by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night Charles and I watched a movie I’d recently bought
on DVD: Fantastic Four, the recent
(2015) reboot of Marvel Comics’ first set of classic characters, introduced in
a comic book from 1962 (and incorporating the Human Torch, who’d been a solo
character in one of their predecessor company Timely Comics’ 1940’s series —
the Torch and Captain America were the only characters from Marvel’s Timely
days to reappear in the run of comic books from their great period in the
1960’s and 1970’s). At one point Marvel was just another comic-book company
selling the rights to their stories and characters to whichever movie studio
they could get interested — superhero movies were pretty much a backwater in
the industry until the spectacular blockbuster success of the 1978 Superman with Christopher Reeve starring and Richard Donner
directing, 40 years after the first Action Comics loosed Superman on the world and launched superhero
comics generally, changed everything and made superhero characters some of the
most lucrative in the entertainment business — and they had made a surprisingly
disadvantageous deal on their hottest 1960’s property, Spider-Man, which they
had to buy their way out of. For a while Marvel was parceling out their
characters to various studios — Spider-Man ultimately ended up at Columbia,
Iron Man at Paramount and the Fantastic Four and X-Men at 20th
Century-Fox — until Marvel decided to create their own movie production company
and partner with various studios, and eventually they were acquired by Disney,
which seems to suck up just about every other purveyor of fantasy entertainment
much the way Galactus (an unimaginably huge space monster that lives by eating
entire planets and is part of the Marvel Universe) or Darth Vader’s Death Star
gobbles up other worlds. Anyway, 20th Century-Fox won the rights to
the Fantastic Four comics and all
the characters therein, and from they made two quite good movies in the 2000’s,
Fantastic Four (2005) and Fantastic
Four: The Rise of the Silver Surfer (2007),
which were relatively unpretentious fun-fests that avoided the strained
seriousness of some of the other superhero cycles of the decade, Christopher
Nolan’s Batman and Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man films in particular. Those films’ director, Tim
Story, and his writers (Mark Frost and Michael France on the first one, Frost,
Don Payne and John Turman on Silver Surfer), understood that the superhero genre is supposed to be mindless entertainment and not
some great meditation on the human condition, and they gave us two of the most
enjoyable comic book-based movies in recent years.
Flash-forward to 2014, when
20th Century-Fox is about to lose the rights to Fantastic
Four — their contract with Marvel said they
had to produce a new Fantastic Four
film no more than seven years after the last one — and Disney, the new owners
of Marvel, are so anxious to get the rights back to Fantastic Four that they offer Fox an extension on their option for
another Marvel property, Daredevil,
if the studio will allow the Fantastic Four rights to revert to Marvel so Disney can make the
next Fantastic Four movie.
Instead Fox, which has been dithering around the property since 2009, when they
briefly planned and then rejected a version with David Yates directing, Adrien
Brody as Reed Richards (a.k.a. the infinitely pliable Mr. Fantastic), Alice Eve
as his fiancée Sue Storm (the Invisible Woman), and either Bruce Willis or
Kiefer Sutherland as The Thing, but that project fell through. So with the
Marvel deadline for keeping the rights to the property, the “suits” at Fox
decided to throw another Fantastic Four movie together at the last minute. Instead of doing the obvious thing
and just making a third film in the Tim Story series — with Welsh actor Ioan
Gruffudd as Mr. Fantastic (and one of the bonus items on the Fantastic
Four DVD paid tribute to Gruffudd’s skills
as an actor by showing him at a press conference talking about the film — and
it was amazing how Gruffudd managed to lose completely his real-life thick Welsh accent and deliver Mr.
Fantastic’s lines in perfect American-accented English), Jessica Alba as the
Invisible Woman, Chris Evans (later Captain America in a pair of
Disney-produced films based on the Marvel character) as the Human Torch and
Michael Chiklis (who, much to his credit, refused to do CGI and motion-capture
and instead insisted on wearing a monster costume) as The Thing, who for the
benefit of the non-cognoscenti
reading this is Reed Richards’ old college roommate and football star Ben
Grimm, until the same forces that give the other Fantastics their super-powers
turns him into a giant beast that looks like a pile of animate rocks, which
comes in handy whenever the Fantastics are faced with a situation that requires
brute strength for them to escape or triumph — they decided to make an all-new
“reboot” with a new director, writers, cast and “take” on the material.
The Fantastic
Four film that eventually got made by 20th
Century-Fox was the product of the same mentality that had given the
directorship of the most recent Godzilla remake to Gareth Edwards on the strength of a surprisingly successful
low-budget indie called Monsters.
In this case, the director of choice was Josh Trank (his last name is the
German word for “drink”), who was coming off a low-budgeter called Chronicle, made in 2012, which I haven’t seen but whose
imdb.com synopsis reads, “Whilst attending a party, three high school friends
gain superpowers after making an incredible discovery underground. Soon,
though, they find their lives spinning out of control and their bond tested as
they embrace their darker sides.” (The artwork for Chronicle on its imdb.com page shows a bunch of urban skyscrapers
leaning leftward under a grey and stormy-looking sky; we know it’s in Seattle
because one of the leaning towers is the Space Needle.) In the all-too-common
round-robin system by which most movies — especially big effects-driven
blockbusters which the studios who produce them hope will be mega-hits and cash
cows for the rest of their slate — are written these days, Jeremy Slater wrote
the original screenplay and then Simon Kinberg and director Trank came in and
rewrote it. What they came up with was a film whose first half is quite
charming and fun, but whose second half sinks under the weight of its own
pretensions. The original Fantastic Four origin story in both the comic books and the Tim Story films was that
Reed Richards was a well-to-do man who was also a scientific genius, and he
self-financed a rocket project that would make him and his girlfriend, her
brother and his old college roommate the first humans in space — only the
spaceship passed through a belt of cosmic rays and fried not only the future
Fantastics but also their great nemesis, Victor Von Doom of the (fictional)
country of Latveria, who in the first Story film had taken advantage of
Richards’ financial reverses to buy an 80 percent interest in the rocket
project and also to move in on his girlfriend Sue. Anyway, the cosmic rays gave
the Fantastics the powers that would make them superheroes, while it fried Von
Doom’s appearance and forced him to wear a medieval-looking metal mask to hide
his new-found ugliness. It also turned him from a creepy but not altogether
evil character into an all-out villain, for which he took the name Dr. Doom.
The new film follows something of the same outline but it begins in 2003, with
Reed Richards and Ben Grimm as boys (Owen Judge and Evan Hannemann,
respectively — and this Ben Grimm
is not heavy-set pre-transformation like his predecessors in the comics and the
Story films) working on an early prototype of a teleportation machine with
which they expect to beam to other planets and back. Since they’re just
fifth-graders, all they manage to accomplish is to break a lot of glass, cause
power blackouts and end up with a residue of odd-looking sand; their entry is
thrown out of the fifth-grade science fair but attracts the attention of Dr.
Franklin Storm (Reg E. Cathey), who’s running a program, funded by the Baxter
Foundation, to find young geniuses, educate them and give them the money to
make exciting new discoveries from which the world will benefit and so will the
shareholders of Baxter’s parent company. By 2013 Reed Richards has grown up to
be played by Miles Teller, with Jamie Bell as Ben Grimm, and he’s encountered
the other principals: Michael B. Jordan as Johnny Storm, Kate Mara as his
sister Sue and Toby Kebbell as the future Dr. Doom. With the Baxter
Foundation’s money — and despite the predictable quibbling of board members who
don’t think all the dough Franklin Storm is expending on his youthful charges
is ever going to amount to a marketable product they can, in the current term,
“monetize” —Richards has scaled up his initial invention to a machine that can
send people literally out of this world and (hopefully) bring them back. They
try it first with a chimpanzee (ironically the chimp being led into the gizmo
and then taken out of it on its return evokes memories of the stock footage of
similar chimps being sent into space during test runs of both the U.S. and
Soviet space programs in the late 1950’s and early 1960’s before both countries
launched spacecraft with people inside) and then they decide to sneak into the
lab and do a secret test run with themselves — aside from Sue, who for some
reason gains a superpower even though she doesn’t go on the initial run.
Richards has realized that the machine hasn’t sent them to another world but to
another dimension, to a place he calls “Planet Zero” that appears to be that
other dimension’s analogue of Earth, and when he and his motley crew go there
and try to plant a U.S. flag on its soil, the planet rebels and starts breaking
up its own surface, forming cracks under which the planet’s material glows
green and shows the existence of a hitherto unknown and potentially unlimited
energy source.
The Four end up with super-powers — and are clapped into custody
by the U.S. military at the super-secret “Area 57” (even six numerals more
secret than Area 51!), where the only one who ever gets let out is The Thing,
and only because special-forces units in America’s multifarious wars in
Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria or wherever can certainly use a guy who’s not only super-strong
(able to literally rip apart a
tank with his bare hands) but invulnerable to ordinary weaponry. Only Victor
Von Doom (ya remember Victor Von Doom?) has remained stuck on Planet Zero, and his bitterness over having
his body cooked to the consistency of metal has led him, like a number of other
super-characters lately (including “The Centre” in the feature-length animated
DVD Justice League: The Final Frontier and even Noah — yes, the one from the Bible — in Darren Aronofsky’s
recent film), to become a deep ecologist, someone who thinks human beings have
become a pestilence that threatens the very survival of Earth and everything on
it and therefore need either to be allowed to kill themselves off or actively
eliminated. Only Doom is planning something even more sinister than
annihilating the human race: he plans to use Planet Zero’s energy to create a
black hole that will suck up everything on Earth and send it all flying willy-nilly into space (though, as one
imdb.com “Goofs” contributor pointed out, Doom’s force field pulls up a lot of
inanimate objects and other life forms but doesn’t seem to affect any people).
The first half of the 2015 Fantastic Four — Josh Trank completed his director’s cut by the end-of-2014 deadline
but Fox decided to demand reshoots that delayed the movie’s release until
August 2015 (and cost them the chance to release it in 3-D — the money they had
budgeted for a 3-D conversion went instead to cover the cost of the reshoots) —
is actually quite engaging, but once the principals do their journey into
another dimension the film turns bleak and heavy, complete with action
sequences that seem to exist more so the filmmakers can show off their command
of CGI than to give the audience honest-to-goodness thrills.
Director Trank put
up a short-lived tweet in August 2015 protesting the studio’s retakes and
recuts, saying, ““A year ago I had a fantastic version of this. And it would’ve
received great reviews. You’ll probably never see it. That’s reality though.”
Trank also said his version would have run between 120 and 140 minutes, whereas
the final release version was 100 minutes (and about 13 minutes of that was an
extended closing credit roll in which, unusually for a Marvel movie, there aren’t any “teaser” sequences.) According to various
imdb.com posts, though, Trank was enough of a prima donna on set that it’s hard to work up much sympathy for
him — as a put-upon director screwed over by the front office he’s hardly in
the same league as Stroheim or Welles — apparently he resented having to use
Kate Mara as the Invisible Woman instead of his choice, Allison Williams, and
he responded by giving both her and Miles Teller a hard time on the set, at one
point almost getting into a fistfight with Teller. He also apparently rented a
house for his dogs to stay in while he was shooting — and the beasts reportedly
caused $100,000 worth of damage to the property, which 20th
Century-Fox had to pay. And frankly I’m fine with Fantastic Four at its current length: I suspect the longer Trank
cuts would just be too much of a mediocre thing. Director Trank deserves at
least a small shout-out for nontraditional casting; we see the Black Dr.
Franklin Storm with a Black son, Michael B. Jordan, and a white daughter, Kate
Mara — and though it’s later explained that Dr. Storm adopted his daughter Sue as a refugee rescue from Kosovo,
it’s still an unusual twist for a movie in 2015. Nonetheless — and despite the
imdb.com page listing a 2017 Fantastic Four 2 as “in preparation” — this version of Fantastic
Four grossed just $56,114,221 in the U.S.
as of October 16, 2015 on an estimated budget of $120 million, and it’s
considered so insignificant and forgettable in the Marvel Universe that
Marvel’s official Web site doesn’t list it.
Thursday, January 14, 2016
Wednesday, January 13, 2016
It’s Gonna Blow!!! San Diego’s Music Underground, 1986-1996 (Billingsgate Media, 2014)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The film the San Diego Public Library showed January 11 was It’s Gonna Blow!!! San Diego’s Music Underground, 1986-1996, about the burgeoning punk-rock scene in San Diego in the 1980’s and early 1990’s and how after the success of Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Soundgarden and the other big Seattle bands in the early 1990’s San Diego attracted industry attention and “buzz” as “the next Seattle.” The film’s director was Bill Perrine, who was present for the screening at the San Diego Public Library and did a Q&A after the movie — he was also by far the cutest guy in his entourage, which included some of the musicians and others he’d interviewed for the film. What’s most amazing was how much of the scene in the early days was not only recorded but filmed — even though the videos of the period had to be shot on bulky camcorders and recorded to Beta or VHS tape (Perrine talked about one clip that was on a badly disintegrated VHS tape — and even that wasn’t the original; the original had been Beta and had been copied — and he was able finally to have it digitized and present the person who lent it to him with a professionally burned and mastered DVD of his recording) — including the actual footage of one notorious punk concert featuring a band called the Vandals. The Vandals met a fate incredibly ironic, given their name (both its original meaning and its common one now); theirs was one of many punk shows invaded by skinheads, who not only beat up the band members but stole their equipment, while the rest of the audience was too scared to do anything to stop it — and of course, this being a punk show, there was no security.
The constant threat of skinhead invasions meant that San Diego punk shows in the 1980’s became clandestine affairs, held in people’s backyards (Perrine remembered one particularly sympathetic mother of one of the band members, who had a home in Tierrasanta and let not only her son’s band but those of his friends play there and give outdoor parties), back rooms of clubs or wherever they could find. The shows were advertised in the pre-Internet, pre-social media age by word of mouth and a secret network of phone calls (much the way Pat Brown recalls recruiting people to join the Gay-rights picketers at the States Steamship Lines in San Francisco in 1969 several months before Stonewall) to let people know that a band they might be interested in would be playing … somewhere. Eventually a few locations coalesced that would routinely feature the music, including the Casbah (whose owner and promoter, Tim Maze — though imdb.com spells his last name “Mays,” it’s “Maze” that appears on the reproductions of posters for his shows in the film — was probably the most important person outside of the actual musicians in building the San Diego punk scene), the Ché Café on the UCSD campus (now threatened with demolition by UCSD’s administration) and the Adams Avenue Theatre (which is now, sadly, a fabric store — public venues in San Diego’s inner city having a huge problem succeeding: the lack of convenient parking space) as well as the original location of Lou’s Records in Ocean Beach, where a lot of the self-published 7-inch singles and 12-inch LP’s of the early San Diego punk bands were sold.
They were also sold at Off the Record in its second location in Hillcrest — it started in the College area and I bought a lot of the early classics of British punk, including Elvis Costello and the Clash, there or at Blue Meannie Records in El Cajon; then it moved to Hillcrest and that’s where it was during the heyday of San Diego’s punk movement, hosting in-store gigs by out-of-town bands that later became major names (including one you might have heard of, called Nirvana — and apparently as many San Diego punk, new-wave and “alternative” rock fans claim to have been at Nirvana’s in-store gig at Off the Record as Gay New Yorkers around in 1969 claim to have been at the Stonewall Inn that night). San Diego generated quite a few bands with seeming potential for major stardom, including Rocket from the Crypt, Drive Like Jehu, Three Mile Pilot (whose clip is one of the most interesting parts of the film, musically; instead of yet another relentlessly fast and loud punk song, theirs is a medium-tempo mood piece featuring not only a sax but bagpipes — in their use of a large ensemble and unusual instruments for rock, they seem like Arcade Fire two decades early) and Inch (with whom I have a personal connection in that they were the feature of the culture section of the first issue of Zenger’s Newsmagazine in April 1994; my then-boyfriend John Gallagher and I caught their in-store show at Off the Record in 1994, promoting their album on the short-lived Atlantic subsidiary Seed Records, and we interviewed them; Inch’s leader, Stimy, who died just two years or so ago, said he was glad to be on Seed because it gave him both the creative independence and easy access to the people in charge of an indie label and the marketing clout of a major — only it ended badly when the “suits” at Atlantic decided his second album for them wasn’t commercial enough and refused to release it; Perrine recalls Stimy telling him, “They wanted us to write a Weezer song!”). I remember telling people at the time, “I hope Inch becomes the next Pearl Jam and we can take at least a tiny amount of credit for helping make that happen.” One of the most interesting bands featured in the film is Trumans Water, founded by two blond brothers (among the sexiest guys in the movie even now!), who added two other musicians and did a major stage show. The film basically follows a three-act structure, though I doubt Perrine thought of it that way (he’s credited as writer but that probably merely means he shaped the overall structure and was the interviewer): Act I is the early, relatively innocent days, in which San Diego’s punk scene was underground and all they had to worry about were the skinheads and (curiously unmentioned in this film) the cops.
Since I was a bit too old for the club scene when I got to San Diego and I’ve never been a big fan of rock clubs anyway (the music is too overpoweringly loud and generally badly mixed so often the only evidence that the song has a vocal is someone is standing in front of the band moving their lips and giving every evidence of singing), I went to almost none of the shows, but I did pick up a few of the records when they trickled out, including a bizarre picture disc of Three Mile Pilot in a sculptured shape that probably threw a lot of people trying to figure out where to drop the needle of their turntables (it’s likely this record did in more than a few styli) which I remember buying at the time (it would be in storage now) but which I don’t remember being as good as their song in the film. I didn’t hear anything that special, and sometimes (as with the record by Locust, which I picked up largely because it was a picture disc and was printed on 5” vinyl) I ran into a particular pet peeve of mine: the singer who screws up his (it always seems to be a him, not a her, that does this) voice into an undifferentiated whine indiscernible as English or any other human language. I remember the Locust disc came with what was alleged to be a lyric sheet, but I defy anybody other than the singer who actually recorded it to discern any connection between the lyrics on the sheet and the vocal sounds on the record. What I do remember in the 1980’s was a constant battle between the punks and the police; one reason a lot of the shows were secret and promoted the ways raves are now was that the cops were always shutting down the venues, including pulling the licenses of the promoters who dared put on this music. I was surprised Perrine didn’t go into the generally hostile attitude of San Diego’s city government, and its police department in particular, towards the punk scene — that was a lot of the reason it developed in such an insular fashion, with so many of the band members knowing each other (Perrine used the word “incestuous” in his post-film commentary) and many musicians being in more than one band. Indeed, he said he’d been trying to get hold of someone who did a genealogy of the San Diego bands and posted it on line, but whose Web site is now defunct — probably it would look something like one of those charts that purported to show the genealogy of the Left and which groups splintered off which.
Act II is the period right after the surprise success of Nirvana returned punk — now called with the bizarre euphemism “alternative” (which of course just begged the question, “‘Alternative’ to what?”) — to the top of the charts, or nearly so, and Nirvana’s Nevermind (their first major-label album) and Pearl Jam’s Ten (their first album, period) sold so explosively that not only did the record companies decide Seattle was the new rock ’n’ roll Mecca, they started looking for the “next Seattle” and briefly thought they’d found it in San Diego. The two biggest bands in town, Rocket from the Crypt and Drive Like Jehu, both signed with Jimmy Iovine’s Interscope Records and were launched with a fair amount of fanfare — but when their major-label debuts didn’t score with the overwhelming sales of Nevermind and Ten the major labels packed up their vans and headed back to L.A. Atlantic bagged a band called Stone Temple Pilots which had played a few gigs in San Diego and might have lived here a short time (accounts differ) but whom the real San Diego scenesters saw as an L.A. band that had just latched on to the San Diego hype, and when a San Diego band finally did break through to mega-stardom (or at least major-label success) it was Blink-182. MCA Records (now Universal Music) wanted them so badly they were willing to buy Cargo Records, the San Diego-based indie that had released many of the local bands’ recordings (the ones that the bands weren’t producing and marketing themselves in the classic D.I.Y. punk tradition — which was actually invented by the 1950’s jazz musician and bandleader Sun Ra, the first leader to abandon the hunt for a record contract and instead record his own albums, have them pressed and sell them at his concerts) just to get Blink’s contract.
The visceral scorn with which the scenesters Perrine interviewed talk about Blink-182, not only disliking their pop-punk music but anguishing with jealousy over the eternal question, “Why them?,” has to be seen to be believed — but then there were probably some edgy bands in Liverpool in the early 1960’s who saw the Beatles become superstars and similarly wondered, “Why them?” I’d have liked It’s Gonna Blow! to feature more coverage of the city of San Diego’s hostile attitude towards the punk scene (it was not only fear of the skinheads, but fear of the police as well, that accounted for the underground nature of the scene and in particular for some of the punk shows being planned and pulled off in rave-like secrecy), and I’d also have liked to hear more from the women involved. A couple of the bands featured in video clips had women members front and center, not just singing but playing instruments as well, but the list of Perrine’s interviewees was exclusively male. (This seems particularly strange at a time when the most vital members of the international music scene — both the mega-sellers like Taylor Swift and Adele and the creative forces like Tori Amos, Neko Case and Lorde — are women.) Perrine scores points with me for picking appropriately grungy locations, including the front of an outdoor men’s restroom, for his interviews. Overall, It’s Gonna Blow! is a quite good documentary on an interesting local music scene, and one which will hold your interest even if you’re not from San Diego and have never heard of any of these bands before — though it’s sad, in a way, because I had the feeling you could probably make a similar film about just about any major city’s youth music scene and feature a lot of bands who play music as good or better than anything on the charts and will likely never be heard beyond a few friends and cultists at local clubs.
The film the San Diego Public Library showed January 11 was It’s Gonna Blow!!! San Diego’s Music Underground, 1986-1996, about the burgeoning punk-rock scene in San Diego in the 1980’s and early 1990’s and how after the success of Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Soundgarden and the other big Seattle bands in the early 1990’s San Diego attracted industry attention and “buzz” as “the next Seattle.” The film’s director was Bill Perrine, who was present for the screening at the San Diego Public Library and did a Q&A after the movie — he was also by far the cutest guy in his entourage, which included some of the musicians and others he’d interviewed for the film. What’s most amazing was how much of the scene in the early days was not only recorded but filmed — even though the videos of the period had to be shot on bulky camcorders and recorded to Beta or VHS tape (Perrine talked about one clip that was on a badly disintegrated VHS tape — and even that wasn’t the original; the original had been Beta and had been copied — and he was able finally to have it digitized and present the person who lent it to him with a professionally burned and mastered DVD of his recording) — including the actual footage of one notorious punk concert featuring a band called the Vandals. The Vandals met a fate incredibly ironic, given their name (both its original meaning and its common one now); theirs was one of many punk shows invaded by skinheads, who not only beat up the band members but stole their equipment, while the rest of the audience was too scared to do anything to stop it — and of course, this being a punk show, there was no security.
The constant threat of skinhead invasions meant that San Diego punk shows in the 1980’s became clandestine affairs, held in people’s backyards (Perrine remembered one particularly sympathetic mother of one of the band members, who had a home in Tierrasanta and let not only her son’s band but those of his friends play there and give outdoor parties), back rooms of clubs or wherever they could find. The shows were advertised in the pre-Internet, pre-social media age by word of mouth and a secret network of phone calls (much the way Pat Brown recalls recruiting people to join the Gay-rights picketers at the States Steamship Lines in San Francisco in 1969 several months before Stonewall) to let people know that a band they might be interested in would be playing … somewhere. Eventually a few locations coalesced that would routinely feature the music, including the Casbah (whose owner and promoter, Tim Maze — though imdb.com spells his last name “Mays,” it’s “Maze” that appears on the reproductions of posters for his shows in the film — was probably the most important person outside of the actual musicians in building the San Diego punk scene), the Ché Café on the UCSD campus (now threatened with demolition by UCSD’s administration) and the Adams Avenue Theatre (which is now, sadly, a fabric store — public venues in San Diego’s inner city having a huge problem succeeding: the lack of convenient parking space) as well as the original location of Lou’s Records in Ocean Beach, where a lot of the self-published 7-inch singles and 12-inch LP’s of the early San Diego punk bands were sold.
They were also sold at Off the Record in its second location in Hillcrest — it started in the College area and I bought a lot of the early classics of British punk, including Elvis Costello and the Clash, there or at Blue Meannie Records in El Cajon; then it moved to Hillcrest and that’s where it was during the heyday of San Diego’s punk movement, hosting in-store gigs by out-of-town bands that later became major names (including one you might have heard of, called Nirvana — and apparently as many San Diego punk, new-wave and “alternative” rock fans claim to have been at Nirvana’s in-store gig at Off the Record as Gay New Yorkers around in 1969 claim to have been at the Stonewall Inn that night). San Diego generated quite a few bands with seeming potential for major stardom, including Rocket from the Crypt, Drive Like Jehu, Three Mile Pilot (whose clip is one of the most interesting parts of the film, musically; instead of yet another relentlessly fast and loud punk song, theirs is a medium-tempo mood piece featuring not only a sax but bagpipes — in their use of a large ensemble and unusual instruments for rock, they seem like Arcade Fire two decades early) and Inch (with whom I have a personal connection in that they were the feature of the culture section of the first issue of Zenger’s Newsmagazine in April 1994; my then-boyfriend John Gallagher and I caught their in-store show at Off the Record in 1994, promoting their album on the short-lived Atlantic subsidiary Seed Records, and we interviewed them; Inch’s leader, Stimy, who died just two years or so ago, said he was glad to be on Seed because it gave him both the creative independence and easy access to the people in charge of an indie label and the marketing clout of a major — only it ended badly when the “suits” at Atlantic decided his second album for them wasn’t commercial enough and refused to release it; Perrine recalls Stimy telling him, “They wanted us to write a Weezer song!”). I remember telling people at the time, “I hope Inch becomes the next Pearl Jam and we can take at least a tiny amount of credit for helping make that happen.” One of the most interesting bands featured in the film is Trumans Water, founded by two blond brothers (among the sexiest guys in the movie even now!), who added two other musicians and did a major stage show. The film basically follows a three-act structure, though I doubt Perrine thought of it that way (he’s credited as writer but that probably merely means he shaped the overall structure and was the interviewer): Act I is the early, relatively innocent days, in which San Diego’s punk scene was underground and all they had to worry about were the skinheads and (curiously unmentioned in this film) the cops.
Since I was a bit too old for the club scene when I got to San Diego and I’ve never been a big fan of rock clubs anyway (the music is too overpoweringly loud and generally badly mixed so often the only evidence that the song has a vocal is someone is standing in front of the band moving their lips and giving every evidence of singing), I went to almost none of the shows, but I did pick up a few of the records when they trickled out, including a bizarre picture disc of Three Mile Pilot in a sculptured shape that probably threw a lot of people trying to figure out where to drop the needle of their turntables (it’s likely this record did in more than a few styli) which I remember buying at the time (it would be in storage now) but which I don’t remember being as good as their song in the film. I didn’t hear anything that special, and sometimes (as with the record by Locust, which I picked up largely because it was a picture disc and was printed on 5” vinyl) I ran into a particular pet peeve of mine: the singer who screws up his (it always seems to be a him, not a her, that does this) voice into an undifferentiated whine indiscernible as English or any other human language. I remember the Locust disc came with what was alleged to be a lyric sheet, but I defy anybody other than the singer who actually recorded it to discern any connection between the lyrics on the sheet and the vocal sounds on the record. What I do remember in the 1980’s was a constant battle between the punks and the police; one reason a lot of the shows were secret and promoted the ways raves are now was that the cops were always shutting down the venues, including pulling the licenses of the promoters who dared put on this music. I was surprised Perrine didn’t go into the generally hostile attitude of San Diego’s city government, and its police department in particular, towards the punk scene — that was a lot of the reason it developed in such an insular fashion, with so many of the band members knowing each other (Perrine used the word “incestuous” in his post-film commentary) and many musicians being in more than one band. Indeed, he said he’d been trying to get hold of someone who did a genealogy of the San Diego bands and posted it on line, but whose Web site is now defunct — probably it would look something like one of those charts that purported to show the genealogy of the Left and which groups splintered off which.
Act II is the period right after the surprise success of Nirvana returned punk — now called with the bizarre euphemism “alternative” (which of course just begged the question, “‘Alternative’ to what?”) — to the top of the charts, or nearly so, and Nirvana’s Nevermind (their first major-label album) and Pearl Jam’s Ten (their first album, period) sold so explosively that not only did the record companies decide Seattle was the new rock ’n’ roll Mecca, they started looking for the “next Seattle” and briefly thought they’d found it in San Diego. The two biggest bands in town, Rocket from the Crypt and Drive Like Jehu, both signed with Jimmy Iovine’s Interscope Records and were launched with a fair amount of fanfare — but when their major-label debuts didn’t score with the overwhelming sales of Nevermind and Ten the major labels packed up their vans and headed back to L.A. Atlantic bagged a band called Stone Temple Pilots which had played a few gigs in San Diego and might have lived here a short time (accounts differ) but whom the real San Diego scenesters saw as an L.A. band that had just latched on to the San Diego hype, and when a San Diego band finally did break through to mega-stardom (or at least major-label success) it was Blink-182. MCA Records (now Universal Music) wanted them so badly they were willing to buy Cargo Records, the San Diego-based indie that had released many of the local bands’ recordings (the ones that the bands weren’t producing and marketing themselves in the classic D.I.Y. punk tradition — which was actually invented by the 1950’s jazz musician and bandleader Sun Ra, the first leader to abandon the hunt for a record contract and instead record his own albums, have them pressed and sell them at his concerts) just to get Blink’s contract.
The visceral scorn with which the scenesters Perrine interviewed talk about Blink-182, not only disliking their pop-punk music but anguishing with jealousy over the eternal question, “Why them?,” has to be seen to be believed — but then there were probably some edgy bands in Liverpool in the early 1960’s who saw the Beatles become superstars and similarly wondered, “Why them?” I’d have liked It’s Gonna Blow! to feature more coverage of the city of San Diego’s hostile attitude towards the punk scene (it was not only fear of the skinheads, but fear of the police as well, that accounted for the underground nature of the scene and in particular for some of the punk shows being planned and pulled off in rave-like secrecy), and I’d also have liked to hear more from the women involved. A couple of the bands featured in video clips had women members front and center, not just singing but playing instruments as well, but the list of Perrine’s interviewees was exclusively male. (This seems particularly strange at a time when the most vital members of the international music scene — both the mega-sellers like Taylor Swift and Adele and the creative forces like Tori Amos, Neko Case and Lorde — are women.) Perrine scores points with me for picking appropriately grungy locations, including the front of an outdoor men’s restroom, for his interviews. Overall, It’s Gonna Blow! is a quite good documentary on an interesting local music scene, and one which will hold your interest even if you’re not from San Diego and have never heard of any of these bands before — though it’s sad, in a way, because I had the feeling you could probably make a similar film about just about any major city’s youth music scene and feature a lot of bands who play music as good or better than anything on the charts and will likely never be heard beyond a few friends and cultists at local clubs.
Night After Night (Paramount, 1932)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night’s film was Night After Night, a 1932 Paramount production that was a weird combination of gangster movie and soap opera that would probably be totally forgotten if it didn’t contain the screen debut of Mae West. Paramount signed her for a supporting role — she’s billed fourth, after George Raft, Constance Cummings and the virtually forgotten but quite impressive Wynne Gibson, and just ahead of the marvelous comedienne Alison Skipworth — and she doesn’t appear until the 37th minute of this 76-minute film, but as George Raft rather disgustedly put it later, “She stole everything but the cameras.” I’d seen Night After Night only once before, on the old Channel 36 in San José which by some freak of the UHF signals back when virtually everyone still watched TV over-the-air instead of on cable came in beautifully and clearly in Marin County just north of San Francisco and gave me my first glimpse of quite a few great old movies. For a while they were doing a weekly comedy showing that basically alternated between the Paramount films of the Marx Brothers, W. C. Fields and Mae West, and one night for some reason they showed this film in that time slot because West was in it.
The film — directed with more moxie than usual by Archie Mayo from a script by Kathryn Scola, with additional dialogue by Joseph L. Mankiewicz, Vincent Lawrence and Mae West (who, blessed be, was allowed to write the scenes in which she appears), all derived from a story called “Single Night” by the sporadically interesting writer Louis Bromfield — opens with a clever montage sequence showing first the construction of a house at number 55 in New York City. We’re never told what street number 55 is the address of, but it’s clearly a house that’s built as a mansion in an upper-class neighborhood and thereafter is turned over under less and less ritzy terms as the neighborhood goes downhill. When it reaches the 1932 present it’s been bought at auction by ex-prizefighter Joe Anton (George Raft) — whose last name is pronounced “Antone,” by the way — who’s turned it into a speakeasy that’s become a huge success. Anton has also racked up an impressive number of female conquests, including edgy mistress Iris Dawn (Wynne Gibson) — Charles joked at the phoniness of that name and I, reflecting on blues legend Howlin’ Wolf’s real name, said, “Her real name was Mabel Kling Harding Burnett” — good-time girl Maudie Triplett (a really awkward name for a Mae West character!) and the one he’s currently after, classy woman Jerry Healy (Constance Cummings). Jerry comes to number 55 (like the later Studio 54, it’s been named after its address) and spends her evenings drinking alone because — as we learn about one-third of the way through the film — her family used to own the house and she was born and raised there before they lost all their money and had to sell it.
Our Joe is becoming disgusted with himself and his success; when we first see him (with tousled hair instead of Raft’s usual greasy pomade, and showing off quite a lot of upper-body male flesh — and even a tuft of chest hair — unusual for an early-1930’s movie) he’s in bed reading a story about Albert Einstein having given an interview in which he says it’s both personally and socially destructive to have too much money. Like Edward G. Robinson in the next year’s The Little Giant — also about a gangster who’s disgusted with his lifestyle and is looking to develop better manners and classier English so he can crash society — Joe has hired a teacher, Mabel Jellyman (Alison Skipworth), to improve his English and make his overall affect more suitable for “society.” A further complication Joe has to deal with is a rival gang, headed by Frankie Guard (Bradley Page), who resent Joe’s success because it’s cutting into the profits of their own illegal boîtes. In classic gangster-movie fashion Guard and his men first attempt to buy Joe out, offering him $50,000 for the place — Joe counteroffers to sell it for $250,000 — and in the meantime Joe tries to romance Jerry, including virtually raping her when she resists too much (and in the bizarre misogyny of many films in this genre, his vicious sexual assault on her is what finally makes her decide she loves him!), deals with her rich suitor Dick Bolton (Louis Calhern), and ultimately sells the place for $200,000 after a gang of Guard’s thugs comes in and starts wrecking the place — which we don’t see; we merely hear what’s going on while Joe and Jerry are enacting their rape-into-romance drama in one of the house’s upstairs rooms. Joe and Jerry end up together, though heaven knows where doing heaven knows what, and the final shot is of the building at number 55, now with a neon sign in front announcing Guard’s ownership, and instead of the usual criss-crossing searchlights Paramount generally used for their end credits in the 1930’s and 1940’s the final credits come up in front of a shot of the house.
Critics and audiences in 1932 basically thought Mae West’s electrifying and audacious appearance was the best thing in the film. Unexpectedly, instead of setting her sights on one of the males in the movie, she puts the moves on (of all people) Alison Skipworth, including sleeping in the same bed with her and ending up arm-in-arm at the end, a pretty audacious Lesbian implication even by the loose standards of the so-called “pre-Code” era in which West did her best work. It’s when Skipworth’s character asks her if she believes in love at first sight that West replies with her second-most-famous line from this film: “Well, it sure saves a lot of time!” Though the original trailer (included as a bonus item on the DVD) focused almost exclusively on George Raft as the star attraction (it did include West’s famous early line; when she shows up at number 55 and the hat-check girl marvels at her jewels — “Goodness, what beautiful diamonds” — West snaps back, “Goodness had nothing to do with it, honey”: the diamonds were real, not glass or paste imitations, and they were West’s own property, not something from the Paramount costume or props departments), West’s scenes were so electrifying Paramount signed her to a star contract and gave her virtually everything she wanted. She sold them the rights to her stage hit Diamond Lil as her next film (though they retitled it She Done Him Wrong), she demanded the right not only to write the scripts for all her films but to be credited as writer in type 75 percent the size of her credit as star, and she got to pick her own leading man (she picked Cary Grant). Night After Night takes off and flies when Mae West is on the screen, but even when she isn’t it’s an oddly compelling melodrama, creaky at times but still a lot of fun and a much better film overall than its reputation.
Last night’s film was Night After Night, a 1932 Paramount production that was a weird combination of gangster movie and soap opera that would probably be totally forgotten if it didn’t contain the screen debut of Mae West. Paramount signed her for a supporting role — she’s billed fourth, after George Raft, Constance Cummings and the virtually forgotten but quite impressive Wynne Gibson, and just ahead of the marvelous comedienne Alison Skipworth — and she doesn’t appear until the 37th minute of this 76-minute film, but as George Raft rather disgustedly put it later, “She stole everything but the cameras.” I’d seen Night After Night only once before, on the old Channel 36 in San José which by some freak of the UHF signals back when virtually everyone still watched TV over-the-air instead of on cable came in beautifully and clearly in Marin County just north of San Francisco and gave me my first glimpse of quite a few great old movies. For a while they were doing a weekly comedy showing that basically alternated between the Paramount films of the Marx Brothers, W. C. Fields and Mae West, and one night for some reason they showed this film in that time slot because West was in it.
The film — directed with more moxie than usual by Archie Mayo from a script by Kathryn Scola, with additional dialogue by Joseph L. Mankiewicz, Vincent Lawrence and Mae West (who, blessed be, was allowed to write the scenes in which she appears), all derived from a story called “Single Night” by the sporadically interesting writer Louis Bromfield — opens with a clever montage sequence showing first the construction of a house at number 55 in New York City. We’re never told what street number 55 is the address of, but it’s clearly a house that’s built as a mansion in an upper-class neighborhood and thereafter is turned over under less and less ritzy terms as the neighborhood goes downhill. When it reaches the 1932 present it’s been bought at auction by ex-prizefighter Joe Anton (George Raft) — whose last name is pronounced “Antone,” by the way — who’s turned it into a speakeasy that’s become a huge success. Anton has also racked up an impressive number of female conquests, including edgy mistress Iris Dawn (Wynne Gibson) — Charles joked at the phoniness of that name and I, reflecting on blues legend Howlin’ Wolf’s real name, said, “Her real name was Mabel Kling Harding Burnett” — good-time girl Maudie Triplett (a really awkward name for a Mae West character!) and the one he’s currently after, classy woman Jerry Healy (Constance Cummings). Jerry comes to number 55 (like the later Studio 54, it’s been named after its address) and spends her evenings drinking alone because — as we learn about one-third of the way through the film — her family used to own the house and she was born and raised there before they lost all their money and had to sell it.
Our Joe is becoming disgusted with himself and his success; when we first see him (with tousled hair instead of Raft’s usual greasy pomade, and showing off quite a lot of upper-body male flesh — and even a tuft of chest hair — unusual for an early-1930’s movie) he’s in bed reading a story about Albert Einstein having given an interview in which he says it’s both personally and socially destructive to have too much money. Like Edward G. Robinson in the next year’s The Little Giant — also about a gangster who’s disgusted with his lifestyle and is looking to develop better manners and classier English so he can crash society — Joe has hired a teacher, Mabel Jellyman (Alison Skipworth), to improve his English and make his overall affect more suitable for “society.” A further complication Joe has to deal with is a rival gang, headed by Frankie Guard (Bradley Page), who resent Joe’s success because it’s cutting into the profits of their own illegal boîtes. In classic gangster-movie fashion Guard and his men first attempt to buy Joe out, offering him $50,000 for the place — Joe counteroffers to sell it for $250,000 — and in the meantime Joe tries to romance Jerry, including virtually raping her when she resists too much (and in the bizarre misogyny of many films in this genre, his vicious sexual assault on her is what finally makes her decide she loves him!), deals with her rich suitor Dick Bolton (Louis Calhern), and ultimately sells the place for $200,000 after a gang of Guard’s thugs comes in and starts wrecking the place — which we don’t see; we merely hear what’s going on while Joe and Jerry are enacting their rape-into-romance drama in one of the house’s upstairs rooms. Joe and Jerry end up together, though heaven knows where doing heaven knows what, and the final shot is of the building at number 55, now with a neon sign in front announcing Guard’s ownership, and instead of the usual criss-crossing searchlights Paramount generally used for their end credits in the 1930’s and 1940’s the final credits come up in front of a shot of the house.
Critics and audiences in 1932 basically thought Mae West’s electrifying and audacious appearance was the best thing in the film. Unexpectedly, instead of setting her sights on one of the males in the movie, she puts the moves on (of all people) Alison Skipworth, including sleeping in the same bed with her and ending up arm-in-arm at the end, a pretty audacious Lesbian implication even by the loose standards of the so-called “pre-Code” era in which West did her best work. It’s when Skipworth’s character asks her if she believes in love at first sight that West replies with her second-most-famous line from this film: “Well, it sure saves a lot of time!” Though the original trailer (included as a bonus item on the DVD) focused almost exclusively on George Raft as the star attraction (it did include West’s famous early line; when she shows up at number 55 and the hat-check girl marvels at her jewels — “Goodness, what beautiful diamonds” — West snaps back, “Goodness had nothing to do with it, honey”: the diamonds were real, not glass or paste imitations, and they were West’s own property, not something from the Paramount costume or props departments), West’s scenes were so electrifying Paramount signed her to a star contract and gave her virtually everything she wanted. She sold them the rights to her stage hit Diamond Lil as her next film (though they retitled it She Done Him Wrong), she demanded the right not only to write the scripts for all her films but to be credited as writer in type 75 percent the size of her credit as star, and she got to pick her own leading man (she picked Cary Grant). Night After Night takes off and flies when Mae West is on the screen, but even when she isn’t it’s an oddly compelling melodrama, creaky at times but still a lot of fun and a much better film overall than its reputation.
Sunday, January 10, 2016
The Sky’s the Limit (RKO, 1943)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
When I got home TCM was running one of Fred Astaire’s more obscure movies, The Sky’s the Limit, a 1943 musical made at RKO (Astaire’s last film for the studio that had made him and Ginger Rogers stars in the films they made there together) in which his co-star was Joan Leslie, borrowed from Warner Bros. and fresh from her triumph in Yankee Doodle Dandy with James Cagney, while Astaire was fresh from his two films at Columbia, You’ll Never Get Rich and You Were Never Lovelier, opposite Rita Hayworth. I watched about half of it — Charles came home while it was on, didn’t recognize it and asked if we’d ever watched it together (I’m sure we had, but I don’t have a listing for it on the computer), and I got to see Astaire do a dance with Joan Leslie that’s surprisingly close in look, feel and actual steps to the great numbers with Rogers (in his outro to the film Robert Osborne said that a recent book on Astaire had said that of all his subsequent partners Leslie danced the most like Rogers) as well as the most incredible number from the film, “One for My Baby.” Like “Night and Day” and “Change Partners,” this is a song that today is primarily identified with Frank Sinatra but was actually written for Astaire — and the song’s mood as presented here couldn’t be more different from the sad, self-pitying way Sinatra sang it. (Reviewing the Johnny Mercer documentary The Dream’s on Me — Mercer not only wrote the lyrics to “One for My Baby,” with Harold Arlen supplying the music, he made a surprisingly assertive straight-up record of it for his own label, Capitol — I wrote, “[W]here Astaire made it angry and Sinatra made it sad, Mercer’s made it rather lighthearted — Astaire’s protagonist literally trashed the bar, Sinatra’s was probably going to fall asleep in his cups, while Mercer’s was going to go home, sleep it off and wake bright and refreshed the following day.”)
Astaire’s “One for My Baby” is one of the great solo numbers of his career; in the overall film he plays a pilot with the famed Flying Tigers who’s been given a week’s leave in New York City with his two buddies from the squadron (one of whom is played by the young Robert Ryan, who puts a lot more intensity and viciousness into what was supposed to be an ordinary comic villain than writers S. K. Lauren, William T. Ryder, Frank Fenton and Lynn Root intended), ducks out on a big publicity tour and tries to live incognito and use his disguise as an ambition-less drifter to win the heart of magazine photographer Joan Manion (Joan Leslie) — incidentally Astaire is also playing a character with the same first name as his own: he’s Fred Atwell but calls himself “Fred Burton” as part of his incognito. Frustrated at all the roadblocks that have been thrown up in the way of his affair with Joan — from the ragging of his two Army Air Corps buds to Joan’s insistence that he get a job either with her boss, Phil Harriman (Robert Benchley in his second film with Astaire, after You’ll Never Get Rich), a character obviously based on Time and Life publisher Henry Luce, or with Sloan (Clarence Kolb), an airplane company CEO whom Fred pisses off by telling him in detail exactly what’s wrong with his planes and how difficult they are to fly in combat — he ends up in the bar of the fancy hotel where he and Joan met. Of course, it’s quarter to three and there’s no one in the place except Fred and a bartender who is almost inevitably named Joe, and as he sings the song Fred gets angrier and angrier until he literally trashes the bar, breaking glasses right and left and climaxing by throwing a barstool through the bar’s heavy glass mirror, shattering it. (Some comments on imdb.com’s trivia page for this film indicate that Astaire cut his shins and ankles on all the broken glass, and that RKO got letters attacking them for breaking so much glass in the movie when ordinary Americans were being urged to turn glass in to be melted down and reused for the war effort — though I suspect much of the “glass” in that sequence was actually spun sugar, Hollywood’s usual substitute for glass when they were doing a sequence in which glass got broken, accidentally or intentionally.) It’s a stunning number and the song buzzes with anger during Astaire’s bar-trashing dance — in which, as he did in the “Say It with Firecrackers” number in Holiday Inn, he manages to suggest drunkenness while still maintaining absolute control over his body — whereas years of hearing Sinatra sing it have conditioned to regard it as sad.
One alternative book on the Academy Awards (meaning in this case “alternative” to Robert Osborne’s Academy-sanctioned official history) criticized the Academy for not nominating “One for My Baby” for Best Song, but in those days the Best Song nominations were in the hands of the studios, not the Academy. Each studio picked a song from one of their movies and put it up for Best Song, and the nominations process just whittled down this list to five before the full Academy voted one of the five as the winner — and in 1944 RKO decided “My Shining Hour” (a great song, both as played here by Freddie Slack and His Orchestra with Astaire singing and he and Joan dancing to it, and as later covered by John Coltrane on the Coltrane Jazz album on Atlantic) would be their choice for this film and “One for My Baby” would not. “One for My Baby” is the highlight of an inconsistent but often marvelous movie (let’s face it, anything with Fred Astaire — even his all-time weakest musical, Second Chorus — is worth watching) that also includes “My Shining Hour,” “A Lot in Common” (a duet for Astaire and Leslie — actually, in Leslie’s case, her voice double, Sally Sweetland — that includes Astaire asking Leslie, “Where’s Cagney?,” and her replying, “Where’s Hayworth?”) and a weird snake dance on a table Ryan dares Astaire to do, threatening to “out” him if he doesn’t. There’s also a nice in-joke in which, trying to get close to Joan by getting in one of her photos, Astaire plaintively asks, “Couldn’t I be the fellow who never gets his name mentioned? The one they call ‘a friend’? You know: ‘Ginger Rogers — and friend.’” I’d always thought the “Ginger Rogers did everything Fred Astaire did, only backwards and in high heels” jokes were relatively recent, or at least post the second-wave feminist movement in the early 1970’s, but here’s a variant of them spoken by Astaire himself; as Arlene Croce noted in The Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers Book, Astaire and Rogers got along personally but were both ferociously ambitious about their careers, and each wanted to show that they could get along and have hit films without the other!
When I got home TCM was running one of Fred Astaire’s more obscure movies, The Sky’s the Limit, a 1943 musical made at RKO (Astaire’s last film for the studio that had made him and Ginger Rogers stars in the films they made there together) in which his co-star was Joan Leslie, borrowed from Warner Bros. and fresh from her triumph in Yankee Doodle Dandy with James Cagney, while Astaire was fresh from his two films at Columbia, You’ll Never Get Rich and You Were Never Lovelier, opposite Rita Hayworth. I watched about half of it — Charles came home while it was on, didn’t recognize it and asked if we’d ever watched it together (I’m sure we had, but I don’t have a listing for it on the computer), and I got to see Astaire do a dance with Joan Leslie that’s surprisingly close in look, feel and actual steps to the great numbers with Rogers (in his outro to the film Robert Osborne said that a recent book on Astaire had said that of all his subsequent partners Leslie danced the most like Rogers) as well as the most incredible number from the film, “One for My Baby.” Like “Night and Day” and “Change Partners,” this is a song that today is primarily identified with Frank Sinatra but was actually written for Astaire — and the song’s mood as presented here couldn’t be more different from the sad, self-pitying way Sinatra sang it. (Reviewing the Johnny Mercer documentary The Dream’s on Me — Mercer not only wrote the lyrics to “One for My Baby,” with Harold Arlen supplying the music, he made a surprisingly assertive straight-up record of it for his own label, Capitol — I wrote, “[W]here Astaire made it angry and Sinatra made it sad, Mercer’s made it rather lighthearted — Astaire’s protagonist literally trashed the bar, Sinatra’s was probably going to fall asleep in his cups, while Mercer’s was going to go home, sleep it off and wake bright and refreshed the following day.”)
Astaire’s “One for My Baby” is one of the great solo numbers of his career; in the overall film he plays a pilot with the famed Flying Tigers who’s been given a week’s leave in New York City with his two buddies from the squadron (one of whom is played by the young Robert Ryan, who puts a lot more intensity and viciousness into what was supposed to be an ordinary comic villain than writers S. K. Lauren, William T. Ryder, Frank Fenton and Lynn Root intended), ducks out on a big publicity tour and tries to live incognito and use his disguise as an ambition-less drifter to win the heart of magazine photographer Joan Manion (Joan Leslie) — incidentally Astaire is also playing a character with the same first name as his own: he’s Fred Atwell but calls himself “Fred Burton” as part of his incognito. Frustrated at all the roadblocks that have been thrown up in the way of his affair with Joan — from the ragging of his two Army Air Corps buds to Joan’s insistence that he get a job either with her boss, Phil Harriman (Robert Benchley in his second film with Astaire, after You’ll Never Get Rich), a character obviously based on Time and Life publisher Henry Luce, or with Sloan (Clarence Kolb), an airplane company CEO whom Fred pisses off by telling him in detail exactly what’s wrong with his planes and how difficult they are to fly in combat — he ends up in the bar of the fancy hotel where he and Joan met. Of course, it’s quarter to three and there’s no one in the place except Fred and a bartender who is almost inevitably named Joe, and as he sings the song Fred gets angrier and angrier until he literally trashes the bar, breaking glasses right and left and climaxing by throwing a barstool through the bar’s heavy glass mirror, shattering it. (Some comments on imdb.com’s trivia page for this film indicate that Astaire cut his shins and ankles on all the broken glass, and that RKO got letters attacking them for breaking so much glass in the movie when ordinary Americans were being urged to turn glass in to be melted down and reused for the war effort — though I suspect much of the “glass” in that sequence was actually spun sugar, Hollywood’s usual substitute for glass when they were doing a sequence in which glass got broken, accidentally or intentionally.) It’s a stunning number and the song buzzes with anger during Astaire’s bar-trashing dance — in which, as he did in the “Say It with Firecrackers” number in Holiday Inn, he manages to suggest drunkenness while still maintaining absolute control over his body — whereas years of hearing Sinatra sing it have conditioned to regard it as sad.
One alternative book on the Academy Awards (meaning in this case “alternative” to Robert Osborne’s Academy-sanctioned official history) criticized the Academy for not nominating “One for My Baby” for Best Song, but in those days the Best Song nominations were in the hands of the studios, not the Academy. Each studio picked a song from one of their movies and put it up for Best Song, and the nominations process just whittled down this list to five before the full Academy voted one of the five as the winner — and in 1944 RKO decided “My Shining Hour” (a great song, both as played here by Freddie Slack and His Orchestra with Astaire singing and he and Joan dancing to it, and as later covered by John Coltrane on the Coltrane Jazz album on Atlantic) would be their choice for this film and “One for My Baby” would not. “One for My Baby” is the highlight of an inconsistent but often marvelous movie (let’s face it, anything with Fred Astaire — even his all-time weakest musical, Second Chorus — is worth watching) that also includes “My Shining Hour,” “A Lot in Common” (a duet for Astaire and Leslie — actually, in Leslie’s case, her voice double, Sally Sweetland — that includes Astaire asking Leslie, “Where’s Cagney?,” and her replying, “Where’s Hayworth?”) and a weird snake dance on a table Ryan dares Astaire to do, threatening to “out” him if he doesn’t. There’s also a nice in-joke in which, trying to get close to Joan by getting in one of her photos, Astaire plaintively asks, “Couldn’t I be the fellow who never gets his name mentioned? The one they call ‘a friend’? You know: ‘Ginger Rogers — and friend.’” I’d always thought the “Ginger Rogers did everything Fred Astaire did, only backwards and in high heels” jokes were relatively recent, or at least post the second-wave feminist movement in the early 1970’s, but here’s a variant of them spoken by Astaire himself; as Arlene Croce noted in The Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers Book, Astaire and Rogers got along personally but were both ferociously ambitious about their careers, and each wanted to show that they could get along and have hit films without the other!
Friday, January 8, 2016
Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials (Gotham Group, TSG Entertainment, Temple Hill Entertainment, 20th Century-Fox, 2015)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
The film was Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials, second in the Maze Runner series of which we’d watched the first the night before. It began life in 2009 when James Dashner published The Maze Runner as a novel, following it up with The Scorch Trials (2010), The Death Cure (2011) and The Kill Order (2012), which are currently being sold as a boxed set. Dasher’s Wikipedia page also lists a fifth book in the cycle, The Fever Code (2016), but says there have been “no official announcements.” (It also reveals he’s a graduate of Brigham Young University — as I recall, Stephenie Meyer, author of the Twilight cycle, is also a Mormon, and one wonders if apocalyptic visions of the future come with the Mormon territory? Then again, if one doesn’t believe in Mormonism, one would probably regard The Book of Mormon as a fantasy novel by Joseph Smith, Jr.) The Maze Runner won two book awards for young adult fiction (the ALA Best Fiction award in 2011 and the Young Readers’ Choice Award, intermediate grades, in 2012), but the cycle didn’t make it to film until 2014, after The Hunger Games and Divergent series had already established the popularity of dystopian sci-fi films based on young-adult fiction cycles. The central premise of The Maze Runner and its sequelae is that Earth has been hit by two catastrophes in rapid succession: first, the sun inexplicably heated up and baked the earth (“The Scorch”), making the surface mostly uninhabitable and forcing the social elites underground while millions of people died; and then a mysterious virus called “The Flare” started infecting the people who were left and basically either slowly and painfully killing them or turning them into creatures much like the zombies of George Romero’s Night of the Living Dead (1968) and its many sequelae, remakes and reboots. The Maze Runner told the story of Thomas (Dylan O’Brien), who like a number of other men in their late teens was sent up in a long, fast and nausea-inducing elevator (the first thing we saw him do in the opening of the Maze Runner movie was throw up) to a little community called The Glade which is surrounded by a huge concrete maze whose walls close at sunset and reopen the next morning but in a different configuration. A number of the boys become Maze Runners, whose job it is to look for a way through the maze and also avoid being stung by the Grievers, monsters who look like giant tarantulas with mechanical attachments — they appear to be part organic and part robotic — and who once again subject the people “stung” by them to long, painful deaths and make them homicidally crazy before they expire.
The film was Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials, second in the Maze Runner series of which we’d watched the first the night before. It began life in 2009 when James Dashner published The Maze Runner as a novel, following it up with The Scorch Trials (2010), The Death Cure (2011) and The Kill Order (2012), which are currently being sold as a boxed set. Dasher’s Wikipedia page also lists a fifth book in the cycle, The Fever Code (2016), but says there have been “no official announcements.” (It also reveals he’s a graduate of Brigham Young University — as I recall, Stephenie Meyer, author of the Twilight cycle, is also a Mormon, and one wonders if apocalyptic visions of the future come with the Mormon territory? Then again, if one doesn’t believe in Mormonism, one would probably regard The Book of Mormon as a fantasy novel by Joseph Smith, Jr.) The Maze Runner won two book awards for young adult fiction (the ALA Best Fiction award in 2011 and the Young Readers’ Choice Award, intermediate grades, in 2012), but the cycle didn’t make it to film until 2014, after The Hunger Games and Divergent series had already established the popularity of dystopian sci-fi films based on young-adult fiction cycles. The central premise of The Maze Runner and its sequelae is that Earth has been hit by two catastrophes in rapid succession: first, the sun inexplicably heated up and baked the earth (“The Scorch”), making the surface mostly uninhabitable and forcing the social elites underground while millions of people died; and then a mysterious virus called “The Flare” started infecting the people who were left and basically either slowly and painfully killing them or turning them into creatures much like the zombies of George Romero’s Night of the Living Dead (1968) and its many sequelae, remakes and reboots. The Maze Runner told the story of Thomas (Dylan O’Brien), who like a number of other men in their late teens was sent up in a long, fast and nausea-inducing elevator (the first thing we saw him do in the opening of the Maze Runner movie was throw up) to a little community called The Glade which is surrounded by a huge concrete maze whose walls close at sunset and reopen the next morning but in a different configuration. A number of the boys become Maze Runners, whose job it is to look for a way through the maze and also avoid being stung by the Grievers, monsters who look like giant tarantulas with mechanical attachments — they appear to be part organic and part robotic — and who once again subject the people “stung” by them to long, painful deaths and make them homicidally crazy before they expire.
At the end of The
Maze Runner Thomas and a group of his
friends from The Glade finally figure out the secret of the maze and get out of
it — and are greeted by a video image of Dr. Ava Paige (Patricia Clarkson), who
set up the whole experiment as a way of winnowing out the kids who were immune
to the Flare virus and also resourceful enough to solve problems. The
similarity to the Divergent
series — also a story about young people who, unbeknownst to them, are the
subjects of a sinister experiment in which their very environment and culture
are being manipulated by scientists with their own agendas — is obvious enough
I wonder if Divergent author
Veronica Roth was ripping off The Maze Runner, though there are enough antecedents for this idea
in fiction it may come from a common source (Roth acknowledged Orson Scott
Card’s Ender cycle as a source; both Card’s novel Ender’s Game and the film based on it are the story of a teenager
who thinks he’s playing war games to repel an extraterrestrial invader but
really is fighting the actual war). In yet another borrowing from a
science-fiction classic — William Nolan’s Logan’s Run and the 1970’s film based on it — it turns out that
the successful maze runners are not
being trained to repopulate the surface of Earth and figure out a way to
survive the Scorch. Instead, they’re being encased in giant womb-like glass
tubes and their life fluids are being sucked out of them because it turns out
the only treatment for the Flame virus anyone has discovered is an enzyme
extracted from the bodies of people already immune to it — only they can’t
synthesize the enzyme, so the only
way Flame victims can be treated is by sacrificing the people already immune,
rendering them unconscious and continually extracting the enzyme from their
bodies. (It’s also an intriguing variation on The Matrix cycle, in which the world was run by super-powerful
machines which fueled themselves by sucking out the life’s energy of living
people. In Logan’s Run the
gimmick was that the youths were allowed to live until age 30, when their bodies were harvested, not for energy or for
enzymes, but for spare parts for transplants to keep the aging 1-percenters who
ran things healthy and in power.)
From there The Scorch Trials turns into an elaborate chase scene drawing on all
the previous films mentioned above plus a strong admixture of Mad Max in the plot gimmick that a group of outlaws calling
themselves “The Right Hand” have hidden out in the desert and the mountains and
have evaded the efforts of WCKD (pronounced “Wicked,” standing for World
Catastrophe, Killzone Department), which is running the Maze experiment and, it
appears, virtually everything else, to round them up and/or kill them. One of the
leaders of the Right Hand, Vince, is played by Barry Pepper, who in 1988
starred in one of the very best recent sci-fi dystopian films, They
Live, which was essentially the Invasion
of the Body Snatchers gimmick applied to
Left-wing social and political comment (and a better movie than just about all
the ones I’ve cited above!). The intrepid refugees from the Maze also have to
deal with Cranks, which is what the Romeroesque zombies people turn into when
they’ve become infected by the Flare virus are called, and Brenda (Rosa
Salazar), daughter of a trader Thomas meets during his travels, seems on track
to becoming his girlfriend until she’s infected by the Flare and becomes a
Crank herself. But in the end Thomas and the rest of the refugees are betrayed
by the woman from part one, Teresa (Kaya Scodelario), who at the end of the
film turns them and the entire Right Hand into WCKD on the ground that she saw
her mother die of the Flare and believes it’s for the greater good that she and
the other Immunes get hooked up to machines and spend the rest of their lives
producing enzyme for the only known treatment. (The whole gimmick with the
Flare and an incredibly costly drug — both in money and the human lives that
have to be destroyed to produce it — couldn’t help but remind me of the
mainstream scientific and pharmaceutical-industry response to AIDS, which has
long since abandoned any talk of a “cure” and instead has aimed at making “HIV”
a so-called “chronic, manageable illness” whereby people stay relatively healthy
but only by ingesting incredibly toxic and expensive drugs for the rest of
their lives.)
It seems that, to paraphrase Anna Russell, we’re going to end up
right back where we started two hours ago — with the escapees from the Maze
once again in the hands of WCKD and about to be turned into enzyme farms — only
Thomas and a couple of others escape and he goes off in search of his friend
Minho (Ki Hong Lee), one of the Maze runners who was recaptured by WCKD, on a
Quixotic quest to rescue him personally. The Scorch Trials wasn’t quite as exciting as the first film in the
cycle, but it was still pretty much action porn, albeit action porn with more longueurs between the highlights, and only in the last
half-hour did it start to sound some of the emotional depths that were present
in Twilight, The Hunger
Games and (less so) Divergent from the get-go: Thomas, Brenda and Teresa emerge as
genuinely conflicted characters instead of the cardboard heroes and villains of
standard fantasy. Still, it’s the sort of movie that’s as much a chore as a joy
to sit through; there’s plenty of good stuff but, more so than in The
Maze Runner, you have to sit through quite
a lot of dull patches to get there. I also think The Scorch Trials has something of a second-act problem; in the
classic three-act construction of a stage play, Act I sets up the premise, Act
II complicates it and Act III resolves it — and in a number of multi-novel and
multi-film cycles the middle entry in the series has the second-act problem
writ large. It’s there in Tolkien’s The Two Towers, Anne McCaffrey’s Dragonquest, The Empire Strikes Back, New Moon,
Catching Fire and Insurgent, and I think it’s part of the problem with The
Scorch Trials as well; some of the plot
devices seem like logical extensions of the first film, while others seem to
have been put there to lead us into the rest of the story — and the
inconclusive ending of The Scorch Trials, in which we’re supposed to “read” Thomas as the indomitable
representative of the forces of good even though we’ve just seen the forces of
good decimated by the forces of evil, is typical of a second-story climax in
that it seems put there more to keep the series going than to provide an ending
in itself.
Thursday, January 7, 2016
The Maze Runner (Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation, Gotham Group, Temple Hill Entertainment, 2014)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Later last night Charles and I ran a quite different sort of movie from the one we’d seen earlier, the 1933 Paramount comedy classic International House: The Maze Runner, a 2014 film from 20th Century-Fox based on the 2009 young-adult bestseller by James Dashner. As has become commonplace at least since the success of the seven-novel, eight-film Harry Potter cycle, Dashner wrote The Maze Runner as the first of a cycle of four novels telling a continuous story about (some of) the same main characters. He also anticipated Suzanne Collins’ The Hunger Games and Veronica Roth’s Divergent cycles in setting his story in a dystopian future in which giant solar flares have wiped out most life on earth, and what hasn’t succumbed to the sun has largely been destroyed by a super-virus that literally eats away at people’s bodies and for which, of course, there is no cure. However, we don’t learn all that until the very end of the film. After the success of the Hunger Games and Divergent cycles on film (and the Twilight films before that — all three the product of the same studio, Summit Entertainment, which has merged with Lionsgate), 20th Century-Fox bought the rights to the Maze Runner sequence and assigned first-time director Wes Ball to the project after their attempt to get Catherine Hardwicke, who helmed the first Twilight movie, fell through.
Noah Oppenheim, Grant Pierce Myers and T. S. Nowlin adapted Dashner’s novel for the film, and made quite a few changes but mostly kept the idea of the original story: the central character, Thomas (Dylan O’Brien), finds himself inside an elevator with only fragmentary memories of who he is and how he got there. The elevator is taking him from an underground redoubt to the surface of the earth — and from the speed, the shakiness or whatever, he’s puking when the film opens — and it deposits him in the Glade, a confined patch of fertile earth inhabited by a bunch of teenage boys who are mostly self-sufficient — they build their own shelters and grow their own food — except for the “Box,” which every month brings the supplies they can’t make for themselves and also transports a new person to their community. The Glade is ringed by a series of tall concrete walls that make up a maze that keeps changing itself so the people inside it can’t figure out how to get out of it, and all the attempts of the boys to get themselves over the walls and out of the compound have been futile. (A number of posters on imdb.com wondered why they couldn’t just build a ladder and escape, which wasn’t explained in the film but was in the book: in the book the walls are even higher than they are in the film, and the entire encampment is encased in a glass dome that, among other things, prevents it from raining inside the Glade, which does happen in the film.) The leader of the compound — and, apparently, the first boy sent there — is Alby (Ami Ameen), a hot Black guy who’s quite frankly the sexiest guy in the film, and among the key others are Newt (Thomas Brodie-Sangster), the androgynous Chuck (Blade Cooper), and the Asian Minho (Ki Hong Lee) — nice to see that this is one science-fiction movie in which the future population isn’t depicted as all-white! (I believe the Nigerian character in the 1961 film 12 to the Moon was the first Black person ever shown in a science-fiction film.)
Also in the dramatis personae is Gally (Will Poulter), a nasty piece of work who takes an instant dislike to Thomas and tries to make his life as miserable as possible. The population is divided into people who do the necessary tasks to sustain the Glade and the Runners, whose job it is to explore the maze and see if there’s a way out. Thomas wants to be a Runner even though he’s only been there for three days, and besides, as Gally tells us, no one before has ever volunteered to be a runner — mainly because the job is incredibly dangerous; not only do the gates of the maze close every day at sunset but the corridors of the maze itself are filled with Grievers, half-mechanical, half-organic creatures that look like giant tarantulas with added attachments to make themselves more lethal. Once a Griever stings you, you first go crazy and then die a long, painful, agonizing death. Thomas learns this when he discovers Jack (Bryce Romero) in a remote part of the Glade, and instead of recognizing him Jack freaks out and tries to kill Thomas because he’s been stung and driven crazy by a Griever. Thomas goes out into the maze, comes upon a Griever, kills it, finds its control mechanism and uses it to deduce that they’re all part of an experiment being conducted by an organization called WCKD, pronounced “Wicked” and standing for World Catastrophe Killzone Department — and that all the Gladers have been programmed to believe in this experiment by having it drilled to them, in one of the few memories that survived their process of being loaded into the elevator and shipped up to the Glade, “Wicked is good.” (And here I thought it was just a rave review of that musical off-take of The Wizard of Oz!) As a result of Thomas’s success in killing a Griever and the group’s figuring out the pattern of the maze — it has eight positions and they rotate in the same sequence over and over — the unseen people running the show decide to make it tougher: they send in a woman, Teresa (Kaya Scodelario), who’s unconscious for much of her first days there and who comes in with a note attached to her reading, “She’s the last one — EVER.” Eventually half the kids escape the maze, the other half choose to stay in the Glade, and finally the kids hear from the head of the experiment (or at least their wing of it), Dr. Ava Paige (Patricia Clarkson), saying that the maze was just the first of a series of tests to which they will be subjected to see which ones are worthy to become earth’s future saviors, or something.
Since neither Charles nor I read the books first before we watched this (as we did with The Hunger Games and Divergent), there’s probably a lot of stuff about the story that isn’t clear, but the essence is a template that’s become pretty familiar lately: the future is going to suck, and only a handful of resourceful and specially talented young people is going to redeem things and make sure there’s a future after that future that won’t suck — or at least won’t suck quite so much. As a movie, The Maze Runner is virtually a non-stop action fest — what little bits of exposition we get to help us understand what’s going on take place almost literally on the run as the kids move from one potential catastrophe to another — without the depth of characterization that made the Twilight, The Hunger Games and Divergent cycles appealing even to readers and filmgoers like us well in advance of the target age for their audiences. It’s also not as well acted, and suffers from the fact that the two most interesting characters, Alby and Chuck, both die before the end (so they won’t be in the inevitable sequelae, at least one of which, The Scorch Trials, has already been made). Dylan O’Brien is good in his role but he’s not especially charismatic — we believe in him as the hero more because the script tells us to than any star quality on his part — and Ami Ameen, who does have star charisma, is virtually hors de combat after the 33rd minute of this 110-minute film (though he survives nearly to the end). The director described it to the studio as “Lord of the Flies meets Lost,” and the Lord of the Flies influence is very strong, especially in depicting the interior politics of the Glade and the rivalries between the boys and the destructive cliques that inevitably develop within the community. So is Ender’s Game, likewise a property that wasn’t filmed until after The Hunger Games established the commercial potential of such stories, but which is also about a young man who’s enlisted in an experiment of which he’s not told the real purpose until the very end — though Ender’s Game star Asa Butterfield is a considerably stronger actor than Dylan O’Brien and made us believe in him, even in a story more weakly constructed than that of The Maze Runner. Charles and I have the DVD of the second film in the sequence, The Scorch Trials, and I plan to run that one tonight and risk possibly overexposing ourselves to this interesting but not especially compelling cycle of dystopian-future stories.
Later last night Charles and I ran a quite different sort of movie from the one we’d seen earlier, the 1933 Paramount comedy classic International House: The Maze Runner, a 2014 film from 20th Century-Fox based on the 2009 young-adult bestseller by James Dashner. As has become commonplace at least since the success of the seven-novel, eight-film Harry Potter cycle, Dashner wrote The Maze Runner as the first of a cycle of four novels telling a continuous story about (some of) the same main characters. He also anticipated Suzanne Collins’ The Hunger Games and Veronica Roth’s Divergent cycles in setting his story in a dystopian future in which giant solar flares have wiped out most life on earth, and what hasn’t succumbed to the sun has largely been destroyed by a super-virus that literally eats away at people’s bodies and for which, of course, there is no cure. However, we don’t learn all that until the very end of the film. After the success of the Hunger Games and Divergent cycles on film (and the Twilight films before that — all three the product of the same studio, Summit Entertainment, which has merged with Lionsgate), 20th Century-Fox bought the rights to the Maze Runner sequence and assigned first-time director Wes Ball to the project after their attempt to get Catherine Hardwicke, who helmed the first Twilight movie, fell through.
Noah Oppenheim, Grant Pierce Myers and T. S. Nowlin adapted Dashner’s novel for the film, and made quite a few changes but mostly kept the idea of the original story: the central character, Thomas (Dylan O’Brien), finds himself inside an elevator with only fragmentary memories of who he is and how he got there. The elevator is taking him from an underground redoubt to the surface of the earth — and from the speed, the shakiness or whatever, he’s puking when the film opens — and it deposits him in the Glade, a confined patch of fertile earth inhabited by a bunch of teenage boys who are mostly self-sufficient — they build their own shelters and grow their own food — except for the “Box,” which every month brings the supplies they can’t make for themselves and also transports a new person to their community. The Glade is ringed by a series of tall concrete walls that make up a maze that keeps changing itself so the people inside it can’t figure out how to get out of it, and all the attempts of the boys to get themselves over the walls and out of the compound have been futile. (A number of posters on imdb.com wondered why they couldn’t just build a ladder and escape, which wasn’t explained in the film but was in the book: in the book the walls are even higher than they are in the film, and the entire encampment is encased in a glass dome that, among other things, prevents it from raining inside the Glade, which does happen in the film.) The leader of the compound — and, apparently, the first boy sent there — is Alby (Ami Ameen), a hot Black guy who’s quite frankly the sexiest guy in the film, and among the key others are Newt (Thomas Brodie-Sangster), the androgynous Chuck (Blade Cooper), and the Asian Minho (Ki Hong Lee) — nice to see that this is one science-fiction movie in which the future population isn’t depicted as all-white! (I believe the Nigerian character in the 1961 film 12 to the Moon was the first Black person ever shown in a science-fiction film.)
Also in the dramatis personae is Gally (Will Poulter), a nasty piece of work who takes an instant dislike to Thomas and tries to make his life as miserable as possible. The population is divided into people who do the necessary tasks to sustain the Glade and the Runners, whose job it is to explore the maze and see if there’s a way out. Thomas wants to be a Runner even though he’s only been there for three days, and besides, as Gally tells us, no one before has ever volunteered to be a runner — mainly because the job is incredibly dangerous; not only do the gates of the maze close every day at sunset but the corridors of the maze itself are filled with Grievers, half-mechanical, half-organic creatures that look like giant tarantulas with added attachments to make themselves more lethal. Once a Griever stings you, you first go crazy and then die a long, painful, agonizing death. Thomas learns this when he discovers Jack (Bryce Romero) in a remote part of the Glade, and instead of recognizing him Jack freaks out and tries to kill Thomas because he’s been stung and driven crazy by a Griever. Thomas goes out into the maze, comes upon a Griever, kills it, finds its control mechanism and uses it to deduce that they’re all part of an experiment being conducted by an organization called WCKD, pronounced “Wicked” and standing for World Catastrophe Killzone Department — and that all the Gladers have been programmed to believe in this experiment by having it drilled to them, in one of the few memories that survived their process of being loaded into the elevator and shipped up to the Glade, “Wicked is good.” (And here I thought it was just a rave review of that musical off-take of The Wizard of Oz!) As a result of Thomas’s success in killing a Griever and the group’s figuring out the pattern of the maze — it has eight positions and they rotate in the same sequence over and over — the unseen people running the show decide to make it tougher: they send in a woman, Teresa (Kaya Scodelario), who’s unconscious for much of her first days there and who comes in with a note attached to her reading, “She’s the last one — EVER.” Eventually half the kids escape the maze, the other half choose to stay in the Glade, and finally the kids hear from the head of the experiment (or at least their wing of it), Dr. Ava Paige (Patricia Clarkson), saying that the maze was just the first of a series of tests to which they will be subjected to see which ones are worthy to become earth’s future saviors, or something.
Since neither Charles nor I read the books first before we watched this (as we did with The Hunger Games and Divergent), there’s probably a lot of stuff about the story that isn’t clear, but the essence is a template that’s become pretty familiar lately: the future is going to suck, and only a handful of resourceful and specially talented young people is going to redeem things and make sure there’s a future after that future that won’t suck — or at least won’t suck quite so much. As a movie, The Maze Runner is virtually a non-stop action fest — what little bits of exposition we get to help us understand what’s going on take place almost literally on the run as the kids move from one potential catastrophe to another — without the depth of characterization that made the Twilight, The Hunger Games and Divergent cycles appealing even to readers and filmgoers like us well in advance of the target age for their audiences. It’s also not as well acted, and suffers from the fact that the two most interesting characters, Alby and Chuck, both die before the end (so they won’t be in the inevitable sequelae, at least one of which, The Scorch Trials, has already been made). Dylan O’Brien is good in his role but he’s not especially charismatic — we believe in him as the hero more because the script tells us to than any star quality on his part — and Ami Ameen, who does have star charisma, is virtually hors de combat after the 33rd minute of this 110-minute film (though he survives nearly to the end). The director described it to the studio as “Lord of the Flies meets Lost,” and the Lord of the Flies influence is very strong, especially in depicting the interior politics of the Glade and the rivalries between the boys and the destructive cliques that inevitably develop within the community. So is Ender’s Game, likewise a property that wasn’t filmed until after The Hunger Games established the commercial potential of such stories, but which is also about a young man who’s enlisted in an experiment of which he’s not told the real purpose until the very end — though Ender’s Game star Asa Butterfield is a considerably stronger actor than Dylan O’Brien and made us believe in him, even in a story more weakly constructed than that of The Maze Runner. Charles and I have the DVD of the second film in the sequence, The Scorch Trials, and I plan to run that one tonight and risk possibly overexposing ourselves to this interesting but not especially compelling cycle of dystopian-future stories.
International House (Paramount, 1933)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
International House is a marvelous movie, a product of the so-called “pre-Code” 1930-34 era of relaxed censorship which Leonard Maltin calls “Forbidden Hollywood” and I call “Hollywood glasnost” — the words “sex appeal” appear in a song lyric and Fields and Franklin Pangborn play a marvelous scene in which Fields takes Pangborn’s statement of their location — “Wu-Hu” (the film takes place, improbably enough, in the International House hotel in Wu-Hu, China) as a cruise! “Don’t let the posy fool you,” Fields mutters to Pangborn as he takes the flower out of his lapel and throws it away. Peggy Hopkins Joyce — considerably more famous as a gold-digger than for her stage appearances (apparently she made only one other film) — plays herself, and her notoriety was such that they were able to stick her in the middle of the story, under her real name, without having to bother to explain to 1932 audiences just who she was. The film centers around a Chinese inventor named Wong who has invented a “radioscope,” a magical form of television that can pick up an image of anything anywhere in the world without the need of a radio transmitter anywhere nearby, and the “radioscope” picks up a wide range of specialty acts, from a short but cleverly funny routine by Col. Stoopnagle and Budd (“Stoopnocracy is peachy,” they said — a tag line that Richmond Young and I threw around the office of the Associated Students of College of Marin in the early 1970’s after we’d seen this film on TV) to Cab Calloway’s performance of the song “Reefer Man” (revealing, if nothing else, that druggie slang hasn’t changed that much since 1932 — though this scene was removed from some 1970’s-era prints). Of all the acts in the film, however, Charles found George Burns and Gracie Allen the funniest — later he told me he’d grown up watching an L.A. TV station in the 1970’s that was still running the Burns/Allen TV shows from the 1950’s, so he remembered them well from his childhood (and probably wondered why the more recent TV sitcoms weren’t anywhere nearly as funny). There’s a marvelous routine early in the movie in which Burns and Pangborn take turns being Gracie Allen’s straight man — as if a single individual can’t stand doing that for too long — and Burns is cast as the hotel doctor and Allen is a nurse (a bow to the success of their marvelous short, Oh! My Operation, I think). — 11/25/95
International House is a marvelous movie, a product of the so-called “pre-Code” 1930-34 era of relaxed censorship which Leonard Maltin calls “Forbidden Hollywood” and I call “Hollywood glasnost” — the words “sex appeal” appear in a song lyric and Fields and Franklin Pangborn play a marvelous scene in which Fields takes Pangborn’s statement of their location — “Wu-Hu” (the film takes place, improbably enough, in the International House hotel in Wu-Hu, China) as a cruise! “Don’t let the posy fool you,” Fields mutters to Pangborn as he takes the flower out of his lapel and throws it away. Peggy Hopkins Joyce — considerably more famous as a gold-digger than for her stage appearances (apparently she made only one other film) — plays herself, and her notoriety was such that they were able to stick her in the middle of the story, under her real name, without having to bother to explain to 1932 audiences just who she was. The film centers around a Chinese inventor named Wong who has invented a “radioscope,” a magical form of television that can pick up an image of anything anywhere in the world without the need of a radio transmitter anywhere nearby, and the “radioscope” picks up a wide range of specialty acts, from a short but cleverly funny routine by Col. Stoopnagle and Budd (“Stoopnocracy is peachy,” they said — a tag line that Richmond Young and I threw around the office of the Associated Students of College of Marin in the early 1970’s after we’d seen this film on TV) to Cab Calloway’s performance of the song “Reefer Man” (revealing, if nothing else, that druggie slang hasn’t changed that much since 1932 — though this scene was removed from some 1970’s-era prints). Of all the acts in the film, however, Charles found George Burns and Gracie Allen the funniest — later he told me he’d grown up watching an L.A. TV station in the 1970’s that was still running the Burns/Allen TV shows from the 1950’s, so he remembered them well from his childhood (and probably wondered why the more recent TV sitcoms weren’t anywhere nearly as funny). There’s a marvelous routine early in the movie in which Burns and Pangborn take turns being Gracie Allen’s straight man — as if a single individual can’t stand doing that for too long — and Burns is cast as the hotel doctor and Allen is a nurse (a bow to the success of their marvelous short, Oh! My Operation, I think). — 11/25/95
•••••
The film was International House, the utterly joyous 1933 Paramount comedy featuring
an all-star cast (though the people you’ll notice today are W. C. Fields,
George Burns and Gracie Allen) in a loony story about ancient Chinese inventor
Dr. Wong (played by the decidedly non-Chinese Edmund Breese), who has invented
something called a “radioscope.” This is a television set — at a time when television
was still the subject of science-fiction stories and articles in magazines like
Popular Science speculating
whether it would ever exist — only, unlike any existing TV set in the world,
then or now, it can pick up events around the world and telecast them without
any camera to photograph them or transmitter to transmit them. Dr. Wong lives
in the (decidedly fictitious, though represented on-screen by sets the
Paramount set builders constructed for Shanghai in Josef von Sternberg’s 1932
film Shanghai Express, with
Marlene Dietrich and Clive Brook) city of Wu-Hu, China, which gives rise to the
film’s most famous gag line (more on that later). The main part of the plot, to
the extent this film has one (Neil Brant and Louis J. Heifetz wrote the
original story — during a recreation break at their asylum, one wonders? — and
Francis Martin and Walter DeLeon did the screenplay, though it’s almost certain
Fields himself came up with most of his own lines), concerns the international
bidding war between countries for the rights to Dr. Wong’s radioscope. U.S.
representative Tommy Nash (Stuart Erwin) is also the fiancé of Carol Fortescue
(Sari Maritza), only they haven’t got married yet because every time they set a
wedding date they have to cancel because Tommy keeps getting diseases like
chicken pox and mumps that Carol (and most people) already had in their
childhoods.
Carol is the daughter of the British representative, Sir Mortimer
Fortescue (Lumsden Hare, the guy they got when they wanted the archetypal
representative of British imperialism and C. Aubrey Smith wasn’t available).
There’s also a German representative, Herr von Baden (Harrison Greene), but
he’s played more as a foil for jokes than a serious character — even in a comic
context. The Russian representative is another story: he’s a major supporting
character in the film, he goes by the grandiloquent name “General Nicholas
Pernovsky Petronovich,” announces himself as “formerly of the Russian Imperial
Guards; at present, general manager of the Moscow Utilities Company,” and is
played to the nines by, of all people, Bela Lugosi, who proves as adept at
character comedy as he was in his famous horror roles. (W. C. Fields and Bela
Lugosi: no degrees of separation!) He’s also one of the ex-husbands of Peggy
Hopkins Joyce, real-life gold-digger of the 1920’s, whose reputation was so
notorious that not only does she play herself in the film, when Carol learns
that Tommy spent the night with her — they were driving across the Chinese
desert from Shanghai to Wu-Hu to avoid the washed-out bridges, and as Tommy
tearfully confesses to his girlfriend, “we didn’t do anything but argue” —
she’s convinced he’s been cheating on her with the spectacularly notorious
woman. When he insists their relationship was “purely platonic” — in those
weird, whiny tones of Stuart Erwin’s that were usually just annoying but in the
right comic context, as here, were screamingly funny — once she learns her
supposed rival’s identity she snarls in disbelief, “Purely platonic — with Peggy Hopkins Joyce?” Charlie Chaplin, who supposedly had a brief affair
with Joyce (and a somewhat longer one with Sari Maritza, so two of the women in this film were Chaplin
girlfriends!), said that Joyce once told him that one of her husbands repelled
her so that on their wedding night she locked the bedroom door on him and
wouldn’t unlock it until he slipped a check for $100,000 under it. Then she let
him in — and the next morning bolted out of bed and made sure she got to his
bank when it opened so she could cash the check before he could stop payment on
it.
All of these people end up either in or around the International House
Hotel, the largest and nicest in Wu-Hu, whose manager is played by Franklin
Pangborn (who else?), as queeny as ever, and whose doctor and nurse are played
by George Burns and Gracie Allen at the top of their form. At one point Burns
and Pangborn play turns being her straight man, and at another point when Dr.
Burns is out of the office, Nurse Allen answers his phone and tells the caller,
“No, the doctor isn’t in just now. Oh, he won’t be back for a long, long time.
He went out on one of those eternity cases.” As I’ve pointed out before, unlike
Lucille Ball (another great comedienne who achieved stardom working with her
real-life husband), Gracie Allen did not just play a ditz: her non sequiturs had a sort of crack-brained sense about them (in one
of their other films she tells an incredulous Burns that she has a cousin with
three feet, and when Burns raises those eyebrows, wags that cigar and says,
“Three feet?,” Gracie says, “Yes, his mother wrote me and said, ‘You wouldn’t
recognize your cousin — he’s grown another foot!’”) and you could make a case
that Burns and Allen were doing surrealistic humor without actually calling it
that (just as Buster Keaton, asked in the last year of his life by interviewer
Rudi Blesh how he came to make a surrealistic film like Sherlock,
Jr., replied, “I was not trying to be surrealistic! I was just trying to make
it look like a dream!”) W. C. Fields literally flies into the action; he plays the celebrated
aviator Professor Henry R. Quail, who loads beer and liquor by the case into
his autogiro (an odd sort of aircraft, midway between an airplane and a
helicopter, that had a brief vogue in the 1920’s and 1930’s; it has a top rotor
but also a front propeller and conventional airplane wings, and in a typical
Fieldsian touch he lampoons Lindbergh by calling it “The Spirit of Brooklyn”)
and sets off on a flight to Kansas City. Only he gets so bombed on all that
booze he loses his way completely — we see a map of the world with a dotted
line across it to represent the route he’s been taking, traced by empty bottles
with which he’s dive-bombed outdoor restaurants and other locations en
route, much the way similar lines would later dot the maps
in the Hope-Crosby Road movies to
show how totally they were
getting lost. Quail lands on the roof garden of the International Hotel in
Wu-Hu just after a great production number, “She Was a China Teacup (And He Was
Just a Mug),” starring Lona André as the teacup and Sterling Holloway as the
mug (who wins the affections of a spoon, a teapot and a sugar bowl but only has
eyes for the China teacup), in a dazzling number. The choreographer is
regrettably uncredited but he (or she) and director A. Edward Sutherland
deserve credit for taking the cameras up and filming this scene in full-on
Busby Berkeley manner, including tracking shots through the chorines’ legs and
giant jigsaw puzzles of the two title characters first separately, then pulled
apart and rearranged to show them together at the end.
Just as the song is
wrapping up, Professor Quail’s entry is heralded by an empty bottle flung from
his plane that bisects one of the tables at the Roof Garden. Quail lands and
says, “Is this Kansas City, Kansas or Kansas City, Missouri?” When it dawns on
him that it’s neither, he asks where he is. A woman answers, “Wu-Hu,” and he
answers, “Woo-Hoo to you sweetheart.” Then he sees a quivering Franklin
Pangborn and asks him, “Hey Charlie, where am I?” “Wu-Hu,” Pangborn says.
Fields, interpreting it as a Gay pass, snarls, “Don’t let the posey fool ya,”
and he looks down at his lapel, removes the flower that’s been there and throws
it away. That “Don’t let the posey fool ya” has become the most famous line in
the film; one imdb.com reviewer recalled that he went to a revival theatre
showing International House and
at least two people in the lobby were quoting it before the film began, and
when I told my husband Charles what we were going to see last night, he
remembered it instantly and said, “Don’t let the posey fool ya,” in a sort-of
Fieldsian voice. Meanwhile, Tommy Nash and Carol Fortescue are about to get
married when — once again — he feels feverish and thinks he’s getting the
measles, and General Petronovich, thinking he’s going to be able to use this to
keep the U.S. representative from getting to Wong and buying the radiograph,
bribes the local health authorities to put Nash’s room under quarantine. Only
the authorities quarantine the entire International House, so Petronovich can’t
get in to submit his own bid for
Wong’s invention, and he tries every avenue he can think of, including briefly
considering a tightrope walk from an adjoining building (though inevitably,
given who was playing him, I joked that in his most famous role Lugosi could
have simply turned himself into a bat and flown into the International House), before he bribes a
group of Wu-Hu plug-uglies to break down the hotel’s door — just as the
authorities are lifting the quarantine and Pangborn is opening the doors,
leading to a great slapstick climax in which, in order to allow them to make
their escape, Prof. Quail presses a button on the side of his aircraft and out
comes a little car, the “Spirit of South Brooklyn,” which he drives up and down
the hotel steps and finally uses to get to his autogiro and fly himself, Peggy
Hopkins Joyce, Tommy and Carol (by then Tommy has completed his deal with Mr.
Wong for the rights to the radiograph) out of danger from Petronovich and his
thugs. There’s a lot of slapstick by-play involving the elaborate rack behind
the lobby desk that contains the guests’ room keys and any letters they’ve
received at the hotel, which keeps getting knocked over and spilling out its
contents, whereupon Pangborn has to laboriously put them all back.
There are
also some great guest acts brought into the picture by Dr. Wong and his
radioscope, including the radio comedians Col. Stoopnagle and Budd (I’ve never
heard their shows but judging from the clip here they seem almost as great as
accidental surrealists as Burns and Allen — especially the sign on their office
door, “Stoopnocracy is peachy,” a pun on the then-popular Technocracy
movement), Rudy Vallée (singing a love song called “Thank Heaven for You” which
he’s addressing to a figure in bed, covered in blankets and sheets, which turns
out to be his megaphone — before electric amplification megaphones were the
only artificial way singers had to make themselves louder and more audible over
a big band — then, in a neat bit of frame-breaking that anticipates the
Hope-Crosby Road movies by at
least a decade, Fields snarls an insult at Vallée’s image and Vallée answers
him back, whereupon Fields sticks his walking stick into the radiograph’s
mechanism, short-circuiting it and forcing Wong to shut down the demonstration
for repairs, an eerie anticipation of Elvis Presley’s penchant for shooting out
the screens of TV’s showing programs he didn’t like — apparently Elvis so
loathed Robert Goulet that every time Goulet came on a TV in his home or room,
he’d shoot it), Baby Rose Marie (the future co-star of The Dick Van
Dyke and salty-voiced nightclub comedienne
at age nine belting out a formidable torch songs called “My Bluebird’s Singing
the Blues” — this got in just one year under the wire before Shirley Temple
abruptly ended the vogue for gutsy, hard-edged child performers and forced just
about every kid into movies into her gooey-sweet sentimental mode), and Cab
Calloway and His Orchestra. The year before Calloway had appeared in the
Paramount all-star musical The Big Broadcast doing a song called “Kickin’ the Gong Around” — the
title was Harlem Black slang for drug use — and just in case we didn’t get what
the song was about from its title, just before he finishes it Cab lifted his
sleeve to his nose and snorted
it. This time Cab did a song
called “Reefer Man,” first showing his bassist, Al Morgan, playing wildly, then
explaining to his band members that he was high on reefers — a real jolt to
anyone who was growing up in the late 1960’s and early 1970’s and didn’t
realize that both marijuana use itself and the slang terms for it were at least
four decades old. Some prints of this movie circulating to TV in the 1950’s,
1960’s and 1970’s omitted this song, some included it, and if you sat down to
watch International House at home
you never quite knew whether you would be getting a version with or without
“Reefer Man.” International House
is an absolute delight start to finish, the sort of comedy you laugh at more rather than less the more times you’ve seen it, and
(once again) a testament to the incredible creativity of comedians then versus
the dreary unfunniness of most of what passes for “comedy” on both big and
small screens now. — 1/7/16
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
