Monday, November 16, 2026

The Paradine Case (The Selznick Stodio, Vanguard Films, Selznick Releasing Organizaiton, 1947)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

The Turner Classic Movies mini-marathon of Alfred Hitchcock/Gregory Peck movies on Sunday, November 15 continued with The Paradine Case, made in 1947 and once again produced by Selznick, who this time also wrote the script. (The initial adaptation was done by Alma Reville, Mrs. Alfred Hitchcock, and James Bridie, and Ben Hecht also made some uncredited contributions.) The Paradine Case began in 1933 as a novel by Robert Hichens, and Selznick, who’d just started an unhappy two years as a producer at his father-in-law’s studio, MGM, immediately grabbed the movie rights as a vehicle for Greta Garbo. Unfortunately [spoiler alert!] Garbo flatly refused to make the film because it would have cast her as a murderess. Selznick nursed the idea of making The Paradine Case for the next 14 years until, flush with the success of his 1946 cornball Western Duel in the Sun (a vehicle for his second wife, actress Jennifer Jones), he finally put it together and assigned the direction to Hitchcock. After once again trying for Garbo and also offering it to Ingrid Bergman, who was disgusted with Selznick and his contractual stranglehold on her career, Selznick imported Italian actress Alida Valli (whom he billed as “Valli,” her last name alone, and in cursive script) to play the story’s central character: Mrs. Maddalena Anna Paradine, wife of a British colonel who’d been blinded in the war. (The last name is pronounced “Para-deen,” by the way.) When the film opens Col. Paradine has just died by poison and Mrs. Paradine is being arrested for the crime in a scene that seems like it was adapted from Cole Porter’s song “Miss Otis Regrets” (which was written around the same time as Hichens’s novel). Being accused of murder seems to bother Mrs. Paradine less than being pulled away from the dinner her cook has just prepared and her butler has just served, and she’s more concerned with making sure all her fine clothes are brought to her in jail and she’s allowed to wear them than with the facts of her case. Mrs. Paradine turns to an old family friend, Sir Simon Flaquer (Charles Coburn), for legal help, but because Flaquer is only a solicitor (a business lawyer) he can’t take her case. (British law makes a distinction between a solicitor and a barrister, a courtroom lawyer; Mexican law makes a similar distinction between a licenciado, a business lawyer, and an abogado, a courtroom lawyer.)

Simon arranges for his friend Anthony Keane (Gregory Peck), a brilliant trial lawyer who’s never lost a case, to take on Mrs. Paradine. The moment Keane and Mrs. Paradine meet, he’s immediately infatuated with her even though he’s already married and has been for 11 years. Flaquer and Keane also frequently socialize with the judge assigned to the case, Lord Thomas Horfield (Charles Laughton), who immediately has the hots for Keane’s wife Gay (Ann Todd). In the U.S. today the idea of the judge socializing and having dinner parties with an attorney in a case before him would be considered an outrageous conflict of interest. At one point Keane offers to withdraw from Mrs. Paradine’s case if that will save his marriage, but Gay insists that he remain on the job and work his ass off to acquit her because if someone else represents her and she’s found guilty, the memory of her will come between them forever. Though the alleged crime took place in London, Keane insists on traveling to the Paradines’ country estate, where he meets André Latour (Louis Jourdan), whom Keane comes to suspect of the crime. Keane intuits that Latour and Mrs. Paradine were having an affair and that Latour gave Col. Paradine the poisoned burgundy wine that killed him. Maybe it was an assisted suicide with Latour merely serving as the instrument of Col. Paradine’s death; maybe Latour killed his boss in cold blood out of lust for his wife. When the trial begins in London’s Old Bailey courthouse, represented by a quite impressive set as well as an establishing exterior in which a portion of the front of the building has been blown off by a World War II bomb, facing Leo G. Carroll as the prosecutor, Keane insists on a vicious and aggressive cross-examination of Latour despite Mrs. Paradine’s insistence that Latour should be left alone. When Keane’s brilliant cross-examination finally has broken Latour’s credibility to shreds, Mrs. Paradine makes a stunning confession that she really did kill her husband because she loved Latour and wanted to be with him. Keane is devastated; he makes a half-hearted attempt at a closing argument, flees the courtroom, and holes up at the home of Flaquer and his grown daughter (the only two voices of reason we see in this film) until he and his wife are finally able to reconcile.

The Paradine Case is much more a David Selznick movie than an Alfred Hitchcock one, and though Edgar Wright acknowledged introducing it on Turner Classic Movies that he’d never seen it until the recent restoration and was quite impressed with it, I had seen it before and hadn’t liked it then or now. Much of it reminded me of the note F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote during his brief stint as a screenwriter on Selznick’s Gone With the Wind, and in particular his comment, “I still think it’s dull and false for one character to describe another.” Selznick didn’t take Fitzgerald’s advice on Gone With the Wind and he didn’t on The Paradine Case, either; The Paradine Case is full of dull and false scenes in which the characters describe each other. Hitchcock was not happy with the cast Selznick saddled him with; he wanted a British actor like Ronald Colman or Laurence Olivier to play Keane. (My husband Charles had the same complaint; he joked that Peck was playing “the only American barrister in London,” though I found Peck’s quirky accent believable as a Brit. I also couldn’t help but recall that Peck’s most famous and highly regarded film, To Kill a Mockingbird, also cast him as a trial lawyer.) But the actor who most ticked Hitchcock off was Louis Jourdan. He had wanted Robert Newton, a considerably uglier character actor, for the role because, as he explained to Charles Higham and Joel Greenberg in the 1969 interview book The Celluloid Muse, “[T]he whole point about the lawyer falling in love with the murderess was to realize the degradation of falling for a woman who had as one of her lovers a manure-smelling groom. He should have had to sit face to face with a coarse, horny-handed slob, and look and say, ‘I’ve sunk low enough to become infatuated with a woman who will even sleep with this. And of course it was all lost because Selznick had signed this pretty-pretty boy.” (Hitchcock was obviously intending for an attraction between the two along the lines of D. H. Lawrence’s 1928 novel Lady Chatterley’s Lover.) In the movie one can see Hitchcock and cinematographer Lee Garmes trying to give Jourdan as unflattering a lighting as possible, but they still weren’t able to turn this French pretty-boy into the manure-smelling lout of Hitchcock’s dreams.

One of the film’s Academy Award nominations was for Ethel Barrymore as Judge Horfield’s wife, though most of her part was lost on the cutting-room floor and she’s only in the film as it stands for three minutes. Apparently the Academy voters screened a longer three-hour version which, according to a “Trivia” item on the film’s imdb.com page, contained “a brilliant museum scene where Lady Horfield requests Anthony Keane to save Mrs. Paradine, and another scene where Lady Horfield tries to hide her coughing from her husband.” (Frankly, watching The Paradine Case I’d found myself wishing that Laughton’s real-life wife, Elsa Lanchester, had been playing his wife in the movie.) The Paradine Case is a David O. Selznick movie masquerading as an Alfred Hitchcock movie, and it’s hard not to look at it without wondering what it might have been had Selznick got to make it at MGM in 1933 with Garbo and Colman in the leads and a more complaisant, less personal director.