other song — the classic AABA structure of a 32-bar pop song converted into a 24-bar ABA), Levine sang it surprisingly well. Then a woman came out — she was identified but too quickly for me to make out her name (it must have been someone important because the audience applauded so loudly it was difficult to figure out who she was because the applause drowned out the announcement) and did a quite good version of “You Make Me Feel So Young.” She later joined John Legend on something called “We Wanted It All” (at least I think that was the title), one of those pieces of pop-rock Sinatra recorded in the 1960’s and 1970’s to try to get back on the music charts as a singles artist — despite Sinatra’s fabulous success he didn’t have a Number One Billboard chart hit between “I’ll Never Smile Again” in 1941 (and he was just Tommy Dorsey’s band singer then) and “Strangers in the Night” in 1965; his albums continued to sell, but he also wanted the higher profile of single hits. The film The Wrecking Crew features an interview with one of the musicians from that legendary L.A. studio group who recalled that after the “A”-team of session players from the previous generation left the studio after a Sinatra-Jobim session, they came in to supply the light rock sound that would hopefully get Sinatra on the charts again (and did for songs like “Strangers in the Night,” “That’s Life” — performed here by Usher in a version that was good but far too polite, lacking the edge Sinatra put on the song ­— and the horribly bombastic “My Way,” which I’d consider Sinatra’s worst major record; ah, if he’d only recorded Phil Ochs’ “My Life” instead!).

Harry Connick, Jr. came out and did “My Kind of Town” — he did it nicely enough (my late roommate/client John P. once told me he thought Connick would be the right modern actor to play Sinatra in a biopic) but I couldn’t help but savor the irony of a guy from New Orleans paying tribute to a guy from New Jersey by singing a song about Chicago. John Legend also did a weird version of “Young at Heart”; he phrased the song acceptably but his high, almost countertenor voice simply sounded wrong for the material. (The show included an interview clip in which Sinatra was talked into recording “Young at Heart” by Nelson Riddle, who said he had a song — he didn’t say what it was — that every other artist he’d offered it to had turned down, but which he was convinced was good and had the makings of a hit; Sinatra trusted Riddle’s judgment enough to agree to record it, sight unseen, and it was a hit, solidifying his comeback after his Academy Award-winning performance in a non-singing role in the film From Here to Eternity.) Connick also did “Luck Be a Lady,” and once again did justice to the Sinatra singing style but not to the Sinatra bravura, the Sinatra “swagger and attitude” — the phrase coined by Bono for that infamous Grammy Awards telecast in which Sinatra got a lifetime achievement award and then was cut off in the middle of his rambling acceptance speech — and Bono and U2’s guitarist, The Edge, performed a song they’d written for Sinatra but he hadn’t recorded: “Two Shots of Happy, One Shot of Sad.” (For all Sinatra’s attempts to reach the top of the singles charts with more contemporary material than usual — though, ironically, his last single hit was “Theme from New York, New York,” a thoroughly traditional piece of songwriting from a musical set in the 1940’s and a song which, though written for Liza Minnelli, was right down his alley — he gave the cold shoulder to major rock musicians who tried to write for him; John Lennon wrote “Nobody Loves You When You’re Down and Out” for Sinatra but couldn’t get him to record it, either.)

At least two major songs long associated with Sinatra, Cole Porter’s “Night and Day” and “I’ve Got You Under My Skin,” weren’t performed on the program — afterwards, when the show ended with a clip of Sinatra performing a bit of “My Way,” Charles asked me if Sinatra had had a signature song before he did it, and I couldn’t think of one, which was a tribute to Sinatra’s eclecticism and omnivorousness in picking material) — and among the ones that were, some of the weakest performances were of singers who tried to put in soul moves; Alicia Keys tried to liven up her usual mopey style on “I’ve Got a Crush on You” (a great song, and one Sinatra did record, but hardly one at the core of his repertoire) with some soul-style “worrying,” and Nick Jonas (who deserves better than being “typed” as a singer with a now long-since-faded boy band) did likewise with “In the Wee Small Hours of the Morning,” a song recorded by Sinatra in a world-weary matter-of-fact manner that made it far more powerful. Zach Brown swung his way through “The Way You Look Tonight” and “Stars Fell on Alabama” surprisingly effectively, though since I learned “Stars Fell on Alabama” from Sinatra’s version and later came to Jack Teagarden’s even subtler 1930’s original, it’s hard for me to put up with the way Sinatra distorted that song while trying to swing it (“Stars fractured ’Bama last night!” — really?). Still, overall last night’s Sinatra tribute was a worthy effort — it helped that for the most part they were using the original arrangements, and the program’s locale, one of Steve Wynn’s big casino projects in Las Vegas, seemed fitting enough.

Friday, December 4, 2015

Rifftrax Presents "Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny" (Rifftrax, 2015; original film by R & S Film Enterprises, 1972)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The movie we went to was a Rifftrax presentation of a thoroughly terrible movie called Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny, made in 1972 as a promotion for a pathetically inept theme park in Dania, Florida called Pirate’s World that attempted to duplicate the success of Walt Disney World and — predictably, if the rest of the place was as dull as what we see in this movie — went out of business in 1975. Rifftrax is a project of the final cast of Mystery Science Theatre 3000 — Mike Nelson, Kevin “Tom Servo” Murphy and Bill “Crow” Corbett — and though Murphy and Corbett no longer play their robot personae the concept is still basically the same: the three make jokes while a thoroughly rotten movie is playing. And not just dumb jokes, either; one of their lines last night referenced John Cage and their dialogue is a marvelous mash-up of high, low and middlebrow culture along with general snideness. It occurred to me that Charles and I were having a date night that was nostalgic for the early days of our relationship — we’d eaten at a restaurant we’d frequented when we were just starting out as a couple and now we were enjoying a new project from the crew of Mystery Science Theatre 3000, which had been in the latter stages of its original run when we first got together. To fill out Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny the Rifftrax crew dug up three Christmas-themed shorts and riffed on them. One was Santa Claus Story (1945), a weird farrago of The Night Before Christmas, the “Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus” article and documentary footage of monkeys fighting over a pretzel (I’m not making this up, you know!). The actor playing Santa was a repulsive presence with a beard whose webbing was all too visible, but at least he was better than the Santas we saw in the other movies, and it probably helped that Santa Claus Story was in black-and-white so we didn’t have to see his bright red costume in Runnycolor. Then they showed Custard the Dragon, a 1965 short so obscure imdb.com doesn’t even have a page for it; it’s based on a 1936 poem by Ogden Nash that might have been a perfectly nice piece of whimsy on the page (the Rifftrax crew invidiously compared Nash to Dr. Seuss but I’ve always liked him — I was especially fond of a poem he wrote comparing a romance to various fruits and vegetables even though the only line from it I remember is, “If we cantaloupe, lettuce marry”) but looked absolutely absurd with children in ill-fitting and really tacky trick-or-treat costumes enacting it on screen.

The plot, if you cared, is about Custard the Dragon coming out of his “cage” (actually a crib set up to look like an isolation cell at Abu Ghraib) to vanquish a pirate, then going back in his cage again. After that the Rifftraxers inflicted on us a short that, like their feature, was aimed at promoting a really cheesy theme park (these places compared to Disneyland about as well as Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny compares to Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs) called Santa’s Enchanted Village, in which one of the actors seems to have accordions in his shoes (at least that’s what we hear on the soundtrack “music,” if — as Dwight Macdonald said about talentless actresses — I may use the term for courtesy) called Santa’s Village, which was apparently constructed on identical plans in both California and Illinois. The hope that the abysmal quality of these films might make Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny look good — or even mediocre — by comparison was quickly dashed. It seems that this wasn’t the first attempt of the Pirate’s World management to dabble in filmmaking; in 1970 they’d filmed short versions of three classic fairy tales, Thumbelina, Jack and the Beanstalk and an Oz story (how they got away with the last remains a mystery, since the rights to the first Wizard of Oz were still owned by what was left of MGM and the rest of the Oz books had been sewn up by Disney), and in the original version of Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny they spliced in their version of Thumbelina in the middle as a moral tale Santa narrated to the kids who are trying to get his sled unstuck from the Florida beach where he’s been stranded. That’s the plot of Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny: Santa got stuck on a Florida beach when his reindeer decided it was too hot for them down there and bolted back to the North Pole, and various local kids (introduced in footage so grainy and ineptly staged it looks like they borrowed their parents’ home movies and spliced them in) bring in various animals (including a pig, a cow, a dray horse and an unusually fat sheep) to try to pull Santa’s sleigh out.

The plot, such as it is, stops in the middle so Santa can narrate a fairy tale from one of the Pirate’s World people’s previous productions — originally it was Thumbelina but in the version the Rifftraxers were riffing on, it was Jack and the Beanstalk, which was considerably better than the feature it was included in. While no great shakes as a movie or a fairy-tale adaptation (just as the gap in quality between films set in the California mission country is between Vertigo at the top and Incubus at the bottom, the gap between musical adaptations of Jack and the Beanstalk puts Stephen Sondheim’s and James Lapine’s Into the Woods at the top and this one at the bottom), it’s at least more watchable than the framing film: Mitchell Poulos as an adolescent Jack is at least cute and fun to look at (he can’t act for shit, but what do you expect?), and Christopher Brooks as “Honest John,” a parody of a used-car salesman who sells Jack the magic beans for his cow, actually has some acting talent even though he’s obviously channeling Gene Wilder. (Well, there are worse models.) Also the photography is considerably clearer, crisper and brighter than that of Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny, whose plot resolves itself (in a manner of speaking) when the second title character (an actor in a preposterously ill-fitting and tacky rabbit suit) arrives in a slow-moving red fire engine that looks like it began life as a Model “T” Ford and gives Santa a ride — whereupon the sleigh magically teleports itself back to the North Pole (as one imdb.com contributor pointed out, if the sleigh could do that why didn’t Santa just use it to teleport back home at the start? Because then we wouldn’t have a movie, which would have been just fine by me except it wouldn’t have given the Rifftrax people something to riff off of). The news of a possible MST3K reunion (with the original host, Joel Hodgson, instead of Mike Nelson) seems rather appalling in its way — one fears it would be like all those wretched “comeback tours” of old rock bands like the Eagles and Fleetwood Mac — but the Rifftraxers are still good at providing their odd sort of entertainment and they made Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny far more watchable than it would have been au naturel.

Follow Thru (Paramount, 1930)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Two nights ago Charles and I saw a 1930 musical called Follow Thru (that’s the actual spelling), made by Paramount based on a wildly popular musical (it originally ran for 401 performances) by the songwriting team of Buddy de Sylva and Lew Brown (words) and Ray Henderson (music) and book writer Laurence Schwab, with Schwab co-directing the film with Lloyd Corrigan from a script adapted from the original by Corrigan and Frank Mandel, both of whom were uncredited. What made this film especially interesting is it’s one of the few films made entirely in two-strip Technicolor for which the color version survives — and though virtually the only prominent colors are green and red (well, for an outdoor musical set largely on a golf course green is about the only color you really do need!), the color is watchable and really improves on a movie that otherwise has its moments but also its longueurs. The film starts in 1910, when “Dinty” Moore (Don Tompkins), a golf pro at a country club is solemnly informed that his wife is about to give birth to their child, and he’s so sure the kid will be a great golfer he’s even bought a set of miniature clubs for him to play with. Then he’s informed that the “boy” turned out to be a girl, and he takes the news with a shrug of his shoulders and a resigned comment, “Well, girls play golf, too!” The story then flashes forward to 1930, when the girl has grown up to be Lora Moore (Nancy Carroll) — though throughout the film I was assuming the more common spelling “Laura” — and she falls in love at first sight with a visiting golf pro, Jerry Downes (Charles “Buddy” Rogers, third and longest-lasting husband of Mary Pickford — they made a movie together in 1927 called My Best Girl but didn’t become a couple until 1935, after she’d divorced Douglas Fairbanks). The problem is not only that Downes is there to coach her upper-class opponent in the big tournament, Ruth Van Horn (Thelma Todd in an unusual and not entirely successful role for her), but he’s under ongoing contract to his friend Jack Martin (Jack Haley), who’s hired him to be his golf pro permanently so he can’t take on other clients without Jack’s approval.

Jack is scared of women — when he meets one he might actually be attracted to he does a singularly ugly involuntary routine of batting his eyes and making gulps with his mouth like a (literal) fish out of water — and Haley (who was also in the original stage production) portrays this by making Jack a screaming queen, so much so that when he and Jerry start talking about kissing girls I half expected Jack to bat his eyes at Jerry and say, “Kiss me.” Previously Jack went to a masquerade party, whereupon he let a girl get him drunk and steal his ring, a family heirloom that the Martins have had for so many generations Jack’s father will disinherit him if he can’t recover it. The girl who boosted Jack’s ring is, of course, on hand in the main action; she’s Angie Howard (Zelma O’Neal, also in the original stage version, and she and Haley steal the film out from under the two leads), Lora’s caddy, and she’s convinced that Jack promised to marry her and is determined to make him make good on that. Also on hand is an older guy named J. C. Effingham (Eugene Pallette, about midway since his playing a romantic lead for D. W. Griffith in Intolerance and the bloated, gravel-voiced apparition he was in his later character parts) whose plot function is not altogether clear. The film is rather dull to watch during the long sequences on the golf course, but the numbers at least somewhat redeem it even though the dance duets between Haley and O’Neal on “Button Up Your Overcoat” (one of the three original De Sylva, Brown and Henderson songs retained from the stage version — as was standard practice well into the 1940’s, Paramount commissioned new songs from other writers and stuck them in) and between Rogers and Carroll on “A Peach of a Pair” (a nice pun courtesy of songwriters Richard Whiting — Margaret Whiting’s father — and George Marion, Jr.) were truncated to a few steps before the movie cut away from the good stuff back to that boring plot. The plot, in case you were wondering, is that Lora is determined to avenge herself against Ruth Van Horn for beating her in a tournament at the start of the film, and with the support of Jerry Downes and his putting tips she ultimately wins a rematch and puts the rich bitch in her place.

Along the way we get something of a production number to the De Sylva-Brown-Henderson song “I Want to Be Bad” — great flames spout up from the dance floor and the chorus line appears alternately as devils and angels — which is the best thing in the movie. Follow Thru is almost miraculous in its survival — about the only other full-length two-strip musicals that actually survive in color are Samuel Goldwyn’s dazzling Whoopee (preserved because Goldwyn, more than most movie moguls, appreciated that his films were his legacy and should be saved — indeed, his son remembers dad walking him through the film vaults and telling him that that was his inheritance) and Universal’s The King of Jazz (which I’ve read online is in the middle of a major restoration project that has proved so complicated it may be finished before I die, but I’m not holding my breath for it). According to film historian Richard Barrios, Technicolor retained ownership of the physical prints of their movies and had the two-strip prints delivered to them and destroyed en masse when the three-strip process was introduced — but somehow Follow Thru escaped the auto-da-fé and survived in color. In black-and-white it would be just another dull musical from the early days of sound, but in color it’s actually rather fun even though one can see the heavy makeup used to make the characters look credible in the color process. Nancy Carroll in particular looks like a china doll, with huge blotches of rouge on her cheeks — but that’s still better than seeing the two-strip films that now exist only in black-and-white, which look like all the actors, including the males, are wearing heavy black lipstick. One reason Ethel Waters comes off so much better in On with the Show than the white performers — aside from her being by far the best singer in the cast — is the print-down from two-strip to black-and-white did her dark skin less damage than it did to the fairer complexions of the white performers!

Thursday, December 3, 2015

Christmas at Rockefeller Center (NBC, December 2, 2015)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night Charles and I stayed in and watched TV, including the Jeopardy! episode and some other shows that were on NBC. There was the annual Christmas at Rockefeller Center mini-extravaganza that combined an all-star concert with the famous tree lighting — the tree isn’t that big a deal but the concert was a lot of fun even though some of the performers weren’t necessarily the ones I would have picked. The show opened with a women’s chorus singing a rather sappy version of “Let There Be Peace on Earth,” offered in honor of the San Bernardino shooting victims (though I presume the program had long since been determined when that event happened) but got a lot better as it proceeded. First Michael Bublé came on and did “It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas” — apparently from a Christmas CD he just released specifically focused on Christmas songs written for holiday-themed movies — his isn’t a great voice but it’s still nice to hear him and think the standard repertoire has a future and there are going to be people still around to sing it once Tony Bennett croaks.

Then a sensationally successful guy named Andy Grammer (I’d never heard of him before, but he is cute!) did a version of “The Little Drummer Boy” that at first appalled me, less because of him than the din going on behind him. “It’s supposed to be the little drummer boy, not the little drum machine!” I joked — but as the song progressed I started to get into the infectious spirit of his rendition even though I’d have preferred him to have done it with a flesh-and-blood drummer. Afterwards they brought in the aging James Taylor — wearing a ball cap to hide the pate the top of his head has become (I’m sure a lot of the people who bought Sweet Baby James 45 years ago were at least initially attracted to the album because of that magnificent head of hair on the cover, and so to see him develop male-pattern baldness big-time was more of a shock than it should have been) — to do “Winter Wonderland” with Chris Botti playing some Miles-esque trumpet behind him. Then The Band Perry, one of my favorite current bands — mainly due to the incredibly soulful and infectious voice of lead singer Kim Perry rather than the two brothers who play instruments and do backing vocals behind her decently but unspectacularly — tore into “Santa Claus Is Coming to Town” (using a tastefully updated version of the Phil Spector/Jack Nitzsche arrangement that was also what Bruce Springsteen covered), and they were followed by what was billed as a modern-day a cappella group called Pentatonix. I wish they had done their song, “Joy to the World,” totally a cappella instead of backing themselves with yet another one of those infernal drum machines, but aside from that noise in the background it was a quite capable rendition, featuring yet another soulful blonde white woman singer who was giving Kim Perry a surprising run for her money.

Afterwards Sting came on with a sort of neo-folk ensemble doing a song I hadn’t heard called “Soul Cake” (though with enough of his trademarks it’s almost certainly an original) — at first I misheard the announcement and thought Chris Botti was playing on it, too, but the secondary voice turned out to be a violin instead of a trumpet, and a quite capably played Irish folk-fiddle style violin at that. Then the announcers said that Carly Rae Jepsen was about to come on and sing “the Wham! classic, ‘Last Christmas’” — “Wham!” and “classic” are two words I never thought I’d hear in the same sentence, but the song itself was fun and nice to hear. After that Andrea Bocelli did “Adeste Fidelis” (we know it as “O Come, All Ye Faithful,” but Bocelli sang it in the original Latin), after an unctuous announcer had informed us that Bocelli had sold 100 million records, more than any other classical singer in history (more than Pavarotti? Somehow I rather doubt it!). Bocelli has a nice voice, and of course the fact that he’s blind has probably built up a lot of sympathy for him among the people who’ve bought some of those 100 million records, but I can’t help thinking of Willie Johnson, Willie McTell, Art Tatum, Lennie Tristano, Erroll Garner, Ray Charles, Stevie Wonder, José Feliciano and all the other musicians who’ve shared Bocelli’s blindness but not his blandness! Then the Radio City Music Hall Rockettes came on with a dance routine to a song called “Let Christmas Shine,” and after that, in yet another tie-in to NBC’s promised live telecast of the musical The Wiz tonight, Mary J. Blige, who’s playing the Wicked Witch in their production, came out and did a quite good soul version of “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas.” Very clever, these hypesters at NBC: have a major star who’s going to be in your production of The Wiz sing a song originally written for Judy Garland!

How the Grinch Stole Christmas! (The Cat in the Hat Productions/MGM Television, 1966)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

After that NBC showed a rerun of How the Grinch Stole Christmas! (the exclamation point is in Dr. Seuss’s original title), originally made in 1966 and featuring Boris Karloff as both the overall narrator of the story and the voice of the Grinch — which enabled him to do his warm, lovable, comforting voice and his sinister villain’s voice alternately in the same project. I hadn’t seen this one start-to-finish in years but I enjoyed it — particularly for the spectacular sight gags created by animator and co-director Chuck Jones, the genius behind the Bugs Bunny and Road Runner cartoons (so he can be forgiven the misbegotten 1970 MGM feature The Phantom Tollbooth, which TCM showed on Thanksgiving Day and which Charles, our friend Peter and I watched about half of before getting bored and turning it off). Much of Grinch is un-narrated and carried mainly by Eugene Poddany’s musical score and Jones’ incredible sight gags, and it was also nice to look it up on imdb.com and find that the voice of little Cindy Lou Who was June Foray — who was also the voice of Rocky the Flying Squirrel on the Rocky and Bullwinkle show and the villainous priestess from India in the 1953 film Sabaka (which also starred Boris Karloff, so this was a sort of reunion for them!). The songs by Albert Hague with lyrics by Ted “Dr. Seuss” Geisel (“Seuss” was his given middle name) are infectious — the Grinch’s theme song is especially fun (and though it’s sung by Thurl Ravenscroft one could readily imagine Karloff doing it himself) — and Jones, who co-directed with Ben Washam, deserves credit for combining his artistic style with the incredibly distinctive drawings of Geisel/“Seuss.” And of course there’s the famous anecdote that Karloff, upon winning the Grammy Award for the release of the film's soundtrack on record, looked at the award — a model of an old-time gramophone — and said, “It looks like a doorstop.”

Wednesday, December 2, 2015

Marked Money (Pathé, 1928)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The movie was Marked Money, a 1928 production from Pathé starring child actor Junior Coghlan and George Duryea, the true name of the 1930’s Western star Tom Keene, and the ambiguous notes on the movie from the download site made it look like it was a Western about counterfeiters. Wrong on both counts: it starts out on board a sailing ship but it’s clearly set in 1928, and “Boy” (Junior Coghlan, whose real name was Frank Coghlan, Jr.) is on board when two plug-ugly thugs attack one of the officers because he won’t tell them where a small box containing $25,000 in cash is hidden on the boat. The victim survives long enough to be taken off the ship and to the home of the (apparently retired) Captain Fairchild (Bert Woodruff), but then expires, and on his body they find a note saying that he wants Captain Fairchild to raise the boy and the $25,000 is to pay for his education and all other expenses taking care of him until he’s an adult. Boy is shown as a precocious little kid — he cuts off a piece of chewing tobacco and uses it himself, and when he sees Captain Fairchild’s model ship he points out that the rigging is wrong. It’s obvious the people who made this movie — writers George Dromgold, Howard H. Green, Sanford Hewitt and John T. Krafft, and director Spencer Gordon Bennet (who had a long career but in the sound era specialized in serials — he did the second Columbia Batman serial, Batman and Robin, and their two Superman serials, Superman and Atom-Man vs. Superman) — were channeling Charlie Chaplin’s The Kid and Jackie Coogan’s marvelous performance in it, and particularly Coogan’s precociousness; Coogan made being precocious the stock in trade of virtually every child actor in the movies until 1934, when the enormous success of Shirley Temple transformed the default setting for depicting kids in movies from “precocious” to “cute.” Marked Money isn’t a Western and doesn’t have anything to do with counterfeiters — we’re given no evidence that the $25,000 is anything other than the Real Federal Reserve McCoy — and though imdb.com marks it as “melodrama” it’s closer to comedy than anything else. Captain Fairchild has a daughter, Grace (the quite lovely and appealing Virginia Bradford, who for some reason didn’t attempt a transition to sound and made only one more film, One Man Dog, in 1929), who shows up in aviator drag and is warned by the family servant, Bill Clemons (Tom Kennedy, who did go on to a talkie career as a character actor, usually playing dumb cops), to get out of those clothes before she sees her dad, who doesn’t like pilots or anything to do with flying.

As luck would have it, Grace is dating Clyde (George Duryea a.k.a. Tom Keene), who’s a Navy aviator — she solemnly warns him to take the wings off his uniform and as (bad) luck would have it, he drops them into Captain Fairchild’s soup and the good captain digs them out again and realizes not only that his daughter is fooling around with planes, she’s in love with a guy who flies, too. Of course Clyde’s pilot skills come in handy big-time when Grace is kidnapped by the bad guys (ya remember the bad guys?) who have grabbed her in hopes she’ll know where the $25,000 is (ya remember the $25,000?) — they’re pretty hapless bad guys, given to staring into the house through the mail slot and looking for all the world like they’re going to seek admission into a speakeasy by saying “swordfish.” (Like Command Performance, Marked Money is the sort of bad movie that keeps reminding you of great ones.) The climax is an aerial dogfight in which Grace is thrown into the back of a plane but comes to long enough to pilot herself and Boy to safety, while the baddies are brought to book and Clyde shows off his own aerial heroics in bringing them to justice. There’s a tag scene in which Boy ties a “Just Married” sign and some string with tin cans tied to it to the back of the plane in which Clyde and Grace take off on their honeymoon. Marked Money isn’t a great film, but it’s charming and cute, and Coghlan, Duryea/Keene and Bradford are all appealing in their roles (which helps take the edge off a typically obnoxious, hammy performance in the role of Captain Fairchild — though I wouldn’t blame Bert Woodruff for this because in movies this old playing a father, especially one whose kid was already an adult, was practically an engraved invitation to overact), and it was nice to see it with the original RCA Photophone soundtrack attached. Though Marked Money was shot as a silent film, it was equipped with a recorded music score that was sent out as part of the film so theatres who had wired for sound and paid off their in-house musicians because they thought their jobs would no longer be necessary could still show the film. Enough movies equipped with recorded versions of the live scores that had previously been played in-house came out and were advertised as “sound” that in some cities the Better Business Bureau warned moviegoers, “‘Sound’ doesn’t always mean ‘talk.’”

Tuesday, December 1, 2015

Command Performance (James Cruze Productions/Tiffany Pictures, 1931)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2015 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night Charles and I watched a rather interesting movie from 1931, billed on imdb.com as being made by “James Cruze Productions” (though, alas, Cruze, one of the most underrated directors of the silent era, didn’t direct this one — the young Walter Lang did) and released through Tiffany Pictures. The original title was Command Performance, and it was based on a short-lived (only 29 performances) Broadway play by Stafford Dickens (no relation, I presume) that shamelessly ripped off The Prisoner of Zenda (which when this movie was made had already been filmed twice as silents — including a 1922 version directed by Rex Ingram and starring Ramon Novarro — but which wouldn’t be made as a talkie until the superb David O. Selznick production from 1937, starring Ronald Colman). The play used the names of real Eastern European countries or provinces — the prince at the center of the action, Alexis (played in the movie by Neil Hamilton), is from Moldavia and his father, the Moldavian prince consort, wants him to marry Katerina (a surprisingly non-comic Una Merkel), princess of Wallachia, to cement an alliance against a well-armed foreign power who will conquer Moldavia if it can’t find an ally. (The real Wallachia is one of the three provinces, along with Moldavia and Transylvania, that make up modern-day Romania; Wallachia was also where the 15th century king and warlord Vlad Tepes Drakulya ruled and reportedly beheaded and impaled over 100,000 victims to keep himself in power; he was the historical character on which Bram Stoker based his vampire Dracula — the name a corruption of the Romanian “Drakulya,” meaning “Little Dragon,” since Vlad’s father had called himself “Drakul,” or “Dragon” — only he misread the historical sources and located Dracula’s origins in Transylvania, and many writers who’ve adapted the Dracula story have compounded the error by locating Transylvania in Hungary!) For the movie, however, screenwriters Maude Fulton and Gordon Rigby changed the names of the countries from the real Moldavia and Wallachia to “Serbland” (at least that’s what Charles and I thought we heard on the soundtrack on a download — from a reissue print that changed the title of the movie to He’s a Prince! — and Charles looked up “Serbland” on his smartphone’s Web connection and found it’s the name of a region in Montenegro, which made both of us chuckle at the thought that a country as small as Montenegro could have “regions”) and “Cordovia,” respectively.

Anyway, the plot is about an actor in Serbland (or whatever it’s called) named Peter Fedor (Neil Hamilton), who’s arrested by Serblandian police in full Ruritanian palace guard gear while rehearsing his latest production. It turns out the cops want him because on his way to the rehearsal he saw a man accosting his co-star and girlfriend Lydia (Thelma Todd, who is fine but regrettably disappears after the opening scene), and hit him. Alas for Peter, the man he hit was Prince Alexis, who’s a notorious skirt-chaser but for some reason finds Katerina, the woman his parents want him to marry, too repulsive to go through with the deal. So Queen Elinor has the Prince imprisoned, and her husband and his justice minister threaten Peter with a likely lethal term of imprisonment at hard labor in the salt mines. Then they notice the striking resemblance between Peter and Prince Alexis, so they decide to make Peter an offer he really can’t refuse: if he doesn’t want to go to the salt mines, he can go to Cordovia, make Katerina fall in love with him, and ready her to marry the prince. (One imdb.com reviewer lampooned this movie and its prototype, The Prisoner of Zenda, for basing their central premises on the idea that two people growing up miles away from each other and with no discernible family ties should be such exact doubles of each other that they can be played by the same actor, but there’s a bit of passing dialogue in Command Performance that suggests Peter is actually the illegitimate son of Queen Elinor and therefore the prince’s half-brother. Zenda too explained the resemblance between the royal and his impersonator through an illegitimate birth, but even though it took place generations earlier than the main action, Selznick’s 1937 version got the Production Code censors riled up in an era of tighter enforcement than prevailed when Command Performance was made in 1931.) When he gets to Cordovia Peter is greeted with open arms by King Nicholas (Albert Gran), a man whose sole hobby is cracking and eating nuts (which suggested to me he’d be more at home ruling Klopstokia, the mythical setting of the 1932 Million Dollar Legs — yes, Command Performance is the sort of mediocre movie that keeps reminding you of great ones), and his queen, Elizabeth (Vera Lewis) — but Katerina herself has his doubts about him and really doesn’t want to marry a man just to cement a political alliance.

As if that weren’t enough jeopardy for Our Hero, he also has to worry about the prime minister, Duke Charles (Mischa Auer in one of the marvelous slimy-villain performances he turned in during the early 1930’s before he got “typed” as a comic actor), who’s killed every previous suitor for Katerina’s hand and is out to kill the prince because he’s an isolationist who doesn’t believe Cordovia needs any entangling alliances that might get the country involved in other people’s wars. Of course, he also wants to marry Katerina himself and become king, or at least prince consort, of Cordovia and the real power behind the throne — and I couldn’t help but quote the lines from Lubitsch’s The Love Parade in which the courtiers complain that no one really wants to be the prince consort because “he has nothing to do” — to which Eugene Pallette, in his unmistakable gravelly voice, said, “Well, he does have something to do” (i.e., fuck the queen to produce an heir to the throne). You see what I told you about Command Performance being a mediocre movie that keeps reminding you of great ones? Indeed, at one point there was a grand scene in which the entire court of Cordovia is assembled to give the (supposed) prince a formal greeting, and all I could think of was Duck Soup; I said, “Where was Groucho Marx when this film needed him?” The story progresses doggedly along the Prisoner of Zenda plot template until the ending, when the formal wedding of Prince Alexis and Princess Katerina is about to take place — even though Peter has already “outed” himself to Katerina and she’s hopelessly in love with the actor and is willing to marry the prince and even have sex with him, but has no feeling for him whatsoever. Then Alexis disappears from the action, leaving his parents a note which says that he realizes the princess doesn’t love him and he doesn’t really want to be a king anyway, so he’s renouncing all rights to the Serblandian throne and leaving the country. There’s only one thing to do: the queen and her consort persuade Peter to take Alexis’s place permanently, marry Katerina and rule the combined kingdoms of Serbland and Cordovia once their currently existing monarchs croak.

This happy ending is hardly as moving as the bittersweet one of The Prisoner of Zenda, but it works for a film that’s surprisingly good for a 1931 indie even though Lang was still directing like it was 1929, allowing his actors to deliver their lines in a stage-bound manner and having them pause between their cue lines and their own lines. (Those maddening pauses were among the reasons a lot of critics in 1929 thought silent films were more naturalistic than talkies.) Though the budgets of James Cruze Productions and Tiffany Pictures didn’t allow for any shots showing both Neil Hamilton characters in the same frame (compare to the dazzling on-screen meetings between the two Ronald Colmans in the 1937 Zenda), remember that this was first done as a play and having Alexis and Peter meet onstage would have been impossible there, too. Producer Cruze and director Lang artfully use stock footage (most likely newsreels of actual weddings from the Austro-Hungarian Empire or some of the countries that derived from it after it was on the losing side in World War I) to make their movie look more impressively budgeted than it was, and they were also quite good at finding standing sets — including the veranda shown in the opening sequences (one of those frame-breakers in which it looks like Peter and Lydia are really Ruritanian royals, and then the camera pulls back and reveals they’re only rehearsing a play), which I’ve recognized from several Paramount films, including the Marx Brothers’ Monkey Business (there, I’m doing it again! I’m citing an acknowledged classic Command Performance reminds me of). Even at just 1 hour and 11 minutes, Command Performance drags a little, and of course it wins no points for originality (one almost wishes they’d gone whole-hog with the resemblance and spoofed The Prisoner of Zenda instead of ripping it off “seriously”), and of course Neil Hamilton can’t hold a candle to either Ramon Novarro or Ronald Colman, but Command Performance is still a charming movie in its own right and the performances of Merkel and (briefly) Todd are especially treasurable in roles quite different from the ones we’re used to seeing them in.