Monday, August 28, 2017

The Other Mother (MarVista Entertainment/Lifetime, 2017)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

At 6 p.m. last night Lifetime re-ran a movie I’d missed on its original go-round, The Other Mother (this was around the same time — last April — they were also showing films called The Wrong Mother and Killer Mom), actually a better-than-average thriller centered around four people: Jackie (Annie Wersching), her teenage daughter Brooke (Kennedy Tucker), Jackie’s ex-husband (and Brooke’s father) Mitch (Tyler Christopher), and Tiffany (Kimberley Crossman), the impossibly perky blonde bimbo Mitch has just married. Mitch met her on a summer trip to France on which he’d taken Brooke, who’s been majoring in French in high school and wanted to spend the summer there to hone her linguistic skills and see the fabled sights of Paris (when she mentioned having been on the Champs-Élysée I couldn’t help but remember Red Buttons’ hilarious fracturing of the name in the film Gay Purr-Ee: “Ah, the Champs Ulysses?”) — only now she wants to drop French and take Spanish instead because she wants to cruise Beau (Lou Wegner), the hot young man she’s got her sights set on, and he’s in that class. This is just one of the flash points that arise between Jackie and Brooke, who’s being pushed by Tiffany to be more independent and stand up to her almost neurotically controlling mother (it’s clear screenwriter Eric Martin wants us to admire Jackie and see her as a responsible parent, but she’s way overdoing it). It turns out the real reason Jackie has become so domineering was that the year before Brooke had been involved in an accident where she got drunk and got behind the wheel of a car even though she didn’t know how to drive — and since then Jackie has run her daughter’s life like a concentration-camp commandant and, among other things, forbidden her from even thinking about learning to drive. So Jackie is infuriated that Tiffany is ready not only to give Brooke driving lessons but to present her with a red sports car as a present once she gets her license. The Other Mother is yet another one of those Lifetime movies that could have been really interesting and moving if its creators, writer Martin and director Sean Olson, had known when to stop; if they’d just kept it a story about a single mom and her teenage daughter and made the central conflict the one between the responsible but over-controlling mother and the stepmom who bops into their lives and seems willing to indulge the daughter’s every rebellious wish, this could have been really good, but no-o-o-o-o

They had to make Tiffany a total psycho — if Christine Conradt had written this she probably would have called it The Perfect Stepmother (a title imdb.com doesn’t list, so it’s presumably available) — who latches on to middle-aged men with money and teenage kids (the last time she did this she called herself “Mary Smith” and got jealous of her husband Greg, played by John Littlefield, over his continued attachment to his son, and ultimately she burned Greg’s house down, killed his son and disappeared, to turn up again and latch onto Mitch), marries them and then gets upset with them because they still feel more committed to their kids than to her. “It’s always the little brats that get in the way,” she says during the big confrontation between her, Jackie and Brooke at the end in which Tiffany goes up against Brooke with a knife, intending to stab her and eliminate the competition, only Jackie sneaks up behind her with a tire iron and wallops her. Tiffany rallies long enough to club Mitch with a frying pan, and later she stabs him, but fortunately the police arrive in time to call an ambulance for Mitch and save his life (and the coda, “Five Months Later,” indicates that Mitch and Jackie have reconciled and are back together following his ordeal with the bimbo). However, Tiffany escapes, presumably to replay the same scenario with another man and his child — why, one wonders, doesn’t she just seek out a man who doesn’t have a kid already? After The Other Mother I watched about an hour of an even sillier Lifetime movie, a “premiere” called Unwritten Obsession, a reversal of the crazy-stalker-fan trope in which writer Skye Chaste (Haley Webb) has written a best-selling novel about a character called Maya, only her publisher and her agent have rejected her second book; at a book signing she meets Holly (Chelsea Lopez), an intense fan and also an aspiring writer who wants advice from Skye on her own book, only instead of doing the crazed-stalker-fan number director David Martin Porms and writer Marcy Holland do the desperate-writer-rips-off-the-manuscript-of-an-unknown-and-passes-it-off-as-hers number. I turned this off in midstream because there was something on another channel I was more interested in, which turned out to be a wise move.