Wednesday, January 6, 2016

NCIS & NCIS: New Orleans: “Sister City” (Belisarius Productions, Wings Productions, When Pigs Fly Productions, CBS Television Studios, aired January 5, 2016)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night the CBS-TV shows NCIS (the original one that kicked off the franchise, based in Washington, D.C.) and NCIS: New Orleans did a so-called “crossover event,” a story that not only crossed over the time slots of the two shows but told a continuing story with both sets of regular characters. The combined episode — combined considerably more artfully than Law and Order and “Chicago Trilogy” producer Dick Wolf has been able to achieve when he’s done these sorts of cyclical shows — starts out with a modern-day high-tech knockoff of the mystery of the Marie Celeste: a plane with a full fuel tank but no one on board — at least no one alive; there are five crew members and passengers, but they’re all dead — enters the airspace over Washington, D.C. and the Naval Criminal Investigative Service (which is what NCIS stands for, both on these shows and in real life, though these days you’d never know that from most of the scripts) is assigned to jam the input to the plane’s automatic pilot from the GPS system so the plane crash-lands harmlessly in a deserted field somewhere instead of the middle of a major metropolitan area, where its nearly full fuel tank could explode and jeopardize hundreds of innocent lives. The plane is owned by a super-capitalist high-tech entrepreneur named Jenner Blye (Samrat Chakrabarti — and given how much of the American manufacturing sector has been taken over from companies from China and India, it’s chillingly appropriate that this Anglo character be cast with an actor whose name proudly proclaims Indian, or at least subcontinental, origins!) whose company developed a defense weapon called Manta Ray. From the script by Christopher J. Waild, we never learn much about what Manta Ray is, how it works (or doesn’t, since it’s established early on that the U.S. Defense Department rejected it), or why it’s so important that elements of the Russian secret service were sent to steal it and kill anybody involved in it or who knows its whereabouts.

There was supposedly a secret meeting between Blye, his executives and Russian representatives, including Anton Pavlenko (Lev Gorn), and someone else has sent a professional assassin to kill everyone who was at that meeting. The assassin is Eva Azarova (Cassidy Freeman — someone created a woman out of a clone of David Cassidy and Bud Freeman?), who gets access to the Blye entourage by setting a so-called “honey trap” which, as anyone who’s ever seen a film noir with Barbara Stanwyck in it (or, for that matter, a James Bond movie) could guess, means a woman who sexually seduces and enthralls a man as part of an espionage plot. The man is Luca Sciuto (Tyler Ritter), brother of NCIS series regular Abby Sciuto (Pauley Perrette, she of the ever-annoying pigtails), a master chef whom Blye hired to cook his meals wherever he was — only he wasn’t on the plane with the other four even though he was supposed to be, which of course leads the NCIS team to suspect that he had something to do with the murders of everyone who was on the plane. Abby predictably pleads that her brother could never have committed such a despicable crime, and when we finally meet Luca, he turns out to be the most dementedly clueless character since the role Cillian Murphy played in the film Breakfast on Pluto, utterly unwilling to believe that his hot girlfriend was just using him for a plot that included sabotage and murder. As the story rolls on and the people at NCIS D.C. trace the plot to New Orleans, where Eva was based and the haunted flight originated (and we get some nice glimpses of CCH Pounder as the New Orleans medical examiner — I always liked both her name and the air of no-nonsense authority she projected, and it’s a pleasure to see her here just as it’s a pleasure to see the older David McCallum, whom I had a hot boy-crush on in his days on The Man from U.N.C.L.E., as the D.C. medical examiner even though he’s weathered the years less well than I have — odd that with all the hot, in both senses, young and young-ish actors on these shows the two most interesting players would be the venerable character actors playing the medical examiners!), and the story travels there for the second half.

We meet a few more interesting characters, including Eva’s hard-assed boss in the Russian secret service, Paulina Kurteva (Tina Benko), and we find that the killings were all (or almost all — at least one of the surprise baddies gets offed in the more prosaic manner of getting shot) done with a super-toxic poison that’s deadly to the touch, and which was administered by lining flatware and bottle tops with it, so the person who lifted the knife or fork or opened the bottle would die while the others in their party who didn’t handle “spiked” utensils would live. Yeah, right — though since the real Russian secret service has been accused of offing its enemies by feeding or exposing them to radioactive polonium (the other element Pierre and Marie Curie discovered, and which she insisted on naming after her native country, Poland), maybe this plot device isn’t so nonsensical at all. Eventually there’s a shoot-out inside an art museum and Jenner Blye’s security person, Blake Huxley (Alex Quijano), is killed (he’s the one who just gets it with a gun instead of an exotic poison), and it seems like Huxley was in league with the Russians to steal his boss’s big secret Manta Ray weapon — only it turns out [spoiler alert!] that the real crook is Jenner Blye himself; when the U.S. turned down Manta Ray (for reasons which Waild’s script leaves as ambiguous as he does as to what Manta Ray was supposed to do in the first place), he decided to sell it clandestinely to the Russians and then apparently had to off everybody who could have testified that he had offered it to the Russians so he couldn’t be prosecuted for treason and could claim to have been the victim of industrial espionage instead. It’s a show with more than its share of silly premises and plot twists, but “Sister City” is an effective two-hour suspense melodrama if you can forget how improbable it all is and how unbelievably naïve Luca Sciuto is (eventually it turns out that both he and Abby were adopted by their parents, and though they weren’t blood relations they inherited their parents’ willingness to take in “stray cats,” an expression I was using long before Waild put it in his script, meaning people who are homeless or disabled or crazy or all three and trying as best one can to help them out), and handle the annoying characters on either end: Pauley Perrette (who since it’s her brother who’s in peril at least gets to act a bit more emotionally than usual) in the D.C. NCIS and Rob Kerkovich as the terminally (and infuriatingly) nerdy Sebastian Lund in New Orleans

Monday, January 4, 2016

Don’t Wake Mommy (D Yeah Films, Marvista Entertainment, Lifetime, made 2015, released 2016)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night’s fare was two Lifetime movies, one called Don’t Wake Mommy which had had its “world premiere” the night before, and another called Bad Sister which was having its “world premiere” last night. Don’t Wake Mommy was written and directed by one Chris Sivertson but followed the Christine Conradt formula so closely he (or she?) might as well have called it The Perfect New Mom. The gimmick is that Donna (Reagan Pasternak) and her husband, firefighter Brad (the genuinely hot Dean Geyer — at least Sivertson did not follow the usual Lifetime convention of casting good-looking men only as villains!), are about to have a baby girl, Ava. Meanwhile, Beth (Sara Rue, whose imdb.com head shot shows her in a nurse’s uniform even though her character, though established as a nurse, isn’t shown working as one) is introduced threatening the married (to someone else) doctor who fathered her child-to-be, a boy named Robert. She, the doctor and his wife have a confrontation in which Beth takes out a large kitchen knife and threatens to kill either the other two or herself, but she eventually slinks away in frustration and logs on to a Web site for new mothers, where she and Donna meet. The two women ultimately meet face-to-face and become friends, and use each other as baby sitters as needed. Only, since Sivertson’s script has already established that Beth is crazy, we’re bracing ourselves for the eventual (and inevitable) scenes in which Beth starts manifesting her craziness around Donna and gets in the way of Donna, Brad and their kid.

She takes Donna out to lunch and gets Donna, a recovering alcoholic, to have a drink — and later she spikes her drink with oxycontin (she’s a recovering addict from that, too), and the drugs give Donna moments of forgetfulness, including one chilling scene in which she’s convinced she’s lost baby Ava and she and Brad finally find her locked in their car. Donna is convinced this is a sign of post-partum depression, while Brad is convinced she’s relapsing into her addictions and will pose a threat to their kid if things continue like this. Meanwhile, Donna’s friend Susan (Alex Essoe) starts investigating Beth and gets in touch with the doctor who was formerly her paramour and supposedly the father of her baby — only the doctor tells Susan (and us) that Beth is infertile and can’t have children. This is a bit of a cheat since we saw her visibly pregnant in the opening scene — were we supposed to believe she was wearing a prosthesis, or that this was one of those hysterical pregnancies (that’s actually the technical term for them) in which women not only form the delusion that they’re pregnant but get distended bellies, sore breasts, morning sickness and all the other indicia of pregnancy except a fetus in their wombs? One nice touch director/writer Sivertson pulled was having us meet Beth’s mother, who’s just as crazy as she is (a touch Mr./Ms. S. probably ripped off from Alfred Hitchcock’s Strangers on a Train and/or Psycho) and who has a “baby” of her own. We’re told that the “baby” is actually a high-tech doll called a “reborn” and it’s used for women who haven’t or can’t get pregnant (anymore) but nonetheless want the thrill of holding a newborn in their arms, one that, in the words of Johnny Marks’ song for Chuck Berry, “Run, Rudolph, Run,” “cries, sleeps, drinks and wets.”

At the end of the movie Beth kidnaps Ava and takes her to her mom’s place, where Donna traces her — in the meantime Beth has clubbed Susan to death when she caught Susan researching her background and about to expose her (that’s what being the Voice of Reason in a Lifetime movie gets you: the villainess clobbers you!), and Donna’s discovery of Susan’s body was what finally alerted her to Beth’s insanity — and Beth coolly informs her that both Ava and “her” baby Robert (whom Beth actually kidnapped from a neighbor couple) are now hers and Donna has proven herself to be an unfit mother and therefore doesn’t deserve a daughter. The two women have a fight in which Beth threatens to incapacitate Donna with an injectable drug — she’s already prepared the syringe, boasting that she knew how to do it because of her experience as a nurse — only Donna manages to get the upper hand and inject Beth with the drug instead, incapacitating her. There’s a chilling scene in which the effect of the drug unexpectedly wears off and Beth grabs for Donna’s leg — and just then the police arrive, take control of the situation, arrest Beth and recover both babies. There’s a final tag scene in which the couple from whom Beth kidnapped Robert gratefully receive him back, while Beth is shown in custody, clutching the “reborn” doll and cooing to it as if it were a real baby (yet another Lifetime ripoff of the ending of Psycho). Don’t Wake Mommy — a rather confusing title — is Lifetime at its most routine, a by-the-numbers psycho thriller in which Sara Rue doesn’t even achieve the appealingly chilly psychopathology of her predecessors in this sort of role (she makes Ashley Dulaney’s performance as the analogous character in The House Sitter look better by comparison than I thought Dulaney was when I watched that film) and the denouement is all too predictable — indeed, throughout this movie we’re anticipating each turn of the plot at least two commercial breaks ahead, evoking memories of Dwight Macdonald’s praise of the 1941 version of The Maltese Falcon for keeping us a beat or two behind the director (the young John Huston, making his first film) instead of always ahead of him!

Bad Sister (Johnson Entertainment Group, Golden Oak Entertainment, Lifetime, made 2015, released 2016)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

After Don’t Wake Mommy (and the previous night’s disappointment from The House Sitter) I was beginning to wonder if the formulae of Lifetime movies were beginning to pale with me. Fortunately the next one, Bad Sister, was considerably better, a film that came from the creators of what I have come to call the “Whittendale universe” — producer Ken Sanders, director Doug Campbell and writer Barbara Cum-Licker (oops, I mean Kymlicka) — because the stories either take place at the fictitious “Whittendale University,” a highly prestigious (and expensive) private college, or feature high-school seniors desperate for admission there. There seems to be uncertainty in the cycle as to just where Whittendale University is; I believe one film in the series mentioned it as being in Vermont, but the locale of this film is St. Adeline’s Catholic high school in Los Angeles and the Bradys (Robert Leeshock and Lise Colleen Sims), parents of the juvenile leads, fraternal twins Jason (Josh Plasse) and Zoë (Jessica Honor Carleton), talk about driving there to see it over a weekend — which would be quite a long drive indeed. From the title I might have expected a romantic or professional rivalry between two sisters, good and bad, something like the 1931 Universal film Bad Sister (Bette Davis’s first film and an early credit for Humphrey Bogart as well, in which — much to the astonishment of anyone who knows Davis from her later credits at Warner Bros. — Davis played the good sister and Sidney Fox, the Girl Named Sidney, played the bad one) — but no-o-o-o-o, instead it’s a recycling of the previous Whittendale film Dirty Teacher, but with the kinkiness level ramped up big-time by making the sexually avaricious teacher bent on seducing poor, (relatively) innocent Jason Brady is a nun, Sister Sophia (Alyshia Ochse) — or at least, as we begin to suspect well before any of the characters do, an impostor posing as a nun — who’s been hired as a teacher at St. Adeline’s after her previous employers, a Catholic high school called St. Valentine’s in Missoula, Montana, gave her glowing recommendations.

Only, as we begin to suspect from the moment Sister Sophia unpacks “her” conservative brown underwear and then the bright crimson bra and panties she really likes to wear — and the panties are not only considerably hotter but noticeably smaller as well — she waylaid and knocked off the real Sister Sophia and assumed her identity. Like every other bad girl in the Whittendale universe (which seems to consist exclusively of corrupt female teachers going after male students and nubile young girl students selling themselves to rich men to pay Whittendale’s tuition), she’s willing to do anything to get Jason into bed with her, including giving his sister Zoë an undeserved C-minus on a history exam (and then entrapping Zoë into cheating on the makeup test by leaving the answers on her desk in plain sight, then reporting her when she looks at them) and slipping a marijuana cigarette into the textbook of her rival for Jason’s affections, “fast” student Sara (Sloane Avery), and a bottle of alcohol under the mattress of Jason himself. This last is a particularly effective frame because during the summer before the story takes place, the underage Jason was busted for driving under the influence, which convinced his hard-nosed dad that he was a scapegrace who needed tough-love discipline to get him on the right track, and in particular to aim him for a first-rate college instead of taking a year off to pursue a music career, which is what Jason wants to do with his life. He’s got as far with music as writing a number of songs, filming himself performing them, and posting the results on social media — which was where the false Sister Sophia first encountered him; she heard his songs, thought they indicated a mystic bond between them and set out first to meet and then seduce him. Sophia eventually gets Jason to have sex with her, first in his dorm room (emblazoned with various music-related wall hangings, including one which is a sort of combination of a treble clef and a guitar) and then, in the film’s most deliciously kinky scene, in the confessional booth of the school’s chapel, where Jason has gone to confess the sin of fornication and finds that the person on the other side of the booth isn’t the school’s priest (Hugh B. Holub, who frankly looks too Jewish to be credible as a Catholic priest) but is his crazy co-fornicator, who corners him in the booth and gets him to get it on with her then and there. (During the movie someone started a message board on imdb.com called “Implausible,” to which I contributed a post that say one shouldn’t expect anything but implausibility from a film set in the Whittendale universe of Sanders, Campbell and Kymlicka, and someone replied to me that being seduced in a confessional was “a 14-year-old private school adolescent’s wet dream.”)

Like many a Lifetime villainess before her, Sister Sophia is so determined to eliminate potential competition that she sneaks into the women’s showers and grabs hold of Sara, pummeling her against the tile wall until she seems to be dead (fortunately, Zoë comes in and discovers her in time to save her life), though Sophie’s favorite method of murder is sneaking up behind people and clubbing them with blunt instruments. It’s how she did in the real Sister Sophia, and towards the end she gives the same treatment to the Mother Superior, Sister Rebecca (a nice voice-of-reason performance by Helen Eigenberg) and in the climax is shown sneaking behind Jason and Zoë in the chapel after Jason and Zoë have sneaked into Sophia’s room and found both the laptop she took from the real Sister Sophia and her own, which contains hundreds of photos of Jason (the old cliché in which the obsessed person posts hundreds of physical photos of their obsession object on their wall has given way to this higher-tech version of hundreds of photos on their computer) and reveals her real name as “Laura Patterson,” though in the earlier scene in which she ambushed and killed the real Sister Sophia, the real one knew and addressed her as “Candice.” She’s about to club them with a church candlestick when the priest and Sister Rebecca come in and overpower her; Sophia once again tries to kill Sister Rebecca — this time by strangling her — only Jason is able to grab the screwdriver he and Zoë previously used to pick the lock of Sister Sophia’s room and fatally stab her with it, saving the Mother Superior’s life and ending Sophia’s reign of terror. There’s a tag scene in which Dad Brady, finally resigned to Jason’s ambitions for a musical career, gives him a guitar while he gives Zoë a car so she’ll have one at Whittendale.

Bad Sister was good clean dirty fun in the best Whittendale-universe tradition, effectively directed by Campbell and mostly well acted; Josh Plasse looks way too preppy in his short hair and ubiquitous dress shorts to look credible as an aspiring rock star (though the songs composed for him by musical director Steve Gurevitch aren’t bad at all; throughout the film I couldn’t help but remember that Bruce Springsteen went to Catholic school, and some of his early songs have bitter anti-Church comments like “Nuns walk through Vatican halls pregnant/Preaching immaculate conception” that were clearly influenced by that experience, though the character cites Justin Bieber as his role model and his music is considerably closer to Bieber’s than Springsteen’s, while he sings in such a high voice for a man one of the other characters says, “You sing like a girl,” and when my husband Charles came home in the middle of one of Jason’s songs he said, “Why is he trying to sing like Tracy Chapman?”) and the film would probably be more believable if he’d worn his hair in the Elvis-style cut of his imdb.com head shot. Alyshia Ochse delivers a marvelous performance as the psycho pseudo-nun, managing indeed to come off like a 14-year-old parochial schoolboy’s wet dream of the woman he’d like to lose his virginity to and maintaining her balance between her nun identity and her slut reality even though writer Kymlicka has her lay a trail a mile long, including not knowing the “morning prayer” with which she is supposed to begin every first-period homeroom class, and calling on the students to lead it instead. (One person on that imdb.com message board wondered why she didn’t bother to learn the morning prayer.) Sloane Avery also strikes a nice balance between her character’s genuine romantic, as well as sexual, interest in Jason and her reputation as the “fast” girl on campus, as if she thought she could get Jason by making herself seem sexually available to every guy on campus. The actors playing the parents don’t have much of a chance to do more than play the stereotypes — hard-assed father and relatively indulgent mom — and the other people on campus (except for Helen Eigenberg’s finely honed performance as Rebecca) are pretty much an anonymous mob, but Bad Sister is overall a nicely entertaining, if frankly unbelievable, movie that’s a pleasant time-filler as well as a good clean dirty exercise in the quirky kinkiness of the Whittendale universe.

Sunday, January 3, 2016

The House Sitter (Moody Independent/Lifetime, 2015)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The film was a Lifetime movie called The House Sitter — note that it’s three words instead of two, though it’s an oft-used title: imdb.com lists a Housesitter (no article) from 2007 (“Waitress Elise’s dream to become a painter isn't going anywhere, unlike her ex Gerry's, so she eagerly accepts to house-sit a month the country estate eccentric gentleman Frank inherited), a The Housesitter from 2012 (“For more than a century an elite secret society from a prestigious New England university has engaged in a macabre rite of passage. Now, a rival they did not know they had has sent a killer”) and another The House Sitter from 2015 (“A house sitter considers the possibility he may not be alone; after he starts hearing strange noises during the night”). The fact that this title has been used so often may explain why this one was originally filmed under the title Welcome Home — though it’s cut so closely to the Christine Conradt format, albeit written and directed by others (Marcy Holland is the writer and Jim Issa — any relation to Darrell? — is the director), they might as well have called it The Perfect Housesitter. It’s basically the same-old, same-old Lifetime formula that’s got pretty threadbare after they’ve been making these movies for over a decade. It begins with a confusing prologue in which a young woman and her boyfriend come to the home of her parents, from whom she’s been estranged for years, and finds that they’re seated at the dining table with their throats slit. Through most of the film I was unclear as to whether that was going to be the denouement we should expect from the main story or whether that was a crime committed by the title character similar to what she was planning to do to the other central characters (it turned out to be the latter).

The main characters are the Lawrences: father Kyle (Sean O’Brien), mother Sara (Kate Ashfield) — who speaks with an impeccable upper-class British accent throughout; presumably Kyle, whose own vocal tones are nasal American Midwest, met and married a British woman lo those many years ago — and their two daughters. One of them, Lauren, the older, died before the main action begins — she fell through the ice at a frozen lake where the Lawrences were vacationing — and the other, younger daughter Amy (Shelby Young) is alive but all too conscious that her parents considered her second-best when her sister was alive and still do even though she’s now the only one they’ve got. Amy is dating a cute guy named Travis (Guyon Brandt) but draws back from having sex with him. The titular house sitter is Rebecca (Ashley Dulaney, who turns in a nice psycho performance, though these nice psycho performances are starting to impress me less and less simply because as a regular Lifetime watcher I’ve seen too damned many of them — indeed, as engagingly twitchy as Dulaney is, I think Young as Amy out-acts her!), who agreed to look after the Lawrences’ home while the three of them went on some sort of business trip that ended early. Rebecca pleads with the Lawrence parents that she has no place to stay since the residents of the next house she’s supposed to house-sit are still there and aren’t planning to leave for a few more days. No problem, says Mrs. Lawrence (Mr. Lawrence is a bit more dubious, as usual in these productions); Rebecca can stay in their guest room — though Rebecca “accidentally” takes a wrong turn and ends up in the dead sister Lauren’s old room, which the Lawrences have kept unchanged as a sort of shrine to her. Amy goes ballistic when she sees Rebecca pawing through her sister’s belongings, but Rebecca apologizes in her best smarmy, mock-sincere manner.

Eventually it turns out that Rebecca is on a campaign not only to take the place of the dead Lauren in the Lawrence family but to push Amy out of the way — Sara is totally taken by her and Kyle is snowed, but Amy realizes, as she puts it, that someone as relentlessly perky as Rebecca is not to be trusted. To turn Amy’s parents against her, Rebecca drugs her water and forces her to pass out in bed, then tells them Amy has been drinking. Next Rebecca seduces Amy’s boyfriend Travis (ya remember Amy’s boyfriend Travis?) and, while they’re in the sex act, shoots them with Amy’s smartphone (luckily for Rebecca’s scheme, Amy went out without it), carefully framing the image so the red bra of Amy’s Rebecca is wearing is visible but her face isn’t, then reports to her parents that she’s found a salacious video on Amy’s phone. Eventually it all works up to the scene anticipated by the “teaser” opening in which Rebecca clubs Amy twice to make sure she doesn’t interfere, then offers to serve Kyle and Sara a dinner — only she ties them to their dining chairs and stabs Kyle so he won’t resist, and the Lawrences would be on their way to the same fate as the mystery couple in the opening scene if it weren’t for Amy, who comes to and distracts Rebecca long enough to get the gun she’s been holding on the Lawrences. It doesn’t fire, but Sara is able to undo her bonds in the confusion and she is the one who gets to grab a blunt object and take Rebecca out with it — though it’s unclear whether she kills Rebecca or just incapacitates her long enough for the police to come and take her into custody. The House Sitter is a pretty ordinary example of the Lifetime formula, a bit below par because writer Holland and director Issa tread on the thin edge of risibility through most of the film and go over it a few times — though they do create some chilling moments, including the scene towards the end in which Rebecca is holding a gun on Amy and telling her she no longer belongs in the family, and Amy is somehow able to hold on to her composure in spite of this stranger “hooking” all her worst fears about her parents looking down on her and wishing it had been she who had died instead of her sister.

Saturday, January 2, 2016

M (Superior Pictures, 1951)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night Charles and I watched one of the best movies we’d seen in quite a while: Joseph Losey’s 1951 version of M, the Fritz Lang-Thea von Harbou classic from 1931 that introduced Peter Lorre to the screen as an unnamed psychopathic murderer of children who is being chased not only by the official police but by a criminal syndicate because the cops’ search for him is getting in the way of the syndicate’s operation. The original was made at a time of intense political ferment in Germany, in which the Weimar Republic was coming apart at the seams and the Nazis were preparing to take over. Just how anti-fascist Lang was at the time is a matter for his biographers to argue about; what is known is that Joseph Goebbels was courting Lang and offering him the chance to run the entire German film industry if and when the Nazis came to power — and Lang turned him down, either because he disagreed with the Nazis politically, he had a Jewish mother and was afraid the Nazis would find out and at best fire him and at worst send him to a concentration camp. Lang and von Harbou originally called their movie Murderers Among Us, but producer Seymour Nebenzal thought that would be too incendiary and in-your-face towards the Nazis (who in 1931 didn’t yet rule Germany but could still throw their weight around and disrupt performances of music, plays and films they didn’t like by literally booing them off the stage or screen). So they shortened the title to M, after the letter one of the gangsters puts in chalk on the child-murderer’s back at shoulder level so the other gang members can more easily track him. When the Nazis did take over Germany, Nebenzal and Lang both fled and ended up in the U.S., and in the early 1950’s Nebenzal, who still owned the rights to the story, started projecting a remake. He ran into a roadblock from the Production Code Administration, which approved the project but only as a remake of an acknowledged classic. Nebenzal also ran into problems finding a director for the project. His first choice was Lang himself, but Lang wasn’t interested in remaking his old film. His next choice was Douglas Sirk, another German expatriate (who had “Anglicized” his name from Detlef Sierck), but Sirk said he would only be interested if he could throw out the story and write a new one whose only commonality with the original would be that the central character would be a mentally ill man who murdered children. When Nebenzal told Sirk he wouldn’t be able to do that, Sirk quit the project and was replaced by Joseph Losey — who also wanted to throw out the original story and write a new one about a child-murderer with no other connection to the Lang/von Harbou original. Nebenzal then told Losey about his deal with the Production Code Administration: he could remake M only if he kept to the original script and made only the most minor revisions.

The reason was that much of the material in M, including the whole concept of a killer preying specifically on children, violated the Production Code, and only by presenting the project as a remake of a classic had Nebenzal got it approved. Losey was inclined to quit the project, too, but he was broke and needed the job. Because of the circumstances under which it was made, and also because legal complications led to the film being taken off the market after its initial release and not reissued until 2013, the Losey M acquired a reputation as being a lousy movie. Surprise! It’s actually an excellent film, not as good as the original (what could be?) but a compelling movie in its own right even if the shadow of Lang’s near-perfect original hangs heavily over it. It’s also a film that bears the marks of the political ferment of the era that produced it; though nothing Losey or anyone else on the film had been anywhere nearly as awful as Nazism, 1951 was the year the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) investigation of Hollywood cranked up big-time after the initial salvos in 1947 and the industry’s cave-in during which the studios and the talent unions agreed not to hire anyone who had been named as a Communist or a sympathizer or had friends who had been or was touched in any way by the eddying spirals of guilt by association. Within a year or two quite a few of the people associated with the 1951 M, including director Losey, co-screenwriter Waldo Salt (listed on imdb.com for “additional dialogue”) and actors Howard da Silva and Luther Adler, would be blacklisted by Hollywood and either driven out of the industry altogether or, like Losey, forced into exile in Britain, where he lived and worked for the remaining 32 years of his life. One can hear the echoes of the blacklist and the questioning HUAC launched against its victims — the “Are you now or have you ever been … ” questions, with the threat of jail time for contempt of Congress if you refused to answer, and the threat of unemployability and shame as a “Fifth Amendment Communist” if you invoked the Fifth Amendment, for which at least they couldn’t jail you — just make your life impossible unless you agreed not only to name names (and thereby feed the inquisition new victims) but essentially repudiate and apologize for any even slightly Left-of-center politics you’d ever been involved in. (I sometimes shudder to think what future HUAC-style inquisitors will be able to do with the Internet, which if you use it to express political opinions at all records them seemingly forever.)

The opening reel of M has a sense of generalized terror about it as the police, confronted with the murders of six children, essentially “round up all the usual suspects,” crashing dive bars and other seamy enterprises on the thin edge of organized crime and arresting people seemingly at random in hopes that the child-murderer they’re after behaves like an ordinary criminal and goes to the same places at which more prosaic offenders hang out. The action of the 1951 M is quite close to that of the 1931 version (not surprisingly given the conditions the Production Code Administration imposed on Losey and his officially credited writers, Leo Katcher and Norman Reilly Raine), and there are particularly obvious borrowings like the elaborate balloon the killer buys for his latest victim — and the blind balloon seller who sells it to him, and who recognizes the tune the killer is whistling (in this version it’s not Grieg’s “In the Hall of the Mountain King” from Peer Gynt but a nameless bit the killer plays on a tin whistle he always carries with him, along with a knife) and helps identify him. The biggest difference is that Losey, Katcher and Raine told their story in a fundamentally different way that reflects their lack of access to elaborate studio settings and back lots; whereas Lang and his designers had built their unnamed city on the sound stages and the whole environment had an artificial look that added to the parable-like nature of the film, Losey and his crew took advantage of the greater portability of film equipment in 1952 and shot on the real streets of Los Angeles. (The city is again unnamed, but the geography is obviously that of L.A. and it’s especially “nailed” for us in the opening sequence, in which the killer is shown using the iconic Angel’s Flight two-block railway. When Charles saw the Angel’s Flight he joked, “Ah, it’s a film noir!”) The result is a movie that takes place in real urban locations, in which the cops and the crooks (no longer an ill-defined “brotherhood” as in Lang’s film, which seems to have been influenced by another Nebenzal project, The Threepenny Opera, filmed by G. W. Pabst the previous year, but a specific crime syndicate headed by an identifiable person, crime CEO Charlie Marshall, effectively played by Martin Gabel) are working through a recognizable urban landscape while both are chasing a psychopath.

Long-time Turner Classic Movies host Robert Osborne (whose age is really showing in his introductions — no wonder they’re slowly edging him out and replacing him with Ben Mankiewicz, whom I’ve referred to in these pages before as “a nodule off one of Hollywood’s most illustrious family trees”) said the makers of the 1951 M had gone much heavier on the killer’s psychology than Lang and von Harbou had, but in fact there are only a few speculations about his relationship with his mother and the embryonic beginnings of what we would now call profiling — the film ends, like Lang’s version, with the cops breaking up the kangaroo court the crooks have set up to “try” the killer and taking him away, and there’s nothing like the long and rather embarrassing ending to Hitchcock’s otherwise brilliant Psycho in which he tacks on a long speech by Simon Oakland as a psychologist explaining What Made Norman Run. What’s different about the 1951 M is that it has much more of a specific place and it takes place in a world closer to our own reality and more familiar to us than the stylized dreamscape Lang and von Harbou created in 1931. Even minor details like giving the killer a name — he’s called “David Harrow” and is played quite effectively by David Wayne (whose usual reputation was as a comedian — he made five films with Marilyn Monroe, more than any other actor — but who’s quite good here, even having to follow in the unfollowable footsteps of Peter Lorre, who when he was cast in Lang’s version also was primarily known as a comedian: when Lorre made M he was acting at night in Bertolt Brecht’s satirical farce A Man’s a Man and shooting the film by day) —bring the story home to us and give it a sense of specificity Lang’s version deliberately avoided. Even the “Watch Your Children!” propagandizing in von Harbou’s original script is ironically reflected here in a sequence in which police chief Regan (Roy Engel) appears on television (and the antique screens of the 1951-model TV’s are nostalgia trips in themselves!) essentially to lecture the city’s parents on how they can keep their kids from becoming victims, with a dire credit machine flashing the word DON’T! in italics and all caps every time he gives a piece of advice — and just about everything he says has become commonplace ever since, as kids are routinely told not to accept money, candy or rides from strangers and parents are told to make sure they know where their kids are at all times. 

In an era in which parents are increasingly brainwashed to be overprotective and not to allow their kids to go out alone at all, these parts of the 1951 M ring true today (and suggest what a modern version of this film would be like; one can readily imagine a version made and set in 2016 and keying off the decades of social paranoia about psychopathic child abusers, and how that would affect people’s reactions when confronted with a real one). The 1951 M also benefits from the characterization of Luther Adler as Dan Langley, one-time attorney who fell into alcoholism driven by his self-hatred at having taken on the grim task of representing Marshall and keeping him from paying for his crimes — and in one of the biggest single changes between this version and Lang’s, Marshall shoots Langley in the kangaroo-court sequence at the end just before the cops arrive, take Harrow alive and are relieved that they finally have a murder they can pin on Marshall personally. This makes up at least a bit for the omission of the best part of the kangaroo-court scene in Lang’s version — when the killer pleads that his life should be spared because he can’t help himself, and the leader of the crooks say that that’s exactly why they have to kill him. (Lang later said he had intended M as a message film against capital punishment, but that’s not really apparent in the movie itself.) The Losey M also benefits from the incredible (in both senses) casting of Jim Backus as the city’s mayor, who in his one scene gives the chief unwanted advice on how to catch the killer, and it’s risible to hear the censorship rear its head in a scene in which we’re specifically told that there was “no sign of violation or criminal assault” on the bodies of the child victims — for some reason it was O.K., at least in a remake of a classic, to show a mentally ill murderer who targeted kids but you had to state explicitly that he hadn’t molested his victims sexually (“criminal assault” was Production Code-speak for “rape”). The Losey M is quite a good film, not deserving of the opprobrium it’s suffered since it was made; it’s well staged, well acted, well written and the basic strength of the plot survives through the relatively minor changes, which are less in actual dialogue or situations than in emphasis and tone.

Sherlock: “The Abominable Bride” (Harstwood Films/BBC-TV, aired January 1, 2016)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

After M Charles and I watched the latest episode of the BBC-TV series Sherlock — the sometimes compelling, sometimes maddening, sometimes both simultaneously attempt to refashion the Sherlock Holmes mythos by having Holmes (Benedict Cumberbatch in the role that’s made him a star) and Watson (Martin Freeman) still living together at 221 B Baker Street in London, only in the present day instead of the Victorian era when Sir Arthur Conan Doyle created the characters and the mythos. This episode, “The Abominable Bride,” was promoted as a special in which Holmes and Watson, still played by Cumberbatch and Freeman, would be returned to the Victorian era and would solve a crime that took place therein. If that’s what they had done — simply relocated the portrayals of Cumberbatch and Freeman to Holmes’ original time and place — this could have been great, but unfortunately this is a modern TV program and has to pay homage to The Great God Serial. It had to begin with the most infuriating adverb one can hear at the start of a TV series episode — “Previously” — which is usually an automatic turn-off for me: tell me that in order to follow your series I have to watch all its episodes, that’s usually a guarantee that I will watch none. Then it contained the scene of Holmes on a plane from the most recent episode of Sherlock’s immediately preceding season, and after that establishing shot we get a title reading, “Alternatively … ” — and we finally get the return of Holmes and Watson to the Victorian London in which they were born and first loosed upon the world. The story is a good one but the resolution is simply silly: a put-upon wife named Emilia Ricoletti (Natasha O’Keeffe) is shown with two guns, randomly shooting at people in the street and saying disjointed things like, “You’re not the one.” Then she is seen standing in a second-story window putting her gun to her own mouth and pulling the trigger. Then, after her widely publicized and noticed “death,” she turns up again and kills her philandering husband with a shotgun, and afterwards other men are murdered by the ghostly apparition of Nicoletti. We meet Mycroft Holmes (Mark Gatiss in a padded suit) finally looking like the voluminous creature Conan Doyle described — I’ve commented before that Rex Stout’s Nero Wolfe mysteries are what the Holmes stories would have been if Conan Doyle had made Sherlock’s brother Mycroft Holmes the protagonist — apparently racing to an early grave by eating way more than is good for him and way more than he knows is good for him. (This is at least a refreshing change from the way Mycroft has been portrayed in the recent TV shows — as a rangy, active-looking man in Sherlock and, even worse, a sexual libertine who seduces the sex-changed Dr. Watson in the otherwise quite estimable Elementary, the CBS-TV series that not only moved Holmes to the present day but relocated him to New York and made Watson a woman.)

Then two-thirds of the way through the episode we are abruptly wrenched to the present day — the entire 19th century plot line has apparently been just a hallucination Holmes suffered during drug withdrawal, or something — though in the end Holmes begs to be put back in the 19th century so he can solve the Emilia Ricoletti case (which is apparently a legendarily unsolved murder in Victorian England), for which the principal clue he gets is an envelope of orange pips mailed to one of the victims (you’ll recall the Conan Doyle story “The Five Orange Pips” in which Holmes’ adversaries were the original Ku Klux Klan — as Charles pointed out to me, despite Conan Doyle’s reputation as a conservative his actual political references in the Holmes stories, as well as his real-life involvement in the case of George Edalji, show leanings that today would be considered liberal: against the prosecution of the innocent, against racism, against restrictive divorce laws.) The final half-hour is a farrago of abrupt cutbacks between locations and times, interspersed with a preposterous resolution of the original mystery (it seems “Emilia” had been diagnosed with fatal tuberculosis and decided to go out with a bang, literally, by faking her own death and then assassinating her husband, and after Emilia’s actual death a gang of women activists decided to keep doing the murders, each one dressing up as “Emilia” to knock off her wayward or straying spouse) and ending in, of all places, the Reichenbach Falls and the confrontation thereon between Holmes and Professor Moriarty (Andrew Scott), portrayed as younger and nerdier than usual. I remain an old-school Holmesian who believes Basil Rathbone is still the best actor ever to play him (even though his Watson, Nigel Bruce, way overdid the comic relief) and the first two of the three actors who played Moriarty to Rathbone’s Holmes, George Zucco and Lionel Atwill, were the best ones in their role. But even within the context of an update — and even with Cumberbatch’s excellent Holmes (he may not top Rathbone but he’s a formidable rival to Robert Stephens and Jeremy Brett for second place) — Sherlock annoys me, not so much because it plays fast and loose with a classic character as that it does so to so little effect.

Friday, January 1, 2016

New York Philharmonic New Year’s Eve Gala, December 31, 2015: “La Vie Parisienne”

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

For New Year’s Eve PBS had on a gala benefit concert by the New York Philharmonic under its current music director, Alan Gilbert, that was supposed to be a salute to “La Vie Parisienne.” Gilbert made a speech at the beginning of the concert that this theme had been decided on before the horrific Islamic State attacks on Paris in November, but those events had added “poignancy” to the program. The program included only one brief work by one of the three people I consider France’s greatest composers — Berlioz, Debussy and Ravel — Ravel’s “Pavane for a Dead Princess,” which for the occasion was played by both pianist and orchestra. Ravel wrote the piece in 1900 for piano solo and orchestrated it in 1910, and in the 1930’s it was turned into a pop song called “The Lamp Is Low.” Both Benny Goodman and Red Norvo recorded “The Lamp Is Low,” and for Norvo’s version the young arranger Eddie Sauter drenched it in Ravelian harmonies and orchestral colors, in a sense returning it to its source. For last night’s performance the New York Philharmonic played Ravel’s orchestral score but invited pianist Makoto Ozone to improvise along with them, though most of his contributions were discreet obbligati to Ravel’s orchestral score and only towards the end did the orchestra stop and allow Ozone to improvise a cadenza, which he did quite tastefully and in the spirit of Ravel’s original. Not surprisingly, the piece was the most beautiful music heard all night! The program opened with the overture to Offenbach’s Orpheus in the Underworld — a piece that, like Rossini’s William Tell overture, includes a strain just about everyone knows (in William Tell it’s the “Lone Ranger” theme and in Offenbach’s it’s his famous can-can), but the strain just about everyone knows doesn’t occur until the very end of the piece. Gilbert proved himself more at home in the slower, more lyrical earlier sections than in the famous can-can, and here and throughout the program there was a particularly good (as well as particularly handsome!) Black man in the orchestra’s clarinet section taking all the solos for his instrument. After the overture mezzo-soprano Susan Graham — whose voice was considerably better than the material she was given to sing with it — did an aria called “Ah, quel diné” from Offenbach’s operetta La Périchole (which is actually about the invasion of Peru by the Spaniards in the 1500’s, and came in carrying a glass of champagne (or at least some prop substitute thereof). She tried to make herself sound drunk because apparently the character in the operetta singing the aria is supposed to be drunk.

After that there was the centerpiece of the program — a truly awful version of Saint-Saëns’ Carnival of the Animals featuring Nathan Lane as narrator. Saint-Saëns wrote Carnival as an instrumental suite (and, interestingly, thought the results so poor he never allowed the piece to be published during his lifetime) but in 1947 Columbia Records hired Ogden Nash to write a humorous narration in verse for a record they were preparing (and which they probably issued on their yellow label, indicating that these were records for children) in the manner of Prokofieff’s Peter and the Wolf. Unfortunately, last night’s performance featured a newly written narration by Laurence O’Keefe and Neil Benjamin, in which Saint-Saëns’ “animals” were turned into various human “types” lurking around New York City. This could have been good satire — indeed, in 1964 Allan Sherman did something very similar with Peter and the Wolf when, hired to perform with the Boston “Pops,” he rewrote it as Peter and the Commissar, a satire on dumb, insensitive bureaucracies in general and the Soviet system in particular. Alas, the gulf between Sherman and the O’Keefe/Benjamin team as satirists is about the size of the one between Chaplin and the latest movie or TV “comic” who thinks he can get laughs by dropping his drawers. Lane did the best, and he’s enough of a professional that he was able to get the horrifically unfunny O’Keefe/Benjamin lines out of his mouth and act like he thought they were the most hilarious words in the world, and Gilbert filled in with a quite moving and transparent performance of the score’s strictly musical parts. But overall the piece was an absolutely disgusting misfire and the New York Philharmonic and PBS should have been ashamed of themselves for putting it on the air! I was amused, however, not only that the orchestra was using reduced personnel and including the composer’s parts for two pianos (Saint-Saëns originally wrote the piece for piano duo and, like Ravel, only later orchestrated it), played by Israeli pianist Ivan Barnatan and Japanese pianist Makoto Ozone. I was amused that Ozone and Barnatan were both playing, not from printed scores, but from images of the score on a tablet computer (though afterwards in the Ravel Ozone played from paper), and they were playing two different brands of piano: one a Steinway, one a Yamaha.

Afterwards came the Ravel piece — the first selection in the second set — and then a couple of songs sung by Susan Graham, one called “C’est Ça la Vie, C’est Ça l’Amour” by expatriate Cuban composer Moïses Simons (by being a Cuban and writing a song in France — with French lyrics — he was essentially reversing the process begun with Sebastian Yradier’s “Habañera,” a piece written in and about Cuba and transposed to Spain for French composer Bizet’s opera Carmen). Ironically, the song turned out to be an ironic and joking retelling of the story of Carmen, complete with a bullfighter and a few passes by the mezzo. After that she did the great Édith Piaf hit “La Vie en Rose” — two choruses, the first in French and the second in English, which was nice — which was better than the Simons piece (the Simons really needed a singer like Josephine Baker or Eartha Kitt, with a stronger sense of how to phrase pop music and a heavier vibrato in the voice to suggest world-weariness) but still lacking the wrenching power of Piaf’s own version or the marvelous musicianship of Louis Armstrong, who recorded what I think is the best version of the English lyric: though his voice is weird to imagine in this role, his sense of phrasing and overall musicianship are excellent and it’s no surprise to me that he’s still the winner and champion for singing “La Vie en Rose” in English. The program closed in a rather embarrassing way; Gilbert and the orchestra were supposed to play a suite from Gaîté Parisienne, the ballet arranged from Offenbach’s music by Moritz Rosenthal in the 20th century, but with a ruthless commitment to keeping the program under 90 minutes they pulled the plug on the orchestra right after they’d played the ballet’s overture, and so the second movement of the suite just became backdrop for the closing credit roll and the rest wasn’t heard at all: a tacky ending to a tacky show. At least the last time the New York Philharmonic decided to commemorate French music on New Year’s Eve, they played substantial music like Debussy’s La Mer and Ravel’s Bolero — and this year they could have had Susan Graham do Berlioz’ song cycle Les Nuits d’Été (which would have suited her voice magnificently) instead of operetta and pop schlock!