Sunday, July 6, 2025

This Side of the Law (Warner Bros., filmed 1948, released 1950)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2025 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Saturday, July 5) my husband Charles and I ended up watching a film on Turner Classic Movies as part of Eddie Muller’s “Noir Alley” series. It was a real oddity from 1950, a Warner Bros. production called This Side of the Law starring Vivica Lindfors, a Swedish actress they’d imported in hopes that after Greta Garbo and Ingrid Bergman, lightning would strike three times and they’d be able to develop a Swedish actress into a major star. They made her Errol Flynn’s co-star in an elaborate 1948 swashbuckler called The Adventures of Don Juan and put her in a leaden melodrama called Night Unto Night, directed by Don Siegel (who married her; it was his first marriage but her third) and co-starring Ronald Reagan (totally out of his depth) in a drama about amnesia based on a story by Philip Wylie. That one was filmed in 1947 but not released until 1949. This Side of the Law had another long delay, filmed in 1948 but not released until 1950. It occurred to me when I read the imdb.com synopsis – “A drifter is bailed out of jail by a lawyer, who hires him to impersonate a millionaire until the man can be declared legally dead and the estate settled. However, the man soon finds out that things are not exactly how they seem” – that This Side of the Law is the movie Edgar G. Ulmer’s Detour would have been if Ulmer and his writer, Martin Goldsmith, had taken up the hint they dropped briefly and then abandoned of having their down-and-out hero pass himself off as the long-missing heir to a major fortune.

Directed by Richard Bare from a story by veteran pulp writer Richard Sale and a script by Russell L. Hughes, it begins with David Cummins (Kent Smith of Cat People, The Curse of the Cat People, and The Fountainhead fame) lamenting that he’s been thrown down an old well at the Sans Souci (he makes sure to reflect on the irony of the place literally being named “Without Care”) and literally can’t climb out again because the inside walls are so slimy. He then delivers a flashback on how he got there: he was on the street, casually eyeing a gun in a store window, when a cop came by and arrested him for vagrancy. He’s taken to night court, where an unscrupulous attorney named Philip Cagle (Robert Douglas) pays his $50 fine and spares him the 30-day jail sentence that would otherwise have been his fate. Cagle has a job for him: to go to Sans Souci and impersonate the long-lost heir, Malcolm Taylor, who’s been missing for six years and 10 months. The time frame is important because if Malcolm doesn’t turn up after having been missing for seven years, his relatives – wife Evelyn (Vivica Lindfors), brother Calder (John Alvin) and sister-in-law Nadine (Janis Paige, mostly known for comedies and musicals but in a considerably darker role than her norm) – can have him declared legally dead and help themselves to his $3 million inheritance. Cummins is able to bid up the price from $500 to $5,000 but agrees to go through with the job. He already strikingly resembles Malcolm Taylor, and Cagle gives him two weeks’ worth of briefings on the history of the man as whom he’s going to pass himself off. Cagle finishes David’s indoctrination with the warning that his brother Calder can’t stand him, and Malcolm’s old dog Angel will only recognize him if he wears clothes Malcolm wore that still have his scent on them. (It’s hard to believe enough of the aroma would linger after seven years, but that’s at best a minor inconsistency in a hastily assembled plot that’s full of them.)

When he arrives at Sans Souci he finds not only that Calder doesn’t like him, his wife Evelyn can’t stand him either, mainly because he’d had a number of extra-relational activities and his latest affair with Calder’s wife Nadine was the final straw. Nadine is the first one to “out” him after noticing that David’s wrists are not scarred – the real Malcolm got permanent scars from a childhood fight with Calder – though she agrees to keep quiet about it for a share of the $3 million. Then David overhears Nadine call Cagle and realizes that the two are involved in a plot together. Cagle, angry at what he considers Nadine’s double-cross, lures her to a secluded spot on the estate overlooking a cliff, kills her, and pushes her body off the cliff. The police rule Nadine’s death an accident, and David is ready to walk out of the whole business and leave Sans Souci, but Cagle offers him a ride to town and then knocks him out and throws his unconscious body into the well. While he’s down there he sees a skeleton with the identification bracelet of Malcolm Taylor, so he realizes the real Malcolm was murdered. Unable to get a grip on the side walls of the well because they’re covered in slime, David works out a way to escape by climbing out horizontally and edging his way up. He gets out in time to save Evelyn from being murdered by Calder, who was going to throw her off the cliff. Cagle grabs a gun and tries to shoot David, but Evelyn sneaks up behind him while David is able to turn the lights out, so Cagle’s shots miss him. Cagle tries to flee, but Angel (the dog ex machina) attacks him and he falls to his presumed death down the well. With Calder arrested and Cagle dead, Evelyn is the legal heir, and she ends up not only with the fortune but also David, whom she’s decided she loves after all and refuses to press charges against.

Even Eddie Muller admitted that This Side of the Law – based on a Richard Sale story called The Doctor Deals in Death, though Hughes rewrote it so extensively that no doctor appears among the dramatis personae – isn’t a particularly good movie. What makes it interesting is that, though there’s nothing supernatural about it, Richard Bare and Russell S. Hughes give it the iconography of a horror film. There’s a portrait on the wall, presumably of a Taylor ancestor, that is strikingly reminiscent of Edgar Allan Poe, which had me thinking that for sheer family dysfunctionality, the Taylors rival Poe’s Ushers and J. B. Priestley’s and James Whale’s Femms. They live in an old dark house perched on the side of a cliff overlooking a seashore (as most of Roger Corman’s characters would in his succession of “B” horrors for American International in the 1960’s), and cinematographer Carl E. Guthrie gives it the dark, shadowy, Gothic lighting of a horror film. Even the incomprehensibility of the plot, the sheer level of uncertainty as to who’s doing what to whom and why, makes this film seem more like a horror movie and less like film noir.

It also occurred to me that in 1949, while This Side of the Law was still in the Warner Bros. vaults, Josephine Tey published a novel called Brat Farrar, another tale of an elaborate impersonation of a long-lost heir to secure a fortune, which is everything This Side of the Law should have been but wasn’t. Tey (true name: Elizabeth Mackintosh) created genuine suspense as the impostor fools everyone in the family except his twin brother, who knows very well he can’t be the real heir because he murdered the real heir. She created a brilliant climax on the side of a cliff that succeeds in creating a genuine sense of terror, whereas the equivalent scene in This Side of the Law is just perfunctory and dull. Tey even explained why the impostor and the dead brother looked so much alike – it turns out he was actually a distant cousin from a branch of the family that had moved to the U.S. – whereas Sale, Hughes, and Bare just couldn’t be bothered and we were supposed to chalk up the resemblance as just another coincidence. Indeed, though Brat Farrar has been filmed for TV at least twice (once in the 1980’s and once more recently), I wish Alfred Hitchcock had made it in 1950 with the perfect actor, Cary Grant, for the lead(s). That would have been a film to conjure with!

Saturday, July 5, 2025

45th Annual A Capitol Fourth (Michael Colbert Productions, Capital Concets, Inc., WETA, PBS, aired July 4, 2025)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2025 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night PBS telecast the 45th annual A Capitol Fourth concert from the Capitol Mall at Washington, D.C., and it was actually more fun than usual. The show started with Lauren Daigle, one of the better “baby divas” cluttering up the modern music scene, singing “America, the Beautiful” and Yolanda Adams churning out a powerful version of “The Star-Spangled Banner.” Then there was a four-song set by The Temptations, the current lineup with one surviving member (Otis Williams) from the original group. Williams, at least according to Wikipedia, owns the name “The Temptations,” and the rest of them are whoever he says they are. The songs they played last night were “Get Ready” and “My Girl,” and the current lead singer on “My Girl” (probably Tony Grant) is a quite good soul belter but doesn’t have the plaintive, understated quality the late David Ruffin brought to the original recording in 1964. Then the concert brought on Trombone Shorty (true name: Troy Andrews) from New Orleans, who played an engaging medley of Professor Longhair’s “Go to the Mardi Gras” (a flop on Atlantic when they recorded it in 1949 but a major local hit for the tiny Ron Records label when Longhair, whose real name was Henry Roeland Byrd, re-recorded it in 1959 and it became the official theme song of New Orleans’s Mardi Gras celebrations), “When the Saints Go Marching In” (featuring a woman vocalist who really belted out the song and brought it back to its gospel roots), and Solomon Burke’s 1960’s soul hit “Everybody Needs Somebody to Love” (also covered in the mid-1960’s by The Rolling Stones). Despite his sobriquet, Shorty doubled on trumpet on the latter two songs. (Well, at least it’s still a brass instrument, so he doesn’t have to make the wrenching change in embouchure – the shape of the lips while playing – that musicians like Jimmy Dorsey, Benny Carter, and Brad Gowans, who played both brass and reed instruments, did.) Afterwards Lauren Daigle returned for a song called “Walking on Sunshine” that turned out to be a cover of the 1980’s band Katrina and the Waves (a group whose name I appropriated for my Hurricane Katrina editorial in Zenger’s Newsmagazine) and Abi Carter, who won the most recent (2024) American Idol contest, sang a suitably inspirational song called “The Climb.”

Then Yolanda Adams returned with Patrick Lundy and his gospel choir, the Ministers of Music, sang “The Battle Hymn of the Republic.” My husband Charles was predictably put out by the fact that the version they performed didn’t contain John Brown’s name (the song was originally titled “John Brown’s Body” and contained the words, “John Brown’s body lies a-mouldering in his grave/But his soul is marching on!”) but used Julia Ward Howe’s bowdlerized version that’s become the standard (“He” – meaning God – “hath loosed the fateful lightning of his terrible swift sword/But his truth is marching on!”). Afterwards they brought out country singer Josh Turner for a nice upbeat song called “Firecracker” (as in, “My girlfriend is a … ”) and then a quite beautiful song called “Unsung Hero” dedicated to Turner’s grandfather, who fought in World War II. While he’s pushing it a bit with that title – how can he call his granddad an “unsung hero” when he’s singing about him? – I loved “Unsung Hero” because it was a respite from the high-energy material that had dominated the concert to that point. I also give Turner major points for including a country-style fiddle and a pedal steel guitar in his band; most so-called “country” bands today omit these once paradigmatic instruments and achieve a sound more like the 1970’s “Southern rock” bands like Lynyrd Skynyrd and the Allman Brothers than hard-core country. Afterwards Jack Everly and the National Philharmonic Orchestra, who provided instrumental backing for the acts that needed it, played a medley of the Armed Forces’ theme songs, in the following sequence: Coast Guard, Space Force (who knew the “Space Force,” a rump creation of Donald Trump in his first term as President, had a theme song?), Air Force, Navy, Marines, and Army. Following that they paid a tribute to first responders – firefighters, paramedics, emergency medical technicians (EMT’s), and health care workers in general – via a song by Lauren Daigle called “Rescue.” After that a country duo called Locash (Chris Lucas and Preston Brust) did a song called “Three Favorite Colors.” Predictably for the occasion, their three favorite colors turned out to be red, white, and blue.

After that came another famous singing group led by the sole survivor among the original founding members – or at least among the relatives who started the band. It was The Beach Boys, led by Mike Love, who owns the rights to the band’s name and has led various rump editions for the last three decades or so. (Another original member, Al Jardine, is still alive and had planned a tour with Beach Boys founder Brian Wilson before Brian’s recent death; he went ahead with the tour in Brian’s memory.) I remembered a previous appearance by The Beach Boys on A Capitol Fourth in 2018 (ironically, that show also featured The Temptations!), and on this occasion they played four songs, all but one of them (“Wouldn’t It Be Nice?,” the opening track from their 1966 concept album Pet Sounds), from the early surf-cars-fun phase: “Surfin’ U.S.A.,” “Help Me, Rhonda” (I remember having a friend named Rhonda who had grim memories of her adolescence because she got relentlessly teased for having the same first name as the girl in The Beach Boys’ song), and “Fun, Fun, Fun.” The long-awaited fireworks began over the ending of “Fun, Fun, Fun” (as they had in 2018 as well) and continued as usual through the remaining musical selections. These started with the last four minutes of Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture (once again I savored the irony of celebrating American independence with a piece composed to commemorate the authoritarian regime of Tsarist Russia successfully defending itself against the at least nominally more liberal rule of Napoleon’s France) complete with cannons and a chorus belting out the Tsarist National Anthem when Tchaikovsky quoted it in the score.

They continued with the U.S. Servicemembers’ Chorus doing an O.K. patriotic song called “Let Freedom Ring”; the U.S. Army Band doing “The Caisson Song” (I remain irritated by the change in the words from “The caissons go rolling along” to “The Army goes rolling along,” though I understand why they’ve done it: who the hell knows what a caisson – a little wagon used to transport artillery balls to the front line – was anymore?) and George M. Cohan’s “I’m a Yankee Doodle Dandy” and “You’re a Grand Old Flag”; Yolanda Adams belting out “God Bless America”; and the obligatory closer, John Philip Sousa’s “Stars and Stripes Forever.” It was a fun evening and refreshingly free from most of the patriotic breast-beating that usually accompanies these events (instead there were two segments of modern-day servicemembers giving brief explanations of why they serve), though to say the least in the first year of the Second Coming of Führer Trump our relationship with the United States of America and the history of its founding is more jaundiced than ever. Earlier in the evening I had played the first disc of the 11-CD Mosaic Records boxed set of V-Discs (special records made by the U.S. military for distribution to servicemembers abroad, since from 1942 to 1944 the American Federation of Musicians called a strike against the recording industry and therefore the professional recording of music virtually ceased) and called it a reminder of the time when the U.S. was actually fighting fascism instead of embracing it.

The Lady Lies (Paramount, 1929)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2025 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Later on July 4 I stumbled across a YouTube post of an old movie that looked intriguing – a 1929 film called The Lady Lies, directed by Hobart Henley, written by John Meehan from a stage play he also created, and starring Walter Huston and Claudette Colbert. My husband Charles had his doubts about this one, worried that since it was an early talkie we’d be in for the soporific line deliveries and long … pauses … between each actor’s … cue line and … their own typical of all too many sound films, especially ones with relatively weak directors. Henley was actually a pretty good director who made at least one of my all-time favorite films, Night World (1932), an oddball hour-long item from Universal in 1932 that was a combination gangster movie and musical and the only film on which both Boris Karloff and Busby Berkeley worked. He also made Bette Davis’s first film, 1931’s Bad Sister (which also featured Humphrey Bogart in an early role as a swindler; for my review, see https://moviemagg.blogspot.com/2023/06/bad-sister-universal-1931.html), as well as having directed the earlier 1922 silent version of the same story, The Flirt. Henley also directed the early Maurice Chevalier musical, The Big Pond (1930), also with Colbert, which gave Chevalier two of his biggest hits, “You Brought a New Kind of Love to Me” and “Living in the Sunlight, Loving in the Moonlight.” Also on Henley’s résumé was a 1930 item called Roadhouse Nights which reunited him with two cast members from The Lady Lies, Claudette Colbert and Charlie Ruggles, along with Jimmy Durante (in his first film) and a story supposedly based on – but actually having almost nothing to do with – Dashiell Hammett’s first novel, Red Harvest.

Actually the problem with The Lady Lies wasn’t Henley’s direction, which was adequate and workmanlike, but Meehan’s script. The title is a bit of a misnomer because the biggest lie in the movie is told not by a lady but by one of the male characters, Robert Rossiter, Jr. (Tom Brown, who’s quite good in this and deserved more of a career than he got: he worked steadily for decades but largely in anonymous character parts). Robert, Jr. is the teenage son of Robert Rossiter, Sr. (Walter Huston), a corporate lawyer with a high-class clientele. In the first scene of the film, we see him with his so-called “drinking buddy” (the fact that Prohibition was still in effect when this movie was made is cheerily ignored, as usual for Hollywood in this genuinely “pre-Code” era: the Motion Picture Production Code wasn’t promulgated until 1930 and wasn’t seriously enforced until 1934) Charlie Tyler (Charlie Ruggles, less foofy than he was later). Charlie asks Rossiter to handle his upcoming divorce (from a wife we never actually see), and he talks on and on and on about the difference between blondes and brunettes, especially on the expense of breaking up with them. Rossiter self-righteously refuses either to take Charlie’s case or to refer him to another attorney. Charlie has a long-term mistress, Hilda Pearson (Betty Garde), who’s friends with a department-store sales clerk (Claudette Colbert) whose name according to the film’s imdb.com and Wikipedia pages is “Joyce Roamer” but the actors pronounce it “Rome,” like the Italian capital. Rossiter meets Joyce in the department store where she works while he’s ordering a birthday present for his daughter Josephine (Patricia Deering), who like her older brother Bob, Jr. is away at boarding school in New England. Joyce suggests a fur jacket as the present and sneaks in a couple of scarves as accessories. Soon she and Robert start dating, though it’s an entirely licit relationship that never gets near the bedroom.

Robert is a widower – his children’s mother died several years before and he hadn’t thought seriously about dating again until he met Joyce – so there’s nothing in the way of him and Joyce getting together except the excessively moralistic attitudes of his children and their uncle and aunt, Henry and Amelia Tuttle (Duncan Penwarden and Virginia True Boardman). The Tuttles bring the Rossiter kids down from Salem, Massachusetts for what we assume is their spring break, and are appalled at the way Robert treats his children, which is to respect them and treat them like adults instead of bossing them around. The clash of values between the Tuttles and the Rossiters is shown rather artfully when Henry Tuttle insists that there be a prayer of grace before they eat dinner – and his “grace” is so unusually long it seems to go on forever. The Tuttles threaten to sue Robert for custody of his children if he doesn’t marry the wife they’ve picked out for him, fellow socialite Ann Gardner (Jean Dixon). The big lie that powers the plot comes from the kids; they call up Joyce and tell her that Robert has been in a bad accident and has fractured his skull. Naturally she comes over right away, only to find that Robert didn’t have an accident, he isn’t there (he went out to pace the grounds and be alone), and the children pulled this hoax to read her the riot act and tell her that under no circumstances should she continue to date their father. Joyce is so devastated that she walks to the balcony of her friend Hilda’s apartment and threatens to jump. Hilda serves as the voice of reason in all this and engineers a reconciliation between Robert and Joyce, and ultimately the children agree rather grudgingly to accept Joyce as their new stepmother. The plot is pure soap opera and one admires the skill of Walter Huston and Claudette Colbert as actors that they try their damnedest to put some flesh and bones on these cardboard characters. Ultimately, though, The Lady Lies just creaks along to its predictable outcome and seems longer than its 75 minutes.

There’s also an odd scene that shows the technical crudities of the early sound era; it takes place at a restaurant, and the challenge of mixing dialogue, music (which is supposed to be source music being played by either a live band or on records), and the “wild” noises of the customers defeated Paramount’s sound engineers. The customers’ noises pretty much drowned out everything else, including the dialogue! Paramount shot this movie at their Long Island studios in New York City, though the only thing this did to the movie for good or ill is it meant they could use Broadway stage actors who hadn’t yet moved to Hollywood for a serious attempt to make it in the movie business. This early in the sound era they were still shooting movies in multiple languages – which meant it helped big-time when they had an actor like Colbert who was bilingual (English and French). In fact she even speaks a bit of French in this otherwise all-English movie. There’s nothing really wrong with The Lady Lies but there’s nothing right about it, either; it’s just a series of predictable plot situations that lurches towards the ending we all saw coming anyway. Fortunately things would get better for both the stars: Walter Huston would go on to make two films as President of the United States – a real one in D. W. Griffith’s woefully underrated biopic Abraham Lincoln (1930) and a fictitious one, “Judson Hammond,” in William Randolph Hearst’s personal production Gabriel Over the White House (1933) – and help launch the illustrious career of his son, John Huston, by insisting he get an additional dialogue writing gig on his film A House Divided (1931) – also a story about a May-December romance. Colbert in turn would make three major films in 1934: Cecil B. DeMille’s Cleopatra; Frank Capra’s screwball comedy classic It Happened One Night, which won her the Academy Award; and John M. Stahl’s gripping social drama Imitation of Life, which should have been her Oscar-winner. She’d reign as a major star for almost two decades until she started to get too persnickety about her parts: she walked out of Frank Capra’s State of the Union (1948) and Joseph L. Mankiewicz’s All About Eve (1950) and was replaced – stunningly, in both cases – by Katharine Hepburn in State of the Union and Bette Davis in All About Eve.

Thursday, July 3, 2025

Without Warning! (Allart Productions, United Artists, 1952)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2025 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Wednesday, July 2), once my husband Charles got back from work, I ran us a surprisingly good 1952 independent thriller called Without Warning! (the original poster art did not contain the exclamation point, but the actual credit did) which was the brainchild of three men who met each other in combat during World War II: producers Arthur Gardner and Jules W. Levy and director Arnold Laven. They got a script from William Raynor about a psychopathic killer named Carl Martin (Adam Williams) who targeted young, attractive women with blonde hair because he’d briefly been married to one, and when she left him he went crazy and targeted women who looked like his ex. Other quirks in his nature is that he always committed his murders on or about the first of a new month, and he uses a peculiar pair of garden shears as a weapon. Without Warning! isn’t a film noir either thematically or visually – almost all of it takes place outdoors in bright spaces even though yet another quirk in the murderer’s psyche is that he usually strikes at 3 a.m. – though the cinematographer, Joseph Biroc, is largely known for his noirs, including Johnny Allegro (1949), Cry Danger (1951), The Glass Wall (1953), Vice Squad (1953), World for Ransom (1954), and another Gardner-Levy-Laven production, Down Three Dark Streets (1954). But it is a quite well done thriller, part police procedural and part suspense film, and fortunately Arnold Laven and William Raynor adopted Alfred Hitchcock’s technique of letting us, the audience, know from the get-go who the bad guy is and building suspense and tension from our wondering where and how the characters will find out.

It also is a film that benefited from its no-name cast; though all the actors in it are at least competent, and Adam Williams and Meg Randall (as Jane Saunders, daughter of a garden-supply store Carl shops at regularly who just happens to be his “type”) considerably better than that, there were only two cast members I’d heard of before. One was John Maxwell (as Jane’s father) and one was Robert Shayne (playing police psychiatrist Dr. Werner – well, there had to be a psychiatrist with a German-sounding name in it somewhere!). Fortunately the people in this film are not only quite good actors, they don’t have the automatic audience associations bigger-name stars would have. Imagine this movie with Lawrence Tierney as Carl and the game would be over right away! At first the police are clueless as to how to find and capture the killer, but they get a lucky break when during one of his assaults the spring on his garden shears falls off and the police crime-scene team recovers it. Police soil chemist Charlie Wilkins (Byron Kane) analyzes the dirt on the spring and realizes it comes from three separate places, so the cops deduce that he works as a gardener and does jobs at various locations in the city. At one point the cops send out a group of policewomen who all look like Carl’s “type” and have them stake out various bars in which he might be cruising – and, in a grimly amusing scene repeated in Blake Edwards’s Experiment in Terror a decade later, one of them arrests a man whose only “crime” is trying to pick up a woman other than his wife for a casual quickie.

In another noteworthy scene, Carl is trying to flee the scene after one of his killings – this time of a woman whom he murdered in her car – when two police officers drive up on motorcycles. Carl’s first instinct is to abandon the car and flee on foot, but when the police keep approaching Carl gets back in the car and tries to drive away. One of the cops comes up to him as the car’s back wheel is stuck in a pothole and asks who the woman is and why she isn’t moving. Carl says it’s because she’s fast asleep after a long night, and when the cop thinks better of it, he inadvertently turns his back to Carl, who grabs the cop’s own gun and shoots him with it. Then his partner also tries to apprehend Carl, and Carl shoots him, too, though he recovers and gives his brethren on the force valuable information as to what Carl looks like. Ultimately the police do a canvass of all the garden-supply stores in the city and eventually they hit Saunders’s. Old Man Saunders sends his daughter out to deliver a prize orchid bush to Carl at his home in Chavez Ravine – among other things, Without Warning! is a fascinating document of what Chavez Ravine looked like before its largely Mexican-American population was driven out through eminent domain and displaced to build Dodger Stadium. (One intriguing minor character is a Mexican girl who keeps interrupting Carl’s murderous rages with demands that he fix her doll, which has literally lost her head.) There’s an exciting climax as Carl suddenly realizes that Jane is his “type” and decides to kill her, while we’re kept in suspense as to whether the police, who are there to question her dad, will get there in time to rescue Jane and arrest or kill Carl. Ultimately one of the cops kills Carl just in time to rescue Jane from his fiendish clutches. Without Warning! is an engaging film and surprisingly well-made given the probable limitations of the company’s budget, and Adam Williams’s restrained approach to playing a psycho killer was well ahead of its time, anticipating Anthony Perkins’s in Hitchcock’s Psycho by eight years.

Wednesday, July 2, 2025

They Live By Night (RKO, 1947, released 1948)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2025 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Monday, July 1) I successfully enticed my husband Charles out of the bedroom, where he’d been avoiding the news, to watch a film on Turner Classic Movies that we’d seen together ages ago on a VHS dub from another TCM showing: They Live by Night, filmed in 1947 and released in 1948 in Britain and 1949 in the U.S. It started out as a 1937 novel by Edward Anderson (it was the last of two novels he published even though he lived until 1969) called Thieves Like Us. It was about a young man named Albert “Bowie” Bowers (Farley Granger), who was imprisoned for murder at age 16. Seven years later he and two other convicts, Chickamaw “One-Eye” Mobley (Howard Da Silva) and Henry “T-Dub” Mansfield (Jay C. Flippen), escape from prison and head for the home of Chickamaw’s older brother Robert (Wil Wright, reuniting him and Da Silva from the cast of The Blue Dahlia, Raymond Chandler’s only original screenplay that was actually filmed, which like They Live by Night was produced by former Orson Welles associate John Houseman) to hide out. They successfully rob a local bank and split the money. Bowie falls in love with Chickamaw’s niece Catherine “Keechie” Mobley (Cathy O’Donnell) and the two escape together, first on a bus and then in a car a corrupt justice of the peace named Hawkins (a charming performance by Ian Wolfe) brokers for them after they impulsively visit his chapel, where he offers weddings for $20 ($10 additional if you want an audio record of the service) with a ring thrown in for an extra $5. Bowie and Keechie have a conversation with Hawkins about where they can flee to, and Hawkins recommends Mexico. They end up in a mountain resort and set up housekeeping when their idyll, such as it is, is interrupted by Chickamaw, who crashes their place and demands that Bowie join him and T-Dub for another bank robbery. Bowie reluctantly agrees to join them for one last caper, but (though we don’t see any of it) that “one last caper” ends badly, with T-Dub killed in a shoot-out with police and Chickamaw jealous of the media attention Bowie is getting as the supposed mastermind of the robbery.

Desperate for a place to hide out, Bowie and Keechie end up in a motel owned by Mattie Mobley (Helen Craig), wife of a third Mobley brother who’s in prison on an allegedly unjust charge. Alas, Mattie decides to rat them out to the police in exchange for freedom for her brother, and the film ends with a shoot-out in which Bowie goes out with a revolver, the police open fire with high-powered rifles, and Bowie ends up dying in Keechie’s arms. After he expires, she reads the farewell note he’d written her. As I noted in previous viewings of the movie, there’s an ambiguous ending that can be read as a “life goes on” statement, since Keechie is pregnant with Bowie’s child when Bowie is killed and they’re both convinced he will be a boy even though there was no way to tell in advance in 1948. It can also be read considerably more pessimistically, given that earlier Bowie had told Keechie that his father, too, had been a criminal and had been killed by police before Bowie was born. There’s at least a hint that the boy will meet as nasty a fate as his father, drifting into crime and later being killed by police. RKO had bought the book in 1941; according to Edward Anderson’s Wikipedia page he got just $500 for the rights, but according to the Wikipedia page on the film the cost to the studio was $10,000. (Both could be right; it’s possible that during the four years between 1937 and 1941 Anderson might have sold the movie rights to someone else and RKO may have paid a lot more to the someone else than Anderson himself got.)

Several writers attempted to adapt Anderson’s novel for film, but the project got stalled until after World War II, when Dore Schary was hired as production chief at RKO. He came with a brief to make RKO the most adventurous major Hollywood studio, and he signed the young Nicholas Ray, who’d just got out of the service and written the script for the Monogram musical Swing Parade of 1946, on the basis of his treatment for Thieves Like Us. Schary hired Ray to both write and direct the film, and assigned John Houseman to produce, though in the end he put on a more experienced screenwriter, Charles Schnee, to help Ray flesh out his concept into a filmable screenplay. Ray insisted on hiring two of Samuel Goldwyn’s contract players, Farley Granger and Cathy O’Donnell, to play Bowie and Keechie, and Granger later wrote in his autobiography (actually ghost-written by his partner, Robert Patrick; when he came out to San Diego to promote the book it was pretty obvious that Granger’s memory was mostly gone and obviously Patrick had written the book based on his recollections of the stories Granger had told him about his career over the years), “Ray and John Houseman were among the few people who fought for me in my career. They said no, we will not make the film without him. When Nick believed in you, he was very loyal.” (I noticed both the Wikipedia page on the film and Alicia Malone’s introduction on TCM carefully cherry-picked Granger’s quotes about Ray; later in his book he said Ray was a monumentally overrated director and They Live by Night and Rebel Without a Cause were his only truly great films.)

Malone also said that Robert Mitchum had been considered for the film, but as good as he was he couldn’t have captured Bowie’s wide-eyed innocence and naïveté about the world. According to the Wikipedia page Mitchum had actually wanted to play the supporting role of Chickamaw, but either Houseman, Schary, or some of the other RKO executives felt that was too small a part for an actor they were working to build up into a major star and who’d already been nominated for an Academy Award for 1945’s The Story of G.I. Joe. Schary and Houseman both encouraged Ray to experiment with unusual filmmaking techniques, including shooting the opening scene of the three convicts driving away from prison in a stolen car and several other key scenes from a helicopter. This posed a problem because Howard Da Silva kept losing his hairpiece from the backwash of the helicopter blades, but the effect is a quite striking one that reinforces the sense that these characters are alienated from society at large. That sense is also communicated by the odd shot before the opening credits, which show Farley Granger and Cathy O’Donnell making love (or as close to it as the Production Code would allow) as we read the words, “This boy and this girl were never properly introduced to the world we live in.” (That does sound like Dore Schary, whose penchant for shoe-horning social comment into his films got so bad that later, when he was head of production at MGM, there was a joke around Hollywood that Schary had “sold MGM’s birthright for a pot of message.”)

They Live by Night was cited in Pauline Kael’s famous extended review of the 1967 Bonnie and Clyde as among the precursors to that classic crooks-on-the-run tale, along with two movies I think are even better: Fritz Lang’s You Only Live Once (1937) and Joseph H. Lewis’s Gun Crazy (1949). But They Live by Night (a title change Howard Hughes insisted on when he bought RKO in 1948) still holds up surprisingly well for its doomed romanticism and the perfection of Farley Granger’s performance: he really does make us believe that despite having almost literally grown up in prison, he’s somehow retained a belief in the basic decency and goodness of the human race even as it gets sorely tested, and ultimately fails him, by the later events of the story. Mention should also be made of the traditional blues song, “Your Red Wagon,” sung brilliantly in a nightclub scene by Marie Bryant. Bryant was a singer who worked with Duke Ellington on his musicals Jump for Joy and Beggar’s Holiday, and sang “On the Sunny Side of the Street” hauntingly in the Lester Young/Gjon Mili 10-minute short Jammin’ the Blues (1944). “Your Red Wagon” is credited here to Richard M. Jones, Don Raye, and Gene de Paul, but it’s actually an old folk blues that got reworked into white hits like Hank Willliams’s “Move It On Over” and Bill Haley’s “Rock Around the Clock.”

Thieves Like Us (George Litto Productions, Jerry Back, United Artists, 1974)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2025 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

In 2006 my husband Charles and I watched Robert Altman’s 1974 remake of They Live by Night, shot under Edward Anderson’s original title Thieves Like Us and returned to its 1930’s setting instead of taking place in contemporary times, as a memorial tribute to Altman. I hadn’t started the moviemagg blog at that time and so here’s what I had to say about Thieves Like Us then:

The film was Thieves Like Us, a very interesting Robert Altman movie from 1974 that was a remake of Nicholas Ray’s 1948 classic They Live by Night, though Altman reverted to the original title of Edward Anderson’s source novel as well as to its 1930’s setting (Ray’s version had moved it to a contemporary time frame). Both films tell the tale of three down-home convicts, Chic[k]amaw (Howard Da Silva in the original, John Schuck in the remake); T-Dub (Jay C. Flippen in the original, Bert Remsen in the remake — and at least Altman and his writing collaborators, Calder Willingham and Joan Tewkesbury, explained that the character’s odd name is a further contraction of his initials. T. W., while Ray and Charles Schnee didn’t bother) and the main protagonist, Bowie (Farley Granger in the original, Keith Carradine in the remake), a (relatively) innocent young man — he was convicted of murder but was only peripherally involved in the killing — who enters into a desperate, doomed romance with Keechie (Cathy O’Donnell in the original, Shelley Duvall in the remake), either the daughter or the niece of one of their outside helpers: Mattie (Helen Craig in the original, Louise Fletcher — in her first film — in the remake), whose husband is also an inmate and who’s living with her brother-in-law, Mobley (Wil Wright in the original, Altman’s old M*A*S*Hman Tom Skerritt here). The critics in 1974 inevitably compared the film to Bonnie and Clyde (and They Live by Night had been one of the models for the Bonnie and Clyde movie, along with You Only Live Once and Gun Crazy — surprisingly, not Persons in Hiding, the 1939 Paramount “B” that was the first film about the actual Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow — cited by Pauline Kael in her famous extended review of Bonnie and Clyde) but, if anything, Thieves Like Us seems to have been planned deliberately by Altman as a sort of anti-Bonnie and Clyde.

Where Bonnie and Clyde was frenetic, funny (Arthur Penn, its director, was hailed as a genius for rapid alternations of comedy and violence — though that had been done before by Buster Keaton in The General and Billy Wilder in Some Like It Hot), energetic, brightly colored and punctuated with a banjo-pickin’ score by Lester Flatt and Earl Scruggs, Thieves Like Us is somber, dark, absolutely determined not to tap any opportunities for comic relief in the story, done in the past-is-brown look that admittedly wasn’t anywhere near as much of a cliché in 1974 as it is now, and with almost no non-source music whatsoever — just an ironic playing of Jimmie Lunceford’s record of “Organ Grinder’s Swing” as the three crooks go to a bank job they think is going to be easy but is going to get them into major trouble (they don’t even make it to the bank; instead their car is involved in a serious accident and Bowie is incapacitated). The rest of the film is “scored” with actual transcriptions of old radio shows of the period (the 1930’s — though, despite the credits to John Dunning as “radio researcher” and Carole Gister as “researcher,” there’s still a good deal of uncertainty as to just when in the 1930’s this takes place: a speech by Franklin Roosevelt — a recording by the real one — identifies it as 1937 and so does a travel guidebook in a bus station at the end, but one of the live broadcasts used is of the Boswell Sisters, who broke up in 1936; the heavy-duty Depression aura is characteristic of the early 1930’s but the relatively streamlined cars used[1] seem to be from the end of the decade) — sometimes ironically, as when the first lovemaking session between Bowie and Keechie occurs while they’re listening to a broadcast of Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet — and the 1930’s atmosphere as recreated in the film is seemingly free of anachronisms (at least I didn’t spot any, though I’m relying mostly on the movies of the period for my authentic view of what the 1930’s “really” looked like).

It’s a well done movie and its only flaw is it seems rather bookish, much the way more recent films like Million Dollar Baby and Brokeback Mountain have: it seems just too distant from the characters, too content to let us watch them from afar instead of actually involving us viscerally in their plights. Robert Altman (to whom we were watching the film as an envoi since he died recently) was mostly a pretty cerebral director — M*A*S*H, the film that made his reputation, is surprisingly atypical of his work in its comedy (Altman usually didn’t have much of a sense of humor), rapid pace and overall excitement — and that’s both the strength and the weakness of Thieves Like Us. Its strength is that Altman’s approach seems to go out of its way to de-emphasize the violence inherent in the material — the film is an hour and a half into its two-hour running time before we actually see any on-screen violence and it’s only in the final bank robbery, the one that goes incredibly wrong (the tag line in the ad campaign read, “Robbing 36 banks was easy. Watch what happens when they hit the 37th”), that we actually see the criminals in operation (though there’s one all too obvious visual quote from Bonnie and Clyde: the slow-motion in which Keechie is filmed as she watches the cops shoot her lover) — and its weakness is that we really don’t feel all that much for the characters.

It doesn’t help that, while Altman’s cast is generally at least at the level of Ray’s (and Shelley Duvall is far superior to Cathy O’Donnell in the female lead), Keith Carradine just isn’t as powerful as Bowie as Farley Granger was. Granger’s peculiarly whiny style usually was just annoying, but in the hands of a major director like Ray or Alfred Hitchcock it could turn into a quite effective portrayal of a certain kind of small-time, small-minded man with visions of reaching far beyond his “place” — and Carradine simply can’t cut it in delivering that aspect of the character, as well as he wears the 1930’s clothes and assumes the proper attitude of nice boy pretending to be bad-ass gangster. It’s also odd that Altman, Willingham and Tewkesbury left out one key piece of exposition about Bowie — that his father, also a criminal, was killed before he was born — which gave a profoundly mixed message to the ending (Bowie is shot while Keechie is pregnant with his child, and we can read that either as “life goes on” or, more pessimistically, that with his father dead before he was born the son of Bowie and Keechie will live out the same cycle and also be a criminal, shot down by police while still a young man) — and therefore deprived the ending of a good deal of the poignancy it had in They Live by Night. Still, the strengths of Thieves Like Us far outweigh its weaknesses (and it benefits from not having the attempts at literal “social significance” patched into it that were probably the product of They Live by Night’s executive producer, Dore Schary, and marred that film), and it was a good tribute to Robert Altman and the kind of filmmaking he did well. — 11/29/06

[1] — One Paul Neanover gets a credit for “cars.”

Tuesday, July 1, 2025

Go Fish (Can I Watch, Islet, KPVI, Killer Films, The Samuel Goldwyn Company, 1994)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2025 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Monday, June 30) I turned on Turner Classic Movies for three films in an all-night marathon of movies with more or less Queer themes, none of which I’d seen before and two of which my husband Charles had never seen either. The one Charles had seen was the first one up, Go Fish, shot on black-and-white 16 mm (at a time when it was still cheaper to make a film in black-and-white than in color; now, if anything, it’s just the reverse) in Chicago in the early 1990’s (it was released in 1994 but it had taken three years to make) by director Rose Troche and co-written by her and Guinevere Turner, who’s also in the film as one of the leads. The other lead, V. S. Brodie, is also listed as an executive producer, and typically for a film made by film students on a shoestring budget, Troche is credited not only as director and co-writer but also as editor and optical effects person. Since Go Fish Troche has directed a number of other feature films, including Bedrooms and Hallways (1998), The Safety of Objects (2001), and Chinatown Film Project (2009), but most of her work since has been for series television, including – almost inevitably – episodes of the Lesbian-themed TV series The “L”-Word. From the presentation on imdb.com and the TCM Web site I’d got the impression that Go Fish was essentially a Lesbian rom-com, but while it is that – Troche and Turner used the classic rom-com strategy of presenting two characters who we can see belong together while taking their time about making the characters realize it themselves – it’s also quite a lot more. Go Fish was considered part of the so-called “New Queer Cinema” of the 1990’s, films made by openly Queer filmmakers determined to avoid the wages-of-sin miseries previous movie people had inflicted on their Lesbian or Gay characters.

It’s also a film very much ahead of its time in acknowledging that not all Queer people are white: one of the romantic leads, whose birth name is Camille but goes by “Max West,” is a Latina who’s thrown out of her family’s home when her mom discovers she’s Lesbian. And the woman she seeks solace with when that happens and ultimately moves in with as a platonic roommate is an African-American Lesbian film professor named Kia (T. Wendy McMillan), who has her own rambunctious sex life but also serves as the voice of reason. Max spots a woman named Ely (V. S. Brodie) at a table in a part-diner, part-bar with a largely Lesbian clientele, and because she’s tall, skinny and has long, stringy, hippie-ish hair Max is initially turned off by her. But Kia has become determined to get Max and Ely together even though Ely has a long-distance relationship going with a woman named Kate (whom we never see), who lives in Seattle. The two haven’t seen each other in nearly two years, but Ely is either clinging to the hope that she and Kate can become a real couple again or using Kate as an excuse to avoid any romantic, emotional, or sexual attachments with women in Chicago. One of the things I liked about Go Fish (the title comes from the children’s card game but it also might be an oblique reference to the slang term “fish,” used by woman-hating Gay men to describe either women generally or the alleged smell of their sex organs in particular) is it plays against the stereotype that Lesbians don’t get down ‘n’ dirty about sex. Not only are the characters shown in at least the beginnings of sexual excitement over each other, there’s one remarkable scene in which four of the characters, lying crossways from each other, their heads linked together, in a conversational pose that recurs throughout the movie, discuss the sexiest way to refer to a woman’s main sex organ.

Ironically, the hottest and most explicit sex scene in Go Fish involves one of the women having sex with a man – and it’s a shock when we realize that her sex partner is male. This triggers a fascinating debate that’s at least 20 years ahead of its time as to whether a woman who has sex with men as well as with women can still call herself a “Lesbian” and whether her dalliance with a man threatens her Lesbian identity. The woman in question anticipates the modern-day “Queer theory,” with its rejection of the whole idea that sexual attachments towards one gender or the other define your identity and belief that you should be able to have sex with any willing partner of whichever gender without feeling that characterizes you as “Lesbian,” “Gay,” or even “Bisexual.” There’s also a plot gimmick in that Max’s and Ely’s first date was to a screening of a new film by a Gay male director, which puts them off because even though the director is Gay he’s still stuck in the old-fashioned negative stereotypes of how to depict Queer people on screen. (Remember that this is a movie both made by and about film students.) Later Ely, who in the meantime has had all that long, stringy, hippie-ish hair cut off and ended up looking quite boyish (enough so that once she and Max get together at last, I could readily imagine people seeing them on the street assuming they’re a straight couple, just as I appreciate Rose Troche’s irony in giving both her Lesbian protagonists and a good friend of theirs, Mel [Brooke Webster], male names), and Max make plans for another date, though in the end they just stay in and there’s a weird scene in which Max notes that Ely’s fingernails are split, she tries to cut them with Max’s toenail clippers, Max takes over and the two ultimately end up in bed together. (One of the other characters even jokes about nail-cutting as foreplay.) Go Fish is a quite charming movie that holds up surprisingly well, and in 1994 it got major distribution (from the Samuel Goldwyn Company), got excellent reviews and did well (at least by independent-cinema standards) at the box office.