Thursday, July 16, 2020

Game of Thrones, season five, episodes five and six: “Kill the Boy,” “Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken” (Startling TV, TV 360°, Bighead Littlehead, HBO, 2015)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2020 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

I put on the next two episodes of season five of Game of Thrones, “Kill the Boy” (episode five) and “Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken” (episode six). Once again switching from MS-NBC to Game of Thrones only underscored what a perfect story this is for the Trump era: a saga with no heroes, just a bunch of opportunists all out for themselves, seeking power not for any idealistic reasons (the one character who actually shows any idealism, nominal King Tommen Baratheon, is played by Dean-Charles Chapman and is depicted as a pathetic wimp who’s only being kept alive by his powerful and unscrupulous mother, Cersei Lannister, played by Lena Headey) but just to have it. Though it’s nominally set in the distant past rather than the near-future, Game of Thrones is a good illustration of George Orwell’s maxim that humanity’s future is “a boot stamping on a human face — forever.” There’s no one in the dramatis personae we really like — though there are a few people in Game of Thrones, like Tyrion Lannister (Peter Dinklage in the role every little-person actor who’s ever lived probably dreamed of: a complex, multidimensional character who can do the most outrageously evil things and retain his roguish bad-boy charm) and the female knight Brienne of Tarth (Gwendoline Christie, whose six-foot height no doubt makes her difficult to cast but she’s ideal here), for whom we have a grudging admiration for their survival skills. As before I’m reproducing the imdb.com synopses of these episodes, this time with bracketed, italicized notes I wrote immediately after seeing them to keep important details in my memory, because the biggest single problem with Game of Thrones is how many different plot threads original author George R. R. Martin and his adapters, David Benioff and D. B. Weiss (who got Martin to sell the rights to his books, a cycle collectively known as A Song of Ice and Fire of which the first book in the series is called A Game of Thrones — oddly Martin still hasn’t finished the last two books in the cycle so Benioff and Weiss had to come up with their own ending to the saga, which got roundly criticized when it was originally shown, though given how impermanent anyone’s hold on power is in this story it’s impossible to imagine a truly permanent ending), try to keep going at once. Charles is also upset at how many plot threads have simply got dropped and apparently forgotten about by the writers —though that doesn’t mean they won’t suddenly reappear: Game of Thrones is full of the sorts of moments Anna Russell made fun of in her legendary parody of Wagner’s Ring of the Nibelung: “Ya remember ___________ ?” Anyway, here are the bare facts of what happened in episodes five and six:

Kill the Boy: In Meereen, Daenerys has to decide how to deal with the former masters after the death of Ser Barristan Selmy and the injuries inflicted on Grey Worm. She decides to round up the heads of the 13 richest families in the city and introduce them to her dragons [who burn and eat two of them]. Jorah Mormont and Tyrion Lannister approach the ancient city of Valyria and, after witnessing something quite incredible [a flying adult dragon], they are set upon by the Stone Men, and Mormont does not escape unscathed. Sansa finally sees what has become of Theon, courtesy of Ramsay Bolton's jealous mistress Melisandre. [Theon has been brainwashed to forget who he is and goes by the name “Reek.”] Ramsay is particularly cruel to Theon at a dinner, much to Roose Bolton's displeasure. At Castle Black, Jon Snow tries to convince Tormund Giantsbane to move his people south of the Wall and settle in lands that will be made available to them. Most of the men of the Watch object to the plan.

Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken: Arya is tested by Jaqen H'ghar in the House of Black and White and he tells that she is ready to become someone else. Tyrion and Jorah have a conversation about Daenerys and Jorah's father and how he was murdered by his own men; out of the blue, they are captured by pirates and turned into slaves. Little Finger stumbles with Lancel in King's Landing and has a meeting with Cersei and he plots against Stannis Baratheon and the Bolton. Jamie and Bronn are riding in Dornes and they meet Myrcella; however they need to fight against the Sand Snakes. Lady Olenna meets with Cersei to discuss the future of Loras Tyrell. He is judged by the High Sparrow and Margaery Tyrell is involved and arrested with her brother to a formal trial [because Loras is Gay and Margaery lied when she said she had no idea of this]. Sansa marries Ramsay Bolton and he humiliates her [by making Reek watch them on their wedding night and apparently raping her in the ass].


In case you were wondering, the title of the “Kill the Boy” episode doesn’t actually refer to killing a boy — though there’s been enough bloodshed in these shows one could readily imagine it would — but to the advice Jon Snow (Kit Harington) gets from one of the old sages that abound in this story (even though he’s put another one to death at the end of one of the previous episodes: he killed the leader of the Wildings, a human tribe on the other side of the Wall separating the seven kingdoms of “Westeros” from the White Walkers, a tribe of ghosts who live north of the Wall and survive, like George Romero’s zombies, on eating people; though Jon had him burned at the stake he alao fired an arrow into him, which I thought was a coup de grace and a quasi-merciful attempt to spare him from being burned alive … though as I pointed out in my comments on the last two episodes, being burned at the stake was actually a relatively humane way of execution since you’d die from smoke inhalation before the flames burned your body; however, homosexuals were considered so especially evil that instead of being burned at the stake they were bound and tied up, then thrown directly on the flames with the fire logs, which is how the term “faggots,” which originally meant fire logs, got to be a derisive slang term for Gay men. This time Jon and the new/old advisor decide to offer the Wildings safe passage, asylum and settlements inside the south on the other side of the wall, even though the Night’s Watch tribe Jon is supposed to be leading and the Wildings have been attacking and killing each other for centuries. (The script frames it as an interesting parallel to the long-standing religious conflicts in Northern Ireland and how difficult it was to frame a peace agreement there and get it to stick despite all the long-standing enmity and bloodshed between the sides.) 

The advisor says that Jon should proclaim this policy and deal with the hostile reactions to “kill the boy” inside him and let the man come forth. As in the previous two episodes, though, the most interesting plot line of this one is the “High Sparrow” cult Cersei Lannister encouraged and then quickly spiraled out of her control (sort of like the Dowager Empress of China at the turn of the last century, who originally sponsored the Boxer Rebellion as a way of controlling the claims the Western powers who had claimed more and more authority over nominally independent China, then had to turn towards the West to save herself and her imperial regime from the Boxers) and the McCarthy-ite way the High Sparrow’s agents ramp up the witchhunt until it ensnares the woman who’s at least nominally the Queen of Westeros (but of whom Cersei is fiercely jealous because she threatens Cersei’s control over her son, nominal king Tommen). There’s also an interesting plot line involving Tyrion Lannister, who isn’t as interesting a character when he’s on the outs fighting just to survive than he was on the “ins” manipulating the others at the royal court and indulging himself with wine and women. In the previous episodes he was captured by Jorah Mormont, who is (or at least is representing himself to be) an agent of Daenerys Trageryan (Emilia Clarke) and is taking Tyrion to Daenerys in a two-person boat when they’re menaced first by the Stone Men and then by slavers. Jonah warns Tyrion not to let the Stone Men touch him as they fend off the Stone Men’s attacks — we get the impression that they will actually turn to stone if a Stone Man touches them (a rare bit of the supernatural in a story that for all its brutality and typical fantasy-like unbelievability has mostly at least stayed within the normal laws of biology and physics, except for those damned White Walker characters), though that actually happens to Tyrion he seems to survive with no lasting ill effects. 

Then when their boat is shipwrecked because of the Stone Men’s attack they end up on a shore where they’re set upon by a slaving party — and I loved the irony that in this story the slavers were Black and the people they’re trying to enslave were white! Tyrion, with the gift of gab and the utter unscrupulous that’s made his lovable-rogue character work through the entire series (as opposed to the hatable rogues that make up most of Game of Thronesdramatis personae), talks the Black captain out of killing him and slicing off his cock for sale (apparently a little-person’s dick was the Game of Thrones era’s equivalent of Viagra) by saying the only way anyone can be sure it’s a little-person’s member is if it’s sliced off in their presence. When the leader of the slaving party says that they can tell it’s a little-person’s dick because it’s correspondingly little, Tyrion smiles and winks with Peter Dinklage’s most charmingly hypocritical smile and wink and says something on the order of, “You couldn’t be more wrong.” Game of Thrones is alternately entertaining and maddening, and as I keep saying it’s a perfect story for the Trump-era Zeitgeist because the characters (with only a few rare exceptions) are so utterly amoral and driven by a lust for power for its own sake (as well as “lust” in the non-metaphorical meaning of the term) they fully live up to the denunciation of both Donald Trump his father Fred as “sociopaths” in the new book Too Much and Never Enough by Mary Trump, Donald’s niece. Game of Thrones mirrors the Trump family’s creed and its valuation of strength and power as the manly virtues, while compassion and empathy are the qualities of suckers and creeps. If Donald Trump belongs anywhere, it’s on the Iron Throne, not in the White House as the powerful but constitutionally constrained ruler of a republic; one wishes we could consign Trump to the fictional world of Martin, Benioff and Weiss and restore a measure of sanity to the real one!