Monday, October 23, 2023
The Delinquents (Imperial Productions, United Artists, 1956)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2023 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
My husband Charles and I watched Robert Altman's The Delinquents on April 29, 2008, just before I started the moviemagg blog. I was inspired to look it up again by a YouTube post featuring the great Kansas City blues/jazz singer Julia Lee, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfXMGJSVbbE, who appears in the film's opening scene. Altman's film, his first theatrical non-documentary feature (he'd worked previously on a documentary called The James Dean Story), was a pretty standard cookie-cutter juvenile delinquency film but it has its moments and is worth checking out if you're an Altman fan.
When Charles finally got home at 10 p.m. we squeezed in a movie mainly because I’d especially wanted to see it: The Delinquents, a cheapie made in Kansas City in 1956 (imdb.com dates it as 1957, but the copyright date is a year earlier) distinguished from all the other J.D. exploitation films of the time only in that the director is a young Robert Altman and the star is a young Tom Laughlin, both of whom made their livings mostly in television for the next decade or so until both of them achieved explosive popularity in movies aimed at the youth counterculture of the late 1960’s: Altman with M*A*S*H and Laughlin with Billy Jack (which he produced and directed — under the pseudonym “T. C. Frank” — and wrote with his wife as “Frank and Teresa Christina,” as well as starring in: the false names came from their kids, Frank, Teresa and Christina). In addition, the film opens with what turns out to be its best sequence: the great Kansas City jazz-blues singer Julia Lee singing the James P. Johnson-Andy Razaf song “A Porter’s Love Song to a Chambermaid” with a jazz band led by the film’s musical director, Bill Nolan. The song is interrupted by an altercation started by a band (and not the musical kind, either!) of juvenile delinquents led by Cholly (Peter Miller), who try a transparently obvious scam to get the bartender to sell them beer (they pass the same I.D. around and all try to use it), are refused, threaten to start a fight and/or break up the place, and eventually leave, then retaliate by grabbing a bus stop sign and hurling it through the club’s window.
On the way out they drive crazily — apparently they got booze from somewhere — and a girl with the group tries to sing Julia Lee’s song while they boast at how scared they got her. (She didn’t look scared at all to me — she looked like she’d seen far worse in the wide-open days of the 1920’s and 1930’s in which Kansas City was a hangout for gangsters from all over the country and many of them went to the jazz clubs and dug the music.) As Charles predicted, the movie went downhill from there. Tom Laughlin plays Scotty White, a decent kid whose descent into J.D.-dom starts when he’s no longer allowed to see his girlfriend Janice Wilson (Rosemary Howard) because her parents (James Lantz and Lotus Corelli), in what has got to be one of the dumbest decisions in a movie full of them, have decided to bar her from seeing Scotty because she’s only 16 and therefore too young to go steady — though they’ll let her see other guys. Devastated, Scotty goes alone to the drive-in movie they were planning to see together and he’s assaulted by another J.D. gang, then rescued by Cholly and company. They invite him to a party in an abandoned (though surprisingly well-stocked) house that the sheriff has sealed off, and there they get him drunk on whiskey (which, judging from the discomfort he feels when they’re forcing it down his throat, he’s never drunk before) and they try to split him and Janice (who’s sneaked out of her parents’ home by pretending that Cholly is her date — ironically, they approve of him because he’s handed them a line about having a good job as a messenger at a stock exchange and wanting to go into brokering as a career!) apart and seduce them. According to an imdb.com trivia entry on this film, Altman directed the party scene by telling his young actors to act as they would at a real party, then moved his cameras willy-nilly and caught whatever they caught for the final film — the one part of this movie that offers any clue to Altman’s working methods on his major films.
Though it’s only 72 minutes long, The Delinquents is one of those films that seem to creep along at a snail’s pace (or maybe that’s being unfair to snails). The big youth party is raided by the sheriff’s men, and the gang members blame Scotty and Janice for having tipped off the cops (it was actually the fault of the boy they stationed as their lookout, who was too busy necking with his girl to give the signal). They go after him and force him into their car, then stick up a gas station — Eddy (Richard Bakalyan), the most blatantly psychopathic of the gang members, who’s essentially to the dramatis personae of this film what Sal Mineo was in Rebel Without a Cause (see, I couldn’t write about The Delinquents without mentioning the great J.D. film it was attempting to reach for!), belts the gas station attendant with his own pump handle (and both Charles and I registered the chime sound when the car pulled up — from the days when gas station driveways had rubber pipes that sounded chimes to let the attendants know that a car had driven in and they had a customer they needed to wait on — as a slice of history that in and of itself dated this film!), and they eventually take Scotty to the home of yet another gang member, get him even more drunk (on the theory that the cops won’t believe him if he has liquor on his breath) and ultimately wound him with a switchblade, whereupon the cops duly arrive, take everybody into custody and the narrator who opened the film in stentorian tones (“The story you are about to see is about violence and immorality — teenage violence and immorality, children trapped in the half-world between adolescence and maturity — their struggle to understand, their need to be understood. Perhaps in its rapid progression into the material world, man has forgotten the spiritual values which are the moral fiber of a great nation: decency, respect, fair play...”) comes in to close it again and give it the general air of a movie you’d see on the audio-visual equipment of a high school.
According to imdb.com, Alfred Hitchcock saw The Delinquents, “read” it as the work of a potentially major talent and hired Altman to direct episodes of the Alfred Hitchcock Presents TV show — though aside from admiring Hitchcock for the accuracy of his call on Altman’s talent, I can’t imagine what he saw in this incredibly cheesy film that gave him the idea the person who’d helmed it was a major director in the making. It was also fascinating to look up both their biographies on the Internet and find that Altman was only five years older than Laughlin (Altman was born in 1926, Laughlin in 1931); on the strength of this film Laughlin appears to be yet another James Dean wanna-be who was trying to make a career by taking advantage of the opening left by the death of the real one (Paul Newman was the “official” replacement — he was under contract to the same studio, Warner Bros., and he made the two films that Dean had been set for when he died, Somebody Up There Likes Me and The Left-Handed Gun — but actors whose ultimate career trajectories were as diverse as Elvis Presley, Michael Landon, John Cassavetes and Steve McQueen also tried for the Dean mantle), and Richard Bakalyan seems the only actor in the piece with any real charisma or star power — though I must say Laughlin holds his own quite well in the fight scenes even though he’s way outnumbered and he hadn’t yet reconnected to his Native American roots or learned karate. There are also a few noir-ish compositions (though Altman was never much for atmosphere — even in his major films he’s more interested in getting sensitive performances from his actors and keeping his famous multiple plot lines sorted out than he is in spectacular visuals) and this film benefits from being in black-and-white (especially by comparison to the RancidColor process used to shoot Teen-Age Strangler!), but — aside from the welcome presence of Julia Lee in the opening sequence (“It’s all going to go downhill from here!” Charles joked, and he was right), The Delinquents has little to offer and seems a very strange first feature credit for Altman.
Saturday, October 21, 2023
The Mallorca Files: "Death in the Morning" (Cosmopolitan Pictures, Clerkenwell Films, BBC, PBS, 2019)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2023 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night (Friday, October 20) I watched a couple of TV shows on KPBS, a better-than-average episode of The Mallorca Files called “Death in the Morning” (2019) and a Live at the Belly Up show featuring Bob Marley’s third child and oldest son, Ziggy. “Death in the Morning” dealt with the murder of British author Nicholas Mountford (Richard Cunningham), who was living in Mallorca to research a book highly critical of bullfighting. According to the script by Rachael New, bullfighting had actually been banned – and that turns out to have been true, though the ban only applied in the autonomous Spanish province of Catalonia; it was passed by the Catalán legislature in 2010 and repealed by the Spanish Supreme Court as unconstitutional in 2016, though even after the ban was lifted no further bullfights have been staged in Catalonia. Mountford is killed in an abandoned bullring while he’s there to research his book, and among the suspects are his widow Leanne (Amy Beth Hayes) and Victor Alzamora (Jan Cornet), security guard for the bullring and the son and grandson of famous and now-retired matadors. The gimmick is that Mountford is killed like a bull in the ring, stabbed through the shoulder blades from the back, by an assailant dressed as a matador. Victor’s alibi is that he was at the coffeehouse and bar owned by his grandfather, and when police detectives Max Winter (Julian Looman) and Miranda Blake (Elen Rhys) arrive at the bar to check out his alibi, granddad is hors de combat from over-drinking his own liquor supply and dad is vague and noncommittal about Victor’s whereabouts.
The police chase Victor on foot through the streets of Cazador, the small town in Mallorca where the action takes place (and director Bryn Higgins gives us some nice shots of Jan Cornet’s well-turned ass), and ultimately discover that Victor and Mountford’s wife Leanne were having an affair. In fact, that’s where he really was the morning of Nicholas Mountford’s murder: Victor and Leanne were having a “quickie” at her place while Nicholas was off exploring the local bullring for research on a book he was writing about a legendary local matador nicknamed “The Whisperer” (El Encantador). “The Whisperer”’s daughter runs a local museum at the site of the old bullring dedicated to his memory, and she turns out to be the actual killer: she dressed up in dad’s old traje de luces (“suit of lights,” the standard bullfighter’s costume) to kill the author. Her motive was to protect her father’s memory; she’d put out the story that he “died of a broken heart” on the day the ban on bullfighting. In fact he’d long been addicted to prescription painkillers he started taking legally as a result of injuries from the bullring, and on the day of the ban he deliberately overdosed and hence committed suicide. It was to keep this a secret that she killed Nicholas Mountford, though she wasn’t able to access the notes he’d made for his book that told the whole story. Rachael New’s script is particularly clever in putting Max and Miranda in situations in which they’re mistaken for a romantic couple – which they aren’t – including one funny scene in which an overly pushy waitress tries to give them a red rose to symbolize their “love.” I like The Mallorca Files and the best thing about it is it’s in a lot of ways a return to the comedy-mysteries that proliferated in American films in the 1930’s before the darker film noir style replaced them as the standard way of portraying crime on film.
Live at the Belly Up: Ziggy Marley (Belly Up Productions, Peaks and Valleys Productions, San Diego State University, KPBS-TV, 2017)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2023 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
After that I watched a rerun of a 2017 Live at the Belly Up episode featuring Ziggy Marley, third child and first son of reggae legend Bob Marley. Bob Marley’s Wikipedia page lists 11 children, though only three – daughter Cedelia and sons David “Ziggy” and Stephen – were the offspring of both Bob Marley and his wife, Rita Anderson Marley. Their oldest child, Sharon, was actually Rita’s daughter by a previous relationship, and a later daughter, Stephanie, was fathered by a Jamaican soccer player Rita had an affair with, though Bob did a legal second-parent adoption. Bob’s other children were from extra-marital relationships: Robert “Robbie” with Pat Williams, Rohan with Janet Hunt (and since their birthdays were only three days apart in May 1972 Bob must have been a busy little bee nine months previously!), Karen with Janet Bowen, Julian with Lucy Pounder, Ky-Mani with Anita Belgravis, and his last child, Damian, with Cindy Breakspeare. (Cindy Breakspeare was the most controversial of Bob Marley’s paramours; he wrote a song to her called “Turn Your Lights Down Low,” but Rita was so jealous she refused to allow it to be used on any posthumous Bob Marley compilations, so it’s only available on the album for which Marley originally recorded it, Exodus. Lauryn Hill recorded a “ghost duet” version in 1999 with Marley’s voice from the original record, and for some reason Rita allowed that.) As Bob Marley’s oldest son and the first to record on his own, Ziggy became in essence the Bob Marley Lama, heir and successor of Marley’s musical legacy, and that was very much in evidence on the Live at the Belly Up show from 2017. I was wondering if he’d cover any of his dad’s songs, and he did: at the end of an extended jam on an original called “Justice” Ziggy quoted Bob’s “Get Up, Stand Up” and “War” (the song with which the late Sinéad O’Connor famously disrupted a 1994 tribute concert to Bob Dylan). Later on he covered Bob’s “One Love” and “Is It Love?”
When Ziggy wasn’t covering his dad he was working in similar grooves, opening with a song called “Reggae in My Head” and later doing a socially conscious song called “We Are the People” (whose message of peace and learning to live together despite one’s differences seemed very timely right now, especially given the horrors now going on in Israel – but then, when have songs about peace and tolerance not been timely? In his preface to Slaughterhouse-Five Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. wrote that he’d told someone he was working on an anti-war book and got the reply, “Why don’t you write an anti-glacier book?” Ironically, given the relentless march of human-caused climate change, it looks like war is going to outlast glaciers!) as well as lighter but still moving fare like “Butterflies,” “Amen,” “Look Who’s Dancing” and “Weekend’s Long.” Ziggy both looks and sounds amazingly like his dad, and he even used a similar band line-up, with two women backup singers (Bob used three, including Rita, and called them “The I-Threes”) as well as two guitarists (one of them Ziggy himself), a keyboard player, bassist and drummer. Ziggy’s songs also reflected the family’s continued interest in Rastafarianism, the peculiar Jamaican religion which hailed the late Ethiopian emperor Haile Selassie I as the living incarnation of God on Earth. (My husband Charles wondered just how Rastafarianism has been able to survive the physical death of Haile Selassie I on August 27, 1975.) Rita Marley had adopted the Rasta faith after seeing Haile Selassie in his visit to Jamaica in 1966 (Bob missed it because he was in the U.S. working at Ford Motor Company in Detroit, but he became a Rasta later and many of his songs explicitly reference Rasta beliefs), and Ziggy obviously continues in the family tradition spiritually as well as musically. Though it wasn’t as good as the Live at the Belly Up, also from 2017, featuring Nahko and Medicine for the Soul, which KPBS re-ran two weeks previously (and I didn’t comment about it because I was in the hospital when I watched it), the Live at the Belly Up featuring Ziggy Marley was a welcome laid-back tribute to him as well as his famous father.
Friday, October 20, 2023
Midsomer Murders: "Happy Families" (Bentley Productions, All3 Media, ITV [Independent Television], American Public Television, PBS, 2021)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2023 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Yesterday (Thursday, October 19) at 10 p.m. I watched a Midsomer Murders episode on KPBS, a rerun of a show called “Happy Families” from 2021 in which the assistant to the show’s lead, Detective Chief Inspector John Barnaby (Neil Dudgeon, who’s been playing the part since this show’s inception in 1997), is the good-looking but rather stuck-up Jamie Winter (Nick Hendrix). “Happy Families” deals with an unscrupulous board-game entrepreneur, Victor Karras (Stuart Mulligan), whose wife Eleanor (Rachael Stirling) is pregnant – not with their child but as a surrogate for her sister, Alicia Matheson (Georgina Rich), whose rather hapless husband Paul (Paul Bazely) apparently couldn’t get her pregnant in the normal way (though the actual biological parentage of the child Eleanor is carrying for Alicia is carefully unspecified by writer Nick Hicks-Beach). In addition to making high-end designer board games (if you didn’t know or care there are high-end board games, I share your confusion), Victor hosts role-playing parties at which fake “murders” are staged and the guests are challenged to see if they can solve them. A young man gets “killed” as one of the victims in Victor’s latest party, and then Victor himself is killed for real when a statue of the ancient Egyptian dog-god Anubis falls and impales him. Later it turns out that getting stabbed by a falling statue isn’t what killed Victor; he really died from cyanide poisoning, though this still begs the question of who administered it and when. Also on the scene are Hugo Welles (Adrian Edmondson), who played a Scotland Yard inspector in the mystery “murder” game; and his wife Helen (Caroline Quentin), who wrote a game Victor Karras ripped off from her decades before the main story. They have a son named Andrew (Ed White), who’s concocted a revenge scheme against Victor Karras that involves him embezzling from Karras and using the money to buy him expensive watches, TV’s and other doodads. Andrew is doing this in cahoots with Karras’s assistant, Joshua Kilbride (Greg Lockett), and there are hints in Hicks-Beach’s script and Audrey Cooke’s direction that the two are Gay lovers.
Naturally Hugo Welles is so into playing a Scotland Yard detective that he makes a ham-handed attempt to solve the murder, though he actually uncovers a key clue – a plastic ring discarded outdoors by the killer, which we see well before we understand its significance. There’s also the character of Karras’s daughter Danni (Vanessa Emme) and her African-British boyfriend Noah Adomakoh (Aki Omoshaybi). Noah started a relationship with her only to get his hands on her dad’s money to develop a new invention, a sort of Super-Glue with which he claims to be able to repair any plate or cup as good as new – though when he presents her with a sample of his handiwork, she gets angry and hurls it into the wall, disintegrating it. This actually provides Barnaby and Winter a key clue to solving the case; in the ruins of Noah’s destroyed plate they find a shard of blue glass with the name “Nitrile,” which I recognized as the material medical gloves are made of now that so many medical personnel turned out to have allergies to latex. But it also is a sort of poison that releases cyanide if it’s heated, and Barnaby and Winter deduce that this was how Victor Karras was murdered. By this time we’ve already had our second victim – Hugo Welles, who had grandly announced that he’d solved the real-life murder and was going to announce it to all and sundry – as well as Alicia Matheson, who is stricken with a mild case of cyanide poisoning but survives. Later Barnaby and Winter declare that Alicia was the real killer – she faked the attack on herself to divert suspicion, slipped the nitrile into Victor’s vape kit so he’d die 12 hours later the next time he used it, and stabbed Hugo and pushed his body down a flight of stairs to keep him from revealing her as a killer. There’s also a red-herring subplot about a private detective Victor hired to find out who was “leaking” his principal ideas for games to his competitors, and the giant puzzle box in which Victor hid his report.
I mostly liked this Midsomer Murders episode, though it fell victim to one of the most frequent traps of this show: the unraveling of so many different crimes, each with little or nothing to do with the others, it’s not only hard to keep track but most of the dramatis personae end up arrested for one thing or another. Alicia’s motive was that she feared Victor and Eleanor were going to double-cross her and keep the baby (ya remember the baby?) for themselves; she’d overheard them talking about building a nursery for the child but didn’t hear the second half of the conversation, which was that they were surprising Alicia and Paul by presenting them with a full-fledged nursery. The show’s ironic title – there are several families depicted but none of them are really happy – is underscored by a postlude in which John Barnaby tells his long-suffering wife Sarah (Fiona Dolman) that he’s been offered a promotion but it will involve doing desk work instead of actually investigating cases in the field, and ultimately he turns it down despite her long-standing discontent of how much time his job takes and the long absences it puts him through. Overall this was an O.K. Midsomer Murders episode but I’ve seen better.
Wednesday, October 18, 2023
The American Buffalo, part 1: "Bloody Memory," and part 2: "Into the Storm" (Florentine Films, WETA, PBS, 2023)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2023 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night (October 17) I watched all four hours of the latest Ken Burns documentary on PBS, The American Buffalo, which began with the account of Merriweather Lewis of the Lewis and Clark expedition in 1805 of how the Great Plains were just filled with buffalo, versus what the same piece of real estate looked like in 1895 when almost all the buffalo had been hunted to near-extinction and it took great pains to rebuild and restore the species. Of course, the story of the American buffalo is intimately intertwined with the story of Native Americans and in particular the genocidal attitude white American settlers took towards them. I watched the first half of the show, “Bloody Memory” (also the name of the companion book by Ken Burns and the show’s writer, Dayton Duncan, published by PBS along with the series), last night on PBS’s “streaming” service, and the second half, “Into the Storm,” “live” as it aired on KPBS. Oddly, the first half was considerably more engaging than the second, even though the story it told was considerably grimmer. Many of the film’s “talking heads” are Native people, especially from the Kiowa tribe, who had a particularly strong relationship with the buffalo. The Kiowa literally worshiped the buffalo – though this didn’t stop them from killing buffalo as needed. They relied on the buffalo for food, clothing and shelter, living on a diet of what was essentially buffalo jerky and other ways of drying meat to preserve it (in the pre-refrigeration days, drying meat was the only way to keep it edible long-term), using buffalo hides to make leather and both wearing clothes made of buffalo and using buffalo skins to make their tipis. The Kiowa and other Great Plains Natives, including the Comanche, prided themselves on using every part of the buffalo they killed and not wasting anything.
Before the advent of the horse – brought to the New World by Spanish conquistadores in the 16th and 17th centuries since, though the horse’s ancestors had existed in the Western Hemisphere, they had died out while the European pre-horses survived and grew – Native Americans hunted buffalo on foot. Often they wore wolf or coyote skins to camouflage their scent so they could approach buffalo herds without the animals sensing them. The advent of horses marked the beginning of the end for the Native Americans and the buffalo who fed, clothed and sheltered them; with horses, they could hunt buffalo more effectively and efficiently, though they still retained the mind-set of not killing more buffalo than they needed and using the entire animal. Unfortunately, the advent of white people on the American continents spelled doom for the Native people and their cultures in more ways than one. Not only did white people – especially white Americans – regard the Natives as essentially expendable, clutter in the way of the so-called “Manifest Destiny” of white people to rule all North America, they introduced diseases like smallpox to which Native people had no resistance. What’s more, improvements in the tanning process by which leather is made led to a vogue for buffalo-derived clothes among white Europeans, mainly because buffalo leather is a lot softer and therefore more comfortable to wear than cow leather. The final blow came with the advent of railroads in general and transcontinental railroads in particular. What Native people called “The Iron Horse” soon criss-crossed the entire country, neatly bisecting the Great Plains and the other habitats on which Native Americans had lived for years, confident that there’d always be enough grazing land for the buffalo on whom they depended to flourish. The next blow to the buffalo herds came from teams of buffalo skinners, who would go out into the West, shoot down buffalo en masse, harvest the pelts for leather and then just leave the carcasses out on the prairie to rot – which appalled the Native Americans and left the prairies literally stinking of rotting buffalo corpses. One buffalo hunter, John Cook, admitted, “As I walked through where the carcasses lay the thickest, I could not help but think that I had done wrong to make such a slaughter for the hides alone.” But he rationalized it by saying to himself that if he didn’t shoot the buffalo, someone else would and make the money from it.
Later a thriving trade developed for buffalo bones; as this show’s narration, written by Dayton Duncan and delivered by Peter Coyote, explained, “Companies in the East offered an average of $8.00 a ton for bones they could grind into fertilizer or use in refining sugar. Buffalo horns were turned into buttons, combs, and knife handles. Hooves became glue. Homesteaders in Nebraska and Kansas – desperate for cash because drought was withering their crops – turned to harvesting the skulls and skeletons still littering the Plains. One entrepreneur in Texas stacked mounds of bones along the tracks of the Fort Worth and Denver Railroad and made $25,000. ‘Buffalo bones,’ a Kansas newspaper reported, ‘are now legal tender in Dodge City.’” It’s a testament to the evil skill of capitalism that it can monetize anything, including its own carnage, for several generations. It’s not always clear from the historical records whether white Americans deliberately pursued a genocidal policy towards the Natives and saw eliminating the buffalo as key to eliminating the Native people, or whether it was just a clash of cultures between the Native tradition of communal ownership of land and other resources and the self-righteous capitalism of white Americans, in which land was just another commodity to be monetized by all possible means. The show contains a chilling reading from future President Theodore Roosevelt’s book on the buffalo: “While the slaughter of the buffalo has been in places needless and brutal, and while it is to be greatly regretted that the species is likely to become extinct, it must be remembered that its destruction was the condition necessary for the advance of White civilization in the West. Above all, the extermination of the buffalo was the only way of solving the Indian question … and its disappearance was the only method of forcing them to at least partially abandon their savage mode of life.” (No wonder Adolf Hitler, interviewed by Edward R. Murrow in 1940, said, “I don’t know why you Americans make such a fuss about the Jews. I’m only doing to the Jews what you did to the Indians.”) Whatever the reasons, in the 91 years between the Lewis and Clark expedition in 1804 and the end of outright hostilities between the U.S. and Native tribes in 1895, the number of buffalo in the U.S. had plummeted from over 30 million to just a few hundred.
The second half of The American Buffalo, “Into the Storm,” is about the handful of people who brought the buffalo back from near-extinction and saved enough of the animals that they could start reproducing and recovering at least a handful of their former numbers. Among them was George Bird Grinnell, editor of Forest and Stream magazine – a journal for hunters (contrary to popular belief, many hunters are also conservationists because almost the last thing they want is for the species they like to hunt to become extinct) – who along with Theodore Roosevelt formed an organization called the Boone and Crockett Club for “the preservation of the large game of this country.” Other activists who took up the cause of the buffalo included former buffalo hide hunter Charles Jesse “Buffalo” Jones, Smithsonian Institution taxidermist William T. Hornaday (who was anxious to preserve and stuff enough buffalo for his museum in case living buffalo became extinct); Charlie Goodnight, a Texas cattle rancher who’d married a Native woman who taught him to revere the buffalo; and Frederick Dupuis, a fur trader in South Dakota who’d also married a Native woman and who built his own herd of buffalo. When Dupuis negotiated with then-President Theodore Roosevelt and his Secretary of the Interior to sell the more than 300 buffalo he’d accumulated on his land, Congress refused to appropriate the money to pay him, so he sold his herd to the government of Canada instead for a buffalo preserve they wanted to set up in Alberta. Later it turned out that Dupuis had been more successful than he realized; instead of the 350 buffalo he’d promised Canada there were nearly 700. “Into the Storm” mentioned the Dawes General Allotment Act of 1887, which provided that the existing Native American reservations would be cut up into small plots of land, each assigned to a Native family, so they would be forced to abandon their hunter-gatherer lifestyle and become farmers. Native people generally had no idea that individuals either should or could own land – they regarded land as communal property that could be worked by anyone for the benefit of all – and so they were thrust into the middle of the capitalist economy for which they had no frame of reference at all.
But the slogan of the day was, “Kill the Indian, save the man” – which in practice meant that Native Americans were to be assimilated forcibly into the U.S. population. They were forbidden to speak their own languages, wear their own clothes or practice their own culture. Their children were forced to attend so-called “schools” where they would learn Western culture no matter what; one of the most chilling scenes in this program shows the clear discomfort of young Native children forced to wear Western dress and pose for group photos in these “schools.” Another “benefit” of the Dawes Act from the white point of view is that if the Natives were going to be farmers instead of hunter-gatherers, they would need only a fraction of the land they had been assigned under the reservation system. So it would justify further incursions in the so-called Native “reservations,” which sparked the infamous Oklahoma Land Rush and other en masse takeovers of former Native land by white settlers. Duncan’s narration mentions that many of the people working on saving the buffalo were also devotees of the so-called “scientific racism” of the late 19th century, including theories of eugenics and Madison Grant’s crackpot racism in his sensationally successful book The Passing of the Great Race. So both the destruction of the buffalo and their preservation were largely at the expense of the Native people who had for over 10,000 years lived in harmony with nature in general and the buffalo in particular. “Into the Storm” opens with various quotes, including one from environmentalist author Wallace Stegner: “We are the most dangerous species of life on the planet, and every other species, even the Earth itself, has cause to fear our power to exterminate. But we are also the only species which, when it chooses to do so, will go to great effort to save what it might destroy.” While there’s an attitude of “Ken Burns’ Greatest Hits” about The American Buffalo – the show touches on subjects of previous Burns mega-documentaries including the Civil War, the national parks system, the American West and even the Roosevelt family – for the most part it’s yet another gloomy tale of the rapaciousness of capitalism and the determination of its ruling classes to wipe out any other concept of how to live with the earth besides total greed-driven domination. The American Buffalo is yet another documentation of the monstrous evil of capitalism and how it destroys everything in its path – including the increasing likelihood that greed-driven Earthlings will destroy the planet’s very ability to sustain their species due to unchecked climate change.
Tuesday, October 17, 2023
Destiny, a.k.a. Der Müde Tod (The Weary Death) (Decla-Bioscop, 1921)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2023 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night (Monday, October 16) my husband Charles and I watched a film I’d been curious about literally for decades: a 1921 film by German director Fritz Lang (my choice for the greatest filmmaker of all time) originally titled Der Müde Tod, which means “The Weary Death.” In the English-speaking world it was called Destiny. It was written by Lang in collaboration with Thea Von Harbou, who was then married to actor Rudolf Klein-Rogge (who is in the film in two small but significant roles; later he’d play Dr. Mabuse, Attila the Hun in Kriemhild’s Revenge, Rotwang in Metropolis and Haghi in Spies, all for Lang) but was having an affair with Lang. (One office guy at Ufa Studios caught Lang literally fucking Von Harbou on his office desk.) The Wikipedia page on Destiny (also called Beyond the Wall in its initial American release, a reference to the impenetrable wall Death builds around his garden that only the dead can pass through) states that the film was inspired by the (East) Indian legend of Savitri, but to this viewer it came off more like the Orpheus and Eurydice myth with the leading character’s gender changed. A young woman (The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari lead Lil Dagover – who’s name-checked in the 1971 film Cabaret as an actress Sally Bowles would like to emulate) and her lover (Walter Janssen) are traveling through the German countryside in a horse-drawn carriage. They stop to pick up a hitchhiker who turns out to be Death himself (Bernhard Goetzke), there to claim her boyfriend. She pleads with Death to spare him, and at one point she visits an apothecary (Karl Platen) and starts to drink a potion he has on sale that will kill her. Then she’s magically transported to the realm of Death, beyond an impregnable wall Death has built around a property which he’s just bought from the town’s council by offering them a price so high they literally can’t refuse.
Having read a passage from the Song of Solomon in the apothecary’s shop – the one that says, “Love is stronger than death” – she insists that Death spare her lover, and Death offers her a deal: he will give her three chances to save a person who’s otherwise doomed, in three different historical eras: a Muslim capital (probably either Mecca or Baghdad during the Caliphate), medieval Venice and Imperial China. If she can use the power of her love to save the life of one of the doomed people in these eras, she can have her boyfriend back to life. Lang has Lil Dagover and Walter Janssen play the leads in each of the sub-stories as well as the main part of the film, and in the Arab story she’s Zobiede, sister of the Caliph (Eduard von Winterstein). Only she’s having a clandestine affair with “The Frank,” who sneaks into the harem in drag even though he’s not only not a woman, he’s not a Muslim. When he’s caught, he’s sentenced to be buried alive, and the sentence is carried out by the caliph’s gravedigger, “El Mott” (also Bernhard Goetzke). Now that she’s one down, Death moves Our Heroine to Venice, where she’s Monna Fiammetta, forced into a marriage she doesn’t want with Girolamo (Rudolf Klein-Rogge) but really in love with Gianfrancesco (that’s right, Walter Janssen again). He shows up at Monna’s home in costume, but it’s a trap set by Girolamo, who tricks Monna into attacking her lover. Then Girolamo’s Moorish servant (Lewis Brody, who was apparently genuinely Black – he was born in what is now Cameroon when it was still a German colony – instead of a white actor in blackface, and he survived the Nazis and died in 1951) stabs Gianfrancesco in the back, and he dies.
Now down two for two, Our Heroine next ends up in ancient China as the female assistant to the great magician A Hi (Paul Biensfeldt). A Hi has been summoned by the Emperor (Károly Huszár) via a letter the length of a human being to entertain him, but the invitation contains a threat: if A Hi’s performance bores the Emperor, the Emperor will have him beheaded. In the film’s most famous special-effects sequence, once A Hi has read the letter it literally stretches to its full length and flies off. A Hi shows up at the Emperor’s court on a magic carpet (which seems to be a bit strange, since one would have expected this in the Arab sequence, not the Chinese one) and offers him a troop of fully alive miniature soldiers and a magic horse that gradually grows from toy-sized to full-length. But the Emperor wants A Hi’s female assistant, Tiao Tsien (Lil Dagover again), and is determined to have her even though that means he’ll have to knock off her boyfriend, Liang (Walter Janssen again). Tiao Tsien takes A Hi’s magic wand, turns A Hi into a cactus, the guards into pigs and Liang into a tiger, but the Emperor’s archer is able to shoot Liang in tiger guise. Tiao Tsien conjures up an elephant so she and Liang can escape, but the emperor’s archer catches up with them and shoots Liang to death.
Having lost all three of her chances to redeem her partner, we next see the woman in the apothecary’s shop, about to drink the death potion, when the apothecary knocks it from her hands. Death then offers her one more chance to save her lover’s life, but only if she can find a substitute victim willing to take his place. She enters a nursing home where the residents are sitting around kvetching about how they’ve lived too long and are anxious to die, but when they hear Our Heroine’s offer, they’re scared and run away. Then a fire starts in the nursing home and the residents are evacuated, but there’s still a baby inside. Our Heroine goes in to take the baby and offer it to Death as a substitute victim, but then she thinks better of it and can’t bring herself to make the baby’s mother suffer from the loss of her child. So she rescues the kid by passing the baby out of the burning nursing home in some sort of blanket instead of actually carrying it out, and Charles “read” the ending as her dying in the fire and thereby getting to join her lover in death since she’d been unable to do so in life, ending the film on one of those weird “the lovers are reunited in death” things 19th Century Romantic authors were very big on. The original German title comes from a line of dialogue (via an intertitle) in which Death himself laments how weary he is of his task. Three years after Destiny was made, Italian author Alfredo Casella would write a play, Death Takes a Holiday, which also dealt with Death getting tired of his dismal task and literally “taking a holiday,” during which terminally ill people just had to suffer in great pain because they were denied the opportunity of actually dying.
Destiny a.k.a. The Weary Death a.k.a. Beyond the Wall is not only a great film in its own right but a deeply influential one on subsequent filmmakers. Alfred Hitchcock called it his all-time favorite film (not at all surprising when you realize just how much of his mature style Hitchcock got from Lang!) and Spanish avant-garde director Luis Buñuel said, “When I saw Destiny, I suddenly knew that I wanted to make movies. It wasn’t the three stories themselves that moved me so much, but the main episode – the arrival of the man in the black hat (whom I instantly recognised as Death) in the Flemish village – and the scene in the cemetery. Something about this film spoke to something deep in me; it clarified my life and my vision of the world.” It is also probably the most impressive “effects movie” made to that time, and it had a macabre effect on the end of Thea Von Harbou’s career. Von Harbou stayed in Germany when the Nazis took over, while Lang left and made most of his subsequent films in the U.S. (with the annoying result that later critics have blamed the sillier aspects of their collaborations on her and credited the good stuff to him), and after the war she was briefly interned in a British camp before her release in 1947. In 1954 she was invited to attend a revival screening of Destiny in Berlin – and on her way out of the theatre she slipped, fell and died several days later of her injuries. And through much of the movie I found myself wishing that Lang had got to remake it in the sound era; the part of Death would have been perfect for Bela Lugosi.
Monday, October 16, 2023
Murdaugh Murders: The Movie, parts 1 and 2 (Johnson Production Group, Lifetime, 2023)
by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2023 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved
Last night (Sunday, October 15) I wanted to watch the four-hour Lifetime film Murdaugh Murders: The Movie, based on the 2021 murder case involving prominent South Carolina attorney Alex Murdaugh (Bill Pullman) – the last name is pronounced “Murdock” – who was accused of killing his wife Maggie (Lauren K. Robek) and their younger son Paul (Curtis Tweedie) on June 7, 2021 outside a dog kennel on the property of one of their many homes. The film was originally released by the Johnson Production Group and Lifetime in two parts, with part one shown Saturday, October 14 and part two on October 15, though instead of watching the first part on Saturday I decided to wait until Lifetime showed the two parts consecutively. They did that by re-running part one at 6 p.m. and then doing the “premiere” of part two at 8. I might have liked the film better if I’d watched the two parts separately instead of consecutively, because as it stood it just wore me down. Alex Murdaugh himself is a fascinating character, a fourth-generation South Carolina attorney whose great-grandfather’s picture hangs in the local courthouse (at least it did until it’s taken down at the end after Alex is convicted of the murders of his wife and son). Alex is the fourth generation of his family to go into the legal business, and the Murdaugh family firm bases much of its track record on the generations (literally!) of influence it has built up and the number of “strings” it can pull. When Alex needs a favorable ruling in a case, he arranges a country-club membership for the judge and sends the invitation in an envelope that makes clear from whence it came. The film opens at a birthday party for Paul Murdaugh – whom Alex calls by the bizarrely infantilizing nickname “Paw-Paw” – at which Alex gives him the keys to a white pickup truck as his birthday present. Maggie warns her son to drive safely, but Paul has other ideas; he’s into drinking and hanging out with a gang of friends, both men and women.
From this setup we just know something dreadful is going to happen, and it does: one night Paul and his friends take Paul’s speedboat (the Murdaughs are supposedly so wealthy Alex can hand his son both a car and a boat as if they’re party favors, but there’s a dark secret as to how Alex Murdaugh is sustaining this level of affluence: more on that later) for a night picnic on one of the local islands. Paul insists on driving the boat home even though his more level-headed friend Cooper thinks Paul is too inebriated to handle the boat, and eventually Paul crashes it into a bridge and one of the girls, Mallory, is killed. Alex tries to use all his well-honed skills as a legal expert and “fixer” to get Paul off the hook, but he fails not only because the case is so severe – after all, you can’t just sweep a dead body under the rug like you could if Paul’s deeds hadn’t been lethal – but because he’s losing his “edge.” At the time of Paul’s accident Alex’s carefully constructed dual life is starting to come apart at the seams. His addiction to oxycodone – a drug he says he started taking as the result of a football injury in high school – is growing and starting to affect his overall capability. He’s also stiffing his drug dealer, and the dealer is starting to get antsy about being paid; at one point the dealer, who makes it clear he’s just an employee of a larger organization, literally hits Alex in the stomach and leaves a bruise as a warning for worse to come in case Alex continues to welch. Later the police learn from their investigation into Mallory’s death that Alex is nowhere nearly as rich as he seems: he’s been financing his lifestyle with the settlement money he’s won for his personal-injury clients (including a man named Hamilton who’s ended up in a wheelchair, unable to work) by embezzling it for himself.
By the time this movie begins Alex Murdaugh is already on a major downward spiral and is barely holding it together. He’s also got a girlfriend on the side – a young woman who slipped him her phone number at Paul’s birthday party – only that relationship ends when Alex comes over to her place for what she thinks is going to be a round of consensual sex but turns into virtual rape. Ultimately he gets so violent she orders him to leave, and later in the movie, when he tries to get back with her, she tells him the bruises he left on her body took months to heal, so he’s not welcome in her life anymore. Alex is also still very much under the thumb of his domineering father, who’s in the last stages of heart disease and has formally retired from the family law firm but is still very much in the picture, and his dad is a living symbol of the legacy generations of Murdaughs have built up before him. As things turn out, dad croaks just three days after Alex kills Maggie and Paul – and though director Greg Beeman (working from a script by Michael Vickerman, who’s also listed as one of the film’s five “executive producers”) tries to keep it ambiguous by showing the murderer wearing a loose-fitting blue hoodie over his other clothes, he later inserts a flashback that makes clear Alex is the killer. Alex deliberately shoots Maggie and Paul with separate guns – Paul with a shotgun and Maggie with an assault rifle – to make it look like they were killed by different people, presumably as part of a hit team sent by the gang that was supplying Alex’s drugs. What makes this movie simultaneously interesting and boring is the lack of any clear motive for Alex’s killing his wife and son: though the two of them had temporarily left him and moved in to one of the family’s other homes, there didn’t seem to be any intimation of a permanent break. If Alex was afraid that his wife and son would rat him out to the police as an embezzler, there’s no hint of that in Vickerman’s script.
Frankly, I would have found this film more compelling if it had focused on Alex Murdaugh’s life pre-murders: an account of how he slowly started raiding the trust funds he was supposedly keeping for his clients as his drugging and womanizing started getting out of control and he gradually shifted from just another corrupt attorney into an outright fraudster and, ultimately, a killer could have made for a much more interesting drama than the one we have. Murdaugh Murders: The Movie (a clunky title explained by the sheer number of TV shows about Alex Murdaugh, both documentaries and dramatized features, we’d already had before it was made) contains two great tour de force performances, by Bill Pullman as Alex and the young, almost ethereally beautiful Curtis Tweedie as Paul (a very hot twink type with especially nice nipples), but the sheer monomania of Alex’s villainy and his chutzpah in insisting on testifying in his own defense despite his attorney’s very good advice to him not to just wore me down after a while. A lot of Alex’s actions, good or bad, don’t seem to have much of a rational explanation – which may be a fault of writer Vickerman or a reflection of how rarely true-life stories have the sorts of neat wrap-ups we expect from fictional ones. I also didn’t like the way Lifetime edited the movie to squeeze in commercial breaks and keep us watching by setting up false climaxes; there’s a break between Alex’s direct examination and the prosecutor’s cross-examination, and another (and even more annoying one) between the scene in which the jury clerk hands the judge the verdict and the judge actually reads it in court. I suspect there’s a much more interesting story lurking behind the Alex Murdaugh case than the one we got here, and in particular one which would focus on the extent to which having built up so much “influence” over the generations literally spoiled the Murdaughs into thinking they could get away with anything because they always had.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)