Monday, November 16, 2026

Lime Kiln Club Field Day (Klaw and Erlanger, Biograph, New York Museum of Modern Art, filmed 1913, released 2014)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Sunday, November 15), after Turner Classic Movies’s mini-marathon of Alfred Hitchcock, Gregory Peck, and Leo G. Carroll in Spellbound and The Paradine Case, Jacqueline Stewart’s “Silent Sunday Nights” feature was a fascinating film that was shot in 1913 but wasn’t edited and released until 101 years later. It was called Lime Kiln Club Field Day and was a vehicle for the great African-American comedian Bert Williams. Lime Kiln Club Field Day was based on a novel called Brother Gardner’s Lime-Kiln Club by Charles Bertrand Lewis and it was produced as a co-venture between the Klaw and Erlanger stage production company and American Biograph, the pioneering studio that was part of Thomas A. Edison’s Motion Picture Patents Trust and launched the career of D. W. Griffith. It was preserved by one of the great unsung heroines of film preservation history: Iris Barry, who as curator of the New York Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in the 1930’s managed to sell her bosses on the idea that film was a modern American art form and therefore as worthy of preservation as any other. (Remember that this was the era in which movies were still legally considered “a business.” In 1912 the U.S. Supreme Court had ruled that films were not a form of “speech” under the protection of the First Amendment, and the court didn’t reverse this until 40 years later. So studios during the entire “classic Hollywood” era of the 1920’s, 1930’s, and 1940’s lived in fear that government censors would come down on them and dictate the contents of their films, and they formed the Motion Picture Producers and Distributors Association of America to forestall government censorship by censoring themselves.) When Barry got word that the then-current owners of Biograph in 1938 were about to junk all the surviving negatives and prints of their films, she got in touch with them and arranged for them to donate the reels to MoMA instead. Alas, it literally took decades for MoMA to inventory the Biograph collection, and while particularly important titles (like most of Griffith’s one-reelers for the company) were in circulation by the 1950’s, much of the Biograph output lay fallow in the MoMA vaults.

In 2014 MoMA’s current curators found this stash of footage from a movie that had been abandoned in post-production after all or most of it had been shot, and film preservationist Karl Malkames transferred the fragile 35 mm. nitrate camera negatives to fine-grained positive stock. The surviving footage of Lime Kiln Club Field Day was assembled under certain rules, including the idea that the preservationists would keep the individual shots together and let them run as long as they did instead of trying to edit them, which would have meant second-guessing the original filmmakers. Jacqueline Stewart presented Lime Kiln Field Day with a co-host, white (or at least white-presenting) author Allyson Nadia Field, author of a number of books on silent film, including Acts of Love: Black Performance and the Kiss That Changed Film History. The “kiss that changed film history” was between a Black man, Saint Suttle, and a Black woman, Gertie Brown, who regularly performed together as part of a group called The Ragtime Four. Along with the other members, John and Maud Brewster, they were responsible for popularizing the cakewalk; Suttle even wrote a song for it, “Old Jasper’s Cake Walk.” Ironically, Suttle and Brown were among the famous Black performers who played in blackface and advertised themselves as “The Two Real Coons” – as did Bert Williams and his vaudeville partner, George Walker. Stewart and Field prefaced Lime Kiln Club Field Day with the 1898 Thomas A. Edison short Something Good – Negro Kiss, which showed Suttle and Brown kissing each other several times. Like Edison’s other movies at the time, it was just one minute long and was meant to be viewed in a peep-show device rather than projected on a screen.

Lime Kiln Club Field Day has a simple plot: the Black workforce at the titular lime kiln (which I’d encountered in movies before only as a particularly efficacious place for dumping the body of a murder victim and having the lime eat it without a trace) has a major picnic and county fair. Bert Williams plays a con artist who fleeces the crowd by selling gin allegedly drawn from a “gin spring” on the grounds of the picnic, but in fact from a jug he accidentally dropped down an otherwise dry well, causing its contents to break and spill. Bert is also one of three rivals for the affections of a quite statuesque young woman (Odessa Warren Grey), all of whom want to take her to the fair despite her overprotective mother (Abbie Mitchell, one of only two cast members besides Williams I’d actually heard of before; she was the wife of Will Marion Cook, member of James Reese Europe’s Clef Club, leader of the Southern Syncopated Orchestra that brought authentic jazz to Europe for the first time in 1919, and Duke Ellington’s composition teacher; Mitchell herself was in the original cast of George Gershwin’s Black opera Porgy and Bess in 1935 and introduced the song “Summertime”), who dumps buckets of water on them. One of the club members is played by Charles Gilpin, the elusive Black actor for whom Eugene O’Neill wrote The Emperor Jones and All God’s Chillun Got Wings (only they had a falling-out because Gilpin demanded O’Neill delete the “N-word” from the script of The Emperor Jones and O’Neill refused), while one of Bert’s rivals for Odessa’s affections is played by Sam Corker, Jr., apparently a major figure in Black theatre in New York until he died just a year after Lime Kiln Club Field Day was shot. The film was accompanied by a rather overly raucous score by Donald Sosin, though for one quite moving scene (the one, seen in three takes, where Bert drops the gin jug down the well) Sosin wisely used an instrumental version of Williams’ own song “Nobody.”

What I knew about Bert Williams before seeing this film came mainly from white performers from his time or the generation afterwards. W. C. Fields said, “Bert Williams was the funniest man I ever saw on stage, and the saddest man I ever saw off it.” Mae West told her late-in-life biographer Charlotte Chandler that her uncle, show business attorney Thomas West, had arranged for her to meet Williams, and Mae West was stunned when she met Williams and found that, while still visibly Black, he was considerably lighter-skinned than he was on stage. Williams regularly performed in blackface, and in Lime Kiln Club Field Day he was reportedly the only character who wore blackface (though I thought I spotted about two or three others). I was already familiar with Williams’s records, including “Nobody,” and from them I was expecting a performance that would blend comedy and pathos in the way Charlie Chaplin became a star from years later. Indeed, throughout Lime Kiln Club Field Day I was thinking “Black Chaplin,” and I had to keep reminding myself that this was shot one year before Chaplin ever faced a camera and two years before he evolved the celebrated “Tramp” character that brought pathos to screen comedy. After the movie Stewart and Field made the same point: Bert Williams was playing the same balance Chaplin became famous for and he was doing it before Chaplin did. It’s both idle and infuriating to think what sort of a film career Bert Williams might have had if Lime Kiln Club Field Day had been completed and released in a timely fashion (though Williams did make a film for Biograph three years later, A Natural-Born Gambler, that’s available on archive.org); maybe he’d have had a star career in film the way he had in the Ziegfeld Follies on stage (which is where he and W. C. Fields crossed paths), or maybe he would have left a few scraps of film behind that would have us asking, “What could he have accomplished if he hadn’t handicapped by racism?,” the way Florence Cole Talbert’s stunning recording of the Bell Song from Leo Delibes’s opera Lakmé from 1922 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=56kd69bBmlw&list=RD56kd69bBmlw&start_radio=1) showed what a great potential talent the opera world denied itself by its anti-Black racism.