Friday, January 22, 2016

The Old-Fashioned Way (Paramount, 1934)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The film was The Old-Fashioned Way, which I’m sure Charles and I had seen together before and which had previously struck me as a perfectly passable W. C. Fields vehicle with some great moments (notably Fields’ famous confrontations with Baby LeRoy — particularly the one in which LeRoy’s mother says, “He’s such a good boy. You really ought to see him some time when he’s by himself,” and Fields replies under his breath, “I’d like to catch him some time when he’s by himself” — and the great scene in which, for almost 10 minutes, Fields does quite a bit of juggling, including the cigar-box trick which he invented and many other jugglers copied, a scene which was excerpted and released in the 1960’s as a stand-alone short called The Great McGonigle). This time around it seemed stronger than that: it was Fields’ valentine to his own early days in show business, traveling with theatrical troupes that performed such standard plays as The Drunkard (excerpted here) and East Lynne, and lived a hand-to-mouth existence as they took themselves from one small town to another, often one step ahead (or not even that!) of various town sheriffs chasing them to collect on unpaid bills from their last town (or two, or three). Though the time period in which The Old-Fashioned Way takes place is pretty ambiguous, it’s obviously not the 1934 present in which it was made; in one scene the characters come to the window of the boarding house where the theatre people are staying to look at “one of those new horseless carriages” driving by, though Paramount wasn’t about to blow the budget of a 71-minute program comedy actually to rent a car of the proper vintage. Whenever it takes place, The Old-Fashioned Way is one of W. C. Fields’ lovable-rogue characterizations as he does whatever he has to do to keep his troupe together, including comforting actors restive because they haven’t been paid or outwitting the various sheriffs — one of whom, in an early scene, tries to serve Fields with a summons, only to find that Fields’ assistant has set it on fire, and Fields uses the flame to light his cigar. Fields plays The Great McGonigle (that’s his entire name; if he has a more normal first name, the script — by Garnett Weston and Jack Cunningham based on a story by “Charles Bogle,” i.e. Fields himself, and with no fewer than 10 other writers listed on the film’s imdb.com page — doesn’t give it to us), whose poverty-stricken little troupe descends on the small town of Bellefountaine (presumably in California because it’s described as being near Cucamonga) and encounter boarding-house owner Mrs. Wendelschaffer (Nora Cecil), who’s worried because she got stiffed by McGonigle’s troupe the year before and this time is determined to get payment for her room and board up front, or she’s going to lock up the actors’ trunks and not let them leave.

She’s also got an obnoxious kid, Albert Pepperday (Baby LeRoy), who dumps McGonigle’s watch in a bowl of molasses. Fields apparently hated Baby LeRoy as much off-screen as his character does on-screen, and according to one biographer he actually spiked LeRoy’s milk with his usual mix of vodka martinis and then kept a straight face as LeRoy’s mother panicked and wondered just what was wrong with her kid. The obligatory young couple are McGonigle’s daughter Betty (Judith Allen, who frankly looks a bit too matronly for the role) and a rich man’s kid, Wally Livingston (Joe Morrison, a quite good Irish tenor who had the misfortune to come upon the scene just when the market for Irish tenors was drying up). Livingston’s dad (Oscar Apfel) shows up to try to talk Wally out of his theatrical ambitions and into returning to college, where he’s presumably going to prepare for a business career. Remember this was a time period when the public repute of actors was so low Fields made a point of repeating a joke he’d heard then, in which a young man makes a prodigal son-like return to the family he abandoned years before. When his parents ask what he’s been doing while he’s away, he hems, haws and finally, shame-facedly admits to them, “I’ve been … an actor.” “An actor?” his parents thunder at him. “And to think we thought all this time you’d become a nice, respectable burglar!” Livingston, Sr. confronts Betty McGonigle and tells her he doesn’t think his son belongs on the stage — and to his astonishment, Betty agrees with him, saying that she thinks he should return to school but he refuses to do so unless she agrees to marry him and come with him — which she doesn’t want to do because as leading lady of the McGonigle troupe, she has a loyalty to her dad. That’s about all the plot this movie has, but that’s really all it needs; it incorporates a good chunk of the script for The Drunkard into its running time, played in a really stilted, phony fashion that may have been in vogue when the script was first premiered (1843) but no doubt seemed as ridiculous in 1934 as it does today. Indeed, the opening credits promise us “The Cast of the Original ‘Drunkard’ Company,” though an imdb.com “Trivia” poster said that by 1934 anyone who could have acted in the original production of The Drunkard would have been dead and what was probably meant was the revival company that had opened a production of The Drunkard in L.A. in 1933, which inexplicably ran for several years — though the poster was unable to obtain a cast list for the 1933 L.A. stage production to compare it with the film’s credits and see just how many members of the stage cast were also in the movie.

After using various stratagems to evade the sheriffs who are after him, including setting one of their summonses on fire (and stealing himself a Pullman ticket on the train while his troupe members have to sleep as best as they can in their seats), McGonigle more or less seduces Cleopatra Pepperday (the marvelous Jan Duggan), Bellefountaine’s richest widow and the fiancée of the town sheriff, into threatening to jilt him if he serves the troupe and paying off the Cucamonga sheriff (the equally marvelous character villain Clarence Wilson, uncredited) in exchange for a small part in McGonigle’s play — which never materializes, though she sings an excruciatingly bad song as her audition piece and endlessly practices her one line, “Here comes the prince,” with absolutely no clue how to stress it. (The gag had already been done on film five years earlier in Gold Diggers on Broadway, in which Winnie Lightner has one line in a big Broadway show — “I am the spirit of Liberty and the progress of Civilization!” — endlessly practices it and finally blows it on her big night.) By advertising Cleopatra’s stage debut McGonigle gets a full house for his performance — “I’m here just to see her make a fool of herself,” says one of the townspeople in the audience — but, whether out of devotion to his Art or because he simply can’t be bothered, McGonigle doesn’t let Cleopatra go on. (“She’ll probably go on right after the epilogue,” he tells her sheriff boyfriend.) After The Drunkard is over, Fields as McGonigle does his juggling act (thankfully preserving much of the routine that made him a star — he originally went into show business as a juggler but then put jokes into his act because he found comedians got paid more, just as the Marx Brothers had originally been a musical act who went into comedy because it paid better) and then there’s a tearful farewell that reveals just how fine an actor W. C. Fields was. He gets a telegram from his bookers that because of the bad reception of his company, the rest of his tour has been canceled. Putting a brave face on it, he says he’s received a big offer in New York, but it’s only for him, not her, so she should feel free to marry her boyfriend and settle down. Then there’s a cut to what he’s really doing now that the McGonigle Theatre Company is no more: he’s on a streetcorner selling a patent medicine called Yack Wee, ostensibly developed from cacti by Native Americans, and he’s pushing it as a cure for hoarseness. In the middle of his pitch he suddenly drops his voice, lowering its volume and making it gravelly as if he really had hoarseness, then he drinks a swallow of the stuff and booms out fortissimo over his crowd, “IT CURES HOARSENESS!”

The Old-Fashioned Way is a lovely movie, setting off Fields’ comedy in the context of a plot that makes sense and makes us feel for the characters. It was directed by William Beaudine — one of the most infamous figures in Hollywood history; in the silent era he rose from shorts to direct “A”-lister Mary Pickford in the 1925 version of Little Annie Rooney, only the Depression left him deep in debt and, like his partial namesake William Nigh, he was determined to pay off all his creditors even if that meant toiling in the salt-mines of third-rate studios like Monogram and making crappy movies on a schedule so tight that on one occasion one of the Monogram executives told him to hurry up so they could meet a release deadline, and Beaudine replied incredulously, “You mean someone out there is actually waiting to see this?” Beaudine hadn’t totally lost his chops as a filmmaker in the early 1930’s — two years before The Old-Fashoned Way he had made Three Wise Girls, a marvelous “pre-Code” movie from Columbia starring Jean Harlow (in her last film for anyone other than MGM) and written by Frank Capra’s collaborator, Robert Riskin — and while I’ve sometimes lampooned Beaudine’s work on The Old-Fashioned Way by saying anyone could direct a Fields movie as long as they kept the cameras on him and in focus, and made sure the sound people were recording his dialogue intelligibly, the fact is Beaudine brings a lot more to this film than that. Aided by his cinematographer, Ben Reynolds, and art director John B. Goodman, Beaudine flawlessly recreates the atmosphere of the turn of the last century and stages the action beautifully, and gets excellent performances from the cast. The Old-Fashioned Way was no doubt a personal film for W. C. Fields — it reproduced the showbiz milieu in which he had got his start — and it’s also a beautiful movie, screamingly funny but also with warmth and heart. It helps that Fields generally knew just how far to push his lovable-rogue characterization so the rogue stayed lovable (at least until the 1939 Universal film You Can’t Cheat an Honest Man, which had a similar plot to The Old-Fashioned Way and the 1936 film Poppy — based on Fields’ star-making 1924 Broadway musical — but whose writers screwed up Fields’ original story by making his character too dishonest and repulsive), and despite Fields’ oft-reported hatred of Chaplin in general and Chaplin’s celebrated pathos in particular, Fields was capable of a quirky sort of pathos of his own that softened his characterizations so he could retain the love of an audience even while treading on the thin edge of despicability. And, as his friend Leo Rosten once said about Fields (though the line is frequently misattributed to Fields himself), anyone who hates small children and dogs can’t be all bad …

[For a previous moviemagg post on The Old-Fashioned Way, please see http://moviemagg.blogspot.com/2013/06/the-old-fashioned-way-paramount-1934.html.]

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

The Cocoanuts (Paramount, 1929)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The film was The Cocoanuts, produced at Paramount’s Astoria studio in Queens, New York in 1929 and starring the Four Marx Brothers (as they were originally billed until Zeppo Marx dropped out of the act) in a film version of their hit 1925 stage musical, produced by Sam H. Harris (George M. Cohan’s former partner and, according to Marx Brothers biographer Joe Adamson, so terminally kind that the nastiest thing anyone could remember him saying about anybody was when he responded to the change of government in Germany in early 1933 with, “Hitler is not a nice fellow”) and written by George S. Kaufman and Morrie Ryskind. Apparently it was so extensively rewritten by the Marx Brothers, who according to some accounts were so fond of improvising and keeping their funniest improvisations in the script that when Kaufman and Ryskind went to see The Cocoanuts midway through its original run, Kaufman turned to Ryskind during the second act and said, “Hey, I think I just heard one of our original lines.” (According to other accounts, the Marx Brothers hated improvising and wanted their scripts in set form before they ever let the material near a paying audience or a movie camera. That was one reason that before A Night at the Opera and A Day at the Races were filmed, they toured the shows so they could perform the key comedy scenes before live audiences and find out literally from the horses’ mouths what people would — and wouldn’t — think was funny.)

In his 1971 book about the Marx Brothers, Paul Zimmerman said that aside from the Marxes’ participation, The Cocoanuts was historically important as one of the few filmed records of a 1920’s Broadway show, complete with stilted song-and-dance numbers and awkward alternations between songs, dances, comic scenes and plot exposition. Later Richard Barrios said in his book on early musicals that that was so much nonsense: he argued that audiences in 1929 who went to see The Cocoanuts went for the same reasons anyone would want to see it today: to laugh at the Marx Brothers. The Cocoanuts certainly has some of the stage-bound flavor of early musicals; it begins with a big production number with a chorus singing the praises of “Florida by the Sea,” as Irving Berlin’s lyric has it — the show was a satire of the mid-1920’s Florida land boom, a classic “bubble” in which Northern promoters bought huge tracts of Florida real estate, promising buyers year-round sunshine and stable climates — and then a big hurricane hit, bursting the bubble and leaving hundreds of investors broke. The film casts Groucho as Mr. Hammer (no first name), owner of the Cocoanut Beach hotel and a lot of the land around it, which he’s trying to sell so Cocoanut Beach can become the next great Florida development and make him and his investors lots of money. Only no investors materialize — just Chico and Harpo (billed under their own names because the character names they had in the stage production, particular Chico’s billing as “Willy the Wop,” were too racially insensitive even for 1929), who arrive at the Cocoanut Beach Hotel penniless and with an empty suitcase. “Oh, that’s all right,” Chico says when Groucho points out his suitcase is empty. “We fill it up before we leave.” By the time they made this movie the Marx Brothers were already in their 30’s and had had at least two decades of success behind them, first on the vaudeville circuit (where they had started out as a musical act but drifted into comedy because comedians were paid more) and then on Broadway in the 1924 revue I’ll Say She Is (most of which is lost, but the famous sequence with Groucho as Napoleon bidding goodbye to Josephine as he heads off into battle was recorded years later and filmed as an animated cartoon with Groucho voicing his original role), The Cocoanuts and the follow-up, Animal Crackers, also by Kaufman and Ryskind and also filmed by Paramount in New York.

The Marxes were appearing in Animal Crackers by night and filming The Cocoanuts by day, and they make a few audible slips in their dialogue — the kinds that often creep into the performances of stage actors who have been playing the same damned script way too often — which the film’s two directors, Robert Florey and Joseph Santley, let slip and didn’t bother to retake. There are some O.K. songs by Irving Berlin — The Cocoanuts became famous as the only show Berlin ever worked on that didn’t generate at least one hit song for him; for the movie he added a big ballad, “When My Dreams Come True,” for romantic leads Mary Eaton (a protégée of Florenz Ziegfeld — he was grooming her to replace Marilyn Miller and that’s shown in her big number, “Monkey-Doodle-Doo,” a song Berlin wrote in the mold of his earlier “Shaking the Blues Away” and inserted a topical reference to monkey-gland treatments, which were supposed to rejuvenate people, doing a dance with the Gamby-Hale Ballet Girls and Allan K. Foster Girls very much in the Miller manner) and Oscar Shaw, but it didn’t become a hit either. The Cocoanuts suffers from its stage-bound production — even the opening shots of the Florida beaches are clearly studio interiors with painted backdrops representing sea and sky — and from musical interludes that are filmed rather dully, though at least co-director Santley (who seems to have been detailed to handle the musical numbers while Florey directed the plot and comedy scenes) uses some three-quarter views of the chorus line, rides a crane camera and in one scene even shoots down at the Gamby-Hale Ballet Girls from overhead and allows them to form a kaleidoscope formation. (This is usually associated with Busby Berkeley but there are at least three movies made before 1930, when Berkeley made his first film, Whoopee, that feature overhead kaleidoscope shots of choristers: this one, Wheeler and Woolsey’s Rio Rita and Albertina Rasch’s two-strip Technicolor ballets in the 1929 MGM flop Lord Byron of Broadway.)

What does hold up about The Cocoanuts are, you guessed it, the Marx Brothers comedy sequences, which to some extent set the template for the entire rest of their career: the comic monologues by Groucho (who kicks off the auction of Cocoanut Beach lots by saying, “Florida, folks, land of perpetual sunshine. Let’s get the auction started before we have a tornado”), the confrontations between Groucho and Chico (including the famous “Why a duck?” sequence in which Groucho hires Chico to be a shill at his auction and bid the prices up, only when Groucho makes the mistake of telling Chico that a viaduct will be built across the property, Chico says, “All right, why-a-duck?,” and they riff on that hilariously for what seems like 15 minutes) and the demonic savagery of Harpo. It’s also somewhat ironic that Charles and I were watching The Cocoanuts just after I’d been commenting on this blog about the risks of hiring a relatively new director with a hot independent film just out and entrusting them with a big-budget studio blockbuster — like Gareth Edwards with the 2014 Godzilla remake and Josh Trank with the latest reboot of Fantastic Four — when something like that happened here. Robert Florey was an assistant director from France who had just jolted Hollywood with an indie short called The Life and Death of 9413 — A Hollywood Extra, and for the unexpected success of that film he was rewarded with the co-director assignment on The Cocoanuts. Only he didn’t find the Marx Brothers, except for Harpo, all that funny; he pretty much left Groucho and Chico to their own devices but worked on new silent gags for Harpo, including the marvelous scene in the lobby of the Cocoanut Manor Hotel in which Harpo drinks the ink out of the inkwells and then eats the desk telephone. (The ink was really Coca-Cola and the phone was made of chocolate.)

The Cocoanuts has been faulted not only for the staginess when the Marxes aren’t on the screen and the oddly belligerent characterizations they assume when they are (both Groucho and Harpo are considerably nastier here than they were in their later movies), but the Marxes’ scenes are hilarious and not only hold up beautifully but set the basic tropes they’d refine and make even funnier in their later films. Also present at the creation, as it were — The Cocoanuts was the Marxes’ first feature, unless you count a 1918 silent called Humorisk which they produced independently with their own money and then pulled from release when their one public showing took place at the epicenter of the 1918-19 flu epidemic in New York — was Margaret Dumont as Mrs. Potter, the only hotel guest who actually has money, whom of course Groucho is romancing in his always twisted way (which reaches its high point when Groucho invites her to make love to him outdoors under a full moon: “I can see it now: you and the moon. You wear a necktie so I’ll know you”) and whose daughter Polly (Mary Eaton) is caught between two suitors. One is Bob Adams (Oscar Shaw), the poor but honest guy — a hotel clerk with ambitions to be an architect and participate in a major Florda remodeling project; he’s the one Polly likes best but the one her mom wants her to marry is scapegrace Harvey Yates (Cyril Ring) because he’s “one of the Boston Yates,” even though he’s a slimeball, he has another girlfriend on the side — Penelope, played by Kay Francis in her film debut and showing herself ready for biggers and betters — and since he’s broke and doesn’t want to wait around to marry Polly Potter and inherit the Potter millions, he conceives the idea of stealing Mrs. Potter’s diamond necklace and framing Adams for the crime. Of course, it all turns out right in the end — Groucho attracts an out-of-town buyer who’s interested in taking over all of Cocoanut Beach and developing it; Bob Adams gets not only Polly Potter but the job of designing the new development; and Harvey Yates and Penelope get waltzed off into jail — but it’s certainly a lot of fun getting there.

The Cocoanuts is an uneven movie (though, aside from the great comedy sequences, the “Monkey-Doodle-Doo” number is fun and entertaining) that’s become even more uneven from the shabby condition in which it’s been preserved: though the version we were watching (from the MCA Universal boxed set of all five Marx Brothers’ movies for Paramount, which I want to run in alternation with the W. C. Fields and Mae West boxes to recreate the marvelous comedy lineup I remember from my teen days watching Channel 36, a San José station that for some reason came in excellently in Marin County when I was growing up and where I saw a lot of classic films) is quite the best-looking one I’ve ever seen, there are still startling gaps in the photographic quality from scene to scene. The reason is that, though The Cocoanuts was a major hit on its initial release, no one print survived complete. The version we have was pieced together in the 1950’s (either just before or just after MCA’s TV subsidiary, Revue Productions, bought the rights to virtually all Paramount’s output from 1929 to 1949 for TV showings, and later assigned the films to Universal when MCA absorbed Universal in 1962) from three partial prints, and the image quality takes some rather startling changes, particularly the sudden drop in clarity and definition just before “Monkey-Doodle-Doo.” Still, The Cocoanuts is nicely done and quite entertaining — the “Why a duck?” sequence alone would make the film worth watching — even though just about everything in it was refined and honed, and made sharper and funnier, in their later films.

Monday, January 18, 2016

The Cat’s-Paw (Harold Lloyd Productions, Fox Film Corporation, 1934)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

After Steamboat Bill, Jr. TCM showed a really weird and different movie: The Cat’s Paw (the American Film Institute Catalog insists on hyphenating the last two words of the title but I don’t recall seeing them so in the actual credits), a 1934 film by Harold Lloyd (the director of record was Sam Taylor but Lloyd, like Chaplin, was the auteur) based on a story by Clarence Budington Kelland, who also wrote the sources for the 1932 Buster Keaton/Jimmy Durante farce Speak Easily and the 1936 film Mr. Deeds Goes to Town, Frank Capra’s classic with Gary Cooper and Jean Arthur (recently remade with Adam Sandler and Winona Ryder — that’s its own comment, I think). Kelland was a specialist in fish-out-of-water tales about naïve innocents suddenly thrust either into untold riches (Mr. Deeds), the illusion of untold riches (Speak Easily) or in this case, political power. Lloyd plays Ezekiel Cobb, Jr., the son of a missionary in China who has lived his entire life from early boyhood to his current young-adult status in a remote Chinese village without telephones, radio or any English speakers. He comes back to his home town of Stockdale with the intent of finding a white wife so he can start a family and continue the family tradition of Chinese missionary work, and he stumbles across a crooked political leader, Jake Mayo (George Barbier), who drafts him to run a hopeless campaign for mayor as part of a phony “reform” party — replacing a candidate who died just two days before the election! As you might expect, Lloyd actually wins the election — thanks to an incident (anticipating the plot of Kid Galahad by five years) in which he punches out the corrupt machine candidate for mayor after the corrupt machine candidate shoved a crippled newsboy to the ground — and attempts to run a genuinely honest administration, thereby opening himself to a frame-up from the gangsters he’s shut out of the public trough. The film is filled with racist dialogue — the word “Chink” is heard quite a lot on the soundtrack, probably one reason why this movie is almost never shown today — though to Lloyd’s credit most of the time the joke is on the racists; but what makes this film astonishing is the bizarre worm-turning ending. Sure he will be thrown out of office the next day due to the success of the frame-up against him, Lloyd has the police round up every known gangster in the city and bring them to the basement of a Chinese antique store where the owner has the actual sword used thousands of years before by a Chinese emperor who beheaded all the country’s bandits. He stages an elaborate charade to make the crooks think he’s going to behead them similarly — and there’s a shocking scene in which a (supposedly) beheaded crook is actually brought in on a stretcher and has the desired effect on the others. Not surprisingly, there’s a gimmick involved — the antique-store owner was previously a stage magician and worked this out as an illusion — but still the frank acceptance of a fascist solution to the problem of urban crime (at a time when Hitler had just taken power and Mussolini still had a lot of American admirers) and the flat-out statement à la today’s TV show Law and Order that due-process rules are nothing more than a way for criminals to evade responsibility and punishment for their crimes make this a quite unusual movie even now. — 9/9/02

•••••

Last night’s “feature” was The Cat’s-Paw, a 1934 film starring Harold Lloyd and made by his own production company but an outlier among his films in many ways. First, instead of being released through Paramount (as were most of Lloyd’s self-produced films once he left Pathé in 1927), it was put out by the Fox Film Corporation pre-20th Century merger. Second, it’s a considerably darker film than most of his movies, and indeed it anticipates the basic plot of Mr. Smith Goes to Washington by five years —though the year before The Cat’s-Paw was made, an independent producer/director named William Berke (who later turned up as a “B” director at RKO in the 1940’s and made several of the later films in the Falcon detective series) had done a film for Imperial Pictures called Corruption which features the basic plot device of this one: an innocent (in both senses) character is picked by a phony “reform” movement to run for mayor of a graft-ridden city, with the intent that he will be defeated and the big-city machine which runs both the government and the ostensible “reformers” will be able to continue to loot the city unscathed — only the patsy accidentally wins and takes the idea of “reform” all too seriously for his sponsors. Third, it has almost no slapstick — Lloyd takes exactly one pratfall in this film — and instead its mood is so dark it almost counts as black comedy. The film opens in a small village in China, where young Ezekiel Cobb (played as a boy by Daniel Holt and given a pair of round-rimmed glasses — actually just empty frames — to let us know he’s going to grow up to be Harold Lloyd) arrives to join his father (Samuel S. Hinds), a missionary. He’s given a book in Chinese by a poet named Ling Po, whose aphorisms he keeps quoting through the entire movie even though when he’s first presented the book he can’t read it because it’s in Chinese (and there’s a nice little gag that it turns out he’s holding the book upside-down).

The time flashes forward from 1914 to 1934 — represented by one year’s calendar dissolving into another (why don’t the Lifetime producers do that instead of putting in those silly titles: “Twenty Years Later”?) — and 20 years later the grown Ezekiel Cobb travels to his home town, “Stockport,” to contact the head of the church for which his father worked. The idea is he will stay in Stockport just long enough to meet, fall in love with and get to marry a white woman, so he can return to China with her and continue his family’s missionary business. Only he’s so naïve about big-city ways (not only has he not been out of China in 20 years, he hasn’t been out of that tiny village so phenomena like telephones, radio and cars are still completely new to him) he ends up in an altercation with a cab driver, who says his ride will be “two bucks,” to which he replies, “I don’t have any bucks. Can I pay you in dollars?” The driver says it will be three dollars, though later thinks better of it and gives Cobb back the extra dollar. Cobb has a box full of valuable gold coins from China which he gives for safekeeping to virtually the first person he meets and befriends, political boss Jake Mayo (George Barbier), head of the phony “reform” movement. Though I’d assumed the box would feature prominently at the end as the plot resolved itself, it’s never heard from again and instead, with the minister Cobb had come to see running as the “reform” candidate for mayor and then dropping dead just two days before the election, Mayo hits on the idea of having Cobb replace him because Cobb is such a naïf he won’t stand a chance of being elected. Cobb, whose whole purpose there is to marry and then skedaddle back to China as soon as he’s hitched, is just fine with the idea of losing. He ends up at a boardinghouse and meets a cigar-counter staffer, Pet Pratt (Una Merkel), to whom he’s attracted, only he makes a ridiculously sexist speech about how he thinks he’s going to have a hard time finding a wife in the U.S. because American women are not properly subservient to men the way Chinese women are. He’s taken to a nightclub and instantly falls for the singer in their floor show, Dolores Doce (Grace Bradley), because she’s singing a song called “I’m Just That Way” by Harry Akst (composer of “Am I Blue?”) and Roy Turk that does express the deference he feels women should have towards men — even though, as we already know, she’s not really like that at all: she’s a paid vamp in the service of the political machine.

Outside the club Cobb sees the machine’s mayor, Ed Morgan (played by the marvelously slimy villain of Supernatural and A Study in Scarlet, Alan Dinehart) push a newsboy, and is so angered he hauls off and hits Morgan. The papers get pictures and play up the story, and all of a sudden Cobb goes from being doomed “cat’s-paw” to Mayor-elect. Once in office he starts vetoing the carefully crafted bills the machine has pushed through the City Council to award lucrative city contracts to “protected” companies, and he demands the resignation of police commissioner Moriarty (Frank Sheridan) — naturally I joked, thinking of Professor Moriarty in the Sherlock Holmes stories, that he had to ask for Moriarty’s resignation once he found out he was on the other side — and appoints Mayo to replace him on the it-takes-a-thief-to-catch-a-thief principle. Only the machine strikes back by having Dolores demand a favor from Cobb — he’s to put an envelope containing her personal papers in his safe-deposit box — and when the district attorney (another Morgan stooge) demands that the box be opened, there is the envelope, which contains shares of stock in the non-corrupt public transit company to which Cobb gave the city’s contract after vetoing the award to Morgan’s company. Cobb is indicted for corruption and the state’s governor announces he’s going to use his power under the state constitution to remove Cobb as mayor — so Cobb hatches a plan to fight back by ordering the police to “arrest” every gangster and grafter in Stockport and hold them illegally in the basement of his friend, Chinese merchant Tien Wang (Fred Warren). There he will threaten them with beheading, using a Chinese ceremonial sword once wielded by a local official in ancient China who did the same thing — illegally executing all the crooks in town and then offering the Emperor his own head as punishment. Of course he doesn’t really kill anybody — though he does wheel two apparently headless corpses through the basement just to show the crooks what he has in store for them, they’re actually a trick made up by Tien Wang, who in his previous career was internationally famous Chinese stage magician Chang — but he does panic the crooks into writing and signing confessions of their misdeeds. In the final tag scene, Cobb and Pet (short for “Petunia,” a name she couldn’t stand) are getting married but arguing where they will live, with he insisting that he still has work to do in Stockport and she saying they have to go back to China immediately.

The Cat’s-Paw is hardly the sort of film one associates with Harold Lloyd today — though late in life Lloyd disgustedly told an interview, “I made only six thrill pictures, and those are the only ones anybody remembers!” — even though Lloyd was the only one of the major male silent comedians to make a fully successful transition from silent to sound and continue his career without a break. (Chaplin didn’t try — though his 1930’s films City Lights and Modern Times are less silents than what Eisenstein called “sound films,” as distinct from talkies: movies which avoided dialogue but used carefully crafted music and sound effects to tell their stories and heighten their emotional content — while Keaton and Langdon both lost their independence around the same time sound came in and were done in by personal problems as well.) The Cat’s-Paw seems strongly premonitory of Frank Capra’s social dramas (most of which hadn’t been made yet even though 1934 was also the year Capra established himself as a star director with It Happened One Night) and even has a direct Capra connection: it’s based on a novel of the same name by Clarence Budington Kelland, who also wrote “Opera Hat,” the story on which Capra and writer Robert Riskin based Mr. Deeds Goes to Town. The Cat’s Paw was both written and directed by Sam Taylor, the infamous filmmaker who not only directed the Douglas Fairbanks-Mary Pickford The Taming of the Shrew but got his name on the writing credits as well: “By William Shakespeare. Additional dialogue by Sam Taylor.” (Alexander Walker pointed out that the film wasn’t based on the original play but on David Garrick’s rewrite, Katharine and Petruchio, so it probably had some of Garrick’s “additional dialogue,” too.) According to imdb.com, Taylor had help both writing and directing this film — in the writing department from Clyde Bruckman, longtime gag man for both Lloyd and Keaton; and in the directing department from Lloyd himself — but it’s still a quite capable piece of filmmaking, full of marvelously atmospheric shots that almost approach film noir and one scene in particular that had both Charles and I shaking our heads. It occurs about 1 hour and 20 minutes into a 1 hour, 42-minute movie, and it’s a montage of the various gangsters and crooks in town getting pulled in by Lloyd’s semi-authorized vigilantes: just after we’ve seen a glimpse of a wild party with the gangsters and suitably “loose” women, we see another shot in the back room of a gym, with one of the gangsters pinched as he’s giving a wrestler a massage, and the hint is unmistakable that Lloyd’s dragnet is busting straight and Queer gangsters alike.

The Cat’s-Paw is one of Lloyd’s most unusual films but also one of his best, and he settled on it as story material after he’d spent two fruitless years looking for material as good as his immediately previous film, Movie Crazy. He stumbled on Kelland’s The Cat’s-Paw when the writer had only got as far as chapter one, and offered to buy the rights if Kelland would take suggestions on how to work out the later chapters to make the character more suitable for Harold Lloyd. When he got the completed story he called his usual gag men together to do their normal function — to spot places in the script where Lloyd could do his famous slapstick and thrill-comedy sequences — but ultimately the gag men weren’t able to find any “holes” in the script to insert Lloyd’s typical funny business, so he took director Taylor’s suggestion and shot the film relatively “straight,” getting its humor from character and situations rather than elaborate physical gags. The Cat’s-Paw suffers from some of the usual racial stereotypes, including the portrayal of Chinese characters by Anglo actors and a wretched whiny Black shoe-shine boy who gets caught up in the dragnet and keeps pouting (there’s no other word for it!) that he doesn’t belong there — he was just shining the shoes of a gangster when he got pinched — but for the most part it’s a surprisingly glum movie. It also contains one of Una Merkel’s best performances, quietly authoritative in the manner of Jean Arthur from Capra’s later masterpieces. The Cat’s-Paw is a forgotten little gem and an illustration that Lloyd wasn’t just a guy who hung off the sides of buildings; indeed, with his face having fattened a bit from his glory days in the silent era, there are some odd close-ups in which he looks remarkably like the young Bob Hope (suggesting that Hope would have been a good choice to remake this) — and its delightful cynicism towards politics and elections came oddly at the end of a night when we’d just been watching the Democratic Presidential candidates debate! — 1/18/16

Sunday, January 17, 2016

Target Earth (Abtcon Pictures, Herman Cohen Productions, Allied Artists, 1954)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The films at last night’s Vintage Sci-Fi series in Golden Hill were quite different on the quality scale and also very different movies — apparently their sole point of commonality, which led the proprietor to schedule them together, was that both featured giant robots as major characters. Of course the program wasn’t just two movies: it also included some movie trailers (including one for the upcoming Batman v. Superman and another from Deadpool, Marvel’s surprisingly scatological spoof of its own superheroes), a couple of bizarre shorts called They’re All Made of Meat (the one he’d shown the night before about two guys from another planet hanging out at a diner and marveling at the fact that everyone on the planet they’ve met so far is made entirely of meat) and Troops (a quite amusing mash-up of the TV show Cops and the Star Wars movies), and a music video of David Bowie singing his song “Space Oddity” — the copyright date was 1969 but this isn’t the version of the song I remember from the early 1970’s, when his Mercury album Man of Words — Man of Music was acquired by RCA Victor (as well as its immediate follow-up, The Man Who Sold the World) and reissued under the title Space Oddity with a cover photo c. 1972. Did the folks at RCA Victor remix it? Were additional string parts added? (There’s a third version Bowie put out at the very end of his RCA Victor contract in 1990, backed with just acoustic guitar, as the flip side of his final RCA Victor release, a wretched cover of Kurt Weill’s “Alabama Song,” drenched in phony cabaret-singer mannerisms that projected the song less well than Jim Morrison’s cool singing on the Doors’ version from 1966.) The night before, the proprietor had shown Bowie’s video of his 1971 song “Life on Mars,” thus paying tribute to this fascinating artist with two of his best songs and ones which actually related to the overall theme of the event.

Of the two feature films shown last night, Target Earth (1954) was actually quite good: though it suffered from a few risible moments, notably when the alien creature (actually a robot, part of an invading army of electromechanical devices controlled from a central location that, as the scientific experts working with the U.S. Army to destroy it, admit, could be a few miles away or millions of miles away on the aliens’ home planet) shows up and it’s a giant white spic-’n’-span contraption looking like the props department made it out of cardboard and spray-painted it just before use. But for the most part it’s a nice, taut suspense tale of five of the usual human flotsam and jetsam in these sorts of dramas — out-of-towner Frank Brooks (Richard Denning), who’s just got in from Detroit (home town of the film’s producer, Herman Cohen); Nora King (Kathleen Crowley), who missed the Army’s evacuation order because she slept through the whole thing — her life had been miserable since her husband’s death in a car accident six months earlier, for which she blamed herself since she’d been driving at the time, and she had determined to O.D. on sleeping pills and end it — barflies Vicki Harris (Virginia Grey, who in a generally quite good cast creates the most indelible characterization) and her boyfriend Jim Wilson (Richard Reeves); as well as Davis (Robert Roark), a psycho killer who enters the action about two-thirds of the way through — waking up to find that their entire city (it’s unidentified but the film was shot in Los Angeles, natch) has been evacuated overnight to get its inhabitants away from some horrible menace that appears to have come from Venus (yes, the planet Venus!) and has taken the form of an invading army of robots who are apparently invulnerable to all human weapons.

Had the story stayed on the five principals and had the Lewtonian stylistics of the opening been maintained throughout, with the alien invader not shown on screen but depicted by sound alone, Target Earth would be an even better film than it is — but it’s still quite good. It’s tightly constructed (the director was Sherman A. Rose and the writing committee included Paul W. Fairman, who wrote the source story, “The Deadly City,” as well as William Raynor, Wyott Ordung — thoroughly redeeming himself from having written Robot Monster — and future American International co-president James A. Nicholson), well directed and well acted; true, Virginia Grey plays the only really multidimensional character and thereby takes the honors, but all the principals acquit themselves well and it seems a shame that in a cast list this good, Richard Denning was the only “name,” then or now, and a movie with several performances that should have turned their creators towards stardom didn’t seem to. In the end, in case you cared, Grey gives her life to save her boyfriend and the two others — who’ve shown a definite attraction to each other in case they decide to try coupling off camera — from the rampage of the psycho, while the Army figures out a way to send radio frequencies that will damage the televisors that are not only the way the robots “see” but also the way they get their relayed instructions from their home world, without which they are helpless since for all their elaborate programming they are essentially blind terminals, and once the Army figures out a way to jam their instructions, they just stop. It’s one of those occasional science-fiction films from the 1950’s that grounded itself in the Middle America of today and sent its fantastical (or historical) nemeses loose in a realistic world — by far the best of these is Don Siegel’s 1956 Invasion of the Body Snatchers, but this one is really quite good and a far cry from what you’d expect from the people who, no matter who released this one (Allied Artists, née Monogram), eventually became the nucleus behind American International Pictures, the studio every moviegoer 20 or older seemed to be able to love to hate.

King Kong Escapes (Toho/Universal, 1967)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Alas, the other film on the program, King Kong Escapes, was pretty lousy. This came about when Toho Studios, who’d made the films starring the second most famous giant monster character in film history, Godzilla, decided to license the rights to the most famous giant monster character in film history, King Kong, for a 1962 movie called, natch, King Kong Meets Godzilla. This was the inevitable follow-up, a 1967 farrago of nonsensical situations called King Kong Escapes in which a scientist has for some reason built a full-sized robot replica of Kong, and the promotion for the film ballyhooed that at the end there’d be a pitched battle between the two. The plot, if you can call it that, concerns a group of good guys in a United Nations research submarine — Commander Carl Nelson (Rhodes Reason, who in an imdb.com “trivia” post is quoted as saying when he got the script he knew the film would be crap, but accepted it anyway because it meant a free trip to Japan); Lieutenant Susan Watson (Linda Miller, who for some reason was not allowed to voice her own part when the film was dubbed from Japanese to English even though she was an American and therefore a native English speaker); and Lieutenant Commander Jiro Nomura (Akira Takarada), who end up on “Mondo Island” in search of the legendary Kong so they can study him scientifically; and a bunch of bad guys — Dr. Who (no, not the one in the famous British TV series!), played onscreen by Hideyo Amamoto in rice-powder makeup and a Dracula cape but voiced in the English version by almost too-well-known voice actor Paul Frees (who’d also dubbed for Toshiro Mifune when he appeared in English-language films) and Madame X (Mie Hama) — who was called “Madame Piranha” in the original version — who’s from a carefully unnamed country anxious to obtain a super-powerful material called “Element X” that can power their private nuclear-weapons program and make them invincible.

Only Madame X and Dr. Who keep having arguments because Madame X wants results, not excuses, and is impatient with the delays and problems Dr. Who keeps running into. In order to mine the Element X successfully and without risking their own lives and those of their henchmen (that’s how they’re identified in the cast list), they first steal the robot Kong and send him into the cave containing the world’s only known supply of the stuff. Only the robot is soon incapacitated by a “magnetic mass” in the underground mine (and I couldn’t help but joke to Charles, “Which part of the magnetic Mass is the problem — the magnetic Kyrie, the magnetic Gloria or the magnetic Credo?”) and so the baddies figure they have to abduct the real Kong from Mondo Island (in the original 1933 King Kong it was called “Skull Island” and in the authorized sequel, Son of Kong, it was destroyed when an undersea earthquake sank it, but who’s counting?) and put him in the mine. They do that — the scene in which they cuff each of Kong’s limbs to one of four helicopters and fly him off the island is cool, even though the copters themselves look like props they bought at the Tokyo Woolworth’s that morning — and they hypnotize Kong into being their slave and mining the stuff even though the radiation is going to kill him within a day or two. Only the Element X deposits are themselves so sparkly they de-hypnotize him. The good guys trace Kong to (where else?) Tokyo, and since both sides know that Lt. Watson has a lot of influence over Kong (he’s fallen for her the way he did for Fay Wray’s character in the original film), they attempt to use her to get Kong to do their bidding. She and Commander Nelson end up imprisoned on the bad guys’ ship, but they escape and the real Kong and the robot Kong end up in a duel to the death that’s a lot less interesting than it could have been since they’ve both climbed a huge TV transmission tower and therefore, like the hero and villain of Quentin Durward, have to fight with only one hand because they’re using the other to hang on.

Before that Kong (the real one) takes on a nondescript killer dinosaur called Gorosaurus in a sequence that’s the best thing in the film by a long shot: director Inoshirô Honda copies the fight between Kong and the T. Rex from the 1933 film almost exactly, down to Kong gently setting Watson on one of the branches of a tree before he does battle — though, alas, Honda and his effects people did not use the charming strategy of Willis O’Brien in making Kong approach the fight like a human prizefighter, blocking, feinting and punching while the monster just charges. Honda does have this Kong kill the monster the way the original Kong dispatched the T. Rex — by grabbing its mouth and bending its jaws so they snapped and broke apart. There’s a later sequence in which Kong attacks and kills a sea serpent, and at the end, after he’s thrown the mechani-Kong off the TV tower (and the robot has broken into pieces upon landing), the real Kong stomps out the baddies’ ship before heading home across the ocean (though he’s so tall it looks more like a wading pool for him) to return to Mondo Island and the natives who, like their forebears in the original film, worship him as a god. King Kong Escapes is silly in all the ways you’d expect and a few you might not — Paul Frees is so associated with cartoons it’s hard to take him seriously even playing a black-hearted villain (he voiced a villain wonderfully as Meowrice Percy Beaucoup in Gay Purr-Ee, but at least that was a comic villain) — and apparently the U.S. version was produced by Universal in association witih the Rankin-Bass cartoon company, which had made an animated TV series of King Kong in which he’s being trundled around the South Pacific on a raft towed by a ship — a hint dropped in the original film in which Carl Denham (Robert Armstrong) decides he’ll ship Kong back to the U.S. by building a raft his ship, the Venture, can tow — and in each episode Kong got off the raft and into some presumably exciting adventure. (I haven’t watched any of the King Kong cartoons in ages but I still remember the theme song: “King Kong/You know the name of King Kong/You know the fame of King Kong/Ten times as big as a man.”) Apparently Rankin-Bass Productions bought the U.S. rights for this one and assigned them to Universal to get publicity for the Kong “brand” that would help their animated TV show — even though my dim recollection is that the TV shows were not only U.S.-produced, they were considerably better than this lame, unexciting movie.

Saturday, January 16, 2016

Mars Movie Night, January 15, 2016: “The Deadly Ray from Mars” (Universal, 1938) and “Rocketship X-M” (Lippert, 1950)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night’s program at the Mars film screening was one of the proprietor’s mixed bags: The Deadly Ray from Mars, a cut-down feature-length version of the 1938 serial Flash Gordon’s Trip to Mars (shown in a tacky download that omitted all the credits to cast and crew); the quite compelling 1950 movie Rocketship X-M; a My Favorite Martian episode called “There Is No Cure for the Common Martian” (in which Ray Walston’s Martian character gets a cold and the virus affects him in unexpected ways; he can’t retract his antennae without causing himself incredible pain, and every time he sneezes he becomes invisible and doesn’t return to visibility until he sneezes again — there’s also a Miracle on 34th Street knockoff scene in which Bill Bixby’s character is assigned to report on an outer-space toy display and Martin, finishing his review for him à la Citizen Kane, comments on all the show’s inaccuracies, including the Polynesian knick-knack appearance of the “Martian” on display there; this show is pretty tackily produced overall but the young Bixby was attractive and I’ve always loved Walston’s dry wit); a few trailers for upcoming movies (including a Marvel parody called, I think, Deadpool, a scatological comedy about a reluctant, to say the least, superhero); and a bizarre seven-minute short in which two aliens (one of whom is dressed in a costume like the uniforms the Beatles wore on the Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band cover) visit an Earth-like planet and comment that the local inhabitants are entirely made of meat — “even their brains are meat,” they say disgustedly (which couldn’t help but remind me of virologist Peter Duesberg’s comment that “to a virus, we are just 73 kilograms of meat”). I already commented on these movies when Charles and I watched them before — we hadn’t seen the cut-down version of the Flash Gordon serial but my comment on the complete serial is at http://moviemagg.blogspot.com/2010/09/flash-gordons-trip-to-mars-universal.html, while my review of Rocketship X-M is at http://moviemagg.blogspot.com/2009/06/rocketship-x-m-lippert-1950.html — so there’s not much more I need to add.

The Deadly Ray from Mars (whose title is given on the imdb.com page for the serial as Mars Attacks the World; an imdb.com “trivia” poster claims the feature version was rushed out by Universal to take advantage of the publicity surrounding Orson Welles’ famous radio broadcast of H. G. Wells’ The War of the Worlds in October 1938) is actually a pretty good condensation of the 15-episode original, though the fact that it was a serial is quite obvious from the start-and-stop nature of the action and the way it keeps building to false climaxes (even with the cliff-hanger episode endings integrated with their resolutions) and lurching forward through bits of off-handed exposition just to get to the next action scene. I missed the gimmick of the Clay People’s healing mist (the serial features quite a few scenes in which people are locked in rooms and subjected to various gases for both good and ill, though the healing mist’s deletion means all the gases in the feature version are toxic) and the scene in which Jean Rogers as Dale Arden briefly becomes an action heroine herself (in this she anticipates Princess Leia in the first Star Wars and underscores the strong resemblance between the properties — indeed, George Lucas’s producing partner on the first Star Wars, Gary Kurtz, once told the Los Angeles Times that Lucas’s first plan had been to do a Flash Gordon remake and it was only because the Hearst Corporation, whose King Features Syndicate subsidiary owned the rights to Alex Raymond’s characters and regained control of the serials from Universal in 1951, asked for so much money for the rights that Lucas decided to develop something similar but “original” instead), but for the most part the feature retains the highlights of the serial, including at least two of the marvelous scenes in which the Clay People, ordinary Martians turned to stone (though still animate) by the evil magic of Martian Queen Azura’s white sapphire, detach themselves from the clay walls of the caves in which they dwell and start walking around. My comments on Rocketship X-M this time around are also similar to those from the last time, including the progressive political content — it seems that the spacecraft in Rocketship X-M was originally aimed at the moon but due to a combination of navigation errors and space accidents it ends up going to Mars instead, and Mars was once the home of a highly advanced civilization which did itself in via nuclear war, and this is presented as a warning to Earth and its people not to do the same thing — and the surprisingly good production, direction, writing and cast for a 1950 “indie.”

Rocketship X-M originally began as a story idea from writer-director Kurt Neumann, who wanted to make a film about a space flight to Mars, where the astronauts would encounter living dinosaurs. He took it to producer Robert Lippert, who essentially told him to forget it — his budget wouldn’t allow them to do dinosaurs or create an artificial planet (though Lippert did a dino-movie just one year later, King Dinosaur, using living lizards photographed on miniature sets to represent the dinosaurs unconvincingly). Then, when producer George Pal announced plans to film Robert A. Heinlein’s Destination Moon, Lippert called Neumann back in and said that if he’d rewrite his script so the astronauts went to the moon instead of Mars, he’d produce it. Only George Pal got wind of this project and, correctly reading it as an exploitation venture aimed at getting a film about a moon flight into theatres before his, announced he’d sue anyone who came out with a movie about a trip to the moon before Destination Moon. So Lippert called Neumann back, and Neumann suggested that they avoid Pal’s ukase by simply having their rocket diverted from the moon to Mars, where he’d wanted to set his story in the first place. The result was a quite good movie, well acted (especially by Lloyd Bridges and Osa Massen in the leads — Massen is an expert chemist who has designed the rocket’s propulsion system and in her opening close-ups she looks strikingly, and appropriately, like the young Katharine Hepburn, though she speaks with a foreign accent about midway between Marlene Dietrich’s and Ingrid Bergman’s), suspensefully directed by Neumann, with the Martian scenes tinted a kind of rust-red to make the “Martian” locations (actually Death Valley) look more like the “Red Planet.” The version shown last night was Wade Williams’ re-edited one from 1982, with some actual reshoots to make the rocket launches more convincing and even a few added scenes with doubles replacing the original cast members — and for that version Williams restored the tints of the Mars scenes that hadn’t been used after the original 1950 theatrical release prints. The final irony was that theatre owners who booked this film found they were attracting a lot of moviegoers who’d thought they were buying tickets to Destination Moon and reacted quite unpleasantly when they found they weren’t — so Lippert had to provide signs to the theatres playing the film that announced that it was not Destination Moon!

Friday, January 15, 2016

Inspector George Gently: “Breathe in the Air” (Company Media/BBC-TV, 2015)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2016 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

I watched a quite fascinating episode of Inspector George Gently on KPBS — this was a recent one, “Breathe in the Air,” from 2015, and in many ways the best show I’ve ever seen from this series. The plot deals with the mysterious death of the only woman doctor in Gently’s community of Dunham, Valerie Cullin (Dierdre Mullins), who’s found dead with a needle in her arm. It turns out she was diagnosed with a rare motor neuron disease that was going to kill her in a year or two anyway, and the rest of the police force is willing to write off the death as a suicide — but Gently (Martin Shaw) and his assistants, John Bacchus (the genuinely hot Lee Ingolby, who as I’ve said before looks like he would be a good choice for a biopic of John Lennon) and Rachel Coles (Lisa McGrillis), are convinced there’s something more to it than that. Even when a suicide note surfaces Gently isn’t sure that Valerie actually offed herself — he’s investigating on the theory that her husband killed her and faked it to look like suicide — and eventually he finds that Valerie was treating a number of people who had the rare cancer called mesothelioma. Mesothelioma is a form of cancer that affects smokers and non-smokers equally, and it has only one known cause: exposure to asbestos. It’s probably best known as the disease that killed actor Steve McQueen (who’d worked around asbestos in the U.S. Navy well before he got to Hollywood or took up acting as a career) and as one of the ones the ambulance-chasing lawyers who advertise on TV looking for clients they can represent on a contingency-fee basis are constantly harping on about — until the 1960’s, when the connection between asbestos and mesothelioma was definitively established, asbestos was considered a wonder material because it doesn’t burn, and was therefore routinely used as fireproofing. The British government (at least according to the script for this show, by Peter Flannery) regulated the manufacture of asbestos products as early as 1931, but only in the 1960’s did they pass a law extending those regulations to the end users of the stuff.

It turns out that Valerie’s husband Andrew (Jason Done) was working as a doctor for the public health service in the Dunham area but was more interested in protecting the interests of the Swiss company that had bought the Dunham asbestos plant than doing his job to keep the workers safe, and he had taken over from a previous doctor who had built up evidence that the high cancer rate in Dunham was being caused by the plant but agreed to suppress it to protect his pension income against the efforts of the Swiss company and their “friends” in high office in Britain to take it away. Eventually it turns out that Valerie Cullen did indeed kill herself — but only because she found out her husband was not only unsupportive of her efforts to expose the company’s lethal practices but had actually gone over to the dark side, not only sucking up to the company but actually having an affair with one of its board members, Anna Zweig (Susy Kane), so he’s not only figuratively but literally in bed with corrupt capitalism. An imdb.com reviewer complained that the episode was anachronistic in that “Gently appears to be a politically correct figure from the 21st Century who has been transplanted back into the 1960’s” — a complaint I’ve had about some of the previous episodes in this series, but not this one: writer Flannery seems to have struck a marvelous balance in creating a story in which the growth of the characters’ awareness not only of environmental degradation and corporate corruption but the equality of women as well (Bacchus begins the episode making sneering comments about Rachel’s demands for equal treatment on the force, and ends it welcoming her participation in the investigation) seems to parallel the overall social maturation of at least some people’s thinking on these issues — and there’s also a chilling plot twist in that Rachel turns out to have had a childhood friend with whom she played on the factory grounds, each putting asbestos dust on the other’s face to make them look like Snow White, and her friend died of mesothelioma at 15 and leaves Rachel to wonder whether she too will get the dreaded cancer. Though redolent of some of the Law and Order franchise shows with their similar wish-fulfillment fantasies of some particularly repulsive member of the 1 percent actually being held to account for their crimes, “Breathe in the Air” is a quite good show, genuinely moving emotionally as well as exciting in that peculiarly understated way of the best British mysteries.