Monday, November 16, 2026

Spellbound (Selznick International Pictures, Vanguard Films, United Artists, 1945)


by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2026 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

Last night (Sunday, November 15) my husband Charles and I watched a mini-marathon of three films on Turner Classic Movies: Alfred Hitchcock’s Spellbound (1945) and The Paradine Case (1947) and a really oddball item, an unfinished 1913 film called Lime Kiln Club Field Day that was a vehicle for African-American comedy star Bert Williams. TCM was doing a double bill of Spellbound and The Paradine Case not only because they were both directed by Alfred Hitchcock and starred Gregory Peck (the only two films Hitchcock and Peck made together) but because they were both given major restorations by the Walt Disney Company in association with the Film Foundation. The TCM showings were co-hosted by Ben Mankiewicz and British filmmaker Edgar Wright, whom I hadn’t recalled but I’ve seen at least one of his previous movies, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World, which I raved about in 2010 on my moviemagg.com blog at https://moviemagg.blogspot.com/2010/12/by-mark-gabrish-conlan-copyright-2010_30.html. I called Scott Pilgrim “refreshingly irreverent towards life, love, teen angst movies, video games, rock bands, vegans and everything else that fits within its compass.” Wright was expressing his admiration for Alfred Hitchcock (just about everyone who’s made a movie since Hitchcock’s time admires him) and also talking about how uncertainties as to who held the rights to these movies had jeopardized their continued existence and made it harder to ensure that they were properly restored and preserved. Spellbound began life in 1927, when two British authors, Hillary St. George Saunders (of whom Hitchcock said, “I think [he] became librarian in the House of Commons or something”) and John Palmer, who published a novel called The House of Dr. Edwardes under the joint pseudonym “Francis Beeding.” (Other major mystery writers, including “Ellery Queen” and “Whit Masterson,” were joint pseudonyms for two people.)

I’ve read The House of Dr. Edwardes in an edition that used the title of the movie, Spellbound, and made it seem like it was the same story as the film – which it isn’t. The House of Dr. Edwardes is about an escaped mental patient who murders the head of an asylum, impersonates him, and takes the place over, turning it into a Satanic religious cult with him as its unquestioned leader. Spellbound is an original by Hitchcock and his favorite writer, Ben Hecht, whose credits state it was merely “suggested” by the novel – which is true. All it took from the book was the basic situation of an impostor taking over a mental institution (with the delightfully inane name “Green Manors”) and ultimately revealing his own mental illness. Constance Peterson (Ingrid Bergman, top-billed, in the first of her three films for Hitchcock) is a psychiatrist at Green Manors who’s totally devoted to her work and uninterested in pursuing a romantic relationship of any kind. One of her colleagues, Dr. Fleurot (John Emery, husband of Tallulah Bankhead, who’d starred in Hitchcock’s immediately previous film Lifeboat), rather patronizingly warns her that until she’s got in touch with her own romantic emotions she won’t be a good psychiatrist no matter how much of the tradecraft she knows. The head of Green Manors, Dr. Murchison (Leo G. Carroll, who made more movies with Hitchcock – six: Rebecca, Suspicion, Spellbound, The Paradine Case, Strangers on a Train, and North by Northwest ¬– than any other actor), has just had a nervous breakdown and the board of Green Manors has forced him into retirement. The man they’ve hired to replace him is Anthony Edwardes (seen in a flashback and played by Edward Fielding), an internationally renowned expert on guilt complexes. Only the person who shows up and claims to be Edwardes (Gregory Peck) is really an impostor with a severe case of amnesia that has cost him all memory of who he really is. Dr. Peterson first catches on when she notices that his signature on a note doesn’t match that of the real Dr. Edwardes on an autographed copy of his major work on guilt complexes found in the Green Manors library. But she asks him a question about medicine and realizes when he answers correctly that whoever he is, he’s had medical training. The impostor is convinced that he murdered the real Dr. Edwardes and took his place.

He also has a phobia triggered by seeing black lines on a white surface, which Dr. Petersen notices when she traces such lines with his fork on a napkin as the Green Manors staff members are having dinner together. The mystery man writes a note to Dr. Petersen saying that he’s leaving Green Manors (which is in Vermont) and going to the Empire State Hotel in New York City. Two police officers show up looking for him, and there’s a marvelous scene in which they, Dr. Murchison and other Green Manors staffers hotly debate where “Dr. Edwardes” might be when they’re stepping all over the note which we know (because we saw “Edwardes” write it) contains his whereabouts but the characters don’t. After everyone else leaves and she finally reads the note, Dr. Petersen determines to head for New York and rendezvous with him there, not only out of concern but because he’s so drop-dead gorgeous he’s hooked her love instincts at long last. Realizing that the police and the house detective at the Empire State have recognized them (his looks are unknown but her face has made it to front pages throughout New York even though the film was shot and set in the middle of World War II and one would think there’d be some more important stories on the front pages). When they realize they’ve been recognized and have to flee New York, Petersen takes “Edwardes” to a train station and tells him to ask the man at the counter for a ticket to whatever destination he went to last – and after a lot of hemming and hawing (which predictably irritates the train station ticket clerk), he says, “Rome.” When they get on the train the conductor is momentarily startled that they’re both taking the train, which floored me for a second until I realized that this was in the middle of World War II and the conductor was probably used to seeing women saying goodbye to their menfolk as the men were going off either to a military camp or an actual combat zone. From the reference to “Rome” and the crude skin grafts on the back of one of his hands, Petersen has deduced that “Edwardes” is a military doctor who was injured in combat in the Italian theatre, and from the initials “J.B.” on his cigarette case she’s at least deduced part of his real name. Calling him “John Brown” for cover, Petersen takes her to her own mentor in Rochester, New York, Dr. Alexander Brulov (Michael Chekhov), where there’s a stunning scene in which a sleepwalking “Brown” stalks Drs. Petersen and Brulov and looks ready to kill either or both of them until Brulov gives him a glass of milk laced with a sedative and he goes under.

Eventually “Brown” a.k.a. “Edwardes” realizes that his guilt complex about black lines in white snow came from an incident in his childhood in which he accidentally killed his younger brother while sliding down a bannister in the snow (depicted by Hitchcock and cinematographer George Barnes in what the hosts called a “counter-zoom” effect, tracking in one direction and simultaneously zooming in the other, which Hitchcock is usually given credit for inventing 13 years later in the scenes of Vertigo that show James Stewart’s character actually experiencing vertigo). For the rest of it the revelation comes in a dream sequence designed by Salvador Dali and ghost-directed by William Cameron Menzies, a longtime Selznick collaborator who had no other role on this film. “I brought in Salvador Dali to do the dream sequences, not for publicity purposes – as Selznick thought – but because I wanted to have dreams photographed vividly,” Hitchcock told Charles HIgham and Joel Greenberg for their 1969 book The Celluloid Muse. “Until then, movie dreams were always blurred, always double exposures, and misty; and dreams are not like that, they’re very, very vivid.” Sorry, Sir Alfred, but that’s just another case of “first-itis” (my term for the tendency of people to claim they or their biographical subjects were the first to do something when other people had beaten them to it). In 1924, over two decades before Spellbound, Buster Keaton had made the film Sherlock, Jr., in which he played a movie projectionist who dreams his way into the film he’s showing – and Keaton (who directed as well as starring), cinematographers Elgin Lessley and Byron Houck, and special-effects genius Fred Gabourie had made his dream sequences bright and vivid, too. (Keaton has finally been recognized as one of the two great geniuses of silent comedy, alongside Charlie Chaplin, but he’s still underrated as a filmmaking innovator.) Predictably, Dali, who’d made two experimental silent films in France in 1929 (Un Chien Andalou) and 1930 (L’Age d’Or) with Luis Buñuel, was not happy with the way his sequences were used in Spellbound. Dali had intended the dream to last 20 minutes; in the finished film it’s only two minutes, and it has a voice-over narration by Gregory Peck in character overly literal in its explanation of what we’re seeing. (Hitchcock recalled that one of Dali’s ideas was to have Ingrid Bergman, who doesn’t appear at all in the film’s dream sequence as it stands, covered in ants, an effect he’d already used in Un Chien Andalou.)

From the dream and Peck’s explanation of it, Petersen deduces that the mystery man was at a ski resort with the real Dr. Edwardes and he witnessed him die in a skiing accident. Using the information Petersen has got out of him, the police go to the resort and find Edwardes – only his body has a bullet in his back, indicating he was murdered. The cops arrest Peck’s character (who in the meantime has recalled his real name, “John Ballantyne”) and Petersen is trying to prove him innocent. She confronts Dr. Murchison, who in Edwardes’s absence has regained his old job running Green Manors, only [spoiler alert!] Murchison makes a slip: he says, “I knew Edwardes only slightly,” revealing himself to be Edwardes’s killer because if he’d known Edwardes at all he’d have instantly recognized Peck’s character as an impostor. Murchison and Petersen meet in his office and Murchison pulls the gun out of his desk drawer, holds it on Petersen, and threatens to kill her. She points out that he might be able to plead insanity on Edwardes’s death but if he shoots her it’ll be in cold blood and he’ll surely be executed. Then she leaves the office and we see an extreme close-up of the gun as Murchison turns it on himself and uses it to commit suicide. (Joseph Breen, head of the Production Code Administration, usually frowned on having a criminal commit suicide because that meant he evaded being held legally accountable, but apparently Selznick talked him into O.K.’ing the scene because Murchison had already been depicted as mentally ill.) The gunshot is shown in a few frames of color film inserted into this otherwise black-and-white movie, though for years prints of Spellbound didn’t contain that flash of color. Ultimately Dr. Brulov and Dr. Fleurot see Ballantyne and Petersen off on their honeymoon.

I regard Spellbound as a good but not a great movie; its sexism annoyed me when I first saw it in the 1970’s and it still does. It was the first film for which Hitchcock got a possessory credit – “Alfred Hitchcock’s Spellbound” – indicating that, like D. W. Griffith, Cecil B. DeMille, and Frank Capra at their peaks, Hitchcock had become a marketable name to movie audiences and people would pay to see a Hitchcock movie no matter who was in it. Spellbound was nominated for seven Academy Awards but won only one, for Miklós Rósza’s musical score (which originally included long stretches of entrance and exit music which were dropped from prints until this reissue), which illustrated the mental discombobulation of Peck’s character by using the theremin, the all-electronic instrument Dr. Leon Theremin, a Russian refugee who moved to the U.S., had invented in 1920 and patented in 1928. David Selznick was hoping to be able to advertise Spellbound as the first film to use the theremin in its score, but in the meantime Rósza got a job working on Billy Wilder’s The Lost Weekend, using the theremin to express the anguish of Ray Milland’s alcoholic character. Due to difficulties Selznick was having with his distributor, United Artists, The Lost Weekend, though made after Spellbound, reached theatres ahead of it. Ironically, after Rósza pioneered the theremin as an expression of mental instability, it became most familiar to movie audiences in innumerable science-fiction cheapies from the 1950’s heralding the arrival of a flying saucer from outer space! Spellbound also has problems with its cast; Ingrid Bergman nails her part but Gregory Peck, in only his third film (after Days of Glory and The Keys of the Kingdom), seems rather gawky and one wonders how Joseph Cotten, whom Hitchcock had wanted for an earlier version of the project that stuck more closely to the novel, might have played it. Then again Peck’s inexperienced gawkiness works, after a fashion, for a man who literally does not know who he is. David O. Selznick green-lit Spellbound because he wanted to make a movie that would celebrate and glorify psychoanalysis. He was under analysis himself with a therapist named Dr. May Romm, whom he appointed to the film as a technical advisor and who apparently frequently clashed with Hitchcock.