Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Slander (MGM, 1956, released 1957)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last Saturday, November 14 my husband Charles and I watched a quite interesting if ultimately frustrating film on Eddie Muller’s “Noir Alley” program on Turner Classic Movies. It was called Slander and was filmed in 1956 but released in 1957. Directed by Roy Rowland from a script by Jerome Weidman based on a CBS-TV show called A Public Figure by Harry W. Junkin, Slander is a thinly veiled portrait of the real Hollywood scandal magazine Confidential. The Wikipedia page on the real Confidential suggests that there’s a much better potential movie in its actual story than the one we got here (though given that Confidential was still alive and very much near the peak of its power when Slander was made, it’s quite obvious why the filmmakers had to tread gingerly around it). Confidential was launched in 1952 by publisher Robert Harrison, who’d got his start working for Bernarr MacFadden on the New York Evening Graphic, a pioneering tabloid that blazed the trail a lot of its successors took, selling papers with sleazy stories about major celebrities. When the Depression killed the Graphic, Harrison moved on to Hollywood both literally and figuratively, taking a job with the Motion Picture Herald, run by Martin Quigley, a hard-core Roman Catholic and one of the authors of the Motion Picture Production Code. During his tenure with the Herald, Harrison collected a number of sexually suggestive but not outright pornographic photos of women in or aspiring to be in the movies. He started a series of magazines to showcase such photos, including Beauty Parade and five others, but drew the line at outright nudity. Realizing that his business model was being threatened by the advent of Hugh Hefner’s Playboy, which famously did feature nudes (Playboy’s first “Playmate of the Month” was Marilyn Monroe; Hefner had acquired the rights to the nude calendar shot Monroe had modeled for in 1949), Harrison decided to launch a new magazine that would do the same sort of star scandal-mongering MacFadden had done at the Evening Graphic. He called it Confidential and it was an instant hit.
To run Confidential Harrison hired an editor with an even weirder background than his: Howard Rushmore. Rushmore had been an active Communist and a film critic for the Daily Worker until 1939, when he was abruptly fired for giving a positive review to Gone With the Wind. Like a lot of other people who were mistreated by the Communists, Rushmore’s politics did a 180° and he hired on as a professional anti-Communist writer for William Randolph Hearst’s New York Journal-American. Rushmore was also briefly on the staff of Red-baiting Senator Joseph McCarthy (R-Wisconsin) until he clashed with McCarthy’s chief of staff, attorney (and later mentor to Donald Trump) Roy Cohn. As editor of Confidential, Rushmore used similar tactics to the ones he’d previously used as a Congressional investigator: targeting lower-level people (some of them active Communists, some of them “fellow travelers” or sympathizers, and some of them non-Communist liberals) and offering to spare them if they gave them information on higher-ups. Harrison and Rushmore cultivated a wide network of informers in Hollywood, including actress Barbara Payton; actor Bruce Cabot’s ex-wife, Francesca De Scaffa; and screenwriter Joseph Quillen’s ex Ronnie, and got stories out of them. Often Confidential would publish a story whose central allegation was true but would embellish it with other accusations that were entirely fictional. As Harrison himself explained, “Once we establish the star in the hay and that's documented, we can say anything we want and I think we make them a hell of a lot more interesting than they really are. What’s a guy gonna do, sue us and admit he was in the hay with the dame, but claim he didn’t do all the other things we dress the story with?” Confidential met its downfall in 1957, when California Attorney General Edmund G. “Pat” Brown (who’d later become governor and sire another California governor) prosecuted the magazine for conspiracy to commit criminal libel. His main witnesses were actresses Maureen O’Hara and Dorothy Dandridge (Confidential had published a totally false story about O’Hara allegedly having sex with a man she’d just met in the balcony of a movie theatre) as well as Howard Rushmore, whom Harrison had fired and would turn against him for revenge. In 1958 Rushmore met with his estranged wife under the guise of attempting a reconciliation; instead he took her in a cab and shot her and then himself.
In the film Slander, the Confidential analogue is called Real Truth and its publisher is H. R. Manley (Steve Cochran, older and more heavy-set than he was at his career peak in the late 1940’s but still great at oily villainy). He’s anxious to get out of a printing deal with Harry Walsh (Robert Burton) who helped give the magazine its seed capital, but he still owes the man $100,000. To get it he insists that the next issue of the magazine must have a really spectacular exposé that will jack up its sales enough to pay off the printer and he’s fastened on movie mega-star Mary Sawyer as the person he'll expose. To the world Mary Sawyer is an ultra-clean celebrity with a husband and family, but Manley is convinced that there’s a dark secret in her past that he can reveal to the world. He fastens on an aspiring puppeteer named Scott Ethan Martin (Van Johnson), who’s married to Connie (Ann Blyth, who actually does pretty well in a thankless role) and has a 10-year-old son, Joey (Richard Eyer, whose freckles help make him convincing as Van Johnson’s offspring). After years of struggle during which he did free shows at settlement houses, Martin, with the help of his friend and agent Seth Jackson (Harold J. Stone), has finally landed a job hosting a TV show and doing his puppet act there. Only he ends up in the cross-hairs of H. R. Manley, who wants to use him to destroy Mary Sawyer because they grew up in the same poor neighborhood of New York City. Martin’s own dark secret is that at age 19 he was convicted of armed robbery and spent four years in prison for it; his wife knew but no one else did (he was planning to tell his son when the kid turned 15 and the Martins assumed he’d be mature enough to handle the revelation). Manley discovers this and prepares an article for Real Truth exposing the new kids’ show host as an ex-convict, then tells Connie Martin he won’t publish it if Scott will give him dirt on Mary Sawyer. It turns out the dirt Scott Martin has on Mary Sawyer is that as a teenage girl she got “in trouble” and Scott’s mother helped her out of it. (It had to be veiled in the script to get it past the Production Code, but it’s obvious to us that Sawyer had got pregnant and Scott’s mother had arranged for an illegal abortion.)
Scott virtuously refuses to “rat” Mary Sawyer out to Manley and in exchange Manley publishes the article about him. The sponsor of his TV show immediately fires him, saying that since their product (a breakfast cereal) appeals mainly to children they can’t have a “jailbird” associated with it publicly. When the issue of Real Truth exposing Scott’s criminal past comes out, Joey’s schoolmates start bullying him about having an ex-con father, and in a scene whose flagrant melodramatics alienated me from the story, Joey flees the classmates, gets run over by a delivery van, and is killed. I don’t know who to blame for this ridiculous turn into outright melodrama ¬– original writer Junkin or screenwriter Weidman – but it hearkened back to the early tear-jerker musicals Al Jolson made at Warner Bros., The Singing Fool (1928) and Say It With Songs (1929) and gave the rest of the movie a false cast. Needless to say, the writers had to figure out a way for Manley to get his comeuppance, and they did it by having his mother (Marjorie Rambeau) shoot him at the end. At least they’d established an antagonism between them over how Manley was making his money, which she found distasteful even though he pointed out that the earnings from his scandal rag were at least enabling her to wear nice clothes, dine at fancy restaurants (though he'd often try to make reservations for her and they’d refuse because the proprietors of New York’s fanciest restaurants were appalled at the way her son made his living), and indulge her alcoholism with far better booze than the rotgut she’d previously had to consume. The film ends with Scott Martin going on a talk show called What Do You Read? with a host who’d already targeted Manley and his magazine and telling his story.
Slander was a personal film for Van Johnson since he’d been libeled by Confidential himself with a story that claimed he was Gay. (They’d leveled that accusation against other celebrities as well, including ones like Liberace and Tab Hunter who really were Gay.) Eddie Muller said at the end that he found the scene in which Manley’s mother shoots him disappointing in that Rowland cut away from her just before she fired the fatal shot, and he wished that Sam Fuller had directed the film. Actually Fuller made a number of films about the sordid side of publishing, including Park Row (1952) and an even earlier one, Scandal Sheet (1951), which Fuller didn’t direct (Phil Karlson did) but was based on a Fuller novel called The Dark Page (1944) and, like John Farrow’s The Big Clock (1948), was about a psychopathic publisher who commits a murder and uses his papers to cover it up. Muller compared the film to Ace in the Hole (1951), Billy Wilder’s masterpiece about corrupt journalism (though in Wilder’s film the villain is a corrupt reporter instead of a corrupt publisher), and I can think of films even further back which made more of this theme, including Mervyn LeRoy’s little-known masterpiece Five Star Final (1931), in which Edward G. Robinson plays a guilt-ridden tabloid editor and Boris Karloff is his star reporter, a former divinity student (until he was expelled) who uses his knowledge of the Bible to pose as a minister and get stories. Eddie Muller said that the title of Slander is inaccurate because slander means a false or defamatory statement about someone made orally, and the written version is called libel. The Wikipedia page on Slander points out that the title is doubly inaccurate because both slander and libel mean making false statements, while the allegation against Van Johnson’s character in the movie is actually true (and he admits it during the story). Slander is actually a pretty good movie that could have been great, and even so it raises questions about just how we know what we think we know about the broader world and what obligations, if any, do reporters have to those they cover and the justifications behind revealing really sleazy tales about celebrities just to titillate readers.