Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Don't Talk (MGM, 1942)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

After Slander on Saturday, November 14 Turner Classic Movies showed a film in MGM’s Crime Does Not Pay series called Don’t Talk (1942). Eddie Muller’s immediately previous “Noir Alley” showing of the film Breakdown (1952) had been succeeded by another Crime Does Not Pay short, The Public Pays, which had been relatively dull (it was about an extortion racket targeting dairies in a fictional Midwestern city). The genesis of Crime Does Not Pay, which ran from 1935 to 1947, is interesting; it began as The Inquiring Reporter, a series of fake newsreels commissioned by MGM production chief Irving Thalberg to sandbag the Democratic gubernatorial candidacy of socialist writer Upton Sinclair in 1934. The “newsreels” were supposed “person on the street” interviews with respectable people ostensibly supporting Sinclair’s Republican opponent, Frank Merriam, and homeless bums who were allegedly about to flood into California once Sinclair was elected to take advantage of the largesse he was promising. (It’s fascinating that Right-wing propaganda has changed so little over the years; remember that Donald Trump has more than once claimed that the U.S. is threatened by so-called “caravans” of immigrants crashing into the country to take jobs and benefits away from “real Americans.”) After The Inquiring Reporter had served its purpose – Merriam beat Sinclair in the 1934 election – Thalberg green-lit a series of shorts with a similar approach and called it Crime Does Not Pay, which ran until 1947. It served the purpose of giving new talent just signed by MGM important experience in front of the cameras – Robert Taylor, star of the first Crime Does Not Pay short, Buried Loot (1935), later became a huge star and a mainstay of MGM – and on at least one occasion a Crime Does Not Pay short, They’re Always Caught (1938), was remade at “B”-feature length as Kid Glove Killer (1942).

Don’t Talk was a timely warning about how even the most seemingly innocuous quasi-public conversations in restaurants and beauty shops could give away wartime secrets that the enemy could take advantage of. Directed by Joseph M. Newman (who’d later become a contract director at Universal and make, among other films, the 1955 science-fiction classic This Island Earth) from a script by Alan Friedman, Don’t Talk is especially interesting not only for the central premise but also for the very interesting actress who plays the principal spy. She’s Gloria Holden, whose terrific performance in the title role of Universal’s horror classic Dracula’s Daughter (1936) should have made her a major star. Unfortunately, Dracula’s Daughter was made at the tail end of the original Universal horror cycle, when Carl Laemmle and his son Carl, Jr. were about to lose control of the studio to a hedge fund run by a man named J. Cheever Cowdin, and Cowdin and his newly installed production chief, Charles Rogers, decided horror films were “out” and Deanna Durbin musicals were “in.” Holden mostly played character roles thereafter, though she’s easily the most interesting cast member in Don’t Talk. She works as a waitress at the Elite Café, across the street from a major factory producing gear assemblies for military vehicles. Most of the workers at the factory eat lunch at the Elite Café, and Holden’s character, a Turkish refugee named Beulah Binvicko who uses the Americanized name “Beulah Anderson,” seems to have ears like antennae. She’s tuned in on any bit of gossip, no matter how seemingly innocuous, that she can use to relay her Axis spymasters so they can target the factory’s products for sabotage.

The Axis spy ring, which among other things has foreknowledge of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor two weeks before it famously happened on December 7, 1941, is run out of a local beauty parlor run by a man named Anatole (Harry Worth). Among Beulah’s assignments at the Elite Café is posting the menu in the café’s front window, and doing so in code so the spies can glean her information from where the letters are arranged in the signboard. The good guys in this one are FBI agents Jack Sampson (Donald Douglas) and Freed (Barry Nelson, later the first actor to play James Bond in the 1954 Climax! TV episode “Casino Royale”), though in a well-done final chase scene the villains run their car off the road and hold them at gunpoint until they’re able to turn the tables on them (absurdly easily) and preserve the precious shipment of gear parts (which we’re told had to be hand-machined, so their destruction by saboteurs would delay war production of a particularly important item by about a month or two). One quirk in the plotting is that, realizing the bad guys have learned the gears are to be shipped out by train, the good guys have the shipment re-routed to go by truck instead. Only one of the truck drivers sprains his hand loading them onto the truck and shows up at the Elite Café with his hand bandaged. He calls his wife at their home to let her know what happened to him – and Beulah overhears his phone call and thus learns that the gears are going to be shipped by trucks instead. So the bad guys plant bombs on a bridge along the route intending to set them off and blow up the trucks as they’re crossing the bridge, and the driver who inadvertently let out the secret panics when he learns what’s going on. “My son is driving one of those trucks!” he bursts out at the FBI agents as he lets them know what route the trucks are going to take and pleads with them to stop the saboteurs before they can blow up the trucks and kill his son. Don’t Talk was an obvious propaganda movie, but it was also surprisingly well made and genuinely suspenseful.